r/ThePacific • • Feb 26 '24

I want to like the Pacific... buuuuut....

1 Upvotes

Hey I'm a hug band of brothers fan so I thought I would finally give the Pacific a whirl. I am on eposide 2 and I am just so bored. No spoilers but can someone give me some encouragement here?


r/ThePacific • • Nov 28 '23

When are the inappropriate scenes?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’m looking to watch this with my son. He’s a bit young but really wants to see it. Is there any way someone can tell me when all the nude scenes happen? The IMDB parental guide has me a little worried.


r/ThePacific • • Feb 08 '25

The Pacific Is Better Than Band of Brothers

100 Upvotes

There, I said it.

Show kept me engaged more, It seemed more real with the brutality and PTSD of war, and I cared for the characters more. Not only that but their mental Health as well.


r/ThePacific • • Aug 17 '23

Just awful

10 Upvotes

How did Spielberg and hanks make band of brothers, then go on to make this shit. Just finished the series and I gotta say I hated it since episode one. The storyline is basically non existent. There’s no character I like. The acting is terrible and the casting couldn’t have been worse. There’s no set up for anything. Just god awful


r/ThePacific • • May 29 '25

Compared to Band of Brothers this show feels very unsatisfying

0 Upvotes

I felt like each episode of The Pacific built up tension but rarely delivered a satisfying climax. For example the Peleliu arc stretched across about 2.5 episodes but we never actually saw how the island was taken. It just ended and suddenly we were somewhere else. That happened with multiple battles. The show covered Cape Gloucester, Peleliu, Okinawa and others but rarely showed clear outcomes. I kept having to pause and Google what actually happened to understand the context. Why didn't they show how they just caved in and blocked the caves with the Japanese inside?

I know it’s not a documentary but Band of Brothers managed to ground each episode with a sense of mission and resolution. When they took Carentan or Bastogne you felt it. There was payoff. In The Pacific we spend a whole episode on the beach at Peleliu under fire and then… nothing. Even with Okinawa we see some of the horror but barely understand the stakes or what progress was being made.

The structure felt disjointed too. Sledge’s arc was gripping but it came very late. Leckie had an entire episode in a psych ward and then kind of faded. Basilone’s story was strong but short. The show had powerful moments but they felt like isolated scenes not a continuous journey.

I admire the realism and the brutality. But compared to Band of Brothers it just didn’t come together as a coherent story. It often felt like buildup without resolution character arcs without closure and battles without clear purpose.

Also the screen/camera shakes I felt were really overdone in the action scenes. Don't get me wrong I love the show and will continue to rewatch again and again, but every time I can't help get this feeling as to why the producers decided not to go the extra mile. I also think they could have deleted all of John Basilone scenes and no one would have noticed anything. There were just so many loose ends. The production just feels like I don't know, a bit rushed? It's a shame because this show could easily have been a 10.


r/ThePacific • • May 09 '25

Question. If we put the books (Sledgehammers and Leckie) into AI, could AI then give us a realistic look into the past to see what the battlefield must have looked like?

0 Upvotes

r/ThePacific • • Jan 27 '26

Sledge

0 Upvotes

So I’m re-watching for the ….who knows how many times now and every time I do, I dislike Sledge just a little bit more. I’ve read his book and in there he is totally different (to me) but in the series he is such an asshole, crybaby, know it all and whiner!


r/ThePacific • • Feb 15 '26

“Melbourne” was a waste of an episode

54 Upvotes

I’ve read “Helmet for my Pillow,” I get it’s a major plot point for Leckie’s story. Honestly I think HBO used it just to get some sex scenes. I’m not looking for more blood and guts or anything like that, but you’re telling me there weren’t more Marines worth telling a story about that they had to devote an episode to a bunch of guys chasing tail? I mean, Leckie had better stories from Melbourne than just the sex. Every time I rewatch I find myself pretty much skipping through this episode.


r/ThePacific • • May 19 '21

What do you think

0 Upvotes

Am I the only one who dislikes Eugene Sledge from the beginning of his “combat career”?


r/ThePacific • • 26d ago

More racism towards Japanese vs Germans accurate depiction?

