r/Tether • u/Cryptoplanetman • Jan 29 '18
No problem with Tether. Problem solved.
Ok Slight exaggeration, but people need to relax. Decided to see what the hysteria was about. I have a financial background:
anybody that has been through the ups and downs of crypto knows that Tether has handled some massive situations heroically and its normal that the peg budged a little during some of those times. Sometimes 1.01 sometimes .98. It happened before. Many times already. Nothing new here.
Bitfinex $1,134,419,856 24hr volume fees on transfers and trades + interest on margin= $2,000,000/day at least!
massive bitcoin purchases? = massive profits i believe. They were buying when everybody was selling. I think they made a total killing here. Like hundreds of millions or even billions.
Tether has huge volume #3 after ethereum! justifying its market cap and price. In fact the price of tether were it not tethered to the dollar would probably be something like $4 at these supply levels. It is greatly undervalued.
The tether business model actually does NOT need to be backed by anything!! Now that they have enough USDT coins they will be able to control the price of USDT without having to buy bitcoin by buying and selling USDT.
Also, just to compare, people do not realize that neither Chase bank nor any other bank has the capital to backup their deposits. Just a fraction of the capital I don't remember maybe its like 15%. If you did what people are doing to Tether to chase and the US gov didn't step in to save them, even Chase bank would go down. Its like screaming fire in a movie theater. Stop it.
Consider, if you had a legit business that was bringing in massive profits every day like Bitfinex/tether would you do something really really stupid to mess that up? Most intelligent people would not. I am not worried.
Another clue is that Bitfinex should probably do an ICO and use their coin like binance, but they have not. This would generate millions, obviously, on top of the hoard of cash they already have. They obviously do not need the money.
I think they are probably right that the US gov doesn't like tether and is giving them a hard time so I can believe the shielding of their business information is reasonable and they have tried to get the info out their by having well known members of the crypto community check their balances -see news.https://news.bitcoin.com/vouching-bitfinex-and-tethers-bank-accounts-hold-nearly-3-billion-usd/
Anyone that knows anything about financial markets knows that confidence is really important and the wild speculation without doing your homework is very irresponsible and destructive putting everyone at risk. I have done this analysis in literally a few minutes of my time. Granted I have a financial education and trading background, but really any average person should be able to quickly see that Tether isnt going anywhere. Please pass this on so that the scaredy cats can calm down. Dont be lazy people-- do your homework! Tether/Bitfinex is clearly an amazing business of historic proportions, now if a bunch of pananoid people and other detractors end up bringing them down externally that is not my fault, thats just people being stupid/jealous etc, but internally you do not need to be an auditor to see that it all makes sense as I have just done. Keep in mind that this is the first time in history that the little guys have made it big while Wall st and the 1% watched from the outside looking in. They want nothing more than panic to set in so they can get low prices and I have noticed this with the reporting.
Somebody do a youtube cat video meme with the tether haters freaking out please... I know a cat that jumps in the air when somebody crinkles a plastic bag...
Under normal circumstances, yes the audit thing would be troubling, but these are very much not normal circumstances and there are powerful people that want to see crypto go down. Some people don't seem to be taking seriously the evidence I presented. They have the world's largest exchange their balance sheet gets larger by millions every single day. The way I calculated it they probably already made enough money on their own to back up the tether and frankly I use the tether all the time for trading and I do not care if I can withdraw actual US dollars. I only care that they maintain the price at $1. With the massive profits I belive they have the ability to do that. In other words if every single person sold USDT for ethereum they now have the ability to maintain the price at $1 even in the most extreme situation. This is unprecedented. Even the worlds largest bank cant do that.
Some peoples logic seems to be well it happened to bitconnect therefore it will happen to tether. Did bitconnect have the world's largest exchange backing them /this level of profit? Forget that they make ridiculous amounts of money legitimately for a second and grow stronger everyday. The USDT they "print" is worth I believe around $4 based on demand due it's preeminence importance on exchanges as a trading vehicle and safety zone during downturns. It's sort of like the crypto world's reserve currency along with bitcoin and Ether. That is worth a lot. So I believe they can still legitimately print up to another 6 billion USDT for now based on what the value of USDT is if they wanted to! There are many possibilities with all this. They could get loans for example. Remember unlike other cryptos USDT doesn't go up when millions pour into it so you don't see what it is really worth.
I think people don't understand that they do not need to buy back at this point because they haven't even reached the optimal level of USDT given the demand!
Wow can't believe people are comparing the ponzi bitconnect to tether the crypto world's standard on the largest exchanges backed by the legit profits of the world's largest exchange . Talk about unfair comparison. I think that is a shady comparison. Wall St. shills are out there for sure! Hope they are not you guys....
