r/TheBigPicture • • Dec 12 '24

My god I miss Amanda

14 Upvotes

Last night I finally got around to watching Maestro (which, by the way is…bad? Like I wanted to like it but…it was bad? And that’s okay! But like someone please give Bradley as Oscar already. He’s such a thirsty theater boi. But I’m glad that men can still find ways to feel important about themselves) anyways I’m watching it and then I totally remembered The Big Pic episode where Amanda gave her take on Maestro,

and so sitting there in my apartment, literally by myself, watching Maestro, chomping on hot hot slippery buttery popcorn, I started HOWLING with laughter and cackling GLORIOUSLY. Like, literally tears. I was sweating and moist from laughter. Even now just thinking about it I’m grinning like a goddamn idiot.

All that to say—I MISS AMANDA! I know, I know it’s been said before. I’m a parasocial sicko as hell. But I do!!! My god I do. I want her back so bad.

She’s a mother, wife, friend, lover, professional film critic—she’s an American woman in the year of our Lord 2024. Be still, my heart!

I admit, I didn’t always “get her,” you know? I’m thought she was unprepared and unprofessional and a brat, but then one day it clicked for me, like, YES, I see what she’s doing and it’s goddamn GLORIOUS. Shes not stupid or annoying. She’s the glue. Shes that stickiness that keeps everything together. She’s the foil to Sean’s white male dude-bro. She’s the person you grab a beer with and Sean is that white dude bro mainsplaining about DFW.

Amanda IS NOT a brat. She’s BRAT (like BRAT Summer). She’s not just the best part of The Big Pic. SHE IS THE GODDAMN BIG PIC. Fuck, like, you either get it or you don’t, you know? And she totally does. She gets it. She IS it!

Okay fuck I need a nap or a snack now yall lol


r/TheBigPicture • • Nov 27 '24

Y'all owe her an apology!

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/TheBigPicture • • Apr 16 '24

The best thing about the 1999 Draft episode…

5 Upvotes

…is the fact that they somehow managed to keep Bill off of it. Given his love for some of these movies, I’m super grateful we dodged that bullet somehow.


r/TheBigPicture • • Nov 22 '25

Someone do a mental health check on Sean

Post image
5 Upvotes

This is a crime against classic American literature!

ps no hate, im just gloating as a Wicked and BP fan

pss. Its a JOKE. I think Sean’s anger is funny. I love TBP


r/TheBigPicture • • Jul 10 '25

Hot Take Dakota Johnson is the best part of Materialists

4 Upvotes

I finally watched Materialists. Mostly overwritten and the caveman stuff and Pedro Pascal were especially bad. Sean is wrong. I don’t know how else to say it. Dakota J is a very subtle and watchable actress. Her character is just subsumed into her mannerisms and consciousness. She doesn’t seem actorly or fake. The fact that Sean likes Anne Hathaway and doesn’t like Dakota really makes me question his entire actor meter.


r/TheBigPicture • • Sep 19 '26

Discussion CR’s criticism of modern horror feeling it has to “justify itself” with personal trauma and social commentary is EXACTLY why I hated Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma

0 Upvotes

Doesn’t this quote below perfectly describe Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma? Like does anyone really give a shit that Jason Voorhees was bullied as a kid?

Just wanted to get that off my chest and see if anyone agrees, because I’m still pretty baffled by the TSDCM reception and feel like it’s tonally 2-3 years behind trend.

______

Horror movies are becoming a drag […] sitting through 45 minutes of ponderous self-examination and sadness rather than, “is this scary and fun?” […] I wanted to be scandalized and terrified. However you want to describe elevated horror, I think that the long tail of that is like a haunted house movie or a possession movie or a scary guy in the woods movie, but we're like talking about like, “Why is he scary though? Why is this guy in the woods? […] And why were you in the woods in the first place? Did your mom die? Like you're probably pretty sad about that. Let's talk a lot about that.” I'm just tired of it.


r/TheBigPicture • • Feb 22 '24

Saltburn is good and rewatchable.

