r/TheDirtsheets • • Sep 09 '14

THE DEATH OF KERRY VON ERICH. 3/1/1993 Observer (pt 1)

156 Upvotes

DEATH OF A DYNASTY

"Somewhere along the way, a cute marketing concept decayed into a macabre body count." -- Irvin Muchnick, Penthouse Magazine, in a 1988 article "Born Again Bashing" about the Von Erich family.

"I was shocked that Kerry killed himself. But I wasn't shocked at all that he died." -- Terry Simms, pro wrestler and one of Kerry's closest friends.

Fantasy vs. reality. For most people in the real world, for the most part, they know the difference. In pro wrestling, among both its performers and its fans, sometimes the line gets a little blurred. Often that's dismissed as simply harmless. But sometimes when the line is blurred for long enough, or the difference is no longer perceptible, or even worse, when the fantasy becomes the reality, it creates a situation of potential danger. The danger is that the day may come when the bubble is burst and the fantasy is over and one isn't equipped to deal with the reality.

The bubble must have come close to bursting several times over the past decade for Kerry Gene Adkisson, who had lived in many ways the ultimate fantasy life up until he was in his mid-20s. The reality after that period was the harshest imaginable. Three brothers died. His other brother suffered a near death experience. One of his brothers' children died at birth. He was involved in a motorcycle accident that left him crippled. The company that was his by birthright went out of business, ending with him having little money left to his name. The superstardom that was seemingly his not only by birthright but through ability and charisma as well, slowly slipped away. Because he was broke, he hooked up with the biggest wrestling company in the world, and for a time, he was getting to relive his past fame. But in doing so, they originally planned to take away his beloved family name.

While he kept his name, the legendary status of it and favored treatment the name Von Erich meant were no longer the case. Slowly the reality that he wasn't what he once was moved him from superstar to preliminary status. The recreational drug problems continued. Soon, the drugs that created his beloved physique were banned as well, causing his beloved muscles to shrink to ungodlike normality.

Eventually, he lost that job as well, and the money that went with it, and was only working once or twice a week, earning the kind of money that he often blew nightly during his years of living the ultimate fantasy, on good times. He was broke, and was in trouble with the IRS to the point that he was auctioning off his wrestling memorabilia from his famous title win over Ric Flair at wrestling conventions. His parents, the cornerstone behind the so-called perfect family unit, split up. His own marriage had its ups and downs. Yet in his own way, he was able to somehow shield himself, at least to a point, from reality by drawing upon the fantasy.

The fantasy was that he was Kerry Von Erich, the Modern Day Warrior. He was one of the great athletes in the world. He had the perfect physique. He was nearly unbeatable at wrestling, and in fact, was the uncrowned World champion. He was the second-youngest man ever to hold the most famous and prestigious wrestling belt in the world and he won it from the greatest wrestler of our time in the most emotional setting and in front of one of the biggest crowds and in one of the most famous matches the wrestling world had ever seen. He was loaded with charisma. He'd have gone to the Olympics in the discus if Carter hadn't called for the boycott or if some heel wouldn't have stomped on his shoulder just before the try-outs that in reality he was never going to attend in the first place. He was rich. He had the hottest car. He could literally do no wrong, because even if he did, since he was a Von Erich, it would always be taken care of. Whatever he wanted, someone would take care of for him because he was Kerry Von Erich, son of the greatest wrestler the world had ever seen and son of one of the wealthiest and most influential men in the community. He was the object of desire for every female in the state of Texas, and plenty in other states as well. Everyone else wanted to be his friend.

Anywhere he went he was mobbed by autograph seekers. Every night he stepped into the ring, the cheers were as loud for him as nearly anyone in the history of a business that was his. He was born to be a demigod. Hell, he was a demigod, at least he was every night when he stepped into the ring in the minds of most of the people in the building and to enough hangers-on out of the ring that he was able to never have to leave the fantasy. He was born into the perfect Christian family, inherited the greatest athletic genes, and through his never-ending search for athletic perfection, achieved dizzying heights of fame. He and his brothers were going to rule the wrestling world.

On Wednesday, February 17, the fantasy world of Kerry Von Erich was about to end. He was indicted that morning on cocaine possession charges stemming from a January 13 arrest. He was already serving ten years probation for forging drug prescriptions during a time about one year earlier when he was supposed to be attending rehab. While it was not a guarantee, the odds were very good that his probation would be revoked and he would be sent to prison. It appears Kerry at least believed that was going to be his future. In prison, there would be no evenings where hundreds of women would screech every time he took off his ring jacket. No women would send him roses and fantasize or realize time with him. There were no world title matches to be won. No ugly heels were going to sell big when he said "discus." There was almost no family left. The drugs that made him a modern-day Warrior, the steroids, weren't going to be available. The drugs he took, just because they were available and plentiful, and the ones he took to numb both the physical and mental pain, were going to be gone. The drugs he took to escape from the reality were also going to be history. He could no longer lie and con, traits that had been instilled in him at a young age because the marks would always believe a Von Erich because they fought the fans' fantasy enemies, nor have everyone that surrounded him believe he was something that he wasn't. Perhaps the worst thing of all was he'd have to come to grips with the fact that the fantasy that was his professional life and became much of his personal life wasn't reality.

He'd have to face what the reality really was. The night of his death, a long-time family friend theorized that if Kerry hadn't have taken his life that afternoon, he would have almost certainly done so in his first week in prison.

When he learned Thursday morning of his indictment, he apparently set out to kill himself. But those who knew him well, or even casually, seem to believe this wasn't a spontaneous decision. Many of his friends recalled in the past few days Kerry would come over, for seemingly no reason, hug them, say "I love you," and then leave. Some were confused by his actions initially. In hindsight, they realized he had been saying his good-byes. It may have seemed unusual, but unusual in Kerry's case wasn't unusual. Terry Funk, who saw Von Erich a few weeks earlier in Philadelphia, remembered him coming up to him and reminiscing about when he and his brothers feuded with Terry and his brother in Amarillo during the early days of his career, talking about it being some of the happiest moments of his life. On January 27, one week before is 33rd birthday, he and his probation office, Gary Hunter, had their routine meeting and he talked of suicide.

"He talked about it then," Hunter said in an article in the Dallas Morning-News. "He said he missed his brothers and said he just didn't feel like going on." Hunter said Kerry rejected his advice to seek counseling for his suicidal feelings and his continuing drug addictions.

"In his own way, he came to say good-bye to me on Monday," remembered Terry Simms, a Dallas wrestler who was one of his best friends. "He came into the (health) club, hugged me and said, `I miss you when you're not around.' It bothered me for a couple of days because it was really strange. His hair wasn't combed. He hadn't shaved. He looked terrible. I'm sure that everyone he came in contact with the last two weeks thought the same thing.

"He didn't want to go to prison. He had told people that if he got indicted, he'd kill himself.

"Is prison really that bad? So he may have had to spend a year in prison. It may have been the best thing that ever happened to him. He had two daughters that he loved deeply. Anyone who was ever around him could tell that in a second."

His father said Kerry had frequently mentioned taking his own life. His wife Cathy, whom he had an on-again, off-again relationship with over the years, hid all the guns from the house. He said the same strange goodbyes to the woman and her mother whom he had been living with the past few weeks, and headed to his father's ranch.

As he had done with everyone else he felt close to, when he arrived at 1:30 p.m., he hugged his dad and told him he loved him, borrowed the .44-calibre Magnum handgun he had given his father for Christmas in 1991 and borrowed his father's jeep telling him that he needed to find a quiet spot to do some thinking.

About 45 minutes later, his father, who in his own fantasy life was the legendary Fritz Von Erich, got worried. Jack Adkisson had built a company largely to package and hype his alter ego as the greatest wrestler of all-time and his children as the prodigal sons. He was the father of the ultimate fantasy family of athletes, but in reality he had already lost four of his six sons, none of whom saw their 26th birthday. He knew Kerry had to pick up his two daughters, nine-year-old Holly and six-year-old Lacy, from school. He searched on his ranch and found that the jeep was empty. Then found the body partially hidden from the thicket. Apparently Kerry had shot himself in the heart.

The death marks the end of one of the most bizarre family stories any of us will ever know. The story is far beyond the significance of simply the pro wrestling world that the family was once among the most powerful and recognizable members of. The Von Erich dynasty, what at one time seemed to have been a brilliant marketing plan by Jack Adkisson dating back to the late 60s, saw the seeds bloom on Christmas night of 1982, and for the next 16 months he owned the hottest and most innovative wrestling company in the world. The cornerstones were his three young, athletic and at the time almost interchangeable sons. The youngest of the three, Kerry, was rivalled by only Hulk Hogan in Minneapolis and Jimmy Snuka in New York as the most popular wrestler in the country. Certainly, in terms of attracting new fans and a young audience, "The Modern Day Warrior" stood as almost a sure bet to become the biggest wrestling star in the world before too many more years were finished. While other promotions quickly caught up and surpassed Jack Adkisson's company, the marketing plan was still in tact for a successful regional business. The Von Erichs were still the kings of North Texas.

The first Wrestlemania, which rocked the nation, died in Dallas. The Saturday Night Main Events of the WWF, at the time a ratings success story around the country, was destroyed head-to-head by Adkisson's local television show on KTVT. The life didn't immediately get squeezed away from the territory, but instead lives themselves started ending, one after another, a body count that engulfed the wrestling world with morbid fascination. The dynasty pretty well ended in April of 1987, with the death of Jack's fifth son, Michael, and third to die, at the age of 23, a suicide caused by overdosing on Placidyl. Michael had been involved with frequent scrapes with the law during the last year of his life, and his death had been eerily predicted just two weeks before it happened by Jack's booker, Frank "Bruiser Brody" Goodish. Goodish was the only wrestler in the glory era who rivalled the sons' popularity in Texas and in a bizarre turn of fate, he would be murdered just over one year later in a Puerto Rican dressing room.

Less than one month after Mike's death, the fourth annual David Von Erich Memorial Parade of Champions took place at Texas Stadium. Only it was changed to the David and Mike Von Erich Memorial show. Even the Dallas fans, who had a national reputation for being the most blindly loyal fans to the family of any fans in the world, suddenly woke up. Three years earlier, when David's death was memorialized at Texas Stadium and drew what was at the time the second-largest gate in pro wrestling history (32,123 fans live paying $402,000 trailing only the Bruno Sammartino vs. Larry Zbyszko 1980 match at Shea Stadium), many of Jack's former closest friends and fellow compadres in the admittedly seedy business, were repulsed at the attempt to make money capitalizing on his sons' death.

"When I was down there (late 70s), I thought Jack was as great a man as I'd ever known," said Denver sportscaster Steve Harmes, who worked for a Dallas television station at the time and eventually became a referee, play-by-play announcer and close personal friend of Jack Adkisson while his sons were first breaking in. "I was really disillusioned when they had the Memorial after David died. After that I mainly followed them in the Observer. They lost touch with reality. The marks who would go to the shows twice a week got fed up when he faked the heart attack and with all the Memorial shows. When I'd go down there on vacation and talk to the fans, that's what I kept hearing."

But the Dallas area fans themselves largely didn't notice the exploitation at the first David Von Erich Memorial Bash on May 6, 1984. Even with the family photos and David memorabilia being sold at inflated prices, including a rushed out 45 record called "Heaven Needed a Champion" being sung at the show and sold at the dozens of merchandise tables, a record cut by one of Jack's gospel singing friends and released literally days after David's death, exploitation was not on most wrestling fans' mind. After all, in their own world of fantasy, their long-awaited dream that had been teased for about two years for most, and for nearly two decades for the older fans that followed Fritz' career, a Von Erich finally winning the NWA world heavyweight title, was about to take place. Just a few miles down the road, the NBA Mavericks were in a do-or-die playoff game with the legendary Lakers of Kareem and Magic fame in a game that shocked the local sports community because it didn't sellout. Even during its heyday, the local community didn't understand the emotion and impact to so many that the world title and the Von Erichs meant, as more than twice as many fans attended the wrestling show.

Pt 2,

Pt 3,

Pt 4,

Pt 5.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Nov 03 '15

(Part 1) The Montreal Screwjob complete Meltzer write up. Wrestling Observer [November 17, 1997]

139 Upvotes

FYI this will probably be a 5-6 parter that I will post throughout the week. This is all from ONE edition of the Wrestling Observer as Dave tried to break down exactly what happened from day 1 of the situation.


It will go down in history as the single most famous finish of a pro wrestling match in the modern era. Twenty or 30 years from now this story, more than any famous wrestler jumping promotions, more than any prominent death, and more than any record setting house, will be remembered vividly by all who watched it live, and remembered as legendary from all who hear about it later. Through the magic of videotape, the last minute of this match will live forever, and be replayed literally millions of times by tens of thousands of people all looking for the most minute pieces of detail to this strange puzzle. But the story of what led to those few seconds starts more than one year ago, far more reminiscent of the dirty con man past of the industry than the current attempted facade of a multi-million dollar corporate above board image those in the industry like to portray outwardly that it has evolved into.

October 20, 1996 - Bret Hart was in a hotel room in San Jose, CA, hours from making the biggest decision of his life--who would win the biggest bidding war in the history of pro wrestling. He had pretty well leaned toward staying with the World Wrestling Federation despite a much larger offer from World Championship Wrestling, but had changed his mind a few times over the previous two weeks as each side presented new offers. In the waning hours, Eric Bischoff and Kevin Nash were trying to convince him to change his mind and how great life was with an easier schedule. Bischoff was offering big money and a shot at becoming a movie star, a goal Hart had been pursuing while on a semi-retirement from wrestling since dropping the title to Shawn Michaels a few months earlier at Wrestlemania. Vince McMahon was offering him, in the now immortal words of Arn Anderson, not just a spot, but the top spot in the company, the chance to be a major part of deciding the future direction of the company, and almost literally, to be WWF 4 life. Many close advisers of Hart's tried to tell him going to WCW was the best move for his present, and more importantly, his future after wrestling. But largely out of loyalty, and that obviously wasn't the only factor involved, he declined the offer. McMahon, determined not to lose a very public fight, offered him the famous 20-year contract where he'd, after retirement in about three years, become almost a first lieutenant when it came to the booking process. Hart would earn somewhere in the neighborhood of $1.5 million per year as an active wrestler, and a healthy but far lesser figure working the front office for the 17 years after retirement as an active wrestler. As part of McMahon's offer, he also was going to allow Hart to explain live on television his decision making process should be sign with WCW. Hart flew to Fort Wayne, IN, where the WWF was holding its live Raw taping after having already verbally agreed to the deal, signed the contract, and gave the interview saying basically that he would be in the WWF forever, figuring to be positioned as the top babyface and perennial champion until he finished his active career riding off in the sunset in a blaze of glory, like Hogan, Savage, and the rest of the superstars before him didn't. As is the case in wrestling, not all the promised scenarios that everyone believed were going to happen transpire as originally planned. And just over one year later, the feelings between McMahon and Hart had taken a 180 degree turn, to the degree nobody would have ever believed.

March 10, 1997 - Top babyface didn't last long as McMahon asked him to turn heel. At first Hart balked at the idea but after three days, McMahon presented him with two lists. One list was his prospective opponents as a babyface--Vader, Mankind and Steve Austin. The other list was his prospective opponents as a heel, Undertaker, Michaels and Austin. Hart agreed for drawing money, his opponents as a heel made up a better list, and he and McMahon agreed that he would turn back babyface over the last few months of his contract and end his career on a positive note. He and Steve Austin did the double-turn at Wrestlemania. Hart himself then came up with the Anti-American angle, where he would remain a babyface in Canada and Europe and do interviews that would for the most part speak the truth, so he could when the time came to turn back in the U.S., have a reasonable explanation.

September 8, 1997 - Vince McMahon and Bret Hart had their first meeting where McMahon seriously approached Hart about his contract. About three months earlier, McMahon had told Hart that the company was in bad financial straights and that they might have to defer some of the money until later in the contract. This time his approach was more point blank. He wanted to cut Hart's regular salary, around $30,000 per week, more than in half and defer the rest of the money until later in the contract period when hopefully the company would be in better shape financially. Hart declined the suggestion, because he didn't want to risk not getting the money in the future after he was through taking all the bumps.

September 20, 1997 - About one hour before the beginning of the PPV show in Birmingham, England, McMahon approached Davey Boy Smith and asked him to put over Shawn Michaels that night for the European title. Smith was apparently shocked, having been told all along in the build-up of the show, that Michaels was going to do a job for him, since Europe was promised to be "his territory." The explanation, which made and still makes logical business sense, is that they wanted to build for a bigger show, a second PPV from Smith's former home town of Manchester, England, where Smith would regain the title--the same scenario the WWF did to draw 60,000 fans in San Antonio with Michaels in the other role working a program with Sycho Sid. So while it all made sense, it was rather strange he wasn't approached with this idea until just before the start of the show. At around this same time period, McMahon approached Hart about working with Michaels. Hart said that he had a problem with that since Michaels had still never really apologized to him for the Sunny days comment, and said it would be hard to trust somebody like that in the ring and due to their past, and told McMahon that he would figure that Michaels would have the same concerns, since a few weeks earlier after first making it clear he would never work with anyone in the Hart Foundation, Michaels had finally agreed to work only with Smith, saying he couldn't trust Bret or Owen.

September 22, 1997 - On the day of the Raw taping at Madison Square Garden, McMahon told Bret Hart flat out that they were going to intentionally breach his contract because they couldn't afford the deal. He told a shocked Hart that he should go to World Championship Wrestling and make whatever deal he could with that group. "I didn't feel comfortable doing it," Hart said of the suggestion. "I feel like an old prisoner in a prison where I know all the guards and all the inmates and I have the best cell. Why would I want to move to a new prison where I don't know the guards and the inmates and I know longer have the best cell? I felt really bad after all the years of working for the WWF." Hart had an escape clause built into his contract since he had so much negotiating leverage when making his WWF deal 11 months earlier, in that he could leave the company giving 30 days notice, and that he would have what the contract called "reasonable creative control" of his character during that lame duck period so that he couldn't be unreasonably buried on the way out. There was a window period for giving that notice and negotiating elsewhere that hadn't begun, so McMahon, showing he was serious, gave Hart written permission to begin negotiating with WCW and Hart contacted Eric Bischoff. The same day, during a meeting with Hart, Michaels and McMahon, Michaels told both of them point blank that he wouldn't do any jobs for anyone in the territory, word that when it got out made most of the other top wrestlers feel even more warmly than usual toward Michaels. Michaels later reiterated that statement to Hart on 10/4 in St. Paul when the two had agreed that for the good of the business that they'd work together. At the meeting, McMahon proposed a scenario where the two would have their first singles match in Montreal, where Undertaker would interfere causing a non-finish. This would lead to Hart wrestling Undertaker on the 12/7 PPV in Springfield, MA, where Michaels would interfere causing Hart to lose the title, as poetic justice since his interference caused Bret to win the title in the first place, and that Royal Rumble on 1/18 in San Jose would be headlined by Undertaker vs. Michaels. During the meeting, Hart told Michaels that he'd be happy to put him over at the end of the run, but Michaels told Hart flat out that he wouldn't return the favor to him. Michaels and Hart spoke again on the subject on 10/12 in San Jose, where once again Michaels told Hart that he wasn't going to do a job for him.

October 21, 1997 - McMahon approached Hart with the idea of losing the title to Michaels in Montreal, but promised that he would win it back on 12/7. Hart, remembering his conversations where Michaels was adamant about not doing any more jobs in the territory, was reluctant, saying after the way the angle had been done with him representing Canada and it becoming a big patriotic deal, that he didn't want to lose the title in Canada. He was then asked to lose to Michaels on 12/7 in Springfield, MA. Hart told McMahon that since Michaels had told both of them that he wasn't doing anymore jobs, that he had a problem doing a job for someone who wouldn't do a job back. He told McMahon that he didn't want to drop the title in Montreal. Later, McMahon, Pat Patterson, Michaels and Hart had another meeting where Michaels, teary eyed, told Hart that he was looking forward to returning the favor to Bret and once again talked about his mouth saying the stupidest things (in regard to saying he'd never do another job in the territory). Hart still refused to lose the title in Montreal. The night before he had been asked to put Hunter Hearst Helmsley over in Oklahoma City via pinfall due to Michaels' interference, but changed the finish to a count out. On this night he was asked to tap out to Ken Shamrock before the DQ ending involving Michaels, which he had no problem doing because he liked and respected Shamrock and wanted to help elevate him. The personal problems with himself and Michaels, which had become legendary in the business, resurfaced once again when the two and McMahon made an agreement to work together but to leave their respective families out of their interviews. It took just one week before Michaels did the interview talking about Stu Hart being dead but walking around Calgary because his body and brain hadn't figured it out yet. By this point, Hart had already stopped watching Raw because he had problems with the content of the show because he had four children that were wrestling fans that he didn't want seeing the direction it was going, so he was reacting to the remark based on the fact that his father and brother Owen heard the remarks and were upset about them.

October 24, 1997 - McMahon, before the show at the Nassau Coliseum, told Hart that the money situation in the company had changed and they would have no problems paying him everything promised in his contract. Hart told McMahon that WCW really hadn't made him a serious offer and that he really didn't want to leave but that he was still uncomfortable doing the job for Michaels in that situation. He left the country for the tour of Bahrain and Oman with the idea that he was staying with the WWF, but knowing due to his window in his contract, he had to make the decision to give notice by midnight on 11/1.

October 31, 1997 - Never one to work without a flair for the dramatics, Bischoff finally caught up with Hart who was basically incommunicado in a foreign land most of the week. Just one day before Hart had to either give notice or stay for another year, Bischoff made a huge concrete offer. We don't know the exact terms of the offer, only that Hart said of the $3 million per year figure that both Jim Ross and Jerry Lawler talked about on the 11/10 Raw, that "they don't have any idea what I was offered," but others close to the situation say that figure is "close enough that you couldn't call it wrong." Hart neither agreed nor turned down the deal, but gave the impression to WCW that they had a great shot at getting him.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Sep 16 '15

[Part 4] Shawn Michaels saga continues [May 01-Mar 02]

132 Upvotes

May 05, 2001

The WWF still hasn’t contacted Shawn Michaels since sending him home right before WrestleMania. Ross has been placed in charge of presenting Michaels with his options, which includes getting professional help for his problems or he won’t be welcomed back…

Dec 02, 2001

Shawn Michaels praised Bret Hart and Triple while appearing on WWF Excess. Michaels appeared an in–studio guest on the Dec. 15 Excess during the show’s first hour. Michaels said he was proud to have won the WWF Title at WrestleMania XII by beating Bret Hart in the Iron Man match. Michaels said it was an honor to win the belt from Hart, whom he praised as being someone who represented the WWF well. Michaels described the feeling of winning the WWF Title as “The most real thing in the world.” Michaels also referred to Hart as the only person who he could have been capable of having a good 60–minute match with. Michaels was also complimentary of Triple H: “No one in this business has the commitment to this business that Triple H does.” Michaels said he spends most of his time at home with his wife Rebecca (a former Nitro Girl) and his son Cameron. He said he misses wrestling “every now and then,” but is committed to his faith and family. Michaels also hosted Smackdown night at WWF New York. Smackdown night at the club usually isn’t packed, but it was packed last Thursday due to Michaels’s appearance. Michaels told the fans he was one of the key people responsible for the WWF reaching the heights it has. After getting an ovation he walked out, he told everyone he never gets tired of that. He said if anyone wanted to know what his future was in the WWF, “ask management because I don’t even have the keys to the door anymore.” Michaels actually did once have keys to Titan Towers. He signed autographs for a long line of people and shook hands with everyone.

