r/SuperMaM • • Mar 11 '17

Micks DYK's in Review #4. Micks Omissions, 1st Supplement. NSFW

24 Upvotes

Michael, I was waiting for you complete 200 DYKs before I continued. I thought you disappeared three days after my last post, but a man of great stature caught you using an alt to brown nose yourself. You and you have now completed 217 numbered DYKs on SuperMaM. This multiple accounts scandal has reminded me of a favoured actor of yours in this film.

By now your quest should be complete and r/TickTockManitowoc sunk. Unsurprisingly it hasn't but if you kept up your 30% conversion rate, the ranks of SAIG should of swelled by thousands and thousands.

Anyhoo, you have continued with repetitions, along with your usual piss and wind, instead of covering the many areas you neglected. So I have been left with no choice but to supplement "Micks Omissions".


Radandt Statement

On October 31 at 4:30 pm JR observers a large fire (possibly contained in a drum) located at the Steven's trailer. JR is sure of this time because it coincides with a shift change at the quarry. JR Interview Report JR Statement

This is the earliest statement (Nov 5) about the fire and it predates any fire discoverys. This statement is also from an independent(?) witness, it sounds like a reliable time and LE should look close to Stevens trailer if they have any suspicions that evidence might have been burnt.

Michael is yet to do a post that contains any reference to this report or statement


Steven's Interview

Pg 31, 32, 33.

In this interview Detective O'Neill does seem interested in a variety of different burning areas. Steven marks out the locations of his burning barrel along with the Janda barrels. (barrels marked "x")

LE now have some extra barrels to look at, if they thought there was some chance of evidence being burnt. Although looking at the distance between the Janda barrels and Stevens burning areas, and taking into consideration there has been no mention of a recent fire on the Janda property, the Janda barrels would only be part of a more comprehensive search.

Michael's post about this interview shows some very poor reading comprehension , fortunately Noxious has cleared up the confusion. I believe a second abject apology is required.


Collecting the Barrels

The removal of the Janda barrels began by driving up Avery rd, with Steven's barrel in full view.

Deputy Kucharski and his team loaded the Janda barrels onto a covered trailer. The barrels were then transported past Steven's barrel on the way to CASO.

On Nov 5, Detective Remiker was checking near Steven's trailer and garage, he located an ear piece and some broken glasses, unfortunately he must of had his head down and missed Steven's barrel.

On the morning of Nov 6, Remiker after completing a search of Steven's garage, helped process and number the 4 Janda barrels but didn't think it necessary to point out Steven's barrel.

Just after loading the Janda barrels, Kucharski, Lenk, Colborn and Remiker searched Steven's trailer and pickup truck that was parked in front of the garage. We'll have to presume none of them noticed that 5th barrel.


Phone Barrel

The phone barrel was eventually found at sometime on Nov 7.

While Deputy Siders was searching a nearby cornfield he discovered a barrel in front of Steven's trailer. In the barrel was found Teresa Halbach's phone and other electronics. Unnamed DCI agents took control of the barrel until custody of the barrel was given to Inv W Baldwin at 1:15 pm.

On Nov 5, Investigator Baldwin had spent one hour in front of Steven's trailer but wasn't curious or bored enough to have a quick nose into Steven's burning barrel.

Michael only really mentions the contents of and alleged smell that came from Steven's barrel, but hasn't mention great effort that went into finding and then looking into Steven's barrel.


Kuss Rd

Just off Kuss rd in an area that was of intense interest to bloodhound Loof, Deputy Bushman discovers an excavated area before 10:35 am on Nov 7. This area was taped off until WI State crime lab photographed the area.

Lenk, Colborn and Tyson interrupt their search for weapon at the Janda residence for 4 hours to respond to Kuss rd but leave before the crime lab show up. They return to finish collecting weapons before going back to Kuss rd 20 mins later. Lenk, Colborn and Tyson quickly discover this was not a possible grave or burial site. The area is cleared 4:51 pm.

Michael hasn't made a post about Kuss Rd


Can I just say

Given the damage the 1985 case had inflicted on the reputation of local law enforcement, the impending "Avery Bill", and with Kocourek and Vogels deposition just around the corner, the temptation to cut corners and get that social outcast back where he belongs must of been immense.

So I would like to take a moment to acknowledge the restraint and respect shown by MTSO in waiting nearly 6 1/2 hours, in order to properly process what they thought may have been the final resting place of Teresa Halbach.

I'm sure I'll have no regrets in saying this,

Well Done MTSO 👍


Shit, ETA the bit about Stevens interview.


r/SuperMaM • • Jan 22 '17

Framing a Murderer NSFW

24 Upvotes

With its exclusivity contract period expired
and with permission received from creator u/xenomicx
SuperMaM proudly presents the award winning animated series..


