r/TIdaL • • Jul 07 '26

News Tidal is NOT secure and IS leaking payment information!

8 Upvotes

If you have active card info here, CHANGE IT OUT / PAUSE IT.

I use virtual cards through privacy so that it is impossible for situations exactly like this to happen. I have not touched this in over a year, and now someone is attempting to make purchases at staples using the card information provided to tidal. I use merchant locked cards, which means I have a card per every individual site, which means this card I have only ever personally used on tidal.


r/TIdaL • • May 18 '26

Discussion New UI sucks

Post image
0 Upvotes

For a couple of reasons (for me):

Switching "Playing from" to the artist's profile is just stupid. It was an easy way to your playlist. If i want to see the artist, I could just click on the artist button below the song name, now you have 2 things leading to the same place plus if the artist is "underground" and doesn't have a picture on their profile, It will just place the first letter of the name and it looks ugly af.

Also, I liked color coded metadata info (orange for MQA, teal for the other qualities). Now it looks all the same and gets lost in the background.

Font is ugly.

Perhaps I'm being too nitpicky but I really hated this update.


r/TIdaL • • Aug 22 '23

News Just received an email from tidal saying that they're not accepting anymore cards outside Argentina... Goodbye Tidal, you'll lose a lot of customers due to your carelessness 😀

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TIdaL • • May 13 '24

Question Compressed audio quality via Bluetooth?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hello fellow audiophiles, just wondering if playing through aux cable has better audio quality compared to bluetooth as an output on Tidal. I am getting this message and wanted to know. Appreciate it !


r/TIdaL • • Feb 11 '26

Discussion Does Tidal expect to gain customers by charging to transfer playlists?

0 Upvotes

I'm trying services other than Spotify, and Tidal expects people to pay transfer playlists over 500?

Seems pretty idiotic to make it difficult to try when you have some of the smallest market share out of your competition.

Edit: Switcheroo is a free app that seems to work decently enough for free at least to test the app.


r/TIdaL • • Dec 30 '25

Discussion Why I left Tidal for Spotify Lossless, and what Tidal really needs to do to not become garbage...

0 Upvotes

I've been using Tidal for almost 10 years now - I first subscribed around 2015, and I never stopped my subscription - except at some point I tried out spotify (way before it became lossless). Before tidal I had Deezer for a few years also. So I'm no Tidal hater - in fact, I'm quite a big fan. During all those years I've used Tidal to the max, both on hifi headphones, and on my home hi-fi system. Heck, I even got MQA compatible DAC/Streamers to benefit it (even though we all know MQA was basically a quasi-scam).

But unfortunately I can't take the chaos that Tidal became, the usefull features it had and got rid of, so for the last 2 months, I've switched to Spotify Lossless and never looked back.

Let me break down the 4 issues plaguing Tidal right now, from worst to the least offensive - in my humble opinion - and each of these points really need to be addressed by Tidal if it could stand a chance and not go bankrupt:

1) The chaos of Artist profiles:

For over 2 years I've been aware of this issue, yet it has only became worse in the last few months. Basically, with the exception of very well known international artists - there's a ton of Artists who have either fake (AI) music, or music from other artists with a similar or identical name on their page. It seems no one is checking this and it has become a clusterf***.

The issue is more and more exacerbated if you listen to not-so commercial music - like techno artist, where it's a mess (Ten Walls has 2 different profiles, with albums and EPs split between the 2, and this is extremely common with other artists as well), or local music (Hebrew/Arabic at the very least have some of their music on their english-written Profile, some on the Hebrew/Arabic alphabet written profile - and sometimes there's even more versions with typos, you basically sometimes have 2-3-4 different spelled Profiles, with typos, of the same artist - and each has a few EPs or Albums).

Or sometimes you have a lesser known know artist, and when you go on their page, there's a ton of music from artists with a similar name that have no connection (like Art Department for example). And sometimes it's the worst of the worst - literally AI music albums with a real artist name. It's not even the same style or voice :)).

I think you get the idea - it's a total mess, total chaos. It need serious work - but for years it's the same, no one cares.

Spotify - I literally never had an issue here. Not only have I not yet found AI music on an artist (no matter how famous or obscure) I listen to, but almost all artists have BIOs and a lot of interesting info on their page for fans. On tidal, many lesser known artists have 0 info.

