r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Feb 16 '25

As a remainder, if your comment or post boils down to "I don't like LGBT people existing in Nosleep", you will be banned. No warnings, no second chances.

480 Upvotes

This will be a permanent ban. Also, if you see posts/comments like this please report it and message the mods (sometimes reports don't show up).


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Oct 15 '21

Off-Topic Classic NSP

Post image
228 Upvotes

r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Oct 05 '24

Discussion Goodbye, NoSleep.

225 Upvotes

So I was introduced to The NoSleep Podcast around 2014-2015, when an old high school friend told me about it. It was the first time since grade school that I was genuinely frightened by horror fiction.

I was an avid fan for years, going so far as to ask for a NoSleep hoodie for Christmas and going to see the live show in Atlanta, where I was living at the time.

You can imagine how painful it was, then, to admit that after season 8, NoSleep had gotten far too big for its britches. I was willing to pay for the season passes up to 13, but after Lightning McQueen became a NoSleep villain I just couldn't take it anymore. But it made no sense in the end to keep paying an increasing price for diminishing returns.

But this past controversy was the final nail in the coffin. It's one thing to change to a monthly subscription when people have already paid for season passes, but allowing those season passes to expire when we've already paid for them? And yes, I know it was said multiple times on the podcast and posted to social media, but that doesn't make up for the fact that those season passes, which we paid for, are gone.

Thankfully, I found a way to get my season passes back, and I only took the ones I already paid for because that's the kind of guy I am, but I can promise that NoSleep won't be getting another penny from me. Not that it'll really matter or will ever even be noticed, but I just wanted whoever works on this podcast and who also reads stuff in this group to know that I, who was once an enormous fan of NoSleep and considered it my favorite podcast, is completely fed up with the nonsense and incredibly disappointed.

My suggestions for the podcast going forward:

  1. Be willing to listen to criticism instead of blocking and/or attacking people who have something negative to say about what's going on. I understand you all work hard for our entertainment, but you can't move forward if you live in an echo chamber and only listen to the positive feedback. Not all criticism is meant to hurt.

  2. Try maybe going back to basics. NoSleep was so much more effective without all of the celebrity cameos and season themes and overproduction. Instead of making a 2 hour plus episode, maybe go back to the hour-long time and take stories from the subreddit and get amateur voice actors; that way you can kick-start new careers, help fledgling new writers and with the shorter time span, you'll have a backlog of stories to choose for newer episodes. At any rate, it'll allower the budget to go to better use and allow the podcast to reclaim its former glory.

Given the entertainment you guys have given me, I'd sincerely like to thank you, but there have been too many disappointments recently and I refuse to support this podcast any further.

Goodbye,

S.


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Apr 01 '24

Off-Topic "His fingers were too long" "He had too many teeth"

Post image
218 Upvotes

r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Nov 14 '20

The NSP Sux If i could eliminate one "genre" of story from this podcast...

Post image
182 Upvotes

r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Nov 10 '21

NSP = Bad Anyone else really hate the Better Help ads specifically?

170 Upvotes

I listen on Spotify and I've yet to buy any season passes but I've listened to every single free episode from ep 1 til now. I don't mind ads, I get why they're there, stuffs expensive and that's fine.

God I hate the Better Help ads though. Like one, Better Help is a horrible service that overcharges and has no quality assurance. Two, all the ads have this fake concern quality to them, like "Oh, you're stressed, depressed and anxious? Is the pandemic too much? Is socializing during the holidays too much? Well, sign up for this overpriced service with a history of screwing over customers and low BBB ratings, and we get a kick back!"

The other sponsorships are fine but that one in particular rubs me the wrong way. Not that I have any authority on this but they should really drop Better Help as a sponsor and replace it with... literally anything else.


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Oct 19 '22

Discussion The Top Ten NoSleep Podcast Stories

139 Upvotes

Contrary to what many people in this community may think, I’m actually a huge fan of The NoSleep Podcast.

I’ve listened to the show’s ENTIRE free archive nearly a half dozen times , and my often sharply worded criticisms of the show ultimately come from a place of genuine enjoyment.

For a long time I’ve debated in my head, “what are the best stories the NoSleep Podcast has ever done?”

What does “best” even mean? Best performances? Best production value? Best pure writing itself ?

I tried to kind of take all three of these things into account with these choices. A few really good stories didn’t make the cut , because sometimes a great story doesn’t necessarily make a great podcast adaptation.

I also limited the upper tier authors to ONE story each. Otherwise, no joke, it would be a list of nothing but Jimmy Juliano and Jared Roberts with one or two stray CK Walker stories lol.

Here’s a few runners up that I felt just barely missed my very loose qualifications for being a great podcast story. These are all good to great stories , but some specific element of their podcast adaptation form holds them back from the S-tier :

The Oddkids, A Story to Scare My Son, Better Days, Soft White Damn, the Jack monster, Undying Love, and Trying to Remember a Pop Song.

So anyway, here’s a few hundred words praising a show that I supposedly hate - The Top 10 NSP Stories:

10.The Stairs and the Doorway, by Eric Dodd - S1E01: I’ve long championed the NSP’s inaugural story for being one of the most effective adaptations they’ve ever created. There’s something supremely effective about the stripped down, low key narration by David Cummings , especially when viewed in hindsight against a show that nowadays often feels needlessly over-produced.

The pleasant background music gives the story a wistful and nostalgic atmosphere that slowly descends into horror as the tension ramps up. The actual story itself is blunt and to the point, and at least contextualizes its wacked out goings-on in a way that listeners can relate to. The Stairs and the Doorway is the story that started it all, and hooked many listeners into a decade+ of nightmares. The current show could learn a thing or two from the borderline bare-bones production aspects of this story.

9.Little Lost Amy, by Dan Fields - S11E23: I’m someone who’s always quick to call out the generally weak story quality of the last couple years of NSP seasons, but I’m also just as quick to acknowledge when something lands. Little Lost Amy is one of the strongest “modern” NSP stories ever featured.

The story has notes of a classic NoSleep/creepypasta, with an urban legend vibe and structure of just “someone relating a creepy experience.” It both embraces and eschews expected conventions of the show, and the brief glimpse we get of the titular supernatural creature is genuinely terrifying. It’s also notable for featuring a rare Corinne Sanders performance that doesn’t involve her being a mopey, unpopular high schooler.

Little Lost Amy is a creepy outing that doesn’t overstay it’s welcome, which stands out even more against a notably terrible season. It’s a conventional type of story for the show, perfectly done with its own unique elements. This is also the NSP episode with the first ad for the inevitably doomed “NoSleep Trading Card” scam Kickstarter. The horror.

8.My Uncle Ford, by Jackson Laughlin - S7E11: This may be a wild card entry on a list like this, but I’ve always had a soft spot for this story. It’s more of a surreal psychological character study than flat out horror, and features prose and structure that feel elevated compared to typical podcast outings.

The voice cast is phenomenal here, with notorious Super Ham DC giving one of his few genuinely great performances as the multi-limbed uncle. There’s a great mounting tension to this story, which is supported by the strong characterization, as the listener knows things are going to go so, so wrong. My Uncle Ford is an underrated gem of the NSP - somber and unnerving with a potent and mournful emotional core.

7.Hum, by William Stuart - S16E10: This is the most recent story on my list, being a part of the 10th anniversary celebrations from the summer of 2021. Hum really shows how good the show can still be when it wants to. These dialogue-only, audio play style stories can often feel hit or miss, but Hum nails all the key aspects.

It’s a supremely creepy , skin crawling story that is mostly effective in what it’s not showing you. It features strong characterization and naturalistic dialogue, with every voice actor cast perfectly in their respective role.

Even the usually annoying (sacrilege I know) Peter Lewis kills it as the demonic presence. With an emphasis on subtlety, flirtations with techno-horror, and excellent production elements, it’s no stretch to call Hum an upper tier podcast story. There’s no reason EVERY audio play style story can’t be this good.

6.Room 733, by CK Walker - S4E15(Halloween 2014): Our first encounter of the list with one of NSP’s “Mount Rushmore”, CK Walker is an author for whom my enjoyment of her work predates my fandom of the NSP. Walker is a talented writer - even her weaker stories tend to land on a purely mechanical level, and it’s no wonder she’s one of the subreddit and podcast’s most iconic authors.

It was kind of hard to pick one singular story above the many great works of hers the show has featured over the years. My mind always goes back to Room 733 though. This is just a great story, and a great audio adaptation to boot. Jessica McEvoy shines in the lead role; she’s a VA who I can sometimes find a little grating, but this story was a great fit for her.

