r/TheMHI • • 15d ago

The Author’s behavior.

0 Upvotes

You know I read some of the books thinking they were ok, schlocky but okay. Was hoping the author would mature and even looking at his social media and he types like a 13 year old boy and calls everyone who disagrees with him slurs and seems to have a problem with trans people and Muslims. Why is he like that and why are his books and self inserts like that?


r/TheMHI • • Apr 03 '25

Been playing around with GPT Spoiler

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/TheMHI • • Sep 11 '25

Fan Project: AI Dream Cast for MHI Book One Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Hey folks,

I’m starting a fun side project: using AI tools to put together a fan-made movie concept for the first MHI book. Since it’s AI, I can cast literally anyone — alive or dead, any age — so I want to aim for the ultimate dream cast.

Here’s what I’ve got so far: • Owen Pitt – Alan Ritchson (Reacher) • Earl Harbinger – Walton Goggins (The Ghoul in Fallout) • Milo – Tom Arnold type (like in True Lies), but as a scruffy redhead • Franks – Dave Bautista

What do you all think? Who would you cast for Owen, Earl, Julie, Milo, Holly, and the rest? I’ll be collecting suggestions and turning them into AI mockups to share here.


r/TheMHI • • May 25 '24

Honest answer.

0 Upvotes

How many of you skip Monster Hunter Alpha on reread once you get through it once. I've listen to the series about 5 times now but Alpha only once lol.


r/TheMHI • • Dec 19 '24

Muchado's end

5 Upvotes

Why the hell did Pitt outright murder the guy?


r/TheMHI • • Jun 30 '20

Now more than ever

2 Upvotes

This is a interesting time we are living through, but now more than ever, I think we all could use a.......... HHHHHHHHHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN!!!!!!!!!!!!!


r/TheMHI • • Oct 23 '23

Guardians, a great story with terrible character assassination. Spoiler

7 Upvotes

I don’t know why its taken me this long to notice this about Guardians. I’ve listened to the entire series on audible at least 20 times.

That has to be a low ball estimate actually, but nonetheless I really just noticed how badly he killed Julie’s character.

Maybe because its my first time listening to tje stories sober in 5 years, but what would have been an excellent story is seriously overshadowed by just how whiny and lame Julie turned in this book.

Its weird because in bloodlines she’s pretty much back to normal and im wondering if Larry just thought because this book was from her pov he had to overact the emotional part, but its seriously hard to finish this book now.

Guess ill have to start smoking pot again when i listen to the series again.


r/TheMHI • • Aug 05 '25

"It" is a pipe and some rock.

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/TheMHI • • Aug 05 '21

Questions and theories Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Please see my previous post about questions and theories

https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMHI/comments/oi3unu/questions_and_theories/


r/TheMHI • • Nov 13 '22

No Game for Knights - don't waste your money

7 Upvotes

Hi. I realize this isn't MHI, but this is relevant to Larry as he was the editor of the anthology and contributed a short.

Most of the stories are forgettable. From my perspective, two were decent. A few genuinely had me questioning if Baen just decided to pad things out. [The story where the author doesn't reveal it's a Squirrel who wants to f*** a chipmunk, etc]

I want to say that everyone is great, honing their craft over time, have a wonderful back catalogue - but I can't. Best case, borrow this from the library, or a friend.


r/TheMHI • • Apr 08 '25

Can I listen to siege after Nemesis?

1 Upvotes

r/TheMHI • • Aug 30 '25

Just started the series and have a couple questions (audiobook listener) Spoiler

10 Upvotes

I'm only 11 chapters into the first book and I'm honestly having a bit of a problem getting into it even with the narrator sounding like young Ron Swanson. I find myself eye rolling often at the dialogue that feels like bad fanfiction. I know authors can take a while to find their stride so I'm still trying because I love the concept but.....

My first question is does Owen ever stop being so awkward about Julie? It is getting over the top cringe the way him and Grant act about it all. Owen knew her all of 10 minutes and loves her and is jealous this "perfect woman" is in a relationship and he instantly hates Grant for being that guy.