2) The lackluster suggestion algorithm:

In general, the suggestions aren't a catastrophe. For more well known genres, they work fine. But again, if you're listening to some local music (non English) or more specific electronic types, like techno or house genres - it's all over the place.

Not only that, it suggests completely irrelevant albums for you to listen to. You'll get a total of 10-20 albums suggestions per day, and only 5 are relevant. In my case, the rest are generally hip-hop for some reason. And I don't listen to hip hop, and don't have that kind of music liked anywhere - albums, liked songs, radios, playlists. Nothing.

And for some lesser known artists, the algorithm doesn't work at all - you can't even have the option to start a radio based on their genre.

Here it can't compete even in the slightest with Spotify. Spotify will suggest to you similar music even if you listen to the most obscure genres from the most obscure places - and every obscure artist and genre I tried, has a radio option - which works excellently.

3) User Playlists:

Is there any point for me to expand this problem? It's a total chaos, you find some playlists from some genres from SOME users. Nowhere close to Spotify. You can't even usefully find certain genres. Try searching for "progressive techno" or "minimal" or "acoustic levantine music" or "deep house". Tidal will bring you up anything between nothing relevant whatsoever to total mess.

Spotify gives you exactly what you are searching for. Much better tool at finding new artists.

4) The "Shuffle" situation:

I don't really think I need to explain to much here either. Go to a playlist of at least 50 songs -yours or someone else's. Play it in shuffle mode. 90% of the time you'll get the same songs in the same order. You need to rearange them, sort them by different labels like artists or song duration, to get tidal to play a different order.

Spotify fixed this a while back with a simple option of "less repeats for shuffle". You can enjoy your long playlists and listen to different songs every day.

For the life of me I don't understand how come tidal, after 10 years, hasn't figured this out.

5) The sound quality situation:

You might be surprised about me mentioning this - but it's no longer even nearly as clear cut as before. First off, Spotify offers the lossless tier - which generally is 16 bit 44.1 khz quality - CD quality. This is also the bitrate that most of Tidal's catalogue is at - some are from 24 bit 48khz and higher.

On paper, Tidal is higher quality - but in reality - I challenge anyone to tell a difference between 16 bit 44.1khz and anything higher- CONSIDERING THE SAME MASTER - this is key! I have very good hearing, and I'm using high end Focal open-back headphones with a high end Fiio DAC at my desktop, and a 10k EUR stero hifi system in the living room. Yes, below "lossless" it sounds worse, but from 16 bit 44.1 and above, no difference.

Moreover, I was surprised to find out that Spotify actually has better master versions for some albums. Take Steely Dan's albums. On Spotify you actually get the quieter, non remastered non dynamically compressed versions, vs on Tidal where it's the brickwalled versions. Don't believe me? Listen to the albums yourself. Spotify sounds quieter, more easy on the ear and with more dynamic depth.

It's a shame what happened to tidal. Yes, it still has a much better UI vs the almost horrible Spotify UI - and yes, I don't care about Spotify pushing podcasts in my suggestions. But these minuses are much smaller than the issues Tidal has right now. A shame...

And don't get me started with that "fair pay" discussion. As it stands right now, Spotify has (and yes you can check the numbers) around 100 times more active monthly users. That would translate, roughly, to 100 times more streams, on average, for artists, on Spotify vs Tidal. Tidal pays artist 10x more per stream than Spotify. This is easy math but you can already tell - netto, at the end of a month, an artists makes 10x more money off of their streams from Spotify vs Tidal.

Of course when you are a platform 100x smaller, you can market yourself by paying even 10x more than the market leader. But if you think Tidal would still pay as much if they were anywhere near Spotify's market share - then simply - of course not!


r/TIdaL • • May 07 '21

Discussion My response to the Golden Sound MQA Test

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/TIdaL • • Aug 26 '24

Discussion Are you serious?!

0 Upvotes

“Past 24. July we will ditch MQA” seems like they did not. Did they just switchto Halfly unfolded or non unfolded MQA? I sincerely hope it’s just the DACs fucked up firmware (FiiO KA17). If it’s not, can they be sued for it? Can anyone test this out with their own DAC? BTW the phone using tidal is an IPhone 15 Pro Max (IOS has dynamic sample rate switching so it would be best if you would test it using an iPhone with relatively recent iOS)


r/TIdaL • • Jan 22 '25

Discussion STAGGERING amount of MQA STILL ON TIDAL!