Jan 19th 2002

There is serious consideration being given to having Shawn Michaels be part of the NWO/DX angle as an active wrestler. He met with McMahon several weeks back, which was why he hosted WWF Excess that same weekend. Talks have gone well and the WWF believes mixing Michaels (an original DX member) with Nash, Hall, and perhaps Hogan could create a new synergy that hasn’t been seen before. There is no talk at this stage of former NWO and DX member Sean Waltman to be part of the angle, although he could be a late addition. He is healthy and ready to return to the scene any time

Mar 16th 2002

Shawn Michaels was backstage at Smackdown last week in San Antonio, Tex. Although there were no major scenes, he apparently acted in a way that cemented that nobody will be going to bat for him anytime soon. He is not expected to be a last-second addition to WrestleMania. With ratings being as disappointing as they have been, the fact that they haven’t gone to Michaels as a way to inject some additional star-power into the angle shows how little the WWF management team currently thinks of Michaels. Friends of Michaels say they would be shocked if he would have even agreed to wrestle at WrestleMania if asked. Michaels is concerned about living up to his past in–ring reputation and has told friends he wants to know what his physical limitations are before wrestling a televised match


r/TheDirtsheets • • Nov 04 '15

(Part 2) The Montreal Screwjob complete Meltzer write up. Wrestling Observer [November 17, 1997]

105 Upvotes

Note: I might have to post 2 of these per day (rough life) due to the overwhelming size of Meltzers write up. Im posting parts 2 & 3 today and we haven't even gotten to the match yet :(


November 1, 1997 - Hart had until midnight to make up his mind. He called McMahon and told him about the WCW offer and said that he wasn't asking for anymore money to stay, but that he wanted to know what his future in the WWF would be over his next two years as an active wrestler and that at this point he was leaning toward accepting the WCW offer. McMahon said he'd think about it and call him back in one hour with some scenarios. Before McMahon called back, Bischoff called again trying to solidify the deal. McMahon ended up calling back four hours later from his barber shop in Manhattan and told Hart that he didn't know what he was going to do with him but to trust his judgement because of their past relationship, that he had many him into a superstar and that he wanted him to stay and that he should trust him and asked Hart to give him ideas of where he wanted to go. During the conversation, McMahon still brought up the scenario of wanting Hart to drop the title in Montreal, but promised that he would get it back in Springfield. "I realized he had given the top heel spot to Shawn, but to turn back babyface, it was too soon," Hart said. Like in the negotiations one year earlier, it was going down to the wire and he had until midnight to make up his mind. When he was talking to McMahon, McMahon told him he could extend his deadline for giving notice. Hart asked for the permission in writing but McMahon told him that he was going out to a movie that night with his wife and said that he was verbally giving permission to extend it and to get written permission from the company's Chief Financial Officer. When Hart called to get the written notice, he wasn't given it because he was told he couldn't get it in writing on such short notice. At 7 p.m. Bischoff called again and presented a deal that, according to Hart, "would have been insane not to be taken." At that point Hart was really having mixed emotions. He somehow felt bad about leaving the WWF and was just hoping McMahon would lay out a good set of scenarios for him and convince him to stay. At 9 p.m., McMahon called and, reversing fields once again, urged him to take the WCW offer. Hart told him that his heart was with the company and it would break is heart to leave, and that he appreciated everything McMahon and the company had done for him. McMahon told Hart that he wanted him back as a babyface, and had been wanting him to turn babyface for two or three months but just hadn't brought it up until this point. He then presented a scenario to Hart, presenting it as a way to get Hart to stay, but obviously designed to get Hart to take the WCW offer. He wanted Michaels to win the title in Montreal. For Springfield, they would do a Final Four match with he, Michaels, Undertaker and Ken Shamrock, that Michaels would again win. At the Royal Rumble, the two would have a ladder match, which Michaels would win. On Raw on 1/19 in Fresno, CA, Hart would open the show and say that if he couldn't beat Michaels and win the title that night, that he would retire from wrestling, and in that match he would regain the title. And then in Boston at Wrestlemania, he'd drop the title to Austin. Hart looked at that scenario of four major losses with only one win and before his midnight deadline, gave official notice to the WWF and signed the contract WCW had sent over, with the agreement from all three parties that the word wouldn't leak out until 11/10 to protect the Survivor Series PPV. Hart went so far as to have his few confidants sign written confidentiality letters to make sure the word of his negotiations and signing with WCW didn't get out until 11/10.

November 2, 1997 - Hart and McMahon started a very amicable conversation with the pressure finally off and the decision for Hart to leave having been made. He again suggested that Michaels win the title in Montreal, and in what will go down as perhaps the ultimate irony, said they could do a screw-job ending to steal the title from him, and that the next night on Raw, McMahon suggested the two get into a mock argument where Hart would punch him, blaming him for the screw job. McMahon even suggested to hardway him (give him a hard punch that would either open him up or at least give him a noticeable black eye) to make it look legit. Hart again refused to do the job in Montreal, saying that he had never refused to do a job but he wasn't going to lose on Sunday or Monday (at the Raw tapings in Ottawa). He agreed to put Michaels over in Madison Square Garden on 11/15, Springfield, or anywhere else, and said he'd put over Vader, Shamrock, Mankind, Undertaker or even Steve Lombardi (who earned a title shot at MSG by winning a Battle Royal at the last show, but they dropped that idea almost immediately but there had been talk of giving Lombardi the match after all). McMahon then made legal threats to Hart if he wouldn't lose in Montreal. Hart talked about the clause in his contract giving him "reasonable" creative control, but McMahon claimed that refusing to drop the title in Montreal wasn't reasonable. The two argued about the finish in Montreal and the legalities of their respective positions all day Sunday and well into the night before finally agreeing to do a DQ finish in Montreal. Then in Springfield, in the final four match, Michaels would win the title. Bret would then go out on Raw on 12/8 in Portland, ME and give a farewell interview as a babyface to WWF fans and put the company and McMahon over as big as possible. He would apologize to the American fans and try to reasonably explain his actions as a way to end his 14-year association with the WWF on the highest note possible, something largely unheard of in pro wrestling, so that all parties and the fans could come out of it and his legacy with the company with a good feeling. Technically there was a problem, in that his WCW contract began on 12/1, so Hart called Bischoff, who when presented the scenario, agreed to allow him to work through 12/8 with Titan. Hart asked an associate who monitors news for him if he thought it was possible to keep the secret from the public until 11/10. Hart specifically asked about being able to keep it secret from one person until after the show, and the associate laughed and said they would bet a million dollars that person already knew.

November 4, 1997 - McMahon called Hart and said that he had changed his mind. He suggested now that Michaels should lose clean in Montreal, then he'd "steal" the title with a controversial finish in Springfield and Hart would get to do his farewell speech in Portland. He said he was going to call Michaels and present the scenario to him. By this point, word that Hart had signed with WCW had actually been reported the previous night on the Observer and Torch hotlines, and it was only about one hour later before the folks who call those hotlines for much of their news started breaking the latest "biggest story in the history of wrestling" as their "exclusives." In response, WWF Canada released a press statement originally totally denying the story, claiming it was simply propaganda being spread by WCW. However, as the word got out, Titan Sports in Connecticut a few hours later contradicted that story saying simply that Bret Hart was exploring all his options, but not going any farther, with the feeling that they wanted to protect the PPV show. Hart wouldn't publicly talk to anyone.

November 5, 1997 - The Internet had paved the way for stories in the Calgary Sun, the Toronto Sun and one line in the Montreal Gazette in a PPV preview story about Steve Austin, a line which resulted in the paper getting an incredible switchboard-blowing response of phone calls. McMahon called Hart and said that Michaels had agreed to the previous days' scenario, but that now he had changed his mind. He said the news was out everywhere and that Bret had to drop the belt before Monday because he couldn't have Bischoff go on television on 11/10 and announce the signing of his world champion while he still had the belt. Hart said that he would get Bischoff to postpone the announcement, but with Bischoff on a hunting trip all week in Wyoming, Hart couldn't get a hold of him. McMahon then asked Hart to drop the title on 11/8 at the house show in Detroit. Hart again refused, feeling the way everything had been built up, he wanted the match with Michaels, which in the wake of all the insider publicity was building up a life of its own like no match in the recent history of wrestling, to not come off as anti-climactic and for that to happen he needed to go into Montreal as the champion. He said that he would drop the title any time after 11/12, suggesting he'd do it at the house shows in Youngstown, OH on 11/13, Pittsburgh on 11/14 or in Madison Square Garden if they wanted it that soon rather than waiting for 12/7. Jim Ross, on the company's 900 line, acknowledged the statement that Hart was exploring other options, said that nobody knows the real story, and in hyping the big match, tossed in the phrase they'd be pushing in the final days leading up to the match--it will be their first meeting in 18 months, and most likely the final match between the two ever.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Nov 04 '15

(Part 3) The Montreal Screwjob complete Meltzer write up. Wrestling Observer [November 17, 1997]

98 Upvotes

Note: I might have to post 2 of these per day (rough life) due to the overwhelming size of Meltzers write up. Im posting parts 2 & 3 today and we haven't even gotten to the match yet :(


November 6, 1997 - In a story in the Toronto Sun, Tiger Ali Singh, at a press conference promoting the WWF house show the next night in Toronto said of Hart's leaving, "It's very disheartening. He's not only been a mentor, but I've been a great admirer of him since I was a kid. And if he leaves, you're going to see a whole bunch of other people leaving. And I'm not going to mention any names but WCW has been approaching a lot of people."

November 7, 1997 - There is no question that the power of on-line services when it comes to influence of pro wrestling was established this past week. It was generally portrayed that it was a power struggle between Hart and Michaels, that Michaels had won out, and to a lesser extent Hart was leaving over the direction of the product. While there was some truth to all of this, probably the greatest truth of all is it was simply a manipulation by McMahon to get out of a contract that in hindsight he wished he'd never offered. Whether Michaels, who the wrestlers feel has McMahon's ear right now and has convinced him that what turned around WCW is Kevin Nash and Scott Hall, and not Hulk Hogan and Roddy Piper, and that he should and the company should do what they did to get WCW over. There is also feeling among WWF wrestlers that Michaels pushed McMahon in that direction to rid the company of his hated rival who had apparently one-upped him when signing the new deal that made him so much higher paid. Maybe it was simply economic because the company is in financial straights. Hart did have a lot of problems over the direction of the company and his own decision was partially made based on that, but it's clear, in hindsight, that McMahon had a strong hand in manipulating Hart's decision to get out of the contract. In the vast majority opinion on- line from people who really had no clue as to what was really going on, Titan, McMahon and Michaels were coming off as major heels. The WWF's own on-line site, said to be the domain of young kids with no clue about wrestling, was besieged with the reports about Hart leaving and the so- called marks were reacting very negatively toward Titan to the point Titan pulled all its folders by the early afternoon, which caused another outcry of censorship of opinions from wrestling fans. Finally, McMahon responded publicly on-line with a letter of his own, stating, "Over the past few days I have read certain comments on the Internet concerning Bret Hart and his "alleged" reasons for wanting to pursue other avenues than the World Wrestling Federation to earn his livelihood. While I respect the "opinions" of others, as owner of the World Wrestling Federation I felt that it was time to set the record straight. As it has been reported recently on line, part of Bret Hart's decision to pursue other options is "allegedly due to his concern with the "direction" of the World Wrestling Federation. Whereby each and every individual is entitles to his, or her, opinion, i take great offense when the issue of the direction of the World Wrestling Federation is raised.

In this age of sports-entertainment, the World Wrestling Federation REFUSES to insult its audience in terms of "Baby Faces" and "Heels." In 1997, how many people do you truly know who are strictly "good" guys or "bad" guys? World Wrestling Federation programming reflects more of a reality-based product in which life, as well as World Wrestling Federation superstars, are portrayed as they truly are--in shades of gray...not black or white. From what I am reading, it has been reported that Bret may be concerned about the morality issues in the World Wrestling Federation. Questionable language. Questionable gestures. Questionable sexuality. Questionable racial issues. Questionable? All of the issues mentioned above are issues that every human being must deal with every day of their lives. Also, with that in mind, please be aware that Bret Hart had been cautioned--on "numerous" occasions--to alter his language, by not using expletives or God's name in wain. He was also told--on numerous occasions--not to use certain hand gestures some might find offensive. My point is: regardless of what some are reporting, Bet's decision to pursue other career options IS NOT genuinely a Shawn Michaels direction issue, as they would like you to believe! In the personification of DeGeneration X, Shawn Michaels' character is EXPECTED to be living on the edge--which, I might add, Mr. Michaels portrays extremely well. The issue here is that the "direction" of the World Wrestling Federation is not determined by Shawn Michaels, OR Bret Hart for that matter. It is determined by you--the fans of the World Wrestling Federation! You DEMAND a more sophisticated approach! You DEMAND to be intellectually challenged! You DEMAND a product with ATTITUDE, and as owner of this company--it is my responsibility to give you exactly what you want! Personally, I regret the animosity that has built up between Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart, but in the end, it is the World Wrestling Federation that is solely responsible for the content of this product--NOT Bret Hart--NOT Shawn Michaels--NOT Vince McMahon, for that matter. May the best man win at the Survivor Series! . That only made the situation worse in regard to how fans were viewing McMahon and the company even worse. "You demand to be intellectually challenged?" By doing racial angles. The fans chose that direction? They asked to see Michaels pull his pants down and jump up and down on television? Hart was booked for his first public appearance before the house show that night at the Sky Dome in Toronto. It was on a half-hour TSN (The Sports Network, the Canadian version of ESPN) talk show called "Off The Record." Host Michael Landsberg opened the show saying the show had received more than 1,000 calls to ask Hart if he was leaving for WCW. Despite the word being out everywhere by this point, Hart would only go so far as to say that he had given his 30 day notice to the WWF, that he's reviewing offers from both groups and is strongly leaning going one way. "I'd like to really come more clean on it than I can, you know, than I have, but I have to do this thing by the book kind of thing." Hart categorized the split as not being a money issue but said that he and the WWF had "reached kind of a crisis or we've reached professional differences as to what direction that the wrestling shows are taking. You know, I'm not saying I'm always right, but I feel that some of the content of the shows goes against my belief in what wrestling should be, and can be." Later in the show he criticized Michaels, and then stated that "wrestling is often scoffed at as a form of entertainment sometimes, or it used to be. I believe it came way up, and I was very proud in the direction, which has a lot to do with where I am right now today. Wrestling was cleaned up, and it became something families could watch..." He talked about inner workings of the business, having to trust the guy you are working with because you give them your body and said the real animosities and hatred that exists have to be set aside. He said that everything he has said about Shawn Michaels is about the Shawn Michaels character, but said that Michaels has said things that have hit a raw nerve with him to the point it's unprofessional. The show aired the footage of the Shawn Michaels interview where he blamed the Hart Foundation for trashing the NOD dressing room and insinuating that Hart was a racist. Hart said that he doesn't blame Michaels for that. "That's obviously a promotional direction, and that's a poor concept. I think that racial tension is something to be very, very careful with. When you start messing around with racial things, that I don't like." Hart said that he stopped watching Raw about five weeks earlier because he didn't like the direction, and agreed when the host brought up Michaels calling him the Grand Wizard (a KKK reference, not a reference to a famous wrestling manager of the 70s), and then brought up what Michaels said about his father that he didn't see. "You know, I don't mind if someone pokes fun at my dad. Jerry Lawler's made a living the last two or three years saying comments about my mom and dad, but he's always fairly humorous about it. Actually I used to get offended at some of the things he used to say about my mother... until I realized that my mother thought they were humorous, and then it was kind of OK with me." He then spoke at length about Brian Pillman. By this point, in certain circles and particularly within the industry, interest in the match on Sunday due to all the uncertainty, some of which was known and most of which actually wasn't, had reached a level not seen in years. For all of Hart and McMahon's wanting to keep the story quiet, word getting out was the greatest thing for the buy rate. There were 14,374 fans paying $296,674 at Sky Dome that night for the show. To credit the huge house to the interest in Canada since Hart leaving had been reported in the local newspapers would be incorrect, as WWF officials a week before the event had figured on a crowd of 15,000. Obviously some fans knew, and there were chants of "You sold out" directed at Hart. Although this should have been expected, and Hart has been a pro wrestler for 21 years and been around the business a lot longer than that, the chants in his home country knowing what he was going through did get to him. The main event was a six-man tag with Undertaker & Mankind & Austin vs. Bret & Smith & Neidhart, subbing for brother Owen who was supposed to start back but still wasn't ready to return after a severe concussion from a few weeks earlier. Bret was asked to do the job for the stone cold stunner, debated the question for a while, then refused, figuring he was the only Canadian in the main event in the U.S. vs. Canada type match with the big nationalistic angle, and Austin ended up using the stunner on Neidhart instead.

November 8, 1997 - The WWF ran a house show in Detroit at Cobo Arena for what would turn out to be Bret Hart's final match in the United States as a wrestler for the World Wrestling Federation. Tensions were really high and the prospects of a double-cross were looming by this time in many of the more paranoid types. By really, this was 1997, and this was the World Wrestling Federation. That's stuff from the 20s when the real bad guy low-lifes were running the business. The days of making Lou Thesz world champion because you needed someone who could handle himself in the case of a double-cross had been over for more than three decades. That day, Hart went to the one member of the front office he knew he could trust, Earl Hebner. While there are what you call a lot of good acquaintances in the business, Hart and Hebner were genuine close friends for years. Hart said he'd use his influence to get Hebner to referee the match because he wanted someone in the ring that he could trust. Hebner said he understood the situation, and told Hart, "I swear on my kids lives that I'd quit my job before double-crossing you." On a personal basis a little more than 24 hours later, remembrance of that conversation crushed him more than anything. At about the same time, the WWF braintrust was in Montreal one day early. Vince McMahon held a meeting at the hotel with Jim Ross, Jim Cornette, Pat Patterson and Michaels. Reports are that at least two of the aforementioned names looked extremely uncomfortable leaving the meeting. Ross, on the WWF 900 line, filed a report saying due to the tension between Hart and Michaels that there would be armed security backstage and the two would dress as far apart from each other as possible. That was a total work since Michaels and Hart actually dressed together and were on professional terms the next afternoon. He also said that McMahon was not going to announce the show, and instead would be handling any last minute problems backstage. Ross also hinted that it could be Hart's final match in the World Wrestling Federation, something Hart at that point wasn't aware of.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Nov 05 '15

(Part 4) The Montreal Screwjob complete Meltzer write up. The day before, and the Match. Wrestling Observer [November 17, 1997]

95 Upvotes

NOVEMBER 9, 1997 The Prelude - Imagine going into the most anticipated match on the inside of pro wrestling in years and on the day of the show, not having any semblance of a finish? McMahon and Hart met that afternoon and McMahon said something to the effect of, "What do you want to do? You've got me by the balls." Hart said that he just wants to leave the building with his head up. Hart said to McMahon, "Let me hand you the belt on Raw (the next night in Ottawa). Everyone knows I'm leaving. I'd like to tell the truth on Raw Monday." At this point the "truth" wouldn't include talking about finances, contract breaches, arguments about finishes or anything that would make McMahon or the company look bad publicly. McMahon said he agreed, that it was the right thing to do and the two shook hands on it. Hart and Michaels were dressing together putting together a match. Both were professional with one another and talking about putting on the best match possible in Hart's last hurrah, agreeing to a DQ finish in about 17:00 after a lengthy brawl before the bell wound even sound to start the match. As they were putting their spots together, Patterson came in. He had a suggestion for a high spot in the match as a false finish. There would be a referee bump. Michaels would put Hart in his own sharpshooter. Hart would reverse the hold. Hebner would still be down at this point and not see Michaels tap out. Hart would release the hold to revive Hebner. Michaels would hit him when he turned around with the sweet chin music. A second ref, Mike Ciota, would haul ass to the ring and begin the count. A few paces behind, Owen Hart and Smith, and possibly Neidhart as well, would run down to the ring. Ciota would count 1-2, and whomever got to the ring first, likely Owen, would drag Ciota out of the ring. While they think they've saved the day on the pin on Bret, suddenly Hebner would recover, 1-2, and Bret would kick out. That would set the pace for about five more minutes of near falls before it would end up in a disqualification ending. Before the show started, both Vader, with his Japanese experience, and Smith, told Hart to watch himself. He was warned not to lay down and not to allow himself to be put in a compromising position. He was told to kick out at one, not two, and not to allow himself into any submission holds. Hart recognized the possibility of the situation, but his thoughts regarding a double-cross were more along with lines of always protecting himself in case Michaels tried to hit him with a sucker punch when he left himself open. The idea that being put in a submission or one of the near falls while working spots would be dangerous for him would be something to worry about normally, but he put it out of his mind because he had Hebner in the ring as the referee.


The match: People on the inside were watching this as close as on the outside. Would Bret do the job? Would Shawn do the job? Would Bret give Shawn a real beating before putting him over? The Molson Center was packed with more than 20,000 rabid fans, who up to that point had seen a largely lackluster undercard. While the fear going in about the word getting out of Hart leaving hurting the PPV most likely turned out to be just the opposite, the sellout was not indicative of that either as it was well known by the advance that the show was going to sellout one or two days early. It appeared that about 10 to 20 percent of the crowd knew Hart was leaving, and there were negative signs regarding his decision, and negative signs toward the promotion for picking Michaels above him or the direction that seemingly forced him to leave. Some things were also strange, and not just the absence of McMahon from the broadcast. Hart, the champion in the main event, wasn't scheduled for an interview building up the match. When his name was announced early in the show, there were many boos from fans who knew he signed with the opposition. Once he got in the ring for the introductions, Michaels wiped his butt, blew his nose and then picked his nose with the Canadian flag. He then put the flag on the ground and began humping it. Hart was immediately established as the babyface. The two began the match as a brawl all around ringside and into the stands. The crowd was so rabid that it appeared there was genuine danger they'd attack Michaels. At one point, they were brawling near the entrance, knocking down refs as planned, knocking down Patterson, as planned, and as planned, Hart and McMahon had an argument almost teasing the idea of a spot later in the match where Hart would deck McMahon. But it was also clear that everything going on was 100% professional and the only curiosity left at that point was how good the match was going to be (it appeared to be very good) and how would they get "out" of the match (with something nobody will ever forget). But one thing was strange. Why were so many agents circling the ring, and why was McMahon right there, and acting so intense? About eight minutes before the show was "supposed" to end, Bruce Prichard, in the "Gorilla" position (kind of the on-deck circle for the wrestlers) was screaming in his headset that we need more security at the ring. Why? They had already done the brawl in the crowd. The finish was going to be a DQ and it was still several minutes away.