Second question is are all the books so heavy on government hate and extremely detailed gun descriptions?


r/TheMHI • • Jun 15 '26

Does the main character progress at all after book 2?

7 Upvotes

Just finished the second book. I really enjoyed listening to these as a casual simple but fun story. Main things that are getting on my nerves though is how incredibly and deliberately dumb and out of control the main character is (e.g. "I think I'll just slug this federal agent in the face, again, even though I know he already wants to have me murdered and can apparently do so legally and there's not a thing I could do about it, and I have no plan or thought for what comes next. Why do it then? Cause I'm Really Mad")

It was ok in the beginning, but if he's going to be like this for the rest of the series without learning anything at all, it's going to drive me crazy.

The other smaller issue I have with it is how "big" the apocalyptic scenario is and how many hunters die on the big battle of each book. I mean, this is supposed to be a pretty small rag tag group of professional hunters - if you're killing a bunch of them off in every book this doesn't really make sense to me, and it also robs any potential emotional pull from a character dying (I had a similar problems with game of thrones and quit watching it - it was just constantly killing characters until I just didn't really care about any of them anymore. Why get invested?).


r/TheMHI • • Oct 30 '23

Iron hands offspring Spoiler

5 Upvotes

For those who haven’t read the memoir’s did not read further this is the one warning I will give

Ok for those who have. I just finished the third memoir. And apperantly iron hand has a daughter. But for the life of me I don’t know who it could be. Does anyone know? Or was that never really explored?


r/TheMHI • • Aug 20 '19

My review for Monster Hunter Guardian

14 Upvotes

Okay, before I commence, I just want to start off by saying that I’ve been a fan of this series since I first downloaded Monster Hunter International on Audible. It was a fun, roller coaster ride of cliches and tropes that were older than dirt and I enjoyed every minute of listening to it.

So when I say that Monster Hunter Guardian is the worst entry in the series, I’m being completely serious. I’d go as far as to say that this was so bad, that listening to it from beginning to end was almost painful to do so.

First, the performance of the reader was atrocious. I gave it one star and that was only because she at least had a pleasant sounding voice. Beyond that, she was pathetically miscast for the role of Julie Shackleford. I’m not sure what criteria someone needs to meet in order to become a reader, but one would assume the ability to speak with various accents would be a given, especially if the book in question has characters with foreign sounding accents. According to this reader, speaking in an African accent can be accomplished by deepening your voice and talking like a constipated robot. Ironically enough, the only person she didn’t attempt to read with an accent was Julie Shackleford herself, who comes off sounding less like a badass monster hunter out for blood and more like a frustrated soccer mom stuck in traffic. Her mispronunciation of several established character’s names is also something that I consider inexcusable, especially since many of them have been mentioned BY NAME in nearly every other book in the series.

Now for the story itself. In terms of basic narrative and plot, this was perhaps the weakest in the series. Plots revolving around a kidnapping are always frustrating because they often follow the same basic formula where the main character spends the entire story strung along by whatever plot device comes between them and whoever got kidnapped until the very end and this story is that from start to finish.

Aside from that, the story had very little if any of the fantastical world and lore building details that had made the previous entries so enjoyable and engaging. All we really got was a retreading on old material, nearly all of it presented by one of the most forgettable cast of side characters ever to be introduced in the series.

The worst part, is perhaps the character of Julie Shackleford herself. The fierce, zombie sniping, southern valkyrie we had first been introduced to back in Monster Hunter International, has now been reduced to the equivalent of an insecure, whiny soccer mom who’s been forced to get her husband’s gun out of the lockbox in the attic because she thought she heard a prowler downstairs. If this was Correia’s attempt to show his readers (and critics) that he is capable of writing from a female perspective, then he failed miserably.

To bring this review to a close, I will conclude by saying that at the very most, Monster Hunter Guardian should be disregarded as nothing more than mediocre filler that can be skipped over completely. Beyond a few significant plot points that will no doubt be mentioned in future installments, I guarantee there’s nothing that you’ll be missing.


r/TheMHI • • Jul 11 '26

Earl and Heather have a baby?

