r/TCK • u/[deleted] • Aug 19 '24
Third culture doesn’t mean more than three cultures
Whoever thinks that must be an a grade moron
r/TCK • u/[deleted] • Aug 19 '24
Whoever thinks that must be an a grade moron
r/TCK • u/JulioCesarSalad • Sep 01 '20
Being a third culture kid is nothing more than growing up in an immigrant family.
It’s not a unique burden, it’s a normal thing that millions of people go through every year. Immigrant families move from one country to another.
Change my view
r/TCK • u/Choice_Level9756 • Jan 01 '25
I was born and raised in London to Nigeria Parents (age 2-4/2-5) till age 13.
I then spent the remaining of my formative years in Nigeria from age 13-21.
I came back to London at age 21, I’ve been living here for the past 7 years .
r/TCK • u/Active-Neat-5511 • Dec 12 '20
I am an American TCK who left the USA very young when I was 9 years old in 1983. First I lived in Senegal in West Africa. Then Dad moved us to Singapore for a year from 1984-1986. Then from 1986-1992 I lived in Dubai. I spent a short period of time as an assistant clerk in the USIA of the US Embassy. Then, one day, I was back in my Northern Indiana city & here is my problem-
When I returned to the USA for college I was around locals. Many of them were hicks. They were mostly the children or grandchildren of Polish immigrants who had settled in the Gary, Indiana who had settled in the area & were the first generation to attend college.
A few of them were real hicks. One roommate I had-randomly assigned to me-was a man of 31 years old who was a "mature student" who himself came from a modest working class background. We didn't get along. I treated him like a complete idiot. He was, in some ways, a rube. But after only 3 weeks...he moved out of the apartment.
I did not have such a problem with upper middle class kids. Many of them had parents who sent them overseas for summers. And I did not have such a problem with the few Jewish kids, some of whom had spent time in Israel & were third culture kids as well.
My problem was purely with working class to lower middle class townies. A few of them really disliked me immediately, sensing that in some way or another I was "privileged". Actually, I would say that my father was not terribly wealthy-we would have been considered on the lower side of upper middle class. But for some reason they found me elitist.
On one occasion, a student subleased an apartment from me in college who was a small town hick. His name was Larry. We had a dispute about a huge utility bill & he said he would sue me (It actually was not my fault but that is another story) & I replied "I don't care, I can transfer from this school & move from this state or country in a minute. Makes no difference to me." And Larry said "Move from this state...I don't think so" & I replied "Of course I can you dumb hick. I'm not some townie who never left Indiana. I'll transfer to an American college in Switzerland & won't feel a thing"...Larry was silent with bewilderment. This was beyond his experience. I vented all of my feelings about townies on Larry. "You are a townie hick hillbilly who never even left the state to go to Disneyland...None of this matters to me...I don't care about this college...I don't care about Indiana...Tomorrow I can be gone..." Larry listened dumbfounded. He was genuinely not angry. He was just silent the way children learning something new & awe-inspiring are silent. Larry never sued me for the utility bill.
I remember after leaving the college, I returned one day to see my old college after returning to Dubai as an adult expat. I ran into a guy I knew. By then we were both 27. I had graduated & moved back to Dubai by then & was a full-fledged expat. He was still at that college. He said "they said you moved to Iraq" & I winced at the ignorance. I had to explain I had moved to Dubai. "Isn't it dangerous there" he asked. I winced again. Dubai was much safer, actually, than Gary Indiana. "Nah, it's cool there man" I replied, inwardly thinking "you are an absolute total moron townie!"
I also sneered at the whole "Hillbilly Elegy". A few of the townies I knew would feed me the sad story of their backgrounds. Mom was into drugs. They got a girl pregnant when they were 18 & had to work & could not attend college. They dropped out of high school etc...To me, these were personal choices. Nobody ran your life for you. Anybody could choose not to do hard drugs, not to get pregnant out-of-wedlock etc. They would blame the environment...but to a TCK, there is no environment. Environments change. Environments are irrelevant. There is only the individual.
As I grew up in Dubai, a few townies brought up the film Midnight Express. What a sad tale of an American kid going through hell in the Middle East. I sneered at this too. What kind of stupid townie goes to Turkey, buys a load of hashish on the street from someone who is certainly a cop/informer in a country where drugs are totally illegal & then tries to smuggle it on him back to his hick town? Why didn't this idiot in Midnight Express factor in the consequences?
As I got into my twenties, I had more & more bad experiences with townies, hicks, rubes from the white working class. When I lived in Arizona, my only friend was another TCK who was dating a Japanese foreign exchange student. One day when we were at the pool at our apartment complex, a local townie walked up & called us "fags". He had a violent reputation but for some reason I just replied "we'll be somewhere else next week or next month but you'll still be in here looking at the same scenery" & the townie just WILTED. I expected him to get violent, but instead he sort of withered like a dying plant & said weakly..."oh".
The sad thing is that I never earned any of these privileges. It was my father who served in the US military, used his GI Bill to obtain a Phd in geology, worked long hard hours for oil companies out in the field. Even as an adult expat, the only reason I worked overseas to begin with was because I had a best friend from the International School who got me a job.
There is no reason for me to be elitist. I did nothing to personally earn the privilege of growing up overseas or being an adult expat.
And yet my entire life I could not get along with townies & sneered at their ignorance & narrowmindedness. This more than anything else was why I became an adult expat. I had to live overseas where people who are poor, who became pregnant out-of-wedlock at the age of 18, who got into meth or heroin in public schools rougher than my own international schools, who had a scrape with the law & ended up on probation & could not leave the state, who were on their own at 17 could not move to.