The double-cross: Hart climbed the top rope for a double sledge on Michaels. Michaels pulled Hebner in the way and Hart crashed on him. Just as planned. Michaels for a split second, looked at McMahon and put Hart in the sharpshooter, just as planned. The next split seconds were the story. Ciota, listening to his headpiece for his cue to run-in, heard the backstage director scream to Hebner that it was time to get up. Hebner, listening himself, immediately got up. Ciota started screaming that he wasn't supposed to get up. Owen Hart and Smith, readying their run in, were equally perplexed seeing him get up. Prichard was freaking out backstage saying that wasn't supposed to happen. Bret, still not realizing anything was wrong, laid in the hold for a only a few seconds to build up some heat before doing the reversal. Michaels cinched down hard on the hold, glanced at Hebner and then looked away, which more than one wrestler in the promotion upon viewing the tape saw as the proof he was in on it, but then fed Bret his leg for the reversal. Hebner quickly looked at the timekeeper and screamed "ring the bell." At the same moment, McMahon, sitting next to the timekeeper, elbowed him hard and screamed "ring the fuckin bell." The bell rang at about the same moment Bret grabbed the leg for the reversal and Michaels fell down on his face on the mat. Michaels' music played immediately and was immediately announced as the winner and new champion. Hebner sprinted out of the ring on the other side, into the dressing room, through the dressing room, and into an awaiting car in the parking lot that already had the motor running and was going to take him to the hotel, where he'd be rushed out of town with his ticket home, instead of staying to work the two Raw tapings. Michaels and Hart both leaped to their feet looking equally mad, cursing in McMahon's direction and glaring at him. Hart spit right in McMahon's face. The cameras immediately pulled away from Hart and to Michaels. Vince screamed at Michaels to "pick the fin belt up and get the f out of there." Michaels, still looking mad, was ordered to the back by Jerry Brisco who told him to hold the belt up high and get to the back. The show abruptly went off the air about four minutes early.


The aftermath: The officials left the ring immediately. McMahon went into his private office in the building with Patterson and a few others, and locked the door behind him. Hart, in the ring, flipped out on the realization of what happened, and began smashing the television monitors left behind until Owen, Smith and Neidhart hit the ring to calm him down. The four had an animated discussion in the ring, all looking perturbed. Finally, Hart thanked the fans, who for the most part left with the air let out of their sails, gave the "I love you" sign to the fans, and finger painted "WCW" to all four corners of the ring, which got a surprisingly big pop, and went back to the dressing room. He first confronted Michaels, who swore that he had nothing to do with it. Michaels, obviously afraid Hart would punch him out right there, told Hart that he gets heat for everything that happens but this time it wasn't his fault and he was as mad as Hart about the finish. He said he didn't want to win the belt that way, was disgusted by what happened, and to prove it, would refuse to bring the belt out or say anything bad about Hart on Raw the next night. Hart said that Michaels could prove whether he was in on it or not by his actions on television the next night. The entire dressing room was furious at McMahon by this point. The feeling was that if Hart, having worked for the company for 14 years and not missing shots due to injuries the entire time, and having made McMahon millions of dollars throughout the years, could get double-crossed this bad, then how could any of them trust anything he would say or do? People were saying that how could anyone trust anyone ever again, and that it was an unsafe working environment.


For three years, after the steroid trial and all the bad publicity, McMahon had worked feverishly to change his legacy in the industry as not the man who ran all the other promoters out of business, not the man who marketed pro wrestling to young children while pushing steroid freaks, not the man who tried to destroy wrestling history and create his own, not his worked Harvard MBA, worked billion dollar company, a man who was so vain as to give himself a huge award in Madison Square Garden as "the genius who created Wrestlemania," not the man who at one time tried to monopolize every aspect of the business for himself, but instead as a working man's hero, coming from humble beginnings, fighting those ruthless rich regional promoters and through nothing but guts, guile and vision, became the dominant force in the industry and taking it to a new level. And now, against all odds, the generous friend trying to help all the small regional promoters, acknowledging the past history of the business, fighting against Billionaire Ted, the man who was stealing all his self- made creations while wasting his stockholders money because of some alleged petty vendetta because the WWF would never be for sale, stealing his patented idea of Monday night wrestling, was hanging in there and would outlast his enemy again and somehow in the end come out on top. Three years of a facade, that was largely working to a new generation of wrestling fans who saw him as their underdog hero. The man who to a generation that didn't know better, created pro wrestling, Hulk Hogan and localized interviews and rose this grimy little industry from carnival tents to major non-smoking arenas and who was the friendly face in the Father Flanagan collar who every Monday night epitomized the world of pro wrestling, was flushed down the commode. Even though he was so good at hiding who the old Vince McMahon was to the point only those who had dealt with him for many years remembered about not letting your guard down, when the pressure was on, the old Vince returned. Only this time, it was in a situation where those who didn't "know" him were truly "introduced" to him for the first time.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Sep 11 '15

The Dirt sheets:New ownership and new content!

91 Upvotes

Long story short I used to lurk here for a long time and eventually became frustrated with the lack of new content.

My idea is to run a few 'Series" instead of random articles to get content flowing again, feel free to up vote or leave me a line if your enjoying this subreddit getting pushed again.

First two series I will be running will be articles based on:

The end of an era, the Death of WCW and ECW. Part 1, ECW Hanging on by a thread?

The return of Shawn Michael's.

Part 1

Part 2

Part 3

I have a few more ideas for series but I will roll with the first one first. Thanks in advance!


r/TheDirtsheets • • Nov 07 '15

(Final part) Aftermath of Montreal screwjob, Undertaker, Hebner respond. Walkout of Raw planned as well as many superstars talking to WCW about jumping ship. Wrestling Observer [Nov 17 1997]

82 Upvotes

Undertaker was furious, pounding on his locked door, and when he came out to talk with him, Undertaker told him in no uncertain terms that he needed to apologize to Hart. He went to Hart's dressing room, where Hart had just come out of the shower. Smith answered the door and Hart said he didn't want to see him. Vince and son Shane McMahon came in with Sgt. Slaughter and Brisco anyway. Vince started to apologize, saying that he had to do it because he couldn't take the chance of Hart going to WCW without giving back the belt and he couldn't let Bischoff go on television the next night and announce Hart was coming while he was still his champion and said how it would kill his business. Hart shot back that he had no problem losing the belt and told McMahon that he was going to dry off and get his clothes on and told McMahon, "If you're still here, I'm going to punch you out." Hart called McMahon a liar and a piece of shit, and talked about having worked for him for 14 years, only missing two shots the entire time, and being a role model for the company and the industry and this was his payback. McMahon tried to say that in 14 years, this was the first time he'd ever lied to him and Hart rattled off 15 lies over the last year alone without even thinking about it. Those in the dressing room watching were stunned listening to Hart rattle them off, and McMahon not offering a comeback. Hart got dressed and twice told McMahon to get out. Hart got up, and a scuffle started, with them locking up like in a wrestling match, Hart breaking free, and throwing a punch to the jaw that would have knocked down a rhino. One punch KO in 40 seconds. McMahon growled like he was going to get up, but he had no legs. Shane McMahon jumped on Hart's back, and Smith jumped on Shane's back pulling him off. Not realizing there would be trouble, Smith had already taken off his knee brace, and hyperextended his knee in the process of pulling Shane off. Hart nearly broke his hand from the punch. McMahon's jaw was thought to be fractured or broken. Hart asked Vince if he was now going to screw him on all the money he owes him and a groggy Vince said "No." He told Shane and Brisco to get that "piece of shit" out of here and glaring at both of them, told them if they tried anything, they'd suffer the same result. In dragging McMahon out, someone accidentally stepped on his ankle injuring it as well.


And later: Hebner, at the hotel and on his way out of town, was confronted by one of the wrestlers who asked how he could do that to one of his best friends. Hebner claimed ignorance and swore that he knew nothing about it and was so mad about it he was going to quit. Jack Lanza, likely as part of another facade, was begging him not to. Patterson, Michaels and Prichard all denied any knowledge to the boys. Everyone denied it, but it was clear everyone had to know, from the production truck to go off the air several minutes early, to the director to get the shot perfect of the sharpshooter where you couldn't see Bret's face not quit, to Hebner in particular, to the ring announcer to get the announcement so quickly, so the man handling the music to have Michaels music all cued up, to all the agents, who were surrounding the ring knowing the possibility of something unpredictable happening. When Hart got back to his hotel room in a total daze, he was furious at McMahon because he knew he was screaming at the timekeeper to ring the bell but almost recognizing it as a reality of a business that he should have known better than anyone. But when he had a tape of the finish played to him, he clearly heard that it was Hebner's voice screaming "ring the bell" and at that point was personally crushed. Phone lines were ringing off the hook around wrestling-land that night. People closest to the inside of the business were thinking double-cross, although the big question was whether Michaels, since he looked so pissed at the finish, was in on it. Some more skeptical types, remembering Brian Pillman and Kevin Sullivan, thought it because of the prominence of the match and the interest, that it had to be a very well acted work. Virtually all the wrestlers backstage thought it was a double-cross, but a few, not wanting to be marks, were wary of fully committing to the idea. Some people who were close to inside thought it was the greatest worked finish in the history of wrestling, because it got everyone talking. Others, particularly people who had casual fans watching with them, or those attending the show live, saw how the finish to a casual fan came off looking so badly, thought it was either a poorly conceived angle that was well acted by a company trying too hard to fool smart fans; or maybe a double-cross. But by the morning the true story had become obvious.


November 10, 1997 - When the wrestlers fully realized what had happened, Hart turned into almost a cult hero, and McMahon's image took an incredible tumble. Hart himself remarked that while he had his problems with McMahon in the late 80s, that when Phil Mushnick wrote all those scathing articles about him during the 90s, he defended McMahon, even though he deep down knew most of what was written about him to be true. According to two WWF wrestlers, roughly 95 percent of the wrestlers in the company were planning on boycotting the Raw taping later that night over what happened. With more curiosity than anything in recent memory, the WWF drew its strongest Raw rating since the early days of the Monday Night War--a 3.39 rating and 5.16 share--largely due to curiosity stemming from the publicity, the match, and from the announcement about Hart earlier in the event on WCW--and amidst all the chaos and confusion, presented one of its all-time worst shows. Nitro did a phenomenal 4.33 rating and 6.39 share. Michaels opened the show. Yes, he was carrying the belt. And what did he say about Hart? He said he beat the man in his own country with his own hold and that he ran him out of the WWF to be with all the other dinosaurs down South. And said that the few down there who weren't dinosaurs are his good friends and some day they'd kick his ass too. Those who were on the fence on the Michaels issue waiting for his interview to prove himself were given their final answer. McMahon never showed his face on camera. The fight with Hart was never acknowledged in the commentary, although Michaels couldn't resist in his interview saying how Hart beat up a 52-year-old man after the show. In the commentary, nobody tried to bury Hart, but Ross, who had never used this figure before, on both Sunday and Monday used the phrase 21-year-veteran, perhaps as subtle acknowledgement of Hart's age, and Lawler did bring up the $3 million per year figure, as a way to encourage the mindless "You sold out" chants. It was acknowledged that it was Hart's final match in the WWF although the reasons for it being the case were never even hinted at. The replay was pushed harder than ever, and why not, since it was the most bizarre finish in modern wrestling history, complete with a commercial clearly showing Hart spitting in McMahon's face, and destroying the monitors which took place after the show itself had gone off the air. The show dragged on, and the efforts to push the new stars, Mero as a heel, Goldust back as a heel, Interrogator, Blackjack Bradshaw and Road Dog & Billy Gunn, all came off lame. You could almost hear the crowd groan when it was Rocky Maivia positioned as the next challenger for Steve Austin's IC title. With all the special effects, the Kane gimmick still came across as a sure winner. And Ken Shamrock was thrust into the spotlight as Michaels' first challenger on 12/7 after all. However, there was another screw up. Shamrock's main event with Helmsley was supposed to end with Michaels interfering and then Shamrock pinning him and the ref counting to three, perhaps to take heat off Michaels rep for not doing jobs, and perhaps as a way to convince Shamrock to return the favor for such an unpopular wrestler on PPV. However, the show went off the air with Shamrock down apparently being pinned after Michaels nailed him with the briefcase, however he kicked out just as the show went off the air. The crowd in Ottawa, largely pro-Hart, finally figured out about 15 minutes before the show was going off the air, that none of the Hart Foundation was there, and that the Bret Hart situation was no angle. The Shamrock-Helmsley main event heat was non-existent, drowned out by vehement chants of "We Want Bret." Ross went on his hotline and did nothing but praise Hart for all his work, even to the point of saying that he himself, being right there, never heard a submission but that the referee claimed that he heard it.

November 11, 1997 - The Calgary Sun ran an article about the double- cross, reporting that Hart's leaving for WCW was actually requested by the WWF due to the WWF claiming financial hardships.

And where does it go from here: It's hard to make sense out of all that happened. While Hart's contract with the WWF was much higher than anyone else's, to dismiss him as being paid above market value is missing a potential valuable point. What is the Canadian wresting market worth? Far more than $1.5 million per year. At the Calgary Stampede PPV show alone, the market was worth about $400,000 on PPV and another $200,000 in live gate, granted those are Canadian money and he was being paid in American money, but you get the drift. While WWF had lost its foothold in the United States to WCW, it owned Canada. WCW, with TBS getting moved from premium cable to basic cable nationwide, and with TSN picking up Nitro every week, was for the first time getting strong television exposure in the country. No matter what he did or didn't mean elsewhere, and there is no denying he was a major draw in the United States, and probably more so in Europe, Germany in particular, he was the wrestling star in Canada. Handing him to the opposition will mean from a Canadian standpoint, every bit as much as Hulk Hogan joining with WCW, and we've all seen what the long-term effects of that turned out to be. It's hard to ascertain fan reaction. Fans are more loyal these days to brand names than ever before, more than to wrestlers themselves. When, in a similar situation only he didn't get into the ring and was fired before "not" doing the job, Ric Flair came out of a situation with Jim Herd in 1991 recognized by most fans as the real world champion, the WCW belt became largely meaningless, Flair went to WWF and did big business in what were never called unification matches but many thought of them as such against Hulk Hogan. For nearly two years, before Flair returned as the cult hero, the small crowds attending WCW matches never stopped the "We Want Flair" chants. There are similarities here, and if anything, times being different mean more people than ever will be aware of it, making similar chants perhaps more likely. But a lot of the newer fans also for the most part have less respect for the wrestlers as people and more as animals to perform stunts to entertain them, like in other sports, have more loyalties to the "home team" than its players who come and go for the biggest buck. And while everyone will put their different spin on what happened, and like with Hogan, and Bruno, and nearly every other superstar of the WWF beforehand, Bret Hart failed one of the things he wanted most out of his career, and that was to walk away from the company without the bitterness and with mainly good memories. Both Bret Hart and Vince McMahon wanted their legacies to be tied together and represent all that can be good about pro wrestling. But the fact it is, no matter how great the match with Smith at Wembley Stadium or at the In Your House in Hershey were, or the Wrestlemania match and SummerSlam matches with Owen were, or the SummerSlam match with Hennig, or the Survivor Series match with Michaels, or any of the rest, his legacy, and Vince McMahon's legacy will forever be tied together in wrestling history. The defining moment of both a Hall of Fame wrestler and the man who for a decade was the dominant promoter in the industry will be the moment that the world realized, right in front of their eyes, with no apologies, and with no turning back to re-write history, just how truly deceitful, to the core this business can be, and just how much 14 years of being one of the great performers in the history of the industry truly meant on the inside to the company that benefitted from it. Only the future can determine whether this was a defining moment in the balance of business when it comes to pro wrestling. Did McMahon really hand over the keys to Canada to WCW? Will fans really hate McMahon four weeks later when Michaels headlines a PPV show with a four star match? Will Hart be a huge success keeping WCW at its current level, or even taking them to an even higher level by having main events on PPV shows that can live up to the quality of the preliminary matches? Or are his best years really behind him and McMahon will have the last laugh at how much Bischoff paid for him? How long will Hart remain a cult hero to the wrestlers for doing what none of them had the guts to do and all at one time want to do? Will McMahon file criminal charges for assault? And will, someday, and stranger things have happened although in this case it would be hard today to believe it as possible, will the two get back together in a few years for a final triumphant run?


r/TheDirtsheets • • Oct 12 '15

[Part 1] Chyna's WWE departure [Apr-Jul 2001]

66 Upvotes

Note: I dug through 2000, and early 2001 to find anything that may have been simmering about the Chyna/HHH/Steph saga early but i was unable to find anything in my log of F4W/Observer or PWTorch's. Is this one of those stories that only broke AFTER it had went down? Interesting none-the less, if anyone out there is smarter than me knows let me know.


[Apr 17, 2001]

The WWF broke off negotiations with Joanie Lauer (Chyna) after they were unable to come close to meeting her terms. Lauer is under contract with WWFE until Nov. 30, although she likely has already topped her downside guarantee and may not receive any more money between now and then. WWFE management says that Lauer demanded a downside guarantee on par with Triple H, Steve Austin, and The Rock. Friends of Lauer confirm that story. Lauer had exhibited signs of an inflated ego during her recent book tour and her makeover from a she-male who wrestled men to a more feminine image after her Playboy shoot. Her contract demands, though, surprised management, who saw her as a role player, not a main eventer on the level of Triple H, Rock, or Austin. Her perception of herself was different; she felt she was being taken advantage of so she gave WWFE management an ultimatum last week. WWFE responded by ending negotiations and issuing a statement on WWF.com stating the break in their relationship with her. Lauer had a number of other factors working against her during her contract renewal talks that had extended over the past few months. For one, her out-of-ring relationship with Triple H came to an end. Second, she was no longer represented by agent Barry Bloom and had in fact filed a lawsuit against him. Bloom represents Triple H, X-Pac, Chris Jericho, Goldberg, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, and Jesse Ventura. Also, she had no negotiating leverage without WCW as a fallback option. Lauer was also very upset at WWFE officials for pulling Playboy’s offer for a second photo spread right away. WWF officials, during the tense negotiations, refused Playboy’s offer, saying they believed it was too soon to feature her again.

[June 9, 2001]

Sources say Chyna not appearing on TV has nothing to do with the news surfacing of Steph and Triple H’s off–camera relationship

[June 30, 2001]

The WWF hasn’t decided what it’s going to do with the women’s title that Chyna officially holds, but it’s not considered a high priority. Although Chyna may return to the WWF some day if the two sides can reconcile, given the tension that exists right now, it probably won’t be anytime this year

[July 11,2001]

Chyna made her first public appearance since the WWF announced that it will not renew her contract once it expires in November. Chyna appeared on a New York UPN affiliate’s newscast that followed the July 6 Smackdown. Chyna told the reporter that Vince McMahon has a monopoly on pro wrestling and added, “I think that’s going to change contract negotiations for a lot of people.” Chyna also stated her intention of moving on to Hollywood as an actress. She said she would like to appear in “Terminator 3” or another Arnold Schwarzenegger movie

[July 19, 2001]

During a July 19 conference call with the media, Jim Ross said no decision has been made regarding the vacant WWF Women’s Title. From a storyline standpoint, the title technically belongs to Chyna, whose contract will not be renewed once it expires in November. Ross said there are no hard feelings between WWF management and Chyna: “It just came to the point that what she and her representatives felt she needed to be at for her to be comfortable… we just couldn’t get there. It just wasn’t in the cards.” Meanwhile, Ross said he would not rule out the idea of Chyna working for the WWF again in the future


r/TheDirtsheets • • Apr 26 '16

JUNE 16, 1997 WRESTLING OBSERVER NEWSLETTER: HBK/Bret backstage fight

64 Upvotes

Heat from fantasy feuds and storylines in this attempted shoot environment spilled out into real life dressing room problems for both the WWF and WCW on 6/9 involving four of the country's biggest name wrestlers, Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, Roddy Piper and Kevin Nash. The end result were no serious injuries, but Michaels' future with the WWF is questionable.

The problems in the WWF were more spectacular, with an incident that took place at approximate 7:20 p.m. in Michaels' dressing room resulting in both Hart and Michaels not appearing on the live show from Hartford, CT that they were originally both supposed to play a prominent role in.

All the problems had been brewing for a long time, in the case of Michaels and Hart, for well over one year as has been well documented in these pages. Although skeptics could try and label both incidents, since they involved wrestlers who have bitter feuds in the storyline as promotions and wrestlers attempting to work the boys in doing angles for the hardcores ala the Brian Pillman-Kevin Sullivan angle which in many ways changed the entire face of pro wrestling and not necessarily for the better, in case of the WWF situation, that was absolutely not the case and is more likely than not also not the case with the WCW situation.

The problems between Hart and Michaels, bad seemingly forever based on professional jealousy based on who would be the top star and highest paid wrestler in the company and who would put the other over in their next meeting and if they ever would have a next meeting, some of which has become ironic since in their personal battle, Steve Austin and probably Undertaker as well passed them both by when it comes to being the top star although not the highest paid. They got hot in recent weeks when Michaels believed that Hart stalled out a live interview on Raw to where the show went off the air before Michaels could do his superkick comeback, which was shown on tape later in the week. As revenge of sorts, Michaels said that Bret had been seeing "Sunny days" on the next week's television show despite both Michaels and Hart supposedly having been told by management to quit doing insider references that the majority of the viewing audience doesn't understand. That remark, combined with a remark made months ago by Michaels on television saying that Bret professes to be a role model but he's seen him on the road and he's no role model, apparently caused friction in Bret's personal life to the point that Hart had been telling friends for weeks that he was going to at some point soon punch Michaels out. Nobody, including Michaels, would debate that should Hart have chosen to start a fight with Michaels that Michaels would come out of it unscathed. But a lot of people didn't believe he'd do it since Hart has the reputation for being such a professional, not to mention that with his knee in the shape it's in, this would be a foolish time for him to do so. Nevertheless the rumors throughout the WWF locker room were that if Hart got the chance, he'd take a poke at Michaels.

