r/TargetedIndividuals • u/Atoraxic • 10h ago
ROLLING STONE ~ CARL BERNSTEIN ~THE CIA AND THE MEDIA (1977)
living in an age filled with seemingly unlimited electronic media access and exposure, a quick look back at the CIA’s interest and involvement in the media of a half a century ago could broaden our warning radar sensing for possible Inteligence interest in, involvement with and influence over modern media and the resultant power it wields over us. Manipulation of victims online social communities has proven powerfully effective at manipulating: Investigators, L.E., Researchers, Journalists, Health Care Professionals and general public opinion in order to psychologically armor and camouflage this disturbing illegal and immoral initiative.
THE CIA AND THE MEDIA
How Americas Most Powerful News Media Worked Hand in Glove with the Central
Intelligence Agency and Why the Church Committee Covered It Up
After leaving The Washington Post in 1977, Carl Bernstein spent six months looking at the
relationship of the CIA and the press during the Cold War years. His 25,000-word cover
story, published in Rolling Stone on October 20, 1977, is reprinted below.
THE CIA AND THE MEDIA
How America's Most Powerful News Media Worked Hand in Glove with the Central
Intelligence Agency and Why the Church Committee Covered It Up
BY CARL BERNSTEIN
In 1953, Joseph Alsop, then one of America's leading syndicated columnists, went to the
Philippines to cover an election. He did not go because he was asked to do so by his
syndicate. He did not go because he was asked to do so by the newspapers that printed his
column. He went at the request of the CIA.
Alsop is one of more than 400 American journalists who in the past twenty-five years have
secretly carried out assignments for the Central Intelligence Agency, according to documents
on file at CIA headquarters. Some of these journalists' relationships with the Agency were
tacit; some were explicit. There was cooperation, accommodation and overlap. Journalists
provided a full range of clandestine services -- from simple intelligence gathering to serving
as go-betweens with spies in Communist countries. Reporters shared their notebooks with the
CIA. Editors shared their staffs. Some of the journalists were Pulitzer Prize winners,
distinguished reporters who considered themselves ambassadors without-portfolio for their
country. Most were less exalted: foreign correspondents who found that their association with
the Agency helped their work; stringers and freelancers who were as interested in the derring-
do of the spy business as in filing articles; and, the smallest category, full-time CIA
employees masquerading as journalists abroad. In many instances, CIA documents show,
journalists were engaged to perform tasks for the CIA with the consent of the managements
of America's leading news organizations.
The history of the CIA's involvement with the American press continues to be shrouded by
an official policy of obfuscation and deception for the following principal reasons:
* The use of journalists has been among the most productive means of intelligence-gathering
employed by the CIA. Although the Agency has cut back sharply on the use of reporters
since 1973 (primarily as a result of pressure from the media), some journalist-operatives are
still posted abroad.
* Further investigation into the matter, CIA officials say, would inevitably reveal a series of
embarrassing relationships in the 1950s and 1960s with some of the most powerful
organizations and individuals in American journalism.
Among the executives who lent their cooperation to the Agency were Williarn Paley of the
Columbia Broadcasting System, Henry Luce of Time Inc., Arthur Hays Sulzberger of the
New York Times, Barry Bingham Sr. of the LouisviIle Courier-Journal, and James Copley of
the Copley News Service. Other organizations which cooperated with the CIA include the
American Broadcasting Company, the National Broadcasting Company, the Associated Press,
United Press International, Reuters, Hearst Newspapers, Scripps-Howard, Newsweek
magazine, the Mutual Broadcasting System, the Miami Herald and the old Saturday Evening
Post and New York Herald-Tribune.
By far the most valuable of these associations, according to CIA officials, have been with the
New York Times, CBS and Time Inc.
The CIA's use of the American news media has been much more extensive than Agency
officials have acknowledged publicly or in closed sessions with members of Congress. The
general outlines of what happened are indisputable; the specifics are harder to come by. CIA
sources hint that a particular journalist was trafficking all over Eastern Europe for the
Agency; the journalist says no, he just had lunch with the station chief. CIA sources say flatly
that a well-known ABC correspondent worked for the Agency through 1973; they refuse to
identify him. A high-level CIA official with a prodigious memory says that the New York
Times provided cover for about ten CIA operatives between 1950 and 1966; he does not
know who they were, or who in the newspaper's management made the arrangements.
