r/TheAgora • • Jan 21 '13

We've all heard of the media's liberal bias and I've even heard "Reality has a liberal bias." Why does it seem that liberals are closer in tune with reality than conservatives? Is this a fair or objective assessment?

8 Upvotes

Something tells me it has to do with the self-correcting nature of progressives, who are by definition unchained by tradition and are therefore free to, if not encouraged to, consider new vistas of thought. Insofar as a liberal has the option of thinking outside the box, and is not anchored by immutable principles, that liberal thinker will have an advantage when it comes to stumbling on the truth. The ethic of liberalism seems to resemble the scientific method, while conservatives seem to be overly concern with the purity or authority of established institutions.

Please, bring on the criticism or counterarguments.


r/TheAgora • • Sep 17 '15

I am interested in discussing my political philosophy: anarcho-capitalism. 'Why are you not an anarcho-capitalist?'

0 Upvotes

Anarcho-capitalism is mostly an acceptance of property, non-aggression, and the 'extreme' consequences there of. The most 'extreme' part being anarchy. My acceptance of anarchy, that is 'no rulers', is the result of being unable to find a credible case that rules made by governments apply to me or my property. If such a case does not exist then their interactions with me would be aggression.

I take 'capitalism' to mean private property and free trade. And no more. Many people try to push more on to that word despite my clear definition. Don't be that user. Private property stems from 'self-ownership' and thus owning the effects of your actions. Free trade is a consequence of non-aggression.

I am interested in understanding the basic essential differences in thought between myself and those who think differently.

Edit: the voting behavior suggest to me that people in this group dont have much of a commitment to seeking truth. Of course people can say whatever they want, I expect some low quality posts. But when low quality posts out rank high quality posts I feel concern. The comments are not as I expected, so I do not intend to be posting again.


r/TheAgora • • Mar 06 '11

Help me refute an argument

0 Upvotes

If there are limited resources on earth argument assumes each person is entitled to an equal share. e.g. there are 100 food units on the planet with 100 people. By that proposition each person is entitled to a single food unit. By the use of artificial means oligarch will seize more units and deprive another less capable person of much needed food. Eventually he will control more food units and consequently people dependent on it (unequal distribution of wealth in postmodern society).

Help me attack this argument.

edit:

I apologize for poor articulation. In later reply I posed potential issues with two different perceptions of current economic system deliberately excluding option of economic efficiency growth. My objective was to demonstrate limited resources (oil, water, land, air pollution etc) and allocation of these resources in order to better understand potential discourse between sides A and B.


r/TheAgora • • Feb 06 '12

My argument (kinda) for Dualism, AKA why there are two universes inside of one larger universe.

0 Upvotes

Hello all,

So, I've been reading Hawking's Brief History of Time lately and my theoretical physics circuits have been firing on all cylinders. If you haven't read it yet, I highly recommend you do! Great science explained through everday analogies.

Anyway, reading it, I was just thinking that based on his model of the universe as a self contained spherical like object composed of space time, there must be some kind of mechanism (like an impulse of some sort) of spacetime itself that moves forward and then back to its "starting point" (in his analogy, the North Pole). So, as spacetime moves forward it gets bigger and bigger till it hits the 'equator', then it starts to shrink back, until the so called "Big Crunch" happens at the analogous "South Pole". This is the end of the first half of the equation in my mind.

After the "end of spacetime" is reached (we hit the south pole) it loops back around on itself and changes direction, proceeding now in the direction of "negative spacetime". I think this negative movement of spacetime is a new universe that is the antithesis of our own universe, composed of antimatter.

So from here, negative spacetime progresses in a very similar manner to "normal" spacetime, only backwards. As hawking explains in his book, "the laws of science are unchanged under the comination of operations (or symmetries) know as C (changing particles for antiparticles), P (mirror image), and T (reversing the direction of motion of all particles). So, in other words, its a completely assbackwards version of our universe.

My theory is that once this negaverse is done doing its thing, and negative spacetime reaches the "North Pole", our universe more or less starts over again, and this cycle that I described keeps going on forever. The big takeaway is that the whole universe(our universe plus the negaverse) is this quantum spacetime object that fluctuates in a neverending cycle.

