r/Tempestmasterrace • • Oct 18 '15

/r/TransformativeWorks - supporting any/all transformative works & the creative fans who produce them

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Tempestmasterrace • • Mar 10 '15

Tempest: Bleeding Crocus (AU, Coming Soon)!

Thumbnail
therewillbesparkles.tumblr.com
2 Upvotes

r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jun 30 '14

Question about a line in Chapter 27

3 Upvotes

It was the last time Anna ever tried to touch Elsa again.

What do you think it means? Does this mean anything about an end to their relationship?


r/Tempestmasterrace • • Sep 18 '14

About Gustaf... (Spoilers)

5 Upvotes

"Gustaf was not a Wraith."

What do you think this line means? Just before this, Elsa asks why Bulda calls her a Wraith, and the answer is that she's denied her heart, which I take to mean her creation of the reliquary. If that's the case, what does this mean about Gustaf?


r/Tempestmasterrace • • Sep 14 '14

2 weeks old, but this is Tateshi's wip on her next prince drawing, and that prince is....

Thumbnail
tateshi.tumblr.com
5 Upvotes

r/Tempestmasterrace • • Sep 16 '14

Young Saul, from, you guessed it, Kenneth's tumblr

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/Tempestmasterrace • • Aug 27 '14

[Spoilers up to Chapter 32] I'm leaving for a few days again. Before I go, I would like to leave you with some of my speculation; some of my thoughts and theories regarding the next arc of the story, Markus, Elsa, Anna and the key Prince. Enjoy!

6 Upvotes

Disclaimer: The last three sentences of this post spoil Tangled's prologue and the twist of Harry Potter Book 1. I'm extremely sorry for not stating this in the title, but please consider yourselves warned. Thank you.


My first thought concerns Edmund. He's left in a prety dark place (literally, as well as figuratively) in 32 after the revelations of 31. He can't really be expected to act rationally, can he? So what is he most likely to do? Lash out and/ or find more answers. Who would let him do both? Markus. And because he hasn't honed his magic at all (as far as we're aware), this means he has a strong desire to do something but no form of protecting himself, which is exactly how the Sorcerer was able to "brainwash" his victims. Who's to say Markus wouldn't do the same to him?

Anna and Elsa are leaving for Arendelle, so Edmund loses the one person who could restrain him through care and the one who could stop him through intimidation and fear. He would make his way up Elsa's tower, and the door would open for him. Why? When Markus first revealed his power to 8 year old Elsa, he told her it pales in comparison to what she is capable of, but we don't know what he himself can do. Anna can pass through her defences because Elsa trusts her, right? Who else does she trust? Markus.

So Markus may open the door, with or without Edmund's comprehension. His grandson would walk into the foreboding room. He would see the mirror and the ice casket before it. We know that Markus is capable of "speech" by transmitting fragmented thoughts to his intended recipient. So he may speak with Edmund, either proudly justifying his actions or simply mocking him. Then he may try to possess him.

In Gustaf's letter he talks of how his father failed to mold him before deciding on trying again with his son. There is precedent for possession in Tempest. Gustaf does so to Reid's corpse, fully in control of the body and capable of precise dissection and speech. If the host also had magic, would he have access to them as well? Surely that would be the ideal host for Markus also? What if, when Gustaf said Markus failed to mold him, he meant that when Markus began to try he was either too mentally secure (having gained a better understanding of the world through Celina) or too far advanced in his own powers to succumb? Edmund wouldn't have the proficiency to resist Markus' influence, but once Markus took over, possibly by killing him, he could easily apply his own knowledge to the power present in his new body, could he not? He may need some adjusting, of course, but afterwards...

And why would he resort to this? His aim in completing the Mirror is to be restored to life. Put yourself in his shoes. He is a King and a highly skilled magician, yet failed to resist the passage of time. How embarrassing must that be for him? Maybe he wanted was immortality, or maybe even eternal youth from the Mirror? When it became apparant that he could not complete it in his natural lifespan, he sought an alternate means of extending his lifespan, first with Gustaf. When he proved too powerful, Markus instead took his son as his own and prepared to raise him to an age where he would be at his physical peak before claiming his body as his own too. He sadly couldn't live to see that happen either, so he needed Elsa to preserve him. If he does claim Edmund's body, he would still want the Mirror completed to grant him immortality in his new body, or to restore his old one. If he chooses to keep his new body, perhaps he could use his new found freedom and advantage to punish Elsa for "betraying" him in favour of a Princess from the kingdom she despised? She, of course, would only ever see Edmund, possibly a bit more secluded than usual, but after everything he'd been through, how could she blame him? Elsa of course would no longer hear Markus when she enters the tower. She would feel devasted for indulging in her own pleasure and spending time with the woman she loved instead of fulfilling her obligations to the man that took her in from her abusive parents and uncaring world all those years ago, at the cost of her father's life. Any improvements she made through Anna's influence, and many more besides from her upbringing in the castle, would be completely lost.