Framing a Murderer - Episode 1

Sgt Andy Colborn of the Manitowoc Sheriff's Department discovering Teresa's RAV 4. Calling his superior, Lt. James Lenk for advice, Colborn is puzzled on how the frame will actually work.
original release


Framing a Murderer - Episode 2

Another presence is lurking in Manitowoc. Sgt Andy Colborn and Lt. James Lenk have difficulties planting the RAV 4.
original release


Framing a Murderer - Episode 3

A hidden location is discovered in Manitowoc that could unlock the mystery.
original release


Framing a Murderer - Episode 4


r/SuperMaM • • Aug 28 '16

The Emperor's Motion NSFW

23 Upvotes

I've tried to stay neutral recently, beating up on both sides with equal vigor. And I know I swore off participating in SAIG or TTM during my last ranting and raving session. (As an MaM/SA addict, I somewhat weakly rationalize that it's okay for me to post in the ostensibly neutral SuperMaM.)

Sometimes I can't help myself, and this is one of those times. When someone as fair and even-handed as /u/SkippTopp gets shredded for merely pointing out that the Emperor's motion has no clothes, something has gone terribly wrong. Terribly wrong.

Skipp didn't claim that KZ had no evidence to back up her allegations. Skipp didn't claim that SA was guilty. Skipp simply pointed out that the supporting evidence was lacking in last week's motion. This is undeniable.

Skipp also expressed his opinion that he thinks that KZ should have better justified her allegations in the pleading. How else can the Court evaluate their merits when deciding the motion? Maybe that's not how it works in the legal world, but this is a perfectly reasonable opinion.

People who claim to seek the truth should demand scrutiny, not bury it under an avalanche of bullying. What kind of celebrity cult has TTM become that the utter perfection of the Supreme Leader cannot be questioned? When did it adopt the mentality of North Korea?

It truly scares the shit out of me that large numbers of people have evolved to this mindset in just a few months of "sleuthing."

I guess I'm not very neutral today.

EDIT: spelling and slight rewording


r/SuperMaM • • Dec 16 '16

PSA: Get over it already NSFW

22 Upvotes

SAIG doesn't like hos. I get it. He says and does things that make me shake my head, or make me want to put it up on /r/cringepics. But for the love of all that is good and holy, shut up about it already. It's been almost a year of this shit, and it's fucking dumb. As if you don't already have tons of material to go bash him on MRC about, you're now making fun of him for watching big bang? Who gives a flying fuck. He should feel bad for liking it? YOU should all feel bad for making us read this horseshit for 11 fucking months. I'm so close to blocking so many of you because this petty back and forth is so incredibly stupid, but you otherwise do post some intelligent, and informative stuff about the case--what I'm actually here to read.

And Hos, seriously dude just stop fucking posting about how much guilters obviously love you and feeding into it. It's equally as annoying and stupid. When you were just posting about the case, I didn't agree with most of your theories or ideas, but at least your ego was in check. You've been acting a fool for months now, and it's giving everyone in here douchebumps.

We get it. You guys don't like each other, but for fucks sakes, get over it already.


r/SuperMaM • • Mar 15 '17

From one truther to another who - despite being handed evidence - still won't believe what she's being told... NSFW

20 Upvotes

As a truther I will - nine times out of ten - back up other truthers beliefs if I think there is merit in their way of thinking and investigative work - i’ll even help where I can. Checking out TTM with my fellow truthers, I came across this (https://www.reddit.com/r/TickTockManitowoc/comments/5zdvh2/is_rjh_a_real_person/). Questioning whether a woman called RJH - as her name appears in the CASO - was actually a real person. Now of course, as a partial believer in innocence, I too found this a bit suss if even the infallible u/foghaze was having difficulty in locating this girl/woman - was she even a real person? That infact, Mark Weigert made up RJH and popped her into CASO to ‘strengthen’ the story against Steven Avery? I took it upon myself to investigate this person and the named address within the CASO. In fact, it took me no more than ten minutes to realise that Marky boy had spelt her name wrong.
u/foghaze wanted ‘Government’ proof of my 'claims' - this can only mean to me that she assumes I am either part of the FBI or I am an undercover Government agent - of which I am neither. Why did she say she wanted this proof? Because who in their right mind is going to post confidential information that would squash her theory of RJH being fake? Well I found the next best thing. I found that the first name beginning with R was in fact spelt ael at the end as opposed to the traditional spelling and the H part of RJH wasn’t actually her surname, you'd have to replace the 'a' with an 'i'. I also provided her with a link to the Wisconsin Court Access of a record which corroborated this - and also provided proof of her time at the named address in CASO. I debunked the theory that this woman was an imaginary person and proved that Mark Weigert doesn’t give a flying fuck about spelling mistakes apparently. However, it’s not enough for u/foghaze. My point here is simple. If I can find this information within 10 minutes - it’s not that fucking hard for others to find it either. We are all constantly looking outside the box for answers - but, when provided with FACTUAL, HARD INFORMATION like I did - even as a truther it proves to me that some of those on my side of the fence, still don’t want to hear or see the truth - they’re looking for a conspiracy. I've got no hesitations or doubts in looking for the issues with the current evidence and reports - but when somethings been debunked move the fuck on.


r/SuperMaM • • Jan 26 '17

What's in the bookcase? Now we know... NSFW

20 Upvotes

r/SuperMaM • • Nov 22 '16

I found a problem in a photo NSFW

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/SuperMaM • • Sep 09 '16

Honest questions for truthers NSFW

20 Upvotes

With Hos' latest blanket ban, we're seeing the usual false claims about guilters trying to justify his decision. One was that guilters don't have any "honest" questions, don't want to discuss the case, and exist only to troll and talk about cats. So here are some honest questions, and /u/Hubert_J_Cumberdale, you particularly said guilters have no interest in hearing your opinions, so maybe you'd like to jump in, because a lot of us genuinely do.