Wow, I could write a paper on this that no one would read. Anywho, feel free to prove me wrong, yadda yadda; also as a disclaimer, I haven't finished ABHoT yet, still got I think 2 chapters to go, so if he explains things there, go ahead and tell me, I don't mind spoilers.

TL;DR: There are 2 Universes which are opposites of eachother, and the whole universe is a spacetime object that cycles through them in an alternating fashion for eternity.

Edit: I am aware that this is a very "out there" theory and probably isn't correct. I just want people to discuss it with so I can be shown to be wrong. Please don't downvote guys; nobody will see this and that will make me a sad panda bear. :(


r/TheAgora • • Oct 26 '10

Marijuana is illegal for good reason

2 Upvotes

I see a lot of arguments for and against the legalization of marijuana. To be clear, I am speaking only of recreational marijuana. The arguments pertaining to medicinal marijuana are more complicated as they involve more value judgments.

Though marijuana, in itself does not kill people, I do believe that marijuana can ruin lives. If we all believe that we should refrain from participating in activities that have a good chance of ruining our lives, then we should refrain from smoking marijuana.

Personal Liberty. Should one have the liberty to ruin one's life?

What makes a life good or ruined. If smoking marijuana makes a life good (because it makes it fun or whatever value you want to place here), then it cannot really count as ruining a life.

*Personal biases maybe. I had smoked marijuana before but I gave it up. I have friends that smoke marijuana. Although I cannot know for sure if they would've been any better off without smoking, I think it is true. I had argued with a friend about whether marijuana actually has any negative effect on his life. I had friends that said they think so and some say they do not think so. I do not have any statistics that back this position. Only anecdotal evidence I had acquired. I estimate it to be a bit over 60%. More often than not, I believe smoking marijuana had a significant negative effect on the person's life

Although I do not have solid statistics (I would be very grateful to anyone who would provide them regardless of whether it hurts or supports my case because it would completely dismantle or strongly reinforce this argument) I do not believe I need statistics to measure what I can see in front of me. The events are not fine enough to require exact measurements. Generalities will do.

10/25/2010 - Major Edit. Changed from Marijuana should be illegal to we should not smoke marijuana.

10/27/2010 - I was originally planning on continuing my argument today. I wanted to qualify what I mean when I say "ruins a life", the reasoning why I think it is an appropriate definition, and why smoking marijuana would qualify for this term.

But before I continue my reasoning, I would like to read all the comments below to respond to each point and to take into consideration their points.

I feel kind of bad for not continuing with my argument so I will provide a very vague definition of a "Ruined Life"

Ruined Life: is a life that does not meet expectations (I know it is very vague and I expect severe criticisms. You should ask: who's expectations? how much must you fall short? how can you even quantify something like this? why do expectations even matter?) To say simply, I will argue it if I have to (I know I will probably have to) your own expectations in a specific state of mind, a significant amount based upon your own preference, and hopefully, I won't even have to quantify something as difficult to measure as this. To explain why expectations matter is a whole paragraph in of itself. I want to say, "You don't want to smoke weed, for your own reasons."

Post is very long and will only be longer, I will try to edit to save space. I will note any significant changes.

11/6/2010 - Hey, so I know that I said I would come back here and try to continue this argument but applying to graduate school is taking a lot more of my time than I thought it would. I would like to finish this conversation but I do not think I would have the time. I will stop continuing and replying to this post today. Sorry to lead you all on like this. I will finish reading to comments other noted below and perhaps make simple comments. I suppose it is the least I can do. Other people can feel free to use this post but I will no longer be working on it. Perhaps, when I finish applying (maybe Mid-December) I will come back to it. Thank you all for contributing.


r/TheAgora • • Sep 22 '15

No Point

1 Upvotes

Beyond a certain extent, there is no point to philosophizing, not really. I appreciate the kind of philosophy that Epicurus or the Stoics propounded - that is, an intensely pragmatic philosophy along the lines of, "if you want to live your life this way, do this." But then, those people didn't spend the rest of their lives pondering lofty ideals disconnected from basic human needs, which I think is the flaw in most philosophies, western or eastern (as much as eastern religious philosophies are "philosophies", i.e. Buddhist Abhidharma or Confucianism, etc.). Epicurus lived in sort of a proto-commune with his adherents and apparently lived very simply, but he spent time then engaging other people in social relationships. I'm trying to say, at least extrapolating from myself, life really doesn't have to be so arch-intellectually complicated - people need shelter, basic security, food and drink, satisfying sexual relationships and friendships, and work that gives them a sense of purpose, exercise, sunshine.