The production value for this story in general is S-tier. It’s a great and immersive listen, with the full cast production combined with CK’s excellent writing giving it a borderline cinematic feel. Room 733 is just an excellent, excellent story. It’s everything great about CK Walker, and the NoSleep Podcast.

5.The Stump, by Ashley Franz Holmann - Extra Sleepless Vol. 1: The voice performances for this story alone should put it in the “all timer” conversation, but The Stump is fantastic on a pure narrative level as well. Jonathan Jones is genuinely terrifying as the monstrous creature. So many of the monsters and villains on this show are either hammed to death, or given completely corny over-modulated vocal effects.

Jones gives a freakish and skin crawling performance without any bells and whistles - just a creepy ass voice saying creepy shit. The story itself is surreal but also has an easy to follow logical through line. On a deeper level, the story also seems to be exploring themes of child abuse or some kind of sexual trauma.

The podcast does NOT usually handle those kinds of subjects with any kind of nuance or depth, so it’s nice to see a story that isn’t slapping you in the face with what it’s trying to say. The Stump is a unique story for the podcast on multiple levels, and has always lived in my memory as one of its greatest feats.

4.Spitting Image, by Meg Molloy - S12E05: The first time I ever heard this story, my initial thought was “This is like a really good episode of Tales From the Crypt.” Indeed, Meg Molloy’s hilarious horror comedy tale involves a supremely unlikable (though highly entertaining) protagonist meeting a cruel and violent fate. The thing that puts Spitting Image in my personal top 5 is that this is a genuinely hilarious story. I struggle to think of another “comedic” NSP story that pulls off the concept as well as Spitting Image.

Most “funny” NSP stories are cornball yuk yuk bullshit, or unintentionally funny. Graham Rowat is the unifying thread that ties this adaptation together - his deadpan narration completely sells the protag’s hilarious complete lack of self awareness. The horror elements are effective too though.

I’m a sucker for horror imagery involving the human body or facial features being twisted and changed to “not quite right” , and Molloy includes a great deal of that in the story. Spitting Image is more proof that the exception proves the rule when it comes to post-Season 10 era NSP’s dubious quality.

3.My Dad Finally Told Me What Happened That Day, by Jared Roberts - S8E25: To me, Jared Roberts is one of the greatest authors the podcast has ever adapted. I struggled to choose which of his stories I’d place on this list, because to me they’re basically all great (possibly excluding the season 15 finale Sunburn, which is something of a mess both on and off the page and was sadly apparently responsible for the disintegration of Roberts’ relationship with the NSP). I decided that this story, which was likely the introduction to his work for many listeners, was the one to go with.

My Dad Finally Told Me is a surreal epic, mashing together numerous threads to create a completely mind-screwing story where almost nothing is explained, but somehow feels more satisfying and creepy than any story where things are spelled out in black and white. From a production and performance standpoint, the whole staff brought their A-game. Particularly, noted “objective best narrator of the whole show”

Mike Delgaudio , whose charming everyman delivery is a perfect contrast to Roberts’ brain melting narrative. The story touches on themes of repressed childhood memories, abuse, demonic possession and trauma - all well traveled roads in horror, but written with Roberts’ unique voice and perspective.

By the end, seemingly disjointed chapters all coalesce to something that is both cohesive and not, but altogether terrifying either way. I know his work is somewhat divisive for it’s confusing nature, but to me Jared Roberts work is the best of what horror has to offer, and his debut effort for the podcast still stands as one of the show’s finest moments.

2.I Used to Work the Grill at Reservation Diner, by Samir Hamrouni - S8E20: This is probably another dark horse pick, but I’ve always thought this was a total sleeper hit in the NoSleep library. The story has a unique tone and perspective that isn’t often seen in horror, and in certain ways it almost reminds of the work of like a Joe R. Lansdale.

There’s something so captivating about the story’s central antagonists - the racist diner owner/cannibalistic humanoid pair is a ton of fun, and there’s an intriguing mystery hanging over the story as to just how these two came to be pals that I think gives the whole narrative such extra depth and weight. It’s an effective one off story that gives you little snippets of a bigger picture.

Matthew Bradford is one of my least favorite VA’s, but the strong material eases him into a good performance, and The Man Mike Delgaudio is having a ton of fun as the lead villain in a rare antagonist role. I just really love this fucking story and wish the podcast adapted more stuff like it. Reservation Diner has got some edge and a unique voice, but is ultimately just a really really good story about a creepy monster fucking shit up.

1.Uncle Gerry’s Family Fun Zone, by Jimmy Juliano - S6E07: Jimmy Juliano is the not only the greatest author the NoSleep Podcast has ever adapted, he’s possibly one of the great modern horror writers of the last decade+. Everything this man writes is phenomenal, and his ability to weave a complicated yet satisfying story is pretty much unmatched. Like Jared Roberts, I struggled to choose which story of his to feature on this list. Ultimately, I had to choose Uncle Gerry’s Family Fun Zone.

This story quite literally has it all. From excellent narration - including a standout performance from Nikolle Doolin, whose read of the chilling final line lives rent-free in my head - to the actual story itself being a completely haunting mindfuck. Juliano serves up some of the creepiest imagery and full stop the most effectively terrifying moment to moment storytelling ever adapted on the podcast. I’ve listened to this story more than any other that the show has ever done. I simply keep coming back to it year after year. There’s not much more you could ask for in a horror story on a podcast. Uncle Gerry’s Family Fun Zone is not only the best Jimmy Juliano story, it’s the best story the NoSleep Podcast has ever adapted.

Well, there it is. I wrote this list to spark some discussion - agree, disagree, wanna list your own personal top 10? Lemme know. I hope maybe I gave some people a new perspective on a story or two that they mightve already had an opinion about, or gave newer listeners some potential material to check out.


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Jan 03 '25

Discussion The NSP Doesn’t feel scary any more

120 Upvotes

Just a little bit of a vent/rant here. Been listening to the NSP since around 2016-17, including season passes and now Sleepless Sanctuary. Every Monday at work it’s on in my headphones. I’m now going back and starting from the beginning that’s on the paid Spotify channel, S3.

Still love the podcast and will continue to sub, but I’ve been feeling the last year or two that it’s really lost its edge. Revisiting old episodes, the stories and sound design are really creepy and atmospheric and unsettling. Recent years… not so much.

But lately it’s felt too over-produced and too predictable? I feel like the tension and anxiety is gone. I specifically remember “It’s Later Than You Think” s19e25 finale, being so predictable, not scary, and just felt like self-indulgent. Like ‘o look at this complex story that jumps around and maybe it’s an unreliable narrator and maybe the situation isn’t what it seems???’ Except I saw the ‘twist’ coming like 25% through. But worst is that it just really wasn’t scary or unsettling in the slightest.

There are definitely ups and downs, and overall it’s still good, but a good chunk of stories are like that now. Plus the real heavy use of the theme framing the seasons is really hit or miss.

Rant over. Still love the podcast but just miss the real sense of dread that old episodes gave me.

Also: the less said about David singing as Creepy Santa the better. Please no more.


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Jan 05 '20

Nolseep Trading Card Kickstarter The NoSleep Podcast Illustrated trading card possible scam masterpost

117 Upvotes

Hey r/TheNSPDiscussion, I’m here to talk about supposed scam run by Charlie Cody and his wife.

I’ve been posting about this story on r/TheNSPDiscussion for a while and have decided to compile a masterpost.

Backstory:

The Nosleep Podcast is a horror podcast that’s been running since 2011. It features multiple voice actors reading stories from r/nosleep. It’s pretty popular now and on its thirteenth season at the time of writing this.

The podcast features a piece of artwork for each new episode. Charlie Cody, who runs the Kickstarter, has been working on the podcast since season 6.

As a long time artist for the podcast, Charlie asked for the podcast creator’s blessing to create a Kickstarter using art from the podcast. It wasn’t an official Nosleep Podcast product but it was promoted on their social media.

The Kickstarter:

“The NoSleep Podcast Illustrated trading card set showcases some of the most haunting original artwork from the show’s visual history.”

120 illustrations from 17 artists (including Cody) were pitched. $10 for the cards but if you could afford between $75-$250 you could get a piece of original art by Nosleep artists.

The Kickstarter finished funding on the 30th November 2018. Cody initially set the delivery date as the holidays 2018.

The Scam:

5th December 2018

Cody realised it would more likely be mid-January for the cards to be delivered due to Kickstarter processing the funds. He claims the holidays deadline wasn’t set in stone and he did update the backers to let them know so everyone was ok with it.

