r/TheGoodPlace • • Jun 19 '24

Shirtpost Am I wrong for feeling unsatisfied with the ending?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I just finished The Good Place, and it was such a rollercoaster of emotions for me; it gave me the same heartwarming and enthralling feelings that Community, another one of my most favorite shows ever, did. I grew so close to every character to the show to the point where I was rooting for even Shawn to make some kind of overture (which he did thank goodness just in time!)

However, like many that watched the show, the ending, even though it brought a finality to the show that many shows like it sincerely needed instead of continuing for so many seasons, doesn't really give me a sense of finality. And I understand the philosophical reasonings behind it, obviously, as we're all "waves that eventually become a part of the ocean once again" like Chidi had implied when he decided it was his time, and it aligns with many of the religions that are practiced here in the real world, like Buddhism and Hinduism, especially around reincarnation, etc.

But I just don't feel ok with it. My idea of the Good Place created by the events of most of the show is that its the "finish line", the place where souls finally complete their journey after dying and reach eternal fulfillment after going through the tests of the afterlife. But once we get to the last two episodes, now its suddenly not and now its just another stop that you eventually get tired of and head off to the door to shed the final part of your humanity and become a part of the universe once again. I don't really dig this, honestly. It makes me feel like that there's really no choice at the end of the line but simply become a "part of the universe". Obviously they give you the "choice" to stay in the Good Place, but its not really a "choice" if the inevitability is that you'll get "satisfied" no matter what and walk that final walk to the end.

Even though Tahani didn't go that route like Chidi, Eleanor and Jason did, it just bothers me that it feels like eventually she will too one day despite currently having a purpose of being an architect. Like what's the point of the Good Place if its not the place where you reach eternal fulfillment? It doesn't really feel like a "Good" Place anymore in that case. Does it even have a place in the afterlife really?

And what about people that can't make it to the Good Place because they keep struggling to get there? Why couldn't they just give up and become a part of the universe if the human part is really insignificant in the end and is just finite? Why is this option just limited to Good Place people? I feel like positioning wouldn't matter here if the endgame is to just shoot you back into the universe where your whole entire consciousness is wiped away for good. (This is assuming they never become humans again or reincarnate)

TLDR: The ending made everything else before it feel insignificant to me. What's the point of any of the Places in the afterlife if you just become another speck in the universe in the end no matter what once you reach human fulfillment?


r/TheGoodPlace • • Dec 04 '23

Shirtpost Hopefully this doesn’t lose me points here

Post image
0 Upvotes

Just felt like tweaking this scene.


r/TheGoodPlace • • Feb 22 '26

Shirtpost Lowkey made a Good Place self-insert character Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Idk if this is out of bounds in this subreddit, but I basically made an OC for the show. I’m OBSESSED with The Good Place, I have seen it 16 times, in the middle of my 17th rewatch!!! I have a lot of memory issues so it’s fun for me to rewatch consistently and catch more details.

The concept of this character is simple and silly, he’s a 12 year old boy named Kody Spielman who hypothetically was also involved in the neighborhood experiment. I thought it would be interesting because I don’t think there’s ever much mention of children in The Good Place or what happens with them in The Afterlife. I like to think most of them default end up in The Good Place but considering for the majority of the show, no one can get into the good place at all, I’d say it works.

He’s a spoiled brat who died at his birthday party hence his little chuck-e-cheese esc crown and tablecloth cape.

He prefers to get what he wants or he’ll be kicking people in the shins and lying that his parents own the place.

I imagine he takes the most liking to Shawn for some reason.


r/TheGoodPlace • • Feb 12 '25

Season Four I don't like how they ended Brents story.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheGoodPlace • • Sep 25 '23

Shirtpost Does jason get any better? I just started the second season, he is a terrible character..

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheGoodPlace • • Jan 25 '24

Shirtpost What was Chidi? What was his job?

Post image
13 Upvotes

I've seen the show like 6 times, I'm rewatching it again right now, and I still can't wrap my head around this. I mean, I get most of the stuff about the characters is purposefully loose and stuff, but this is just so... mundane that it makes me feel like I'm just missing something.

What is Chidi? He calls himself a profesor, but he keeps talking about how he is working on his thesis and meeting his thesis advisor? Are phd students in Australia called professors? Do professors in Australia have thesis advisors?