Life can never be perfect or find dissatisfaction totally absent from it, but I think having those pretty basic things goes a long, long ways towards emotional and physical health and happiness. Philosophy (for most people, at least) isn't about knowing what is true, but about knowing what is true and secretly hoping truth will lead to happiness. So, it's really about happiness, and studies I've read about on happiness and contentment in life say that happiness has much more to do with emotions and little to do with intellectual prowess. You can have all the intellectual prowess in the world, but if you don't also have your basic emotional needs met somehow, it won't really matter.


r/TheAgora • • Nov 30 '15

Isn't geometrical point logically impossible conception?

0 Upvotes

It seems for me, that Euclidean geometry is broken, because it uses absurd conception named "point". Why? Because any point has zero dimensions. But if a geometrical object has zero dimensions, then this means it doesn't occupy any space. But if it doesn't occupy any space, then there is no way for this geometrical object to be able to exist. Statement "There is a physical object what exists and takes no space at the same time" seems self-contradictory for me.


r/TheAgora • • Jan 02 '12

[x-post]Political activism + bad writer = fail?

0 Upvotes

x-post from r/writing, text as provided:

I am in the process of trying to get a group of subreddits off the ground. I am also wanting to start a grass roots organization. However, I feel as if my writing skills lacks what is necessary to be able to condense a message into the size that explains my point yet isn't overly inflated. Also I tend to over explain things at times and not be as clear as I'd like at others. What I am looking for is someone who can help read over some of the things that I write and possibly edit it. This would be without payment. If I had the money to pay I most certainly would. If more than one person wanted to help it would be great to have a team of people to help with this. I can explain more if necessary. Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.


r/TheAgora • • Jan 13 '12

Mathematical Functions as Enzymes

3 Upvotes

What has most astounded me recently is the fact that a function implies motion. I never used to get that, that math was an actual process and not just sets of numbers.

But what has confused me is, what do functions do? They seem to draw two numbers together, create a ordered pair for a Cartesian coordinate. How does this happen? I posit that functions are like enzymes. To explain this I will first explain an enzyme.

Imagine an enzyme with two sites. One holds the substrate, the thing to be acted upon, and one holds the co-factor, a complementary molecule needed to push the enzyme into the right shape so it can hold the substrate.

Fig. 1

I think that x acts like the co-factor in the relationship, and y the substrate. If f(x)=x+3, then a co-factor of 4 shapes the function so that only 7 fits, so y = 7. A x of 5 makes it so only 8 fits, so y =8. And so on.

So I posit that this is how functions produce ordered pairs.


r/TheAgora • • Jan 06 '11

The jury was wrong in "the McDonald's coffee case".

10 Upvotes

The case of the woman who spilled hot coffee on herself and successfully sued for an initial award of millions of dollars is well known. However, opinion on the validity of the case has changed in the public's perception over time. For a long time it was the poster case for US sue happy culture gone wrong. Many people, on learning the extent of Liebeck's (the plaintiff) injuries and other apparent facts of the case, consider her win as the appropriate result.

It is my contention that Liebeck's claim was completely without merit and that no award should have been made, neither in compensatory nor punitive damages. Discuss.

EDIT: Can I ask people not to downvote this post. Unless of course you feel that the discussion is out of place in TheAgora, in which case I'd like to hear why. Otherwise you are simply stifling the discussion, which is against everything TheAgora is meant to stand for.


r/TheAgora • • Nov 27 '10

Lets Kill The Argument. Euthanasia Should Remain Illegal

3 Upvotes

Euthanasia is suicide assisted by a willing volunteer. The publicized campaigns for euthanasia legalization I've seen are centered around people with terminal illnesses who are in constant untreatable pain, who want to die with dignity and/or end the suffering without having to resort to jumping off a building.

