55
43
May 06 '20
I'm very hyped because of this... I'm so interested in how will be their video calls integration. Knowing that they like to claim they're the best... What could be awaiting for us with those video calls?
We'll just have to be patient.
-1
u/Ubel May 07 '20
Their audio call quality is dogshit compared to Discord so they're definitely not the best at that.
Obviously Discord is gonna be good, but it's using Opus which is open source .. why Telegram isn't either is quite odd.
9
u/p0358 May 07 '20
My experience is the exact opposite. Especially that Telegram goes to 128 kb/s in good conditions, and Discord to like 64 or 96, not more, unless you pay
6
u/Ubel May 07 '20
Never seen Telegram say the bitrate, is that new?
Literally though I'll call my friend on the same mic setup and Discord sounds farrrr better, Telegram was like he was talking to me over a walkie talkie in comparison. That was like a year ago though.
He was using Discord and Telegram on his PC with the same mic.
At the time when I did the test with my friend Discord was at the max bitrate for non paying customers.
2
May 07 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/p0358 May 07 '20
Also, are you kidding me? xD
Discord starts screwing up audio after 30 minutes for lot of people, after 1 hour for most, impossible to attend a lesson without reloading this thing at least once in these times.
Meanwhile I can talk with a friend for 8 hours on Telegram and there are no issues at all
In my experience it’s an entirely different level of quality
2
4
0
May 07 '20
[deleted]
11
May 07 '20
That last one came to my mind a bunch of times... It can be really good. But I'm always afraid of, you know, "the costs" of it.
High quality stream 1to1 seems reasonable. And a lower quality for the group calls they already said will be coming with it.
4
u/FierroGamer May 07 '20
"the costs" of it.
I'm not as savy as I think I should be, do you mean stuff like telegram having to host the videos and the related privacy concerns? I don't think it should be a problem as long as they're transparent about it and let you not use that function, it will burn through their money faster tho.
5
u/d7mtg May 07 '20
limited to one to one
they clearly said otherwise.
from the telegram blog:
What's next, you might ask? The current global lockdown highlighted the need for a trusted video communication tool. Video calls in 2020 are much like messaging in 2013. There are apps that are either secure or usable, but not both. We'd like to fix that, and we will focus on bringing you secure group video calls in 2020.
5
u/FierroGamer May 07 '20
Frankly, you've made my day, I didn't even consider they would do such a thing, surely that will extend to group audio calls.
0
May 07 '20
[deleted]
5
u/FierroGamer May 07 '20
Oh, haven't used them in years, when I first checked them out me and a couple friends made comparisons and found telegram really good and even better than others that we tested. IIRC there were a couple settings to toggle to get the best results, now that I'm looking for them they don't seem to exist anymore so maybe they just settled with the more data saving option?
Edit: Heck, the call quality was the reason I got one of them hooked with telegram
5
u/SrGrimey May 07 '20
Not really, compared with whatsapp (where there's always a delay) they are good
5
u/Powerdamn May 07 '20
Well, WhatsApp sucks. However, Telegram calls used to better in 2017/2018 when they had a VoIP dev.
1
3
1
u/Powerdamn May 07 '20 edited May 07 '20
Yep, that's true. There is a reason for that: They don't have a VoIP dev for 1 year now. The VoIP library, libtgvoip, is pretty much stuck at version 2.4.4 for months if you check GitHub.
Also, there is that, which gives hope:
This stage concludes the public phase of the Telegram VoIP contests. In addition to receiving their prizes, some winners of the contest will be invited to work more closely with us on improving 1-to-1 voice calls, as well as launching group and video calls later this year. We will be reaching out to each of them separately – and are looking forward to working together.
Source: https://t.me/contest/166
17
u/vitali2y May 07 '20
Just do it better than Skype or Zoom, plz!
0
May 07 '20
[deleted]
4
0
u/Squiggledog May 07 '20
The voice calls are end-to-end encrypted, so can only be between two parties.
0
May 07 '20
[deleted]
1
u/mrbesen_ May 07 '20
Yes, i think signal has it implemented for group chats, no video calls but it should be possible.
5
5
u/SrGrimey May 07 '20
They said to stop asking this in their last blog post. I know it's not an easy thing to do, but considering Durev likes to compare with whatsapp it's weird that this feature hasn't been added yet.
4
3
2
2
2
u/d7mtg May 07 '20
This isn't really news.
What's next, you might ask? The current global lockdown highlighted the need for a trusted video communication tool. Video calls in 2020 are much like messaging in 2013. There are apps that are either secure or usable, but not both. We'd like to fix that, and we will focus on bringing you secure group video calls in 2020.
When will they be ready? You‘ll be the first to know when we’re done, promise. So stop asking.
- Telegram blog post, April 24, 2020
2
u/TrevvingTheEngine May 07 '20
Wonder if this will push WhatsApp to work on their video calls some more. They copied a lot from Telegram but this time they at least have a headstart and need to innovate if they want to keep people happy and not leaving for Telegram.
2
u/Squiggledog May 07 '20
VK has had video calls since 2017.
0
2
1
1
u/brofesor May 07 '20
At least something positive this year, huh? Hopefully with better audio calls first.
1
May 10 '20
Only normies would want such a feature. Another case for a slimmed down 'basics only' text version of TG.
1
1
May 25 '20
I'm very exciting of the sound and videoquality :3 but i think, telegram will do that great💻😍
-1
u/realkoyuchan May 07 '20
Telegram: adds useless features like darts and virus animations and does some PR around the coronavirus
Also Telegram: We're adding video calls soon™
-5
May 07 '20
Tweet DOES NOT exist. But they did say awhile back that video calls are coming in 2020. When they're ready.
1
u/jbar3640 May 07 '20
tweet does exist: https://www.reddit.com/r/telegram/comments/get5we/_/fpqtqdh
-5
May 07 '20
See it on mobile. Not on the app. This is the most recent response I see to the question. https://twitter.com/cazack15/status/1258232945585913857?s=19
2
u/jbar3640 May 07 '20
it's not the same original question tweet. not related with app or web browser. you may open previous link and check it yourself.
0
May 07 '20
[deleted]
3
u/FloPinguin May 07 '20
They have done contests about the best video stream encoding already many months ago
2
u/failsex69 May 07 '20
Link twett?