Apparently the problems escalated before the show on 6/9 as both were meeting in long personal conversations with Vince McMahon, to the point that McMahon was having little time to converse with anyone else regarding details and attention to the ensuing live television show. Hart wound up going into Michaels dressing room and the two began arguing. There were eye witnesses to this which basically said they argued and started fighting, and it was rather quickly broken up. Most versions have it that Hart was screaming about how Michaels comments affected his personal life and he crossed the line and that Michaels was a smart-ass back. The two went at it, with most versions having it that Hart started it but that Michaels was every bit as guilty in precipitating it. It was believed to have been a one-sided short tussle which resulted in a few punches thrown and a large clump of Michaels' hair being pulled out of his head to the point it was described that Michaels was given a major bald spot. Michaels face was all puffed up from the punches and he was bleeding from the elbow, apparently from being thrown on the floor. Hart apparently aggravated his recently repaired knee, but none of the injuries were serious. Agents Jerry Brisco and Pat Patterson and some other wrestlers quickly broke it up with Hart on top of Michaels pounding on him, and Brisco and Hart argued loudly back-and-forth in another room for a long time before Hart finally left the arena at about 8:30 p.m. without appearing on the television show. Michaels was blown up from the fight and a little worse for wear, but not injured to the point he couldn't have appeared on the television show. Michaels was scheduled to wrestle Brian Pillman in the television main event, doing the run-in after the Hart Foundation were all scheduled to jump Austin as he was coming down the aisle for the match. The Austin vs. Pillman match that had been hyped all week was canceled because Austin injured his right knee (the good one) by landing wrong on it coming off the top rope during a spot in the previous night's match with Michaels. The knee was swollen badly to the point they decided to keep him out of the ring on 6/9 although he was willing to gut out doing the match, because they didn't want him being hurt any worse and with all the other problems, add Austin to the list of guys who would be missing the upcoming weekend's major shows in Montreal and Toronto. Michaels was going crazy after the predicament and said that he would never work against anyone in the Hart Foundation because he couldn't trust them. He ended up walking out of the building claiming that he couldn't work or stay in this kind of an environment just before the show was scheduled to go on the air at 7:57 p.m.

Other performers claim as he left the building that he was screaming about how he was quitting and that if he could make it to Boston (where Nitro was being done live) on time he'd just as soon go there. At that point the entire television show had to be scrapped and a new show put together literally minutes before it went on the air. The main changes involved doing three angles with Ken Shamrock to put him into the mix as Shamrock will be put in Michaels' spot in the ten man tag team main event at the next PPV on 7/6, the Canadian Stampede. Shamrock teams with Sid, Austin and the Legion of Doom against Bret, Owen, Davey Boy Smith, Jim Neidhart and Pillman. Mankind was then made the replacement for Austin in Pillman's first major television match, but the match totally fell flat because there wasn't much to it, it was a major letdown with all the hype of Austin vs. Pillman both on television all week and throughout the live television show airing clips of the ankle breaking angle, the breaking into Pillman's house angle and Austin sticking Pillman's head in the toilet bowl the previous night. In addition, Mankind isn't over as a babyface at this point the way everyone expected he would be and Pillman is limited in what he can do in the ring with his ankle still in tremendous pain.

Exactly how this affects other schedule matches is unclear, although almost all of Michaels scheduled house show matches involved members of the Hart Foundation including a first meeting with Bret in a triangle match scheduled for the 6/28 head-to-head showdown in Anaheim/Los Angeles which at press time barring a reconciliation will now be changed. If Michaels won't work with the Hart Foundation, it'll make it extremely difficult to use him in an effective manner since they are the lead heels and his most natural program is with Bret. On the live show, Vince McMahon did address the situation saying late in the show that both men had been sent home from the arena due to conduct unbecoming a professional. Jim Ross acknowledged the incident on the WWF hotline calling it a fistfight and not going into anymore details other than making it clear it was not an angle, that Michaels had walked out of the WWF, that he didn't know what the results of it would be but acted like he wasn't sure of the future of the WWF tag team championship with Michaels & Austin as a team and that a decision about it would be made this week.

On 6/10, McMahon sent an internal memo out to WWF executives saying, "Last night in Hartford, Shawn Michaels breached his contract by refusing to perform. We are hopeful Shawn will reconsider his position and return to work. Shawn has four years to go on his five-year contract. The door is open for Shawn to return under the terms of his contract." By virtue of that memo, at press time it would have to be concluded that unless a reconciliation takes place, that for the time being Michaels won't be appearing on the house shows advertised or future television shows but there are no official replacements matches aside from the change in Calgary since the incident had just taken place.

What happens next should Michaels not return is a really tricky situation. If he doesn't perform, Michaels could and likely would be suspended without pay. The question becomes can Titan theoretically if things don't work out, suspend him for four years without pay. Would they continue to pay him his downside guarantee, believed to be close to $15,000 per week, for not working to keep them from breaching his contract and enabling him to go to WCW? Would they give him a limited release allowing him to work elsewhere in the world besides WCW, which is where he says he wants to go? Or could Michaels use the fight and other incidents in the past such as when he was given a scare by the Harris Brothers (who were on their way out at the time but eventually brought back) in the dressing room at Madison Square Garden and try to claim an unsafe working environment as a way to claim he should be legally let out of his contract to go to WCW, where he claims he wants to be.

Michaels and his father had a meeting at McMahon's request on 5/18 to air out their problems, at which time Michaels told McMahon that he wanted out of his contract to go to WCW and McMahon claimed Michaels told him that if he went to WCW, "I could be set for life." McMahon refused to let him out of his contract. That statement about being set for life brings yet another question to mind, that of potential contractual interference by WCW, a charge that has been made whenever major stars under contract to either ECW or WWF have jumped to WCW and has been claimed by WWF in the Curt Hennig case. Reports that Michaels had a clause in his contract that guaranteed him being the highest paid wrestler in the company turned out to not be true, however Michaels has claimed he and McMahon had a verbal deal on such when he signed his contract. Since that time Hart signed a far more lucrative 20-year deal with McMahon since he was the subject of a bidding war. Michaels also claimed to friends that McMahon told him that if he was ever unhappy in the WWF that he would be free to go. McMahon did make that promise to Ric Flair years ago and allowed Flair to return to WCW in 1993 despite having time left on his contract, but the situations were far different then as compared with now and others close to the situation are skeptical of the latter story if only because the whole reason McMahon has broken his longstanding business practices by signing every major wrestler in the company to guaranteed money long-term contracts is so he can keep them from going to WCW.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Apr 17 '16

Smackdown Politics and Cena’s Ascension, can John Cena overcome the backstage politics killing Smackdown's momentum? PWTorch [Nov 29, 2003]

63 Upvotes

No the sub is not dead, Ive just been crazy busy the last couple weeks starting at the beginning of April (Was in Dallas for Mania and have been playing catchup in life ever since.) Got a few more in the bank for this week, thanks everyone!


Leo Tolstoy once wrote that every happy family is the same, but each unhappy family is unhappy in its own special way. He wasn’t talking about pro wrestling locker rooms, but he could have been.

WWE wrestlers used to wish for a transfer from Raw to Smackdown, or maybe even to NWA–TNA. By all accounts, the Smackdown locker room is a different locker room than it was several months ago. At that time, Raw was floundering as Triple H and his friends stole the focus of the program away from everyone else, while Smackdown was built around Brock Lesnar and Kurt Angle.

Now, as we rapidly approach the end of the year, the mood has changed in all three locker rooms. WWE Raw, which used to be the play toy of Triple H, is wide open now that Hunter is a part–time movie star. Morale is awful in NWA–TNA. More of the wrestlers have realized that the entire promotion is a vehicle to get Jeff Jarrett over as a major league superstar. But at least Jeff Jarrett is an actual wrestler. Smackdown is its own special case. Two weeks ago at Survivor Series, Vince McMahon made it apparent that Smackdown is WWE’s secondary brand. Goldberg’s match with Triple H was the main event of Survivor Series, just as the Raw World Title match headlined SummerSlam, which was the previous joint pay–per–view.

There were only three Smackdown matches on the Survivor Series pay–per–view, and the most prominent of those matches saw the 58 year old leader of the company defeat former four–time World Champion The Undertaker. In previous months, we have seen Mr. McMahon award himself pay–per–view victories over non–entities Zach Gowen and Stephanie McMahon, while using lots and lots of television time to build up those matches.

Smackdown has become Vince McMahon’s own form of bizarre televised therapy. Before that, it was the vehicle for Stephanie McMahon–Levesque to push herself as a network television star. You would think that the crew of wrestlers would be so disgusted with their crazed superiors that they would form a sort of bond. You definitely wouldn’t think they’d turn on each other. And you’d be wrong.

The whispers have already started about how Brock Lesnar and Kurt Angle have assumed the leadership role on Smackdown from Undertaker. Taker has had injury problems of his own over the past year or so. It is not surprising that the power has shifted down one level to Lesnar and Angle. The two top amateur wrestlers in World Wrestling Entertainment were on in the final match of Wrestlemania XIX. Both of them obviously have the confidence of the WWE front office. They have had three high–profile matches in 2003, all of which are potential North American Match of the Year candidates. Both of them have worked through serious injuries in the past twelve months. In fact, the WWE champion is reportedly putting off knee surgery in order to keep his schedule.

Nobody is questioning the toughness, the talent or the qualifications of Lesnar and Angle. But, whether it’s fair or not, there are WWE performers who blame Angle and Lesnar for holding down wrestlers on Smackdown. Rey Mysterio, Jr. hasn’t become a crossover superstar the way many fans thought he was going to when he entered World Wrestling Entertainment. It looked as though Eddie Guerrero might get an opportunity to become a main event babyface for the company, but his turn hasn’t worked out the way the creative team had hoped it would. Chris Benoit is renowned for his ability to carry mediocre workers to good workers, and he and Kurt Angle stole the show at the 2003 Royal Rumble. We keep hearing about how Benoit is going to get his main event run down the line, but it hasn’t actually happened.

With Kurt Angle out again due to injury, and Undertaker off selling the effects of his Buried Alive loss at Survivor Series, that leaves an opening for someone to wrestle WWE champion Brock Lesnar at the upcoming Royal Rumble. This presents a perfect opportunity for fresh rapper babyface John Cena to step up to the plate. Sure, Cena wrestled Lesnar several months ago at Backlash, but he was a heel then and no one can remember back that far.

Cena’s move to the fan fa vorite side has gone reasonably well. Since Cena was getting a positive reaction from fans as a heel, he shouldn’t have to change much in order to keep the fans. Cena’s freestyle trash–talking prematch raps are still there. It probably was a mistake to have Cena attack Chris Benoit after their tag team match on Smackdown a couple of weeks ago, but that never made it to air. Yet Michael Hayes had the right instinct; John Cena isn’t going to become a major superstar by shaking hands and kissing babies. The fans are enjoying his cocky persona and his dollar store Slim Shady gimmick, so he should keep doing what works. Cena’s got the muscular white bread look that Vince McMahon digs, and it’s a look that the boss is going to push as hard as he possibly can. Cena is being programmed against McMahon and Lesnar. If recent history is any indication, a McMahon vs. Cena match could happen as soon as the No Way Out pay–per–view in February. So what’s standing in the way of Cena’s rise to superstardom? Not Vince McMahon. Probably not Brock Lesnar or Kurt Angle. Heck, if Cena can get over, he’s a potential big money opponent for the twin terrors of the amateur circuit.

What’s standing in the way of John Cena is the same problem that has plagued World Wrestling Entertainment and the McMahons for years. We’ll call it the Law of Unintended Consequences. The truth is, nobody can predict exactly how wrestling fans will react to a given match, angle, or wrestler. In an area where kayfabe lies bleeding in our hands, the tried and true methods of getting a new top superstar over don’t cut it any more.

If you doubt this, cast your mind back to “Stone Cold” Steve Austin’s beginning in the World Wrestling Federation. Austin arrived at the beginning of 1996 and became another cog in Ted DiBiase’s Million Dollar Corporation. Stone Cold’s victory in the King of the Ring tournament in 1996 was done as a punishment to Triple H for his role in Kevin Nash’s impromptu farewell ceremony at the Madison Square Garden house show. Austin’s coronation speech wasn’t supposed to be a big deal. The previous year, Mabel’s crowning as King of the Ring was a goofy non–event. But fans took to the “Austin 3:16” line like Islam in the desert. Go back and look at the tapes of the October 1996 “Buried Alive” show, or the 1997 Royal Rumble. WWF diehards were behind the Rattlesnake for at least six to eight months before Austin officially turned babyface.

The Rock was the son of Rocky Johnson, and was marked for superstardom before he ever wrestled a WWF match. Rocky’s glad–handing good guy persona was met with scorn after he debuted in November 1996. When The Rock won the Intercontinental Title in February 1997, the New York fans were so sick of having the newcomer shoved down their throats that they chanted “Die, Rocky, Die.” Rock was written out due to injury in the spring of 1997 and returned months later as an evil enforcer for the Nation of Domination. But the People’s Champ then had to struggle to keep the fans from turning him into a babyface. Rocky has even faced that problem recently. The fans hated him at WrestleMania 18 and SummerSlam 2002, but cheered him when he was supposed to be drawing heat at the evil foil for Bill “Whisker Biscuits” Goldberg.

What about Triple H? The World Wrestling Federation spent years trying to get Mr. Levesque over as a snooty New England blueblood. Then, as the Attitude era began, The Game got the big promotion. The night after WrestleMania XIV, Hunter went from being Shawn Michaels’s sidekick to being the evil usurper who grabbed the Heartbreak Kid’s spot as the head of the WWF’s top heel faction. Instead of booing Triple H and paving the way for Michaels’s eventual glorious return, the fans quickly got behind him and made him into one of the company’s strongest babyfaces before he was sidelined with injuries later that year. It wasn’t until 1999 that Hunter and Chyna were able to turn bad and gets audiences to boo them.

Don’t take any of this as an indictment of John Cena. Cena has a lot of things going for him, including his unique charisma and his outstanding facial expressions. He has plenty to work on, but all of his shortcomings can be fixed. Cena will probably be a major player in the promotion for years to come. But whatever happens to him won’t be dictated by the brilliant WWE storylines. In the end, Cena’s rise to stardom will depend on his ability to adapt when the fans don’t react the way they’re supposed to.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Sep 14 '15

[Part 3] Shawn Michaels headlining Backlash 2001, backstage actions result in being sent home. PWTorch [Apr 7/14, 2001]

57 Upvotes

Part 1

Part 2

March 31, 2001

Shawn Michaels made his first backstage appearance at a WWF event in a long time at Raw on Monday and managed to get under the skin of a number of people in a short span of time. He conducted himself in such a way that it was clear many of his past problems are as prominent today as in the past. He is scheduled to headline the Apr. 30 Judgment Day PPV based on an angle at or right after WrestleMania. His conduct at Raw may jeopardize those plans. He wasn’t scheduled to be on Raw; his attendance at Raw backstage was meant to be a chance for him to reorient himself to the locker room and prepare for his on-air role beginning next week. The WWF extended Michaels’s contract in anticipation of him working at WrestleMania. Michaels vetoed that plan, saying he wouldn’t be ready to return at WM, and the WWF extended his contract anyway. In retrospect, especially with the acquisition of WCW, there was no urgency in extending his contract.

April 7, 2001

Shawn Michaels walked out of the Smackdown tapings last week after a dispute with management. As reported last week, WWF management wasn’t pleased with Michaels’s conduct at Raw the night before. When they talked to him about his situation the next day, a confrontation resulted and Michaels left early. Michaels had been scheduled to return to TV this week either at WrestleMania or Raw or Smackdown to be part of an angle that would lead to his in-ring return at the Apr. 29 Backlash PPV (perhaps teaming with Triple H against Undertaker & Kane), but those plans appear to be erased as a result of the happenings last week

April 14, 2001

All plans for use of Shawn Michaels have been cancelled indefinitely due to his conduct his first two days back on the road. Two weeks ago Michaels showed up at Raw and immediately made it apparent to everyone through his appearance and conduct that his problems of the past were also problems of the present. Among other more serious problems, he also managed to upset a number of people with what were described as “unnecessary digs” and “smart ass” comments. “He was being a dick to everyone,” says one WWF wrestler. “It’s that simple.” The next day he took a nap shortly after arriving at the arena for Smackdown, sleeping with his cap coveirng his face. When he woke up, he met with Vince McMahon and Jim Ross. During that meeting he was asked to leave. Michaels did leave without creating a big scene. He appeared to be surprised by management’s request and took a “sorry you feel that way” approach to the situation. Sources say now Michaels will in essence be given a choice—shape up in terms of his attitude and get help for his other problems or he won’t be back. In other words, it would likely be at least another month or so before management would even considering bringing Michaels back.

Wrestlers also say there is a lot of tension between Shawn Michaels and Triple H. Sources say Michaels blames Triple H for WWF officials asking him to leave the Mar. 27 Smackdown tapings. Michaels is accusing Triple H of bad–mouthing him to management following the previous night’s Raw taping. Triple H is denying the allegations, but is also said to be disappointed that Michaels showed up in no condition to work. Michaels complained about Triple H “not sticking up for him.” He tried to get Hunter to go to Vince and straighten things out—in other words, use his clout to get management to overlook his problems. Triple H said he would go with Michaels to meet with Vince, but Michaels told Hunter that only he (Hunter) could get Vince to see his way


r/TheDirtsheets • • Sep 11 '15

Michael's returning to WWF? PWTorch [Jan 06/13, 2001]

55 Upvotes

PWTORCH [Jan 6, 2001]

•Although it’s far from a confirmed done deal, there are strong indications Shawn Michaels will be returning to the ring at WrestleMania. There are even indications that he will be wrestling more than just one “finale” match, but may be physically capable and interested in a part-time return. Friends say that he is training as if preparing for a return to the ring. The most likely match at WrestleMania for him would be against Triple H. Both Rock and Steve Austin have dismissed any particular interest in wrestling Michaels, while Triple H remains his friend. Apparently Michaels’s back condition would allow him to return for more than just one sendoff match. In essence, says one friend of his, “He's been waiting on the sidelines until there was a place for him. He wanted to be asked back, and his ego can't handle not being a top star if it happens.” Hours after we first reported the potential of a Michaels return on PWTorch.com, Jim Ross updated his “Ross Report” with the following regarding Michaels: “I expect to speak with Shawn Michaels soon about his future in the World Wrestling Federation, and the possibility of performing in another match, or perhaps more in 2001,” he wrote.

PWTorch [Jan 13, 2001] By Wade Keller, Torch editor

Shawn Michaels is negotiating with the WWF for what would essentially be a full-time return to the WWF. He would only wrestle occasionally, but he would be a constant presence on television and PPV. He also may be a regular presence at house shows. Michaels’s contract expires in July, and the WWF knows that if they don’t reach an agreement with him, it’s possible if not likely that a competing group would make an offer, especially if Eric Bischoff has a role in WCW decisions. The WWF does not want to invest TV time in Michaels until he makes a long-term commitment to the WWF. Michaels was once the top player in the industry, winning the Torch MVP Reader Balloting in 1995 and 1996. He won Torch Best Wrestler Balloting in 1995, ’96, and ’97. He finished in the top three in that category in 1994 and ’93. But his incredible bumps and unrelenting schedule as WWF Champion took its toll. Eventually the back pain he felt became too excruciating to continue. He struggled to get through his final WWF match at WrestleMania against Steve Austin, and after completing it, considered back surgery. He is now recovered as much as he will ever be, and the door is open physically for him to attempt a return. While Michaels made a good living as WWF Champion, he didn’t come close to making what Steve Austin and The Rock have made the past two or three years. He probably didn’t earn in his best year half of what Triple H earned last year. He still has wrestling in his blood and a desire to cash in if possible.

Jim Ross met with Shawn Michaels and his attorney on Dec. 30 in San Antonio, Tex. The meeting went well from all accounts, including Shawn Michaels who posted a message about his status on his website last week. Michaels positioned himself as somebody completely fulfilled professionally and only interested in being a good husband and father. Could be true, but it could also be contractual positioning. It’s in the WWF’s interest to make Michaels feel wanted, but not needed. It’s in Michaels’s best interest to make it seem as if he doesn’t need the WWF, and that it will take a lot of money to pull him away from his time with his family. “I've done it and have absolutely no desire to do it again,” Michaels wrote. “I for one don’t want that kind of demand on my time. In the immortal words of Al Snow, pin me, pay me.” Those who know Michaels would say he’s not being entirely forthright; he does have interest in returning (for both the money and fame) and in the past he hasn’t been thrilled about doing jobs. In fact, record books show that most of his injuries came up just before he was scheduled to do a high profile job to lose a title. In fact, his attitude is a major concern of WWF management and wrestlers. The WWF is an entirely different place compared to when Michaels was running the ship three or four years ago. But Michaels wants people to believe he is different, too. Regarding his critics, he wrote: “First of all, they have known me and they are going on an idea of theirs about a reputation that is three years old. Three years is a long time, kids.” The working idea right now is for Michaels to return for one match at WrestleMania with two options coming out of it: (a) he finds out his back can’t handle the stress and he doesn’t wrestle again; (b) his back holds up well and he begins training regularly in anticipation of wrestling a combination of singles and tag matches totalling roughly between 2-6 per year. Michaels needs to be rebuilt. At this moment he isn’t considered a major star by the majority of the WWF’s viewers who know him only as a glassy- eyed ex-commissioner who couldn’t keep his train of thought during recent on-air appearances. Before the WWF invests any TV time in getting Michaels over as a major star, they want a commitment from him. But the problem is, neither party knows what Michaels can deliver. Michaels, though, is willing to wrestle one more time if the legal matters can get worked out. The two sides have to work through a complicated negotiation that ends with Michaels getting a downside guarantee that he is happy with, but with strong incentives built in should he be able to become a regular in-ring performer. If Michaels could wrestle regularly, the WWF would make him a full-time on-air character. He might become a player-coach and work with some of the younger wrestlers on air. For instance, he could take Jeff Hardy or Edge under his wing, tagging with him occasionally, and eventually feuding with him. In the end, he could create a new star by passing the torch by jobbing to him. Given that five or ten years of a full–time ring schedule is out of the question for Michaels, the WWF’s best use of him will be (a) utilizing him in occasional big- money matches and (b) using him to establish new stars. The more Michaels is willing to mentor younger stars in positive ways and eventually do what is necessary to elevate them (job to them), the more valuable he is to the WWF. If Michaels brings baggage with him, either in terms of his own personal habits or in terms of the attitude he instills in some of the younger wrestlers who looked up to him growing up, he’s a detriment to them. Michaels has been made aware of the changes in the WWF locker room, and multiple sources insist that he would be watched closely. He’d be under a microscope and if he showed signs of immaturity and arrogance (which he implies is a “three-year old rep”—but doesn’t deny was true at the time), he would be ostracized quickly. If the WWF invested in a sizable downside contract, though, they would end up having to pay him just to sit at home and avoid contaminating the strong locker room. Another concern is that if Michaels is pushed as a top star yet can’t work a full-time house show schedule, and The Rock continues to find demands on his time outside of wrestling taking him away from house shows, then arena events may begin to seem second-rate. The WWF likes its top star on TV to also appear at house shows. Michaels, though, would likely appear at many house shows in some capacity even if he didn’t actually wrestle according to current scenarios being discussed. There are a number of major issues to be worked out, but both sides seem ripe to work out a deal that would ultimately lead to Michaels returning for a match at WrestleMania. Although the most obvious match for Michaels would be against former DXer and protege Triple H, the Triple H vs. Austin match may be saved for WrestleMania. However, a WM co-headlined by Rock vs. Austin and Triple H vs. Michaels doesn’t look so bad on paper if promoted well.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Oct 18 '15

Austin walks out on Raw, Austin buried by McMahon, Rock and Ross on WWE TV, PWTorch [June 17, 23 2002]

54 Upvotes

June 17th 2003, Raw Report

•Before Raw on Monday afternoon, Steve Austin went home against management’s wishes for the second time this year. WWE management had proposed to Austin on Sunday that he wrestle Brock Lesnar on Raw. Austin apparently didn’t like the storyline as proposed and believed that they were using the equity he had spent years to build up on a hotshot match with Brock Lesnar in order to try to pop a ratings increase. He didn’t want his hard–earned equity to be used to make up for their weak storywriting in recent months. He showed up at Raw early in the afternoon, and was on his way to the airport to fly home shortly thereafter. It’s possible his departure will be more than short-term, considering that his grievances from two months ago were not, in his opinion, adequately addressed. Austin had expressed on the WWE web show Byte This two weeks ago that he thought that WWE storylines had been “piss poor” lately. McMahon agreed with those sentiments on last week’s Byte This show, and promised a huge edition of Raw this week in an attempt to begin correcting the problems. Raw was originally scripted where about 25 percent of the segments would include Austin, so the show had to be rewritten and reformatted at the last second. As a result, the Vince McMahon- Ric Flair storyline dominated the show instead. The McMahon-Flair storyline was created due to Austin’s departure since McMahon needs Flair in a babyface role to replace Austin headlining Raw crew house shows. The fact that a last second decision was made to turn Flair indicates McMahon may not be confident that Austin will be back anytime soon.