I'll start, but hopefully some other guilters and truthers alike can jump in with their questions for the other side and have civil conversations.

  • I completely understand people who have problems with the case and aren't convinced of Avery's guilt, think maybe someone else did it. But a lot of truthers say they are 100% sure he didn't do it. That confuses me. There's literally zero exculpatory evidence. He has no alibi. He was seen burning and cleaning things the day of the crime. He had known contact with Teresa and she was never seen or heard from again. How could you be sure he's innocent? It was completely possible for him to kill her, he had the time and a gun. If cops planted evidence to secure a conviction that's wrong and the evidence should be thrown out and he probably wouldn't be convicted without it, but that doesn't mean he didn't do it. Where does the certainty come from?

  • Does anyone have a theory on how the frame job was carried out? There's a lot of evidence to explain- bullet, blood, car, keys, license plates, bones in two different barrels, hood latch DNA. And it matches his actions- he was seen using the fire pit and burn barrels where evidence was found, he had a recent cut on his right finger that matches where the blood was found. The cops would've basically needed to have surveillance on him and kill Teresa themselves. And what if he went back inside after their meeting and started calling people all afternoon? What if he went back to work like he usually did? What if he ran out for gas or food? There was huge risk he'd spoil their whole plan by giving himself an alibi. What if Teresa got back on her phone after their meeting and called someone saying she just finished work and was heading home? There'd be a witness that she left the meeting alive. It was incredibly risky to plant all this if they weren't watching Avery on 10/31 and therefore sure he didn't have an alibi, and even if they were watching him, at any point he could've done something that would give him an alibi like deciding to go back to work. Would they just dump Teresa's body if he did and try again later? Is there any theory on how the frame job was pulled off that takes all the evidence into account? (this is my biggest question for truthers, been asking for 9 months to no avail)

  • What are your thoughts on Avery's early interviews in November? For me, that was very hard to explain. I can't imagine an innocent man, when accused of a crime, wouldn't say "I couldn't have done it, I was with Brendan all evening, ask him he'll back me up!" Instead both Steven and Brendan lied and said they were home alone all night. The bones hadn't been found yet so an innocent man wouldn't know not to mention the fire. How do you explain both of them separately deciding to lie and deny being together, if they weren't doing anything suspicious together?

  • Who is your #1 suspect, and why do you feel they are a more likely candidate than Avery? How did they pull it off?

  • How many people do you think were involved in the framing?

  • What are you thinking/hoping Zellner's test will come up with?

I'd really like to hear the answers to these questions, and hear what questions truthers have for guilters. Hopefully we can engage in the civil discourse they accuse us of being incapable of.


r/SuperMaM • • Aug 13 '16

Ken Kratz walks into a bar with Steven Avery on his shoulder.... NSFW

20 Upvotes

Ok....Ken Kratz walks into a bar with Steven Avery on his shoulder. The bartender says, "Wow, where'd ya find that fat, sweaty, disgustingly vile sexual predator?".

Avery replies, "Calumet County Prosecutor's office".


r/SuperMaM • • Apr 13 '17

Can we be friends NSFW

19 Upvotes

As you may have noticed, I restricted posts for a bit.

I thought the truther bashing was getting a bit out of hand. So many posts without much substance just saying 'truthers are stupid', 'truthers are poopy heads'..

Guilters get bashed for being guilters too. And they're accused of being cops, paid to be here.

We're all people. We're all here because of the tv show. Guilters were once truthers and should understand that passion. Truthers should understand how it's easy to see Steve being guilty.

While having opinions that are on opposite poles, can we respect each other a wee bit more? Can we use info rather than insults? If we take a breath before commenting, could we make SuperMaM more nice? More super?

I will try. Will you consider it? Cheers.


r/SuperMaM • • Mar 25 '17

Is it just me or does KZ's new twitter picture look shopped? NSFW

19 Upvotes

r/SuperMaM • • Feb 24 '17

The TTM hypocrisy of using Kratz's history NSFW

19 Upvotes

Seriously, guys? Every time we bring up Avery's history you brush it off as irrelevant to the case and only based on victim statements, not actual convictions.

Then you have u/foghaze's post about Kratz's history, completely irrelevant to his actions as a prosecutor or to the Avery case in general. Just a wild character assassination.