3 Upvotes

This is a screen record I took of me cycling through recommend artist radios and one of my mixes. As you can see, a majority of the tracks are in MQA and nearly ALL of the tracks I was complaining about being in MQA last year and the year before still are in MQA. This tells me that Tidal has made very little to no progress on this matter and wanted to rely on the removal of the labels to deceive us into believing that they removed all of it. THIS IS NOT OKAY! If we as consumers just bend over and take it and not flood their support channels with our concerns about this issue nothing will be done about it. If you are saying that your service offers millions of tracks in Lossless and HiRes FLAC you need to provide that. In my state this would be considered deceptive advertising which is a misdemeanor.

Below is another track I found since the screen recording that is still MQA from the last time I complained about it 👇🏾

https://imgur.com/a/2EEUCi6


r/TIdaL • • Dec 11 '25

App / Site My review of tidal after 2 months inside

0 Upvotes

At first while i registered(paid) it was my first loseless streaming service and everything was new so u have to give one week to get use to the app and there are not enough songs that u have listened to so the app's ai dosent know u.

but after 1 month when i listened to enough songs and used the recommended songs based on my listening experience playlist its great to listen to music .

my recommendation is just play songs that u like in the beginning by search field and then look for the app's ai rexcommendation at the first page whrn the app opens.

apart from this the playlist functionality is good for me.the sound quality is superior.before registering i compared tidal with apple music and deezer and tidal was the best out of the three.

i think they improved the sound quality while using ldac bluetooth codec (ldac is near loseless bluetooth codec) and the music sounds amazing on my 1more sonnoflow and qcy h3 pro headphones.

So go for tidal and happy listening all.


r/TIdaL • • May 22 '24

Question Can't tell the difference in sound quality between Tidal vs Spotify

3 Upvotes

I've been sitting here listening to various songs and genres across both services, making sure I was only checking out songs that were available in max sound quality on tidal.

I really can't tell a difference. Is it because the gear I'm using is not high end enough, or is this common? I'm just using a HD560s with no dac/amp, I have equalized it though.

Just me?


r/TIdaL • • Jul 27 '24

Question Why did Tidal get rid of MQA?

0 Upvotes

r/TIdaL • • Sep 27 '24

Supporting Artists anyone else in the club?

Post image
0 Upvotes

who else here is followed by the best platform?


r/TIdaL • • Feb 24 '24

App / Site Is it just me or?

1 Upvotes

Is the Tidal app a complete price of shit? I moved over from Spotify 6 months ago as I wanted to use my usb DJ controller with a streaming service. All good for that, but as a phone app for listening to music on the way to work.. WTF is wrong with tidal? Why is the iPhone app so unreliable and generally just shit?


r/TIdaL • • May 19 '26

Discussion Tidal new UI is sh*t

0 Upvotes

Hey, this isn’t so much a request for support as it is user feedback—a sentiment widely shared among my friends and family these days.

I’m extremely disappointed with Tidal’s new design. As a loyal user for years, I was initially pleased a few months ago to see Tidal transform into a more modern and streamlined interface while retaining its visual identity.

However, for about a month now—first on PC, then on mobile—the platform has completely adopted Spotify’s graphical elements and interactions: the “+” to add a track to favorites, which turns into a “✓” once added (just like on Spotify); a “lyrics” button; the display of lyrics, the various other buttons and their layout, the presentation of the current track, and even the shape of the graphic elements…

This “Spotify-ization” is very disappointing.

The most disappointing aspect is the prominence given to the audio format on the playback page. Whereas it previously occupied a central position in the graphic layout—with a color associated with each codec and a dedicated box—it is now relegated to the background: below the timeline bar, transparent, and “colorless.”

This is all the more problematic given that this indication of the audio format is at the heart of Tidal’s messaging, as the service aims to offer the best streaming audio format among its competitors. It makes no sense to relegate such an element when it is the main marketing selling point.

Finally, regarding the bug, this codec indicator disappears when you switch to another app (without closing Tidal), but reappears when you return to Tidal.

In short, while some are celebrating a “good alternative” to Spotify, I see this as a specific criticism from those who were loyal to the platform for what it offered; the semi-professional and high-quality aspect is being sacrificed in favor of mass-market marketing.


r/TIdaL • • Dec 21 '25

Discussion Dedicated Tidal fan considering jumping ship

0 Upvotes

I have been subscribed to Tidal since about 2018, and always recommend it to friends. I have a family plan at the moment.
But I have always had a somewhat clunky experience using the Android app and windows desktop app. My partner reports annoyances on iPhone too.