31st January 2019

u/duckbats asks on r/TheNSPDiscussion if anyone backed the Kickstarter as cards were meant to ship mid-January.

u/gaelfling says the Kickstarter isn’t an official NSP product.

u/duckbats contemplates if Cody will take the money raised and run.

u/satanistgoblin points out it’s not run away to Bolivia money.

1st February 2019

u/duckbats states an anonymous artist working on the project messaged her to say that despite the mid-January deadline, artists haven’t been paid and Cody won’t answer emails.

3rd February 2019

u/jilliangreen33 comments that there have been setbacks but cards are still in production. The user comes off as very hostile, claiming Cody has a full time job and is doing everything himself. The user also seems angry that the illustrators have not helped with organising the Kickstarter but want to be paid.

4th February 2019

u/duckbats replies that illustrators will get paid before working on a piece. The user also points out that everyone has jobs but there should be an update even if it’s small.

Later that day an update is posted on the Kickstarter page. Cody takes aim at u/duckbats for suggesting the Kickstarter is a scam. He also states he’s the only one working behind the scenes and there have been supplier problems.

5th April 2019

u/duckbats asks r/TheNSPDiscussion what happened to the Kickstarter.

15th April 2019

u/duckbats says the same artist reached out to her again to say that Cody hasn’t spoken to artists since the February update.

17th April 2019

u/foolishchoices comments that they are an artist on the project. The user confirms u/duckbats’ source and says they haven’t heard from Cody since February. The user says there was a problem with the prototype; hence the delay. Sketches and Commission rewards still haven’t been started. They state they have no information on the client and have not been paid.

24th June 2019

u/foolishchoices comments on r/TheNSPDiscussion claiming Cody messaged artists privately (there was no KS update) to say there had been several health emergencies which slowed down production time. Cody then said he hadn’t calculated shipping correctly to get materials to artists for some rewards.

The artists didn’t hear from him for a while until he updated to say he had gotten married to his wife which further slowed down production times. However the prototype was fixed and artists would receive pictures soon but that was 2 weeks ago according to u/foolishchoices.

3rd August 2019

u/duckbats posts to r/TheNSPDiscussion that theres still no Kickstarter update.

16th August 2019

u/duckbats posts a screenshot to r/TheNSPDiscussion.

Screenshot

It appears to be a private group on Facebook for Cody and the artists to talk.

The post asks if artists raised money for the KS or Cody’s wife’s new business.

A second artist chimes in that they assumed the KS paid for the Cody’s wedding.

A third artist says imagine raising 11k for an officially licensed product only to take funds to pay for your wedding/wife’s side business.

17th August 2019

u/foolishchoices states artists still haven’t been paid and reveals another 2 reasons for delays was a car wreckage and left just being hectic.

19th August 2019

u/Varo comes forward as another artist and apologises for what is happening with the Kickstarter. The artists had no idea Cody would behave like this and they all trusted him. They also stated it’s important to remember that there is no evidence the money went to the wedding or Jillian Cody’s side business.

u/Varo confirms artists have seen pictures of the prototypes now but as Charlie is the only one with access to the KS and money, the artists can’t do anything.

The user goes on to say Jillian Cody has become a middle man for her husband in April despite no one agreeing to this. Artists have contacted both Cody’s privately and publicly but received no response.

20th August 2019

u/cucubert points out Jillian’s business pages are filled with questions about the KS.

u/varo says they cannot see the comments but say no one working on the KS is encouraging people harass the business. The user would like to see the comments if people have screenshots though.

u/cucubert responds “Commenter said that Jillian ghosting the community and leaving artists to be approached by angry backers when this was their Kickstarter was unprofessional and that people were beginning to think that this new business was what the Kickstarter money had gone to. Commenter said that regardless of whether or not this was the case, the backers, NSP, and artists deserved an explanation of what was going on. The shop initially replied asking that they be contacted privately with such matters and that they asked to be treated with the same respect they show their patrons. Then commenter pointed out that as the Cody's were not reachable by Kickstarter, e-mails, or any other form of contact, this way seemed like the only way to get their attention and that ghosting the artists and backers was not respectful.

The shop then denied that they even knew what was being talked about until a screenshot was posted of Jillian's friend saying (the business) was Jillian's new business.

As soon as that happened the shop stopped replying. Just silence. Sometime after, I suppose they deleted the entire conversation.

I'll post the screenshots later if my friend has them (I foolishly did NOT think to take any).

I'll end this by saying that I have a source saying the Cody's have completely ghosted not just the Kickstarter backers and artists, but also the NSP and that a member of NSP who has been trying to email them for months have received no reply. And yet here is this very active social media account proving that the lack of contact from the Codys is by choice, and perhaps even intentional.

I have an artist friend who is tied to this project, and I don't want her business to be affected because she is tied to this Kickstarter, nor the business of every other artist, none of who have received any payment to have their businesses affected by the Cody's ghosting on the project.”

u/duckbats states she has people she loves working on the project which is why she started making these posts. She claims to have also been in contact with Kickscammers on YouTube.

u/foolishchoices chimes in to say the Cody’s once claimed slow progress on a sprained ankle.

u/cucubert posts the screenshots

Screenshot 1

Screenshot 2

In the KS comments someone called Claire claims she has received an update apologising for the delay. The KS is 2/3rd finished and updates for the KS was posted to Cody’s page rather than the KS. (This doesn’t seem to be the case).

21st August 2019

An update is posted to the Kickstarter page. Cody apologises for the lack of updates and states backers will receive regular communication from now on. The update also posts pictures of the box the cards will be stored in.

Cody also comments on the KS comments and says he’s sorry again. The says the only way he could have completed the KS to the original deadline is if he took it on as a full time job. He says he has realistic deadlines planned and more updates soon. He also claims social anxiety is a reason he doesn’t update much.

u/foolishchoices posts to r/TheNSPDiscussion that one of the Cody’s came to the private Facebook group to yell at the artists for being unhelpful and assuming the Cody’s stole the money. They also explained the cost of their wedding and the history of Jillian’s business.

23rd August 2019

u/varo thinks Jillian posted the update as Charlie doesn’t use emojis. Varo says they didn’t know who Jillian was until she became a middle man in April. Varo also claims Charlie gave regular email updates to artists until he was paid the 11k.

Varo also states there have been no images of products on the Kickstarter for the last 8 months so it’s hard to say when the pictures were taken. These pictures could possibly be the prototype designs from earlier in the year.

24th August 2019

u/foolishchoices agrees that the pictures are old pictures. They also point out that they’re unsure what the art in the update was for.

u/Varo says Jillian would say she worked on the KS every night but Varo was unsure what Jillian could be working on.

31st October 2019

u/duckbats posts a screenshot of angry KS comments to r/TheNSPDiscussion

Comments

30th November 2019

It has been a year since the KS campaign ended.

29th December 2019

u/duckbats privately messages Jillian’s side business on Facebook and asks her to tell Charlie to update the Kickstarter. Worried Jillian wouldn’t respond, u/duckbats reminded her some think the money went to her business so an update is really needed.

30th December 2019

The business responds and explains several people run the business and Jillian isn’t running social media but can pass the message along.

The business confirmed Jillian was in a car accident and the driver settlement paid out was put into this business.

Messages

11th January 2020

Charlie Cody’s portfolio website is down

screenshot

24th January 2020

u/duckbats notices the website is down and alerts the community.

28th January 2020

u/duckbats states Charlie Cody removed every post made about the Kickstarter on his Facebook page. Unfortunately there are no before and after pictures. It’s assumed to be taken down after all the negative comments on the posts. However his art page still contains the images.

Facebook screenshots

u/duckbats also confirms Jillian’s car crash was real as Jillian posted pictures on Facebook.

Censored photos of the crash

23rd February 2020

u/duckbats decides to update the masterpost. Out of curiosity, she checks if Cody’s website is still down.

Cody now has a new website on Squarespace and has a “call to action” banner that states he is taking commissions.

Charlie Cody new website

Screenshots in case the site is taken down

5th August 2020

u/Duckbats comments its almost been a year since the last Kickstarter update and Cody hasn’t logged in since.

15th August 2020

Olivia White, the chief operating officer for the podcast, logs into Cody’s Kickstarter account and makes an update.

The Kickstarter is no longer an independent work; the podcast is now directly involved.

Backers will be compensated with extras and minor edits may be made.

White claims the Cody’s have experienced a tragedy but cannot elaborate at this time. She ensures she has evidence to prove this fact and will reveal more in time.


