I fell in love with The Eric Andre Show from season one, because of how insanely unpredictable it was. Seeing him destroy the set right at the beginning was incredible because i'd never seen anything like it. The format of a surreal nightmare talk show was fresh and original and felt genuinely exciting. The jokes came out of nowhere and hit hard because of this.
As the seasons have gone on, the show has started to follow more of a formula. The same intro, the same skits keep reappearing, the same style of interviews... I also note how there is less really surreal stuff in the new seasons, which I was a fan of. How many more ways can they break the set? How many more ways can they torture the guest? How many times can they do another version of "ranch it up"? The longer it goes on with the formula the less interesting it is, and the less surprised I am.
I think they could have made the show really special if they completely changed things up after season 2 or 3, but they didn't, and every new season starts to drag on. I still overall enjoy the new episodes, but it seems like they will never reach the excitement and appeal of those first few early seasons.
What do you guys think? Do you agree or disagree?