0 Upvotes

I feel the show does a decent job of articulating the amount of anger to words, Japanese versus Germans in World War II?


r/ThePacific • • May 02 '25

Just started watching and on episode 4

14 Upvotes

I’m really disliking Leckie. He had a girl back home whom he wrote love letters to. Caught feelings for a girl he met when he was drunk. Had sex with her twice and heartbroken when she broke things off. Got horny when he saw that nurse. And still wrote to Vera. Don’t spoil, but I need more Eugene and Basilone. Leckie annoys me.


r/ThePacific • • Mar 08 '24

Assuming the entire populace is passive and doesn't arm themselves and the soldiers have an MO of surrendering like the Germans, how difficult would invading mainland Japan be by 1945 before the nukes were dropped?

2 Upvotes

Its a universal cliche that so many Americans feared invading Japan and most academics and military analysts agree dropping nukes was the best thing because not only did Japanese soldier have an MO of refusing to surrender and fighting to the death but also because they were arming the entire civilian populace with weapons including giving housewives of military men guns and arming civilian family's children with spears and knives. Basically estimates are always expecting millions to be killed because not only will the well-disciplined Japanese army fight to the last man but even innocent children will do stuff like throw grenades out of nowhere at American convoys and sisters of soldiers will do knife stabbing ambushes. Basically many people were expecting invading Japan to be similar to the war we've been having in Iraq (full of stuff like suicide bombings and civilians pulling pistols and shooting American soldiers from behind, etc for the last decade except 10X worse).

However recently I read that although we tend to think of Japan as a small country who defeated much larger nations because of their culture immense self discipline, in reality Japan is not only roughly the size of Germany but also her population was a bit higher-so high that one of the main reasons they wanted to invade China was to provide livable lands to its citizens and for farming purposes.

Because of how complex stuff gets such as the evolution of the ancient Ashigaru system from Tokugawa system that was still practised by descendents of Samurai and naval infantry that still remained despite the destruction of the Japanese navy, (and I forgot, the 1 million troops in China) I will just leave it to the assumption we are merely fighting the remnants of the Japanese army that Operation Downfall often assumes and in the manner many wargamers and netizens discuss about the sorry state of Japan in 1945.

How would thinks end up? Documentaries, internet discussions, general history books, and pop media would have you believe the real fear of downfall was the entire populace of Japan getting spears, knives, and other last ditch weapon and doing Al Qaeda style terrorist attacks. As if the main Japanese army was so broken this point that it wouldn't matter.

So as I said only military men involved and no Japanese civilian attempts to do Al Qaeda style attacks and last minute volunteer similar to the Last Stand of the Confederacy in WW2 by untrained young men. And Japanese soldiers get sane and surrender in hopeless situations like Germans did (such as 3 soldiers in a house waving white flags when they see a squad of Americans approaching). And because I mentioned Japan is much larger and has a higher population than many people tend to assume (70 million, 10 million more than Germany's at the time, with Japan being almost as large as Germany's total land mass), I will allow properly trained draftees that was going through bootcamp a month before the scheduled invasion to be used and other properly military use of Japan's 10 million (such as training more local militia properly before being sent as conventional infantry reinforcements during the first month of the IJA remains holding off the initial waves of American assault). Not the spear armed children and other idiotic Al Qaeda style nonsense guerrilla warfare defense often assumed in Operation Downfall scenarios.

How heavy would casualty counts be? Would it be must lower than many wargamers and amateur historians assume because civilians won't be doing Al Qaeda style suicide attacks and because Japanese soldiers surrender in much larger numbers and earlier)? Or would Japan's similarity to Germany's geography(esp total area) and population numbers make a much much much bigger difference than the common assumption of civilian casualties bringing millions of deaths and prolonging the war that many internet discussions often conclude?

Is the only reason why a supposed real life Operation Downfall would cost horrific casualties on both side is because of the assumption that the people of Japan will fight Jihad style where just like ISIS, every one will practically fight to the death and use Al Qaeda style tactics like improvised hidden explosives, civilians charging at American soldiers in mass human waves with spears and blades, and Muslim fundamentalist suicide bombing MO by individual soldiers sneaking into an American camp? Or would even say a German and British style army defending Japan with a Westernized population and no mass conscription still be difficult to fight for the American landing forces?


r/ThePacific • • Jan 30 '24

Why did the Marines seek out maggot infested food for protein?

0 Upvotes

Are they stupid?

I didn't get the scene


r/ThePacific • • Jul 16 '24

Racism in the Marines

Thumbnail self.bandofbrothers
2 Upvotes

r/ThePacific • • Sep 03 '25

“Unrealistic” battle scenes?

