The way that Chugga's fans have been acting the past week is a prime example of a parasocial relationship, constantly thinking of ways to justify why Chugga isn't a bad person.
When it was Emily, this fandom spent days, post after post on Chugga's sub about "Emily is clout-chasing", "Emily's lying", "What happened wasn't a big deal", "She would've handled it privately", demanding people hold off on judgement until Chugga spoke and when he did, it was a universal "Yup, I knew it, he's innocent. Emily is a lying bitch".
After his apology, so many people took his "I'm getting therapy" to mean that he's better, that we should all support him and just ignore despite everything else in his apology being proven fake, namely that he and Emily had handled this privately but that was coming from the evil Emily so ofcourse that can't be trusted.
Then Masae came forward and suddenly the allegations were true...except for "Why didn't she say what Emile did? Why'd she leave that out?" all while people STILL attacked Emily for starting this. As more and more people came forward, it went from "Chugga is autistic, he just doesn't understand" to "This looks bad but...he's growing, he's learning".
Now that evidence has came out that he was being sexual with a 15 year old girl and has kept at it for 15 years, half of this girls life, grooming her, it's still "We don't know...", "It was so long ago, it doesn't count", "It's not illegal, let's wait for the cops".
Every time a new allegation comes up, people in this fandom find some reason to justify it, ranging from Emily is lying to everyone is lying, to let's not use words like sexual harassment because that devalues actual victims, to it was just 2009 and everyone joked about being a pedophile while talking to underage girls. Some people have asked how it got this far, how Chugga was able to do this for so long and the very reason is his fandom enabled it, the victims knew that the moment they came forward, they would be attacked, belittled, and say they're making it up and look at what's happened.
I'm sorry your weird parasocial bestie was outted as being a pedophile that spent 15 years preying on his fans but stop defending him, stop pretending like it's not a big deal. If these victims were your cousins or your sisters, you wouldn't be "The guy is super friendly, he just didn't know...let's wish him well", no, you'd be calling him a pedo and wanting nothing to do with him. If you're still justifying why Chugga isn't that bad, I urge you to seek professional help. After being subbed to the channel since day one, I'm out.