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • May 23 '22

Discussion Borrasca

109 Upvotes

Alright. I see A LOT of hate for Borrasca on this sub. I read it in its original form, have listened to both the nosleep and qcode productions of it and I still like it and still think it shocks and disturbs. This post is me looking for ANYONE who actually liked it. I'm tired of looking for stories or scrolling through comments where people passively patronize me and others for liking stuff, great example is when people are looking for stories an someone goes "wow that was fast!" And the response is "yeah everyone knows that one because we hate it."

I like Borrasca. I understand that its not for everyone because it is often the case that using sexual abuse as the height of horror is fucking gross. However, to me, the notion of everyone assuming supernatural or otherwise elements over human evil conveys a truth that is uncomfortable. Too often, rich men in power are the villains of many stories. On that, it is an excellent allegory for the harms of capitalism and patriarchy, the main source of the villains in the real world. I see people online and irl calling it an "Epstein island ending" and the same conversations often call it unrealistic, which is funny and I hope I don't have to explain why. Horror can be an escape, and that is a wonderful thing and one of the main reasons I gravitate towards it, but it also be a mirror on the monstrosities of the world.

TL;DR: I actually liked borrasca and hate the condescension I see on people's tastes in horror. If you didn't like it, this post isn't for you. Please, fans, tell me what you liked about it!


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Jun 13 '25

Discussion I've FINALLY finished listening to all of NSP (free + paid)! Here's a list of my personal top 150 stories across all seasons.

102 Upvotes

It took 7 years, but I’ve finally listened to ALL 22 seasons (free + paid content) of the NoSleep Podcast! I love the show and it’s been a blast. It’s also just insane how many hours of content NSP has released, and working through the backlog is hampered by the regular release of new material. For anyone curious, I started listening while Season 11 aired. At that point, I essentially listened on 2 tracks at once, oscillating between new content and old content.

Presently, I thought it would be fun to compile my favorite stories. When I went through the list of stories and made a chart of all my favorites, I ended up with about 175, and from there I thought it would make sense to condense them to the round number of 150. If you want to see the stories that barely missed the cut, you can find them here, and I naturally excluded from consideration the stories I wrote that have been on the show.

If all you’re interested in is just a straightforward list of my favorite stories without any stats, asides, or descriptions, you can take a look at it here! Otherwise, feel free to peruse the longer version below.

Probably the biggest "heavy hitters" not to appear here are The Showers and Whitefall. I've always thought that the former just didn’t deliver enough to justify its long-ass buildup, and I've always had divided feelings about the latter as described here.

Before getting started, some quick stats:

  • The writer with the most stories here is C.K. Walker with 12, followed by C.M. Scandreth with 8. After that, it gets a little complicated with how you count certain series (i.e., counting Tales of the Moon Beast as 1 story versus 5 stories) but essentially the writers with the next-most stories are Marcus Damanda and Manen Lyset, followed by Henry Galley and Oli White, followed by Rona Vaselaar, Kelsey Donald, and Jared Roberts. No one else has more than 2 stories on here.

  • 96 of these stories, or just under two-thirds, derive from seasons 1-11, and the rest are from later. The seasons with the most stories are season 1 (with 14), season 2 (with 12), season 5 (with 10), and then seasons 3, 6, and 7 (with 9 each). The seasons with the fewest stories are 22 (with 1), followed by 11, 13, and 16 (with 4 each).

I note that the descriptions are not intended as any kind of deep analysis, just a succinct reference to 1-2 things that jump out to me about them. Also, feel free to drop some of your favorite stories below, especially if I omitted any that you think deserve attention!

With all that out of the way, here is the list:

-150. S9E10 Burn by C.M. Scandreth

Highlights: That there’s so much depth to it, as it explores masculinity, femininity, sexuality, loneliness, and insecurity using an array of multilayered metaphors.

-149. S19E25 It's Later Than You Think by C.K. Walker.

Highlights: How it builds carefully towards an ending that does not hold back in its relentless mean-spiritedness.

-148. S15E12 Graduating by Michael Harris Cohen

Highlights: The one guy who avoids eternal suffering by never rising above mediocrity. This remains one the bleakest and most cynical stories NSP has ever released in a way that has stuck with me.

-147. S10E06/S10E16 The Black Square/The Black Square is Growing by Matt Dymerski

Highlights: The central conceit, which manages to be ominous yet vague enough to serve as a vehicle to explore the narrator's community and a local government that couldn't care less about it.

-146. S22E02 What Becomes of Human Resources by Rob Tiemstra

Highlights: The absurdly timely political commentary, plus Nikolle Doolin's razor-sharp performance.

-145. S13E05 Troll Bridge by William Stuart

Highlights: How the last few minutes take the bullied-kid-fights-back trope in a harrowing and unpredictable direction.

-144. S16E14 Fascimile by Michael Miersen

Highlights: Jesse Cornett's fantastic performance, and the genuine threat posed by the "mimics."

-143. S2E04 Hide and Seek by Troy Lewis

Highlights: Hearing a tapping at the door of an isolated cabin in a snowstorm, and the way the monster parallels the narrator's abusive father.

-142. S14E25 Canadian Paranormal Encounters by Manen Lyset

Highlights: Near-death by rolling bookshelf & the amazing art by Emily Canon.

-141. S11E02 Black Sand by Gemma Amor

Highlights: Just how exceedingly well-written the prose is throughout. Plus, grisly death by hot sand.

-140. S15E23 Spacegirl by Ryan Peacock

Highlights: The character interactions and the ludicrously unsubtle pro-LGBT message, something the podcast could use a bit more of honestly.

-139. S18E21 A Long December by Stephanie Scissom

Highlights: The cast of characters, and how fluidly this incorporates a few supernatural elements into a compelling murder mystery with a true crime feel.

-138. S17E01 Listen Right by Austin R. Ryan

Highlights: The buildup in the music and the final line - shivers.

-137. S2 Bonus #3 Tunnels by Michael Whitehouse

Highlights: The detailed descriptions of the claustrophobic setting (sewers of Amsterdam), and the moment Henke realizes the ghost girl is pointing not at him but behind him. Also, I feel a little bad listing only this one Michael Whitehouse story here, has he's written a plethora of stuff I liked and admired, just only a few that resonated particularly strongly with me personally.

-136. S3E19 Locked In by Kelsey Donald

Highlights: How well it captures the spookiness of an empty late-night office.

-135. S10E22 What Became of Lavinia Cartwright by S.H. Cooper

Highlights: The poignancy with which the injustice faced by Lavinia was presented, plus the general spookiness of encountering ghosts in an abandoned building.

-134. S13E06 Blackberry Gap by Luke Kondor

Highlights: Just how hauntingly this presents a patch of land that devours even the memories of its victims (something rife with metaphorical implications).

-133. S7E18-21 Stolen Tongues by Felix Blackwell

Highlights: I love stories set in isolated winter cabins, and this one benefits from so many creepy sounds coming from the woods and brooding sense of mystery and dread.

-132. S1E13 Holes by Joey Brashier

Highlights: The building sense of paranoia and shocking payoff.

-131. S9E17 The Hour of Our Death / S14E12 Amateur Night by Marcus Damanda

Highlights: I decided to include my two favorite installments of the infamous and justly divisive Summer series, which I think is a worthy if highly abrasive part of the NSP canon, as a single entry here. Yes, each entry centers around a repulsive protagonist and really takes its time, but they also feature some exceptional writing that brings their time periods to life. The Hour of Our Death features Summer flirting, however half-heartedly (and ultimately unsuccessfully) with doing the right thing; Amateur Night has an array of thrilling action scenes and an intricate audio production.

-130. S12E13 There Is No Such Thing as Real Magic by Edwin Crowe

Highlights: The ending twist! Eek.

-129. S18E15 Underhill Rectory by Simon Bleakin

Highlights: I could listen all day to NSP tales of David Ault undercovering the lore of a haunted estate, and this is my favorite of the bunch.

-128. S18E1 Elkhorn Trail by K.G. Lewis

Highlights: The well-rounded and strong-willed protagonist (voiced ably by Linsay Rousseau) and Brandon Boone's sweeping music.

-127. S14E08 Phase II by Frank Oreto

Highlights: The Tremors feel to it, and the explosion sound effect at the end.

-126. S7E15 The Rosie Hour by S.H. Cooper

Highlights: Erika Sanderson's performance as the stalker.

-125. S18E21 Angelton C.M. Scandreth

Highlights: The music, and the highly creative premise and setting.

-124. S20E05 Date Night Charlie Davenport

Highlights: The way Sarah Thomas captures the 'girlfriend from hell,' and how the tragedies she causes pile up at the hapless narrator's feet.