So my question is, have other TCK's had this experience.
r/TCK • u/Active-Neat-5511 • Dec 14 '20
I am an adult male USA TCK who grew up primarily in Dubai from the ages of 12 in 1986 to 19 in 1992.
Was any other Western TCK who grew up in the Middle East or Muslim countries shocked at the pervasiveness of pornography in Western society or the sheer obsession that Western men & women have with pornography?
When I was growing up in Dubai, porn just wasn't around much. Occasionally, somebody's Dad had a playboy magazine. That was it. The internet later blocked pornography but when I was a kid in Dubai, few young people were really exposed to porn.
But when I got back to the USA & went to college, I was just amazed at the American obsession with pornography. Guys in my college dorms all had pornographic magazines or videos. Even some young women I met were really obsessed with pornographic films or the acts in them. Pornography was literally everywhere in the dorms.
I had a girlfriend in college & I remember going over to see a friend & his girlfriend & there was a really hardcore spread of pornographic magazines on their living room table. Having grown up in Dubai, I was sort of shocked that people would leave such material on display.
I kept my feelings to myself, but I was sort of grossed out by hardcore pornography. One girl on my hallway used to invited people over who would just sit & doing a running commentary while watching a porn film & smoking weed. To me, somehow, it was off-putting. I just never got used to it. It seemed horribly degrading.
As the internet came in, it seemed to me that the American obsession with pornography intensified.
Because I grew up in the Middle East in a Muslim country where pornography was relatively scarce I could not get used to this.
Nowadays, it seems as if the US culture is pornographic. All we hear about is Ron Jeremy, James Deen etc. Porn performers seem to have the respect of Nobel physicists & their lives are reported upon in Yahoo.
American frankly seems to love porn. Apparently, it is empowering to women. Many people, male & female, find it integral to their personal lives. They have to have porn.
Does any other TCK kid who grew up in the Middle East think this is weird or had trouble coming to terms with this?
r/TCK • u/[deleted] • Jun 12 '23
I believe the term Third Culture Kid is too limiting. Third Culture Individual (TCI for short) accurately describes the entirety of our communities and our various hybrid cultures. It better represents us, as many of us are no longer children.
A Third Culture Individual is someone who is either currently growing or who grew up in multiple countries and thus either is absorbing or has absorbed the cultures of multiple places. The reason I don't like TCK is that it makes me feel like the person is only referring to children who are currently growing up in multiple countries, rather than those who grew up in those conditions but is now an adult. It is a question of inclusion.
An addendum: I define an expat as someone who moves to a foreign country but does not expect to remain there, and an immigrant as someone who moves to a foreign country and plans on staying. A TCI can be an expat, or an immigrant, or they can be a "local" if they moved back to their passport country. The terms, in my opinion, do not have much overlap, so I am not arguing that adults who grew up in one culture but then moved around a lot somehow become TCIs.
r/TCK • u/nondualmonist • Aug 24 '26
From the time I was in school, my view of TCK is people who are growing up going to international (usually IB) schools with expat parents and have a different citizenship from the country they are living in, and then usually end up in a different country for college. Hence the "third" culture. And most people I associate with TCK have experience living in at least 3-4 countries, and end up with identity issues as a result, such as speaking English as a first language even though it is not their native language in some cases.
But on Reddit it seems TCK is just a stand-in term for children of immigrants in western countries who are usually in public schools. I don't want to sound like an elitist douche or anything but I really don't think that encapsulates the TCK experience and is much less international and syncretic than what I imagine when I use the term. Has there been a change in how this term is used, or is it just a Reddit thing, or both?
r/TCK • u/Active-Neat-5511 • Dec 12 '20
I am a USA TCK who was born in a modest Midwest city. From the age of 9, I was overseas. Dad was a geologist & realized he could make good money for oil companies so off we went. Then, aged 19, I returned to my birthplace after graduating from an International school & a stint at the US Embassy in the USIS division (USIA now). Here is my story & dilemma:
My parents were still overseas & separated. They sold my childhood home in the suburbs because my Dad did not want to rent it, complaining about repair costs. So I had no home to return to (My Dad later remarried & never returned to Gary, Indiana anyhow).
At first, I moved in with my grandparents. But they had restrictions. When I could come home at night (I'm male), no bringing girls over (Religious Irish Catholics) & this did not bode well for a 19 year old who had already worked for a US Embassy so we started to argue & my Dad stepped in & said "live in a dormitory".
I enrolled in the dorms of a state school & immediately, I had trouble fitting in. Other kids said "He's different". They called me "old man" because I was 19 & seemed 30 years old. Some of the rowdier frat types began playing really awful pranks on me like peeing in cups & propping them against my door so when I opened my dormitory room door urine would spill all over my floor. My only friend was a Jewish girl who had served in the IDF so she too had been overseas & when I asked her "why are they doing this?" she replied "They say you are different." In International schools overseas, everyone is different. Different countries, different cultures. Nobody looks at anybody different twice. There are no cliques really. Brits hang around Brits a bit more in Dubai, Indians with Indians, but other than that there are no jocks, dweebs, gearheads...And no bullying.