Wow, the double standards on this one! /u/Minerva8918 , I'm personally waiting for your righteous scolding of TTMers using Kratz's victims to push their agenda in such a despicable way.


r/SuperMaM • • Feb 09 '17

Kratz's book bombshell: Avery DID send a letter asking him to represent him NSFW

19 Upvotes

Have'nt read a word of it yet, but of course I like to look at the pictures first.....

https://imgur.com/a/7ckOX

Offering him the chance because ... "you now the case" ..... and "so we can all get money together"

What was he talking about with Candy? He was trying to use her as a scapegoat, FFS? Shameless.

u/mickflynn40 , you are vindicated.


r/SuperMaM • • Feb 04 '17

peacepipe Things I’ve learnt about ‘Guilters’ and ‘Truthers’... NSFW

19 Upvotes

This will get downvoted into oblivion I’d expect - are we really all that different? In fact, we all have more in common than we probably think…

  • We’re all passionate about our beliefs.

  • We all want interesting and constructive dialogue.

  • There are absolute fucktards on both sides of the fence.

  • We all throw the most random ideas out there - some work, some are downright crazy.

  • There are people on both sides that won’t ever listen to the other sides argument/opinions.

  • Some of us are die-hard in our beliefs.

  • Some of us don’t question the evidence enough.

  • Some of us don’t think about the possibility that perhaps SA is innocent or guilty.

So why can’t we, just for a few hours of a few days - respectfully debate the facts instead of being us all being cunts to each other? It’s just a thought…


r/SuperMaM • • Feb 17 '17

Team Truther Unmasking NSFW

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/SuperMaM • • Apr 19 '17

chinscratch Why, oh why, is this still a question? NSFW

17 Upvotes

Truthers are still apparently claiming Avery was listed as a suspect on 11/3 and the Rav 4 was entered as evidence on 11/3. THIS HAS BEEN VERY THOROUGHLY DEBUNKED FOR MONTHS! Unfortunately I can't link to posts on other subs debunking it, but I know of at least two here because I wrote them:

https://www.reddit.com/r/SuperMaM/comments/541htk/steven_avery_was_listed_as_a_suspect_an_hour/

https://www.reddit.com/r/SuperMaM/comments/566cta/the_car_was_entered_into_evidence_on_113/

Why continue to spread misinformation? Because that's the only way to keep Avery looking innocent. Lie and ignore facts.


r/SuperMaM • • Mar 23 '17

Guilters must think truthers are idiots NSFW

17 Upvotes

"ooh we know something"

"woah, we so totally have a secret"

"i know it, and it will come out soon"

let me guess..

this big revelation will come on April 1st, 10 days from now...right?

jesus christ, show some originality.


r/SuperMaM • • Mar 08 '17

New records from Marinette County Sheriff's Dept - NOW ONLINE NSFW

17 Upvotes

A couple weeks ago, /u/Nexious gave me a list of documents from Marinette County Sheriff's Department that were listed on pages 2-3 in Kratz's correspondence regarding discovery. I didn't get everything I requested (which was listed the same way it was in the above correspondence), but there were are couple new records that we did not have before and a couple records that we already had but were not complete.


Written statements

Here are the statements referenced in the above report:


Other Marinette records


Updated records

We already had copies of Steven Avery's interviews from November 5th and 6th that were done by Detective O'Neill. Our previous records did not have sketches attached that Avery had done for those interviews.


Two transcripts from Brendan's trial

Nexious and I each grabbed some transcripts that were on Pacer, which are now available here.

I also sent in a request for the following documents from Brendan's Compilation of Record:

Document #Description
17Notice of Motion and Motion to Suppress Statements
19State's Memorandum in Response to Defendant's Motion to Suppress Statements
20Reply to State's Memorandum
26Order Denying Defendant's Motion to Suppress Statements
28Motion Regarding Withdrawal of Counsel
29Memorandum Regarding Withdrawal of Counsel
34Order Denying Defendant's Motion for Withdrawal of Counsel
38Notice of Alibi
42Motion for Withdrawal of Counsel
43Supplemental Affidavit of Michael O'Kelly
44Order Directing Counsel to Withdraw
63State's Motion in Limine Series I
67Notice of Intent and Motion to Admit Statements; Motion in Limine Series II

and the two exhibits from the 2010 Post-Conviction Hearing:

Exhibit #Description
61CV of Michael O'Kelly
231Polygraph charts dated 4.16.06

r/SuperMaM • • Mar 07 '17

Naming and Shaming (special dumbass liar edition) NSFW

17 Upvotes

Today's victim(s) is a special 2 for 1 with mickflynn39/40 as they are one in the same. 1 part dumbass, 2 parts liar.

I really didn't want to make this post but the dumbass has lied too much for me to give him a free pass. That and I have had many requests to put him in his place, and I will happily oblige. He could have "sorted" it out as he likes to put it in the comments but he chose to obfuscate, deny, and lie. I did give him a chance to make a proper abject apology to everyone for lying to them, he has exhausted his time to do that and forced my hand to make this post.

