So, I never use my twitter account. I have it, just to have it on hand, just in case. Apparently the situation that forces me to use it again is when I see a bad episode of The Librarians and am driven to message the writers and tell them why it was bad and how it could've been saved very easily.
Cue fifty tweets between me and Geoffrey Thorne (writer) wherein it's obvious he cannot be persuaded to give half a fuck. I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt - maybe he can't discuss an ongoing show in public without some network repercussions, maybe he's in a bad mood, maybe this is the millionth time someone's messaged them with this sort of thing (in which case, maybe listen, it might be legitimate), but the bottom line is, he wasn't havin' it.
I would love to be wrong and see that they go on to make it a show that fulfills the premise's potential. I'm pretty doubtful of it, though. There's just so many instances where it's obvious something's been written in such a way as to force a situation into a more easily-writable scenario at the expense of having subjects act out of character and things straight-up making no sense. I get it; it's hard writing for characters that are geniuses, because obviously you aren't geniuses - that's not a slight on the writers, that's just reality. I'm not a genius either. What you have to do, though, is fake it well enough to sell the character's actions to the audience. And they do not do that.
I couldn't do it on twitter because of the 140 character limit... and because Geoff blocked me pretty quickly... but here are a few criticisms and fixes I feel could be put in place very easily:
Your characters are geniuses. You went out of your way to specifically tell the audience this. They were hand-picked by a magical, semi-sentient, pseudo-omniscient transdimensional building. With that in mind, you cannot have them make stupid mistakes - maybe once, in the first couple episodes, when getting used to the concept of magic. Not afterward. And you certainly can't do it while using the character of The Librarian himself, whose sole purpose for his entire career has been the proper containment and handling of magical artifacts. When The Librarian sees the Apple of Discord, and knows that it's the Apple of Discord, and sees what it's done to his teammates, he should know to not fucking pick it up and be under its spell. This is basic logic for any character over 100 IQ, but for this specific, incredibly experienced in this particular field, incredibly intelligent character, it is simply unacceptable behavior to write for him. I know why it was done. It's obvious. The concept is that the Apple is handled, over the course of the episode, by each main character as a means to give more exposition to their personality. It shows a side of them that they and the audience would never otherwise witness, and provides to the other characters a way to gain more knowledge of them by proxy. It's an easy mechanic and, in theory, it can reap plentiful narrative rewards. You grow closer to the character, you see them growing closer to each other which makes you grow even closer to them as a group - it's great! But it was done in the laziest possible fashion you could've ever done it in. There were ways in which the Apple could've ended up on each of their persons respectively, giving the desired narrative and exposition, that do not require the characters to be dimwits and forget everything they know about magic and logic. First guy gets tricked into picking it up - second guy instinctively catches it during a scuffle with the first guy - third guy has it planted on them by the (apparently omnipresent) female bad guy - fourth guy gets put into a situation where they have to take it to save a life, or literally whatever. It took me about a minute to come up with these wholly reasonable premises without ruining the motivations and intelligence of the characters.
Do you want your math-wizard genius to have autism? Because you're writing her as if she has autism. She's got synesthesia. It's different from retardation. If you want to have her be autistic, that's great, that's an interesting and complex character concept you can do a whole lot with - but just having her get mentally sidetracked during her calculations is, again, really lazy. It doesn't add to her character as it is. From the audience's perspective, her power is really interesting, and I was excited to see her using it in such a Sherlock-esque fashion against the bad guy(girl). I don't know why she never did that before, and sadly I suspect she won't be doing so ever again because that was her being "bad", as if knowing how to successfully and nonlethally disable a murderous assailant (which would've been useful in pretty much every single episode up to this point) is strictly a trait used by 'her worst self'. You don't want her to be a two-dimensional ditzy liability, but that's literally all she's been as a character. She can do math, but you've made it so that even her power requires her to show weakness, needing constant help and reminders to stay focused. If she were competent, she would be a greater asset than literally every other character put together. Maybe you're afraid of what that would do to the show's dynamic, and that's completely reasonable, but that's no excuse for writing her as the constant damsel in distress who means well and fucks up. Allow her her clarity of mind and write up the other characters to be just as useful with their own individual potential, don't keep her stupid just to make your job easier. Again, that's lazy writing. Which brings me to the next point.