On Android, the first time I start playing a track for each day, it takes about 20-40 seconds to begin playback, with the spinning circle (I assume DRM/account checking), same on mobile data or wifi, same whether tracks are downloaded or not. It's only for the first track at the start of the day's listening so I just got used to it.
But now I'm trying out Qobuz, and the user interface is really slick and fast in comparison.

I pay good money for the Tidal software, and it's really below average. Am I expecting too much?

I've had issues in the past with Tidal downloaded track playback, offline listening during flights not working, and general interface clunkiness.
So even though I like paying artists more, and I like HiFi/High Res audio, I don't have any reason to stick with Tidal if Qobuz is better, which it seems to be.
Qobuz also pays artists slightly more than Tidal.

Tidal has a bigger catalogue, and a couple of my favourite albums aren't on Qobuz. But I can buy those on Bandcamp, which I already use also.
Tidal doesn't show any signs of improving, a while ago they laid off a lot of staff, so I don't think we can expect it to get a lot better very soon.

Trying Qobuz has made me realize how much better an experience I could be having.

Gripe over.


r/TIdaL • • Sep 25 '23

News Tidal automatically cancelled the Argentina subscription, so bye bye Tidal

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TIdaL • • Oct 09 '24

Discussion bye

0 Upvotes

Finally gave up n going to apple music. Songs need to be constantly replaced when they go missing, eats data and storage. Overall just a messy experience


r/TIdaL • • Apr 23 '26

Discussion Tidal is trash

0 Upvotes

The superior audio quality was the only thing this service had going on, and even that isn’t enough anymore.

UX is a nightmare. Search is worse than Spotify was a decade ago. Artists with the same name get merged into one chaotic page. Reordering tracks is painful, sorting options are inconsistent across platforms, and one specific bug throws “failed to connect to server” errors when you sort by date added. There’s still no swipe-to-add-to-queue after years of requests, and imported playlists routinely break offline downloads.

Offline downloads barely work. Tracks get stuck midqueue, “downloaded” songs demand internet to play, and support’s fix is “reinstall the app,” which wipes everything.

Apple Music has lossless and Atmos at the same price with an app that actually works. Qobuz is better for audiophiles. Deezer still has working stems. Spotify finally has lossless. There’s no reason left to stay unless you enjoy troubleshooting your music app every week.

Anyone else done?


r/TIdaL • • Aug 05 '25

Discussion Trying to like Tidal but will likely go back.

1 Upvotes

As a recent convert from Spotify to Tidal, I wanted to share my first impressions. Perhaps in reading it, those that have been using Tidal for a while may have a response and possibly some solutions to some of my critiques.

I decided to do a trial switch from Spotify to Tidal. Although I enjoy Spotify, the idea of them taking the lion's share of the profits for themselves and giving artists a pittance has never sat well with me. (For those wondering, I don't really care about all the political stuff.) In the past, I hadn't considered Tidal because, price wise, they weren't even remotely competitive. From my perspective, the service was made strictly for audiophiles who have no problem paying significantly more. As someone on a budget and frugal, this was not for me. Fast forward to now... My son inquired as to why I haven't switched and informed me that Tidal's price model has changed and are now positioned to compete with Spotify. I was intrigued and, after a little investigating, took the plunge and subscribed.

That being said, I'm seriously reconsidering my decision and, despite my desire to go with a company that will treat artists with more respect financially, will likely go back to Spotify. Bottom line, the reasons are connectivity problems I'm having with the Tidal app, its UI (both desktop and phone) and its incompatibility with Amazon (i.e., Alexa) devices.

First off, connectivity over cellular is aggravatingly terrible! No matter which level of quality I choose (I started from Max then went down to Low/320), the app will play about 5-10 songs from my Tracks list then just crash. It's always having connection problems. And I'm driving on a freeway that is lined with cell towers and can easily get a strong 5G signal. Additionally, the interface with my car won't list Tracks as my last played list, so I have to navigate to Tracks in order to start playing again. Another annoying interface disconnect between phone and car (Hyundai Tucson using Android) is that the shuffle option only becomes available when you play the first track. You can't just press "shuffle" to start random playing. This is not only an annoyance but also a safety hazard. I usually end up driving in silence after about 10 minutes of music rather than mess around with the dash screen and risk causing an accident. Sorry, but I've never experienced this using Spotify.