The Agency's special relationships with the so-called "majors" in publishing and
broadcasting enabled the CIA to post some of its most valuable operatives abroad without
exposure for more than two decades. In most instances, Agency files show, officials at the
highest levels of the CIA (usually director or deputy director) dealt personally with a single
designated individual in the top management of the cooperating news organization. The aid
furnished often took two forms: providing jobs and credentials ("journalistic cover" in
Agency parlance) for CIA operatives about to be posted in foreign capitals; and lending the
Agency the undercover services of reporters already on staff, including some of the best-
known correspondents in the business.
In the field, journalists were used to help recruit and handle foreigners as agents; to acquire
and evaluate information, and to plant false information with officials of foreign
governments. Many signed secrecy agreements, pledging never to divulge anything about
their dealings with the Agency; some signed employment contracts., some were assigned
case officers and treated with. unusual deference. Others had less structured relationships
with the Agency, even though they performed similar tasks: they were briefed by CIA
personnel before trips abroad, debriefed afterward, and used as intermediaries with foreign
agents. Appropriately, the CIA uses the term "reporting" to describe much of what
cooperating journalists did for the Agency. "We would ask them, 'Will you do us a
favor?'".said a senior CIA official. "'We understand you're going to be in Yugoslavia. Have
they paved all the streets? Where did you see planes? Were there any signs of military
presence? How many Soviets did you see? If you happen to meet a Soviet, get his name and
spell it right .... Can you set up a meeting for is? Or relay a message?'" Many CIA officials
regarded these helpful journalists as operatives; the journalists tended to see themselves as
trusted friends of the Agency who performed occasional favors -- usually without pay -- in
the national interest.
"I'm proud they asked me and proud to have done it," said Joseph Alsop who, like his late
brother, columnist Stewart Alsop, undertook clandestine tasks for the Agency. "The notion
that a newspaperman doesn't have a duty to his country is perfect balls."
From the Agency's perspective, there is nothing untoward in such relationships, and any
ethical questions are a matter for the journalistic profession to resolve, not the intelligence
community. As Stuart Loory, former Los Angeles Times correspondent, has written in the
Columbia Journalism Review: 'If even one American overseas carrying a press card is a paid
informer for the CIA, then all Americans with those credentials are suspect .... If the crisis of
confidence faced by the news business -- along with the government -- is to be overcome,
journalists must be willing to focus on themselves the same spotlight they so relentlessly
train on others!' But as Loory also noted: "When it was reported... that newsmen themselves
were on the payroll of the CIA, the story caused a brief stir, and then was dropped."
During the 1976 investigation of the CIA by the Senate Intelligence Committee, chaired by
Senator Frank Church, the dimensions of the Agency's involvement with the press became
apparent to several members of the panel, as well as to two or three investigators on the staff.
But top officials of the CIA, including former directors William Colby and George Bush,
persuaded the committee to restrict its inquiry into the matter and to deliberately
misrepresent the actual scope of the activities in its final report. The multivolume report
contains nine pages in which the use of journalists is discussed in deliberately vague and
sometimes misleading terms. It makes no mention of the actual number of journalists who
undertook covert tasks for the CIA. Nor does it adequately describe the role played by
newspaper and broadcast executives in cooperating with the Agency.
THE AGENCY'S DEALINGS WITH THE PRESS BEGAN during the earliest stages of the
Cold War. Allen Dulles, who became director of the CIA in 1953, sought to establish a
recruiting-and-cover capability within America's most prestigious journalistic institutions. By
operating under the guise of accredited news correspondents, Dulles believed, CIA operatives
abroad would be accorded a degree of access and freedom of movement unobtainable under
almost any other type of cover.
American publishers, like so many other corporate and institutional leaders at the time, were
willing to commit the resources of their companies to the struggle against "global
Communism." Accordingly, the traditional line separating the American press corps and
government was often indistinguishable: rarely was a news agency used to provide cover for
CIA operatives abroad without the knowledge and consent of either its principal owner,
publisher or senior editor. Thus, contrary to the notion that the CIA insidiously infiltrated the
journalistic community, there is ample evidence that America's leading publishers and news
executives allowed themselves and their organizations to become handmaidens to the
intelligence services. "Let's not pick on some poor reporters, for God's sake," William Colby
exclaimed at one point to the Church committee's investigators. "Let's go to the
managements. They were witting." In all, about twenty-five news organizations (including
those listed at the beginning of this article) provided cover for the Agency.