I'm just going to lay it out and you can decide for yourselves.


mickflynn40 posted this thread @ Sun Mar 5 18:23:26 2017 UTC - The Real Did You Know (part 298) Dassey not as thick as truthers would like to believe. In it he refers to "*my excellent hand writing analysis", but being that it was posted by mickflynn40, and we all know mickflynn39 did the infamous bogus hand writing analysis, I called him out on being in the wrong alt account and he deleted the thread immediately afterwards. Here is a screen shot before he deleted it. You'll see the one 1 comment which was mine, and that it was up for at least 4 minutes. Also notice it is using mickflynn39's stupid new numbering system.

mickflynn39 posted the exact same thread @ Sun Mar 5 18:29:21 2017 UTC - The Real Did You Know (part 298) Dassey not as dumb as truthers would like to believe. Keep in mind mickflynn40's was up for 4 minutes, so this was posted 2 minutes after it was deleted by mickflynn40. Exact same thread title save for "dumb" instead of "thick". In it he also refers to "my excellent hand writing analysis" which was the subject of my comment to his original deleted thread posted by mickflynn40. I promptly called him out again and he immediately denied and asked for evidence. Well dumbass, here it is.

I can't say it fairer than that.

He will probably deny it, lie, obfuscate and lie some more but the evidence is undeniable. He shut right up after he was presented with the indisputable evidence and has tried to buy him self 7-14 days to come up with some more lies to get out of it but I am not waiting that long to hear his stupid lies.

Mick, you are a dumbass liar. Just admit it, you've been caught. Get a proper abject apology sorted for the entire sub and maybe they will forget about this and you can try and save some face.

Get on with it will you you dumbass liar!


r/SuperMaM • • Feb 23 '17

What's the least extreme possible narrative in the framing conspiracy? NSFW

17 Upvotes

In /u/nexious' most recent book report, he states:

Kratz also devotes one chapter of six pages to describe what he dubs "The Vast, Fantastical Police Conspiracy" in which he sensationally and backhandedly presents the most extreme possible narrative in the framing conspiracy, under the pretense that Lenk and Colborn were exclusively responsible for every single act possibly including the murder itself.

Now, I haven't read Kratz's book, and maybe he's presenting a narrative involving EWE, aliens, and Lenk all converging on the Zipperer property, but what I'm interested in is hearing what Nexious & Co. think is the least extreme possible narrative in the framing conspiracy?

 

Now this isn't the first time that this question has been asked. Several months ago, /u/super_pickle asked truthers:

Is there any theory on how the frame job was pulled off that takes all the evidence into account? (this is my biggest question for truthers, been asking for 9 months to no avail)

More recently, I asked Nexious:

Can you detail a reasonable scenario where Steven could have been framed for the murder that takes into account all of the evidence?

As expected, he ducked the question, no matter how many times I asked.

 

Since Nexious isn't presenting a theory of his own, perhaps it's best to turn to /r/MakingaMurderer. If we look at the top posts of all-time on the sub, there is one theory near the top, titled "The most credible theory I have seen so far", with 2,580 points (96% upvoted). Here's a summary of the theory:

"By shear colossal luck, two completely independent frame jobs targeting one man, Steven Avery were shaping up into the perfect storm. On one front, from Lenk and Colborn regarding the RAV4, ....and on the other unconnected front by Scott Tadych and Bobby Dassey regarding the cremains of Theresa Halbach. One party wasn't aware of the other's involvements at any point during the days leading up to the official discovery of Halbach's RAV4 at the Avery Salvage Yard"

The theory also includes Ryan, Mike, and Pam, and seems quite extreme. But again, what theory doesn't?

 

So, if you can't present a reasonable (at least in your opinion) scenario for the frame-up yourself, and "the most credible theory" of Steven's innocence according to the MaM sub is indeed a vast, fantastical police conspiracy, can you really fault Kratz?


r/SuperMaM • • Feb 21 '17

The Real Housewives of Manitowoc County NSFW

Thumbnail
youtube.com
17 Upvotes

r/SuperMaM • • Jan 16 '17

On SA, Sociopathic Tendencies, and some better/deeper understanding on this issue NSFW

17 Upvotes

Got into an interesting chat this morning regarding SA, the cat burning, and the possibility of SA being a sociopath (or having sociopathic tendencies). I'd like to point some things out here that I think may clear the issue up (a little, hopefully), and maybe shed some light as to why we need to step back on making this assumption.

Let's look at two points specifically in which /u/Aydenzz highlights in this, Michael Griesbach and many others have pointed to as a sign of SA being a sociopath.

  1. Obsession with fire setting

  2. Cruelty to animals


Now, let's compare to what we know about SA's history related to these incidents. I'm going to credit /u/Aydenzz here for supplying quotes attributed to the fire setting.

Obsession with Fire Setting

A. Former girlfriend: He was so distraught over their break-up that he told her he was going to burn down her parents’ house while they were inside.

B: Unnamed Teen Relative : "He would tell me things like...if you don't do this, I'm gonna set your house on fire...there was a couple of times that he told us that, or told me, that if I didn't do something that he wanted me to do, that he would set our house on fire and that we would have nothing."

