r/TheGoodPlace • u/TheOriginalElTigre • Jun 19 '24
Shirtpost Am I wrong for feeling unsatisfied with the ending?
I just finished The Good Place, and it was such a rollercoaster of emotions for me; it gave me the same heartwarming and enthralling feelings that Community, another one of my most favorite shows ever, did. I grew so close to every character to the show to the point where I was rooting for even Shawn to make some kind of overture (which he did thank goodness just in time!)
However, like many that watched the show, the ending, even though it brought a finality to the show that many shows like it sincerely needed instead of continuing for so many seasons, doesn't really give me a sense of finality. And I understand the philosophical reasonings behind it, obviously, as we're all "waves that eventually become a part of the ocean once again" like Chidi had implied when he decided it was his time, and it aligns with many of the religions that are practiced here in the real world, like Buddhism and Hinduism, especially around reincarnation, etc.
But I just don't feel ok with it. My idea of the Good Place created by the events of most of the show is that its the "finish line", the place where souls finally complete their journey after dying and reach eternal fulfillment after going through the tests of the afterlife. But once we get to the last two episodes, now its suddenly not and now its just another stop that you eventually get tired of and head off to the door to shed the final part of your humanity and become a part of the universe once again. I don't really dig this, honestly. It makes me feel like that there's really no choice at the end of the line but simply become a "part of the universe". Obviously they give you the "choice" to stay in the Good Place, but its not really a "choice" if the inevitability is that you'll get "satisfied" no matter what and walk that final walk to the end.
Even though Tahani didn't go that route like Chidi, Eleanor and Jason did, it just bothers me that it feels like eventually she will too one day despite currently having a purpose of being an architect. Like what's the point of the Good Place if its not the place where you reach eternal fulfillment? It doesn't really feel like a "Good" Place anymore in that case. Does it even have a place in the afterlife really?
And what about people that can't make it to the Good Place because they keep struggling to get there? Why couldn't they just give up and become a part of the universe if the human part is really insignificant in the end and is just finite? Why is this option just limited to Good Place people? I feel like positioning wouldn't matter here if the endgame is to just shoot you back into the universe where your whole entire consciousness is wiped away for good. (This is assuming they never become humans again or reincarnate)
TLDR: The ending made everything else before it feel insignificant to me. What's the point of any of the Places in the afterlife if you just become another speck in the universe in the end no matter what once you reach human fulfillment?