June 23, 2002 Cover Story By Wade Keller

Wrestling promoters have long made a tradition out of burying a wrestler when he left a territory on bad terms. WWE took that to a new level this past week regarding Steve Austin. “It’d be like John Wayne becoming a coward in a big fight. You never saw it happen. You’d never see it coming, and I didn’t see this coming,” said Jim Ross, Austin’s biggest ally behind the scenes as well as on camera over the years. Ross’s comments were part of over 30 minutes of WWE Confidential dedicated to Austin’s fallout with WWE. “He took his ball and went home and obviously I'm pissed off,” said Vince McMahon. “I think this was the single most selfish act that Steve Williams, Stone Cold Steve Austin, could have ever done in World Wrestling Entertainment.”

A combination of professional frustrations and mounting personal demons has led to Steve Austin’s departure from WWE. The events that played out over the past couple of weeks might be considered too bizarre for a work of fiction, especially once McMahon was done putting his surreal spin on the situation. The burial of Austin on WWE programming this past weekend starting on Confidential and culminating in The Rock’s promo on Raw on Monday is unprecedented in wrestling. The burial of Bret Hart by Vince McMahon for not following a “time–honored tradition” and “doing the right thing” by doing a job to Shawn Michaels at Survivor Series ’97, at that time, was the most revealing any promoter had been on the air about a departed wrestler. Bill Watts, Gene Okerlund, Gordon Solie, Wally Karbo, Eric Bischoff, and others had buried departed wrestlers in previous decades, but never did they reveal the extent of their side in as much detail as McMahon did regarding Bret Hart. The details revealed about the Austin situation took it to a new level.

McMahon explained how he heard about Austin’s latest beef. “I received call at about 10:30 p.m. on Sunday night from Jim Ross telling me that Steve Austin wasn’t happy with the creative planned for Raw on Monday. I immediately called Austin’s cell phone and told him no matter what hour it was when he got this message to call me. So at about 2 o’clock in the morning he called me. So that began my Monday. I went through the entire creative process with him and explained to him how this was good for him and good for the company. He said all right. Not that I need his approval, but it’s important for a talent to buy into what it is you’re trying to do because they feel better about it if they’re part of the creative process. That’s what I tried to do and thought I had done.” Austin’s gripes can be summarized rather simply: Austin had been upset with the creative direction of WWE for months. He felt his concerns weren’t being adequately addressed despite repeated attempts on his part. He felt he had given Vince McMahon enough chances to fix what was wrong. He was fed up and decided to go home without any notice. He felt being asked to do a job to Brock Lesnar on the June 10 Raw was akin to him giving up years of hard work building his credibility just to partake in a hastily thrown together hotshot angle that was conceived to make “piss poor” scriptwriters save face for an extra week. He didn’t want any part of it. When he felt games were being played by people with differing agendas, he went home. “There’s going to be a lot of things written, half the crap you read is wrong,” Ross said on Confidential. “Didn’t want to do this, didn’t want to do that. People with active imaginations who to try to stir crap. The bottom line is he has some issues that maybe some day will be revealed, will be explored by the public, because that’s what the public wants. That’s why I’m doing this interview now, people want to know.”

Ross, surely referring to Austin’s growing personal demons outside the ring, noticed by wrestlers who saw his infamous mood swings grow greater than ever in recent months, admitted with those words that viewers weren’t getting the full story. WWE, though, made sure their side—or as much as they could get away with saying—was communicated. Did WWE present all of Austin’s side? They’d say, “How could we? He won’t talk to us.” True. Austin’s conduct at home helped paint WWE as the sympathetic figure. Certainly when Austin received national publicity in newspapers and even on MTV News when his wife Debra called police claiming Austin hit her over the weekend, Austin lost much of the benefit of the doubt he might have received. Austin was difficult to work with, his mood swings had gotten severe, and now he had allegedly hit his wife (who decided not to press charges). WWE could easily paint itself as the sympathetic figure. But why bother?

In the end, what matters isn’t whether the public thinks WWE is the “good guy” and Austin is the “bad guy.” What matters is whether the public still finds WWE television entertaining enough to watch every week. The focus on airing dirty laundry and attempting to control how the story is perceived publicly won’t necessarily translate into loyalty unless those who fill Austin’s TV time are at least equally entertaining. “You can’t calculate the loss of this investment for the long term,” said Vince McMahon. “He just took it and flushed it down the toilet.” McMahon, in an apparent effort to bury Austin for his actions, drew attention to his resignation that the loss of Austin will “devastate” his company. Sure, he and Ross talked about Austin’s departure opening new doors for others, but the message sent ultimately is: We are a weaker company without him. Does it matter to investors whose fault it is? Will someone hold a stock because they feel sorry for WWE? No more likely than fans watching WWE out of charity if they don’t enjoy WWE as much without Austin. Perhaps McMahon sacrificed a weekend of TV storylines in order to send a message to other wrestlers not to cross him as Austin did. To top it all off, McMahon threw his other top star, The Rock, into the middle of the mess, having Rock come out and express gratitude toward the fans for making him a star and vowing to never turn his back on them. WWE attempted to communicate to fans that while Austin may have left them, Rock never will. If Austin returns to WWE rings some day— and given the history of wrestling it’s more likely than not—this can all be spun into a storyline, perhaps a profitable one. In the mean time, though, WWE personnel and performers are concerned with how the Austin crisis has been handled, especially since McMahon has seemed preoccupied with the Austin crisis at the expense of moving forward with the tools he still has.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Sep 12 '15

[Part 2] Shawn Michaels finalizing wwf contract? Michael's headlining Wrestlemania 17 with HHH? PWTorch [Jan 20/27/Feb 17/Mar 3rd, 2001]

53 Upvotes

Michael's finalizing contract PWTorch [Jan 20, 2001]

Shawn Michaels has or will soon finalize a new contract extension which assures a long- term future in the WWF. Regarding the prospects of a Michaels return, Ross wrote last Friday in his WWF.com column: “My meeting recently with Shawn Michaels has been widely discussed on the internet. The Heartbreak Kid will definitely have an expanded role on future Federation television broadcasts but when, if, or how many actual matches he has cannot be determined until he gets the first one under his belt. No date has been set for this first match, but it is probably 3-4 months away.” With WrestleMania on Apr. 1, and Ross writing those comments on Jan. 19, that means WM is two-and- a-half months away. So Ross’s comments would indicate that a WM appearance isn’t in the cards, or if it does happen he doesn’t want to give strong indications to set up that expectation even if it is tentatively planned. The widespread belief in the WWF among the wrestlers is that Rock vs. Steve Austin will headline and Triple H vs. Shawn Michaels with get co-top-billing. Michaels is said to be extremely excited about returning, and hopeful that he can perform in the ring on a regular basis (especially since there hefty financial incentives in his new contract if he can).

PW Torch [Jan 27th, 2001]

•Shawn Michaels probably won’t wrestle at WrestleMania after all. His contract extension with the WWF is considered just a formality at this point and is expected to be wrapped up within a few weeks. Michaels will be working full–time for the WWF, but whether it is as a full–time or part–time wrestler or just as an on-air personalities (commissioner, manager, coach, announcer) depends on how his back holds up after his first return match. Michaels is going to intensively train for about three months to get ready for his return, which would put him well past WM. He may participate at WM in some form, but won’t be working in a headline match unless plans drastically change. Michaels’s back will be tested in the first match back. He will then determine whether he can wrestle more often. It’s believed there are significant incentive clauses built into the new contract if he can wrestle regularly. Michaels will probably be a TV presence for a while and be drawn into a match eventually due to a storyline, perhaps at SummerSlam. Michaels is shutting down his Texas Wrestling Alliance and his training center in anticipation of returning to the WWF full–time.

PW Torch [Feb 17, 2001]

•Shawn Michaels may have made the choice not to work WrestleMania, even though that was the original plan. Michaels vetoed the idea to have WrestleMania be his first match back because he said he feared he’d look rusty and would let his fans down. Another theory is making the rounds—Michaels didn’t want to do the job to Triple H in his first match back. Triple H, who was Michaels’s sidekick at the time Michaels retired, has risen to a status higher than Michaels ever reached. Michaels has a reputation for a fragile ego, and there are signs he isn’t interested in returning to the WWF to job to his old protege. “Michaels is one of those wrestlers who could definitely come back and have a great match right away,” says one WWF worker. Unless plans change, Michaels will not wrestle at WrestleMania, although appearing on camera in some sort of angle leading in to WrestleMania isn’t out of the question.

PW Torch [March 3rd 2001]

Will Shawn Michaels wrestle at WrestleMania? Michaels just signed a contact extension with the WWF. The WrestleMania commercial that aired on Raw showed Michaels several times; he was the only wrestler featured who hasn’t been active recently. Triple H is without an opponent for WrestleMania. Yet the WWF, Michaels, and Triple H continue to say that Michaels isn’t going to be ready to wrestle in time for WM. On his website this weekend, Michaels detailed his status. “I have not been contacted even once since I met with J.R. I signed my new contract and have heard absolutely nothing so your guesses are as good as anyone’s. My guess is no one knows what or where to put me and quite frankly, neither do I. None of the writers know me. I haven’t been around for a long time. It’s a tough situation. I think everyone should just be patient. It’s always better to have a well-thought-out plan as opposed to just being thrown out there.” He added that he is very nervous about his first wrestling match. “Being visually in shape and ring shape is very different,” he wrote. “That’s what I think I’m worried about most. I used to never blow up or get tired. Now, though, I just don’t know.” He joked that those who didn’t like him but had to admit he was a great wrestler may now be able to add that he’s a bad wrestler, too. “I’ll be a prick and a shitty wrestler,” he joked.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Nov 22 '15

(Part 1) 1 year later. Meltzer reviews new Montrael Screwjob information after Wrestling with Shadows releases. Wrestling Observer [Dec 21, 1998]

52 Upvotes

December 21 1998 Observer Newsletter

Montreal Screwjob Part 2

More than one year after the actual event took place, it appears that the U.S. air date of the "Hitman Hart: Wrestling with Shadows" hopefully, Vince McMahon willing since half his booking ideas seem to come from attempts to gain some sort of personal retribution, will finally put closure to what without question will go down as the most famous ending of a match in North American history. Bret Hart is among the leading candidates to be the pro wrestler of this decade. He's one of the best in-ring performers of this generation. Vince McMahon, is the most successful wrestling promoter ever, and from a historical standpoint is probably the most important one of all-time, although some would argue the latter point. Yet for all of Hart's great matches and all of McMahon's business accomplishments, the defining moment in both men's professional lives and possibly even what both will over the long haul most be remembered for, at least personally, is chronicled in this movie. The documentary, which aired last month in Canada, and airs from 9-11 p.m. on the A&E Network on 12/20, has gotten unanimously positive reviews from every media source in North America that has reviewed it, which is amazing given the subject of the movie is pro wrestling. Certainly that is a first for any movie on pro wrestling, or even with a theme revolving around pro wrestling. The version of the movie on television will be the "Child Friendly" videotape version, with some language edits from the original version. It was given an "A" in the 12/18 issue of Entertainment Weekly and a positive review for the movie, but not for the wrestling industry, in the current TV Guide in Phil Mushnick's "Sportsview" column and the most glowing review of all by film critic Barbara Phillips in the 12/14 Wall Street Journal.

The EW review states, "Bret Hart nails the essence of Shadows when he muses that, as phony as pro wrestling is, it's realer than people think. This artfully trenchant documentary shows how things got all too real for the grappling hero as he neared what he hoped would be a dignified retirement from the World Wrestling Federation. Turns out the league's own Dr. Evil, Vince Mcmahon, had other plans. More than that, though, it's a revealing gaze into the mechanics of the multibillion-dollar biz, and the musclemen who get ground up in its gears." Mushnick used the movie as the backdrop for noting that pro wrestling's recent success has transpired without much critical inspection by mainstream journalists, who see wrestling as largely a cartoon world, and as Mushnick writes, "so a twisted, sickening industry grows wealthy while operating with impunity." Mushnick brought up the angle of a few months back where Kaientai went to castrate Val Venis, and noted the WWF being banned from the Catholic Youth Center in Scranton, and that pro wrestling's steroid problem and sudden deaths of performers in their 20s and 30s receive comparatively little attention. Phillips, who said up until seeing this movie, she couldn't tell WCW from WWF and was not a wrestling fan, said "I was pinned to the living-room couch for the entire length of (the movie)." The review focused far more on the parts of the movie about the life of Hart growing up in a wrestling family, his relationship with his father, and Hart's take on his leaving the WWF, and actually barely touched on the movie's climax of what went on in Montreal, concluding by saying, "this is truly a knockout film." I'm sure everyone seeing this movie for the first time will come to their own conclusions of what cannot be simplified into a black and white or right vs. wrong issue, although many will choose to do so. I'm going to save my own thoughts on this subject for next week's issue, after every reader at least in the United States that wants to see how the movie turned out has that chance to see it for themselves. But it is a situation where because one side is right, doesn't necessarily make the other side wrong, or where one side is wrong, doesn't necessarily make the other side right. Or where by pointing out wrong in one side, that may be and in this case probably is totally irrelevant in justifying wrong actions on the other side.

The movie did an excellent job with the story, but it was a movie produced to be a good movie while remaining accurate, and the accuracy is overall excellent. But it is still a movie, and thus couldn't be bogged down in all the details that would confuse the general public and for that matter nearly all wrestling fans to the issues the movie itself is about. But those details are important to explaining the story as to what happened and why to those who want to know the real "Truth of November 9, 1997." Whether Titan Sports will answer back in a forum other than another year of petty booking attempts at humiliation of Hart, either by mocking the finish on nearly every show, or humiliating Owen in Canada, either in its publications, on its web site, or even on its Raw program the next night, doesn't seem certain. There are varying schools of thought as to what the company's public reaction will be. Clearly those who state the movie isn't a big deal to them haven't followed the storylines of Raw, which took an abrupt turn to mimic events of the movie, and even of that night in Montreal which ended up not in the movie, for much of the last 13 months in some form. But the mimicking picked up in a big way after McMahon had received an advanced copy of a rough version of the movie, and has continued strongly through events of this past week. There are schools of thought as to why Titan shouldn't answer back, being that the portrayal of McMahon in the movie is consistent with their storylines. But at previews, it was clear even to the general audience what in the movie was storyline and what wasn't, and only the densest wrestling fans won't be able to point out the "evil" Mr. McMac-man on television and the very real Vince McMahon in the movie that the television character derives are as different as the real person, and an actor playing a role he was born to play. Realistically, the company on television has spent the past year doing almost nothing but answering back to a degree that has been often entertaining, and at times perversely pathetic. Some of this is direct, much more in a sly manner. Hart, in media interviews promoting the movie, has stated that from what he understood, the two things that upset McMahon the most about the movie is that, unbeknownst to him, it contained a brief portion of the actual conversation where they discussed the finish hours before the match in Montreal basically proving that McMahon had agreed to a DQ finish, which Hart believes basically shows he was the one telling the truth, since McMahon originally portrayed it to everyone as Hart in their conversation that day refusing to drop the title anywhere at any time, although he clearly was not going to do that specific job. But long before the movie came out, it was common knowledge McMahon agreed to a finish and double-crossed Hart, and reluctantly even admitted on TSN's "Off the Record" by McMahon himself, but only when backed into a corner by Michael Landsberg. The other was the scene of a shaken, disheveled McMahon limping out of the locker room after coming out of the short side of a one punch knockout, which to this day he tries to categorize as his valiantly allowing Hart a "free shot" to the face, a version of what happened contradicted by nearly every eye witness to the incident. The former point in a sense was bad news for McMahon, because his personal credibility due to his portrayal of the events as Hart refusing to do business at the end to not only the rest of the employees in his company, but to the boys themselves, is shot in the movie. Even with the company flourishing, it's a trust level among the top guys, even when they get along with him, that can never fully be had. His claims were that Hart had refused to drop the title at all, as opposed to simply not wanting to do it in Canada for Michaels.

The fact, which wasn't spelled out in the movie, was both sides had already agreed before the match in Montreal where (Springfield, MA), when (December 7, 1997) and how (in a four corners match with Michaels winning) the title would change hands, even though as it turned out, neither side truly wanted it to end that way. The movie, accurately, makes it clear Hart refused to lose to Michaels in Canada and he clearly had the contractual right to do so. He still had three weeks left on his contract to drop it anywhere else. He also had an agreement from Eric Bischoff that he could work eight extra days with the WWF while on the WCW payroll starting in December, if necessary, to drop it on the next WWF PPV and give a farewell speech on Raw the next night, if a PPV show as opposed to a Raw taping or a house show was the forum McMahon wanted to change the title on. Hart, a few hours before the match in Montreal, did suggest, but did not come even close to demanding, a change in the agreed upon scenario to where he'd simply vacate the title and give a farewell speech the next night at the live Raw in Ottawa, wanting to go out as champion and do his farewell in an environment where it would be guaranteed the best possible crowd reception, all of which McMahon agreed to. However, the wheels had been in motion for McMahon's plan long before Hart came in with that suggestion.

As to why, there are several theories. Hart, and people close to him, in hindsight, believe McMahon was planning almost from the day he signed the 20-year deal, to find a way out of the contract and that he never intended to honor it. Their belief is that McMahon felt due to the timing of Hart as a free agent being the biggest star in the company, coming on the heels of Kevin Nash and Scott Hall jumping and WWF at its lowest point in history when it comes to TV ratings (even though actual live attendance wasn't bad at that point in time in 1996), that he feared Hart leaving and the public reaction to it to the degree he'd do anything to keep him. As these negotiations were going on, there were several periods where WWF higher-ups conceded the probability of Hart going to WCW, on the grounds that WWF, which at the time was operating rather deeply in debt, legitimately couldn't afford to match the WCW contract offer (a $2.8 million annual base salary for three years plus merchandising and other percentages that pushed the total to around $3 million). McMahon talked of things like loyalty and family and offered a 20-year contract to prove it. Was McMahon bitter from almost the moment he signed him for a wrestler putting him in that kind of position? Did McMahon hold a grudge when Hart wouldn't tear up the WCW contract live on Raw during his interview saying he was WWF 4 life, as requested (a decision that in hindsight was the smartest one Hart made during that entire period) and plot to ruin his career?


r/TheDirtsheets • • Oct 14 '15

Heroes of Wrestling PPV ends embarrassing PPV with Jake "The Snake" Roberts embarrassing himself, PWTorch [Oct 16,1999]

52 Upvotes

Full PPV on YT if you've never seen it.

Wouldnt advise watching it for entertainment, maybe educationally it will be entertaining though. Jakes segment is at the end.


Because of Jake Roberts’s embarrassing performance, the last hour of Sunday’s “Heroes of Wrestling” pay–per–view will be talked about for years to come. It will probably mark the last time any promoter hires Jake Roberts for a live national TV appearance. Then again, there will probably be another money–mark to come along who wants to relive his ’80s wrestling fandom by promoting a terrible old–timers’show. Before ring introductions for the semi–main event of Jake Roberts vs. Jim Neidhart, Michael St. John interviewed Roberts backstage. Roberts said when you’re in a casino, everybody thinks you should gamble. He warned Neidhart not to play cards with him because he’ll cheat. “If you’ve got 21, I’ve got 22,” Roberts said, slurring his words. “You wanna play blackjack, I’ve got two of those, too. You wanna play aces and eights, maybe I’ve got too many of those, too.” He pointed to the ground where his snake Damien rested in a bag. The cameraman pointed toward the snake. Roberts lost patience with the cameraman for not pointing the camera back at him quickly enough. As Roberts put his arm around St. John and tried to get a DDT chant started, St. John looked as though he feared for his safety.

Neidhart came to the ring as fireworks shot off. Then an out of shape Roberts followed, seeming to be concentrating hard on just remaining upright. Roberts set the snake in the bag on the ring apron, then in a strange move returned to the back. At that point, he told promoters he was willing to do the job—perhaps realizing that given the condition he was in, he owed them a concession. (Neidhart had agreed to do the job, but changed his mind that night, so a non-finish was planned.) Roberts jogged back to the ring at which point he stopped in front of a woman in the crowd. He grabbed her arms and rubbed her hands over his chest and then acted turned on. She kept a smile on her face; not everybody would have. The bell rang to start the match, but Neidhart immediately bailed out and paced around the ring to fill time. With the risk of serious injury, who would want to put their body on the line against a wrestler in the condition of Roberts? At the one minute mark Neidhart went to an armlock. Roberts appeared to be telling Neidhart the new finish of the match, or else just calling spots. After three more minutes of armbars and stalling, Roberts pulled out the snake. He put it between his legs and stroked it as if he were masturbating. That’s going further than even Val Venis would. The director cut to a crowd shot. Jake lay on the mat and licked the snake’s mouth and tongue.

