Firstly, I will admit that Hyun-gyu lacks tact, charisma or affibality. He has a lot of self-pride and some of the reasons why people don't trust him can be related to how he comes across—and the fact that they can't manipulate him. If he loses, I do think it's from the consequences of some of his poor social play—but I am still rooting for him.
Also, he isn't as selfish as people make him out to be. He's more prideful and independent than selfish. He didn't earn anything in MM2 and MM3 because he prioritised his team. He could have moved to a higher square in MM2, but he chose not to.
However, I will admit that his big mistakes were 1) lying to Hyun-joon about his hidden game when Hyun-joon was offering an alliance (albeiy Hyun-joon would have turned on him either wat) 2) gunning for Se-dol under the logic that Se-dol was a strong player because following that logic meant he would be next (albeit again that he was going to get targeted no matter what) and 3) giving a very poor account of himself socially and ignoring the need to form alliances. His poor social play has him in alliance with someone constantly trying to backstab him—and he doesn't even notice. He totally ignored the need to actually make friends. Maybe he thought he was making friends with So-hee, but he didn't try very hard. His insistence on being independent, together with his pride and overconfidence, also undermines his ability to create alliances. That is probably his biggest flaw.
But right now, everyone has turned on Hyun-gyu, making him a bit of an underdog, regardless of the hidden game advantage, which only kicks in for the final. He only ever won pieces in MM1 and MM4, deservedly and he was under consideration for prison after MM2 and MM3. He even finished 10/12 after MM2. It's not like he has always been having it easy. He was lucky that his deserved winnings from MM1 kept him out of prison after MM2 and that he was chosen for the living room after being considered for prison after MM3 and after MM4. He should be forming alliances. His strategy of doing whatever he wants to isn't helping. But I still hope he succeeds.
Sure, he didn't have the valour or bravery to just volunteer himself or brace himself for the prison. He is a bit prideful and immature, and he doesn't give "hero" vibes and he is also very open about how it's a game and people should make cutthroat decisions. It's not the kind of statements people want to root for. At the same time, it is a gameshow and those characters with valour (e.g. Tinno, Se-dol) have been eliminated. Much of the surviving characters are either leading alliances or benefitting from them. Tinno shouldn't have volunteered himself to go to prison. Sang-yeon shouldn't have allowed himself to be sacrificed. Se-dol should have pushed to play the hidden game. You win when you get ahead.
Also, Hyun-gyu's own teammate in MM3 wanted to betray and eliminate him (again). He was just lucky that it didn't work out (and he was one place away wow!), but Hyun-joon and Eun-yoo put plans in place to do so. So it's not like Hyun-gyu was safe and coasting through the rounds, and that having valour was going to be to his benefit. He has been an outsider and underdog, just very lucky.
The only thing he should have done differently is at least have one or two friends/alliances.
Honestly, the justification for people wanting to eliminate him is odd. Apart from MM1, he hasn't shown himself to be the strongest player—and even there, he played well but he didn't come up with the winning strategy. In MM4, he did way better, but some of his ideas didn't work and he didn't uncover the most clues. He played well, but wasn't the strongest. Alliances of good or decent players, where each contributes, has been more of a motivating factor in winning than pure individual performance.
My view is that Hyun-gyu is a decent-enough player with good potential, who plays independently and doesn't just go along with what he is told. That can indeed be threatening and a motivation to eliminate him. He is also isolated so it's easy to rally players behind eliminating him. That's the conditions for the current ganging up against him, not so much that he is the strongest player or anything like that. He is strong enough to win, maybe, but it's mostly that he is an easy target—that's why they are targetting him.
It's an alliance of everyone against Hyun-gyu now, which makes me hope he can prove himself and come out on top. That would be so cool.
At the same time, even though he was excluded, he isn't that actually that evil of a player. He has not betrayed anyone in his own team, even if he doesn't outright listen to everything they suggest he should do. In the MM1, he doesn't betray the thieves or the other secret police. In MM2, he uses his triple yellow to help his team win, even though that causes him to finish close to last place.
But in both cases, he knocks heads with 7High. In MM1, Hyun-gyu wants to save a member of his green team instead of three Red team members—something that makes 7High upset. In MM2. he doesn't want to be the one to exile other players (even if he is fine with the exiling happening)—again against 7High's wishes.
Honestly, that is the best play. Should he just up and listen to whatever 7High says (like the other players do)? Taking three Red team members benefits 7High because that is his sphere of influence. It does not benefit Hyun-gyu at all—and Hyun-gyu played the MM1 excellently. He should be allowed to save someone from his team. And he was excluded from the alliance between the thieves, secret police and 7High in the first place!
He was already at a disadvantage from the beginning of the game because in the Living Room, there was an alliance between the 1-piece players and an alliance between the three older guys (he was not in any). It's not his fault, at this stage, that he was excluded. He is also excluded from the prison alliance. This is already from the beginning of the game. So he has no choice but to play alone, which is also maybe why he was so motivated to play the hidden game.
These exclusions are important because it means he was either just going to be a sideshow being used around to fulfill other players', especially 7High's, wishes. I don't think he wants to play as a fiddle. I admire that.
Maybe, he could go about it better. He did make mistakes. He shouldn't have lied, for instance. His downfall is partly his own, but I still hope he makes it out of being picked on.
He's like that kid with bad social skills who was excluded in the playground and then everyone expects him to put in all the work to make himself worthy enough to be included. Sure, he's done some unlikeable things, but beung excluded still sucks. Being betrayed by Hyun-joon is even worse.
The responsibility is shared. It's not up to someone alone to be liked, accepted, included etc. Maybe he was originally excluded from the alliance of older guys because he was young? Maybe, some players are intimidated by him? Maybe, he doesn't have the charm other players have? It's best for someone to just be themselves and play the best way they know how—and make it as far as they can. Also, maybe he would have played differently if he was included from the start.
Hyun-gyu is a player who is not just trying to survive, but is playing to win. I respect that—and I think the winner should be someone playing to win. At least other players who were targeted were not targeted by everyone. It's sad if he goes out like that, but I guess that is the game.
I most liked how he solved the 8x8 Knight's Tour. It's easier with a paper then real-life and he didnt practicr the 8x8, but instead applied the principles of the game. Now, he got help here from So-hee, no doubt, but it was still a good achievement solving the 8x8. Of course, also, he didn't find the clocks either, but he eas the first person to see the letters inside the clocks. He saw the letter 'T' and he also noticed the die. So it's not like he didn't play an active role in figuring out the clue to the hidden game—and it's something that the people who found the clocks did not figure out. So, sure he didn't figure it all out alone, but it's not like he was just sitting around doing nothing. He's persistence at solving the clues was instrumental.
My read is that Hyung-gyu does not concern himself with developing bonds and trust, so the only alliance he found himself in wasn't even that genuine. He might have difficulty with that in real life too. But he's not a villain. Far from it. He's just a flawed person who wants to win, and wants to be independent while doing it. He has something he wants to prove and maybe he'll fail at that, but he is going to push himself through any odds as best he can.
He's not necesarilly cruel or intolerable. He just lacks socialibility and likeability. But I'm still rooting for him!