r/TheOSR • u/ScholarchSorcerous • Nov 11 '24
r/TheOSR • u/PersonalityFinal7778 • Jun 12 '23
Cool! I got booted from the other Reddit sub
Not sure what's going on over there. No message, no warning. It's a private community now. Maybe I mentioned Z one too many times. Who knows.
In other news I'm going to run horror on the hill with wbfmag soon. I'm excited. Got my cousins playing dnd. I ran them thru most of lmop in 5e. Now due to circumstances we will be playing online, so it's time for some old school dnd.
r/TheOSR • u/Ok-Image-8343 • Mar 14 '25
Tips for using an AI DM for a TTRPG noob?
Ive been using Grok voice mode with storyteller mode. Its fully uncensored, fits on my phone. I like to play by myself or when my friend and I take his kid to the park, itll DM for us. Unfortunately, voice mode cant resume chats nor can it read PDFs, yet.
If I give up voice mode then I can give it an entire OSR rules PDF and it will run an encounter using the rules, Ill experiment with giving it modules too. I can ask it to tell me everything its doing behind the narrative and reference each rule that it uses. If it tells me what its doing then that helps me build trust and learn how to DM. Im enjoying playing sandbox style and simulation style. I dont want the DM to pull any punches, if I die then I die. It does not go easy on me.
It cites all the rules that it uses and runs pretty fun games. It can even draw out a grid in ascii to represent maps and character locations that I can then use to set up minis.
It feels like a really good DM, but having never played real DND Im not sure what Im missing.
It does seem to have an advantage over a normal DM in that it can look up and calculate super complex rules instantly. Which makes me wonder whats the best rule set for an AI DM? From what I gather people hated DND 3.5 because it was so rules heavy and the rules bogged down the game, but with AI rules don't seem do bog down the game they seem to make it feel more real.
Can anyone recommend any rule sets that might be good for an AI DM? Or any suggestions at all?
I like playing with stakes and consequences to my actions.
r/TheOSR • u/Hacklette • Jan 15 '24
Other OSR Server - Encouraging piracy by moderators and users
r/TheOSR • u/[deleted] • Jul 26 '24
General Storytelling vs Simulation and what the OSR can learn from 5e's success
The biggest problem facing DnD is that most players want to play a story, not a simulation, but DnD is a simulation.
The point of all the mechanics in a role-playing game is to make the game impartial, so that no one player is fully in charge of what happens. This is the basic function of rolling dice, but also of stats, encounter tables, and all other mechanics. It removes agency from the DM and creates consistency which players can use to make decisions which have predictable results.
The advantage this has over free-form storytelling is that you are better able to inhabit the mind of a character when the outcomes his actions create are consistent and not based on the whims of any other player. You're doing more ROLE PLAYING. If the DM rolls up 25 kobolds on an encounter table, that's bad luck your character is experiencing. If the DM decides arbitrarily to make your character fight 25 kobolds, that's the DM fucking with you. When the DM is god, resistance to his whims are futile. When the rules are god, then learning the rules empowers you to strategize and succeed.
The problem is that after Ravenloft ('83), module and rules design gradually enhanced DM agency by creating contingencies DMs could trigger to make things happen at narratively appropriate moments. E.g.:
[If 2 days have passed and the players haven't found (clue), Strahd busts into their camp and kidnaps one of the players.]
This is the DM telling a story, not simulating the world as a neutral arbiter.
Storytelling is fine and fun, but the thing about DnD is that it makes storytelling VERY difficult, because you have to make your story consistent with a complex assembly of mechanical RULES, and (what's worse) with fairly unfettered player AGENCY. As successive editions of DnD have doubled and tripled down on the DMs role as storyteller, the planning burden on the DM has deepened and deepened; to create the highly thematic plots that players demand, they have to create contingencies balancing rules and agency against the imperatives of plot. The difficulty of balancing these things has given rise to three strategies that DMs and systems use, all of which have made modern DnD unpleasant.
