r/Technocracy • u/Necessary-Art8995 • Aug 31 '26
r/Technocracy • u/MIG-Lazzara • Jan 04 '26
Venezuela
Should Venezuela be slowly incorporated into the United States to help make progress towards the original Technate design?
r/Technocracy • u/EzraNaamah • Mar 14 '25
Should Technocrats Use Religion To Control Society?
Obviously this creates a lot of moral and practical problems, but less intelligent people who cannot understand politics are evidently more swayed by religious ideas than actual scientific evidence. In China, the communist party has made plans to choose the next incarnation of the next Dalai Lama and they have said before that animals stopped becoming spirits once socialism was established. Despite being atheistic, I think they eventually just decided it’s easier to play along with religion than to try and get it out of people.
A technocratic society could choose an alternative to the pope for the technate, and with a bit of influence we could have our pope guide the religious institutions of the country closer to progressive ideas and away from the extremist and dangerous rhetoric that is currently being spread. The same could theoretically be done for other major religions within the technate, to stop foreign bourgeoisie from holding influence over technate citizens. Some religions like major cults or sects are based within the US, so those would be even easier to infiltrate and usurp. Maybe we could even declare our own reincarnation of the Dalai Lama or provide legitimacy and support to the one chosen by the Chinese Communist Party.
A more subtle way of doing this would be to ban church donations or ownership of religious institutions by private individuals, which means that wealthy people could not build megachurches that contribute towards the degradation of science, human rights, or towards even more nefarious goals. This would also promote religious tolerance as long as major institutions do not interfere with the human rights of people in society.
I see this as a win for everybody since people can go to their services and the rest of society doesn’t need to deal with fanatics and religious extremists. However some people may eventually take issue with it. What do you guys think, is this better or worse than state secularism, or simply ignoring this section of the population?
r/Technocracy • u/KlemiusKlem • Jan 26 '23
The Technocratic Schism
We are in the middle of a split inside our community and movement. There are these who mistake scientific communism and marxism with the true core idea of Technocracy and the rest of us.
Many have bastardised the original beliefs while copying the marxist works and theories without considering that Technocracy is not a child of marxist thought but rather a new idea founded on our true idea. Expert rule!.
Joules command economy, communist societal stratification, marxist rhetoric and communist approach to realising Technocracy are but a few examples of this ideological contamination.
The split can be seen in the online field as the discord server decided first to establish again our roots. Do not be fooled by the loud minority, we are the vast majority!
r/Technocracy • u/YeetFromHungary • Oct 07 '23
Technocracy sounds nice and everything but I fear a possible over-centralisation or dictatorship, and I am sceptical of the whole socialism thing.
What I mean by the title?
Simple. I consider myself a man of liberty. I don't like being told what to do in every way. But I don't reject the idea of a state and the existance of rules. And here is the thing, if I want to do something and a person who I know that knows more than I do or proved to be more skillfull, I'm going to listen. So that's why I like the sound of technocracy and meritocracy. People who actually know what they are doing or proved to know that they do a good job is way better than some demagogue with empty promises.
But I fear the over-centralisation of power in any form. Why? You see, I am from a post-socialist nation, one from the Eastern-bloc. I may not have lived in those times but I can tell that the old system and the current one have something similar. Centralised power. Why is that bad? The ones who have the say in things had and have it way better than anyone else and they were and are pretty opressive when it comes tó the question of power. That's why I fear the centralisation of power, because it's a coin flip if the ones in charge live back with their power or not.
And why I don't like the whole socialism thing? One is that we can see from experience that the socialist regime sucked. The entire Eastern-bloc was genually less developed than the West. And sure, different time, different level of development, but still, I consider the capitalist system more preferable. But I don't ignore all it's problems.
I belive that if you want something, work for it. And I follow the morale "no lunch comes free", but also, the price you pay matters. So it doesn't matter of you want a house, you pay debt for the rest of your life or you pay it back within 7 years (for example).
A bonus point to the capitalist system is that Franco (I know he was pretty much a fascist) listened to actual experts and turned to a capitalist system and it worked pretty well.
But to be honest I find a distributist system preferable. I find the wide ownership and of capital or being self sustaining good ways to avoid tyranny and exploitation.
r/Technocracy • u/LEGO_Man2YT • Jul 07 '25
Some people, me included, missunderstood this sub
Trigger warning I guess
As I've seen in the last posts, you guys want technocracy as it was originally intended, communism with ruling scientists, and that's ok, seems better than the current government of my country, but I thought this community was more open to more ways of thinking.