In addition to cover capability, Dulles initiated a "debriefing" procedure under which
American correspondents returning from abroad routinely emptied their notebooks and
offered their impressions to Agency personnel. Such arrangements, continued by Dulles'
successors, to the present day, were made with literally dozens of news organizations. In the
1950s, it was not uncommon for returning reporters to be met at the ship by CIA officers.
"There would be these guys from the CIA flashing ID cards and looking like they belonged at
the Yale Club," said Hugh Morrow, a former Saturday Evening Post correspondent who is
now press secretary to former vice-president Nelson Rockefeller. "It got to be so routine that
you felt a little miffed if you weren't asked."
CIA officials almost always refuse to divulge the names of journalists who have cooperated
with the Agency. They say it would be unfair to judge these individuals in a context different
from the one that spawned the relationships in the first place. "There was a time when it
wasn't considered a crime to serve your government," said one high-level CIA official who
makes no secret of his bitterness. "This all has to be considered in the context of the morality
of the times, rather than against latter-day standards -- and hypocritical standards at that."
Many journalists who covered World War II were close to people in the Office of Strategic
Services, the wartime predecessor of the CIA; more important, they were all on the same
side. When the war ended and many OSS officials went into the CIA, it was only natural that
these relationships would continue. Meanwhile, the first postwar generation of journalists
entered the profession; they shared the same political and professnial values as their mentors. "You had a gang of people who worked together during World War II and never got
over it," said one Agency official. "They were genuinely motivated and highly susceptible to
intrigue and being on the inside. Then in the Fifties and Sixties there was a national
consensus about a national threat. The Vietnam War tore everything to pieces -- shredded the
consensus and threw it in the air." Another Agency official observed: "Many journalists didn't
give a second thought to associating with the Agency. But there was a point when the ethical
issues which most people had submerged finally surfaced. Today, a lot of these guys
vehemently deny that they had any relationship with the Agency."
From the outset, the use of journalists was among the CIA's most sensitive undertakings,
with full knowledge restricted to the Director of Central Intelligence and a few of his chosen
deputies. Dulles and his successors were fearful of what would happen if a journalist-
operative's cover was blown, or if details of the Agency's dealings with the press otherwise
became public. As a result, contacts with the heads of news organizations were normally
initiated by Dulles and succeeding Directors of Central Intelligence; by the deputy directors
and division chiefs in charge of covert operations -- Frank Wisner, Cord Meyer Jr., Richard
Bissell, Desmond FitzGerald, Tracy Barnes, Thomas Karamessines and Richard Helms
himself a former UPI correspondent); and, occasionally, by others in the CIA hierarchy
known to have an unusually close social relationship with a particular publisher or broadcast
executive. [1]
James Angleton, who was recently removed as the Agency's head of counterintelligence
operations, ran a completely independent group of journalist-operatives who performed
sensitive and frequently dangerous assignments; little is known about this group for the
simple reason that Angleton deliberately kept only the vaguest of files.
The CIA even ran a formal training program in the 1950s to teach its agents to be journalists.
Intelligence officers were "taught to make noises like reporters," explained a high CIA
official, and were then placed in major news organizations with help from management.
"These were the guys who went through the ranks and were told 'You're going to he a
journalist,'" the CIA official said. Relatively few of the 400-some relationships described in
Agency files followed that pattern, however; most involved persons who were already bona
fide journalists when they began undertaking tasks for the Agency.
The Agency's relationships with journalists, as described in CIA files, include the following
general categories:
* Legitimate, accredited staff members of news organizations -- usually reporters. Some were
paid; some worked for the Agency on a purely voluntary basis. This group includes many of
the best-known journalists who carried out tasks for the CIA. The files show that the salaries
paid to reporters by newspaper and broadcast networks were sometimes supplemented by
nominal payments from the CIA, either in the form of retainers, travel expenses or outlays
for specific services performed. Almost all the payments were made in cash. The accredited
category also includes photographers, administrative personnel of foreign news bureaus and
members of broadcast technical crews.)
