r/TheCulture • u/wildskipper • Jun 09 '23
General Discussion Ten years to the day since we lost Iain Banks
Let's hope he's enjoying living with the sublimed.
r/TheCulture • u/wildskipper • Jun 09 '23
Let's hope he's enjoying living with the sublimed.
r/TheCulture • u/xoexohexox • May 20 '25
https://www.vox.com/culture/413502/iain-banks-culture-series-elon-musk-jeff-bezos-mark-zuckerberg
"The Culture is not good because they are strong. Their strength is a metaphor for their goodness. They have the best technology because that shows that they are rational, that they value intelligence, that they are motivated to give their citizens the best possible quality of life.
The Culture is not good because they are strong. Their strength is a metaphor for their goodness.
To avoid this idea when reading Banks, you would have to be exquisitely attuned to the pleasurable spectacle of technology and the power that tech offers its users, and then ignore everything else. In that case, what the broligarchs’ love of the Culture series reveals is that they see the world through the lens of power and spectacle first and foremost, and have no particular problem evading the work’s deeper meaning. That’s why this group has a propensity for big, pointless stunts, like trips to almost-space and carting a kitchen sink through Twitter headquarters and threatening to punch one another in a public fight. It’s as though they feel entitled to their power because their favorite book taught them that the side with the best tech always wins, and the most important thing you can do with that tech is put on a show. They seem not to have read deeply enough to understand what the book was really trying to say: that the most important thing powerful people can do is use their power to make the world freer, fairer, and more pleasurable for everyone else."
r/TheCulture • u/Sailbad_the_Sinner30 • Jan 05 '22
r/TheCulture • u/jabba1977 • Nov 24 '20
r/TheCulture • u/[deleted] • May 09 '19
tl;dr: start with either Consider Phlebas or The Player of Games, then read the rest in publication order. Or not. Then go read A Few Notes on the Culture if you have more questions that aren't explicitly answered in the books.
So, you're new to The Culture, have heard about it being some top-notch utopian, post-scarcity sci-fi, and are desperate to get stuck in. Or someone has told you that you must read these books, and you've gone "sure. I'll give it a go". But... where to start? Since this question appears often on this subreddit, I figured I'd compile the collective wisdom of our members in this sticky.
The Culture series comprises 9 novels and one short-story collection (and novella) by Scottish author Iain M. Banks.
They are, in order of publication:
Consider Phlebas
The Player of Games
Use of Weapons
The State of the Art (short story collection and novella)
Excession
Inversions
Look to Windward
Matter
Surface Detail
The Hydrogen Sonata
Banks wrote four other sci-fi novels, unrelated to the Culture: Against a Dark Background, Feersum Endjinn, The Algebraist and Transition (often published as Iain Banks). They are all worth a read too. He also wrote a bunch of (very good, imo) fiction as Iain Banks (not Iain M. Banks). Definitely worth checking out.
But let's get back to The Culture. With 9 novels and 1 collection of short stories, where should you start?
Well, it doesn't really make a huge difference, as the novels are very much independent of each other, with at most only vague references to earlier books. There is no overarching plot, very few characters that appear in more than one novel and, for the most part, the novels are set centuries apart from each other in the internal timeline. It is very possible to pick up any of the novels and start enjoying The Culture, and a lot of people do.
The general consensus seems to be that it is best to read the series in publication order. The reasoning is simple: this is the order Banks wrote them in, and his ideas and concepts of what The Culture is became more defined and refined as he wrote. However, this does not mean that you should start with Consider Phlebas, and in fact, the choice of starting book is what most people agree the least on.
Consider Phlebas is considered to be the least Culture-y book of the series. It is rather different in tone and perspective to the rest, being more of an action story set in space, following (for the most part) a single main character in their quest. Starkingly, it presents much more of an "outside" perspective to The Culture in comparison to the others, and is darker and more critical in tone. The story itself is set many centuries before any of the other novels, and it is clear that when writing it Banks was still working on what The Culture would eventually become (and is better represented by later novels). This doesn't mean that it is a bad or lesser novel, nor that you should avoid reading it, nor that you should not start with this one. Many people feel that it is a great start to the series. Equally, many people struggled with this novel the most and feel that they would have preferred to start elsewhere, and leave Consider Phlebas for when they knew and understood more of The Culture. If you do decide to start with Consider Phlebas, do so with the knowledge that it is not necessarily the best representation of the rest of the series as a whole.