-123. S1E10 ETAOIN by Trevor La Pay

Highlights: How close the narrator came to meeting the same fate of the other victims, and how we’re left to wonder about the caller.

-122. S19E17 Sweet Winds by Winona L.

Highlights: The way you can feel and even smell the heated chase through the field of sugarcane, and the jaw-dropping final twist.

-121. S20E19 F is for Fatal by Prim Rosewell

Highlights: The way this perfectly builds (and keeps building) off of my perpetual nightmare of showing up for an exam unprepared.

-120. S20 1/2024 Premium Bonus Episode Happiness Hills Resort by K.G. Lewis

Highlights: One of the two highlights of the premiere monthly bonus episodes thus far, thanks to how effectively it draws from NSP's pristine audio resources to make its rework of Jurassic Park thrilling from start to finish.

-119. S19E13 The Panic by Jacob Steven Mohr

Highlights: There’s lots to choose from – this story is frightening, and makes use of a large cast – but I think the highlight is Danielle McCrae's performance as a traumatized child.

-118. S16E18 The Neighbor’s House Is Getting Closer by Mr. Michael Squid

*Highlights:*Jeff Clement's unnerving and disturbing sound design.

-117. S18E15 The Other Side of the Planchette by Kat Sinor

Highlights: The bittersweet, romantic, and frankly beautiful way this presents a séance from a ghost's point of view.

-116. S19E23 The Prizrak Case by René Rehn

Highlights: The general sense of eeriness throughout the story, thanks in large part to Ilana Charnelle's narration and the subtly unsettling music.

-115. S11E23 Little Lost Amy by Dan Fields

Highlights: The horrifying, mostly secondhand glimpses we get of the monster.

-114. S2E12 The Scarecrow Game by Rachel Martin

Highlights: It's just so haunting and poetic, particularly the image of Marcus standing still and the way it makes me think of lost childhood friends.

-113. S6E07 Something Wrong is Happening in Las Vegas by Cassandra Soucheck

Highlights: Brandon Boone's electronic score, and the dizzying wtf-ness of what the narrator encounters in the brothel.

-112. S4E14 Repressed Memories are Meant to Stay Dead by C.K. Walker

Highlights: The final, goosebump-inducing memory of the blood-covered statue smiling while dancing away.

-111. S21E03 The Bynum Girl by Paul Buchanan

Highlights: The moment, near the very end, when the story teeters from rumor and suspicion into action in the face of impending horror.

-110. S21E12 Box-O-Screams by Lisel Jones

Highlights: The interactions and chemistry between the main characters as they steadily piece together the impending doom they all face.

-109. S9E14 A Forgotten Curio Shop by C.M. Scandreth

Highlights: The way each "cursed item" has its own unique way of spreading torment and mayhem.

-108. S21E18 Have You Ever Played the 'Would You...?' Game? by Quincy Lee

Highlights: Seti’s appearance in the bunny suit.

-107. S1 Bonus Episode #1 Butcherface by A.J. Garlisi

Highlights: The boldness of David Cummings in selecting a story this thoroughly gruesome and thoroughly weird as only the fifth episode in the series.

-106. S21E20 Eggshell by Gemma Amor

Highlights: The way Gemma Amor manages to draw from her best qualities as a writer to present an investigative procedural story in a way that feels authentically researched and appropriately focused on the victims instead of the killer.

-105. S16E17 The Firewall by Marcus Damanda

Highlights: The George A . Romero feel to this zombie story, which may as well be a 4th entry in the ___ of the Dead series. I also always wonder if the narrator is a stand-in for the writer's experiences as a teacher dealing with unruly students.

-104. S14E17 Avoid the Costumed Characters in Times Square by Mr. Michael Squid

Highlights: My favorite MMS story, which combines his signature creepiness with a dose of dark humor.

-103. S2E18 Snow by Claverhouse

Highlights: The strong sense of suspense, and James Cleveland's emotive performance.

-102. S2E25 Jack in the Box by Graham McBride

Highlights: How efficiently it moves, and the whammer of a final line: Don't Eat It.

-101. S5E15 Obscurity Man by Braedon Balko

Highlights: The chant, and the unique concept behind the villain.

-100. S2E05 The Smiling Man by L.S. Riley

Highlights: How straightforward and unpretentious it is. Perfectly encapsulates the old-school creepypasta feel.

-99. S4E14 The Stump by Ashley Franz Holzmann

Highlights: The absolutely repulsive voice of the monster and the way its comments carry deeper and more disturbing implications.

-98. S3E23 Icing Addiction by Lykaia Quinn

Highlights: How marvelously disgusting it gets.

-97. S8E15 Two Facts You Should Probably Know by Henry Galley

Highlights: The dialogue is so good in this story, and also well-delivered by David Ault and Oliver Gyani.

-96. S7 Premium Bonus Episode Stranded on Lake Michigan by Mercer Scott

Highlights: The sense of desolation that the ending leaves you with.

-95. S10E12 My Anime Body Pillow by Oli White

Highlights: One of NSP's ultimate gross-out stories that makes excellent use of its outlandish concept.

-94. S2E08 Low Hanging Clouds by T. E. Grau

Highlights: The quiet, subdued way the story slowly hints at its apocalyptic scenario.

-93. S5E23 The Pidgeons Around Here Aren't Real by Manen Lyset

Highlights: The author's spinoff poetry. (The story's creepy as hell too.)

-92. S12E17 Clinical Trial Scott Savino

Highlights: The way the second person narration (probably NSP's best ever use of it) makes the story more intense by throwing you into the narrator's position.

-91. S12E17 A Ride Through Shenandoah by Henry Galley

Highlights: The truly unwavering evil embodied by the brother.

-90. S1E05 A Game of Flashlight Tag by William Dalphin

Highlights: The moment the narrator spots Charlotte, not quite realizing what he's seeing.

-89. S1E08 Laurel Highlands by Bill Penfield

Highlights: This whole story is terrifying. I'm fully onboard with the narrator sprinting away at the end.

-88. S8E21 Chuck Came Back Wrong by Marshall Bannana

Highlights: All the weird, uncomfortable moments. And the way the narrator 'solves' the problem in a way that hardly ever works in horror.

-87. S12E08 Locked In by C.M. Scandreth

Highlights: Its introduction of one of NSP's most memorable and original villains, perfectly captured by Nicole Goodnight.

-86. S1E11 The Crawling House on Black Pond Road by William Dalphin

Highlights: Christina Scholz's pitch-perfect narration and all the spine-tingling moments with the bugs.

-85. S16E06 A Sundown Town by LP Hernandez

Highlights: The tension as the family finds themselves in the parade, and their defiant drive at the end.

-84. S2E08 The Thing in the Walls by Jonathan Sheeran

Highlights: A classic sleepover monster encounter soaked in early season ambience, with some nuanced thematic overtones that add a layer of depth.

-83. Halloween 2023 Premium Bonus/October 2024 Premium Bonus Ragdoll Meets Homunculus/Ragdoll Meets Baby Yaga by Marcus Damanda

Highlights: The likeable main character, who I'd love to hear go on more adventures!

-82. S12E03 *Pub Trivia/S12 Christmas Framing Story by Troy H. Gardner/C.K. Walker

Highlights: The way they both walk the line between dark comedy and mean spiritidness, both falling on different sides of it but doing so completely successfully.

-81. S17E13 The Black Library by C.M. Scandreth

Highlights: How effectively the writer manages to craft a story about cutthroat smart characters (stupid ones are way easier to write). I'd love a sequel thought it seems highly unlikely at this point.

-80. S19E01 The Graveyard by Blake Chastain

Highlights: The immense tension in the sequence where the narrator has to hide his body's disintegration from colleagues, and the literal way he falls apart.

-79. S8E12 The Unknown Hiker by Jacob Healey

Highlights: The way the story sells its remote mountain setting, and the intriguing mystery of the unknown hiker's origin and motivations.

-78. S1E01 The Stairs and the Doorway by Eric Dodd

Highlights: How well the narrator's descent into darkness functions as the opening of the series. I always think of him unleashing a monster as loosely parallel to the horrors of all subsequent NSP stories being unleashed onto the world.

-77. New Decayed Episode 3 Smile Dog by Michael Lutz and Oli White

Highlights: The return of Sammy Raynor and NSP doing something that draws from a classic creepypasta.

-76. S2E18 Plot Holes David Knoppel

Highlights: The clever way the story manages to resolve the question of how we're hearing a first-person narration from a narrator who's deceased (or at least stuck in some kind of shadow dimension).

-75. New Decayed Episode 3.5 The Iscariot 8 by Oli White

Highlights: Nikolle Doolin's powerhouse performance, one of NSP's all-time best.