The first is elaborate character building and the de-emphasis of non-combat procedures. This reached its apex with DnD 3e and Pathfinder. By giving the players a ton of options in BUILDING their character, the game limits optionality in PLAYING a character. By creating complicated and sophisticated combat systems which are, from a rules perspective, a walled garden, the game funnels player attention onto a domain of play with very limited outcomes (either the players win or they lose) and allows the DM complete latitude to shape events outside of this domain. Because players spend so long building a character, understanding feats and stats, etc, players want a chance to USE these character features, which are basically all related to the minutiae of combat. Combat grows more detailed, but combat OUTCOMES remain more or less binary; as a result, player agency is funneled into a system which presents minimal interference to DM storytelling.
The second is heavy reliance on modules. Balancing player agency, rules simulation, and storytelling is an enormous amount of work. Paying someone to do that work for you makes a lot of sense– and so, we began to rely heavily on modules. Ravenloft sold gangbusters and was the genesis of this strategy. It suits Wizards of the Coast just fine, to be sure– but it makes the mode of play much more about CONSUMING than CREATING. This strategy synchronizes with the growth in combat complexity– the more complex combat rules are, the harder they are to balance, so the greater the temptation grows to just pay for a professionally manufactured module that has worked out the balance ahead of time.
The third strategy emerged when these first two built upon each other to an unsustainable level– house rules, aka "just ignore the rules". An unintended side-effect of this escalating complexity was that DMs began to ignore rules entirely. This might seem liberating from the DM's perspective, but in practice it's disastrous; now all of the onus for not only managing the game but also what the rules even are is heaped on the DMs shoulders. This ethos of play– an increasingly common one, often presented to new DMs as the default– means that every ruling is a decision point for which their players can hold them accountable. Scarcely any illusion of neutrality remains.
The culmination of these trends, DnD 5e, as it is ACTUALLY played, is essentially a DM-led storytelling session disguised as a game. The DM tells you what happens, you break for a torturously involved combat session where actual mechanics are relevant for a minute, the DM decides by fudging rolls and making shit up whether your party wins or loses, and then you return to the storytelling. If the DM has put in dozens of hours of prepwork, is uncommonly talented at improv, or bought a module, the story is good. If not, the story is bad, and the players are unhappy. But what it isn't is a GAME.
The OSR solves all these problems neatly by simply giving up on storytelling and returning to what RPGs are actually FOR. The DM preps "situations" and the players interact with them as immersively as possible. No one knows ahead of time what will happen, the players don't blame the DM for what happens, and "stories emerge organically from play".
(Incidentally, this is why a lot of people who object to the OSR maintain you can play 5e like old-school DnD. This is certainly true, but the economy of player and DM attention means it's much more difficult to play it this way than it is in the house-ruling, making shit up way I described above. When I first got started DMing 5e, I actually had a co-DM who ran the combat rules and served as a rulebook against which I could check my decisions; it was effective, but wouldn't be necessary in an OSR game.)
But, as coherent and successful as the OSR has been at creating systems which play to the strengths of the medium and minimize its weaknesses, the movement remains relatively unpopular. The largest OSR YouTuber I'm aware of, Questing Beast, maintains a small but dedicated following, but is by no means mainstream. OSR systems and modules sell enough to keep the lights on but aren't meaningfully competing with the mainstream systems. In most corners of the RPG-playing internet, OSR fans are seen as rude, bossy, and judgmental for telling people that they're "playing the game wrong".
If, as I've claimed, the OSR solves the problems that make modern DnD so unbearable, why hasn't it been wildly successful?
Simply put, the general public doesn't WANT to play simulation-based, impartial games. They want to tell stories.
This isn't meant as a judgment; the relative unpopularity of the OSR doesn't make it any less enjoyable for those who can find groups to play with. The general public is unnecessary to the health of the movement. But this framing does suggest a few things that OSR creators and DMs looking for players should keep in mind.
The first thing is that DnD 5e's massive success is owed not to its actual rules, but to the way it presents its rules as negotiable. The flood of players brought in years ago by Critical Role see the system fundamentally as a backdrop for collaborative storytelling. Players create elaborate characters and DMs create plots for those characters, and anything that gets in the way of that back and forth is discarded. 5e succeeded by telling people to IGNORE it whenever and wherever they needed to in order to tell their story.
What this suggests is that real, mainstream, "DnD killing" success is possible through STORYGAMES, not RPGs. Probably, because RPGs are culturally legible and storygames are not, such a game would need to be presented as an RPG even if it isn't one. But the enormous tension and energy in modern RPGs– the constant flood of DMs complaining about players, of players complaining about DMs, of strategies, of name-calling, of reams and reams of advice– results from the fundamental opposition between the RPG people are playing and the storytelling game they actually want.