C. Jodi's Mom Jodi told her one time that Jodi and her daughter...had to lock themselves in the bathroom inside of Steven's trailer because they thought that Steven was pouring gas around the trailer to light it on fire.

D. Jodi "He told me once if I did leave him, that he'd burn down my mom's house with them and my daughter in it."

E) and of course, the cat burning incident. Many arguments were had here over who's idea it was, who poured the gasoline on it and who actually threw the cat in (and what happened after), but for brevity and just to make the point in general, we'll just say SA participated, enabled and facilitated the burning of the cat.

Now, this ties into the second point:

Cruelty to animals

Which, in this case, as far as we know, is actually animal--singular. We only know of this one incident of cruelty to an animal.

While some of these behaviours can be indicative of sociopathic tendencies or personality disorders, it should be noted that in order for someone to actually be diagnosed with these disorders, there has to be a repeat pattern of these destructive behaviours over quite a period of time. Typically this is an ongoing and invasive issue that, if not "caught" and dealt with, often increases or gets worse.


For a hypothetical, I'd like to put forward an example of an individual that would definitely raise some red flags for sociopathic tendencies and possible Antisocial Personality Disorder (which I'll likely refer to as APD in future).

Let's say...I started playing with matches at a very young age, maybe 7 or 8. I began just by igniting them and watching them burn down. As I became older and more experienced with using matches, I began burning off loose threads, the bottoms of my socks, or other things of such nature. By the time I was 13, I began lighting small fires behind my house, usually just loose or scrap paper. At 15, I was lighting public garbage cans on fire, starting forest fires, or (and someone I know actually did this, thank god no one was harmed) flicking lit matches onto the roof of a local/community gazebo and burning it down.

I also had developed an interest in animals, specifically death and dissection, and the workings of internal organs at a very young age. I started dropping frogs down a sewer when I was 7 years old to see what would happen when they hit the bottom. I eventually moved on to larger animals, injuring birds or other small animals like squirrels and rabbits. In my adolescent and teenage years, I began dissecting and killing stray animals, such as cats and dogs (see: Jeffrey Dahmer). This pattern of behaviour continues into adulthood.

The key difference here, and what I've stated, makes there a distinct possibility that someone like this could fit some of the criteria for sociopathic issues/or APD, or at least set up some red flags for these kinds of issues, is that these things would be consistent over several years, and a repeating and increasingly destructive pattern of behaviour. This is one of the most important and key criteria for these issues.

Now, there are several other criteria for something like APD, some of which I'm sure many of you could argue SA fits based on statements of others and your own perceptions of him. I get that. However, none of us (I don't think) actually know SA, have seen and interacted with him on a daily basis, or are in a position to diagnose him or assess him as having any such disorder, and as such, should probably save the diagnosing for someone who can or does actually have the ability to do so.

If this is a topic that interests you, or you'd like to see some more on APD, you can look over this document that provides the criteria (old and revised) for APD and other personality disorders. It should be noted, however, that the DSM is not a perfect tool, and is most often used as a framework for additional and follow-up testing, as many Mental Health professionals agree the DSM is not flawless.

To conclude: SA may or may not be a sociopath, but none of us are in any position to say so or not, and should leave the diagnosing to actual Mental Health professionals, not Reddit Psychologists (myself included). I merely wanted to provide a bit more insight and information on this topic to create a better understanding of these issues and to highlight that diagnosing someone with anything is not easy (and for a reason, because these kinds of mental health issues are pretty serious).

[Note: I'm going to be floating on and off Reddit, so if you have any further comments or questions/whatever, I'll try and get back to you ASAP, but please don't take my delayed response as me being a horrible, evading bitch lol!]

Edit: formatting and such. This is my most lengthy post ever, so I'm sorry if it's not formatted super well.


r/SuperMaM • • Nov 14 '16

One down, one to go NSFW

17 Upvotes

Brendan Dassey to be released on bond

Deal with it

last page on imgur

ETA

This cunt just got involved


r/SuperMaM • • Apr 14 '17

New Rules NSFW

16 Upvotes

Some heavy news.

Some behaviour has to stop. We're disturbing the force.

From now on:

  • no more username tagging

  • no more linking to other subs

If you show a screenshot, names must be wiped out.

And, as well as no tagging, there cannot be abuse targeted at individual users.

It's been getting too wild. Action had to be made.

These rules are now here to stay.

Fank you and have a chocolatey day.


r/SuperMaM • • Mar 17 '17

Lifting the foghaze surrounding Dr. Ken Bennett and the Female Human Ilium Bone cited in the Nov 15 Criminal Complaint. NSFW

16 Upvotes

Dr. Ken Bennett and the Human Female Illium Bones

Did Dr. Ken Bennett declare bones from the quarry under evidence tag 8675 to be human female bones?