-74. New Decayed Episode 4 I Found My Abduction Journal by One Faraday and Ronin Ellis

Highlights: Graham Rowat's mapcap performance, and the trigger warning "Sexual assault by aliens."

-73. S15E10 Hide the Knives by Marcus Damanda

Highlights: The Halloween feel, and the friendship between Sasha and Bindy.

-72. S2E15 Flood by Kelsey Donald

Highlights: How unnervingly uncanny everything is, and how it's unclear what, exactly, is going on with the parents.

-71. S18E11-20 This Book Will Kill You by Alexander Gordon Smith

Highlights: Brandon Boone's music and Kristen DiMercurio's performance as Flint.

-70. S8E12 I Could Live Forever or Die Tomorrow by Jackson Laughlin

Highlights: How the absolute monster that is the main character hides in plain sight, gaining the support of friends oblivious to what he does. Also the unforgettable climactic image of him reaching out for the baby. If anyone deserves the fate of The First Man in Cryostasis, it's him. This feels like one a lot of other listeners don't like. I think it's overlooked.

-69. S5E08 The Doll House by C.K. Walker

Highlights: How it's just filled-to-the-brim with an array incredibly spooky sequences.

-68. S3E20 Unknown Cargo by Jon Patrick

Highlights: The way the narrator continues to see the mysterious figure (cough Nosferatu cough cough) even after he makes the ultra smart decision to disembark the doomed ship. This is so well written and tense throughout.

-67. S6E24 Our House on Coffey Hill by Rona Vaselaar

Highlights: Learning the rich history of the Victorian home and the ghosts who haunt it. It’s such a lovely and immersive story.

-66. S9E09 The Secrets Inside Dune by Jared Roberts

Highlights: Although the writer is best known for his long-form works, this short story plays its ridiculous premise straight and manages to be disturbing as hell.

-65. S9E24 Making Deals with Devils by A.A. Peterson

Highlights: The relationship between the narrator and her best friend. And also that this story manages to be great even with an antagonist literally named "Booger."

-64. S17E14 – 23 Goat Valley Campground (Volume 1) by Bonnie Quinn and TJ Lea

Highlights: The worldbuilding, and the huge cast of distinctly written and amazingly compelling characters.

-63. S1E13 Button Head by Trevor La Pay

Highlights: The description of the face, and especially the liquid oozing under the door. Ooof, I'd get a different job ASAP.

-62. S7E09 Feed the Pig by Elias Witherow

Highlights: Obvious answer, but, ahem, the part where the pig gets fed. Eek.

-61. S1E04 Stinson Beach by Walter Smith

Highlights: The huge step up in production quality from the first few stories and the ominous ending, which derives from a response to the original post containing the rest of the story: If you're ever in Marin county California, come down to Stinson beach, there is something you need to see. It just brings to mind the era where people had a lot of fun with the central conceit of the r/nosleep forum.

-60. S1E18 When You Wish Upon a Star by Anna Smith

Highlights: The way it flawlessly executes so many classic r/nosleep tropes and Christina Scholz's understated narration.

-59. S21E21 The Gehenna Hollow Tunnel by Cole James

Highlights: The part where two characters drift away towards a mysterious light, never to be seen - or even remembered - again, except in grainy footage on an old-school camera. Undoubtedly one of the most chilling stories in recent years.

-58. S17E11 Shrieking Willow by Amanda Cecilia Lang

Highlights: The romantic first half, replete with vivid descriptions of the environment that complement the earnest young couple's affection, which makes the second half all the more gut-wrenching.

-57. S1E14 Georgie's by Christopher MacTaggart

Highlights: The presence of a smart protagonist who successfully identifies and avoids a growing threat.

-56. S4E23 The Mailbox in the Woods by Julie McGinn

Highlights: The gradual encroachment of the woods on the old man's house. It's an inspired, unsettling concept executed with precision.

-55. S7E8, 22 Down in the Library Basement Pt. 1 and 2 by Rona Vaselaar

Highlights: Brandon Boone's symphonic score and the distinctly warm/positive feel to it, even as it features its fair share of monsters and scary moments.

-54. S4E15 Room 733 by C.K. Walker

Highlights: The eerie atmosphere and superb use of the undergraduate setting.

-53. S9E23 Resting Lich Face by Oli White

Highlights: The emotional depth with which the first half explores its premise, and how cleverly it sets up its brutal ending. An overlooked contribution from Oli White.

-52. S13 Old Time Radio Vol. 9 Sour Toe Shuffle by Ele Matelan

Highlights: Jesse Cornett's insanely good performance of the song at the end.

-51. S4E17 The One-Way Tunnel by Terrey West

Highlights: The intricate buildup that slowly creates overwhelming feelings of claustrophobia and disorientation.

-50. S11E16 It Was a Different Time by C.M. Scandreth

Highlights: The mall setting, and just how brilliantly the ending twist brings everything together. Maybe the coolest time travel story NSP has ever done.

-49. S15E1 Farewell and Goodnight by T. Michael Argent

Highlights: The terrifying villain, the epic feel of the story (it feels like a novella adaptation), how much the narrator cares about her brother ("Goodnight, Casey" sob), and the heartfelt score.

-48. S11 Halloween Bonus #3 Her Stolen Candy by Marcus Damanda

Highlights: How successfully it tugs at the heartstrings. For a story about a Halloween ghost, it somehow manages to be one of the most poignant and moving stories NSP has ever aired.

-47. S5E13 My Wife Cooked Me Dinner by Rona Vaselaar

Highlights: The dedicated performances by David Ault and Erika Sanderson, how well the writing conveys the sense of grief, and the piano music.

-46. S1 Bonus Episode #3 Correspondence by Bloodstains

Highlights: The off-putting sound and voice effects and the array of gory, disturbing images. I remember listening to this during a lonely late-night drive in a desolate area and it freaked me out.

-45. S15E21 The Hungry Man by Lindsay Moore

Highlights: The slow burn and buildup of tension, the spooky and creative antagonist, and the characterization of the mother. There are a lot of layers to it than are discussed here.

-44. Interim S19/S20 Content Tales of the Moon Crawler by Manen Lyset

Highlights: How much the narrator in part 1 cared about the rest of her clan, Andy Cresswell and Penny Scott-Andrews' performances in part 3, and the sustained level of quality throughout all 5 parts.

-43. S15E14 The Crows Will Teach You to Fly by Scott Savino

Highlights: The poetic prose and Wafiyyah White's pitch-perfect performance.

-42. S20E25 The Wrong Side of the Tracks by Seth Borgen

Highlights: This was just such a well-rounded, exciting story throughout. It made for the strongest finale from season 10-present. I think the central group of friends being so likeable and well-utilized by it is my favorite part.

-41. S9E25 The Hidden Webpage by Jared Roberts

Highlights: There's a lot to love about this story, but the opening passages about 'old' internet stuck with me most.

-40. S14E01 The Voices Underneath Us by C.K. Walker

Highlights: The performances by the whole cast, and how effectively it incorporates multiple layers of symbolism into its tragic narrative.

-39. S5E18 Soft White Dam by M.J. Pack

Highlights: There's more competition than I realized, but I think that this takes the cake as the ultimate 'hearing spooky sounds in an isolated cabin' story, thanks in large part to Jeff Clement's acting and sound design.

-38. S7E25 Borrasca by C.K. Walker

Highlights: The character Kimber, the thoroughness with which NSP brought to life the whole town and its large cast of characters, and the brutal payoff it ultimately delivers as to its central mysteries.

-37. S14E09/S15 Holiday Hiatus 2 Mr. Empty-Belly by Alexander Gordon Smith

Highlights: Sammy Raynor's performance (after being brought back for Smile Dog) and the absolute horror of his character's fate.

-36. S13E23/S13 Holiday Hiatus 2 Don't Choose the Goat by Ali Habashi

Highlights: The Twilight Zone feel to it, the smart political commentary, and the children's chant.

-35. S3E22 Pro-Life by M. Grayson

Highlights: One of NSP's two most unforgettable 'real world' horror stories, effectively tackling tough subjects of pregnancy, abortion, and religion, as well as power dynamics and controlling behavior in relationships.

-34. S4E04/S5 Bonus #5 Paradise Pine/Blue Ridge by C.K. Walker

Highlights: The brilliantly-written senses of paranoia that permeate both stories. Both build so much tension. The first has some stellar psychological horror, the second benefits from showing the effect of the supernatural presence on the dynamics between the larger cast of characters.