11
u/cbu_ Jan 29 '18
Then why has friedman llt cancelled their the audit just a few days ago if it's all good? You, with your financial background, don't think it's bad sign?
1
8
u/ysraell Jan 29 '18
It's doesn't matter if you or everybody trust or not, in general, we must be exactly sceptics and formal: is there a third party audit? A work really falseabile (verificable)? If not, still under suspected fraud, and fraud is fraud, not a belief or a fath question. Again, it's not about, and like, bank's leverage, it's about fraud or not fraud, it's about honesty. They use the financial digital system for what? How gain more with exchanges and proportional to the digital coins's price? If they use tricks (magic), the price have no sustentable support, it is dust under dust, a pyramidal fraud system. I like a lot and believe in the digital money, but with this suspected actions may stain the whole idea. Whatever, it's happen with all new ideas, always we have the trickers, the bad guys, so it's important that the good guys keep an eye on, always.
2
u/Cryptoplanetman Jan 29 '18
I agree that its important to ask questions, but I think its going too far. If we create hysteria and destroy the whole crypto market that is not good for anyone. They have done their job maintaining the peg even during major incidents. Dont they get credit for that? There is a showdown coming with banks and regulator vs crypto that is what is going on I think. They are circling with wagons basically. You guys are not helping. Bitconnect was a ponzi you cant compare to this. The top exchanges use USDT and they also have the legitimate organic profits from the world largest exchange. That has value. Lets say hypothetically for arguments sake that somehow things got out of hand and they only have 1.5 billion vs 2.2 bil USDT. Yet their business is bringing in millions everyday so they would reach that goal within the year. Would you destroy them for that and tank the crypto market and permanently hurt confindence and cause regulators to say ah ha see!!! We have to stop this. Is all that worth it? or better to give them some time? Again, this is hypo, I believe they have the money, they just dont want to show their banks while they plan their strategy or negotiate with regulators or whatever. I could be wrong, but they appear to be making enough to honor their promises.
3
u/TOP_20 Jan 29 '18
"Everyone just shut up and drink the kool-aid"
There's good reason they registered in the Virgin Island along with the other 900,000 offshore businesses - Virgin Island population 108,000.
There's good reason they lie on their website about having 'frequent audit's'
There's good reason why you should not believe in what every alt coin / token company claims they are worth.
If you want to believe in tether funny money play tokens fine but why are you trying to push your belief on others.
Alerting others that there may be a fire in the theature when you smell smoke all around you makes sense.
The fact you keep pushing the association with Bitfinex as a bonus of tether inc's value is bizarre are you aware of how they treated their clients when they got hacked of bitcoin? Forcing everyone to take a 36% loss even those who didn't own bitcoin on their exchange.
1
u/Cryptoplanetman Jan 30 '18
The problem is hysteria could end up hurting a lot more people than just killing tether. This is a sensitive time for the entire industry especially with regulators. Therefore, it is in everyones interest to get a little more hard evidence of wrongdoing before crushing everyone and possibly killing the market. The regulators are just starting to realize the threat of crypto, they would love an excuse to kill it.
2
u/ysraell Jan 30 '18
I understand, but like I said: it's not about believe or something like "if the Pope uses the USDT", it is about business and money, real money! And it's doesn't matter if they create the dollar tether, if they set the rules before everyone gets into the game, it is not fair to change the rules during the game. They promised 1 USDT = 1 USD, they should honor that!
4
u/BlottoOtter Jan 29 '18
5) The tether business model actually does NOT need to be backed by anything!! Now that they have enough USDT coins they will be able to control the price of USDT without having to buy bitcoin by buying and selling USDT.
I'm amazed by the willingness of some to argue "it's OK Tether might be outright lying to its customers, here's a theoretical alternative business model that completely contradicts their stated business model!"
0
u/Cryptoplanetman Jan 29 '18
I know, its just hypothetical for people to understand that the model works just fine without all that backing/deposits. Its too bad they already promised that because its totally not necessary.... Still their main duty is to maintain the peg and they have done a great job.
5
u/BlottoOtter Jan 29 '18
What good is your hypothetical when your hypothetical is fraudulent? Do you not realize that, to someone skeptical of Tether, defending them with such bogus hypotheticals is more concerning?
Your hypothetical isn't even accurate. A peg without full reserves can only be held temporarily, not indefinitely. The market will continually test their ability to hold that peg, and there will eventually come a day where the market will push them to the breaking point. The question isn't if, it's when.