0 Upvotes

Just signed up for my Prime Video and watched Saltburn for the first time on Monday. Watched it again tonight with my wife. Really solid movie……Oxford scenes were great, Rosamund Pike is perfect, awesome soundtrack, and very stylish. It’s by no means a great movie and the last 30 minutes are sort of a mess……..but it’s really fun and entertaining. Weird that Sean and Amanda always complain about the lack of mid budget thrillers and they get one in Saltburn and pick it a part. I could see this movie being a “Rewatchable” in a few years.


r/TheBigPicture • • Nov 05 '25

The <blank> of it all

0 Upvotes

I really need Dobbins to stop saying this phrase every single episode.

And while we are at it, the can also retire “it’s very <blank> coded.


r/TheBigPicture • • Jul 20 '25

It's hilarious watching people meltdown over Ari Aster

0 Upvotes

Every time an Ari movie comes out just like tons of people just lose their minds. It's hilarious to me. Have you heard of Verhoven?! He's in on the joke! It's HILARIOUS TO ME THAT YOU HAVE ANY CRITICISMS ABOUT HIM WHATSOEVER.

Edit: lol at you taking the bait.


r/TheBigPicture • • Jul 27 '25 Helpful

Discussion The Fantastic Four Episode is really irritating.

0 Upvotes

I know that Marvel movies aren’t “real cinema,” and I understand and agree that the last few years of comic book stuff has been passable to downright terrible, but I don’t remember a pod in recent memory from Amanda and Sean that misses the mark this completely. Listening to them fumble over each other as Amanda performatively misremembers previous Marvel entries and Sean earnestly acts like he knows fantastic four comics when he very clearly doesn’t had me feeling very frustrated up until the very final moments of the pod. I have not listened to an episode that I think in its entirety was in such bad faith from them and I’m really just shocked and surprised. Even more so given Sean’s earnest and honest love of Superman and the almost universal praise for FF thus far.

I’m wondering if anyone else thought or felt this? I just really don’t get the take here, and I think they almost missed the forest for the trees here — and maybe the trees too — in some major ways.

For the record, I love the pod and I rarely feel negatively toward them as hosts or disagree with their opinions. This is part of why I feel so alienated by this pod.


r/TheBigPicture • • Aug 10 '25

Discussion Bullet Train on a Plane

0 Upvotes

I was on a work trip and needed something for the flight that required minimal attention - a good ol’ second screener - while I got some work done. Instead, I was enraptured by how bad this flick was. I’m not sure there’s anything redeeming in it.

If Guy Ritchie is garbage Tarantino; is this garbage Chad St. John?

It looks cheap. Every line of dialogue feels like it was created by an LLM. The Reynolds cameo.

Could we have just gotten Atomic Blonde 2?


r/TheBigPicture • • Aug 05 '24

Sean & Amanda Really Pumped Up The Fall Guy

0 Upvotes

Now the I have seen it, I feel compelled to ask, was that a bit? Movie sucks. At least in my opinion.
Reasons the Fall Guy is bad:
-Emily Blunt is wildly miscast
-Aaron Taylor Johnson is wildly miscast, and a missed opportunity for something that could've been funny
-Even in action comedy a modicum of character development is nice, this film had none
-The "satire" is extremely soft where it could've been pointed or specific

Gosling is good, Winston Duke is good, Hannah Waddingham is good. The movie stinks. Quite poor. Just one mans opinion.


r/TheBigPicture • • Oct 07 '25

Poor Sean

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/TheBigPicture • • Dec 18 '25

The ads are becoming insufferable

0 Upvotes

That is all


r/TheBigPicture • • May 26 '24

I like 'The Big Picture' more than 'The Watch' now!

9 Upvotes

Lots of reasons for this....

  • Sean and Amanda being way more innovative regarding content (Movie Drafts, Movie Star Rankings, Hall of Fames)

  • Sean's passion for movies and movie theaters (trying to save them)

  • TV being absolute trash in 2024. During the 2010s, I absolutely took television more seriously than movies. That's no longer the case. There hasn't been a great show since 'The Bear' Season 2 (I've heard good things about 'Shogun'....not really into historical epics).

  • Despite the terrible box office, I've actually been really into movies this year. I loved 'Dune II', 'Challengers', 'Love Lies Bleeding.' Even trash like 'Miller's Girl' was more entertaining than any tv show I've seen this year.