-33. S8E01 The Pancake Family by A.A. Peterson

Highlights: This might be the most disgusting and nauseating story has ever aired…and it's brilliant.

-32. S6 Old Time Radio Sorry, Wrong Number Lucille Fletcher

Highlights: NSP's adaptation of this 1943 radio drama delivers on all levels. It’s tense and superbly acted.

-31. S9E23 Mr. Banana by R.K. Gorman

Highlights: Perhaps the ultimate "wtf" NSP story. It goes all in on a completely insane premise and totally pulls it off. Peter Lewis' performance is priceless in it as well.

-30. S8E10 The Things We See in the Woods by C.K. Walker

Highlights: The bond and banter between the two ghosts. They just have so much chemistry together.

-29. S5E23 The Whistlers by Amity Argot

Highlights: The abject sense of isolated desolation, unparalleled in its bleakness anywhere else in NSP's catalogue. Also, Jessica McEvoy's weary line delivery, which helps sell the atmosphere.

-28. S2E25 Autopilot by Kevin Thomas

Highlights: The other classic 'real world' horror tale, perfectly delivered by David Cummings and written in a way that causes it to stick with you long after it ends.

-27. S3 Bonus #2 Hunger by William Dalphin

Highlights: I'm still amazed at how effectively this pulled the rug out from under me, with an absolutely savage plot twist that literally made me gasp in shock when I first heard it.

-26. S3E08 The Midnight Hike by Kelsey Donald

Highlights: The way the characters keep ending up on, or almost on, the red trail, and just how little concrete information we're given about the entity that haunts them.

-25. S7E12 The Djinn Bottle by C.M. Scandreth

Highlights: The fascinating way this story covered a vast period of time. It's so full of interesting little details and story beats.

-24. S3E24 Box Fort by Julie Taylor

Highlights: When the narrator crawls around the fort, and around, and around, until by any reasonable measures she sould have long been able to exit it. Just an incredible story all the way through.

-23. S4E12 Ash Hollow R.J. Wills

Highlights: Getting lost in a seemingly endless library. This whole series of anecdotes is criminally overlooked, I highly recommend checking it out if you enjoyed the Search and Rescue series.

-22. S6E25 Creeping Crimson by Michael Marks

Highlights: The grotesque monster, and the way it relentlessly tears through everything and everyone in its way.

-21. S6E25 Better Days by Robert Ahern

Highlights: This is my favorite presentation of an apocalyptic scenario on the show. It's absolutely horrifying on every level, never more so than in the cruel twist ending that signals impending doom for our own reality.

-20. S3E11 The Red Light in the Warehouse Jimmy Juliano

Highlights: The outstanding writing that expertly circles around its central mystery in way that keeps you wondering and guessing at the exact nature of the horror dwelling just out of sight.

-19. S17E02 The Door People by Matthew Maichen

Highlights: How the whole cast drives home the overwhelming sense of wrongness of the events that unfold.

-18. S6E17 The Pit by E.L. Brym

Highlights: The cruelty of the entity, and the haunting final lines: "I think we’ve all thought about that grimy, cold hand reaching out from beneath the bed. But I promise you, we’re not trying to pull you down. We’re trying to get out."

-17. S5E04 The Mummer Man by David Sharrock

Highlights: One of NSP's all-time best villians, and writing that enables Peter Lewis to go full Peter Lewis.

-16. S3E19 Betsy the Doll / Tales from the Void E5 Plastic Smile by C.K. Walker/Francesco Loschiavo

Highlights: I'm including the Tales from the Void episode because I think it's a huge improvement over the original story, even as it owes its literal plot foundation to it, in that it fixes the original's main plot hole (it’s not plausible for Betsy to remain hidden where she is) while brilliantly expanding on its themes of neglect and the fog of childhood memory. It's an outstanding work that ends with a colossal gut-punch.

-15. S7E05 A Seaside British Pub by C.M. Scandreth

Highlights: The colorful descriptions (impeccably delivered by Erika Sanderson) of the pub's extremely unique denizens. This is a real crowd-pleaser and fun one to revisit.

-14. S7E15 Bounce by Taylor Allgood

Highlights: How thoroughly it explores the concept, and the logical steps the narrator takes to deal ethically with his predicament.

-13. S4E19 Rocking Horse Creek by C.K. Walker

Highlights: How this escalates from "kids engaging in mischief" to tragedy, especially in the sob-inducing ending.

-12. S10E07 Christmas with Mr. Strings by Henry Galley

Highlights: The whole cast is splendid, as is the script, but Atticus Jackson's performance here naturally takes the cake.

-11. S12E21 Rocking a Ranch C.K. Walker

Highlights: David Cumming's sorrowful narration, as well as the sheer tragedy of it all, from the guilt that haunts the narrator for betraying his friend and the ultimate reveal of the culprit.

-10. S6E18-22 Search and Rescue by R. Brauer

Highlights: The way so many brilliant little anecdotes add up to a tapestry of dread and inexplicable evil lurking in the woods.

-9. S10E18 500 Yards by Henry Galley

Highlights: The sheer intensity of the whole story, and Erin Lillis' standout performance.

-8. S15 Christmas Bonus Episode A Christmas in Pine Grove by Manen Lyset

Highlights: There's plenty to praise about the performances and audio production, but the hilarity and cheeky satire of the script (as well as its share of NSP allusions and easter eggs) is what stands out the most about it.

-7. S12E06 How to Summon the Butter Street Hitchhiker by Chris Hicks

Highlights: The reveal of the hitchhiker's face (or lack of it), and the moment of spine-tingling dread when he responds, "That's two questions." Arguably the highlight of post-Season 10 NSP.

-6. S2E25 Psychosis by Matt Dymerski

Highlights: The nerve-wracking feel of the escalating paranoia. It does a lot with a little, constantly upping the tension. It makes a brave choice providing a firm answer at the end (I'm sure the writer was tempted to leave it ambiguous) that feels just right.

-5. S6E07 Uncle Gerry’s Family Fun Zone by Jimmy Juliano

Highlights: The way the second recitation of the visit to the Fun Zone plays off the first, revealing an unexpected layer of nightmarish implications that make this one of the scariest tales NSP has ever aired.

-4. S5E23 The Girl in the Shed by Manen Lyset

Highlights: The absolute perfection of the final twist, which encapsulates the combination of whimsical humor and dark horror that Manen Lyset brings to the podcast.

-3. S8E25 My Dad Finally Told Me What Happened That Day by Jared Roberts

Highlights: The whole story is a masterclass in dizzying layers of suspense and confusion, but the part that stands out to me is when the narrator discovers what's been happening with his mother. It's a uniquely disquieting moment in a tale filled to the brim with them.

-2. S6E08 Persistence of Vision by Alex Beyman

Highlights: Elie Hirschman's performance, the journey through locations and (highly original) ideas this takes you on, and the devastating ending. This is another overlooked masterpiece.

-1. S1 Bonus Episodes #2 and #4 Penpal by Dathan Auerbach

Highlights: As tempting as it was to select something off-the-beaten path here, there's just no beating the intricate, yet immediate and accessible writing of NSP's first masterpiece. Sammy Raynor is the John Cazale of NSP, giving only a few performances but living up to some of the show's best material when doing so. There's one flaw in this story (the reasons why the final victim is who he is, rather than someone else, which I think could have been satisfyingly explained with a few minor tweaks), but it's not nearly enough to bring down this superb example of everything that makes NSP great. It's the kind of story that sinks its hooks into listeners and keeps them returning for years - nearly 15 of them at this point - to come.


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Sep 26 '19

AMA I'm Jared Roberts, Author of NoSleep's Most Mystifying Stories. AMA!

99 Upvotes

EDIT: Thank you all for letting me hang out with you for the last few days. You made me think, laugh, and cry. And I appreciate it. And thanks to /u/Gaelfling for opening the doors of TheNSPDiscussion to me.

Hi TheNSPDiscussion!

I wrote legendary(ly puzzling) stories like The Hidden Webpage, The Trees Are Not What They Seem, and My Dad Finally Told Me What Happened That Day.

I often get direct messages asking about my stories or about writing for NoSleep. I wanted to make myself available to answer any questions you might have about writing horror, NoSleep, the Podcast, or my stories. I have nothing to promote, just here for some good conversation.

I'll be answering questions until Sunday evening. I have a day job, so it may take me an hour or two to reply. Oh, and I have a pretty thick skin, so no need to hold back. I won't!


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Mar 18 '21

Off-Topic Beware... beware...

Post image
97 Upvotes

r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Jun 07 '21

Recommendations In your opinion what are the scariest nosleep stories?