My second thought is a bit simpler. Elsa and Anna are departing for Arendelle as per Anna's wish. The first question is how will the king react to seeing his only daughter in the arms of the woman who subjugated their land? He is extremely overprotective of her, as per Anna's own description of him, especially after the death of her mother. He would immediately fear the worst, that Elsa hoodwinked her or manipulated her with her magic (which is true, but not the reason for their relationship) or broke her in some way and Anna underwent Stockholme Syndrome. Elsa would remain cold, but would try diplomacy and attempt to show kindness for Anna's sake, but would struggle, both in the actual act of being kind to someone and when attempting to reconcile the action with her mindset towards people in general and Arendelle.

The king would continue to plant divides between the two. Even if this doesn't happen, being in their homeland, and with Saul's warning no doubt present in her mind, they may come at odds with one another in small ways (even without Saul's influence, as Elsa would no doubt be afraid Anna would ultimately choose Arendelle over her), possibly culminating in more serious disputes. This may result in both of them realising their own flaws in how they're approaching their relationship, as well as the flaws in themselves.

This would affect Elsa more. Returning home, with all the freedom of a feared and powerful guest and ruler of the realm, she would have freedom to roam her former home. She may visit her old home, with or without Anna, mentally or physically. She may finally decide to confront the seemingly erroneous memory she received in Weselton. Gustaf's words, from before and after she learned his secret, are no doubt on her mind and she may consider them now. Why would he help her so much while secretly plotting against her? Why would he continue to do so, even with his dying breaths? Surely there would be some truth to his words then, right? She may finally begin to suspect Markus in this time, deciding to confront him upon her return. If he appears dead to her when she returns of course, it would only make her feeling of guilt stronger.

One other thing she may consider here is why Arendelle had no Mirror shards for her to collect. Every other country had them, so what makes Arendelle, the country that caused her so much grief, so special? Then she may realise the answer: herself. I've theorised before that Elsa possesses Arendelle's quota of shards within her, and she may reach the same conclusion, or at least begin to understand this at this time. Why else would the supposedly all-powerful only be able to sustain her magical father's life once she fed it strength with her own reliquary? If Markus really did want it to achieve immortality, doesn't this mean the incomplete Mirror accomplished a rudimentary form of this purpose with Elsa's strength? A thought I had is this: what if, in some way, Elsa is the Mirror? Her ice lets her heal her wounds after all, isn't the Mirror used in a medical context as well? And when she calls fragments of the Mirror to herself, is she essentially pulling herself together? Or rather, maybe Elsa is an embodiment of the Mirror or its power(s), strengths/ weaknesses and all it represents. Kenneth once compared the Mirror to the flower in Tangled. What if Elsa could be considered "the Mirror" in the same way Gothel refers to Rapunzel as her "flower"?


Returning to my first thought, I compared Markus' plan to Voldemort's in Philosopher/ Sorcerer's Stone: he tried to sustain himself with unicorn blood until he could obtain the stone and produce its elixir of life. Markus wants to sustain himself through inhabiting other bodies (not unlike Voldemort's plan for Quirrel) until he can obtain the power of the Mirror.


I'll add more when I can! Thank you for your time!


EDIT: 21/09/2014, 21:59 BST: My comments on the next three chapters may be found here!


r/Tempestmasterrace • • Sep 05 '14

We've reached the 50 subscriber milestone!

6 Upvotes

Congratulations /r/tempestmasterrace! Here's to many more subscribers to come! Keep up the good work everyone!


r/Tempestmasterrace • • Sep 05 '14

Chapter 34 (Happy weekend, guys!)