Your other characters. Stone's 'power' is that he's got a ridiculous IQ (different from savant-like mathematical ability, useful in different ways) but the only usage of it has been him recalling historical footnotes and being able to identify or name artwork. Other than being able to point to a Van Gogh and know if it's fake, his 'genius' hasn't been properly utilized. He should be the most well-roundedly useful character on the show. He should be good at everything, grasping concepts much quicker than the others, mastering them easily. His ability to wrap his head around things should show its fangs in him mastering martial arts (as it is, he's a simple bar-brawler. Relatively effective, but no more competent than The Guardian, whose expertise is basically just military training, albeit rather extensive training.), psychology, puzzle-solving (logic puzzles, rather than math-wiz's math-oriented puzzles. You could suggest that all puzzles, and in fact all things, boil down to being mathematical in nature and she should be outright better in all things than he is. You wouldn't be incredibly wrong, but writing her with some amount of weakness and allowing the others to fill that gap is a better narrative, and doesn't break her character's consistency in doing so. So long as her weakness isn't "I can't concentrate and have mouth-diarrhea" like it is now.), diplomacy (this is arguable - it's a concept, he should understand it like the back of his hand and be able to utilize it just as effectively, but it could be argued that intelligence isn't necessarily translate to charisma, which diplomacy is largely based off of. It's the art of tricking people into liking you, or believing what you have to say.)... what I'm saying is he should essentially be Batman. You heard me right. This would be a great role for him as the baseline good-at-everything teammate.
Ezekiel is a problem. You've made him the thief character, but he's incompetent. His thieving successes thus far include him picking a pocket and knowing how to smash a glass to get what's inside. He's been utilized more often as a distraction, or a negotiator - which he was bad at. It seems as though it's actually a running joke in the show that whenever they actually need to do some thievery - Labyrinth artifact, dragon pearl - he's not utilized. I think he was able to hack into a computer at some point, maybe? Bravo. Basically, he's being improperly used. You introduced him as the thief, and this should mean he's the planner, the schemer. The bag-man who, when push comes to shove, isn't afraid of getting his hands dirty. Instead, he's the fly-by-the-seat-of-his-pants loose cannon with looser morals. He doesn't really serve a purpose in the team, as it is; especially under the assumption that the others will become better at fulfilling their roles. Between the Math Genius and Stone, all puzzles and traps are solved. All technology is thwarted. All strategies are considered ahead of time. He would be great if he could be the immoral foil opposite the rest of the cast, doing what needs to be done when nobody else can bring themselves to do it. Problem there is that you've written him as the comic relief. So what you end up with is Deadpool without the powers, or the skills. And without the comedy, really; his lines are often low-hanging fruit that are more cringe-inducing than funny. I remember he had one good line he delivered really well in the Santa episode where he wore the hat, dancing around with children, and he turned to the others and smiled, saying "Kill me." - that was good. That was the diamond in the rough, and that's most of what's keeping me rooting for him at this point, hoping they find more of that for him. Ideally he'd be the Comedian to their Watchmen; I understand if they don't want to go that dark, but the concept is solid. They've hinted at it, but they haven't given him the chance to showcase his ability to get the job done at the potential cost of morality. They seem afraid of him, and this is a running theme I'm finding - the writers are afraid to utilize the characters. And I think it shows.
The Guardian serves to protect the librarian. Simple concept. And yet that's not how that shit goes down, almost ever. More often than not, The Librarian ends up saving her. He can defend himself, and with his knowledge of magic he's better-equipped to avoid magical death than she is to protect him from it. So what's she been doing? Well, whenever they would've been in trouble with the law she whips out her badge and talks some bullshit until they get away. Unless they're intent on utilizing her as nothing but a Guardian From The Law, she needs to step it up. Especially with the realization that Math Wiz can snap bones and knock people out with ease using her crazy physics knowledge, and Stone has the capacity to master almost every martial art that exists (being a genius with a physique), the only one she seems to need to defend is Ezekiel, who has already established himself as a "run away rather than fight" sort of character. Slim pickings for someone whose sole purpose is to defend. It would help if she were written to be more than just a badge and a gun and a punch and a love interest - if she could properly integrate the team to be more effective as a whole, knowing when to use each talent, when to take command, when to let them take the lead - essentially be their Nick Fury, then she would fulfill a consistently useful purpose. Her character would mean something. Her being chosen by The Library would make sense. That's not how she's being written. I hope that changes.
Then there's The Librarian himself. I assume there's a situation where the show can't afford the budget to have Noah Wyle show up in every episode - that's fine, they aren't the only show to have to work around that. That said, he's one of the few characters they haven't fucked up completely. Possibly because he was already pre-written through the concept and movies that came before the show itself. He's suffered the fewest character writing flaws, I feel. He's got a good reason to be out and not on-camera, doing his own Doctor Who mission thing, gotta find the rest of the TARDIS - his love story with The Guardian falls kind of short, though. It's so expected. And as it's written, it's so shallow. It can be done better, I'm sure of it; there's a wide middle-ground between "longass tsundere courtship" and "immediate attraction-turned-relationship", and they went from one extreme to the next pretty quickly. Develop the characters first, then the romantic aspect should come naturally, rather than being as forced as it seems to be now.
Obviously I'm not on the show and I don't write for it, as Geoff Thorne so aptly pointed out. But these aren't difficult concepts. At least, I think they aren't; maybe I'm entirely wrong and it would take way too much investment to pull something like this off, and what they have now is as good as it gets. I hope it's not. If this is it, then it's not enough.