TL;DR — A clarification after reading your feedback:
This was my first Reddit post. The title mixed genuine frustration with playful Ted Lasso quotes; I didn’t mean it as anger or a personal attack. I understand why it landed that way, and I’m sorry.
I’m not asking for blind praise or less criticism. People are free to criticize, vent with others who relate, decide they’ve seen enough, or judge the show and move on frustrated. I respect those choices.
When I say judgment, I mean a rigid conclusion that closes off possibility—not discernment, criticism, or honestly sharing your experience.
“Be curious, not judgmental” has deeply affected how I approach people, art, and life. To me, curiosity holds conclusions open long enough for more information, understanding, appreciation, and possibilities to emerge.
When the intention is to help something improve, I hope we can offer more Roy-style feedback that gives Colin a way to grow and less Nate-style contempt that simply calls him a dolt. That’s an invitation, not an expectation.
Honest disagreement can create refinement and innovation. Toxic positivity can shut that down just as much as rigid negativity can.
My hope is for conversations where criticism, venting, disappointment, enjoyment, and belief can coexist without contempt. For more context, read my original, unfiltered thoughts below—or skip to the bottom edit for the perspective this community helped me refine. I appreciate your time and genuinely welcome your thoughts.
___
I’m disappointed by the fan base that used to show up so curious insightful and smart. The posts I’m seeing lately are full of judgment, little curiosity, and no BELIEF.
It’s like you are pretending to be curious but so hijacked by judgment your subconscious expectations govern that it fills this once loving space with bullshit that kills shows.
I know everyone here wants to see Ted Lasso at its best. I do too.
I’m getting curious about what’s going on and hopefully the artists behind the show can use our feedback to help them where it’s needed and trust that they will figure it out and we will all get to experience something better than we could have expected.
The show we loved was written with no expectations and full creative space for the magic of what we loved to come to life.
Years later, our egos just love to pick apart all the little things that are so challenging to navigate as expectations about characters and plot holes and all kinds of shit messes with the writers heads. (My take, not necessarily fact)
Maybe it’s old industry expectations like actor/actress contract minimums and wanting to spend more time with old characters we miss vs holding space for to fall in love with the new characters introduced? That shit is hard. Especially in a time when profit usually governs rather than artistic freedom and creating from the heart no matter the twists and turns it wants to take us on.
Learn from Brooklyn 99. Samberg never requested more screen time if it got in the way of the story and the quality of the show. That’s what’s needed. Idk how. But it’s important for all the wonderful people on this show to commit to that, if they haven’t already.
I feel that Ted Lasso could be an incredible gift to humanity as a 9 season show, with three 3-season arcs that explore different characters and the journeys they go through, how Ted uses his coaching style to help them become the best versions of themselves on and off the stage/pitch/court/field/board room. And how over 3 arcs, characters like Ted Beard Rebecca Roy and Keeley can learn, make mistakes, figure their shit out, and embody the best version of themselves that we fell in love with.
We are all guilty of repeating mistakes and not learning from them the first time. That shit is human. Don’t let your mind seeking novelty miss the beautiful impact that this human experience can reflect in our own journey. Maybe you going through that and judging yourself is why you judge the show. I’ve been there. I’m not going to be there anymore.
To quote Hamilton. We need to learn to say goodbye and welcome the new. To embrace new directions and be encouraging and curious to see where these beautiful souls want to take us.
Letting our attachments to what’s been done will only breed more unhelpful stuff like “this show has jumped the shark”. Do you really want that to be true? I don’t. I believe this show has the potential to take us through emotional journeys and breakthroughs that no other show has ever pulled off. Going deeper with characters we spend time with, exploring nuances that can only be explored after years of time with characters. And holding space for people in different stages of their journey learning growing and having fun facing the challenges because they aren’t alone. They have each other.
Very few incredible artists get a chance to fully share their hearts with the world with the resources and time that Jason and the team have. I hope Apple just realizes the gift of this and brings in the people onto the team to help these artists realize and create unhindered. I will show up however I can to help this vision.
In a time when art is killed by money analysis and temporary sentiments, let’s be a support that only makes the show we love thrive. After all, that’s what Ted would do.
Discern my friends. Don’t judge. Share what you observe and encourage something more authentic and magical to come forward.
Sending love to you all (creating the show and watching) and I can’t wait to see the magic yet to come.
___
EDIT — What I learned from this discussion:
Thank you to everyone who shared a perspective, especially those who helped me see where my message and the way I delivered it didn’t match.
I realized I was lumping criticism and judgment together. They aren’t the same. Discernment, criticism, and honestly saying something isn’t working are all important parts of making things better.
The clearest example of what I was trying to express is the difference between Nate and Roy giving Colin feedback. Nate saw Colin struggling and called him a dolt. Roy noticed the problem too, but gave Colin feedback he could actually use to improve his game. Both saw something that wasn’t working. One responded with contempt; the other created a possibility for growth. I see us as "Team Ted Lasso" so that sparked this whole thing.
That’s what I hoped to encourage: not “Don’t criticize the show,” but “Can we direct some of our criticism in ways that leave room for something better?” Nobody owes the writers a solution, but when we want to help something we love improve, specificity creates more possibility than contempt.
I also understand that sometimes people just need to vent their frustration and connect with other fans who feel the same way. That’s okay too. Not every reaction needs to become constructive feedback, a solution, or an invitation to a deeper conversation.
If someone has seen enough, reached their own conclusion, and is ready to judge the show and move on frustrated, they’re free to do that. I respect that choice, even when it isn’t the choice I would make for myself.
“Be curious, not judgmental” has always meant something larger to me than being curious about another person. I experience curiosity as an energy or posture toward life. It holds a conclusion open long enough for more information, understanding, and possibilities to appear. That reframe has made my life richer.
That speech led me to notice places where I had shut down too quickly—where I might have known someone more deeply, appreciated art from another angle, or built a stronger connection with a community. Judgment, when it becomes a rigid ending rather than useful discernment, can cut off possibilities and leave life less rich than it could be.
I also see that curiosity has to include perspectives I disagree with. Honest disagreement can begin refinement and innovation. Avoiding it through toxic positivity shuts down possibility from the opposite direction.
Some of my original words came from frustration, and I didn’t fully embody the curiosity I was trying to encourage. I assumed people’s motives and drew conclusions about the community while asking others to hold their conclusions more lightly. I’m taking that lesson with me.
What I still hope for is a space where we can point out what isn’t working, appreciate what is, vent when we need to, disagree honestly, and remain open to discovering something none of us can see yet. That’s an invitation, not an expectation.
I appreciate the time you gave this—whether you agreed with me, challenged me, or helped me find clearer words for what I was trying to say. I’m still listening and genuinely welcome your thoughts.