It has only been 9 years, but the release of this album has felt inextricably oxidized after the global events since that time, furthered by Swiftâs re-recordings.
Reputation is a pivotal album from a star in the pop sphere, standing out from the rest of her discography. It came from a transitionary point in Taylor Swiftâs life, as the last of her 6 albums to be under the control of her record lable Big Machine (with whom she worked under for 13 years), before her further propulsion into globe-dominating fame.
But nine years ago, we werenât quite here yet. At the time, it was a highly-critiqued album in the publicâs eye. The phase of her last project (1989) ends with the last single, New Romantics, released off the heels of her 1989 World Tour before the infamous Kim Kardashian drama causes a Taylor swift blackout after #taylorswiftisoverparty trends on Twitter. Swift recludes, going virtually unseen for a year before clearing all of her social media; emerging from the smoke with the visage of the viper metaphors used against her.
Itâs hard to fully describe the dichotomy taking place at the time. What was this country-sweetheart-with-a-fake twang-turned-pop star doing, mumble-rapping lines to herself over a snatchy beat to a sample of Too Sexy For My Shirt? It was beyond many peopleâs imaginations- with a music video where she swings evocatively in a cage, as if trapped in her own private circus, and then lords over fallen clones of herself, before rapping to the pulsing bass of an oddly alternative Sleigh Bells-inspired tune, before singing her heart out about found love over rolling drums and synth thrums later in the album?
Sheâs been known to be ahead of trends at times (the edm breakdown in I Knew You Were Trouble. being a popular example, or her folk-inspired album released near the start of the pandemic), but it could be said that this was the biggest standout of her synth-pop era before folklore; it sticks out like an edgy step-child. While her 1989 album was definitely better-received, this one offered a somewhat matured take on the sound. In much of her discography, Swift doesnât try to break the mold; she ignores it entirely, finding the flavors that work best to tell her stories in. But this album is very much the exception- coupled with 2017-era vocal chops and heavy vocoder, soft EDM breakdowns under hi-hats, singing about being lonely at parties and Twitter (now X) shade, this album is very much an ode to her presence in the media at the time, the very reputation she speaks of.
While immensely popular, she wasnât quite the cultural icon people think of just yet. For sure, she was very much the face of Millennial music and had solidified her presence in that generation. But there werenât fans competing so fiercely for scalped tickets enough to crash Ticketmaster, or large enough venues to cause minor earthquakes.
But she was always a marketing monolith- While the world of Swift was a much smaller place, this was still a planet where singles were could be locked behind deluxe album premiums (New Romantics), and streaming was also still developing at the time (remember when Taylor Swift left Spotify?); although this album ended that trend by being her first to have no deluxe.
Itâs also impossible to write about this without referencing her Taylorâs Versions- this is one out of the two remaining albums left without one, due to her regaining control of her library and so abandoning the project (for now).
A lot has happened since the release, but there are a few things that even now seem to have slipped past the public lens. We know a lot about how her situation with her masters developed. But if we take a look back at these lyrics, was she trying to tell us this all way before it happened?
Love is a very common theme among her previous discography, as well as being wronged (Better Than Revenge and Bad Blood coming to mind), but not necessarily the level of angst present throughout this album; topics of things tantalizingly held in front of others. Take these lyric snippets:
âŚReady For It?
âKnew I was a robber, first time that he saw me // Stealing hearts and running off and never saying sorryâ
End Game (ft. Ed Sheeran and Future)
âI bury hatchets but I keep maps of where I put âemâ
I Did Something Bad
âCause for every lie I tell them // they tell me three. This is how the world works // now all he thinks about is meâŚâ
Donât Blame Me
âDonât blame me // Love made me crazy. If it doesnât, you ainât doing it rightâ
Look What You Made Me Do
âI donât like your kingdom keys. They once belonged to me. // You asked me for a place to sleep. Locked me out, and threw a feastâ
So It GoesâŚ
âAll eyes on us⌠You make everyone disappear and // Cut me into pieces. Gold cage, hostage to my feelingsâ
Delicate
âMy reputationâs never been worse so // you must like me for me.â
This Is Why We Canât Have Nice Things
âSo whyâd you have to rain on my parade? // Iâm shaking my head and locking the gatesâ
Call It What You Want
âI brought a knife to a gunfight // They took the crown but itâs all rightâ
With ones like Nice Things, it was pretty obvious that this song was about Kim Kardashian, as she references âfriends donât try to trick you // Get you on the phone, and mind-twist youâ. But with tracks like Look What You Made Me Do, itâs a lot more vague- she doesnât explicitly say who she is referencing (not that she ever calls by name, but itâs left more mysterious here).
Now, many of these lyrics are also about love, but one theme stood out in particular from âŚReady For It?. In the albumâs first track she already starts out cryptic, switching between the edgy criminal persona and her vulnerable self in the lyrics:
âIsland breeze, and lights down lowâŚâ
âI see nothing better, I keep him forever, like a vendettaâŚâ
âin the middle of the night, in my dreamsâ
This song, oddly enough, parallels the single Wildest Dreams from her previous album in many ways:
âletâs get out of this townâ
âsee me in hindsight, tangled up with you all nightâ
âin your wildest dreamsâ
Both reference escape and fulfillment of their fantasies; hidden from the gaze of the public under the guise of sleep. In this newer worldâs music video, she is still very much there, but now trapped in a glass box and visited by her edgy cyberpunk doppelgänger.