Like, I get that him working on one article for... however many years it has been, I'm unclear about his age, and having a huge office to himself is just so the plot works. But like... what is he?! Is he actually just a phd student? Did he really roll up to the afterlife and with absolute confidence told an immortal demon he was an the authority on morality and ethics when he couldn't even finish his doctorate? Why wasn't humongous hubris ever cited as a reason for him being in the bad place?!


r/TheGoodPlace • • Jul 21 '23

Shirtpost Is it just me or does Micheal remind you of the old guy from Cracked?

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

This guy


r/TheGoodPlace • • Oct 28 '18

The Good Place is Boring

1 Upvotes

Hello Reddit, I have already watched 5 episodes of this show, and found it very boring, but it seems that I am the only person in the entire world that doesn't like the good place. Should I keep watching or should I just move on?


r/TheGoodPlace • • Feb 26 '23

Season Four Spoilers! Tahani Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I just rewatched and realized no one ever talks about how Tahani never got a soulmate. Her “soulmate” fell in love with a robot…

I guess her soulmate was herself? And they were in the bad place all along so the whole “soulmate” thing was a lie Michael told them to make them believe they were in the Good Place?

But I would have like to see her and Jason end up together. That would have been fair to the character, especially a minority woman character…

It gave very Bonnie from The Vampire Diaries 😬


r/TheGoodPlace • • Aug 04 '21

No Spoilers Damn, I didn't expect a negative reaction on this sub...

0 Upvotes

I expressed my heart and love for this show and how it helped during a really bad point in my life, and I get a comment saying that no one cares. Lol That was funny but super unexpected. Not like I expected mad responses, but I didn't expect that. Lolol

https://www.reddit.com/r/TheGoodPlace/comments/ox65yt/never_going_back/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3


r/TheGoodPlace • • Dec 16 '24

Shirtpost Doug Forcett makes no sense.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/TheGoodPlace • • Dec 31 '24

Shirtpost What did he do? (man on the inside.)

Post image
3 Upvotes

I’m actually confused why is everyone so angry at him when they realize that he was only there so he could find the thief, I mean it’s not like he did anything wrong and he didn’t hurt anyone. He didn’t even lie to any of them.


r/TheGoodPlace • • Jun 28 '26

Shirtpost Was anyone else bothered by Chidi and Eleanor’s relationship? Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

I just got the sense that he never truly liked her. Except for that one time when they confessed their love for each other at Mindy’s place. It started with her anticipating his sneeze and handing him the tissue.

Every other time, it felt like Eleanor was pushing for it, chasing him, convincing him. In the beginning I was really rooting for them, but seeing how she was so desperate for him and how he proved time and again he could take it or leave it with her was maddening. That is not how you create a compelling romance between two characters.

And he was always abandoning her. Two prominent times I remember were when Simone was coming to join the experiment in the afterlife and when he literally leaves the good place in the last episode. Do you even like this woman?? She’s always crying and pleading for them to be together. And he’s always like, “K, bye.”

I could’ve done without their romance, tbh.

And also, minor note, I prefer Jason and Tahani together than he and Janet.

Wow, just realising the romance in this series fell completely flat for me. That’s all.


r/TheGoodPlace • • Feb 17 '23

Season Two Tahani is younger than Kamilla… probably

0 Upvotes

Tahani’s actress is a fair bit younger so I’m calling it- she sprouted early in the Good Place, while Kamilla grew at a more steady rate.


r/TheGoodPlace • • Dec 18 '25

Shirtpost Do you think Jason and Tahani deserve what they got ?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I mean getting into the good place at the end

I feel like Eleanor and Chidi carry the soul squad so much Tahani and Jason contribution in saving mankind pale in comparison . It would make more sense in my opinion if only the first two get there . I would love to change my view if you can


r/TheGoodPlace • • Jan 24 '20

Season Four The show has written itself into a corner by refusing to take a stand. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Okay, so obviously by the title I'm not a huge fan of tonight's episode. To give some context, I absolutely despise the idea that the ultimate end goal of self-perfection should be self-obliteration through enlightenment. I've always found it to be a deeply depressing view of what makes living worth it.