1
u/targetpro Jan 30 '18
Wow! You really are delusional. No wonder you ditched your last account and made up a new one.
3
u/ayydance Jan 29 '18
I like that you call your opinions "evidence presented"
1
24
4
u/phlogistonical Jan 29 '18
We know that banks don't have the capital to backup their deposits, which is exactly the problem. The US doesn't have the gold to back the USD. You make it seem like that is ok, but we trust that tether is not operating as a fractional reserve. If it turns out that it is, that would be inexcusible.
Any cryptoexchange that was secretly operating as a fractional reserve went belly up so far.
If tether is secretly running as a fractional reserve, they will go broke and deserve it. The sooner the better, for all of us.
2
2
u/cryptobodget Jan 29 '18
Wouldn't it be great if they just posted a screenshot of the bank balances showing 3Bil USD and we could all just get back to buying bitcoin.
No audit required, just show us the money, the best form of transparency!
Simples.
2
u/innatangle Jan 31 '18
How much evidence would be enough though? Screenshots are easily doctored. Do we then demand Tether give us their user name and passwords for their bank accounts so that we can individually inspect their holdings? Then if they did that, how do we know the accounts we were accessing were 'real' and not fake accounts?
1
u/cryptobodget Feb 01 '18
True, but it would be a start. They could post daily screenshots along with their daily live stats.
2
u/innatangle Feb 01 '18
The root of the Tether 'problem' seems to be based on the observation that a seemingly ridiculous number of Tethers were minted during November/December. The assumption that is being made is that these Tether came into existence yet the bank account balances that back it remained stationary.
For what it's worth, the number of people that began talking to me about crypto was amazing, nearly all of them were throwing plenty of cash into the system as well. Given the growth I saw in the values of all currencies, as well as the number of new people that were pouring money into the system, it seems reasonable that the amount of tether minted matched the increased interest.
Bitfinex seems to have been open about the depositing and withdrawing bank issues they were having around mid last year. This would have naturally constrained the number of tether that could have been minted (assuming the strict self adherence to the 1:1 ratio). Towards the end of the year, the banking issues seemed to be resolving with more people able to successfully transfer in and out. The resolution of these constraints would have naturally seen an uptick in the number of Tether needing to be printed providing of course that account balances were increasing.
Whilst it seems fair game that Bitfinex's/Tether's motivations can be called into question, it seems only reasonable that the same can be asked of the 'Tether Anti-Shills'. As a trader myself, I appreciate that at least on the surface, Tether provides a reference back to fiat currency. What do the anti-shills propose we do if Tether is buried? Trade Bitcoin pairs? How many new tokens were minted out of thin air during the Bitcoin forks?
If Tether ends up buried, it's probably quite feasible that one of the gold backed cryptocurrencies might take its place. In which case we'll be destined to repeat this whole sorry exercise because the doubters will wax hysterical that there's doubts about whether a gold back crypto is really backed by gold...
At some point, faith has to be placed in the system. This is crypto, it's the wild west. If people feel uneasy about it, go back to the traditional investment institutions like Lehmann Brothers...
0
u/Cryptoplanetman Jan 29 '18 edited Jan 29 '18
Under normal circumstances, yes the audit thing would be troubling, but these are very much not normal circumstances and there are powerful people that want to see crypto go down. I think they should be given the benefit of the doubt in this case at least for a while, first because the way I calculated it they already made enough money on their own to back up the tether and frankly I use the tether all the time for trading and I do not care if I can withdraw actual US dollars. I only care that they maintain the price at $1. With the massive profits I belive they have the ability to do that. In other words if every single person sold USDT for ethereum they now have the ability to maintain the price at $1 even in the most extreme situation. This is unprecedented. Even the worlds largest bank cant do that.
0
Jan 29 '18
[deleted]
0
u/Cryptoplanetman Jan 29 '18
Some peoples logic seems to be well it happened to bitconnect therefore it will happen to tether. Did bitconnect have the world's largest exchange backing them /this level of profit? Forget that they make ridiculous amounts of money legitimately for a second and grow stronger everyday. The USDT they "print" is worth I believe around $4 based on demand due it's preeminence importance on exchanges as a trading vehicle and safety zone during downturns. It's sort of like the crypto world's reserve currency along with bitcoin and Ether. That is worth a lot. So I believe they can still legitimately print up to another 6 billion USDT for now based on what the value of USDT is if they wanted to! There are many possibilities with all this. They could get loans for example. Remember unlike other cryptos USDT doesn't go up when millions pour into it so you don't see what it is really worth.