Two of the Agency's most valuable personal relationships in the 1960s, according to CIA
officials, were with reporters who covered Latin America -- Jerry O'Leary of the Washington
Star and Hal Hendrix of the Miami News, a Pulitzer Prize winner who became a high official
of the International Telephone and Telegraph Corporation. Hendrix was extremely helpful to
the Agency in providing information about individuals in Miami's Cuban exile community.
O'Leary was considered a valued asset in Haiti and the Dominican Republic. Agency files
contain lengthy reports of both men's activities on behalf of the CIA.
O'Leary maintains that his dealings were limited to the normal give-and-take that goes on
between reporters abroad and their sources. CIA officials dispute the contention: "There's no
question Jerry reported for us," said one. "Jerry did assessing and spotting [of prospective
agents] but he was better as a reporter for us." Referring to O'Leary's denials, the official
added: "I don't know what in the world he's worried about unless he's wearing that mantle of
integrity the Senate put on you journalists."
O'Leary attributes the difference of opinion to semantics. "I might call them up and say
something like, 'Papa Doc has the clap, did you know that?' and they'd put it in the file. I
don't consider that reporting for them.... it's useful to be friendly to them and, generally, I felt
friendly to them. But I think they were more helpful to me than I was to them." O'Leary took
particular exception to being described in the same context as Hendrix. "Hal was really doing
work for them," said O'Leary. "I'm still with the Star. He ended up at ITT." Hendrix could not
be reached for comment. According to Agency officials, neither Hendrix nor O'Leary was
paid by the CIA.
* Stringers [2] and freelancers. Most were payrolled by the Agency under standard
contractual terms. Their journalistic credentials were often supplied by cooperating news
organizations. some filed news stories; others reported only for the CIA. On some occasions,
news organizations were not informed by the CIA that their stringers were also working for
the Agency.
* Employees of so-called CIA "proprietaries." During the past twenty-five years, the Agency
has secretly bankrolled numerous foreign press services, periodicals and newspapers -- both
English and foreign language -- which provided excellent cover for CIA operatives. One such
publication was the Rome Daily American, forty percent of which was owned by the CIA
until the 1970s. The Daily American went out of business this year.
* Editors, publishers and broadcast network executives. The CIA's relationship with most
news executives differed fundamentally from those with working reporters and stringers,
who were much more subject to direction from the Agency. A few executives -- Arthur Hays
Sulzberger of the New York Times among them -- signed secrecy agreements. But such
formal understandings were rare: relationships between Agency officials and media
executives were usually social -- "The P and Q Street axis in Georgetown," said one source.
"You don't tell Wilharn Paley to sign a piece of paper saying he won't fink."
* Columnists and commentators. There are perhaps a dozen well known columnists and
broadcast commentators whose relationships with the CIA go far beyond those normally
maintained between reporters and their sources. They are referred to at the Agency as
"known assets" and can be counted on to perform a variety of undercover tasks; they are
considered receptive to the Agency's point of view on various subjects. Three of the most
widely read columnists who maintained such ties with the Agency are C.L. Sulzberger of the
New York Times, Joseph Alsop, and the late Stewart Alsop, whose column appeared in the
New York Herald-Tribune, the Saturday Evening Post and Newsweek. CIA files contain
reports of specific tasks all three undertook. Sulzberger is still regarded as an active asset by
the Agency. According to a senior CIA official, "Young Cy Sulzberger had some uses.... He
signed a secrecy agreement because we gave him classified information.... There was sharing,
give and take. We'd say, 'Wed like to know this; if we tell you this will it help you get access
to so-and-so?' Because of his access in Europe he had an Open Sesame. We'd ask him to just
report: 'What did so-and-so say, what did he look like, is he healthy?' He was very eager, he
loved to cooperate." On one occasion, according to several CIA officials, Sulzberger was
given a briefing paper by the Agency which ran almost verbatim under the columnist's byline
in the Times. "Cycame out and said, 'I'm thinking of doing a piece, can you give me some
background?'" a CIA officer said. "We gave it to Cy as a background piece a…