This school campus was in downtown Gary, Indiana so there was crime. I grew up in Dubai, so I was used to a crime free environment. One morning, someone from my dorm was involved in an on-campus break in of a campus store. The police mistakenly knocked on my door because he lived next to me. I opened it & the Sherriff was rough & said "hands against the wall!" & began frisking me when he realized my name was not Tom the suspect & he had the wrong dormitory...so he simply without explanation left. I was shaken by the experience. Moreover, there was racism at this school. Some of the whites were racist & used racist terminology. Because I grew up overseas, I never met racists. My best friend in Dubai was from Zanzibar.
In a desperate attempt to fit in, I grew my hair out & grew a goatee. I bought clothes with marijuana emblems. I figured that "stoners" were an easy clique to blend into: it was, to begin with, multiracial & also did not require much in the way of expenses. If people thought you were "stoned" they would ignore your weirdness. The problem was, at the age 19 & raised in Dubai, I did not know anything about weed. Soon other students who were "alternative" & would actually talk to me said that there were rumors that "I was a cop" who was "undercover". My only friend in that first year was a Korean exchange student & he smoked pot & taught me how to roll a joint well enough & how to inhale that I would no longer be thought of as a "narc" again.
I also experienced petty crime for the first time. My locker lock was sawed through at the Student Activity Center & my shoes, ID, everything stolen. In Dubai, there is virtually no theft. Nobody in an international school is going to steal your shoes.
After one year at this Gary college, fed up with crime & various urban woes, I transferred to a more bucolic school 100 miles South. The rural Midwest is real backward in some ways. Many of the locals were what you might refer to as "redneck trash".
However, there was none of the serious urban crime of Gary.
In this rural town, I had a problem adjusting with the local rednecks. Many of them behaved exactly like you would expect people from the cast of DELIVERANCE to behave. They chewed tobacco, they wore too-tight t-shirts, they had beer bellies, cheap tattoos, dirty John Deere hats. I made no attempt to "fit in" with them. But the only jobs I could get were off-campus & the locals really disliked me. I didn't talk about my childhood in Africa, Singapore & the Middle East nor did I did I mention I attended an International School so the local yokels I had no choice but to work in construction or landscaping with just believed I was a "rich college boy hippie".
After I moved into an apartment off-campus, my problems got worse. My roommate did not get along with me & moved out after only three weeks. He was a stoner & business student at the college. He thought I was strange, self-centered, aloof. He moved out after only 3 weeks.
In an act of desperation in need of roommates, I allowed a guy my age named Scott to move in whose girlfriend Tonya was a college student I worked with at the student cafeteria. Scott was from the local trailer park. He was 21 years old & already had a 2 year old daughter from a previous relationship. I went over to help him move out & his mother was in the double-wide & she was a woman in her 40's who tried to get me to stay for a drink & even pawed at him provocatively & Scott exclaimed (In front of his mother) "CAREFUL, MY MOM IS A PERVERT!" I had no problems with Scott personally but one night he came home from his telemarketing job which his boss had fired him from & got his SKS & went out to his boss's house & then came back & bragged "I had the sight on my boss through his living room window". This was my first experience with the redneck obsession with guns-how poor disenfranchised rednecks felt "empowered" by firearms. I got scared at this point & moved to another off-campus apartment. Scott later was arrested for child support & they found his SKS in his apartment & went to jail for a long stretch but not before he got Tonya pregnant (his second out-of-wedlock kid).
During this time, I was still going back to Dubai in the summers. My mother, an architect, still worked there. So I was seeing old friends from International School & now many were graduating & returning to the UAE from Australia or UK or Sweden or India with degrees & working in Dubai. I began to talk to some of the Indian guys I had known from International School in Dubai about THEIR EXPERIENCE in US state colleges-we would trade stories about the comparative backwardness of rural locals, the racism, the ignorance of kids who had never been anywhere in their entire lives & many of these Indian kids felt the same way I did.
My best friend in Dubai was a Swedish kid name Markus who saw I was depressed & said "Why don't you just stay here. I'll give you a job at my publishing company. We can share the company flat." But I declined, wanting to complete my degree.
The last year I returned to Indiana I was really depressed after that summer in Dubai. I moved back into the dorms from off-campus, simply to get away from lousy roommates & local hicks. The problem was that now I was 23 & the other students in the dorms were 19 or 20. I requested to live with the RA, simply because I thought he might be more mature. When I met him he exclaimed "We thought you were a foreign kid because of your name" & I just winced. That last year in the dorms was difficult.
So I transferred to Arizona State University. I figured the desert vistas would remind me of Dubai. Too old for the dorms by then at age 24, I found a condo to share in Tempe with some students from the local art college.
For the first time in Phoenix, I also encountered a new species called the "Tweaker". This genus belonged to the unfettered white urban underclass & they were crystal meth addicts. I was warned about them. How they would steal anything. A few panhandled me. On one occasion outside my Tempe condo, I witnessed a "tweaker" running down the sidewalk with his pants down & another tweaker was chasing him.
I also had a bad encounter with Phoenix PD. My bike got a flat tire & I parked it in an alley. Suddenly, some police swerved over in a patrol car. The jumped out very aggressively. One drew his gun. They flashed their badges. "We just saw you abandon the bike, that looks suspicious!" Then the policeman asked me for ID. I reached for it & he shouted "GET YOUR HANDS AWAY FROM YOUR POCKETS!" Finally, he got my license. He ran it for warrants, which of course I did not have. Fed up & having taken a law class in college I said "am I being detained" & the officer snarled "Don't be a wiseass or you'll be trying to get bailed out of jail!" & without a word he & his partner took off.