I think people don't understand that they do not need to buy back at this point because they haven't even reached the optimal level of USDT given the demand!
2
u/TOP_20 Jan 29 '18
You 'believe' tether tokens - the 2.2 BILLION of their play money they created out of thin air is worth $4.00 each? They are worth what people are willing to pay for them - they are paying $1 USD for them so that's what they are worth. How anyone "in the financial industry could believe they are worth 4 times what people are willing to pay for them is beyond me lol.
1
u/innatangle Jan 31 '18 edited Jan 31 '18
Have a look at Crypto20, a tokenised index fund of the top 20 crypto coins. Right now, on their own website they declare a 'Net Asset Value' of $2.32, according to coinmarketcap, one C20 token is currently being traded for $3.08. So yes, people are prepared to pay above market value for a token.
EDIT: And I'm aware that 132% of a value isn't 400%, but I think the point still stands.
1
u/TOP_20 Feb 01 '18
Well why would someone pay $4.00 for a tether token when you can buy them on almost any exchange for $1.00 - millions of them at 1.00 each - and how can you think they are worth 4.00 for them when nobody in their right mind would pay $4.00 for something they can buy for $1.00 - you aren't making sense to me.
1
u/innatangle Feb 01 '18
According to Coinmarketcap, Since March 2015, Tether has been priced as low as $0.92 and as high as $1.05 (-8% +5%). You are indeed correct, nobody has ever paid $4.00 for a Tether token.
I believe the point that u/Cryptoplanetman was trying to make is that for the functionality that Tether provides, theoretically it should probably be worth a lot more than what its face value is.
Tether helps to provide stability in very volatile markets and it seems to be a solution that can be used to reduce the number of physical transfers of fiat between exchanges (when a trader buys tokens on one exchange, transfers them to another and cashes out).
1
u/TOP_20 Feb 01 '18
Well a USD does all that and a whole whole lot more - still nobody would ever pay $4.00 for a USD when they can easily get them for $1.00 so obviously a USD isn't worth $4.00 no matter how useful it is- the only way someone would pay more than about a buck for a buck is somewhere they were extremely rare (some tribe in the amazon or something??), there are over 2.2 billion tether tokens available to buy at 1.00 right now - far from rare :)
1
u/innatangle Feb 01 '18
Don't take it so literally! No one is paying $4.00 for a Tether.
Well USD does all that and a whole whole lot more
USD is a lot less convenient and more costly to move around, remember, this is part of the reason crypto got going in the first place.
A central pool of funds enables exchanges large and small to accept any size token transfer and most importantly, facilitates the cashing out of those tokens without compromising the financial integrity of the exchange involved.
1
u/TOP_20 Feb 01 '18
USD is a lot less convenient and more costly to move around
uh what? USDT can pretty much only be used for one thing in the world at this time - exchanging real money for it's play money to buy your crypto currency...
USD is more convenient then tether tokens in pretty much every other use mankind has at this time lol - so no, USDT is not worth 4x what you can buy it for - you can currently buy a 10 million of those puppies for $1.00 each so that's what they are worth 1.00 :)
A central pool of funds
Isn't one of the highlights of crypto getting away from centralized banking and one government having so much control, yet so many are putting all their blind faith and trust in one small fly by night offshore company and it's exchange...trusting they won't be dishonest out of greed (as happens constantly when it comes to finanical dealings)... as if they are immune to greed when it comes to making themselves many millions of dollars at the expense of those who did not do their own due dilingence and believe 'well others are using it so it must be safe right?'
→ More replies (0)0
Jan 29 '18
[deleted]
2
u/Cryptoplanetman Jan 29 '18
Any exchange that is doing over a billion $ in volume that they legitimately make money on that whole billion is not questionable. Then there is margin profits. The timing of the purchases seems to make sense. It all adds up to a company with a very large amount of organically generated capital. Please tell me these exchanges. Are they tiny? How much volume to they trade? how many coins? I use large ones and all the ones I use use USDT. Just a couple of days ago Cobinhood exchange just started using USDT. Im sure they gave a lot of thought on what to use.
1
u/targetpro Jan 30 '18
Another zero-day account!
Wow! The shills are out in force today!
Once again Tether has fucked up. This time by not maturing their shill accounts prior to using them. Really, you're making this far too easy.
1
0
u/Bison4691 Jan 29 '18
I didn't even think about point 6 yet...shame on me
Thanks for that contribution
5
u/inthearenareddit Jan 29 '18
Banks have positive equity - their assets exceed their liabilities.
Can you say that of Bittfinex?
0
u/Bison4691 Jan 29 '18
Thats not the point.