Moving to the UI, I find it buggy, and outdated. To start, the desktop version takes forever to cache all your tracks. I have about 5500 songs in my list of Tracks. If I want to scroll down the list, I have to wait for it to populate before continuing every single time I start the app. Getting to a band that starts with "V" is a 5 to 10 minute ordeal. At first, I thought there was a limitation because I initially couldn't scroll past the letter "B". When it finally started populating, I figured it was a one time deal. I was disappointed see that I had to go through the same delays the next day. For what it's worth, the phone app doesn't seem to experience this issue. Another annoyance, at least for me, are the incredibly outdated artist profiles. Some of the artist's profiles show information that doesn't go past 2016! I'm not sure if it's the artist or the Tidal staff that keep this updated, but yikes! To its credit, it does seem that the Tidal algorithm provides selections from new artists that align closer to the artists I'm listening to.

Finally, moving to compatibility, there is a lot to be desired. I had already mentioned the interface translation between phone and car app, but there is also the issue with Amazon's Alexa devices. (Again, if you don't like Amazon, for whatever reason, I don't really care.) No matter how I try to connect, Tidal and Alexa refuse to recognize each other. I've enabled, disabled, and reenabled the Tidal skill multiple times. I've tried Bluetooth. Nothing works. I don't know if this is a problem on the side of Tidal or Amazon, but it is incredibly frustrating.

So, there you have it. I really want to jump to Tidal. I really want to use a service that provides better quality streams and better supports the artists that actually do the work to create art. Unfortunately, there are just too many pain points for me to make the leap at this time. I hope these things improve because, as soon as they do, I will be happy to jump ship.


r/TIdaL • • Dec 05 '25

Discussion Is Tidal Rewind hiding a song with 'Trans' in the title?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

The song appears as number 10 in my automatically generated 2025 playlist but for some reason the rewind image has song 11 pushed up in it's place. Bonus pic because I'm apparently 5th biggest fan.


r/TIdaL • • Jan 26 '25

Discussion Why have a "deluxe" version if the extra tracks are missing?

Post image
0 Upvotes

What's even the point?


r/TIdaL • • Feb 22 '26

Tech Issue Not Playing Blonde

1 Upvotes

It’s 2:23AM. I’m drunk. All I want is to hear the best album of my generation. I pay for this service. I want to listen to my favorite album while I wait for my Taco Bell and then go to bed. I go to hit play on Nikes. “Something went wrong. Please try again later. (11:-42800).” NO. I PAY FOR THIS SERVICE. I WANT BLONDE. WHY DO I PAY FOR THE FREAKING SERVICE IF I CANT ENJOY THE ART I WANT. ART SHOULDNT BE BEHIND PAYWALLS ANYWAY. I hate the world we live in so much. Now I have to listen on YouTube and be sold things when I’m drunk. Tidal sucks. But I will not fund Spotify. Still worse than this situation.


r/TIdaL • • Jan 12 '25

App / Site I signed up for Tidal today - here's my review

5 Upvotes

Audio: 5/5

App/Streamer features: 4/5

App ease of use: 3.5/5

Price: 3/5

Customer Service: 1/5

Try before you buy : 0/5

Overall: 3.5

TLDR: You should get it because it is a worthwhile product but have the patience of a saint because the customer service and sales departments f*cking suck. Just ask Chat GPT to help you set up and find out potential issues because the robot and the staff are useless and will not listen to you, let alone help you. It is a good product though with really good audio so don't let that stop you (genuinely). You'll have to sign up for the free trial AND download the app AND get use to the interface AND search for a track that might be a max track AND check that it's actually a max track and not the regular res track in order to: find out if the audio quality will be enough to make membership worth considering. (That's honestly my biggest gripe - the audio is fantastic though).

------------

I was able to test my experience against: Youtube music, Spotify, Amazon Music. My experience was mostly with the desktop app or in browser.