One last thing happened before I finally managed to graduate from ASU. I was in downtown Phoenix & was nearly assaulted by a roving gang of "Cholos". Gangs were a real problem in Phoenix.
Another issue was that I really had nowhere to live in Northern Indiana. My parents had long divorced & they themselves were gone from the USA. Dad went on to work for oil companies in Chad in Central Africa, in Jakarta in Indonesia, a bunch of other countries I've know forgotten. My mother moved to London to work as an architect. She worked in London for 25 years after Dubai. My grandparents were in their seventies so I could not really live with them.
Finally, I called Markus, my Swedish friend in Dubai. I pleaded for him to get me a job & let me live with him & his Lebanese girlfriend who also graduated from our same International School.
I quickly sold my meager possessions & bought a ticket.
The last week in Tempe, Arizona my old "international kid" persona & cultured boarding school accent returned. I cut my hair, stopped smoking weed, bought new casual dress clothes, a new suit.
I started treated the townies with a kind of contempt. One of them, nicknamed Zeke, was an Eminem-type wannabe (As they were called in those days) who would break out in inane rap songs. "YOU'RE GOING ON AN AMBLE...WHERE DA JOCKEY'S RIDE CAMELS-" & I looked away from really disgustedly. He pressed me on it & I replied "You're an idiot, you really are."
So I flew to London, where my mother worked, and visited her. I felt so much better. So much safer in London. There were no more "cholos" or "tweakers" like Phoenix. The English bobbies were friendly & not aggressive like the US police. There were no hicks calling people "fags". There were no hillbilly single mothers with sullen bruised eyes. There were no crackheads. I'm sure these things exist in London (Though not Dubai) but I did not experience them.
I got back to Dubai to the room in Marcus's flat. I put on a huge casual act but when I was alone, I broke down & trembled about the things I had experienced during my 6 years in the USA.
The weird thing was that returning to Dubai in the fall of 1999 was like coming home. I was genuinely relieved to have returned to a place I felt safe. A place filled with erudite European professional class people where nobody from the various nationalities would ever call me "a fag" & everybody was different.
Occasionally, my mother would visit me in Dubai. I came clean to her. That I thought the Northern Indiana was a dismal awful place, that I believed that the US suffered from some deep societal rot, that as an international kid who had grown up in privilege I could not cope with the crime, the squalor, that my earning power was not great enough in the USA to get away from these things, that I loathed "rednecks" on crystal meth.
Sometimes in Dubai my experiences with "white trash rednecks" in Northern Indiana would haunt me. I would be driving jogging down the beach as the sun set over the Gulf of Oman & I would think about Scott's grotesque made up cougar Mom in the double-wide trailer & the words "CAREFUL, MY MOM IS A PERVERT!" or the tweaker in Tempe, Arizona who ran down the street high on meth with his pants down.
Occasionally, for reasons of some sort of self-satisfaction, I would contact some of the kids I knew at school on social media. One of them was a Polish-American named Stanley who returned to Gary. He complained that Gary was getting much worse, that he could not sell his house & move, that his job as a public school teacher was dangerous. Somehow, this affirmed my feelings in some way.
I also spoke to other American TCK's I had known in my youth at the International School. A few became full-fledged junkies who struggled with heroin for years. When I asked him why, he told me he did not like the USA & was basically "stuck there".
To some degree, far more than the British or Australia other nationalities at the Dubai international school, the American former TCK's had a much more difficult time adjusting to the USA as adults.
A few of them even visited Dubai as adults with their own money, not an inexpensive trip. One of my classmates, Steven, from Texas, even took his honeymoon there. He & I visited our old International School & sat outside. He told me he missed Dubai deeply as an adult. His father also worked in oil & he had returned to his small Texas town outside Austin. He had the same complaints I did. That he was around "dumb hicks" who were unworldly that could not relate to him or vice versa. That he thought many US laws & cultural aspects were "stupid".
Over the years in Dubai, I forgot about my experiences. I traveled & lived around the world. I never returned to my birthplace.
So I wondered if other American TCK's had a similar experience.
r/TCK • u/Pomodoro44 • May 15 '25
I'm curious if there's any third culture kids or adults into those 2 values. Anyone here?
r/TCK • u/Legitimate-Face-8260 • Feb 17 '25
r/TCK • u/Background-End-3315 • Apr 18 '23
What are these insights we TCK purportedly possess?
r/TCK • u/Passageavide1983 • May 05 '26
Hello everyone,
I would love some advice on a complicated situation.
I am an American (28F) living in Paris. I have been in a relationship with my French partner (27F) for nearly 6 years. We met when I was studying abroad in Paris right before the pandemic hit. I stayed in France and finished my studies via Zoom (the campus had closed during covid).
Before the pandemic and before getting into a relationship I had been planning to get a Master’s in London after my studies. My partner and I at the time were both young and naive, we decided to both forego our masters to do 2 years of internships together and hopefully start a business together afterwards. This choice entailed a very brief internship in Morocco followed by an 8 month internship in Amsterdam. TLDR our great plan didn’t work out as well as expected. After a year and 2 months my partner decided she would get a job in France. We moved to the Alps and then the South of France for two positions for her over the course of 2.5 years. I didn’t work during that time due to lack of opportunity in those locations/visa difficulties. This led to a lot of shame and suffering on my end.