This claim comes from u/foghaze. You can read the original post from MAM in the link below.

https://www.reddit.com/r/MakingaMurderer/comments/4afx1q/the_bone_that_was_verified_to_be_from_human/d10so3a/?context=3

First, The Criminal Complaint in Question

Dr. Ken Bennet is quoted as determining that an illium bone he analysed came from that of a human female. This appears in the Nov. 15th Criminal Complaint against Avery which you can see here:

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Search-Warrant-File.pdf#page=25

Here's what the small section in the Criminal Complaint tells us.

  • The bones were transported by DCI agent Freymiller

  • Bennett identified the bones as being human in nature

  • Bennet determined based on the characterisics of the "ilium" bone, the bones are from an adult human female.

There is no mention of where the bone Dr. Bennett was looking at came from, nor any reference to an evidence tag in the Criminal Complaint.

The Claim.

u/foghaze claimed:

The only problem is there are no ilium bones noted by Eisenberg in evidence at the burn pit on Steven's property. The only thing that even resembles an Ilium is at the quarry

Ilium Bones at the Quarry, Eisenberg's Testimony

This lovely picture details the ilium bone for those of us who aren't anthropologists and will be helpful later when reviewing Eisenberg's testimony. It is essentially your "hip bone".

On page 167 of the transcript for Feb 28 2007, Strang asks Eisenberg about bones she wasn't sure were human or not

On page 169 Strang specifically asks about "the superior aspect of an iliac blade". Eisenberg begins demonstrating using a skeleton diagram on the ELMO. She explains the pelvis is made up of 3 bones. Two hip bones on each side called iliac crests and then the "tail bone" or sacrum".

Strang then asks about a bone "referred to as the sacral iliac articulation" which Eisenberg corrects him on and tells him is where the two bones, sacrum and iliac crest meet. You can see this clearly labeled on the diagram I provided earlier as "Sacro-iliac joint".

Eisenberg cannot confirm that these are human to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty.

The next day on March 1st, Strang adds the contextual information about where these two fragments were found in the quarry and under 8675 (These two being fragments of "the superior aspect of an iliac blade" and the other "referred to as the sacral iliac articulation").

Eisenberg references back to the iliac crest she was discussing yesterday and states it was part of evidence tag 8675.

It is also worth pointing out at this point that it is Strang who calls them "the quarry pile".Here is where the "quarry pile" in question was located.

So Foghaze claims that nothing that resembles an ilium was found anywhere besides the quarry. What does Eisenberg say?

Eisenberg is never asked whether any other "ilium" bone fragments were found in other evidence tags, though her exhibit 400 diagram quoting "pelvis" clearly suggests there may have been.

Eisenberg's diagram for tag 8318 (items sifted from the burn pit), Exhibit 400, indicates that there were bone fragments from the Pelvis found in that collection of fragments.

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Exhibit-400-Graphic-Showing-Bones-Found-in-Burn-Pit.jpg

u/foghaze is correct that this diagram does not specify the "ilium" just the "pelvis" but the "ilium" is part of the pelvis. So clearly, some part of the pelvis was found at 8318, could the pelvis fragments have been part of the "ilium"? I would suggest it is definitely possible, maybe even likely. Eisenberg testifies that there are three bones in the Pelvis, two of which could be considered "ilium", so I'd give it a 66% chance on the information we have that the Pelvis bone in 8318 was part of the "ilium".

Also worth mentioning is that Eisenberg testifies that a fragment from nearly every bone below the neck was found in the burn pit, which would also suggest fragments of the Pelvis/ilium.

So What Bones Were Sent To Dr. Bennett to analyse?

As stated at the beginning, the Criminal Complaint from Nov. 15th does not specify where the "ilium" bone that Dr. Bennett declared as Human Female came from.

What we do know about the Criminal Complaint is that in the paragraph immediately before the one containing Dr. Bennett's analysis details that " on November 8, 2005 while continuing to execute the search warrant of the property located near the residence of Steven Avery located at 21932 Avery Road in the Town of Gibson, Manitowoc County, Wisconsin, officers located bone fragments and teeth in a fire pit area located approximately 20 yards south of a detached garage that is located next to the residence of Steven Avery." There is no mention of the quarry, and this is a criminal complaint for Steven's arrest for homicide in the first degree so why would the people writing this include information about analysis on bones from a property not connected to Steven? After detailing Dr. Bennett's analysis and Dr. Eisenberg's analysis, the Criminal Complaint further supports the idea that the bones Dr. Bennett reviewed by continuing to refer to items gathered from the Avery Burnpit such as the teeth fragments review by Dr. Simley.

If this criminal complaint was looked at in isolation you would assume the ilium bone fragments Dr. Bennett reviewed came from the aforementioned burn pit.

In fact this was the debate I had yesterday on SuperMAM with u/chromeomykiss .

I looked at u/chromeomykiss ' profile and found this comment and thread from TTM discussing the bones received by Dr. Bennett.