If individuals are not affected by a mental illness that impedes their ability to act on their own accord, then they will always have the freedom to choose to end their life at any point. However, it follows circularly that if suicide is the wrong thing to do for the wellbeing of the person, then it should be discouraged by a society that values the wellbeing of its constituents.

Discouragement of suicide implies discouragement of assisted suicide, as the two have the same outcome. However, just because something should be discouraged doesn't necessarily mean it should be made illegal. Smoking is a legal activity that comes to mind discouraged by society, but not made illegal because it impedes on an individual's right to liberty.

Having euthanasia illegal, on the other hand, does not impede on anyone's liberty. A quadriplegic who physically cannot turn off her life support machine is not having her liberty impeded as she is not being prevented from choosing to end her own life by someone else or the state. Whether or not she physically can or not is irrelevant. A doctor keeping the machine on also is not impeding her liberty as the doctor is merely maintaining her status quo of being alive.

I submit that there are an infinite number of possibilities for how the future will unfold. If this is the case, then there is always the possibility that one event in the future will make the past retroactively worthwhile, therefore making suicide and assisted the suicide the wrong thing to do in all circumstances.

Conclusion:

Since keeping euthanasia illegal doesn't impede on anyone's liberty, and suicide should be discouraged by society because it is wrong, euthanasia should remain illegal.

EDIT:I'm scared because I used the words "always" and "anyone". Preparing to be ripped to shreds!


r/TheAgora • • Apr 18 '12

I am a feminist. Are you?

33 Upvotes

i. Ways of being a person

The article "Making Up People" by Ian Hacking is, I think, the best place to begin understanding my premises.

The basic idea is that people are not born this way or that way (contrary to what Ms. Gaga professes) so much as they are “made up” or “dressed up” this way or that way. For instance, one is not born, but rather becomes, a lawyer.

I imagine that this is an easy notion to agree with for most for you, but can you also agree with the statement “[o]ne is not born, but rather becomes, a woman” as easily? What about the same statement made of men? of ethnic groups? If so, you’re probably a feminist, among other things.

The reasoning behind this thinking is that people can’t just be, period. They have to be someone. Who that someone turns out to be occurs through the interplay of both society and individual, not through just one or the other. Being a woman requires a society plus an individual just as much as being a lawyer requires those things.

It used to be that the options for who some people could be were incredibly limited. Peasants couldn’t be kings, black people couldn’t be president, etc. Indeed, people even believed that you were born into your occupation. People were born to be lawyers or bakers or derelicts.

In the last 100 years, but especially in the last 50, we’ve come to rethink the eternal nature of such roles entirely. We have come to see the limited options for who we can be as oftentimes arbitrary and constructed by ruling groups, and we have come to value a society that opens up for us a whole vista of possibilities, equally, for everybody.

Some people are a little more conservative about this point of view than others, though. While they accept a lot of the historical arbitrariness of roles, they ask us to rethink the extent to which a lot of the limitations we face concerning our identities is the result of economic realities and not just arbitrary judgments.

It is an economic reality, for instance, that I cannot become a lawyer until I go to four years of college and then law school. It can’t happen overnight. You can even say that it is an “economic reality” that I cannot be an ethnic Zulu if I was born as a white person in the United States.

Most debates in politics stem from this difference in sensibility. Some see our menu of social roles as too arbitrary and servicing of higher orders. Others view the porridge as just right, so to speak, since our options reflect the economic realities of the time.

Now, since I’m not here to talk about the Left-Right dichotomy, allow me to choose one without presenting a giant case for it. After all, the player of an RPG must choose a class before setting out for an adventure. So I choose Leftist.

ii. Patriarchy

With that in mind, we may now ask ourselves (thus finally getting on with the topic!) to what extent is gender arbitrary and servicing of dominant groups, if at all? How is this arbitrariness and exploitation organized, if at all? But the most important question to ask is, how would a feminist answer the above two questions?

This particular feminist will answer them as follows: (1) there persists presently and rampantly a reasonable degree of arbitrariness and exploitation in certain gender roles, and (2) this is organized around a patriarchy (or patriarchies).