We ended up moving back to Paris nearly 2 years ago because we both a ) wanted to live in Paris again and b) both had professional opportunities. I have been working as an assistant in a furniture gallery. I haven’t been thrilled about my job (very low pay except if I make a big sale, average of one client every two weeks, not much intellectual stimulation). Despite these drawbacks, the experience has led to my desire to strike out on my own in the industry, ideally working as an interior designer as well. I have learned a lot but don’t feel legitimate enough to start a studio off the bat, despite the fact that a lot of interior designers don’t have formal training.
While I was perusing a designer’s work a couple weeks ago I came across a university in London that has a program that I believe could bring a lot of weight and legitimacy to my potential business. I didn’t think too much of it and wrote it off as a pipe dream.
Yesterday my partner told me she saw a job offer in London for the company she used to work for. She told me she wanted to apply. She asked if Id be interested in moving there , I said yes.
Today I spoke to her about the master’s program in London. She told me that after reflection she doesn’t want to move to London and leave her friends and family. At first she criticised my desire, asking if I didn’t think it was ridiculous to get a master’s degree at nearly 30 and that it’s sad I don’t have enough self confidence to start a business on my own. She asked why I can’t do a masters here, to which I replied I prefer not to when French isn’t my first language. She then told me that she would never mpve to London with me unless I had a job and could support myself (rather than being supported by my parents), also telling me that if I were to do a masters here we would move into different apartments because she doesn’t want my half of the apartment to be paid by my parents.
This evening she told me she was unsure if things would work between us because I clearly want to live elsewhere and she didn’t want to move.
She’s now saying it’s ok if I go but I’m saddened by the whole situation and feel guilty about my desire to perhaps go for a masters. Any advice would be appreciated.
r/TCK • u/Active-Neat-5511 • Dec 14 '20
I was an American TCK who became an adult expat rather young in life, about 25, and mostly through the assistance of friends/parents so it was relatively easy for me to leave the United States as a young adult. Here was my experience:
I spent some time in college around locals in a smallish town & was shocked at the intransigence of their lives. Twenty five year old men would have "beefs" with some other guy their age from high school over some girl. I thought this was ridiculous. I still do. At 18 I was in Dubai. At 19 I was in Gary. At 24 I was in Phoenix. At 25 I was back in Dubai...when I e mailed a few college buddies & they said that "so & so is still at Indiana state" it boggled my mind how locals lives never changed.
My behavior started to slip my last week in Phoenix when I knew I was returning overseas. My own roommate was a middle-class Graphic Artist but to some of the hickish locals I started making jokes about films like DELIVERANCE or TEXAS CHAINSAW MASSACRE "look what your brother did to the door!" "Squeal like a pig, boy".
The very second I managed to get a friend to get me a job in Dubai & told me I could stay with him...I was gone. The six years from 19-25 that I had spent in the USA meant nothing to me. Zero. I owned a traffic fine in Phoenix & never bothered to pay it. I liquidated & packed my bags.
Fellow Dubai TCK's have pointed out Dubai's authoritarianism & human rights record. I didn't care. There was a guy from Houston in my apartment building who worked in one of the oil supply yards & I would have described him as white trash & his son was a 15 year old juvie delinquent who trashed a neighboring car for no reason with a pipe & within two days that white trash family was gone. I liked that. No escalation of the son's behavior until some other kid got shot over a meth deal a year later or cops coming in and out, the Dubai police contacted Dad's company & he dismissed & gone instantly. On another occasion one Indian guy in my building was beating up his wife & his sponsorship was terminated he was gone when the cops came to arrest him. I liked this too.
I'm told that TCK's are sometimes authoritarian for some reason. Honestly, I kind of wonder. After putting up with some crazy behavior on Indiana public buses & once witnessing a crackhead beat up his GF at the bus terminal & being relentlessly panhandled by the "tweakers" who were outside my apartment in Tempe I was sort of glad that in Dubai anybody who makes a problem is removed from that society. No muggers. No pushy drug dealers at malls as their had been in Indiana. When I was mugged in Phoenix & made a police report the cops told me that my assailant was a PCP-addict who'd just gotten out of prison for serving a 10 year sentence for manslaughter when he mugged someone at a park aged 16 & the gun had gone off & killed the victim. Honestly, I liked the fact that in Dubai these people were not around.
When I was around lower class urban or rural white Americans in the USA which was common for a few years as a young man, I noticed they were sort of stuck in a self-induced cycle of self-destructiveness. As a TCK, you just don't have the option of this overseas. Nobody can choose to be a heroin addict when they are 14 years old. Nobody can choose to be a stripper Mom. It's impossible. Usually there are no broken homes in Dubai because Dad is the one with the job & Mom either works or stays at home. International schools don't have vicious teen street gangs in their hallways. It just doesn't happen for TCK's. Another poster mentioned that people's decisions are made for them, which is kind of true. They are. Growing up in Dubai, you cannot really choose to make terrible decisions like becoming a heroin addict at 14 or joining a vicious gang. If you did, you would be deported, instantly. Probably the company your Dad worked for would just say "This fellow's family is so much trouble let's just get rid of him."
People say that Dubai is a police state but it was in the USA that I had a couple of bad experiences with police officers. I found USA police very rude & aggressive. I had not done anything wrong so there was no lethal escalation & I am white so I was not fearing for my life but I still did not see that UAE police were worse in any way than US police. Actually, in Dubai I never interacted with any at all. I observed than in Dubai if you did nothing wrong & were an expat police would never ever have any reason to detain you. But in the USA, they might do so.
