Okay, before I commence, I just want to start off by saying that I’ve been a fan of this series since I first downloaded Monster Hunter International on Audible. It was a fun, roller coaster ride of cliches and tropes that were older than dirt and I enjoyed every minute of listening to it.
So when I say that Monster Hunter Guardian is the worst entry in the series, I’m being completely serious. I’d go as far as to say that this was so bad, that listening to it from beginning to end was almost painful to do so.
First, the performance of the reader was atrocious. I gave it one star and that was only because she at least had a pleasant sounding voice. Beyond that, she was pathetically miscast for the role of Julie Shackleford. I’m not sure what criteria someone needs to meet in order to become a reader, but one would assume the ability to speak with various accents would be a given, especially if the book in question has characters with foreign sounding accents. According to this reader, speaking in an African accent can be accomplished by deepening your voice and talking like a constipated robot. Ironically enough, the only person she didn’t attempt to read with an accent was Julie Shackleford herself, who comes off sounding less like a badass monster hunter out for blood and more like a frustrated soccer mom stuck in traffic. Her mispronunciation of several established character’s names is also something that I consider inexcusable, especially since many of them have been mentioned BY NAME in nearly every other book in the series.
Now for the story itself. In terms of basic narrative and plot, this was perhaps the weakest in the series. Plots revolving around a kidnapping are always frustrating because they often follow the same basic formula where the main character spends the entire story strung along by whatever plot device comes between them and whoever got kidnapped until the very end and this story is that from start to finish.
Aside from that, the story had very little if any of the fantastical world and lore building details that had made the previous entries so enjoyable and engaging. All we really got was a retreading on old material, nearly all of it presented by one of the most forgettable cast of side characters ever to be introduced in the series.
The worst part, is perhaps the character of Julie Shackleford herself. The fierce, zombie sniping, southern valkyrie we had first been introduced to back in Monster Hunter International, has now been reduced to the equivalent of an insecure, whiny soccer mom who’s been forced to get her husband’s gun out of the lockbox in the attic because she thought she heard a prowler downstairs. If this was Correia’s attempt to show his readers (and critics) that he is capable of writing from a female perspective, then he failed miserably.
To bring this review to a close, I will conclude by saying that at the very most, Monster Hunter Guardian should be disregarded as nothing more than mediocre filler that can be skipped over completely. Beyond a few significant plot points that will no doubt be mentioned in future installments, I guarantee there’s nothing that you’ll be missing.