Audio: 5/5
The reason you're signing up for this product is because of the superior audio, which it does have, most of the time. The main problem is that it's a mission to find the tracks that are "Master Quality". Simply put, there are two kinds of tracks (I've seen anyway), "Regular" which can be streamed in low of high res quality depending on things like your connection, your drivers etc. and Max Quality Audio, which are the same song but treated as seperate tracks - Tidal has a mini game where you don't know which of your favourite songs have "Master" copies of those songs and Tidal doesn't tell you if those songs have master versions either, the only way you can tell if something is a master version is if you're playing the song and it plays in Master quality. Oh yeah! And you can't search for Master Quality versions of Audio either and songs that are in Master Quality don't have anything to indicate over them that they are the Master versions... The quality of the master audio is great though... if you can find it and it exists in the first place that is.

App/Streamer features: 4/5
It's very intuitive and an easy transition if you're coming over from somewhere like Spotify. The listing of more songs (in order of popularity for an artist) was good and way more than you get with Spotify - I did like this. The layout is clean and doesn't feel cluttered - actually I think it's a lot more aesthetic than Spotify's design. You can't see how many people have listened to each stream (like on Spotify) which is a shame, it's not an essential but having the option to see this or not could be nice. Being able to customise what's seen in the playlist would be a nice feature (I've already added the song to the playlist I want it in, why do I want to add it to others? I could just use the ellipses... to add songs no?). Like I said before, would be nice if there was a more intuitive way of searching for Master Quality Audio, would be even better if songs added would alert (or outright replace) to songs if Master copies were available since this really is the main selling point of the Tidal product/experience.

App ease of use: 3.5/5
It's intuitive enough and not the worst in the world. Once you get use to it, it's not so bad - with that said though it's a mini learning curve without any guide and I had to use Chat GPT to take me through the process of setting up and troubleshooting various issues (like how "normalise volume" is set to default, not something you'll want if you listen to everything on max blast). Apart from that though, it's okay - it could do with a few extra feature just to really smooth it out but you're not going to have too much trouble.

Price: 3/5
Meh. You get what you pay for. No more, no less really. Having a lot more smoothed out features and a smoother signing up process (where you know what you're buying before you pay for it...) would in my mind make it a lot more value for money and an easier sale imo.

Customer Service: 1/5
The bot sucks, it doesn't let you list line breaks and the customer service/sales rep does not give two shits about being there and will not answer your question - just tells you to sign up for free trial even if that had nothing to do with your question. Wasn't the lacky's fault, the problem was the way the system seemed to set it up - live chat would have been a lot more appreciated here - further, a lot of the problems could have been easily avoided and solved had better policies been put in place (like allowing the sampling of audio without having to sign up and "just know instrinsically that OF COURSE Firefox doesn't integrate well with Tidals browser player... everyone f*cking knows that don't they?"...

Signing up process / Try before you buy: 0/5
Fire your directors of sales & marketing right now, not even kidding Jack... the only thing that's selling this product is the product. I spent two hours trying to find out how I could listen to an audio sample so I could compare it to the other platforms. Turns out it was my fault because the listening area isn't obvious on the front page (if it even is), and I should have "just known" that ofc the max audio isn't available on firefox... well soooorry... sheesh. It's a very basic concept. I want to know what it is that I'm buying.... before I f*cking buy it! Is that so hard to understand???
I don't want to sign up and give you my details and all that, I just want a small audio sample so I can compare it to other services. Instead you have to sign up or download this and that, and there's no instructions teling you how to get a hold of the audio and there's no link to the music previewing page and it only streams in low quality unless you've signed up for the free trial - which... what????? I want to hear the audio quality.... you already have a preview thing available... let's hear that master quality preview then... nope, okay, I have to sign up to the "free trial" in order to preview the 30 seconds of music in audio quality other than low??? Really??? I'll just delete this account then.
Actually, that's what I did. No word of a lie, I signed up for the "2 months for £2 deal" and was so frustrated trying to get any of it to work I deleted the whole account and cancelled the subscription because I was just so pissed off with it. I had to go to youtube music to listen to ocean music to calm the f*ck down from having a f*cking migraine. Actually - I decided I'd just stick with YT music and be content with saving the money, the music wasn't as high quality though and I could tell so I started looking elsewhere and it was chat gpt that kept reiterating that Tidal had the best bitrates - so then and only after I calmed the f*ck down did I decide to give it one more try and signed up (paying the full price this time and losing out on those two months I got earlier) to try and work my way into finding this mythical "Max audio", which I only managed to get working after chat gpt slow talked the process and problems to me and explained why the max audio wasn't showing (It doesn't work on Firefox and most of the songs on Tidal aren't actually Max).
Fire your directors of Sales and Marketing. Hire me instead - I have no experience and little employment history, I'll do better than both of those f*ckfaces by doing absolutely nothing.