As I discussed with another TCK, I kind of liked Dubai or Asia's authoritarian approach-no sitting around debating abortion or the legalization of marijuana while meanwhile poisonous lead sludge come out the faucets of cities like Flint, Michigan because the infrastructure is so bad. Just a five-year plan & that is that. No ifs, ands or buts. Americans will speak of political "freedom" but what about civil engineering? Who gives a rat's hump about abortion when your wife has a miscarriage because you drive into an asteroid sized crater on a US road or street?
As an adult American TCK, I talk to other American TCK's who talk about making an adjustment to a small town & I realize that I could never have done that. Even if I could have made better money in a USA small town-and it probable that I could have-I would never have been able to live around people who were 30 years old old & still "beefing" with some other 30 year old about the fact that he stole their GF in high school in the 11th grade. When I did go back overseas as a younger adult & got a hold of some friends from college & they said "James is still at Indiana State" I was sort of dumbfounded...I had left the USA, moved back to Dubai, holidayed in Goa & Nepal, spent a summer in London & this former dormmate of mine was STILL at college, albeit as a grad student? I would have been bored to tears.
What also surprised me, looking back, was how easily I returned overseas from the USA. There was not a single split second of indecision. I never wanted to marry in the USA (I'm married to a Chinese woman) & I never wanted to have dependents in the USA or mortgage a house in the USA or in any form or fashion be "stuck there". I just wanted to drift overseas. London became Dubai & Dubai became Indian & India became Philippines & Philippines became Taiwan...I didn't care. As long as I was overseas.
Another aspect of my personality was that overseas I enjoyed the nepotism of knowing local movers & shakers. I thrived on the whole "wasta" thing. When I lived in the Philippines I liked the fact that I was close to the influential Chinese-Filipino business community. That I "knew people". In Indiana, I had known nobody. I was just another local shitkicker on the street who, every so often, police would detain. Police did not do that in Philippines. Some of them knew that I was good friends with some Chinese-Filipinos. This isn't very democratic & Americans are supposed to be democratic, but I liked befriending people of local importance overseas. In the Midwest, such elitism is really detested, though not so much in other parts of the USA.
At the same time, the reason people liked me overseas was BECAUSE of my clean-cut, square-jawed, honest Midwest Flash Gordon (I resemble Sam J Jones who played Flash but without the blonde hair) appearance/persona. I actually used this "Midwestern Nice" to great advantage but ironically it was to ensure I never went back to the Midwest.
I'm not sure whether this is a case of needing therapy or not. I'm now 46 yrs old & own a house in Asia & I am married & have a daughter. So my decisions in life are sort of already made. All of the things a person does as an adult I did overseas. Do other TCK's have the same experience.
r/TCK • u/Active-Neat-5511 • Dec 14 '20
Prologue
Like many a Dubai Western expat I drifted on to the Philippines. While in Dubai, I had good Filipino friends & knew a few American expats in Dubai in the Philippines so eventually I moved there & got a job.
The Ohio Cop in Makati
The American expat community is small enough-as all TCK's know-that it is like living a small town. Everyone eventually know of everyone.
One American from Ohio was an ex-cop-tough, sullen, burly-who ran a call center (Sort of a pass-the-time occupation for American pensioners in the Philippines) & disliked me. I'm careful never to be offensive to other Americans. I have a lifetime of diplomacy behind me & like most TCK's I can read people right quick. I knew what the Ohio cop thought: there was something off about me. I'd seen it in the looks of the frat guys I knew in college & local yokels in the USA I worked with in my college days. I knew the look. It was xenophobic & distrustful.
The Ladyboy
I won't get into what I do as I value my privacy but I had a ladyboy working for me. Because I'm a TCK, I have no assumptions & no judgements about others. TCK's are libertarians in some senses. You have to be overseas. And anyhow you have no basis of comparison, really.
The Rumor
An American named Mark told me this Ohio cop-Roddy was his name-had been telling other Americans he had seen me with a ladyboy at 10 pm. He had, actually. Outside my office. But I didn't like this. At all. The fact that another American had been watching me. I did not care that he thought I was gay or told other Americans I was gay. But something about an American believing he had the authority to watch me or pass judgment on me made me dislike him. Also, there was something ominous about Roddy. He clearly was a homophobe, but also, he still thought he was a police officer. He himself was coping, I feel, with the fact that he was in a foreign country & was no wearing a badge. Or something. I don't know what went through his mind.
The Chinese-Filipinos
I was close to the Chinese-Filipino community, which is wealthy & influential. Most TCK's grow up around privilege & are familiar with identifying centers of power/influence. They go to international schools with the local elite, themselves international TCK's.
Roddy had already made a few mistakes with anybody who was anybody local there. He was always talking about the US military role in the Philippines & how we defended the Philippines from China & how important the USA was to the Philippines. This is a stupid mistake. Any American TCK who grew up in Asia knows this.
Randy also said something rude to Chinese-Filipinos in Robinson's Mall about "Chinese working on railroads where I am from" which another American mentioned to me. Mark had tried to explain to Roddy that irritating the Phil-Chinese community was a mistake & repeated this to me.
Ride him
I went to a Chinese-Filipino who represented me. I told him Roddy was ominous. That he had told other Americans he disliked me, that he expressed homophobia about me & suggested I was gay (I'm not).
I said to my Chinese-Filipino lawyer "can you ride him?"