I think almost any economic system can work under a technocrathic government, but a majority (not only here) sees no difference between both politic and economic systems or sees them as absolute incompatible things.
I guess I can't call myself a thechnocrat if this is how people will prejudice me.
I'm against kakistocracy, and I think we all should. But I thought wrong this was a sinonym of technocracy.
r/Technocracy • u/EzraNaamah • Jan 18 '25
Why I Propose The Technocracy Movement Have An Esoteric/ Occult Branch
Trigger Warning: If you are offended by discussion of religious ideas or atheism you may not want to read this. I had to explain a lot of things for this proposal to make sense, but my intention is not to proselytize for/against any religion or spiritual ideology. If this scares you, then consider it a work of fiction.
A big issue with getting everyone to agree on scientific government is that people weaponize religion to make people believe the things they want them to. Prosperity gospel is an obvious example where people are told wealth is a result of faith, inadvertently putting an implied blame on the poor for being faithless. Other issues such as lifestyles that deviate from those organized religion deems acceptable are also made into huge issues. I believe that organized religion in the current developed world is a net negative for human progress.
So I am proposing an esoteric/occult branch. It’s not to promote any religious or spiritual ideology but actually to promote atheism. It may seem like nonsense or it may seem like an oxymoron, but as someone that has personally experienced paranormal events I actually feel closer to atheism and logic as a result, because I come to the conclusion that modern religion cannot provide satisfactory explanations for the things that happen mor these things that (apparently?) exist. The Scientific method applied to the supernatural also stops fanaticism and idolization of things that humanity simply cannot fully understand. Once people experience encounters with supernatural beings and/or anomalies and the process loses its mystique, I believe that fanaticism will die.
By making scientific deductions about the occult, you can only say for sure that anomalous beings exist and for the person who is deeply devoted to them, they show up once in a blue moon. Instead of having it validate whatever beliefs people have about the supernatural, you can come to the opposite conclusion and think that religion exists because primitive humans encountered these things at some point. Some people may feel strongly that we can interact with these things in certain ways and get desired results most of the time, but I find that it’s not incompatible with secularism or atheism since that understanding does not create fanaticism for those who are experienced with it.
I will admit I do realize the huge irony in proposing an esoteric branch is created to promote atheism and secularism, but I believe some people will not take theocratic ideas and faith-based thinking off of a pedestal without this information. I am also confident that the effects of such a movement on society would be profound.
r/Technocracy • u/DJFlawed • Oct 30 '24
Is Technocracy About Ideology or Data?
I seem to have ruffled a few feathers in this channel, which is good—that’s what technocratic thinking is all about! However, I’m seeing a lot of focus on ideology here. So I’d like to challenge this channel. If I’m wrong, I’ll accept it. But isn’t ideology fundamentally opposed to the technocratic process?
Ideology, by definition, is a set of beliefs or doctrines that individuals or groups hold onto, often resistant to change regardless of new data. In contrast, technocracy is about adapting and evolving based on empirical data, not clinging to rigid beliefs.
The modern technocratic process, as I see it, should align with the Reddit definition here: using scientific methods to manage resources, optimize welfare, and guide society. Yet many here seem to be defending Technocracy Inc., an outdated ideological model from Howard Scott. If you believe in Scott’s model, then show me the data supporting it. I’ve searched thoroughly, and I haven’t found any real-world model or empirical evidence backing his ideas.
Why are we focused on an ideological vision that hasn’t been proven, instead of the adaptable, evidence-based process that technocracy should represent? Isn’t that the exact opposite of the purpose of this channel?
r/Technocracy • u/MinuteStatistician52 • Jan 29 '22
Some other stuff
Development on my biggest work/contribution to technocracy will begin tonight.
PEOPLE! STOP STOP!!! STOOOOOOOOPPPPP writing "Manifestos", they're counter productive and I'm working on something better as we speak but you'll need some patience, quality over quantity after all.
I may have to return to the discord in the future, to collect data for my projects.
I've setup an email for stuff relating to the movement ([email protected]).
If you want to write stuff, and actually feel like you're contributing/being heard please write your ideas in a word/google doc and email it to me, the subject I'd like you to respond to is "Describe your ideal state", basically write down what technocracy means to you and how you'd implement it, I expect at least a couple paragraphs to read over.