The point is that if everybody goes to the bank and wants to get his money at the same time (bank rush) they couldn't pay because they have invested the money people "lend" them. Thats how they gain money. They give you 2% interest (lol i wish in Europe) and give it to others if they pay them 4% interest. They just have like 15% of the money stored that they lend from people to transact the daily payment transactions
Well binance made 200 million $ profit in q4 2017 for example. These exchanges make a shit ton of profit which is credibility enough
2
Jan 29 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Bison4691 Jan 29 '18
How do you think these tethers have hit the market? For them to being involved into the market they had to be traded for something else. Either Fiat or other cryptos. So the worstcase is that the Tether company is holding cryptos worth 2billion $ (at the point where they have bought it). Best case they sold them for fiat and have the 1to1 backing
So let's say they fucked up and sold their tethers for 11,7k tethers each bitcoin but were only able to sell that bitcoins for 11k dollars each. Then they made a loss of 6% which they have to compensate with their winnings elswhere (bitfinex?) But maybe the bought bitcoin in the dip with 10k tethers each bitcoin and sold the bitcoins at 11,5k dollars each now. Guess what they made even 15% profit on that.
I dont even wanna talk about that they threw new tethers onto the market when tether was worth 1,02$ and can buy them back now at 0,98$. Another win margin.
The reality is that we don't know how they operate but it's not like they can throw tether on the market and have nothing. They buy things with it...either fiat or cryptos
2
u/inthearenareddit Jan 29 '18
The very reason we want to see the B/S is to ensure the things they have bought still hold value, at least as much as their liabilities (Tether).
It's really not fair to make a comparison with banks which are regularly audited, have deep access to cap markets and are regulated. Plus we are not really discussing liquidity mis matches - we're discussing the potential for fraud (saying tether is backed by USD when it's not)
1
u/Bison4691 Jan 29 '18
We can discuss fraud the whole day long. Yes it might be fraud. I would never say that I am certain that it is not fraud. But some people started to mix things like "tether is fake fiat injected into the market" into this whole tether controversy which is bullshit. They don't know the difference between fiat and goods/things that have a certain value which is alarming
-6
u/BananaPlanterZ Jan 29 '18
This. Sadly you will be downvoted to hell because a honest and reasonable opinion on this matter is not what this sub wants to hear.
1
u/targetpro Jan 30 '18
Then why post here?
Take your shill account to a place where you can try to get your bullshit to fly.
1
u/BananaPlanterZ Jan 30 '18
What do you mean why im posting here? I think it would be good to have an unbiased discussion about this, but all comments and posts which doesnt take tether into the dumpster are downvoted out of sight. Thats not how a discussion should work. If you disagree with someone, you shouldnt call him out and downvote his post.
1
u/targetpro Jan 30 '18
There's nothing honest and reasonable about a company stealing $2.3b from consumers.
There's nothing honest and reasonable about a company refusing to have an audit done (while claiming they did).
There's nothing honest and reasonable about a company hiring a small army of shills to attempt to sway the public discourse by presenting NO facts. Just opinion after opinion after opinion. The whole time claiming they're facts.
If you can't see the writing on the wall of what's underway, then I'm not sure what to tell you. You're probably not the sharpest arrow in the quiver.
0
Jan 29 '18
[deleted]
3
u/targetpro Jan 30 '18
Just another Shill account. Tether & Co. just signed up a bunch of fresh new accounts today.
0
u/Cryptoplanetman Jan 29 '18
There is no comparison with Bitconnect thats a totally false comparison. That was a pure ponzi scheme with little organic business to back it up. Tether is the crypto worlds standard at the largest exchanges along with Bitcoin and Ether for trading and stability. Its backed by the massive profits of the worlds largest exchange. Very deceptive comparison.
2
u/targetpro Jan 30 '18
Welcome to the discussion, how did the Reddit registration go? Have to come up with another email address too?
0
15
u/Bi_Azy Jan 29 '18
Thats really funny I can see so many analogies to the bitconnect/bcc sub. Many people tried to warn everyone about bitconnect but most of them were ignored. Then some people (like you) came up and said: Look guys it works why should they scam you everyone is making money, everyone is happy, don’t listen to the other people they are just jealous because they haven’t bought in and now they are spreading FUD. And now it is exactly the same with tether. The treacherous thing is that these scams don’t go down in 2 days. Scams are running for a long time and so many people trust tether although they think it could be a scam! However, finally the value will go to zero because they create money from nothing and it will burst at least then when more people want to cash out for real money and notice that there isn’t any real money left just worthless tether.