94 Upvotes

Like the title says what do you consider to be the scariest stories on the podcast? Or maybe even the most disturbing?


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Oct 21 '21

Off-Topic Got bored. Made an NSP iceberg meme.

Post image
92 Upvotes

r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Feb 04 '25

Discussion Danielle McRae and her mispronunciations

87 Upvotes

Does this bother anyone else?? I am an English teacher and have done some amateur voice acting myself and I cannot stand listening to anything she narrates. I really don't understand how it even slips through the cracks EVERY time she does a part. Like the latest episode, she mispronounces "trough", "silhouette" (twice), and "cacophony". That's probably the lowest count I've heard lately. It's so confusing, like does nobody listen to her parts when they edit the episode? I've even typed up something to send to NSP directly on IG, just haven't sent it. I'm greatly considering it because it just bothers me so much for a podcast of this magnitude to have this type of mistake. Thoughts?


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Sep 08 '21

NSP = Bad Dear Laura has kind of ruined NoSleep for me

86 Upvotes

I just can't stand this story. The writing itself is fine — not great, but fine — but the story is at turns boring, aggravating, and upsetting. It is not, however, remotely scary; it confuses being actively unpleasant with being actually frightening, in the same way a lot of torture porn movies do. And hey, that's fine, it's non uncommon for an episode to have a story that I don't care for. But it is uncommon — unprecedented, in fact — for that story to drag on, and on, and on for over a month. I've been skipping a significant chunk of the show, and honestly I might just stop listening. It's baffling to me that they thought this was a good idea.


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Nov 16 '20

The NSP Sux What happened to this podcast?

85 Upvotes

So, I got into this podcast in the last year or so. I listened to seasons 12 through 5 (I went backwards) and was really loving it. Okay some stories are better than others but all in all really solid. Then when season 13 came out I noticed I wasn’t loving it as much but I figured everyone has an off year. Now with season 14 I feel like I’m listening to a horror podcast for kids. The stories end right where they normally would just pick up and get crazy. I have nothing but respect for the actors and story tellers but I just find the quality has fallen off. Am I alone here? What are your thoughts?

*Not sure why this was tagged Nsp Sux. I didn’t do that just to be clear


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • May 06 '25

Discussion Im out they don’t deserve loyalty

83 Upvotes

I’ve been a long-time listener and supporter of The NoSleep Podcast. I got on board in 2019 and stuck around through format shifts, uneven seasons, rotating cast members—you name it. But after the Nancast disaster and the way they fumbled the bag on communication? I’m officially, unapologetically done.

I bought multiple season passes through Nancast back when we were promised continued access. Eventually they hinted that the platform might shut down, but they said fans would be informed. Naturally, I assumed that meant a real notification—like an email. You know, what any other professional platform would do.

But nope. No email. No proper heads-up. Just a few vague podcast intros and social media posts scattered like breadcrumbs. Life got busy. I wasn’t glued to Reddit or listening weekly. Then I check back—and poof—Nancast is gone, the download window’s expired, and everything I paid for has vanished into the void.

And when people asked what the hell happened? They got templated “we’re working on it” replies. Push for real answers and suddenly you’re the problem for not magically keeping up across five platforms. Apparently, supporting the show now means being part detective, part psychic.

Let’s be real—this wasn’t some unavoidable tech issue. It was a willful communication failure. They had time. They had tools. They just didn’t care enough to use them.

And this isn’t a first offense either. OGs remember the 2018 subreddit nuking—when they wiped the entire community because people criticized a weak Halloween episode. Labeled it “toxic,” but really, it was just people being honest. They’ve been allergic to criticism ever since.

Now add to that the fact that the content has been on a slow, sad decline. These days? You’re lucky to get two solid stories in a season. Most of it feels recycled, bloated, or trying way too hard to be edgy. And when things get stale, they toss in a celebrity cameo—like Mike Flanagan’s wife—like it’s gonna distract us from the quality drop.

Honestly? You’ve got a better chance of getting the NoSleep staff to tell you next week’s winning lottery numbers and the exact date of your own death than you do getting a straight answer about their subscription model. That’s where we are now.

The only part I’ll actually miss? Mike Delgaudio and Jessica McEvoy. They’ve been carrying this show for years. Pros through and through. As for the guy doing his best Scooby-Doo villain audition in every story he’s in? I won’t miss that one bit. Horror doesn’t need to be campy, but lately it feels like half the cast is one evil laugh away from yelling “and I would’ve gotten away with it too!”

So yeah—fk it, I’m out. I’m done handing money to a team that treats its fans like they’re disposable. No more chasing updates, no more waiting for a comeback that’s not coming. They lost the plot, and they lost me.

TL;DR: Paid content? Gone. Nancast? Nuked. Communication? Nonexistent. Criticism? Silenced since 2018. The horror? Mostly in how far it’s fallen.

I’m out. Might come back just to watch the subreddit burn when the next mess hits.

– Lavernius Tucker

Edit: **Just to clarify before I step away from this thread—none of the earlier criticisms I’ve brought up were the main issue for me. Story quality, casting changes, even production choices—I could live with all of that. What pushed me to finally disengage was the lack of direct communication when Nancast was shut down and access to paid content was removed.

There was no official email notice to the people who financially supported the show. Just silence.

That’s not a platform issue. That’s a customer service failure. And when people raised valid concerns, some of the responses weren’t helpful—they were passive-aggressive. Here are a few examples from a cast member’s replies:

“sigh alright I can see you’re just here to argue… Never change, Reddit.” “I’m not feeding you anymore, dude.” “And neither do you…” “There was enough of a warning through the episodes and social media for you to know what’s going on.” “I was under the impression you needed help instead of thinking you know the metrics of the podcast more than I do.”

That’s how paying supporters were spoken to—people just asking why the content they paid for was gone without warning. No accountability. Just blame-shifting and sarcasm.

And the issue clearly isn’t resolved. People are still coming to this subreddit asking what happened to their content. That alone should say something.

I’m not expecting special treatment. But I do expect the bare minimum when it comes to communication. A single email could’ve prevented this entire situation.**


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Dec 05 '24

Discussion Anyone else get annoyed by all the stories that don't have any payoff?

83 Upvotes

I swear there are so many NoSleep authors who basically just write the setup for a story and end it when things are getting interesting. I know they probably think it's clever to just leave things mysterious, but I just find it irritating most of the time. I recently listened to one where a woman finds a hatch to a bunker or something in the ground with a guy locked inside yelling for help. When she gets the cops to look, the hatch is gone. Then the story ends. There's some vague suggestion that maybe the police know something, but it's all left really ambiguous.


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Jun 13 '21

Fanworks HAPPY BIRTHDAY NOSLEEP!

Post image
82 Upvotes

r/TheNSPDiscussion • • May 05 '24

Fanworks Low effort meme go brrrrr

Post image
80 Upvotes

But for real We Forgot About Muriel had me hiding tears at work


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Nov 10 '25

Off-Topic NSPD Contributing Author Here!

Post image
78 Upvotes

My first book “Stories About Monsters” has finally arrived and I’d love to mail you a signed copy! I had my story “Tall Betsy” featured on NoSleep last year and just wanted to let y’all know about the book! If you’re interested please send me a message or comment here! Thank you!


r/TheNSPDiscussion • • Sep 22 '20

The NSP Sux The podcast isn't good anymore

78 Upvotes

Yeah yeah I know but hear me out

When it first began, the podcast adapted reddit/creepypasta/internet stories to audio form and it was wonderful. The season 2 story "Proof" is probably the most frightening story they every produced. We could not be further from that kind of refined brilliance at this present moment. We are far too removed from the beginnings and are all the worse for it.

My grievances:

  1. STOP DOING ACCENTS. It is embarrassing to have David Cummings attempting british/russian/irish/southern american accents. This is (supposedly) a professional podcast. You could actually employ the genuine article, but instead you make your actors force half-assed accents? This decision is a giant failure and turns a magnificent performance by, say a Mike Delgaudio, into a farce. Unacceptable.

  2. Fantastical elements. Every show has multiple stories involving some creature. Maybe that works for horror for some people, hell maybe a TON of people, but your audience is broad. I understand horror is very subjective. Me personally, I'm much more frightened by the darkness inherent in man's heart than I am a haunted tree monster. I suspect I'm not alone.

  3. Length. Not every story has to be a novel or novella. Again, the perfect example for me is "Proof". These stories go on and on and on, padding their run time with pointless exposition and detail. It just isn't necessary.

I'd love nothing more than the podcast to return to their roots and produce compelling content again. But the path it's been on for many years now gives me little hope. Anyone else feel the same way?