r/SubredditReviews • • Oct 01 '13

/r/Minimalism: Less clutter, more space (Medium 70k+)

13 Upvotes

Hello. Before I begin, I apologize for nothing. I can't speak for /u/appropriate-username, but I can speak for myself - I forgot about this subreddit and knew that I need to do something. So, without further ado, we shall look in and see if /r/Minimalism is a subredit you should check out.


/r/minimalism

Top post: All I need...

Submissions

Minimalism is very subjective. People have different opinions on what their ideal minimalist life style is. You may believe it could really cause downvotes, but generally they all have one type of minimalism in mind: clutter free.

Positive

Low repost count.

Good rule following.

Negative

Could be more posts (the subreddit isn't that big, though)

All in all, the submissions are very good. They're pretty much all positives, and you can't really change anything about the posts and frequency. It's not a huge subreddit, but there are enough posts to it.

RATING: 9/10


COMMUNITY

What makes or breaks a good subreddit? A good community. You must need a good community to actually be successful - whether it's a city, country, or what, a good community is needed. How do they feel about themselves?

Positives

Lack of circlejerking ("It has gotten a lot better!" -nexe).

Friendly most of the time.

Negatives

Do not frequently report spam.

Not the friendliest subreddit (" this is a community of strange people" -nexe).

In general, it is okay. Not the greatest, certainly can use improvements. Then again, this was posted almost two months ago (Aug 6 2013), so it could have changed.

RATING: 7/10


MODERATION

Mods are what keep the subreddit going. They're just overseers, to watch how things are doing. There are 2 (3, if you count AutoMod) moderators on the subreddit. It's a medium sized subreddit, so with only having 2 mods (and AutoMod) and not have much trouble is impressive.

Positives

Rules aren't harsh.

"Seems like they believe in the true Reddit spirit of letting the hivemind take care of most things, which is great." -nexe.

Friendly.

Negatives

"I never see any posts against the rules, but I never hear of them deleting them either." -BermudaCake (can be taken both ways)

So in actuality...the mods are great. Only two real mods on the subreddit, and they have great support from the community. It's definitely something to respect.

RATING: 9.5/10


OVERALL: 8.5/10. The subreddit is a very nice subreddit if you are willing to put up with how subjective minimalism is. If you live the minimalist lifestyle and aren't subscribed, it's something to check out, at least. My name is /u/woflcopter, and thank you for reading.


r/SubredditReviews • • Dec 26 '21

Turbocourses - My Positive experience with this website.

12 Upvotes

I sign up to reddit just to say few good words on turbocourses. I had great experience buying courses from them.

Subscription:

it costs only $30 lifetime experience(never expire)

Courses

Have more than 3k courses is forever useful ad they update more courses every month

Value

really good value saved me money and I am happy from them.

Link: turbocourses.net


r/SubredditReviews • • Jun 19 '14

/r/NoStupidQuestions: stupid questions? What are those? [Medium (40k+)]

8 Upvotes

It's been about 5 months since the last subreddit review and I'm finally back out of hiatus. I can't speak for any of the other mods but I plan on posting about 2-3 times a month (more or less). A big problem is the lack of support from some subreddits and that's a big fear actually getting very few responses.


/r/NoStupidQuestions

Top post: What is the best strategy to use to win a game of Monopoly?

Submissions:

The posts on NSQ are generally pretty creative. Usually some people might be like "huh, why didn't I think of this" or "wow this is so easy to understand." But generally there is going to be at least a few posts there that might help some people understand some things.

  1. "The only things I can think of that would improve the sub would be a requirement for sources on more professional topics ( history, science, anything someone might aquire a degree in. Another suggestion is to add an FAQ, I don't think this sub has an excess of repeated questions, but it couldn't hurt to implement it none the less." -nafoozie.

  2. "Search function before posting"/"No repeat questions" should include something about at least a cursory googling. All too often, I can paste the exact topic question into the engine and the answer is literally the first hit. At least try on your own, and then ask here for further clarification." -PocketBuckle

  3. "One of my favorite pre-bed hobbies is to read through todays questions. Sometimes they give a chuckle, sometimes I catch myself saying "Oh come on, how can you not know this?". But most of the time, I find questions to which I don't have the answers, or things I never even thought about, and that drives me into the thread to see the answers." -Qieth

NSQ has some solid posts from my personal experience. A lot of the time the posts are actually quite interesting. Don't take the word of some commenters, go take a look for yourself!

8/10


Community:

The community is one of the biggest parts about a community. A hostile community ruins subreddits (not naming names). Luckily, NSQ is far from a hostile community and is very welcoming. A lot of people on the subreddit know a lot of things in one way or another. " I am often surprised at how quickly we can get a number of answers going on some of the weirder questions we get."

  1. "Very few posts go unanswered, and many times, people post replies very quickly. My last question was answered very clearly within 10 minutes, and that sparked another question to the person answering, from another user that was reading his reply." -Qieth

  2. "I would also like to have some backup on cracking down on joke answers. Most of the time, it's not an issue, but occasionally, someone will say something jokey or karmawhore-y and not actually attempt to answer the question, and it will end up the top post, even beating out researched responses that actually offer an answer." -PocketBuckle

The community, from my experience, has been very good at getting quick answers and answers easy to understand. Very friendly and it can be a lot of fun for some (very few) arguments and discussions.

9/10


Moderation:

There are good mods and there are bad mods. Some subreddits have a dozen, some have a handful. If the community misbehaves, mods always step in the way to prevent much from happening. Or at least, many bad things happening. Sadly we didn't get many responses to this category.