A lot of people, especially on the Left, agree with my (1) but not my (2). They say that gender arbitrariness is not as easy to parse out as that. I hope to show that there really isn't a distinction in agreeing with (1) but not (2). If we agree that wherever arbitrariness exists, it usually indicates some sort of dominating group of people accessing this arbitrariness for gain, then we should agree that it is important to name this group, even if people do not enter into this group permanently, but rather float in an out of it through their actions.

Patriarchy is the mechanism by which people may be included in the group who benefit from the arbitrary and unequal terms of gender. It is not the group itself.

Now, this is why it might seem at first that feminists are suggesting that the group most benefiting from arbitrary gender roles is men necessarily (and that they are therefore "man-haters."). This isn’t so. A given patriarchy does not equal a given collection of men. It is not the set of all men. Indeed, patriarchy does not equal any collection of individuals at all. Women can be just as patriarchal as men, given the opportunity and payouts for doing so. (Think of conservative housewives who preach about where a “woman’s place” is.)

A good analogy would be drawing a powerful card in a game of Magic: The Gathering. The Patriarchy Card is incredibly useful if it arises in certain games. You’ll probably win that specific game if it is drawn and played (given the presence of the appropriate land card, of course).

The difference, however, is that The Patriarchy Card can be played without every showing up on the table. It can be "sleeved." This is because, again, patriarchy isn't the group. It is the way of becoming a member of the group. (Whereas genders like man and woman represent both the group and the way of becoming members of the group.) In other words, patriarchs don't exist, just patriarchy.

Now, you might be asking, “If anybody can technically manipulate patriarchy in a given situation, if anybody can be a secret patriarch, why the suffix patri-? Why the emphasis on masculinity over femininity?”

Here we must underscore technically. Actual “gameplay” suggests that men have greater access to The Patriarchy Card in their “decks” more than women (to keep with our Magic analogy). That is to say, men receive more frequent access to a position whereby one may leverage whatever weaknesses exist in gender roles at that time than women. This is itself a weakness in the gender woman, one which has not been proved to be a necessary part of being a woman.

The natural follow-up question to all of this is, of course, what about systems that reward people at the exclusion of being a man? What about mechanisms for manipulating your way to an enjoyable status on the sole basis of being a woman? What about matriarchies?

The simple truth of the matter is that historians and anthropologists find it hard to point to any real-life examples of matriarchy. For the most part, patriarchy has prevailed by a huge margin all over the world. (About the closest thing to a matriarchy scholars know is the Iroquois culture.)

There is still much more to be said of patriarchy. For now, however, I will let that monster sleep.

iii. Final notes

It is here where I must rest my weary typing fingers and end this post, not for any logical or narrative purpose, but merely due to an exhaustion of my own patience. Such resignation is not uncommon in the discourse of feminism. The topic will oftentimes exhaust you before you exhaust it.

We should nonetheless recap.

  • There are many ways of being in relation to the world, some which are masculine and others which are feminine.

  • Most people encounter the terms upon which we may be this or that as predefined by society.

  • A masculine way of being in relation to the world enjoys a systematic position of privilege insofar as being a man allows one to influence the terms upon which other people may be x or y more so than the other way around. This is called patriarchy.

  • Matriarchy, the feminine version of the above privilege, is logically possible ableit actually rare, if not altogether nonexistent.

  • The reason for this is not a destiny in genetics or some such other such facts, but rather a snowball effect stemming from single chink in women’s armor (which can be discussed later).

  • Patriarchy persists today.

That’s it. If you agree with the above bullet points, you’re a feminist.


r/TheAgora • • Apr 17 '12

Jonathan Foley @Ted - The Other Inconvenient Truth

0 Upvotes

Great video on the importance of radical transformation of our agriculture systems.


r/TheAgora • • Nov 02 '10

The income tax is theft.

0 Upvotes

Theft is the acquisition of property without consent from the original owner.

Consent is only possible when there is no threat of harm for non-compliance.

Income is the good an individual has received (usually money) from another party. Usually the income is the wage an employee received for his work. Because the employer is the rightful owner of his money, he has the right to give it to a worker, relinquishing his ownership to the worker.