At the six minute mark, King Kong Bundy made his way to the ring. Neidhart then went into a two minute headlock. Jake came back with a short–arm clothesline and signalled for the DDT. Bundy then interfered in the match. Yokozuna then walked to the ring to even the odds and the main event singles match between Bundy and Yokozuna turned into a tag match. As Roberts literally collapsed to the mat, Dutch Mantel on commentary said, “I hope Jake doesn’t go to the craps table tonight.” Neidhart hit Roberts with two chairshots. Aminute later Jake just lay in the ring as Bundy and Neidhart took turns beating on him. Five minutes into the tag match Jake hot–tagged Yokozuna. Yokozuna immediately trapped Neidhart in the corner of the ring as Bundy splashed Jake in center– ring for the three count. Before the announcers could wrap up the show and thank viewers for ordering the event, the PPV abruptly cut to a black screen for a minute—a sign the promoters figured it was better to be safe than sorry. It came back on briefly with a wideshot of Yokozuna trying to help Roberts, who appeared to be nearly passed out on his back, roll out of the ring. The promoters of the event have talked about making “Heroes of Wrestling” a regular event, perhaps planning on running as many as three or four events next year if this week’s event drew around 40,000 buys nationally. The undercard was at times excruciating to watch with most of the wrestlers, not surprisingly, being terribly out of shape. As a novelty act, the event may be able to survive beyond one event, but it might be better to find former national stars who are in better shape, limit the event to two hours instead of three, and avoid wrestlers with Jake Roberts’s reputation.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Mar 13 '16

Jeff Hardy shows up "messed up" to TNA Victory Road PPV, audible called by TNA. Wrestling Observer [Mar 21 2011]

51 Upvotes

TNA VICTORY ROAD PPV POLL RESULTS

Thumbs up 3 (04.7%)

Thumbs down 51 (79.7%)

In the middle 10 (15.6%)

BEST MATCH POLL

A.J. Styles vs. Matt Hardy29

Ultimate X13

WORST MATCH POLL

Sting vs. Jeff Hardy19

Hernandez vs. Matt Morgan18


18 months ago, the most popular pro wrestler in the world was Jeff Hardy. But what happened at TNA’s Victory Road defied any explanation on more than just one level.

Hardy, 33, showed up, and according to numerous reports, messed up backstage, far worse than before. He came to the ring for the main event as a challenger to Sting’s TNA title. After a kick and a chop, Sting gave him the scorpion death drop and went for the cover. He went to kick out. Sting held him down. The ref counted three without hesitation so the ref knew what was the finish. Hardy got back up and seemed like he was asking the ref what he was doing. Sting left the ring while the crowd chanted “Bullshit” and Sting said, “I agree.”

He did this just days before his latest court case on drug possession and distribution charges. He did this only a couple of months after he was nearly stripped of the title and pulled off the Final Resolution PPV on 12/5 when the belief was he was loaded again, but he claimed he was exhausted from a tour of the Middle East and a personal appearance over the previous week. Hardy lost the title to Sting on 2/24, partially because it made for a good story, and likely that if he ended up pleading guilty to drug charges, that he would not be TNA’s current champion at the time. He was not scheduled to win this match, nor was he scheduled to be in the title picture at the Lockdown show.

The show itself was not good up to that point. There were a few good matches, but a lot of bad finishes and a flat crowd. With the title match ending the way it did, announcers Mike Tenay and Taz stretched and they did a match-by-match recap, but the show still ended about 20 minutes before a normal TNA PPV show would end.

TNA sent him home and didn’t use him on the tapings this week. They also made a decision that they would give any fan who purchased the PPV six months of free access to the company’s TNAondemand.com library as a make good. The letter posted on their web site two nights later read, “TNA Wrestling strives to give fans who purchase our pay-per-views as close to a full three-hour event as possible. This Saturday’s `TNA Victory Road’ fell short of that standard. Your support of TNA is never taken for granted. To sow you how we value that support, we would like to offer six months of free access to the TNAondemand.com library. To receive your free offer, please send us a copy of your Victory Road pay-per-view purchase receipt to: TNA OnDemand Offer, 209 10th Ave. South, #302, Nashville, TN 37203. Please be sure and submit your name, address and email address as we will be emailing a special code that will unlock over 300 hours of great TNA Wrestling action.”

If nothing else, they are the first promotion in history that put on a crappy PPV show and felt bad enough about it that they offered something to those who purchased the show.

But why did it happen? Okay, Jeff Hardy screwed up. That I get, and they took the risk by hiring him. He was the company’s biggest draw and they were pushing him as the top star for months, even after the fiasco with the Final Resolution show and with a track record that dates back years. I’d like to feel sorry for the company, and if it was somebody out of the blue, it would be one thing, but it’s someone who was fired by WWE over the belief he had problems, hired by TNA, where he missed a number of dates and was fired by them as well. Then, WWE, with that track record, hired him back, and somehow the fans willed him to be the most popular wrestler in the business. Still, problems continued, including two drug suspensions, one which pulled him out of WrestleMania. And there were other incidents that were largely ignored by WWE such as the situation at an airport where he wasn’t allowed on a plane in the morning, which should have been cause for concern. But he left on his own accord, turned down offers to keep an affiliation, and then just weeks after leaving, was arrested on a series of drug charges. TNA hired him while under indictment, and he worked there for one year.

The question is, if he was as messed up as numerous people reported, why was he sent out to wrestle? And if they thought he was okay, and then he wasn’t, why was there not a back-up plan? Why did they just not send someone, whether it be Rob Van Dam, Mr. Anderson or A.J. Styles to the ring and at least not leave the people on two straight terrible matches? I don’t know who makes decisions, but the inability to call an audible is what led to this mess. If a new match was sent out to close the show, it still may have been a bad show, but at least you would blame them for pushing a guy who had given them warning signals, but they tried to do their best. There is no viable explanation for not doing something. Nobody could be so stupid to not be able to come up with that. Anyone with half a brain cell would have come up with that in less then 20 seconds. They’d still be criticized but at least they’d put a band-aid on the problem as opposed to let the gash be infected. Why didn’t they? For that reason, the only logical explanation is that this was a work as a way to get attention. And perhaps some of it was. It’s not like we didn’t see this in WCW under both Eric Bischoff and Vince Russo’s watch in the past. It’s not like Russo didn’t book Road Warrior Hawk to pretend he was loaded in an angle while he was really loaded. It probably wasn’t a work, but at least as a work to get attention I could understand the mentality behind it. I think it’s stupid, but when your entire goal is next Thursday’s ratings, I can at least see where that could work. There is no explanation feasible if not a work. And yet, there are no indications it was.

It wouldn’t surprise me at all to see the first quarter of the 3/17 television show do a big number just based on that curiosity. Under normal circumstances, they may have done significant harm to their already weak PPV business. But for the few thousand they haven’t run off, I really wonder if they could even if they tried. And there were times on the show where it did feel like that was the show’s intent, particularly when Rob Van Dam and Mr. Anderson had a bad match with a flat double count out finish, and we were told to tune in to the free show on Thursday to find out what happens next. That felt like they were slapping everyone who bought the show in the face. And that was before the main event.

What happens next for Hardy isn’t clear. He is a draw, at least as much as anyone can be in the TNA environment. He makes the company a lot of money at house shows in the post-show autograph parties. The odds are they are trying to figure out a way to bring him back. They need to give him an ultimatum–rehab or firing. WWE did that years ago with him, and he took the firing. That alone speaks volumes. The fact that he had jobs three more times after screwing up on all three jobs due to the same issues speaks more about this profession than almost anything. And the fact WWE was pleading with him not to sign with TNA one year ago even after his arrest is also telling. And if history is any predictor, he’ll be brought back again, if not by TNA, some time down the line by WWE (although I would not expect that for a long time just because for WWE, as big a star as he would be short-term coming back, the risks are not worth it if something goes bad on their watch with all the warning signs, and the company has stated based on its drug policy that Hardy would return with his “two strikes,” meaning any drug policy issue would mean automatic termination), even if he pleads guilty. The company terminated him once for not going to rehab as requested, and he instead went to TNA, his track record there was poor, no-showing several television tapings and a PPV and no longer being used. But they still hired him back, and at the time they did, he was nowhere close to the level of star he became during that run.

And when he comes back, he’ll be over like crazy with the live audience, and then pushed to the top. And then the cycle will happen all over again.

Hardy’s spot when it came to plans for the next TVs that were already written and the next PPV that was already planned was taken by Bully Ray, who was pulled out of his feud with Devon that was scheduled for the blow-off cage match at the Lockdown show on 4/17 in Cincinnati. Of all the people to replace Hardy, they end a program cold early that was when of the best-booked they had done before the scheduled blow-off match.

Instead, the Lockdown main event will be a Lethal Lockdown with the Immortals team of Ray & Abyss (returning with a new look the day after the tournament to crown a new TV champion ended) & Matt Hardy & Ric Flair vs. Kazarian & Beer Money and a mystery partner (since they did an angle the first night of TV where A.J. Styles was “injured” after Ray gave him a power bomb off the stage through a table). Not announced at TV yet, but Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Jarrett in a cage is also on the show, as is Mickie James putting up her hair against the Knockouts title held by Madison Rayne.

The show was as poorly promoted a PPV as there has been. Most of the matches came in with almost no television push. And most of the card wasn’t even announced publicly until three days before. We don’t have any PPV estimate, but the numbers of people watching on illegal streams was tons lower than any TNA show in months. So if few people wanted to see it for free, whatever number it did on PPV is the baseline number. But luckily so few saw it because maybe half of one percent of the television viewership likely bought the show.



r/TheDirtsheets • • Oct 19 '15

Modern Dirtsheets: CM Punk walks out of Raw night after Royal Rumble 2014. Wrestling Observer [Feb 3, 2014]

51 Upvotes

Cover Story: Dave Meltzer.

The status of C.M. Punk has become a major talking point in WWE, as he told Vince McMahon about 30 minutes before the start of Raw on 1/27 in Cleveland that he was flying home, and did.

He wasn’t on the show and didn’t appear at the Smackdown tapings the next night. WWE has since pulled him off all shows, although at press time he was still being advertised for Elimination Chamber on 2/23 in Minneapolis. We’re told that he will eventually be pulled off that show as well.

It’s sketchy what happened. Over the last week, ever since Punk’s interview with Ariel Helwani before the Chicago UFC show where he openly brought up that his contract was up in July and didn’t want to say what he was going to do next, several people who know him had noted not to be surprised if he leaves. Two different people said that he was “as good as gone” in July, and one said that they didn’t expect him to even last until July.

There were frustrations with creative and with money, even though he has made great money the last several years. This was not a spur of the moment thing as much as something that had been building. The way we were told was that he couldn’t take it any longer and told McMahon that he was going home. McMahon had been tied up all day since they were rewriting the show, based on what happened the prior night at the Royal Rumble to figure out a way to keep the show under control and not have the audience hijack it again. Punk had been scheduled for an interview on the show to presumably build up a match with Kane on the PPV, which would lead to his planned WrestleMania match with HHH.

Because McMahon was so busy, Punk didn’t see him until 7:30 p.m., when he told him he was leaving. The reason the Kofi Kingston vs. Alberto Del Rio match on Raw went so long is because it came during the period laid out for Punk’s interview and had to go a second segment to cover the time, so the key “money” segments would be in their correct time slots.

The working assumption internally has been for several weeks that Punk was leaving in July and not going to sign a new deal. The belief was that he is not a spender, has saved his money and doesn’t have to work. It was a weird dynamic because he’s one of the few guys on the roster that the company and Vince McMahon knew believed he didn’t need them, and financially, really doesn’t. So they can’t deal with him from the same level as all the other guys who are scared to lose their jobs and spots.

Within the company, the reason was that he came to the realization that he would never be positioned higher than he was. His goal was to main event WrestleMania, as in be in the real main event. He felt that because he didn’t fit the mold of what they think the top star in the company should look like, he would never be the guy and the centerpiece.

It’s not known at press time what caused the situation to get to where it did and what was the straw that broke the camel’s back.Another person close to the situation who was aware it was coming, just didn’t know when, said it was a classic case of being burned out, and noted the dichotomy that he’s never had a job where he’s made anywhere close to the same amount of money, nor ever been as famous, and gotten more out of wrestling than this one. But, he has been miserable at the job for some time, and he was a guy who loved working in pro wrestling when he made nothing or very little. It was noted that he never had the personal connection with Vince McMahon that most of the big stars had, and always knew he was not their kind of guy, didn’t have the look they thought a star should have, and felt he got over in spite of how he was used and not because of how he was used. The feeling was that there was a communication issue and lingering unresolved issues that dated back some time, probably most of the last year, combined with frustration regarding creative going forward and of late.

Sheamus will be replacing Punk at all the Smackdown tapings where he was largely advertised as the main star. It is a brave new world and you can never rule out the possibility it’s a work, and you won’t know for sure unless Mania comes and goes without a return. Daniel Bryan will be advertised as the main star on Smackdown going forward since John Cena is not booked often on the Tuesday tapings.

Punk was at the Wizard World Comic Con in Portland, OR, on 1/25, as he flew form Chicago to Portland, then back to Chicago for UFC that night, and then to Pittsburgh for Rumble before leaving from Cleveland. During the Q&A, he seemed very lackluster about WWE. He basically said that he used to argue the creative but now he just shows up and does what he’s told. He pushed the idea that he felt this was Daniel Bryan’s year and knocked the short-term booking and planning several times. In many ways, this was similar to when Steve Austin left in 2002, when he publicly started complaining about creative, and a week later he was gone (of course that was precipitated by them wanting him to job to Lesnar clean with no buildup on Raw as opposed to Lesnar going through everyone to set up their first match on a major PPV).

Punk did a long interview with MMAFighting.com reporter Ariel Helwani from his home, since UFC was in Chicago. He said at the time that his contract was up in July and said there’s no point in saying anything about it. He said if he doesn’t sign, he wouldn’t say so now, and if he says he is looking at not signing, and then he does, people will think he was working an angle. Plus, he said in 2011, when he started that angle where he was leaving, he was in his mind, 100%, out the door at that time.

The circumstances that ended up taking place led to him signing a three-year deal. He’s always said that he won’t be around as long as people think. Many in WWE have noted to us that Punk has not been happy with his creative.

At the same time, of the full-timers with the company, Punk, Batista, John Cena, Daniel Bryan and Randy Orton are the top tier. Batista is scheduled full-time but he is 45 and has had a lot of injuries in the past, although to his credit his body held up for an MMA camp, which is more intense than a wrestling schedule. The difference is the MMA camp is two months and a wrestling schedule never ends. While WWE doesn’t “need” anyone, even Cena, Punk does have significant value given the lack of depth on top and injury rate.

You can also see with Batista and others that if you do really leave for a while, your value can increase greatly by not being there if you want to rest for a few years and then come back. There’s the legends role of a few big shows a year, the Jericho role of half the year or so full-time (although as we’ve seen with Jericho and RVD, that role does limit greatly how much they’ll push you), or leave, rest up injuries and come back full-time, waiting long enough for a Batista level return.

The one thing with Punk is he is a big enough star that if he does leave for several years, his return would be a big deal. Still, very few walk away at 35. Batista and Jericho left, but they both did so for other entertainment ventures. Punk hasn’t seemed like he’s interested in that direction.

He said some days he’s hurting really bad and other days he’s not, noting he’s taken very little time off over the last ten years. He said when he took the two months off last year, that he probably should have taken more time. He wasn’t fully healed but came back because the Payback PPV was in Chicago and he worked with Chris Jericho, starting a babyface turn.

As noted many times, the reason he turned heel when he was a hot babyface, was recognizing that he could be the top heel in the company, but would always at best be the No. 2 babyface. But after the heel run, he was turned back. Still, he was always in top programs, was beating The Shield in 1 vs. 3 matches consistently and was being groomed for a match with HHH at WrestleMania, which while not the main event, was guaranteed to be pushed as one of the key things on the show.

Vince McMahon does like a challenge in the sense if a guy looks like he wants out, like Punk did the last time, he may be able to cut a better deal than the guy who the company knows isn’t going anywhere and is so glad to be there and afraid of losing their job that they’ll take anything.

It’s an interesting game because he is valuable, maybe second or third most valuable guy in the company, at a time when value of the individual means less than it ever has.

He was also asked about doing MMA. He talked about it like he’d like to do it, and noted that he knows people think he can’t do it and looks at that as a challenge. He noted that people thought he couldn’t do what he did in wrestling and he loves proving people wrong.

Bellator has already expressed at least preliminary interest in him. He would be free and clear of any WWE contractual obligations in July.

He thought some people who wanted him to fail would tune in to see him get beat up, but he gets punched in the face four times a week anyway.

I get the impression a part of him would like to do it the same way Batista did it as a bucket list thing. With Batista, it seemed on the surface to be a real bad risk, but in the end, he did it and wasn’t hurt at all. With Punk, on the surface, it would seem the same thing. A theoretical big risk.

There was a time when a giant name pro wrestler doing MMA would have been huge, as noted by Brock Lesnar’s UFC debut. But I don’t see UFC using an 0-0 guy for the same reason they never used Herschel Walker, and at least with Lesnar and Kurt Angle (who they made a strong pitch for), they had the high-level wrestling credentials to make them real. Bellator should take him, but that limits the upside and PPV money.

The key is he’s 35 and his body is beaten up from years of pro wrestling. While he does train in fighting disciplines, he doesn’t have the competition background at a high level in any fighting sport. That is very old to start out in unless you want to compete at the beginners level. It’s also hard to say if he goes against someone legit and loses, how it would affect him for a WWE return, either with the fans, or with management. And I’m not sure exactly what kind of challenge he’d be up for. Herschel Walker was up for the challenge, got a lot of publicity, but was put in with guys below his level that he was going to have no trouble beating. But he’s also one of the great athletes of modern times.

Alberto Del Rio’s previous MMA means nothing good or bad for him because most fans don’t know of it. But Punk is such a big star people would know. Batista did one fight and few saw it and it meant nothing one way or the other, but he also didn’t lose. Had he got knocked out, would it have made a difference? I’m leaning toward no from a fan standpoint because wrestling fans know the difference and if you are a star to wrestling fans, no matter your personal life shortcomings or screw-ups, in the end, you are still a star to them.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Mar 19 '16

Wrestlemania 26, Michael's, Hart, McMahon and Ross participate in final Wrestlemania performances. Wrestling Observer [Apr 5, 2010]

50 Upvotes

The retirement of Shawn Michaels, losing the WrestleMania main event to The Undertaker on 3/28, ended up overshadowing that he was one of four of the most important figures in modern pro wrestling that look to be gone from the spotlight as of this past week.

Michaels, 44, got the big sendoff with a retirement speech on Raw the next night, where he thanked a number of people and stated that he really hopes he doesn’t wrestle again. It was pretty clear that Michaels in his own mind is sincere about his retirement. But most don’t believe it just because of his age and human nature of guys who have been in the spotlight. Michaels had started talking retirement two years ago, watching the farewell of Ric Flair, who was the wrestler he watched as a teenager in San Antonio on TBS who made him want to be a pro wrestler. He had retired before, several times. He quit once after failing a drug test, only to return after his suspension. He gave a tearful retirement speech in early 1997 due to knee damage so bad he could no longer perform, the famous “Lost my smile” speech, only to come back two months later, without surgery, and his first move was a back flip into the ring. A year later, after breaking his back as champion and coming back for one last match at WrestleMania to drop the title, he retired again. This retirement lasted four years, although he did have one match in the interim for his own promotion that he briefly ran during that period.

Several times in recent years, when he took sabbaticals or was out with injuries, he would tell the office that he was retiring, to the point it became almost a running joke. HHH even used the joke on Raw talking about how he always says he’s retired and nobody ever believes it. Usually, he would get the phone call that somebody is injured, and be guilt tripped into coming back to help the company that needs him short-term and enabled him to live such a good life. Still, even with the talks of not coming back at other times, he had given a date, WrestleMania 26, for his farewell match back in late 2008.

Over the past several months, he had told friends that this was going to be his last match. As he gave his farewell interview, with fans chanting “One More Match,” he very nicely shut them down, saying he knows about pro wrestling retirements, but he doesn’t want to break his word and that he really hopes he doesn’t wrestle again. Historically, few people in wrestling retire and don’t come back.

Jack Brisco is the most notable, but he left without any fanfare. Bret Hart left in 2000, but that was due to post concussion syndrome. Steve Austin also left, largely due to neck injuries because he had money and didn’t want to risk his quality of life when he got older. The Rock’s career ended in a unique way. He moved on to acting, with his last match at WrestleMania XX in Madison Square Garden. He said going in he thought it would be his last match, but months later, he was thinking about a scenario for WrestleMania XXI, when WWE, without calling him, let his contract expire at the end of 2004 His friends held a retirement party for him, but it was bittersweet at the time. He will also most likely never wrestle again. Almost everyone else came back for one, or 100, or 1,000 more matches.

But there’s a difference of moving on to something like acting where it’s consider better to not be affiliated currently with WWE television.

The point being, aside from Brisco, who was 43, but could still go, nobody has truly walked away except over health issues, or if they were in a new career where coming back could be seen as a detriment.

Michaels is believed to be in good shape financially. He’s been under a contract with a seven figure downside guarantee, and likely earned $2 million or more per year in recent years. Between what he’s already earned, his Mania payoff which will likely be high six figures (the final number depends somewhat on the final buy rate), and merchandise this year, he’s guaranteed a huge year. He’s said to have some non-wrestling related offers, so financial need at this point doesn’t look like it’ll be an issue.

But things change. Unlike in real sports, when you get to a certain age, no matter if you are Michael Jordan or Joe Montana in your prime, you simply can’t play at the major league level, wrestling allows for comebacks. There are wrestlers less physically talented than Michaels who have had very good matches well into their 50s. Michaels himself has talked in recent years about the idea of why couldn’t he come back into his 50s for that same reason, maybe doing one match a year, although his comments this week made it appear that is no longer his mind set. But lives change and people change.

It was quite ironic that Bret Hart’s final match was on the same night as Michaels, and they both did farewell interviews on the same show. Hart, 52, retired a decade ago and came back for a number of reasons. In many ways, no matter how many great matches both men had, they will forever be linked by their most famous match in 1997 in Montreal, one that in hindsight, both likely wish had never happened. On a positive note, Hart’s comeback did seem to close the book on Montreal and in a sense allow both men’s legacy to no longer be defined, or at the very least, dwelled on, by their respective actions that weekend in November. While Michaels’ last match will be remembered as one of his best, Hart’s last match won’t. Still, both will be remembered as two of the best wrestlers of this or any other generation. It was notable in their respective retirement speeches that both thanked the other. Hart congratulated Michaels on a great career and said he was one of the greatest wrestlers of all-time. Michaels went one step farther, saying that all the terrible things Hart had said about him over the years were deserved, and he took full blame for them. His career ended with the ultimate mark of unselfishness in a career, that was really two different careers, the first of which he’ll readily admit was at times consumed by selfishness.