Has this become anyone else's favorite Ringer podcast?


r/TheBigPicture • • Sep 30 '24 Heart of Silver

I Saw the TV Glow

0 Upvotes

I was so excited for this movie. So, so excited. The pod with Adam Nayman and the director made it sound like it was made for me.

I was kind of a lonely kid. Obsessed with things in pop culture. Particularly music/tv/movies.

Even as the movie started I was like this is perfect. The imagery was so beautiful. Particularly the color. Shots like the one in the gym class under the parachute. Otherworldly. Incredibly cinematic.

And then it went nowhere. The acting (outside of Justice Smith and even he was up and down...) was awful. There was no plot. There was no character development. There was almost no dialogue except for one or two speeches and one or two outbursts. I thought the actress/model who played Maddy was abysmal. The aging of the actors seemed wrong at every point except maybe the preteen version of Owen.

Did anyone else feel crestfallen by the end of this film?


r/TheBigPicture • • Dec 18 '23

Will the 2023 Oscars age worse than any?

0 Upvotes

Everything, everywhere all at once

The Whale

All Quiet on the Western Front

Basically won every award. I think time won’t be good to EEAAO, I personally found it insufferable and think that’ll be a prevailing thought when people start to rewatch it.

I don’t know anyone who thought the Whale was good, Fraser Oscar was a classic dumb one for a guy people like. Not as bad as the JLC one though…

AQOTWF - I liked it, but will probably never rewatch it. Will probably fade into memory and the awards it did win weren’t for ‘Stars’ or guys we’ll see much again.


r/TheBigPicture • • Nov 25 '24

Hot Take Gladiator II was better than Wicked.

9 Upvotes

I liked Wicked, but in between the musical numbers, it felt kind of dull, and you could definitely feel the filler in the story. I thought Gladiator II kicked ass. Am I crazy?


r/TheBigPicture • • Sep 22 '23

Amanda saying she hasn’t been scared in a movie since she was 12 is ridiculous

0 Upvotes

I just don’t believe her. She acts like she’s above it and too mature to get scared. I like Amanda, but I hate how she talks about horror movies.


r/TheBigPicture • • Sep 20 '25

Discussion Margot Robbie's follow up to Barbie flops. She was ranked number one on The Big Picture's 35 under 35 Movie Stars

Post image
0 Upvotes

Turns out there is no "Barbie boost" to her box office drawing power.


r/TheBigPicture • • Aug 13 '26

Discussion Way, way too early Best Picture predictions

Post image
0 Upvotes

EDITING THIS POST, NEW LIST BELOW … THE PEOPLE HAVE SPOKEN:

After much debate and discussion, I’m adjusting my predictions:

OUT: Cliff Booth, The Debut, Fjord

IN: Wild Horse Nine, Digger, Project Hail Mary

On the bubble: Obsession … for Dune 3

Original post below:

I was thinking about Nolan potentially cruising to another BP Oscar and decided to predict what else might get a nom. Honestly, outside of The Odyssey, La Bola Negra felt like the only surefire lock (given Netflix’s seeming big show of support for it). Everything else here is a bit of a shot from the hip, an attempt to triangulate what typical Oscars taste seems to be these days.

Toughest cuts:

Project Hail Mary … I don’t think there will be room for this and The Odyssey and Dune Part 3 … and I think it’ll just be the one most forgotten by the end of the year.

Digger … Idk. This should probably be in. I feel like I have Cliff Booth in the spot instead, and I could totally see WB pushing Digger even harder than Dune. Maybe Digger should be in and Dune should be out? Is Digger going to win BP? I guess I just look at a comedy where none of the most important people involved are not comedians and i start to get queasy. High ceiling/low floor.

Obsession … Don’t think there’s a big enough Gen Z contingent in the academy.

Wild card bad movie that should maybe be here: Michael


r/TheBigPicture • • Apr 15 '26

News Hopecore Is the Vibe Shift Hollywood Needs

Thumbnail
hollywoodreporter.com
0 Upvotes

r/TheBigPicture • • Oct 19 '25

Does anyone else watch for Amanda's outfits? They're always outstanding. Same with Charles and Van from

0 Upvotes

Midnight Boys


r/TheBigPicture • • Jun 07 '26

it’s a parody movie. It’s not meant to win Oscar’s, just chill

Post image
0 Upvotes