If you decide you want to leave Consider Phlebas to a bit later, then The Player of Games is the favourite starting off point. This book is much more representative of the series and The Culture as a whole, and the story is much more immersed in what The Culture is (even though is mostly takes place outside the Culture). It is still a fun action romp, and has a lot more of what you might have heard The Culture series has to do with (superadvanced AIs, incredibly powerful ships and weapons, sassy and snarky drones, infinite post-scarcity opportunities for hedonism, etc).
Most people agree to either start with Consider Phlebas or The Player of Games and then continue in publication order. Some people also swear by starting elsewhere, and by reading the books in no particular order, and that worked for them too. Personally, I started with Consider Phlebas, ended with The Hydrogen Sonata and can't remember which order I read all the rest in, and have enjoyed them all thoroughly. SO the choice is yours, really.
I'll just end with a couple of recommendations on where not to start:
Inversions is, along with Consider Phlebas, very different from the rest of the series, in the sense that it's almost not even sci-fi at all! It is perhaps the most subtle of the Culture novels and, while definitely more Culture-y than Consider Phlebas (at least in it's social outlook and criticisms), it really benefits from having read a bunch of the other novels first, otherwise you might find yourself confused as to how this is related to a post-scarcity sci-fi series.
The State of the Art, as a collection of short stories and a novella, is really not the best starting off point. It is better to read it almost as an add-on to the other novels, a litle flavour taster. Also, a few of the short stories aren't really part of The Culture.
The Hydrogen Sonata was the last Culture novel Banks wrote before his untimely death, and it really benefits from having read more of the other novels first. It works really well to end the series, or somewhere in between, but as a starting point it is perhaps too Culture-y.
Worth noting that, if you don't plan (or are not able) to read the series in publication order, you be aware that there are a couple of references to previous books in some of the later novels that really improve your understanding and appreciation if you get them. For this reason, do try to get to Use of Weapons and Consider Phlebas early.
Finally, after you've read a few (or all!) of the books, the only remaining official bit of Culture lore written by Banks himself is A Few Notes on the Culture. Worth a read, especially if you have a few questions which you feel might not have been directly answered in the novels.
I hope this is helpful. Don't hesitate to ask any further questions or start any new discussions, everyone around here is very friendly!
r/TheCulture • u/fusionsofwonder • Aug 01 '22
r/TheCulture • u/the_turn • Dec 17 '25
As per this article: https://collider.com/these-8-upcoming-sci-fi-shows-based-on-books-could-be-epic/
I am cautiously optimistic that this adaptation may actually make it to production and release this time, but…
does anyone else have a lingering reservation around a corporation owned by the second wealthiest man in the world being responsible for adapting The Culture? It just seems like an insurmountable conflict of interests and theme. I do not trust that the corporation will remain true to the socialist themes of Banks’ work.
r/TheCulture • u/DeskDreamer • Oct 10 '20
r/TheCulture • u/wijnandsj • May 11 '24
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/advance-article/doi/10.1093/mnras/stae1186/7665761 scientists may have found Dyson spheres.
Or maybe not, t it's an interesting read
r/TheCulture • u/gclaws • Feb 21 '18
r/TheCulture • u/SecretCatPolicy • Jul 29 '19
r/TheCulture • u/infpburnerlol • Jan 10 '22
r/TheCulture • u/qed101 • Aug 24 '20
r/TheCulture • u/grapp • Dec 25 '22
r/TheCulture • u/clearly_quite_absurd • Feb 23 '26
Hamin's private estate could be straight out the Epstein files.
Shortly after that section, Banks even uses the phrase "fake news" in a book first published in 1988!
r/TheCulture • u/Forgotthebloodypassw • Jun 09 '26
It's hard to believe time has flown by so quickly. 13 years ago the news of his death was announced and there would be no more wonderful musings from this great talent.
RIP Iain, a person is not truly dead while their name is still spoken. GNU.
r/TheCulture • u/Dismal_Accident9528 • Jan 05 '25
When Gurgeh has his house party, a guest brings their pet, something called a proto-sentient Styglian enumerator. It's described as three-limbed, waist-high, blonde-haired, and having no discernible head but lots of little lumps. It shows up and just starts shuffling around the house, counting under its breath. First counting people, then furniture, then legs. Its only line of dialogue is when it walks up to Gurgeh and starts counting his toes while he's in the middle of a conversation with a woman. It mutters "say six" under its breath and then wanders off.
I don't think I've ever seen such a funky little critter as this. Absolute peak character, 100/10, best character in the series by far, needs its own spinoff novel.