The income tax is the state's acquisition of this earned money from the worker. The worker does not give consent because he is under the threat of harm from the state for non-compliance.

Therefore, the income tax is theft.


r/TheAgora • • Feb 01 '11

Resistance should be exercised at will; not governed by reason

0 Upvotes

This sounds axiomatic to me, so why is it ignored so much?

First, it implies that resistance should be understood as something already possessed by the observer. Meaning that resistance is something someone already has. This statement is justified simply by tracing the source of resistance. Which I take to be the void of reason. It seems that one resists most when they have nothing to lose.

The puts great emphasis on value because it defines what you cherish most and what point you resist. You don't decide to resist. It just comes to fruition.

So rather than put reason to resistance, we should focus more on what we value because that can be changed with reason. Which greatly changes what we resist. And also value is how we define ourselves.

An example.

If you smoke and want to quit, it seems more effective to outweigh the value of smoking with the value of something that includes not smoking. Yet rather than put the effort into doing that, we usually just repeat empty mantras of hypothetical scenarios where the smoker exist without smoking.


r/TheAgora • • Nov 25 '12

How can modern/contemporary art be appreciated?

0 Upvotes

It takes a certain amount of skill to produce a work of fine art. For example, one must practice an instrument for a long time in order to play it skillfully and produce beautiful music. Practice makes perfect, as the saying goes.

Yet when I go into a museum and see a painting whose artist wantonly threw paints upon a canvas, or monochrome shapes littering a white background, I do not think that it took any amount of skill to make something like that. Anyone could do it and pass themselves off as an artist.

(If the term "modern/contemporary" isn't specific enough, perhaps "minimalist" might be better. Hopefully you know what I mean regardless.)


r/TheAgora • • Feb 21 '12

Just thinking about a line from my favorite book of all time.

8 Upvotes

This is your life, and it is ending one minute at a time. -Tyler Durden, Fight Club

This is true. You cannot fight this. You cannot change this inherent truth of the world. What you can decide is what you are going to do with this knowledge. You can decide to wallow is self pity, knowing that your life is insignificant and small. You can deny it and believe that there is more to life than just this. You can say that this cannot be true because there is something more after this life and that after your last minute is up you will be given more. You can rebel and shout defiantly into the empty that your life is not ending and that you are not the same meat as the rest of us. You can accept this as truth and strive everyday to make the best of the time that you have, knowing that you are the same meat as the rest of us. You can simply ignore it and hope that it goes away.

How you choose to react to this statement reveals more about you than any other single factor. There is no right way to react to this statement. One way is not inherently “healthier” than another. It simply reveals who you are. But, if you are able to be honest with yourself about how you choose to react to this and why you are doing so you are a more conscience person than most of us.

It is a statement of profound power and terrifying implications and in my mind the most fundamental of all ideas. What do you think about my conclusions. Am I full of it or do you agree? Let me know


r/TheAgora • • Apr 30 '11

A case for suicide following the loss of a loved one

5 Upvotes

Premises:

  1. I have lost my beloved (or parent, or child, or what have you) to the grave.

  2. My beloved is more important to me than anything else, even life itself.

  3. Because of the limitations of our senses, we cannot be certain that we have an accurate perception of reality.

  4. It is possible that we are not experiencing reality as it actually is.

  5. Because the nature of this potential reality is unknown, my beloved might exist there (however small the chance may be).

  6. Through death I have a chance to exit the world as we know it.

  7. By exiting the world as we know it, I might enter another reality where they still exist (however small this chance may be).

  8. Because my beloved is more important to me than life itself, any chance of finding them is also more important than life.

Conclusion: I may rationally commit suicide in order to give myself a chance at finding my beloved.


r/TheAgora • • Apr 26 '20

Can you answer a question?

0 Upvotes

It’s a descivingly simple question. But, it has a difficult answer at the least.

To give context, I am asking as a writer who want to write a novel which is a metaphor about happiness. As a writer in the beginning of the book you establish a few questions which then are answered throughout the book. As I was writing the questions I was going to answer I realized that I don’t have answers to these questions.