Thumbnail
fanfiction.net
7 Upvotes

r/Tempestmasterrace • • Sep 18 '14

Chapter 35: Yes, I Want to Build a Snowman

Thumbnail
fanfiction.net
7 Upvotes

r/Tempestmasterrace • • Aug 18 '14

Prince Tobias, by tateshi

Thumbnail
tateshi.tumblr.com
7 Upvotes

r/Tempestmasterrace • • Apr 28 '15

Tempest Master Collection PDF (908 pages, includes side-stories!)

Thumbnail dl.dropboxusercontent.com
9 Upvotes

r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jul 06 '14

Names (Spoilers up to Ch. 27)

7 Upvotes

Since I brought up the subject in the Gustaf thread, I figured I would make an actual post about it; I did choose names for certain reasons. I tagged this as spoilers, but I won't actually be spoiling future things that may be related to their name.

Gustaf. Of Swedish or German origin, and means either "Royal Staff" or "Staff of the Gods." It's a name commonly held by monarchs, and hints at the high hopes Markus held for him.

Tobias. Means "Goodness of God," and name of the hero of the apocryphal Book of Tobit in the Old Testament; Tobias, with the help of the archangel Raphael, is able to drive away a demon. Subversion. Tobias is easily one of the most cynical brothers, and arguably cursed by God, since he was born physically frail. Much of his plight is driving away his own demons and insecurities.

Saul. Of Hebrew origin, with the meaning "asked for" or "prayed for," and the root verb (sha'al) is used largely in entreaty for God's guidance and salvation. Also, a variant, she'ol, is often translated to mean "hell." Quite the dichotomy.

Alek. Variant form of Alexander, meaning "defender of men," or "protector of mankind." Alexander the Great was, of course, a remarkably successful military leader.

Edmund. Of Old English origin, and meaning "wealthy/prosperous protector."


r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jul 02 '14

I love how we got to watch /u/charredgrass' progress

Thumbnail
puu.sh
9 Upvotes

r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jul 04 '14

Quick thoughts on the reliquary. Does it WANT to be emptied? (spoilers)

6 Upvotes

We know that Elsa secretly wants her emotions back, especially after meeting Anna. Anna, for some reason (power of love perhaps?) can circumvent her defences (e.g. her locked doors). Maybe this is because her powers somehow consider Anna to be Elsa herself? If so, when the reliquary "reaches out" to her (and Elsa later states that it "recognises its master" which is why it harms Tobias) is it because her heart wants to go back home? It is after all bursting with all of Elsa's suppressed emotions and dreams of being complete and not lonely, isn't it? And isn't the heart usually the one to contain the truths you usually don't want to confess to in stories? So even if Elsa tells herself that it's better to stay "heartless", both figuratively and literally, deep down (or high up, in her case) she knows that's not true.

And we've yet to see her interact with the reliquary. Maybe she has to fight it back whenever she needs to bring it close for any reason? What would reclaiming the organ do to the Mirror, besides weaken it and kill Markus? Would she finally be able to use the connection between her and Anna?

I'm a bit busy right now sadly, so I'll be back to finish this, hopefully soon.


r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jul 08 '14

Discussion Slow-read Chapter 5 discussion thread

6 Upvotes

So while /r/Frozen goes berserk over /r/FrozenFriends actually getting some traction (and their precious shit-posts/trends going away), we'll do what we do best.

Here's chapter 5 my friends.

Message the moderators if you guys have any questions, we're really good about seeing your guy's messages, and are happy to help if you have any concerns or suggestions. Or you just want to tell us how much you love Kenneth, don't worry, we do too.

One of the most important edits ever: If you're blind, and somehow clicked on this without seeing the glorious thumbnail, then it is my honor to inform you that chapter 28 has been released. Again, thanks so much for the work you do Kenneth but damnit now the wait will be longer...


r/Tempestmasterrace • • Apr 21 '15

Sorcerer!Anna by charlestan

Thumbnail
charlestan.tumblr.com
6 Upvotes

r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jul 21 '14

Chapter 29 is out!

Thumbnail
fanfiction.net
6 Upvotes

r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jul 22 '14

I really want to read this chapter but...

3 Upvotes

I don't really like the serialized nature of fanfics, so I will probably wait a few weeks until there are more chapters so I can read them in a block. It's more intense for me that way.


r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jul 03 '14

(Spoilers up to Ch. 27) This is how I keep track of the brothers.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
9 Upvotes

r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jul 20 '14

Tempest Elsa Fanart

Thumbnail
jabs-wocks.tumblr.com
6 Upvotes

r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jul 06 '14

Edmund. (Spoilers)

5 Upvotes

Let’s start with the changes wrought upon Elsa by the reliquary and see if they match up with Edmund.