My Chinese Filipino lawyer replied that Roddy, like many other Americans, probably did not have all the paperwork in place for his call center. He probably had not gone through the incredibly arduous process of getting a BPI-a business permit.
Roddy hadn't.
BPI Raid
The BPI noisily raided Roddy's office. They shut it down. They demanded his current business permit. They fined him.
The Outcome
My Chinese-Filipino lawyer kept some of the fine, which was split to him because he got the "tip off".
That's corruption, of course, but I understand corruption. I grew up with wasta in Dubai. Corruption is legal in the Philippines.
Roddy could have gotten the BPI but he simply closed his small call center & moved on. I never saw the guy again. He moved to some other part of the Philippines or maybe back to the USA.
In Philippines, no retiree can come up against local bigwigs. It's impossible. American retirees don't know anyone important. They aren't making any money there & usually haunt the girly bars soaking booze with younger girls. They are glorified sex & prostitute addicts, really, so no Filipino with any pull is doing business with them.
Epilogue
Roddy never saw me again. I never let Roddy know it was me. My Chinese-Filipino lawyer assured me of that.
But for some reason, I felt vindicated. I had gotten even with all the frat boys in college, the rednecks, the local yokels, the Midwestern townies who had once made me feel powerless, hapless, maybe even slight afraid for my physical safety. I had made Roddy feel alien, out of place.
Roddy was not one of the frat boys who played pranks on me or townies in college...but an education Roddy received.
I had the advantages overseas in the Philippines. I understood wasta, as it is called in Arabic. I understood the centers of power & influence better than Roddy. I was a TCK who went to international schools so I was in a certain club with the Chinese-Filipinos in Makati.
As an American, I wrestled with what I did. Roddy was breaking the law. But I went after another American in a foreign country.
How do fellow TCK's feel about this?
r/TCK • u/Active-Neat-5511 • Dec 13 '20
I will have to limit myself to one rambling post per day but I find this board helpful & feel reassured knowing I am not the only American TCK to feel this way but I have some questions:
Did other American TCK's grow up in relative privilege in another country & returned to the USA & suddenly become critical of the USA or even shocked at some aspects of its socio-economic or political system?
Did any other American TCK begin comparing the USA negatively to other G-7 (Or non-G7) developed countries after spending time in the USA? I started comparing Gary, Indiana to European countries I visited & to Australia & even Singapore & Dubai & started believing their political & economic systems were somehow superior because they did not have the problems or inequity that the USA has, particularly in the rust belt.
Did any other American TCK sort of wonder why so many Americans were self-destructive? Starting in college, I was around lot's of people with problems you might call white trash. I could not understand them & the fact that some kids my age chose to have children out-of-wedlock young & unskilled, or they did hard drugs, or they wanted to be gangsters, or they committed petty crimes or basically acted like Springer guests. Was any other TCK really disgusted by "white trash"?
Was any other American TCK get into an argument with a staunch Republican over the systems in Australia or NW Europe (Free healthcare, free education, higher minimum wage etc) & when the Republic started talking about American "freedom" or "individualism" & the TCK responded that Australians or Europeans had more social mobility an argument ensued?
Did any other American TCK ever consciously return overseas as an adult TCK feeling as if they had escaped a second or third world country? My Gosh, I was shocked at some of the rural squalor of Indiana or the urban depravity of Phoenix, Arizona.
Did any other American TCK feel like every American they met regardless of class lacked self-awareness/insight. Do TCK's have more insight or self-awareness than other Americans?
Let me make a comparison between the USA & Dubai or Singapore (Places I used to live): Why is the USA infrastructure worse than that of Dubai overall? Especially in the USA Midwest or South? Don't they have civil engineers? Why are roads, bridges & public transportation superior in Dubai or Singapore when these are supposed to be "developing countries"? Why are so many USA cities collapsing? Why in the USA is there more crime than in Dubai or Singapore? Try operating a drug-dealing gang in Dubai & selling meth or crack on a street corner. You'll be in prison in 40 minutes. Why does the USA have such a problem with gangs/drugs? Why are USA public schools dangerous? Why are International Schools in Dubai & Singapore safe? Why do so many Americans have social pathology such as out-of-wedlock pregnancy or teen pregnancy or heroin abuse or petty crime but the citizens of Dubai or Singapore don't have these problems? Why does the USA have such homelessness with so many empty buildings & why don't Dubai or Singapore have homelessness (maybe a few but not masses in every city) like the USA? Why don't Singapore or Dubai have mentally ill people on the streets pushing shopping carts & talking about an apocalypse like the USA does? Why do Dubai & Singapore have less issues with illegal immigration or opponents of illegal immigrating than the USA has? Why is racism a problem in the USA but not in Dubai or Singapore?
As every American TCK whose father was in the oil business knows, many places in the USA have a great deal of oil. Yet places like Dallas or Houston also have horrendous poverty-both stark rural trailer park poverty & grinding inner-city poverty-while Dubai is able to provide all Emirate citizens (Though not guest workers) with a good standard of living & uses oil money to maintain a standard of living for everyone. Why can't oil-rich Texas cities do that for their poor people? To go spend a single hour in a downtown Dallas, Texas Greyhound station you would never know the city has any oil wealth at all.
Sorry for the endless questions but I have a last one for American TCK's. Has any American TCK every returned overseas as adult just to get away from certain Americans or a certain American milieu? When I returned to Dubai, I never met another trailer park redneck like Scott, I never had encounters with "Cholos" again & I never saw another "tweaker" aka meth head. I was glad for all of these things. It is not that I cared one way or another about politics or religion. I just never wanted to be around the American underclass again. Sure, Dubai has human rights abuses. No question about it. But was any other American TCK forced to confront working class or lower income life in the USA & got really grossed out & simply left the USA like I did?