38 Upvotes

On Episode 6, I am fairly well read on the Pacific War but some of the battle scenes seem off.

I know that at Alligator Creek the IJA units all but walked into an ambush, but the show seems to overdue depictions of “human wave” assaults that don’t seem to employ flanking or even suppressive fire by friendly MG’s.

At Peleliu for example the US Marines are depicted running across the mostly open airfield in large clumps, assaulting with no preparatory artillery or air strikes.

There’s no friendly naval gun support, air support, sledge and the other mortar crews (in the show) don’t fire for 5+ mins and there isn’t even suppression via MG’s.

If you can’t get accurate enough info for artillery fire or air support, fine. But not employing basic infantry doctrine learned during WW1 seems absurd.


r/ThePacific • • Oct 07 '24

PFAS reference in The Pacific?

0 Upvotes

In the second last episode of the series, Snafu remarks to a replacement marine about how the waterproof ponchos are full of chemicals and are making soldiers sick and that he can trade with him, leaving the new Marine with a tattered and destroyed poncho. Is this a reference to polyfluoroalkyl substances, Teflon and DuPont?


r/ThePacific • • Jan 22 '20

HAIRCUTS seriously?

0 Upvotes

About 3 minutes into watching and there's no way these are Marines, all of them need haircuts. It's not believable to watch for anybody that's been around Marines.

Did the director just pussy out on demanding realism from his actors??

Demi Moore had the balls to shave her head for GI Jane but these guys couldn't get a high n tight haircut??

Not impressed so far.


r/ThePacific • • May 29 '23

Snafus’s race

2 Upvotes

Was snafu black this has been puzzling me for the past 8 years in real life he looks like he’s mixed with something I’m aware he was Cajun but was he half or a quarter black?


r/ThePacific • • Sep 25 '26

Sometimes I wonder if Oda Island was real and they encountered the beast that lived there

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/ThePacific • • Mar 23 '25

Something is really bugging me in episode 7. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So great show, love it but something is bugging the F out of me. We all know Sledge is supposed to be of high moral character and it seems like they are angling him toward a more hateful arch (good) but... He rightfully kills a Japanese officer who is charging him with a katana earlier in the episdode. Then after the bunker is cleared they show him taking off and toying with a bayonet for a while before discarding it... Ok fine theyre trying to show his disillusionment with the idea of war prizes I guess? But why would they not have him go for the sword and do the same thing? A Japanese officer's sword was one of if not THE premier war prize one could get and he actually killed the owner fair and square. It bothered me A LOT that he didn't take the sword. Then just a short while later they show him ready to pry out a dead Japanese soldiers gold teeth, and ends up just taking the insignia which... ok I guess but he didn't even kill that guy. I just find that whole thing very clumbsy and annoying. Anyone else agree?


r/ThePacific • • Aug 23 '25

Anyone else feel like the storylines were scattered?

11 Upvotes

I just finished episode 9, and overall I enjoyed the series a decent bit but I feel like the storylines were kind of all over the place. I feel like it would’ve made more sense to maybe dedicate a certain number of episodes to each main character ( Leckie, Basilone, and Sledge) or something just to organize it better? I also felt like the combat was so broken up that it made it quite hard to follow where we were in the war. Maybe it’s just me, but those were the only criticisms I had, just curious if anyone else felt this way.


r/ThePacific • • Feb 19 '24

"HoHoHo"

0 Upvotes

r/ThePacific • • Oct 07 '23

Why are the Japanese portrayed as cartoonishly bad at soldiering?

12 Upvotes

They always scream before attacking to give a warning, even when they are ambushing. They can’t take a guy 4 against 1. In one scene a Marine is pooping in a cave and instead of shooting him or trying to stab him, he starts shouting then chases him through the camp until the others shoot him. Why was he even hiding in the cave? He could have just stayed where he was hidden. Why didn’t he have any kind of weapon? And with no weapon at all, why run into a camp of enemy soldiers. There are other scenes where the soldiers just run up to the marines and wait to be killed. Is this meant to be an accurate portrayal, or just poetic license to show the Japanese as stupid and inept?


r/ThePacific • • Mar 11 '26

Where to pirate?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I want to watch this this series to the end, but HDTODAY and Lekuluent are failing me. All the servers freeze on ep5 20:15 for a reason i will never know. Any suggestions? P.S. I also didn't really like the Melbourne episode, i just didn't care. Thanks