Perfect Recall: Yep. He hasn’t displayed that trait in the present day story and he tells Anna that his optimism is his “only redeeming trait”. Curious, isn’t it? What if I reminded you that we have only heard mention of this ability twice? Once in a reliquary-induced flashback and again in Checkmate. Edmund himself has yet to tell Anna he has this ability. Is he intentionally hiding it from her? From everyone even? Trying to let them forget he has a secret weapon?

Chronic headaches: Yes again. He has a headache in Checkmate. Granted he doesn’t have one for quite sometime in Tempest, but he gets one when talking to Anna later on (Chapter 17 or 18).

Unable to exercise creativity: Yep. At a young age, he is able to sketch a fine image during Elsa and Gustaf’s chess match, yet confesses that he can only “copy stuff”.

Personality shifts: Also yes. He is usually upbeat (very much a “male Anna”), but gets very gloomy at times before bouncing back - have a look at how he acts when Anna interrupts his tribute to Tobias, and again during his libation for Reid; in the latter he is much different to the Edmund we once knew.

The Sorcerer claims his reliquary was made at a young age, so Markus could correct the method for Elsa. Edmund is 8 in Checkmate yet displays all the signs of possessing a reliquary. Elsa’s gift is already known to the brothers at this point (at least, Saul doesn’t freak out when he interrupts her during lessons when they are older), so it’s easy to see how he’d accuse Markus of using him as a guinea pig.

Edmund himself says a few things. In Chapter 27, he apologizes to Anna on Reid’s behalf, even though, as Anna tells him, it’s odd that he’d have heard word of his attack. The Sorcerer says he admires Anna for being pure and Edmund echoes the exact same sentiments in this chapter also. It quickly becomes apparent to all that Anna is Elsa’s weak point, and who encourages Anna that Elsa gives her good vibes? Edmund again.

Edmund is a good man. Even if he turns out to be the Sorcerer. What if the tributes he offers to the brothers are genuine? The Sorcerer claims he wants to be whole, correct? What if he wants to do more? In Chapter 18, Edmund tells Anna:

“Everything will be all right one day. I hold onto that dream. I know I’ll make it happen.”

Having magic sure would make that easier, huh? When Elsa tries to exile Gustaf, Edmund finally lashes out at her, calling her heartless (funny choice of vocabulary there) and ending their friendship. What if he really does want to protect people from her? He’s quite enthusiastic on accompanying Kristoff on his supply raids; what if he thinks fighting fire with fire (or magic with magic, to be exact), is the best way to protect his home? Even if he wasn’t particularly fond of the dead brothers, maybe the tributes he offers them is genuine (and he’d later apologize for defiling Alvard’s corpse)?

A few other points; what is behind the wall he disappeared in front of? If Edmund is the culprit, did he really want Anna to find it? Why? Or did he just lead her to a private area so he could brainwash her? Because it seems a bit counterproductive otherwise (if he isn't the Sorcerer, you could argue that he panicked and wanted to warn the real one). Also, let’s say he only reconnected with Elsa to get closer to her? That would easily give him the opportunity to hide the folder as he does; I guess he simply didn’t get the chance to destroy it or remove it from the room without being discovered? If Elsa never left him alone in there, he couldn’t have hidden it securely at all. Are these too obvious? Is Edmund leaning on the fourth wall a bit when he asks Anna if he suspects her?

Gustaf once tells Anna that “there are only… shadows now” in his life, and he spends an awful lot of time with Edmund, even appearing at the collapsed warehouse together. Is Gustaf under Edmund’s thumb? The warehouse appearance could possibly be a red herring; there would be too many questions asked if those two appeared for any reason other than hearing word legitimately, unless they chose to wait for the messenger to arrive before departing themselves. Either way their appearance could mean anything.

Incidentally, this may also be why he supports Saul’s actions as temporary ruler of the SI in Elsa’s absence; the Sorcerer supports his bid for power and Edmund has no designs on the throne (that have yet become apparent); besides, it would be better for the Isles’ new ruler to not have as powerful magic as their Queen Regent after all.