I should add that many American TCK's I knew growing up returned to the USA & had no problem readjusting. Over the years, I've contacted them on social media. Upon graduating from high school, they returned to the USA & never traveled again. No desire to. Nor did they look at the USA with a critical eye. I would not say that they even really missed the countries I met them in. We exchanged a few funny stories but they had mostly forgotten all about being a TCK & really had zero interest in what happened in another dimension of time & space years before.
I should add that I probably could have made more money had I remained in the USA & really focused on being a success there. But somehow, I could not do so. There was something about life there that really go under my skin. I did not even want to maintain a house in the USA. In warm climates like Dubai or Asia, the architecture is so easy to maintain. In Indian winters, roofs had to be repaired etc. And everything was a fire hazard because everything was built out of wood. I once lived in a college apartment building & after I was no longer a tenant the place burned down because of some electrical wiring problem. In Dubai, everything is tile & concrete. You never hear about a fire. Same in my apartments in Asia. If nothing else, it seemed as if home maintenance was easier overseas. There wasn't any.
r/TCK • u/apreasercher21 • Mar 03 '21
Hi everyone: I'm taking an AP Research Class as a TCK and I need help! I'm surveying teenage TCKS (ages 16, 17, and 18 ONLY) for my class and I am in dire need of survey responses. The form should take three minutes maximum and is totally anonymous. If you can help out, I'd greatly appreciate it.
r/TCK • u/danielle_ardance • Sep 18 '26
Do you guys understand what I meant as fellow TCKs? 🥺
r/TCK • u/kangauri • Oct 02 '21
**The survey is now closed. Thank you to everyone who participated! I appreciate it.**
I am interested in designing a product or service to help improve Third Culture Kid (TCK) experiences, specifically to do with transition.
For the purpose of this survey, a TCK is a person who has spent a significant part of their developmental years living in cultures outside of their parents’ home culture. They have lived a mobile lifestyle with the expectation of moving back to their passport country.
If that sounds like you, I would appreciate your participation in this survey!
The survey will take about 10-15 minutes to complete and all responses will be kept anonymous.
Link to the survey: https://forms.gle/RTxiCdcYvv3es5id8
Thank you so much!
r/TCK • u/lucianadeu • Feb 12 '24
Hi there TCKs! 📷📷
My name is Luciana Deutschmann, I'm from Guatemala and I'm currently working on my AP Research project. 📷
My project is centered around the different ways in which culture affects love and romantic demonstrations of love (love languages) --- especially in individuals with diverse backgrounds, like TCKs. My research goal is to recognize the deep-rooted connection between love, intimacy and culture in adulthood, as well as to assess the spectrum of relevance of national and/or parental relationships throughout an individual’s upbringing and its impact on their love life.
The overall participation involves the completion of a 7-10 min survey and a follow-up interview to hear about your experiences and dynamics in more detail. You would need to be at least 25 years old to participate! If you're interested in participating in this study, fill out this short forms so I can personally contact you --- more details will come to you via email.
Here is the forms: https://forms.gle/VDdYavwT8V8FdWREA
I'd love to hear from some of you!!! 📷📷📷
r/TCK • u/ApprehensiveSeal • Jun 17 '23
I’ve moved back to my passport country (the UK) after living abroad from age 2 to 23. Living abroad is super central to my identity. However I’ve noticed my colleagues here are so uninterested in my experience abroad. When I tell them I grew up abroad, they smile or say “oh” then move on and talk about other stuff. Yesterday they had an hour conversation about remodelling their gardens. I’m really not trying to sound conceited, but these people have now worked with me for three years and never once asked about my experience. It’s killing me suppressing this part of my identity. I know others aren’t as fortunate to have lived abroad, but surely they should have SOME interest in the “other”? Don’t really have a question, just struggling with this and want to rant with people. Been feeling a bit alone 😞
r/TCK • u/Technical_Abroad_410 • Feb 22 '26
I've been living in this European country for my entire life and I hate it here. My entire life I've dreamed of moving to the U.S. which is funny because I am first and foremost a U.S. citizen. Choosing to stay here for college was the biggest mistake in my life.
r/TCK • u/[deleted] • Jul 04 '22
Hi everyone. I've been thinking about my identity recently.
A bit about my background: I was born in the USA to Mexican immigrants. I grew up speaking only Spanish until I began school. We moved into a city which consisted mostly of Asian immigrants and their kids. Thus, I grew up with a mixture of Mexican and Chinese food. I grew up used to hearing Spanish at home and Cantonese and Mandarin in the city.
I learned how to hold chopsticks from my friends' parents. I learned numbers and greetings in Asian languages. I've been told by other people that I have an Asian accent, but I'm not sure what that means.
I've never really felt in touch with my Mexican or American culture. I kind of feel like an outsider within my parents' culture. I feel more comfortable within Asian cultures I grew up in. My comfort foods include Mexican and Chinese dishes. I actually like the smell of fish markets and incense.
So, what am I? If I'm not a TCK, then how do I identify?
Edit: Thank you to everyone who's replied to my post! So, I feel that CCK fits me more so than TCK. I'm happy that I have a label to match my upbringing.
r/TCK • u/globalstorylistener • Apr 17 '23