In my opinion, a competent, flexible, meaty storytelling game which meets the following criteria would wreck shop. A game which:
1: Is setting neutral, tone neutral, and plot neutral, to present itself as the "all-in-one" solution
2: Elevates one player (whoever actually bought the game) to a managerial position as the main storyteller, taking pressure off new players who might not know the rules
3: Supports some sort of module system to facilitate the reviews and product hauls that fandoms run on
4: Is sufficiently simple that anyone can master it but sufficiently complex that it's worth purchasing rather than just homebrewing it yourself
Previous storytelling games have probably all failed in one of these aspects. Of the ones I'm familiar with, Burning Wheel fails number 4 by being too complicated, and Polaris: Chivalric Tragedy at the Utmost North and Call of Cthulu fail number 1, because they have to tell specific kinds of stories.
The second thing that this understanding of 5e should teach the OSR is that it really needs to hammer home that it's a different type of game from DnD 5e. Most OSR games already do this, but on a DM level, you have to understand that new players might very well understand RPGs as "Storytelling sessions with combat systems", and explaining the difference of ethos to prospective players in some immediately legible way will make it easier to find the people who are actually interested in the OSR style of play. OSR games aren't just "better DnD" at this point.
The third thing is that, in rhetoric and online argument, OSR fans should probably stop trying to claim that organic storytelling is better than inorganic storytelling. A lot of people object to the OSR style of play because it seems cold and mechanical compared to a style in which DMs give events thematic significance. I often see people argue in response to this that stories that emerge immersively from play are somehow better than stories that are designed with intention. I think that this line of argument needs to be rethought. Really, what happens during a sesh of OSR play isn't a story, it's a MEMORY. It's a different type of activity which registers as a different experience. When you're cutting your way through the Bastion of the Boglings in your first sesh, lose your mage because he only had 4 hp, and barely make it out alive, you don't think of that as something that happened to Sir Lothric, you think of it as something that happened to YOU.
This is a different and valuable experience that is much less like a story than it is like a dream or a memory, and the reasons you might engage in such an experience are bound to be different. I really don't think it's the case that "OSR just isn't for everyone" or "OSR is for hardcore gamers" or whatever. As a rule, OSR games do a much better job of achieving what they set out to achieve than mainstream role playing games; they're much more self-consistent and easier to play. But most players don't understand at the outset that the experience we're trying to create is fundamentally different from the kind they're used to, and they bounce off it for that reason.
Anyway, if you've read to the end, I hope you found these thoughts interesting. I've been working on a story game of my own, though I haven't yet redesigned it to meet the 4 criteria I've outlined. I've also been DMing Mausritter, and intend to realign both my style of DMing and how I pitch the game to new players as well.
Edit: previous final sentence was misleading. I'm pitching Mausritter as less of a storytelling activity and more of a simulation, and creating a story game as a separate enterprise so to meet a different need.
r/TheOSR • u/Suarachan • Jul 24 '24
Blog REVIEW: Mothership 1e - Player's Survival Guide by Tuesday Knight Games [2/5]
r/TheOSR • u/LinksPB • Apr 22 '26
Links A response to Ben Riggs' claims on Gary Gygax
The first in a series of, at least two planned, response videos by Aten (WeLoveTTRPGs! Youtube channel) to Ben Riggs' claims on his blog post of July 7th 2024: https://www.writerbenriggs.com/blog/4h8ich5klfw83ehgcxamqko6u1yrg7
In case you worry about giving monetary support to someone whose views you don't support by simply watching this video: he turned off monetization for it.
r/TheOSR • u/VengerSatanis • Apr 23 '25
VENGER CON IV: Post-Modern Apocalypse (July - Madison, WI)

It's close enough to taste...
Venger Satanis is putting on his yearly con, this is the 4th. One of the smallest and most based RPG conventions in existence. July 18th - 20th. Guest of Honor this year is Sandy Petersen.