Incidentally, Edmund is dark-haired. What if he’s looking for men that resemble him so he can be restored? The little girls and Elsa’s reliquary? Besides gaining dominance over her, maybe he wants to conduct a few experiments on her, to return the favor? Finally (for now), maybe the Sorcerer’s chess analogies are a form of self-depreciation? As Anna states, both Elsa and the Sorcerer are prone to self-loathing.

More to come. Again, I typed this up in a bit of a hurry, in a less than ideal writing environment. Sorry!


r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jul 05 '14

Before my "big post", this is some of the criteria I believe can help identify the Sorcerer. What do you think? (spoilers)

6 Upvotes

His key trait seems to be the fact that he has a reliquary. I figured that a good thing to do would be to identify the changes it brings upon any individual, and see whether it matches up to the Princes. So let's take a look at Elsa. For the record, I initially chose traits that differentiate her from canon!Elsa. Thankfully some of them got confirmed anyway :)

The first thing we learn about her is that she lacks emotions (for the most part), at least until Anna begins to bring them out in her. The Sorcerer admits that he wants his back too, but for now we could be looking any Prince with a mismatch of the four humors. Which Prince seems too moody, too angsty, or too energetic?

Something that I suspected since the beginning was that the reliquary was the source of Elsa's chronic migraines and amazing memory (she has several books and plays memorised down to the page/ act number). She confirms both of these in Chapter 19 (the headaches are implied to be the result of her trying to repress her childhood memories) and adds that the reliquary gave her perfect recall. We're looking for someone with a very good memory and recurring headaches.

Elsa undergoes a personality shift due to the reliquary, and also loses her need to eat, sleep and drink, becoming a workaholic of a Queen and also a shut in (more or less). How many of the Princes tend to keep to themselves (or perhaps, with a small group)?

She also lost her power to create, retaining only the capacity for large scale destruction. As Saul says during the reliquary-flashback, a lot of the Princes have gifts. How many of them exercise creativity in doing so, and how many can only mimic other works?

Anna makes her own observations on the comparisons between the Sorcerer and Elsa: they both have "mood swings", alternating between personas quickly. They're both consumed with self-confidence and self-loathing in equal measure (I wonder...). They have identical body language and share a "quest for identity" of sorts (even Elsa begins to see a kindred spirit in once of the brothers...).

You can already see where my thoughts are going, but I'll move on to the Sorcerer himself. We see him four times (not counting mental conversations). Three times he talks to Saul, once to Anna, Hans and Alek. In the last conversation, he claims he greatly respects Anna and also that his reliquary was made when he was a child, to act as Elsa's guinea pig. Is he just misplacing blame, or did he really lose his heart after Elsa had arrived? If so, which brother has been displaying the above traits since childhood? Then again, isn't one of Elsa's many points of contention between her "brothers" her preferential treatment from their father?

Let's move on to Saul's conversations with him. There's a potential red herring with the Sorcerer's "average build", but I'd rather mention it anyway. In contrast to Elsa's "icy" scent, he smells of "musk and dark spice" and greatly supports the idea of Saul being King. So we're looking for a Prince who has yet to express desires of being King himself. One constant in all their interactions is the particular analogy he seems fond of making. I would state the analogy here, but as Kenneth points out in the A/N of his first chapter (17), maybe it's too obvious.

Two other points that I can mention without implicating any one Prince over the other (I'll do that later ;) ): the Sorcerer has a deep voice, from what we've heard of him (through Anna's POV mainly). Then again, he's wearing a mask and voice-changing doesn't seem too difficult for someone of his caliber (or something he'd neglect). Also, the kidnap victims from the slums fit one of two appearances: young, blonde girl or older dark-haired man. The girls obviously bear resemblances to Elsa. The men may have been taken because they resemble Markus, but aren't some of the brothers dark-haired as well?

Finally, Kenneth has confirmed a few things on here: the Sorcerer is one of the living Princes and is fully aware that he is (no split personality shenanigans!), though he refused to tell me whether "the Sorcerer" and "the Prince" have ever shared a room. He was also kind enough to tell me that the Sorcerer isn't one of the underdeveloped Princes. That... really cuts down on the possible candidates, doesn't it?

Before I go, I wonder whether Elsa could make him fall for this, or whether he'd just pull the same trick on her...

