Hi! I'm sorry if this thing was already discussed, but I've been thinking about it for years and really want to know other fans points of view!
Well, Margaret Atwood wrote this story in 1985 and claimed that everything she mentioned existed in our history (which is true). But the show has gone too far in some aspects, which makes it seem unrealistic and overly dystopic!
Like, how can ALL the people (except the Commanders of course) of a very modern and technologically advanced country like the US just stopped immediately using their phones, computers, and the Net after the Gilead seized power?! It wouldn't be a surprise in a poor African country or somewhere like Afghanistan, but in America?? WTF Like, I know, women (about 50% of the population) are forbidden to read and write, but men (who are not as priveleged as the Commaders)?.. Yes, in the 1980s, it was not an issue, but know... We CAN'T live without our gadgets!!
Okay, let's just forget about it. But they also can't read books (females), watching TV, or listen to the radio! In the book and in the 1992 film they had at least two of these available! But in the series, they have literally NOTHING! It seems SO unrealistic for the 2017 - time of information society!!
That's only the beginning. I'm not even gonna talk about how Gilead's economy can survive without at least 50% (women) of people being forbidden to work and most good specialists and highly educated people either executed or sent to the colonies. Women are the majority in many important fields, and you can't just remove them all over the country without serious circumstances!!! USA is not a poor upwards state like, as I've said, Afghanistan! OK, those terrorists chose the military field (male-dominated) to develop and support.
Again, about their lives. They destroyed beautiful churches and almost all Christian rituals. So they can't just go to church and pray unless it's a crowded, imposed "ceremony"! There are also no cinemas, cafes, bookshops (obviously), malls or other everyday life stuff. I know that most of the people there are literally enslaved, but even slaves need some entertainment! They don't even have music anymore!!
Wifes... They are literally doing NOTHING all day long!! They don't do housework and cannot read, listen to the radio, watch TV, listen to music, go to church, go shopping, or even just go for a WALK!! Even handmaids or marphas have more freedom and things to do! It seems like real TORTURE for educated women. They can only abuse their handmaids or play (they don't even feed, care for, or educate them) with their stolen children. Absolutely useless class for the country! They are not even real housewives who do everything on their own!! I'm not surprised why they're so mad
Also about reading. Actually it seems like a total nonsense and insane! Delete all the written signs in cities, especially streets and station names!! Come on, how the f*** are you even able to live in a megapolis like Boston without that?! How can you know the right address you need or take the right train cause you don't have the Net or maps anymore!!
And they all wear special uniforms... Who made MILLIONS of those clothes?! If women are forbidden to work!!
Also, most importantly, they don't even think about pregnant handmaids health!! No diagnostics, a very stressful and miserable life (the only privilege is not being tortured or exuted for a while—how lovely! ), which can affect the baby, and even no doctor's help in labor! Come on, you don't even care if the baby (the most expensive property in Gilead) dies, not helping the mother AT ALL!! They even attend execution in late pregnancy!! Stupid and unreasnoble
Well, how can you explain anything about that? ..
Update. okay, I see that you hate my opinion and answers, maybe I'm not nerdy or fanatic enough to understand the show