We would love to have you attend VENGER CON IV. Get your weekend badge now! https://tabletop.events/conventions/venger-con-iv
Thanks for checking it out and sharing this news on social media,
VS
r/TheOSR • u/AlucardD20 • Sep 12 '24
AD&D 1e AD&D Comeliness: The Power of Attraction, is the Attribute needed?
r/TheOSR • u/VengerSatanis • Jun 22 '22
Dungeons & Dragons My latest adventure, Rainbow Crystal Utopia, was taken down from DTRPG after one hour!
So, this time it took about one hour for DTRPG's protocols to trigger a pull from the shelves and review of my latest Cha'alt adventure. Only 6 downloads, but a number of complaints.
It's called Rainbow Crystal Utopia. I take a few satirical jabs at prevailing concerns of the day. Obviously, a certain segment of the gaming population doesn't like that very much... or me. That's why I have to wait another 2 business weeks to see if they'll "blacklist" it, like they did The Good Syma'arian.
If you want it, there's a way... https://vengersatanis.blogspot.com/2022/06/rainbow-crystal-utopia.html
Thanks for your continued support, hoss!
VS
r/TheOSR • u/TheWizardOfAug • Jan 31 '26
Podcast On OSR Tourists
Tourists in the OSR ecosystem: who are they, why are they here, and is it really appropriate to use the term "Tourist" as an insult?
On Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/2ocUzlvOh0B7dsM5CypORJ
On YouTube: https://youtu.be/iixH0iqnJME
r/TheOSR • u/AlucardD20 • May 11 '26
AD&D 1e The AD&D Druid Was Never Just a Nature Cleric
Today on the channel I am talking about the Druid Class in AD&D and how some people mistake the class as a Nature Cleric.
The AD&D Druid Was Never Just a Nature Cleric
r/TheOSR • u/Knubberub • Jul 03 '22
Links Interview with Zak S and Michelle Ford
Recently I conducted an interview with Michelle Ford and Zak S – we talked about a lot of things
Here is a link to the recording of it -- https://youtu.be/Axg1duLBuxE
Here are some reasons it is important:
1: Michelle is a woman of color who is often dismissed as a liar or sockpuppet.
2: Michelle is a direct eye witness, and has made statements for Zak.
3: People ignore Michelle and other women that stood up for Zak, dismissing them for a variety of reasons.
4: People dismiss Zak or spread misinformation about him – in this interview he refutes or addresses all claims I have heard or read levied against him.
5: Zak is still in legal action – so if he was lying, this video would be proof against him – think about this when you consider what he has to say.
Zak and Michelle had to have a lot of bravery and time to make this happen – so please give them some support, they deserve better than they were given.
If you care about this whole situation – Please Comment, Like, Retweet, Share, anything helps – Just a little effort is noticed and appreciated greatly.
Thank you!
r/TheOSR • u/hoja_nasredin • Nov 02 '23
General AI created bestiary. Please comment 2 monsters you liked and 2 you hated
files.catbox.moer/TheOSR • u/K9ine9 • Mar 03 '23
Now that "He who may not be named" has cleared his name will the ban be reversed?
r/TheOSR • u/ScholarchSorcerous • Jan 18 '24
Links Tabletop Review: Shadowdark RPG by Kelsey Dionne - 6/10 - ******
r/TheOSR • u/TheMayorHasArrived • Jul 24 '22
Update - Tenkar's Minions Shirt has Arrived - Should be Available for the Masses Before the End of Summer
r/TheOSR • u/VengerSatanis • Aug 04 '21
Dungeons & Dragons Old-School more immersive than modern D&D?
I use 3 points to determine that pre 3rd edition D&D is objectively more immersive (and therefore superior) to "modern" D&D, such as 3rd and 4th edition. 5th edition is more of a hybrid between the two, which is why it's so popular.
This discussion has enjoyably and hilariously blown-up on FB, so thought I'd offer it here. I'm happy to debate any claims made by myself. Let's get it on!
The YouTube link: https://youtu.be/7oaVUASdQn4
Thanks for watching,
VS
r/TheOSR • u/notquitedeadyetman • Dec 07 '24
Blog Race-as-Class vs Race-and-Class, and the Solution
r/TheOSR • u/nlitherl • Oct 23 '22
General Character Reputation in RPGs: The Small Legend
r/TheOSR • u/nlitherl • Oct 16 '22