All the responses will influence my document I plan to release, so this is most likely the easiest way for any of you guys who want to really change the course of, or direct the movement in any way to do so.
r/Technocracy • u/[deleted] • Nov 10 '24
Too many people in this sub believe AI would lead to a perfect technocracy.
Title speaks for itself.
r/Technocracy • u/Routine_Complaint_79 • Sep 15 '26
Some concept Technocracy flags
We need to super be vigilant to protect minorities because I'm tired of governments and political movements not caring about people. There is no government without the people and there is no people without their culture and people just love hating on it whenever one bad actor does something wrong.
If Technocracy ever wants to get off its feet and become mainstream we need to make these people feel safe. A lot of mainstream sub-reddits have icons with pride in them, I say we should do the same.
r/Technocracy • u/DJFlawed • Oct 30 '24
Howard Scott’s Technocracy Inc. is Not a Guide, Nor is it Real Technocracy—It was Ideology
Howard Scott’s Technocracy Inc. is often referenced as if it represents true technocracy, but that’s a misconception. Scott’s vision was heavily ideological and focused on replacing capitalism with a rigid, centrally planned “Technate” driven by an “energy theory of value.” This approach treated technocracy as an all-or-nothing system, rather than a flexible, pragmatic way of solving problems.
True technocracy isn’t bound to any single economic model or system. Instead, it’s about using expertise and data to address real-world challenges, regardless of whether the solutions are capitalist, socialist, or something else. A real technocratic approach adapts to what works, without pushing a strict ideology or tearing down existing structures unless there’s strong, practical evidence that it’s necessary.
Modern technocracy values what’s effective, not what fits into a specific ideology, and Scott’s rigid vision doesn’t capture that.
r/Technocracy • u/MinuteStatistician52 • Apr 07 '22
Announcement
The Technocratic movement has rejected my ideals, and I can fight the community all I want, but, fundamentally, if no one supports me, my ideas will not gain traction, and my ideas do not gain traction, there is no movement or cohesion.
Thus I have decided to step away from politics completely for the time being, I'm going to use my spare time to focus on building up an education and making money, also studying politics more, but not participating in it actively.
I view this as a short term sacrifice for a significant long term gain, doctors also told me it's probably better for my health this way.
I will cease all online political activity, except posting documents to develop the ideology further every couple months, I think will mainly conduct that here, these documents will mostly focus on criticism and application of technocracy, rather than defining it as others have done numerous times here.
Thank you for your understanding.
r/Technocracy • u/EzraNaamah • Aug 24 '26
Building a Technocratic Movement in an Age of Sexual Repression
While I would rather be writing about purely economic or policy issues, I believe any political movement would be ineffective without tackling the problems generated from sexual repression. Freud’s theories may sound ludicrous to apply to political ideas, but the constant societal focus on issues like natalism, marriage, feminism, and even the rights of transgender people are just a socially acceptable way to have arguments about sexuality.
The economic issues play a very large role, but many people identify with ideologies that oppose socialism so they would not want programs to help them unless they were modified or presented in certain ways so they conform to their own ideological beliefs. This results in the economic issues going unaddressed in favor of the ones that resonate with emotional needs and sexual drives like the ones mentioned before. It also means that for Technocrats, our policy proposals and ideas may actually feel too distant and disconnected from the motivations of potential members and citizens of the future technate. For a Technocratic system to truly inspire a following, it may be a good strategy to emphasize how the abolishment of the price system would increase personal freedom and vastly improve the reproductive autonomy of the population.
The major increase in power and popularity of conservative ideas has been alarming, but when viewed from the angle of sexual frustration and as the real motivations behind them being related to reproductive autonomy, they all begin to make sense. Left-wing movements have struggled to tap into the population of sexually frustrated men because of their inability to handle and manage themselves through ideological deviation, which has resulted in a culture among socialists about proving their ideological alignment and purity. While this is not inherently a bad thing, the desire to perform and enforce conformity to an ideology leads to similar repression of true motivations and goals that is seen in religious groups. From a functional perspective, this is catastrophic if modern political problems are about sex and the population cannot relate a movement’s ideology to the fulfillment of their own personal needs.
While a Technocratic movement can tap into a population traditionally loyal to rightism, we will need to modify our approach and be flexible in accepting who calls themselves a Technocrat and what their goals are from participating. Depending on the political climate and the system of government that Technocrats are operating under, it may be more important to rally people around and have them identify with your party than to actually have them conform ideologically to your movement. The inability to understand political systems or understand policy decisions made by experts does not disqualify anyone from supporting a Technocratic party, and the willingness to accept support and identification from the masses is what can take a movement from theoretical to applied to a current world government.
r/Technocracy • u/EzraNaamah • Mar 16 '25
What Foreign Governments/ Organizations Are Sympathetic To Our Cause?