Itâs obvious âŚReady For It? is structured as if to a lover. But if you listen more closely, some of those other themes return:
âWondered how many girls he had loved and left haunted. But if heâs a ghost then // I can be a phantom, holding him for ransomâ.
There it is again, that theme of parallels and finding tat for tit. She may be analyzing herself through the publicâs eye- or is she referencing her current self, trying so hard to control that âtrueâ Taylor inside the box, but being unable?
She has stated before that she knew her music would be sold, but she got no say in who it was to and found out along with the public.
(Note: I would not be the first to cover the topic of reputation in relation to her regaining control of her masters. But it still shocks me to this day that the only results to come up easily on the topic of reputationâs meaning in relation to her life at this time are from Buzzfeed.)
She is known for her âcluesâ that send many Taylor Swift fans into frenzies interpreting the smallest details. Sheâs not often one to do things without intention. And during this era, as that article points out, she was seen wearing mermaid memorabilia many times, even dressing as Ariel herself for Halloween as well as posing in a 2017 Marc Jacobs Resort camo anorak jacket emblazoned with patches, including one of a mermaid (more on the symbolism soon).
When she returned from her year-long silence with new music (cold-dropping Look What You Made Me Do on YouTube after posting a simple image saying âFirst single out tomorrow nightâ on Instagram, and another simply stating the title and release date along with the new album cover), the first single was heavily critiqued by many news outlets, including the Guardian. Pitchfork even called it a petty snarl of a single that jumped to No. 1 thanks largely to sheer anticipation, despite it immediately breaking records for the most views/streams in 24 hours on YouTube and Spotify.
Many fans were left skeptical upon their first listen of the lead single, unsure of who the lyrics were referencing or what this new approach was. Many people guessed it was about Kim or Kanye, especially with the snake imagery, but something didnât quite add up at the time. This song was different than her previous work, and very bold. Not just because of her relationship with the publicâs eye at that time being so rocky, but because it was almost a direct âscrew youâ to her label, even if nobody knew what she was referencing.
She speaks to herself in a culturally significant moment, proclaiming âthe old Taylor Swiftâ dead. Many assumed she was saying goodbye to her old image, shedding her former skin so to speak- but it became apparent as the years passed that she wasnât talking about leaving her old work behind; it was that it was beyond her grasp. Many of the songs on this album tie into her reputation, and can also be analyzed about her relationships as well- but this song is undoutedly speaking about something different.
The first verse is pretty general in that itâs hard to pinpoint one person (âI don't like your little games⌠the role you made me play, of the foolâ). But the second is where things get more interesting:
âI don't like your kingdom keys
They once belonged to me
You asked me for a place to sleep. Locked me out, and threw a feast (what?)
The world moves on, another day another drama, drama
But not for me, not for me, all I think about is karma
And then the world moves on, but one thing's for sure
Maybe I got mine, but you'll all get yoursâ
The first part speaks to these metaphorical keys, to her work. It became public later on, announced during Lover that Scooter and Big Machine would only let her keep her master recordings if she recorded 6 new albums, allowing her to regain control of her masters in a one-for-one hostage exchange. Scooter and the label signed her on as a young teen, and then wanted to reap the profits of her work and lock her out of the process. In this context, the mermaid imagery begins to make more sense. For those that may somehow not have seen the masterpiece that is this movie, itâs about a young merwoman who, in order to find love on land trades her voice to an evil seawitch, who ends up using it for her gain (sound familiar?).
This was before the public knew a lick of anything about her album deals. In the music video for Look What You Made Me Do (which is unforgettable for a multitude of reasons, including an homage to the Pussycat dolls, the diamond bath, and the old Taylors arguing), she is also seen dining at a table in a shot reminiscent of a courtroom, before swinging around a cage in a jumpsuit-orange garb wearing gold shackle-like bracelets.
This is from the same song where she refers to being locked out, and a âfeastâ being thrown from said home. What do courts and feasting have to do with each other? To paraphrase from the second single, the games had begun.
When she is asked in April of 2016 in her 73 Questions with Vogue âWhat advice would you give to anyone who wants to become a good singer?â she answers, âGet a good lawyer.â
She may not have told us outright, but she was being point-blank. In her own words on the topic:
prolog from reputation
âWe think we know someone, but the truth is that we only know the version of them that they have chosen to show us.â
So what did we make her do exactly? She developed a whole new persona for this era, ditching the album promotions and fan events sheâd always done in the past. We had the publicity part down; she was very clear in that message. But it seems she was going through more at the time than just a shift in the social kaleidoscope: she was dropping hints the entire time of what was happening, as openly as allowed, piece by piece.
To wrap up, this album has definitely solidified its place as a staple from her repertoire, despite its charged reception. While itâs very much a product of the time, in sound and content, that would seem to be the goal here, and it can live on in our memories as a tribute to Taylor Swiftâs past.
The world may not have been ready for its arrival, but it certainly became a tribute to her reputation.