I’m disappointed with my agency.
I am an intended single father. I signed up with an agency in June of 2025. I paid close to $40,000 up front to sign up. I was told it would take about 8-12 months to match with a surrogate.
In May of 2026, I’m finally presented with a potential match. After my clinic approves her, we end up matching at the beginning of July. She has two kids and has been in a two year relationship with her current partner (not her kids’ father). After the match, I pay the agency a $7,000 match fee.
I meet with my attorney to go over the contract. One thing I was concerned about was the language in the contract, “Intended father agrees to take custody of any child the GC gives birth to that she’s not biologically related to.” I was concerned about that because what if there was a clinic error, like there was an embryo mixup or sperm mixup? My attorney said, “That’s the risk you have to take because you can’t leave a baby stranded with nobody to take care of it. Your remedy in that situation would be against the fertility clinic. And the contract allows you to get parentage testing early in the pregnancy, and if the baby isn’t yours, that’s what the termination clause is for.”
Well, the termination section did not specifically mention I could request the GC get an abortion in the event of a clinic error, so I texted the GC and asked what she wanted to do in that situation. The GC said, “If you’re indicating you’d want to terminate in that situation, I’d understand.” I asked if she would be comfortable with termination under those circumstances, and she said yes. So I told my attorney to insert language to that effect in the termination section.
Later my attorney’s office forwards me an email conversation between my attorney and the GC’s attorney where they’re discussing the proposed language. The GC hadn’t met with her attorney yet, but her attorney was not sure if the GC would agree with that proposal and that there were other things to consider like the biological parents of the fetus in the event of an embryo mixup. My attorney invited the GC’s attorney for some alternative suggestions, and the GC’s attorney thought it didn’t need to be addressed in the contract because it was a very unlikely scenario and if it did happen, more parties would be involved. So my attorney asked the GC’s attorney to present the contract to her anyway and if she didn’t accept that proposal, he would let me know and we’d figure out where to go from there.
At that point, I wasn’t expecting the “termination in event of clinic error” language to stay in the contract, but I thought the attorneys would work something out.
My sister flies in to town, then we meet up with the surrogate and her boyfriend for dinner. My sister pays for everyone’s dinner, and as far as I could tell, we all got along and everything seemed fine. We didn’t discuss the contract or the proposed termination language. We were texting photos to each other afterwards.
My surrogate met with her attorney in August, and then three business days later, I’m informed by my attorney’s office that the match has been disrupted and will not be moving forward. I have to wait a week before I’m able to meet with my attorney to find out why because the agency won’t tell me anything. I didn’t contact the surrogate to find out what happened.
When I finally meet with my attorney, he says that the proposed embryo mixup contingency plan was not received well, it made the surrogate uncomfortable, so her attorney notified the agency’s legal director. It wasn’t clear to me whether the surrogate didn’t want to stay matched with me or if the agency decided to just end the match, but I was informed that she did not want to hear from me and she didn’t want me communicating to her ever again. My attorney said that the agency said, “If you insist on the surrogate getting an abortion in the event of an embryo mixup, we are not going to match you with another surrogate.”
Well, I was never insisting anything! I was just trying to come up with some contingency plan in the contract. You’re allowed to propose terms in contract negotiations, the other side doesn’t have to accept the terms. Ordinarily, if one party rejects a term, that doesn’t shut down negotiations all together. And it didn’t make sense in this case because I had checked with the surrogate first before telling my attorney to add the language in there.
Anyway, so now I’m waiting to be rematched. It’s been over two months since the match disruption.
But honestly, I think the agency should have done more to prevent the disruption or given me some meaningful opportunity to course correct. After paying all that money to the agency, and considering how long I had to wait to be matched, and how long I have to wait again. I feel like they breached their contract with me. The agreement I signed specifically has a term that says, “Agency will do whatever necessary to facilitate and mediate between the intended parent and the surrogate,” or something like that. Well, what did the agency do to try to tell the surrogate, “Oh no, don’t worry, he’s not insisting on it.” No, they just let the match fall apart.
It happened so abruptly. I’m disappointed because I had planned to have the first transfer attempt in late October or early November.