Michaels came to the ring, and before he could start his speech, Undertaker’s music played. Undertaker came out of the ramp, tipped his hat to Michaels, and then left. Michaels noted he started coming weekly into people’s homes when he was 23 (he was talking about the beginning of his run on WWF television, a year after being fired, and ignoring his AWA tenure on ESPN that started a few years) and now he’s 44.

At this point, a “Thank You Shawn,” chant began. Michaels responded, saying “I have to thank you” to the audience. Michaels had a tear coming down his face, and said there was a time when the wrestling fans were all he had because there wasn’t much to like about him and the only time he liked himself was when he was in a wrestling ring. He thanked HHH for being his friend for 16 years and sticking with him at a time when most people hated him. He said he was hesitant to thank people for fear of leaving people out. He thanked all the production truck, the camera men, mentioned Michael Cole, Jerry Lawler and Jim Ross, making a point to say Ross was the greatest wrestling announcer of all-time (he emphasized this apparently because his request to get Ross to call his last match was turned down). He went out of his way to thank Adam, who puts together all the video packages and said that the videos he produced made him seem better than he really was.

A “One More Match” chant started and he said that he didn’t want to disrespect Undertaker, or go back on his word. He would not outright say he wouldn’t do another match, clearly trying to be as honest as possible and knowing how things change in life, but said he really hoped he would not have another match. He said he would do everything in his power to make sure that one more match does not happen. The people respected that.

It should be noted that while this was emotional to a degree, it was nowhere near as emotional as what it will be compared with, the Flair retirement, two years ago. From talking with one person in the building for this long speech and the short Jens Pulver speech a few weeks back, that the Pulver speech as far as far as reactions of being emotional in the building was significantly bigger. It was noted that with Flair, people were crying everywhere. With Pulver, they were not outright bawling, but much of the crowd had tears in their eyes, more impressive because unlike Flair and Michaels, most of those people really had little longtime viewing of him and many barely knew his name. With Michaels, the production people had to search the crowd to find people crying. They were there, but you had to look for them. The funny part is, Flair did come back. Pulver probably will fight again. But people believed it was over. Michaels, who really knows, but even though I believe he is completely sincere today about not wanting to wrestle again, only a small percentage of people don’t think he’s going to wrestle again.

Another aspect of why it was not as emotional is because so much of the audience remembers the Flair situation. There was a long build and everyone knew Flair was retiring, even though he didn’t stay retired. For Michaels, it was pushed for a few weeks but never in a way that people actually expected it. It was noted after WrestleMania two years ago, that whole weekend, everyone was talking about Flair’s retirement. This past week, when the show was over and Michaels was lost, people were talking about how they had seen a great match, not that Michaels was retiring.

Michaels thanked Bret Hart. He said he looks back and realized he drove Hart crazy and Hart ha every right to say everything he said. He thanked Hart for accepting that he had changed.

He then thanked Vince McMahon, saying he doesn’t think Vince would want him to say this on television, but that he could never work for anyone else. He said he probably drove Vince crazier than even Bret. He said that Vince gave him the opportunity and straightened him out at times. He said without Vince straightening him out, he wouldn’t be here.

After thanking the fans, and telling his kids that “Daddy’s coming home,” he said “Shawn Michaels has left the building,” which is a lie they used in 1992 to help get him over as a singles heel during his first run near the top of the cards.

The segment ended with HHH coming out, the two hugging and Michaels kissing him. HHH put down glow sticks on the ground in the shape of an “X,” which was their version of the wrestlers retirement symbol that is now only used at the amateur level where you take off your boots, put them in the middle of the ring and leave them there.

But to less fanfare than Michaels or Hart, two others major characters when it comes to the most successful period business wise in this industry’s history may also be finished when it comes to being regular television characters.

The biggest surprise at WrestleMania was not Jack Swagger winning the Money in the Bank match and becoming World champion two days later. It was that, no matter how many times it was stated in the days prior to the show that this would be the case, that Jim Ross did not announce the last match of Bret Hart, and what may be the last match of Shawn Michaels.

Michaels, in his speech, made a point of thanking Ross (as well as all the announcers), to the point of calling him the greatest announcer of all-time. Michaels and Undertaker had both gone to Vince McMahon to ask him to change his mind, and at least let Ross announce their match. It’s not the first time this has happened. Ross was put out to pasture in a sense in 2000, then brought back as a comedy figure, but ended up back as the lead announcer after both Steve Austin and The Rock went to McMahon in 2001 and told him they wanted him to announce their WrestleMania match. He’s been put out to pasture so many times in the last 11 years most people have lost count. Usually, it’s right around WrestleMania time when he’s brought back, which is why it was such a surprise it didn’t happen here.

We had been told that outright by someone who would know even before the word spread to the talent a couple of weeks back. Right after the word had gotten out, we were told the decision had been changed. Even when it was well known the decision was changed, and Ross wrote about it, few believed that on the day of the show, as is often the case, McMahon would change his mind because to almost everyone, the “right” decision seemed obvious, particularly since it was a show that would include Hart and Michaels’ presumed last career matches.

One person close to the situation said the subject was broached one last time during the week at a creative team meeting. Vince said no to the suggestion when it was delicately floated to him. He said the company could not live in the past and needs to use the full-time announcers on the biggest show of the year. He felt that Ross shouldn’t be highlighted if he wasn’t coming back to be a full-time announcer, and it was said after that meeting it was a dead topic.

A few days before the show, when it was broached, McMahon said that the company can’t live in the past and people have to recognize that Michael Cole, Jerry Lawler and Matt Striker are the PPV announcing team. Others who echoed his words said if he was there, it would become a big part of the show, and that’s not what McMahon wanted. McMahon decided against using Ross as a special big events announcer. Ross’ writing about no longer being hot on traveling 52 weeks a year apparently took him off the boards as a weekly announcer.

Whether Ross constantly writing about wanting to announce the show played a part in it in the sense McMahon didn’t like being pressured, is something only he would know. Whether Ross’ open talks about wanting to announce MMA, which very quietly on the international front has become a major thorn in the company’s side with the fear what happened in North America could happen in international markets, played a part in it, again, only he knows. The decision came off worse in hindsight because Cole was not very good at Mania, Lawler at times acted like he didn’t want to be anywhere near Striker (the two don’t get along when it comes to announcing together) and Striker was at times insufferable.

After the show, Ross, 58, wrote, “Broadcasting wrestling in WWE is likely history for me, but there are many other areas to which I can contribute in WWE and these options, among others, will be weighed over the next month.”

The description from people in Phoenix said seeing Ross was uncomfortable, because he was clearly hurt by the decision, virtually nobody agreed with it, and him being there all week was weird because of it. Those close to the situation believe Ross will be offered a new contract (he’s currently under a one-month extension that ends on or around 4/20) similar to that of Gene Okerlund. He’ll no longer be on the broadcasts, but may fly in to do segments for 24/7, and later, be a part of building the new network. The most apt description is that “They’d rather he’s on the inside pissing out than on the outside pissing in.” Plus, it is no secret TNA has been pushing hard to get him to come in. From a timing standpoint, this right now greatly works in WWE’s favor. First, TNA’s disastrous ratings make it more of a perceived step down, not to mention one has to question if they would be getting on a sinking ship. In addition, TNA has already laid out millions to acquire new talent without much in the way of popularity or financial benefit. Before 3/8, they were aggressive to a degree in spending money for talent. Now, after laying out all that money to no return, the company is going to likely be more squeamish now about adding new expenses. They are going to have far less confidence today than a month ago that such a move would help growth.

The fourth WWE institution who was talking privately about calling it a day as a performer was Vince McMahon.

Over the past week, McMahon stated that the match with Bret Hart would be the blow-off of the Mr. McMahon television character. He noted that character was spawned by the aftermath of the 1997 Hart vs. Michaels match and this was the right time and the perfect angle to finish the story and put the character to bed. It should be noted that McMahon, who is of the belief that television is for younger faces and having an aging look is death to the promotion, has said in the past that he felt he was too old to be a performer. But an angle would come up, ratings would come down, he’d get the itch, and would be back. McMahon, 64, was planned for a Mania match (originally it was going to be with Undertaker) before the angle was put together with Hart. But the absolute destruction in that match was meant as the end of the character, to blow off all the heel heat off the character, and for the character to in the end be turned babyface.

Many noted amusement that he picked a scenario to turn babyface that completely failed. It ended up as the most psychologically confusing big match in recent history. You’d be hard pressed to ever find an angle more talked about on such a big stage that confused the audience to the point it garnered such little reaction. It was well known the limitations of the match. Hart had a serious stroke, not to mention a knee replacement, and honestly, when you consider that, what he did on offense still looked good and it was a significant triumph from a physical standpoint just that he was able to get in the ring and do as much as he did. In addition, his overall performance from January through the final angles was very good, at times tremendous, bringing a level of believability in the early part of the angle. The fake car accident unfortunately took the angle away from its potential, even though the actual reveal two weeks before the show was a tremendous television moment. Whatever lessons can be learned from the different twists and turns really don’t matter, because there is unlikely to be a similar pro wrestling angle in our lifetimes, even though we’ll probably have a generation of people failing when attempting to duplicate it. There were the obvious limitations due to Hart’s concussion issues. He could not take any bumps, for example, or anything that could possibly jar his head, nor for medical and insurance reasons, could he take anything near his head. McMahon, between his age and back problems, was limited as well. But you are also talking about two men who are absolute masters of the art of psychology. That’s what made what is the in-ring swansong of one, and possibly the other, so perplexing.


Shawn Michaels made his last match one of his best, while the storyline ending to the single most talked about real conflict in pro wrestling history ended up filled with questions at WrestleMania 26.

This year’s spectacular on 3/28 at the University of Phoenix Stadium in Glendale, AZ, started slow and midway through, the show that was can’t miss on paper was looking like somehow it was going to. But a strong finish, most notably matches with Edge vs. Chris Jericho, Batista vs. John Cena and Michaels vs. Undertaker, made it a show that may not have fully lived up to expectations, but if it didn’t, it came close.

Michaels lived up to his nickname of Mr. WrestleMania, as he seems to always do. Michaels, coming off winning Match of the Year in 2008 with Chris Jericho, and last year with Undertaker, may join Kenta Kobashi (2003-2005) as the only person to win three straight matches of the year. A WrestleMania match, because of the stage it’s on, has an inherent advantage in voting because so many more people will see it, and it would be very difficult for a match to have the level of emotion this one had.

Billed as the streak vs. retirement, the two built several near fall spots that looked like the finish, before Michaels kicked out of a tombstone piledriver. In an attempt to replicate the emotional finish of the Ric Flair vs. Michaels match of two years ago, they did a long dramatic pause after the kick out. Undertaker pulled down his straps and told Michaels to stay down. He got up, did a throat slash, and slapped Undertaker hard in the face. Undertaker then picked Michaels up and laid him out with a jumping tombstone piledriver and pinned him. Undertaker helped Michaels up and they shook hands and hugged. Michaels looked to the sky while fans chanted his name and he started crying.

You could make a case that Michaels has had the best match on 12 of the 17 WrestleManias he’s performed on.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Feb 23 '16

(Part 1) The downfall of Lex Luger's WWF run, from handpicked replacement of Hogan to being replaced at Wrestlemania X by Bret Hart. Wrestling Observer [Nov 1993-Jan 1994]

50 Upvotes

Nov 8th 1993

The Lex Luger-Ludvig Borga series continues to be a major disappointment in almost every arena. It's amazing with all the money and time spent on pushing Luger just two months ago and how well it appeared on television that it was working, that it turned into such a major flop. When asked about Hulk Hogan on the radio show, Luger and Jim Ross had nothing but good things to say about Hogan.

Dec 19th 1993, 1994 preview

Royal Rumble: Titan's television leading up to the Royal Rumble has come to this. The top three undercard matches will be Yokozuna vs. Undertaker in a casket match for the title, being billed as Undertaker's "only" title shot (although he's still getting title shots nightly on the road). Also Razor Ramon defends the IC belt against IRS (matches with Shawn Michaels for the belt are being saved for the houses) and the Quebecers defend the tag titles against Bret & Owen Hart, which will obviously lead to the big split between those two although the split itself may take place after the card if it doesn't happen during the show. With Undertaker and Hart out of the Rumble, and the announcement made that the Rumble winner gets the WM title shot, it appears the original plan of Yokozuna vs. Luger at Mania with the title changing is still on the books which is something of a surprise since it's well acknowledged within the company that Luger has been a flop in his role, with Bret Hart reportedly promised the title from Luger at Summer Slam in Pittsburgh next August.

Dec 27 1993

They also seem to be doing a "900 line scam of the week." Last week they asked fans to vote where Randy Savage should be allowed back as a broadcaster, which set up him co-hosting WWF Mania. This week they were asking fans to vote to give Jack Tunney input on whether or not Lex Luger should be allowed in the Royal Rumble, which is a total scam since that decision was made in the office months ago. Aside from the obvious speculation of Yokozuna keeping the belt and losing to Luger at Mania, which was the original plan, there is a lot of talk of Undertaker winning and Yokozuna going face ala Kimala.

Jan 24 1994

For the Royal Rumble (as opposed to a Royal Rumble), best guess is that Owen will be the marathon man, but that Bret will win, but somehow instead of getting the title shot the angle with his brother will take precedence (similar to 1992 where Hogan was awarded the shot at Flair but it turned into Hogan-Sid and Flair-Savage) and Lex Luger will get the shot at Wrestlemania and win the title. This is all a guess, not a scenario laid out for me. Maybe Luger will just win the Rumble.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Nov 09 '15

Steve Austin’s 1995. Injured and fired from WCW, to the most talked about wrestler in a matter months. Signs with WWF in late 1995. Wrestling Observer (July-Dec 1995)

49 Upvotes

By Dave Meltzer

July 3rd 1995

Steve Austin suffered a bicep injury while in Japan and will be out for several weeks.

July 10, 1995

Those of you waiting for the reformation of the Hollywood Blonds, don't hold your breath. Steve Austin is out for at least another five weeks with a muscle tear in his arm. By that point if there is a new booker and that idea was from the old booker (well, actually it wasn't but it was the old booker who was planning it) so you know how those things go. Not saying it isn't going to happen, just don't bet money on it.

Aug 7 1995 There has been concern expressed by several of the names above that WCW has been unable to get anyone over, the Benoit's treatment when he was in WCW along with the treatment of Brian Pillman and Steve Austin, who have been with the company for years and are two of the three or four best workers in the company, seemingly have had their careers go nowhere.

Sept 25 1995

WCW did fire Steve Austin (Steve Williams) on 9/15. Austin, 30, was considered for years as perhaps the best young wrestler in the United States. His career languished for the past year almost to the point that he was spoken of, like his former tag partner Brian Pillman, as a wrestler who had made a lot of money by signing good contracts but had great careers ruined by a WCW organization that had been both unwilling and unable to get any wrestlers over. Austin had been in the doghouse with WCW management over the past year over a reputation for not exactly keeping quiet with his discontent about how he was used and for those involved in cost cutting seeing the $200,000 or so figure he was earning per year while not being involved in any significant programs as wasted money. While on a tour with New Japan in June, Austin tore his tricep and has been out of action since and was believed to be about six weeks from being ready to return when he was fired. This of course paints WCW as a real class organization for firing a guy while injured when he suffered the injury on a tour the company sent him on. Austin's main problem appeared to be in the cliquish nature of WCW (which is consistent not only in wrestling but in most jobs but worse in WCW than most places obviously). He didn't hang with the right crowd. When the Hogan camp got into power, they dismissed Austin as a highly-paid wrestler who was a good worker with no charisma and in their view of wrestling, workrate meant next to nothing. The Hogan clique basically consisted of WWFers from the mid-80s when wrestling was hot and thus, could dismiss any wrestler who came along later as being "unable to draw money" (forgetting that most of those who drew money in the mid-80s became suddenly unable to draw money either when the business lost popularity). He wasn't in the Flair clique either, so nobody spoke up for his workrate on the inside at the meetings. Austin was given little chance to show his stuff after the career ending back injury of his main opponent, Rick Steamboat. Austin then suffered a knee injury which kept him out for a few months, and before he was plugged into a new planned program, a reuniting of his tag team with Brian Pillman, he went to Japan and suffered the tricep tear. It's unknown what Austin's plans will be once he's able to return to the ring, but he would be able to get a strong spot with ECW if he would want it since he's a long-time friend of Paul Heyman, although that would entail a major comedown in money. I don't know if he has any connections or has made any with All Japan, but if he wants to make a career out of Japan, that promotion and him almost seem tailor-made if he can learn that style and psychology. All Japan needs new foreign stars they can push and very few Americans have the ability to make it with that group and Austin potentially fits into that select group. Of course WWF is the most logical option. He probably could also return to WCW if he was willing to work for less money and a per night deal although I'm betting the nature of his dismissal which will almost certainly result in very bitter feelings will make that very difficult. A few hours later, WCW and Gene Okerlund's agent Barry Bloom agreed verbally to a two-year contract which, with incentives, is more potentially lucrative than his previous deal which was said to have a $250,000 base. Okerlund's WCW contract had expired two days earlier and it was questionable if the deal hadn't been put together whether he would have appeared at the Fall Brawl PPV show. Naturally the timing of the Austin firing, particularly being fired while injured ala Steamboat, and the Okerlund raise didn't set well with several wrestlers within WCW for obvious reasons.

Oct 2nd 1995

Steve Austin appeared on the 9/23 ECW house show in Middletown, NY and will make his first appearance on the television show this coming week. Austin, fired on 9/15 by WCW, is still about six weeks away from getting back in the ring because of a torn tricep suffered while on a tour with New Japan. Austin, who will be billed as "The Extreme Superstar," a combination spoof on WWF calling all its wrestlers Superstars and perhaps as a modern day Billy Graham, is no doubt going to be pushed as ECW world champion as soon as they can viably get the belt on him. As of this point, there are no serious negotiations that I know of between Austin and All Japan, which would enable Austin to remain long-term with ECW and still make a major league living at wrestling. Obviously his long-term tenure in ECW will be based on whether or not either the group improves itself to the point he can make a competitive living with it, or he can use ECW as a supplement to a regular Japan gig. In his first television interview, Austin mocked Hulk Hogan by calling himself "The Stevester" and that "Steve-o-mania" was running wild and said that it was unfortunate that he wasn't a good enough wrestler to get past mid-card in WCW.

Oct 9th 1995

There were people more upset than you'd think about the Steve Austin interview on the ECW show last week where he mocked Hulk Hogan.

Oct 16th 1995

What appears to be the situation with Austin is that he was scheduled for a meeting on 10/10 with Vince McMahon. He's also got talks scheduled with All Japan. If he works out a deal there, the odds are great he'll work here and be world champion and pushed as the star of the promotion. If not, it's inevitable just from a money standpoint and the fact the WWF badly needs heels who can work and young stars and right now there isn't a long list of people who can fill that bill that he'll end up with WWF.

Oct 23 1995

Steve Austin and Cactus Jack both did killer interviews on the past weekend's television. Austin basically talked about being held back in WCW and how all the promotions have been calling him but he decided to go to ECW because Tod Gordon must have taken out another mortgage on his house to pay him. Austin talked about how he was fired in WCW from a phone call by Eric Bischoff's secretary and contrasted it to the way Dean Malenko and Eddy Guerrero left ECW. He still ran down ECW saying it was a bunch of violent crap. The only problem with all this is that it appears likely Austin is going to wind up with the WWF as he has a second meeting scheduled this week so aside from a few great interviews, not much in the long run is going to materialize from this.

Nov 6 1995

The most talked about thing on this past week's television was Steve Austin. Austin wore a black wig impersonating Eric Bischoff's announcing on "Monday Nyquil," "where the big boys play with each other." He got in some funny lines including pretending to fall asleep calling the matches because the matches are so boring, building up a match with Geritol on top of a pole for all the "old codgers" in WCW and making light of Bischoff not being able to call matches because he doesn't know any of the moves. Later in the show from the last ECW Arena show, he climbed the ladder before the Mikey Whipwreck vs. Sandman title change match and insulted Woman calling her a "$5 piece of ass" and saying that she married a midget. Needless to say, this didn't go over very well in the WCW office. Give Woman credit for being professional enough to go along with something she couldn't have been thrilled with doing because it's the direction the booker wants to go in. At least two other ECW names are said to be close to joining WCW, close enough that storylines have already been prepared for them.

Dec 4th 1995

Steve Austin is said to be seriously considering going to All Japan, which would allow him to work here between tours. WWF is still very interested in him as well.

Dec 26th 1995

Steve Austin did an unbelievable interview on the 12/19 show saying how he spent four years waiting for a world title shot, then got two in two weeks and lost them both, and admitted he came into ECW out of shape, that he didn't rehab his arm and said if he was smart he'd call up Eric Bischoff and tell him he deserved to win announcer of the year and kiss his ass to get his job back so he could sit around and get a big paycheck. He said he was disgusted with his career over the past four year.

*Note Meltzer never directly reports that Austin has signed with WWF, just has this in a followup piece a week later

Jan 29, 1995 There was talk they were going to change the Ringmaster name to something less silly, but Steve Austin debuted with that name on Raw. When Ringmaster entered, Vince McMahon called him "Steve Austin, known as the Ringmaster." It was amazing to see the physical improvement in Austin compared with just a few weeks ago in ECW.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Sep 26 '15

173-1! Kevin Nash ends Goldberg's streak at Starrcade! PWTorch[Jan 2, 1999]

49 Upvotes

Kevin Nash pinned Goldberg to capture the WCWHvt. Title and end Goldberg’s winning streak at 173. The match, which was declared a no–DQ match mid-way through Starrcade, ended with interference by Disco Inferno, Bam Bam Bigelow, and Scott Hall. It was one of the more “tainted wins” ever in a WCW Title change. After Goldberg took time to dispatch of Disco and Bigelow, Hall zapped him with an electric “stun gun.” Nash, who was unaware of the interference, jackknifed Goldberg for the win. Nash looked at Goldberg as he struggled to regain his equilibrium with a curious look, as if he couldn’t believe he was able to pin him so easily. On Nitro the next day Nash, accompanied by Konnan and Lex Luger, said he couldn’t celebrate his victory with everyone else. He said he got into pro wrestling for money, power, and respect. He said Starrcade wasn’t about money or power, it was about respect. He said the way he won didn’t sit well with him. He said there isn’t another human being on the planet he has more love for than Scott Hall, but he made a mistake last night in his attempt to help him. He said he has a lot of respect for Goldberg and for the WCWTitle, so to make things right, he offered a rematch to Goldberg next week on Nitro. He said he thinks he can kick Goldberg’s ass without any help from others and he wants a chance to prove it.