There is a hacker group called Anonymous that is performing cyberattacks on social media to oppose the regime here, and it has me wondering if any activist organizations or foreign governments are potentially sympathetic to our movement and would be willing to provide training/ weapons/ ideological or financial support to help us. Also, should we be willing to adopt certain political stances in exchange for support such as denouncing Ukraine for aid from Russia, etc.? In some cases it might be easier to get aid if we just call ourselves communist.
If we do get support from hackers/ foreign governments and they want to teach us how to damage government infrastructure or give us a bunch of money, is there any organized political party that can organize training and the distribution of aid as well as decide how it will be used? Right now I think Technocracy Inc. is the only real organization with the name, at least in this country? Even if it’s underground we would need some entity to be able to receive support for this scenario.
r/Technocracy • u/RemyVonLion • Nov 10 '24
Technocracy by humans might be inherently impossible.
So I was thinking about how our fate depends on AI, experts, and leaders, and how the CEO of a company like OpenAI should be an expert in the field as well as clearly ethical/humanist, not just some novice that has charisma and leadership, because our future depends on both guiding and building AI for an overall optimal outcome. That's where the problem is, the experts are busy working while the people with leadership skills and basic knowledge of the field do all the management and decision-making/guidance. This ultimately means that we will have to rely on future AI to lead us into an optimally designed future, as our best experts are too busy at work to decide what to do with what they're making.
r/Technocracy • u/biliby8172 • May 17 '26
Do humans actually need rulers, or are we just used to being ruled?
I’ve always been skeptical of governments, leaders, and any system where a small group holds overwhelming power over everyone else.
Not because I think every government is evil.
It’s more that I keep asking myself:
When did humans collectively accept that millions of people always need a handful of people to tell them what direction society should go?
Do people truly need leadership?
Or have we simply become dependent on it because modern civilization became too big and complicated?
Sometimes I try to imagine what Earth would look like without these large centralized power structures.
No supreme authority.
No permanent ruling class.
No institution deciding what is “correct” for everyone.
Would society completely fall apart?
Or would people eventually find new ways to organize themselves naturally?
Maybe communities would become smaller and more human again.
Maybe technology and global connectivity could replace parts of traditional government structures.
Maybe real collective intelligence forms better from the bottom up than from the top down.
But maybe the opposite is also true.
Without systems, laws, and coordination, human beings might become even more tribal, violent, and fearful.
That’s why I don’t think this is a simple question.
I’m not trying to promote chaos or argue that civilization itself is bad.
I’m just wondering whether centralized authority is truly something humanity will always need,
or whether it’s simply a stage of civilization that we haven’t evolved past yet.
What if the systems we see as “normal” today are only temporary forms of human organization?
r/Technocracy • u/N_Quadralux • Nov 04 '24
Could some form of monarchism make part in a technocracy?
Both technocrats an monarchists agree that generally, being ruled by few people that know how to reign is better than being rule by everyone if that everyone is stupid. They diverge whatever, in how that ruler should be chosen.
But let's suppose a royal family whose royals are thoroughly educated in how to do good, that also have limits in their power instead of being absolutists of course. Considering how having a monarch can be good for tourism and help national unity, do you think that some form of monarchism, maybe even just a cerimonial one, be of use for a technocracy?
Edit: I'm just curious, not saying that I think it would be the best option. As a lot of you said it probably wouldn't be very useful most of the time
r/Technocracy • u/o69k • Jul 30 '20
Social positions poll
Issues: Abortion, gay marriage, women's rights, immigration and trans ""rights"".
r/Technocracy • u/LoveLo_2005 • Dec 08 '25
Are Disney parks an example of what a Technocratic society would be like?
At Disney parks, everything is meticulously planned and managed with close attention to detail. At the Magic Kingdom, utilities and service rooms are placed beneath the park in 'utilidors' so maintenance workers can operate the park without disturbing the guests on the surface as well as being able to quickly move around. Service equipment on the surface are painted in a shade of green called 'Go Away Green' to not stick out. Trash cans are placed within 30 steps of each other so that guests are never too far away from one.
r/Technocracy • u/[deleted] • Dec 01 '23
What are your thoughts about Islam
Can Islamic theocracy and technocracy be synthesized?