So really the better question(s) to ask is: What makes you qualified to answer a question? I came to the conclusion that it comes down to experience. Ok now the question is: What type of experiences do you need? Diverse ones I guess? Can someone who is old be inexperienced compared to a teen?

Just a little ramble, if anyone wants to add on that would be great!


r/TheAgora • • Mar 15 '12

Help and criticism of my blog - it promotes knowledge

2 Upvotes

meaningfulknowledge.blogspot.com

Any criticism of either my blog's layout, looks, presentation of information, or discussion/logic in general would be of great help. This is my first blog and Redditors are the only people i trust for criticism.


r/TheAgora • • Apr 07 '16

Save the planet! Kill yourself

0 Upvotes

Would you agree to commit mass suicide to save the planet?


r/TheAgora • • Jun 24 '11

No One Deserves a Fair Trial

0 Upvotes

The guilty deserve to be punished. The innocent deserve not to be tried in the first place. Trials are a means, not an ends.

Does anyone disagree with this statement?


r/TheAgora • • Apr 13 '11

A thought experiment. Cross-breeding Humans with Chimpanzees (and/or bonobos).

0 Upvotes

Somehow this idea came into the front of my mind lately.

Normally, the idea of breeding people with chimps is repulsive, and for several good reasons. But how about in a (contrived) extreme situation?

Let us suppose a plaque has killed most of humanity. There are only you and a handful of others, all male (there are no women left (you can reverse the genders if you like)). Also, there are no viable gamete or zygote banks left. The only way open to you to keep humanity alive long term is to attempt to interbreed with our nearest genetic neighbors, the chimps. Lets also stipulate that all breeding is done using artificial insemination methods, to take sex out of the question.

Would you be willing to try reproducing in such a situation? Realize that offspring, if any, may not be themselves fertile, and will be not quite human, may be not human at all. Do you try, or do you just let humanity come to a dignified end?


r/TheAgora • • Nov 12 '17

Existential Nihilism, Rick and Morty & science

2 Upvotes

FINAL FEEDBACK SESSION (before journal-submission): Existential Nihilism: Living in a meaningless universe

Reconciling the only “really serious philosophical problem” with science Since Friedrich Nietzsche, philosophers have grappled with the question of how to respond to nihilism. Nihilism, often seen as a derogative term for a ‘life-denying’, destructive and perhaps most of all depressive philosophy is what drove existentialists to write about the right response to a meaningless universe devoid of purpose. This latter diagnosis is what I shall refer to as existential nihilism, the denial of meaning and purpose, a view that not only existentialists but also a long line of philosophers in the empiricist tradition ascribe to. The absurd stems from the fact that though life is without meaning and the universe devoid of purpose, man still longs for meaning, significance and purpose. Inspired by the adult animated series’ Rick and Morty and Bojack Horseman, this essay explores and analyses the various alternatives that have been offered in how to respond to the absurd, or as Albert Camus puts it; the only “really serious philosophical problem” and conclude that the problem is compatible with a naturalistic world-view, thereby genuine and transcending existentialism. KEYWORDS: existentialism, nihilism, absurdism, Camus, Nietzsche, Sartre, Rosenberg, Nagel https://www.academia.edu/s/65398c370e/existential-nihilism-living-in-a-meaningless-universe-reconciling-the-only-really-serious-philosophical-problem-with-science


r/TheAgora • • Nov 11 '11

Democracy is flawed. Let's fix it.

1 Upvotes

Socrates went and questioned it's fellow citizens about governance, life, and other important issues. People just didn't have a clue, they just followed popular people opinions. And after questioning these popular people he also found out they didn't have a clue either, someone who devotes effort on becoming popular rarely has the inclination and surely doesn't have the time to dwell on the study of important matters.

Since democracy as it is now conceived is nothing more than a popularity contest, he reached the conclusion that it just wasn't a good method of governance.

I have always thought the fix for democracy is that you have to "earn" the right to vote. If you need to be certified to drive a vehicle, why not for having an opinion on the future of your country?

A simple multiple selection test, on the history and geography of your country, would suffice, and such a body of electors would do a much better decision than what we have now.

What are your thoughts?