PS. Can I suggest flairs for posts? Namely "Previews", "Chapters", "Slow-Reads" and "Speculation"?

EDIT: Forgot to add (so embarrassed right now). If you think a particular Prince seemed too obvious in later chapters, just wait til the slow read moves on a bit. There are some giant neon signposts floating around back there, that may or may not be just as valid :P Let me confirm however, that I DO have answers to all of the above questions in mind.


r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jul 24 '14

Discussion Chapter 10 discussion thread

3 Upvotes

Does it irk anyone else how every single discussion thread we create has a different sort of title?

Chapter 10 everybody

Discussion has picked up once again, probably has something to do with Kenneth's own update for Tempest. So that can only mean one thing.

Kenneth, keep em coming.

Don't blame me! pls


r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jul 05 '14

Gustaf. (spoilers)

7 Upvotes

This is simply meant to serve as an accelerated slow-read of sorts, focusing on the Princes instead of the story in general. As the title suggests, in this particular post I’ll be talking about Gustaf. Looking over my notes, he’s actually gathered quite a bit of my attention over the course of the story. Sorry for not being able to provide Chapter references for all of these. I’ll try and add them over time, but no promises.

Note. I will be referring to my comments in this post quite often. Feel free to read it beforehand.

I raised the point there that the Sorcerer is gathering people that bear resemblances to both Elsa and Markus. Of course, Gustaf is said to look almost exactly like him. Coincidence? Maybe so, maybe no.

Gustaf also has a strong motivation for being the Sorcerer. When talking to Elsa, he tells her he once lost something, regained it, then lost it again. In the above post, I mention comparing Elsa to the Sorcerer, so let’s do that now. Elsa also lost her emotional capabilities, but lost them when she made the reliquary. She slowly began to regain those emotions after meeting Anna.

What if the same thing happened to Gustaf? What if he spent his entire life without a heart, met his future wife and began to heal, only to lose her and her son (maybe) when he tried to revolt? Wouldn’t he then become desperate to restore his humanity in any way he could, even the macabre method the Sorcerer is caught using in Chapter 24? I earlier stated that the men the Sorcerer kidnaps may resemble Markus. By extension, they'd also resemble Gustaf himself. Maybe he's searching for one who's heart will be compatible with his own? Maybe he wants Elsa's reliquary so do the same to her with the girls he's taken (note Gustaf and Elsa's own age difference of 20-odd years)? After all, he claimed he was Elsa's test subject; why not turn her into his? Gaining dominance over her would certainly be a nice bonus.

Keep in mind that we don’t know why he tried to usurp his father. We’re told how he did it; he tried to convince the King’s court that he was “unfit to rule”. However, Elsa never bothered to ask why, possibly because she was blinded by bias. I’m sure that “Hey, the King thought cutting his first-born’s heart out for a botched science experiment was a good idea” would certainly be a good reason to fear for Markus’ sanity. Then, when Markus used what he learnt from Gustaf’s failure and successfully had Elsa make a reliquary, he would understandably make the claim he made in Chapter 24. He may be misplacing blame here (claiming he was always Elsa’s guinea pig), but we know that Elsa’s memories of being mistreated aren’t accurate, and also that Arendelle had no Mirror shards. Using the Eagle Vision Theory, maybe Markus was always keeping his eye on a new heir, possibly manipulating her since childhood?

There is precedent for his desire for humanity. He and Elsa speak twice during the present day story, and both times he stresses the importance of mingling with and embracing one’s own mortality (the first time adding that Elsa doesn’t want to be Queen). In fact, he is very similar to her in terms of personality: they are both have very calm exteriors, yet speak thoughtfully and exude an aura of authority, wordlessly demanding respect.

In their first meeting, he tells her to not follow through on her “father’s crusade”. You may originally think he’s referring to Elsa’s tendency to take over other countries, but she only began this after becoming Regent, and she notes that Markus taught her to not rule “senselessly”. Of course, the main quest he entrusted him was to complete the Mirror. What else could Gustaf be referring to? Following up by telling her that something cost her her open mindedness. This is a reference to Checkmate, but is Gustaf referring to Markus’ influence, or a deeper change that could have done this to her?

In their second meeting, he enters Elsa’s room without her knowing. He passes it off as Elsa being too preoccupied, but the Sorcerer didn’t need to knock when he first met Saul, did he? This is when he makes the comment that he “lost purpose” and that he found, then lost it again that I spoke of above. He then tells Elsa to not lose her chance to reclaim her humanity and flat out tells her that he lost his own. It’s at the end of this second conversation that Elsa finally admits that the two of them are very much alike (Chapter 27).

