Hi! I’m a relatively long-time, but also young (23), fan of Coheed (I’ve been aware of them since Good Apollo, and really got into them with No World for Tomorrow), and I recently realized that I hadn’t actually listened to their full discography. So, on a long drive, I put their albums on and decided to compile my thoughts and a list!
I’ll be going from “worst” (relatively, at least) to best, with some thoughts on each. I’m starting from Turbine and going to Unheavenly Creatures, so no Shabutie or Prize Fighter. I’m also using the Spotify releases, for reference. Let’s get started!
9. The Second Stage Turbine Blade
-Highlights: Delirium Trigger, Neverender
I feel like it’s hardly surprising that their first album is my least favorite. It has a lot going for it, but it feels a lot rough around the edges, which makes it less enjoyable than later albums. A lot of songs really overstay their welcome, and they tend to be fairly monotone throughout (Devil in Jersey City, for instance). Not a bad album overall, but definitely the bottom.
8. Good Apollo I’m Burning Star IV Volume One
-Highlights: Welcome Home, The Suffering, Wake Up
This is my first controversial opinion, I assume. This album has some absolute bangers, but.. it also has the absolute weirdest final 30 minutes in a Coheed album, culminating in what I can only assume is a case of a group of hillbillies breaking into the studio for a jam session. It has a similar issue as Turbine, with a lot of songs overstaying their welcome.
7. In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3
-Highlights: In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3, A Favor House Atlantic, The Light & the Glass
The first album where I feel like every song is at a baseline of “good.” This is a very solid album, but ultimately doesn’t match up to later albums that are baseline “great.” It’s interesting to hear how many of Coheed’s sounds came from this album, though.
6. Year of the Black Rainbow
-Highlights: Here We Are Juggernaut, World of Lines, Pearl of the Stars
I’ve heard negative things about this album, but I honestly loved it. The three songs I listed are amazing, but the rest of the album is no slouch. I just prefer other albums overall.
5. The Unheavenly Creatures
-Highlights: Queen of the Dark, The Dark Sentencer, Old Flames
This album felt finally different from Coheed’s previous work, with a lot more bright and poppy music, but I definitely enjoyed it. It’s the album that made Coheed my number one artist on Spotify in 2019 haha.
4. The Afterman: Ascension
-Highlights: Domino, The Afterman, Goodnight Fair Lady
Here’s where things start to get hard, and I start ranking based on how hard the emotional songs make me cry. Domino might be the single best storytelling song Coheed has made, and The Afterman has so many feels. I don’t really like Holly Wood, though, which is why this album sits below its other half.
3. No World For Tomorrow
-Highlights: Mother Superior, No World For Tomorrow, III - The End Complete
This is the album that made me a fan. I listened to it nonstop throughout my high school career, and Mother Superior is still one of my favorite songs to this day. A few songs falter a bit (Feathers and Justice in Murder), but it’s overall an excellent album.
2. The Color Before the Sun
-Highlights: Atlas, Here to Mars, Colors
Another controversial pick, but hear me out: Here to Mars is probably my favorite song of all time and never fails to make me lose my shit. It’s so good that it single-handedly puts this album high on my list, but the rest of the album is also just an interesting and emotional look into Claudio’s mind. It may not be an Amory Wars album, but it still succeeds in my eyes.
The Afterman: Descension
-Highlights: the whole album
And here it is, my favorite Coheed album. There’s not a song on here that’s less than great, and tracks like Sentry and Dark Side of Me are absolutely top tier music.
Thanks for reading all of this if you got this far! It’s rare that I find anyone interested in listening to me ramble about Coheed, so apologies if I come off a little strong.
Also, for the record, the combined Afterman album would rank second after Color, in case anyone was wondering.