In this vein, I think the show's depiction of the Good Place is a natural product of the way in which it has (from the very start) refused to take a deeper stand on what makes life meaningful. For the entire series it has worked its way up to the idea that the goal of a good life should be a constant cycle of fixing your flaws and surmounting your problems. This is easy to work out within a sort of modern-secular framework, while also fitting in very well to the bulk of world religions. The problem is that the show has kind of written itself into a bind with the need to not annoy anyone by settling on the idea that heaven is a constant fulfillment of your wishes. In essence, heaven is hedonism, and, once satiated, the ennui makes it unbearable. The option the show takes is thus to say that the the ideal solution is to offer a way out to give the hedonism more meaning and to allow for one to exit once satiated.

But, the thing is that this resembles no religious afterlife, and, due to how inherently religious the concept of an afterlife is, there are few secular humanist approaches to pull from either. The religious concepts of the afterlife contain that element of physical reward and satiety, but it's always paired with spiritual bliss as well, being together with billions of other souls. Just as much of the Good Place is a secularized take, accidentally or purposefully, on a genericized religious afterlife, this idea of the spiritual reward of heaven could also fit in as well in a secular form. The show has been defined by the relations built between complete strangers, so why not make a stand on it. Why not say "Heaven is other people", an eternity to meet billions on billions of other souls who you would have never encountered, a never ending chance to learn and teach, to always grow?

Instead the show seems to be trapped in a mushy middle of wanting to engage with a spiritual concept without actually engaging in spiritualism, and, much like the Good Place Committee itself, its taking an easy way out designed not to particularly annoy anybody in particular.


r/TheGoodPlace • • Feb 10 '23

Shirtpost They said season 4 was a good life span well they were totally wrong.

1 Upvotes

I can’t believe they felt like 4 seasons was enough. Especially since it just felt like there was so much going on in season 4! We got 3 great new characters in the good place with Brent, Simone and John. But then takes em out of the show just like that.


r/TheGoodPlace • • Jan 07 '24

Season One Halfway into S1. A bit disappointed

Post image
0 Upvotes

Currently half way into Season

  1. This show doesn’t make much sense imo. There are so many weird things about the good place. The show tries to blame all these things on Eleanor who was sent there by mistake but it’s not convincing me. 1. How does Eleanor’s bad behaviour cause chaos? The show explains it with a Swiss watch being smashed by a hammer but I still don’t get it. There’s like no correlation between Eleanor stealing shrimps and shrimps flying over the sky

  2. Bart and Nina in the sinkhole episode just seem odd. In Episode 1 we were told that all people in the good place were saints who saved lives or fought for gay rights, but then Bart and Nina are just a detective and a marriage counsellor…? I’m not saying they are bad people but they don’t seem like saints. Now that I think of it Chidi also seems off, he was a moral philosophy professor. He’s a good person but he doesn’t seem as good as the guy who donated both of his livers to a stranger and it’s weird that he is in the good place

  3. Tahani shouldn’t be in the good place. Yes she did raise lots of money but she was doing it to compete with her sister from what I see so far. She also likes showing off so she definitely isn’t a good person, not a saint at least.

  4. Michael doesn’t seem like an angel. I mean what kind of angel would kick a puppy into the sun???

  5. It seems like Michael never leaves the 4 main characters, which is weird bc there are more than 300 people in the good place.

I know most of these are for comedic effects or plot progression but they really bug me. The good place just isn’t as perfect as they claim it to be (Sorry for low quality unrelated image)


r/TheGoodPlace • • Jan 13 '23

Season Three Chidi falling in love with Eleanor in s3 Maker no sens Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I was rewatching the series for the third time but it’s the first time that it felt weird, during the episode of the bar fight in Canada, Eleanor declare her love to Chidi after seeing her memories with him from the “good” place and realising she stills love him. But Chidi says her because he does not have any memories from that he doesn’t love her which seems reasonable. But Eleanor thinks that it’s unfair because they are the same person only without the memories so their love is still their.

Chidi does not have any recovery of any intimate relationship with her, he has no obligation to love her back and it seems that he doesn’t and explains it to her.

But in the next episode where the four cockroaches are hiding in Janet’s void while they argue about this, Chidi finally kisses Eleanor and falls in love with her almost instantly and during the remaining episodes they are the most perfect couple and Chidi is so in love with her.