The most controversial finish at Starrcade was Eric Bischoff pinning Ric Flair. Originally Flair was booked to win the match, but as has become par for the course in wrestling these days, plans were changed the PPV would help set up a ratings–drawing rematch on Nitro the next day. While Flair lost under less than fair circumstances, it still seemed disgraceful for someone of Flair’s status over the last 25 years in wrestling get pinned under any circumstances by his non–wrestling boss.

The most remarkable story coming out of Starrcade and Nitro was how the WCW Title change was handled on television. While Flair vs. Bischoff was the third from final match and Goldberg vs. Nash was the final match, the announcers on Nitro barely addressed the WCW Title change. Instead, in a jaw–dropping display of playing to the boss’s ego, they talked almost exclusively about Bischoff’s pin on Flair. Nitro began with a limousine celebration scene—not of Nash celebrating his title victory, but of Bischoff, Hennig, Scott Steiner, and Buff Bagwell celebrating and Bischoff saying, “Hollywood would be proud.” The announcers then recapped the circumstances of Bischoff’s win for just over one minute before Schiavone broke in with the news that Nash beat Goldberg. Just 20 seconds later, the announcers went right back to talking about Bischoff and Flair. The four minute Bischoff highlight package then aired yet again. The announcers then talked more about Bischoff and Flair. It wasn’t until 15 minutes into the show that they got into specifics of how Goldberg lost, and that was simply during ring introductions of the first match.

Granted, Vince McMahon has succeeded at making himself the centerpiece of Raw, giving Steve Austin the luxury of not having to carry the show every week. Bischoff seems determined to push himself into that position also so he can receive the acclaim that McMahon has, but unlike McMahon, he’s been doing it at the expense of the top storyline as opposed to be part of it and his performances aren’t considered to be anywhere nearly as entertaining as McMahon’s. The only defense or the approach is that since the Flair–Bischoff rematch was the TV main event, they wanted to make that seem like a huge deal, but it’s not as if Nash’s first interview as champion couldn’t have been built up also throughout the show to also help the ratings. Instead, his first interview was barely an afterthought to the Flair–Bischoff hype. Goldberg didn’t appear on the show at all.

WCW has a lot to look forward to in 1999. Randy Savage made his return on Nitro with a new look (a ’roided–up looking physique, slicked back hair, and Konnan–like loose–fitting jeans). Sting is set to return within six weeks. Hulk Hogan may return as soon as next week. Roddy Piper is still waiting in the wings for a fresh angle in which to get involved. With that star power, WCW hopes their NBC specials will be a ratings success. The WWF, during their days in the late–’80s running Saturday Night’s Main Event specials, drew very good ratings (including one that beat any Saturday Night Live broadcast). In those days, NBC paid the WWF $450,000 per 90 minute show. It was considered a bargain for NBC considering the price they paid for other programming that drew similar ratings. For prime time rather than late night programming, chances are WCW received substantially more than that for each special. That extra money, not to mention the added exposure and intangible reputation that comes from being on network prime time television, should help WCW regain a lot of lost momentum. There is pressure on Bischoff and Hogan, though. If they can’t turn Nitro’s ratings around despite their loaded star–powered roster and the rub from NBC, then what would it take? Starrcade was so void of attention to detail, especially in the middle of the card, that it was obvious WCW was looking past the PPV toward trying to regain ratings momentum on Nitro and set the stage for the NBC specials.

Other questions loom for WCW in 1999. Can 49 year old Flair sustain his current momentum when he gets in the ring with real wrestlers? Will Nash give WCW much needed booking leadership and authority as he begins working in the front office full time next week? Will the big egos with power in WCW sabotage Goldberg when, thanks to NBC, he has a chance to become a true crossover superstar and end all fears that he’s just a flash in the pan? Can Hogan reinvigorate his limp and stale persona or will he drag down everyone else while clinging to his fleeting career?


r/TheDirtsheets • • Sep 12 '15

July 13, 1998 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: Goldberg wins WCW World Heavyweight Championship

49 Upvotes

It can be debated whether at this stage of the game, putting the title on Bill Goldberg was premature and a panicked reaction to being drubbed in the ratings the previous week. What can't be debated is that the lesson learned from the flop that was Sting was learned from, and once the decision was made to do it, that this time it was done right. The 31-year-old Goldberg, less than ten months after making his televised debut last September 22 in Salt Lake City, was given the WCW title by Hulk Hogan before the largest crowd in the history of the company, the fourth largest crowd for pro wrestling ever in the United States on 7/6 at the Georgia Dome and garnering without question one of the biggest pops in the history of the business. WCW built the television around Goldberg from start-to-finish, showing clips of him warming up throughout the show, and opening the show with Hogan stating that Goldberg could only get a title shot if he first beat an NWO black & white member that people haven't seen for a while, which turned out to be Scott Hall. To the first of many thunderous reactions, Goldberg planted Hall with his spear and jackhammer combination in 5:56. Much of the NWO black & white attempted to do the run-in, but were all laid out by chair shots delivered by Diamond Dallas Page and Karl Malone, one of which, Page's shot on Ed Leslie, was so stiff it opened Leslie up and he needed to be stitched up backstage and words were actually exchanged between the two of them in probably the only major stressful situation backstage. Hogan, who from all accounts had no problems putting Goldberg over the right way as was originally planned. Those original plans, formulated by him, were for this to be a non-title and non-televised match plans that were officially changed on 7/2 as a response to the previous weeks' ratings drubbing. The current plans, subject to change in the next panic attack, are for Goldberg to keep the title for the time being and not to do a quickie back to Hogan because of the feeling that Goldberg could be the man in the business, and to not screw it up as they did Sting (and truthfully, a lot of that problem wasn't just the way the Hogan feud was booked but because Sting himself had no fire in the ring when he returned). Hogan still had no problem doing the job the right way for Goldberg, but in return apparently got the promise of being, when the time is right, the person to end Goldberg's winning streak, although the present plans are for that to be a long time coming. Due to the July 4th holiday, ratings for Monday weren't available at press time. It is generally believed that WCW was going to win the week, but at what cost in not only giving away a potential $7 million PPV bonanza, but in costing the company numerous other huge PPV matches that previous storylines were building to such as Hogan's title defenses against Kevin Nash and Bret Hart that are now out the window. In fact, with Hogan not having the belt, both programs are cooled off to the point it's questioned what the purpose will be to even continue in the original directions. If WCW doesn't win, which would be a horrible blow to the company after putting on its biggest money match and getting maybe 12 percent at best of the potential revenue from it, it can only blame itself as this was the first Nitro since TNT established a West Coast feed. While in the long run, moving Nitro from a 5 p.m. to 8 p.m. start on the West Coast should theoretically help ratings, WCW never once mentioned it on any of its television shows, basically almost handing the entire West Coast audience to WWF on a night where it was giving away far too much money just to win one week of ratings.

Although an attendance figure of 39,919 was given on the broadcast, when all was said and done the actual number in the building was 41,412, which was a sellout for the configuration set-up and there were a few hundred fans turned away, with 36,506 paying $906,330--destroying previous company records set on 1/6 for Nitro in the same building of 26,773 fans and 23,058 paid, and devastating the gate record set for Starrcade at the MCI Arena in Washington, DC of an even $541,000. Realistically the show was going to draw in excess of 30,000 fans even without the Hogan-Goldberg match as they had topped 20,000 tickets sold several weeks in advance before the match was ever announced and it wasn't until after the show had already shattered the company gate record that Hogan came up with the idea of putting Goldberg over in a non-title dark match so he could make it look like he drew the house. Even at the time Hogan made the decision, the handwriting as to the direction the Monday night wars were going had already been written, and it came as no surprise that by show time, despite the local advertising that it wouldn't be on TV, that it was put on TV, although going so far as to make it a title match was real desperation. We don't have exact merchandise figures at press time but the number was in the $300,000 range, which also broke the all-time company record of $249,842 set for the 2/2 Nitro from the Alamodome in San Antonio. In the history of pro wrestling in the United States, the only shows that drew more people paid were Wrestlemania III from the Pontiac Silverdome on March 29, 1987 with the Hogan vs. Andre the Giant match (approximately 78,000 fans and about 76,000 paid), Wrestlemania VIII on April 5, 1992 from the Hoosier Dome in Indianapolis headlined by Hogan vs. Sid Justice (Vicious) which drew 62,167 and about 47,000 paid, and the Royal Rumble on January 21, 1997 from the Alamodome in San Antonio headlined by Sid vs. Shawn Michaels which drew 60,525 and 48,014 paid. There is an unverified figure of 45,000 for a July 30, 1935 match with Strangler Lewis vs. Danno O'Mahoney from Fenway Park in Boston, and among the other legendary numbers from the past are 35,265 on September 30, 1934 between Lewis vs. Jim Londos from Wrigley Field in Chicago, 38,622 on June 30, 1961 at Comiskey Park in Chicago for Buddy Rogers vs. Pat O'Connor, 36,295 on August 9, 1980 at Shea Stadium for Bruno Sammartino vs. Larry Zbyszko and 32,123 on May 6, 1984 at Texas Stadium for Flair vs. Kerry Von Erich, all of which are total attendance and not paid attendance although in those days the idea of papering houses in wrestling didn't exist so it's doubtful there would be more than a few hundred of any of those crowds that wasn't paid. The gate would rank as the eighth largest in U.S. history, trailing only the Wrestlemanias in 1987, 1988, 1989 (which holds the all-time record of $1,628,000 with the Hogan vs. Randy Savage main event), 1992, 1993, 1994 and 1998. It was, as hyped repeatedly on television, the largest crowd ever in the U.S. for a live broadcast television show. But as impressive as the category that puts this show, it pales with this figure. Starrcade did $7 million on PPV and with a good long build-up, there is no reason this match wouldn't have done the same or more as Goldberg should be more of a drawing card than Sting. And that was given away in desperation to win the ratings for one week. After doing a match at Starrcade and Nitro, when they put Hogan and Sting back on PPV it did about $4 million so business when it comes to this is like a movie opening. In other words, what was done was the WCW equivalent of putting the movie "Titanic" on free television, and then opening it nationwide in the theaters the next week, thus giving away the monster first weekend of business.

Not that the match and the show didn't work. It couldn't have worked better. Having seen most of the really momentous pops of this generation, from Ric Flair beating Harley Race at the first Starrcade, to Hulk Hogan beating Iron Sheik to win the title, to the Rougeaus beating the Garvins in the loser leaves town match in Montreal, to Misawa's first win over Jumbo Tsuruta at Budokan Hall and Kerry Von Erich and Sting's first title win over Flair, this blew almost all of them out of the water. Sure, there was choreography of modern technology. Nobody piped "Kerry" chants into Texas Stadium to jump-start the crowd so it would look good on television. But even so, this reaction was still amazing. It was Goldberg's night in the building, it was more than a weekly television show and more than most PPV shows. It was perhaps, with the exception of Wrestlemania, the event in U.S. pro wrestling for this year. And the anticipation and excitement was very bit the level of the Hogan-Andre series, when the two had pitiful matches and it didn't even matter because the crowd was so hyped. When Goldberg and Hall blew some spots early that would have ruined the match had it involved anyone else, but it didn't matter. Nothing mattered as long as Goldberg was in the ring and did his jackhammer. It wasn't even going to matter that Hogan can't work (although he did work much harder than usual to make the match as good as it could have been given who was involved) and Goldberg rarely goes past 2:00. And even more so, it was his night to become a bonafide superstar in this profession, from the warm-up clips, to the clips of mythical wins 1, 25, 50, 75 and 100. After a few power moves, Hogan began whipping Goldberg with his weight belt. Goldberg got the belt away, and instead of using it, threw it out of the ring. Hogan cut off Goldberg with a low blow, and his usual pathetic offense wasn't there as Goldberg sold a stiff clothesline and a few decently hard chair shots. Actually Hogan was the one who sold big for a weak clothesline. Hogan legdropped Goldberg twice, but Goldberg kicked out. At this point Curt Hennig came out for the run-in, but this brought out Page and Malone again, this time with Malone giving Hennig a diamond cutter. This was the cue for spear and jackhammer time at 8:12 and the huge post-match celebration of Goldberg holding both the WCW World and U.S. belts, billed as the first wrestler ever to win a world title while having never lost a pro wrestling match (probably not true, although the only name that comes to my mind that would fit that label would be Salman Hashimikov, but he won his world title under similar somewhat unplanned circumstances after only being in the business for five weeks in 1989 and you can see where his career ended up). Nitro was heavily pushed on all the Turner Network programming and in newspaper press releases with the hype that both Malone and Dennis Rodman would be there and meet up before their PPV match. Rodman didn't appear as had been planned from the start for a Georgia Dome appearance by both leading to one last big angle the week before the match. Rodman didn't return WCW's phone calls although Hogan tried to cover for the no-show in an interview saying that he had been on the phone with Rodman, which really bodes well for the PPV and his dedication toward putting on a good match. The night before his no-show, Rodman appeared at a Pearl Jam concert in Dallas, guzzling wine from a bottle and went on stage shirtless and shoeless and tried to sing along until the stage crew cut off his mike and lead singer Eddie Vetter said to Rodman, "I'm guessing you've been drinking for about three days straight." After such a horrible reaction both by fans and in the ratings, Eric Bischoff, after having WCW spend $70,000 for the set, dropped his mock "Tonight Show" gimmick after just one week.

So will Goldberg be WCW's answer to Steve Austin, or be this generation's version of Hogan or Flair as the unquestioned historical superstars of their era? Or will he be this year's answer to Sting or Sid or Luger or Hellwig, the guys who were supposed to be the next big thing, but when put in the position, their flaws became too evident and it just never worked? He's still green as a worker, but in his case that doesn't seem to matter. He's unproven as a talker, but that hasn't stopped him from getting the most incredible crowd reaction of any wrestler of modern times aside from Antonio Inoki. This was not something built up with a lot of planning. He has no set-up challengers on the horizon or big money matches on the table, something that can't be said for Hogan, who gave the belt away. And his win changes the structure of the company. Make no mistake about this and if there is one thing evident from the events of Monday night. WCW is now Goldberg's company, not Hogan's or anyone else's, no matter what the brass at TBS may think. It's one of those things that just happened and now all the factions will be trying to recruit Goldberg for their internal power struggles. When the story is written years from now, people will be shocked that Goldberg's first world title win wasn't something planned in advance and came simply because a company was desperate after losing the television ratings the week before. But that wasn't all that different from how Lou Thesz ended up with the title the first time either. July 6, 1998 could be a historical night for pro wrestling ushering in the first big match of one of the most charismatic figures the game has ever seen. Or it could have been one humongous pop for a moment, a moment that means nothing in the long run.


r/TheDirtsheets • • Nov 24 '15

(Final part) 1 year later. Meltzer reviews new Montrael Screwjob information after Wrestling with Shadows releases. Wrestling Observer [Dec 21, 1998]

48 Upvotes

The feelings between the two heightened when Hart was asked to do a job in a six-man tag on November 7 in Toronto (Undertaker & Austin & Mankind vs. Hart & Davey Boy Smith & Neidhart) for Austin's stunner, and refused saying it was in Canada and he was the only Canadian in the main event thinking it was the wrong thing for the show. His creative control had kicked in, and partner Neidhart did the favor. McMahon and others in the company tried to position this internally as Hart refusing to job to Austin, who he had no heat with, noting that Austin had put Hart over in their previous year Survivor Series and Wrestlemania matches. The next night in Detroit, Hart was booked by the office once again to do the job in the same six-man, but the agents at the building didn't even bother asking him, and asked Neidhart instead. Somehow in the miscommunication, the word got to the office that Hart had refused again, this time not in Canada, which is where some in the office thought he wasn't "being business," although McMahon himself knew the truth about Detroit as well, as their conversation in Montreal shows. So nothing was truly settled regarding Montreal, although the finish talked about from all accounts at the production meeting the night before was still a DQ, leading to a title change to Michaels at the final four in Springfield. There is some circumstantial evidence that leads me to believe that the night before there were people aware of the planned double-cross, with the unanswered question being Jim Ross' hotline report and pre-game show report that "this could be Hart's final match in the World Wrestling Federation," when the storyline idea agreed on was that Hart would be around for one more month, including the next PPV show. The fact McMahon wouldn't be doing the broadcast as usual had been part of the meeting the night before. There was also a production sheet where it listed playing Michaels' music at the end of the match that was printed up a few days before the match. There is clear proof in documentation form that the day before Montreal, Hart was willing to lose the title to anyone but Michaels, and he later even changed his tune regarding Michaels, anywhere but in Canada. Which leads to what actually happened in the conversation. What aired in the movie was edited down to a few sentences regarding the specific finish agreement, which makes what some would say was the key point of the movie, and quite frankly, without Hart being wired, this entire story would be simply one man's word against another's, something McMahon no doubt was figuring when he started talking on the issue. While the movie was much more than the finish of the Montreal match, it was that finish that gave it its dramatic conclusion. The basics of the conversation, McMahon and Hart agreeing to the DQ finish, but not the conversation itself, is already well-known by now to virtually everyone in and around this industry, except for those who are still so smart that they believe this was all just an angle.

This is the actual conversation, and also not the complete version because much of it dealt with things having nothing to do with the match and the period leading to the match, but this is an exact version of what went down as it regarded the match. The parts not mentioned here are non- relevant issues such as the story behind Remembrance Day (the holiday in Canada which took place the night of the match): McMahon: Have you given some more thought on what you'd like to do? Hart: I think what I'd like to do is get through today, and I think tomorrow I should go in and do my speech and forfeit the title. I think everyone on the planet knows, and I think it allows me a chance to leave with my head up and leave in a nice way. If I lose anywhere, everyone knows I'm going to lose. They're waiting for it. And then at the same time for the next few weeks I can have matches where I think people would be kind of sympathetic. I got the feeling last night in Detroit that they, well, they kind of booed me, but I was a heel all the way through the match until the end of the match. Then when I walked around they, everyone was very emotional. People were crying, hugging me. It was like a ten minute walk around the ring. I don't think, they dropped, it was not a work anymore. I think that's the right way to do it. McMahon: Sensing that, it seems like everybody knows. There does seem to be that sympathy factor, too. Hart: I think I would feel really good about that. It would make me feel better. Me and Shawn could take the edge off. I don't have to beat Shawn. We could have a shmazz (run-in non-finish) or whatever you want. For me, I don't have any authorization or permission (from Bischoff) to do anything more than what I asked them. I haven't spoken to anybody. McMahon: That's what Pat (Patterson) told me. Hart: All I know is that I asked them, can I do a final four match on the 7th? And they said that's okay. I don't really know if you want them dictating anything to you or me either. But I don't really have the right to call them back and say, `They changed it. I'm working a single match on the 7th.' They might say, well, that's not what you promised, or not what you said. The same about tomorrow (on Nitro). I haven't got, but I believe I will get some kind of word from them that, because I expect to hear from somebody even today, that I can try to get them to stop, or to not announce that I'm going anywhere. I wonder if it's even worth it now. Everyone knows.

McMahon: It's probably not. Hart: But I would feel much better doing that. It would give me the right, I'd feel, I'd like to leave and say nice things and leave with. McMahon: Yeah. I'm all for that. One of the things I want to ask you about is, what exactly did you mean in that TSN interview when you said something to that extent of, that it's not (the situation regarding Hart's decision) what it appears, and that's true. It's not. But I didn't know where you're going with, what the hell was that phrase, the deceitful business practices? Hart: I don't know. I was kind of scrambling. I have no idea. To be honest, I felt pretty bad. I felt bad about having to sort of. McMahon: Address it. Hart: Well, I kind of felt bad that I had to fight as hard all week long to sort of leave with my head up. I thought it wouldn't be such a hard fight. McMahon: Well, I appreciate that. Hart: I thought, it's kind of been really hard. I broke out in cold sores and everything. I've been so stressed out on it. Even in Toronto when they asked me to do the job in the six-man. Geez, why would they beat the only Canadian in the match, in Canada, in Toronto? It's like almost like you, if you wanted to aggravate me or really keep pushing my. McMahon: Stick you with a stick. Hart: Yeah. It's like jeez, I didn't have a problem last night or anywhere else. But it just seems like, it wasn't, well I didn't think it was a very good call. McMahon: Well you and I have. . . Hart: If it's going to start to get nasty, like where it's, well I don't want to get nasty. I never ever wanted to leave here with any kind of bad feelings. But this week has been a bad week for me. I feel it's been really bad for me. I feel kind of betrayed a little bit. McMahon: Well, I do too a little bit. And it hasn't been a good week for me either. And like I said before, I'm determined this is going to wind up the right way. Because it should. And it should. So let's just make it that way.

Hart: Work backwards. McMahon: Yeah. Hart: And go forward again. McMahon: Yeah. Hart: Well, that's what I'd like to do. McMahon: Okay. Hart: I think it would be the classy way to go. I think it would be applauded by all sides. I think people would look at it as a nice, nice exit for me. Everyone knows. (They're thinking) How's he gonna exit? How's he gonna leave? I think it's the right way for me to go. I've never had a problem putting somebody over. I don't so much have a problem putting Shawn over, mind you I don't appreciate some of the things he's said, but my biggest thing is I think how this thing has been depicted, like the way it's aimed, it's really hard for me as a hero here to come up short this weekend, or tomorrow or the next day. And I've had nothing to do with the word getting out. McMahon: I know that. Hart: All I've tried to do is fend off the. McMahon: And again, as I mentioned to you when we had these conversations, all we're talking about is really is Ted Turner. That's what's coming between you and me. And that's all. I can't tell you how appreciative I will always be for everything you've done for this company. And like I said in our previous conversations I'd just be damned even though it's Ted Turner's money and Ted Turner's all that kind of shit, that's no reason for two people who have spent as much time as we have spent together through the years and have worked as closely as we have had through the years, it's no reason to have any problems. Hart: I couldn't agree more. I didn't want to leave with any problems. Actually I didn't want to leave at all. And then it's a point where you just, it seemed like there was no other choice but to go. But I've had a lot of hard feelings through the week I think over just what I thought should have been a fairly easy, I should have been able to leave fairly easy for just for what I've put in. (at this point the discussion breaks from the subject talking about other wrestlers, the fax machine story that is in the movie, WCW, what he wants to be remembered as a wrestler for, his legacy, and working with Hogan and his hoping the WWF would never erase his history from their history). Hart: I guess that's kind of why I've been so stubborn about this because for my 15 years here, it's been such a great story. . . McMahon: Uh, huh. Hart: Well, it's 14 years, to see 14 years here, to have it end in 20 minutes on a low note or a less than grand note just, I'd rather not have it at all. I'd rather not have any of it. I just take so much pride in everything I've ever done here, my Wembley match, my matches with Shawn (Hart starts going over his WWF career here and says that so many guys had their best matches with him) McMahon: I think there's no doubt. Not only the guys that are here now, but the guys that were here and left, and haven't had a good one since.

FINISHED IN COMMENTS!