In my last post I drew attention to the analogy the Sorcerer tended to make around Saul; he kept referring to chess pieces. As we know, Gustaf is the castle’s resident chess expert (as he seems to play it for its own sake, as opposed to Cyrus and Fabian, who use it solely as a form of competition). This seems too obvious by itself, but when Gustaf recounts his past to Anna, he finishes with telling her how, without his family, his life is empty and I quote:

“There are only… shadows now”. (Chapter 17 or 18)

A bit on the nose, huh?

Then there’s his brief appearance in Chapter 25, once Anna, Alek and Hans have escaped the collapsing warehouse. If he is the Sorcerer, it makes sense for Edmund to have been his puppet (and may have entertained the notion since he defended him when Elsa tried to banish him, if he didn’t implement it right then) and he may have simply wanted a first hand look at the trio he’d just tried to kill. More on “Puppet Edward” later, and by later, I mean in another post.

Let’s talk more about the effects of the reliquary, and whether the symptoms match up.

Gustaf is a very jaded man, keeping to chess and calligraphy, while entertaining at least three of his brothers. So, a lack of outward emotions and keeper of small company? Seems good. Headaches? Elsa has hers because her perfect recall means she’s always fighting back memories of her childhood. Gustaf doesn’t suppress anything, letting them shape his worldview without trying to pretend the death of his family never happened, so maybe he doesn’t have them (and if he does, he doesn’t have them enough that the story draws attention to them).

What about a strong memory? Gustaf definitely has that. He’s memorised a number of chess openings, even pinning a name to 10 year old Elsa’s plays in Checkmate. Not only this, but he’s also memorised passages from the bible and other ancient texts, in different languages no less (English and Latin at least)!

A lack of creativity? This may explain the calligraphy. When explaining it to Anna, he tells her he alternates between practicing focus (what would be easier for one without a heart) and freeform writing (where he would no doubt struggle to not accidentally replicate something he studied beforehand). Even the chess; chess has a fixed set of rules, openings and gambits defined by others over the years, As someone who used to play it (and with mediocrity, so fair warning as to my validity), I can tell you how hard it is to not be funneled into a particular sequence of moves, be it a result of your own moves, or a result of your opponent continually forcing your hand. It is a thinking game after all, so it would definitely have therapeutic value to him.

Mood swings? We’ve seen those happen as well, Gustaf’s trigger being the mention of Markus (the Sorcerer doesn’t like him either). When Elsa mentions his father in Tempest, he suddenly changes from “strict chess teacher” to “chess master” and stops playing after spending a long time teaching both her and Edmund. He also does this again when first meeting Anna; going from a polite conversation with Anna to throwing chess pieces at Cyrus and Fabian to shut them up.

Gustaf is a very alert person, as seen by both Elsa (young and old) and Anna. Elsa even notes that he seems far more alert than his appearance would suggest (she’d know a lot about unreliable appearances). Not only does he philosophise a lot, he seems to have a grey/ gray morality system he strongly encourages in others. So does the Sorcerer.

This theory isn’t perfect, as there are some factors that don’t match up (the overarching timeline for example). I’ll work on that. Some clues even match perfectly with another Prince, but need some hammering to fit for this one. As I said initially, this post is the first of a series.

I’ll add to this when I can (there are some thoughts on the front of my mind I just can’t pin down!). What do you think? Do I think he’s the Sorcerer? Maybe so, maybe no. Will I be analysing other Princes? Yes. Why? Because I like playing Devil's Advocate and also because I may/ not like keeping secrets of my own. See you then!

Furthermore, what if Gustaf used to sit by Markus' side at meals, not because he was the heir to the throne, but because he was his father's protege in magic? Then, when Elsa came around with far greater power, Markus made the switch to reflect that? It's obviously not a secret that her powers (and need to complete the Mirror) were the reason she inherited the throne after all. This begs the question, then, of whether or not Elsa's potential created the wedge between Gustaf and his father (Gustaf understandably furious at his being replaced after losing so much) that in turn lead to his failed rebellion? The fact that Elsa's ice powers seem more compatible than shadow magic may have compounded this sentiment.