Biggest take away: You are signing up for this product because of the superior audio quality. The product overall is not bad at all and the closest you'll get to something like Spotify (if that's where you're coming from) so the transition isn't intrinsically hard in and of itself...
One thing I learned from testing audio across these platforms was that each of them had something that made them stand out as to why you should go with them and here is the basics:
Youtube Music: Premium is like £1/1$ extra so might as well get that for no ads on youtube, you're honestly getting premium for the usual yt and paying £1/$1 extra for low quality music.
Amazon Music: The music quality is decent (better than spotify) and its cheaper as well (if you consider prime benefits), but the main feature or selling point is that its decent price when done through Prime and it's got the second best audio (of the ones I tested).
Spotify: Convenience, Joe Rogan? (Gtfo xD)
Tidal: Music quality.

Overall: 3.5/5. It has a lot going for it but it's a little rough around some edges. When you can find max quality audio, it's great - it's really good but that process is a chore to put it mildly and you won't know the experience until you jump through some hoops or have chat gpt explain how to listen to the mythical max quality audio like you're five.

If you absolutely must have the best quality audio, then yes, absolutely get Tidal, it beats the competition by a long shot - if you're looking for a balance between convenience and good audio then Amazon is what you want. If you want a decent deal, don't care about quality of music but like the idea of no ads on youtube - then yeah (figure it out).

Personally, for the moment, I'd probably only reccomend Tidal to those who are diehard music lovers like myself - with the caveat and warning that setting up and dealing with the company can be somewhat of a nightmare. But if they really want the best of the best audio with the most ethical treatment of its artists then Tidal is the way to go (Tidal pays the most to its artists which is pretty f*cking cool tbh). If you want artists to be given pittance whilst giving Joe Rogan 100million USD for exclusive rights to his shitty podcast, then by all means, go with Spotify's inferior audio.

Worth it?: Overall yes. Pissed me the off to start with but I'm happy with it.

---

I wrote a list of suggestions to make the application and service better:

  • Search by lyrics.

  • Search by abbreviation (e.g.: RATM, RHCP etc.).

  • Search by Humming (like google has) would be really f*cking cool.

  • Highlighting Master Quality Audios during searching / Allowing for the search of Audio by master quality and Genre.

  • Intergrating Master Quality Audios in with the low+high red audio streams so the high quality one can be selected as default (and lower qualities when needed for other purposes selected by user like data limits etc.).

  • Allow playlists to be reorganised according to user preferences.

  • Allowing tracks to be dragged from search dropdown onto the playlists.

  • Being able to drag other songs from about the page into playlists (even if search dropdown is open).

  • Drag songs from "Reccomended songs area" to the playlist.

  • Equalizer in Settings would be nice - perhaps it could be dynamic based on music being listened to?

  • Not automatically defaulting onto "normalised volume" - that was actually annoying I found.

  • Comments by users under each song to make it a social platform and talk to other folks into the same kind of music.

  • Forums for artists and genres maybe? Reddit whatever.

  • Editable Playlist Image.

  • Sack the Entire Sales and Marketing Team, or in the very least sack the heads of those departments - they are not doing you any favours.

  • Provide the ability for potential customers to listen to sample audio from the front page of the website for free and WITHOUT having to sign up or download anything. Serious, this is basic marketing guys - wake the f*ck up. You've heard of capitalism right? Let them listen to previews of the master audio....

  • Have a popup come up on certain browsers like FIREFOX that says that max quality audio is not available - especially if the user is trying to listen to/sample the max quality audio on such a browser and its not playing... just let us f*cking know guys and we'll change browsers or something.

  • The bot your speak to should let you make line breaks without trying to answer right away.

  • Tickets are frustrating and the staff suck, just have the potential customer speak to a human right away in a live chat, more expensive but you'll get more sales and the lacky who doesn't want to answer tickets will be forced to listen to potential clients - do the math $$$ 🤌.

  • Allow users to connect and create parties on Discord.

  • Give me the 2 months I lost from being salty lol (I know... it's my own fault :( )

  • Ban Joe Rogan