6 Upvotes

It may wind up having to be fanfic to get there, but what would Earl and Heather name their baby? If it was a boy? If it was a girl?


r/TheMHI • • Mar 27 '23

What are "Guardian" important plot points for the future book? Spoiler

10 Upvotes

I am giving up on reading the guardian. I forced myself through the book until Julie blew up some child-eating black market dealer monster with a grenade.
It sounds amazing but the action was not written good or entertaining, just like the whole book. I am tired of hearing "MY BABY" every 20seconds. And Julie being ignorat fool unlike in all the other books is irritating at best. Seriously her freaking out about every single thing and constantly loosing temper at the smallest things. Her attempts to sound dangerous and cool with "I was beyond angry, angry was my little weaker brother at the moment" - that was cringe - even on monster hunter books which are glorified cringe already.

Could you nice people here please give me sums up what important guardian stuff are actually in this book? Until this point the book gave absolutely nothing new about MHI world, no new characters that would stick. It feels just like hollow filler.


r/TheMHI • • Mar 28 '20

Chad Garnier's daughter Spoiler

3 Upvotes

So spoilers for Monster Hunter Saints. But Earl Harbinger signs off with CHad Garneirs Iron Hands daughter is a bad ass. The thought just occured to me that it might be Holly from the main series. Thoughts?


r/TheMHI • • Jul 03 '25

Graveyard of Demons Spoiler

3 Upvotes

SPOILER ALERT, and kind of a rant

I’ve really enjoyed this series and don’t want to come off as negative, jumping online to rant about things isn’t something I do.

With that said, the ending of this book just doesn’t make sense to me. The casteless amass a giant army and stand outside the gates of a ruined capital, they hold all the cards and are in a perfect position to reset the continents entire society and they…ask permission to stay at the bottom rung of society but at least be looked at as “real” people? Freedom isn’t asked for, it’s taken. That’s true for all of humanity (fantasy world but they are humans). They didn’t need to ask permission to do anything and could have made any demand they wanted to. Obviously completely flipping society on its head wouldn’t be the greatest idea as that would just lead to more wars later but, these are people that just survived a genocide and they’re content to going back to being looked down on, but with some small amount of basic human rights now? It goes against human nature.

Also, so much time is spent on building up the need for a king, only for that king to just be a token position that really has to agree to any terms Thera’s demands (because what other choice does he really have?). His position, I’m guessing, has a bigger part in the next book but, there just doesn’t seem to be a need for the character to be there, especially with zero consequences for his actions.

Yes, I get the whole concept of humanity coming together to fight a greater enemy, that’s a given. People who hold all the cards don’t beg for crumbs though… I’m just disappointed that this is the direction Correia went with this.


r/TheMHI • • Jan 03 '25

Downgrading Earl?

7 Upvotes

Anyone else kind of notice that in the audiobooks after Legion, that the voice of Earl sounds way off? Sometimes, Earl sounds like G-Nome. It's really unfortunate.


r/TheMHI • • Jul 20 '25

What If...Jack Reacher?

12 Upvotes

What if Jack Reacher had some sort of supernatural encounter during his travels, and meets Earl Harbinger much the same way Owen does. Earl leaves him a business card. What does Reacher do? Do you think he joins up? Maybe after dealing with the MCB he would want to stick it to them. Say this takes place sometime between book #3 and #4 of the main series, how does Reachers involvement change much. I'd love to see a crossover between these two series.


r/TheMHI • • Feb 13 '19

My updated MHI cast choices.

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/TheMHI • • Jul 21 '23

MHI on r/place ?

8 Upvotes

Is there enough people to put MHI on r/place? Would be rly cool.


r/TheMHI • • Sep 29 '22

Dorcas Spoiler

8 Upvotes

Do we think Dorcas could be Ray IV mother? She had a thing for Earl but didn't work out maybe she took a liking to his son?


r/TheMHI • • Apr 08 '26

Rereading Alpha Spoiler

Post image
24 Upvotes

Rereading alpha just got past this scene. Poor Heather.