It seems so weird to me that he went from : no I don’t love you because I only have 2 years worth of memories of you, to : I love you so much you are the love of my life ! In just a few hours.

Have I missed something ?


r/TheGoodPlace • • Nov 13 '18

Five episodes into season 3 and so far it's been disappointing

1 Upvotes

It feels like season 3 has gotten rid of what made the show unique and so creative and feels like a generic show. Taking place on Earth where Michael and Janet have no powers just really takes away so many creative possibilities and really limits what can be done.

I think I read that season 3 is dropping in viewer numbers and I wouldn't be surprised if this ends up being cancelled with how season 3 has been so far.


r/TheGoodPlace • • Nov 07 '23

Shirtpost Important Plot Hole Question

Post image
0 Upvotes

How come Jason does know how to have sex with Tahani, but doesn’t know how to have sex with Janet?


r/TheGoodPlace • • Dec 31 '20

Season Four CMV: Chidi's wave analogy is terrible and should provide no comfort whatsoever

0 Upvotes

The wave analogy has bothered me since I first watched it. Saw another meme referencing it today, so here we go: The wave analogy is terrible, and isn't at all similar to the situation it attempts to describe.

A wave is a random collection of water that physics happens to shape into a particular shape that is pleasing to look at and experience. The same could be said of a human being, and that seems to be Chidi's point: that once the wave is done, the ocean can use the same material to make another wave, just as pretty and entertaining. And the material that makes up a human can go on to be part of another human, or a wave (since we're mostly water).

But this completely misses the uniqueness of human beings. You can watch the beach for a day, and see a thousand waves, and each of them is completely unique, but crucially, each is as pretty as the next, and you couldn't remember two waves well enough to distinguish them.

If we were judging humans from the point of view of a theoretical alien, or maybe a god, the analogy would hold: they wouldn't see the need to distinguish one human from another, and they could watch us come and go the way we watch the waves, perfectly content to enjoy the show.

But humans do recognize other human beings as individuals. If Chidi's water, carbon, etc., was reformed into another human being, that person would randomly be very different, and in no way a reasonable comfort for Eleanor. To Chidi's full analogy, if Chidi's raw material becomes some soil and a rose bush, should Eleanor be comforted that she can still talk to the roses?

Things that would change my view:

  1. Explain how I have completely misinterpreted the analogy.

  2. Explain how a rose bush is just as useful to Eleanor as Chidi was.

Things that won't change my view:

  1. Appeals to the poetry of the metaphor: it's pretty, and William Jackson Harper does a great job delivering the lines. That doesn't change the fact that Chidi is not a random wave to Eleanor, and the next "wave" won't be just as useful to her.

  2. Arguments that I'm just not seeing the big picture/looking at it the right way: that's the alien/god argument, and the metaphor isn't for an alien, it's for Eleanor. To her, Chidi is unique and irreplaceable. He's not a wave.

So, CMV.


r/TheGoodPlace • • Apr 04 '23

Season Two Unpopular opinion: Eleanor hitting on Tahani was gross and weird

0 Upvotes

I'm sure I'm gonna get downvoted for this, I don't care. Many people gloss over this maybe because the perpetrator is a pretty woman, but if you think about it, Tahani never reciprocates about Eleanor's sexual comments. She's clearly not interested, and it's supposed to be a group of four friends-Eleanor, Jason, Chidi, and Tahani. Can you imagine if Jason started making sexual remarks about Eleanor or Tahani's ass, while Tahani/Chidi never reciprocated? It's no different with what Eleanor did to Tahani.

It's borderline sexual harassment and it really feels out of place. Very close to Gina from Brooklyn 99 making sexual remarks about Terry. An unfortunately common theme in both shows by Michael Schur (who's shows I love by the way!). We're just supposed to ignore gross sexual comments and harassment just because the perpetrators in both these cases is a woman.

Eleanor's comments don't age well like the rest of the show does. They're gross, creepy, and don't fit with the vibe these four friends usually share.


r/TheGoodPlace • • Aug 29 '18

Season Two Doesn't Chidi speak French? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

In the season 2 finale, Chidi speaks perfect English when Eleanor walks into his office. In the pilot, he says the good place is translating his French. Are they living in simulations or are they alive?