Imagine the shock I had when I saw that chrome and foghaze were going back and forth on the bones and foghaze was still perpetuating this idea that the only ilium bones were found in the quarry 8675 tag and that " Eisenberg does not report finding this bone at all. ". Well, we know she reports finding bone fragment(s) from the "pelvis" in 8318 from the burn pit and we know that the pelvis is composed of 3 bones, per Eisenberg's testimony, and that 2 of those three pelvis bones are what is considered "ilium" bones. So while technically no "ilium" bone is specifically reported I don't recall seeing Eisenberg saying that the only "ilium" bones were found under the 8675 tag.

But anyway, u/chromeomykiss linked to Eisenberg's testimony from the preliminary hearing.

On page 117 Eisenberg details the box of fragments that she received, including a plastic bag of bone fragments separated by Dr. Ken Bennett

On page 119 Eisenberg details the types human bone fragments she found inside the box that had previously been reviewed by Dr. Bennett. These include "dental structures, which may have represented fragments of jawbone and/or tooth structures", Eisenberg ends the evening on Nov 10th with several bags "representing human bone and bone from different areas of the body"

Drumroll please

On page 130 (Of Eisenberg's testimony on Feb 28th at the actual trial) Eisenberg identifies the box she received, photgraphed in Exhibit 383 (below), as being "under Calumet County Sheriff's Office Tag 8318"

Here's a photo of the box containing tag 8318, also containing the plastic bag of bone fragments declared human by Dr. Ken Bennett.

So, hold on. Let's review what we've learned.

  • Dr. Bennett reviewed a box of bones

  • Dr. Bennet placed some bones he suspected to be human into a clear plastic bag.

  • That bag was placed back into the box and sealed with evidence tape upon which it was taken to Eisenberg's office on Nov 9th.

  • Inside that box, alongside the bag of human bone fragments identified by Dr. Ken Bennet, were multiple human bones including jaw structures identified by Dr. Eisenberg on Nov. 10th.

  • Eisenberg specifies that "additional remains that had been collected by the Division of Crminal Investigation on the same property, from which the original box of fragments came."

  • Those bones that Eisenberg reviewed on November 10th are testified by Eisenberg to have come from an adult female.

  • Eisenberg testifies that the box of bones she received on November 9th 2005 came from Calumet County Tag 8318, this is the same box that Dr. Bennet reviewed in his analysis before sending it to Eisenberg.

Conclusion

So, the same box of bones that Dr. Bennett looked at is what was taken to Dr. Eisenberg. As far as I can tell, those bones ALL came from tag 8318. We know there were pelvis bones in tag 8318. I'm going to suggest that the ilium bone that Dr. Ken Bennett reviewed and declared human female is part of the pelvis bone fragments from 8318.

Even u/chromeomykiss doesn't seem to disagree with the proposed chain of custody:

So the chain of custody appears to be Freymiller to Dr. Bennett who examines, ID's human bones, separates out into plastic bag, then reseals and returns to Freymiller who then brings to Dr. E. office to be signed for by her assistant and Freymiller leaves the voicemail with Dr. E as well. Dr. Bennett does then file a 2-page report on 11/10/05 which is the day that Dr. E begins her exam on the bones.

Caso Page 180 indicates that tag 8318 was taken to the WI State Crime Lab on 11/09/2005.

There is no mention 8675 going to the WI State Crime Lab. A Ctrl + F for '8675' will first bring up page 407 and a supplemental report on January 17 2006. Describing 8675 as the contents of a debris pile. Before page 407 of the CASO, a search for "debris pile" will bring you to page 402, detailing the 5 gallon buckets containing the debris piles. At some point, 8675 appears to have come from one of these debris piles, or at least that's what I can assume.

If it didn't come from one of the debris piles listed on CASO page 402, then I suspect it was collected on either the 10th/11th/12th of November (Before Dr. Bennet could have seen it on November 9th and also prior to Eisenberg receiving that same box Nov. 10th) as that appears to be when they were at the "county quarry" according to Sippel on Page 203 of the CASO.

So, u/foghaze and u/chromemykiss , if you want to continue claiming that the bones Dr. Ken Bennett called human female came from 8675 then I ask you to please identify when 8675 was taken to Dr. Bennett. Using the CASO, I can at least identify when tag 8675 was taken to Eisenberg, and that it did not come from Dr. Bennett in January 2006 but via Deputy Hawkins.

According to the CASO pg 404, it would appear that Eisenberg only came into contact with tag 8675 on January 17th 2006, 2 months after she reviewed the box of bones that came from Dr. Bennett.

The next time that tag 8675 appears in the CASO is December 11th 2006, a whole 10 months later, when they are being retrieved back from Dr. Eisenberg

So, when did Dr. Bennett look at 8675?

TL;DR The bone fragments that Dr. Ken Bennett states are the ilium from a Human Female came from tag 8318, the burn pit, as testified to by Dr. Leslie Eisenberg. There is nothing supporting the conclusion that Dr. Bennett lied in the Criminal Complaint. There were other pelvis bone fragments that could have been declared human from the 8318 tag. u/foghaze jumped to a conclusion instead of doing the proper investigation once again.