  1. "Speaking as a casual mod here - we don't see a lot of trash, but there is always the occasional troll. We have a lot of active mods though, so these things doesn't stay up for very long." -Qieth

From my experience on the subreddits, mods rarely step up to prevent anything, because they're so well-behaved already. Can't really talk about how well mods do their jobs, but with the lack of trolls they seem to be pretty good at what they do. Whether it's the mods or community, though, is hard to tell.

8.5/10


Overall:

9

/r/NoStupidQuestions is a subreddit not like many, and that's a great thing. It's not as complex as /r/explainlikeimfive and it's not like /r/changemyview. It's more laid back and generally it hits a lot of the good points that subredits should hit. And that's why it earned a 9/10.

Relevant subreddits: /r/OutOfTheLoop, /r/explainlikeimfive, /r/TooAfraidToAsk

A big thanks to /u/PocketBuckle, /u/Qieth, and all the other mods for letting me post!

Full thread


r/SubredditReviews • • Jul 07 '20

I want to know how the world sees r/hobbydrama!

7 Upvotes

r/hobbydrama seems to be bit of a hidden gem to me! It's a subreddit where people detail the crazy, specific dramas going on in their hobby - ones that the rest of the world are likely blind to. What do you think of the stories on there?


r/SubredditReviews • • Oct 14 '17

INDICOIN: Blockchain redefining Social Service

7 Upvotes

Join our subreddit to find about INDICOIN.

IndiCoin is an autonomous cryptocurrency and a social service platform built on top of Ethereum Blockchain that enables users to provide social proof to the blockchain community through a decentralized and transparent voting process thereby incentivizing and encouraging the user to create an inclusive community of people who are incentivized to do social tasks. it is the first ever social platform where people can not only contribute but also validate through any kind of content posted anonymously from anywhere, anytime and also earn through it.

IndiCoin is developed to address the broken social sector. We are building a DApp where one can share any proof of work such as live videos, images, illegal document leak, e-way bills for which our DApp will provide full anonymity and in exchange provide Indi tokens. Along with that, we'll be addressing poverty, child labor, proper sanitation, education, bringing drinking water accessible to everyone and million other test cases. IndiCoin token sale would be the first ever Token Sale/ICO officially covering India.

Our mission is to create awareness among 1.2 billion unaware Indians about cryptocurrency and blockchain ecosystem also create a sense of social accountability among individuals.

Its ICO is LIVE! To take part, visit website

Also, give your suggestions and reviews about us.


r/SubredditReviews • • Jul 28 '13

/r/changemyview: A place to persuade you. [Medium (45k+)]

7 Upvotes

/r/changemyview

Top submission: I believe the government should be allowed to view my e-mails, tap my phone calls, and view my web history for national security concerns. CMV

Submissions:

As far as /r/changemyview's opinions on submissions go, I'd say most submissions on the page seem fairly appropriate and interesting. Some bad things are (in no order):

  1. OP doesn't support their view. They say it and want their view changed without defending it.

  2. Same questions are asked sometimes.

  3. Some days the submissions can be slow, but no one can do much about it.

  4. Submissions aren't really interesting most of the time.

Yet there are positive things:

  1. Conversations in the comments are really really interesting most of the time (especially on front page posts).

  2. Almost all posts are on topic (hard not to)

  3. Almost all posts are appropriate.

  4. "New is across the broad [sic] more interesting." - monkyyy

  5. "Most submissions are thought provoking, even if unoriginal at times." - skaterfan93

Overall, it seems like they really like the submissions and they think that as far as submission quality and originality goes, it's alright. Frankly, I see the same posts a lot, but that's just me. I only go on /r/changemyview every now and then.

RATING: 8/10


COMMUNITY

Bad things:

  1. Even though it is an open minded subreddit, there is still some unnecessary downvoting.

  2. "Far from being open minded, I've seen evidence of posters who would rather insult than offer meaningful commentary." - Independent

Good things:

  1. There are a lot of common names on the subreddit that people notice

  2. "there are some ill-deserved downvotes, but mostly downvotes are used against trolls/posts that don't follow rules/arguments that don't make sense or are downright false." - Joined_Today

  3. Rarely any puns/off topic comments.

Honestly, it seems like the community at /r/changemyview is one to be respected. Frequent commentors, enough discussion in the comments, and a fair amount of people who downvote things that are against the rules. Unfortunately, there are still some comments and actions by the community that take away the 1 point from perfect.

RATING: 9/10


MODERATION

Bad things:

To be honest, I haven't noticed anything that the mods do that I (or the community), would say would be bad.

Good things:

  1. "I think the mods are doing a damn good job here. This is probably one of the most well run subreddits I've seen," - mombo101

  2. Remove "hostile comments" in less than 5 minutes once it was reported.

  3. Good CSS

  4. Ban trolls

RATING: 10/10


OVERALL: 9/10 I think that /r/changemyview will become a default subreddit, or at least a subreddit that people will respect in the future. Great community, great moderation, and great submission quality. I've been on /r/changemyview since it had 20k subs, and seeing it grow into something like this is truly amazing.

Possible alternatives: /r/gue (has been rather inactive, though), and /r/PoliticalDiscussion (pretty active).


Hey /r/subredditreviews , I'm a new mod on here and I plan on making a review once a week or so.


r/SubredditReviews • • Jan 17 '17

/r/raisedbynarcissists: more like run by narcissists

6 Upvotes

This subreddit is for vulnerable people who have suffered parental narcissistic abuse therefore, sensitivity of replies is compulsory there. I'v been posting on this sub for a while now for support when dealing with current and past issues of my narcissistic family. Had the odd idiot who doesn't understand the forum rules post something which does not follow community guidance and it's been removed as requested.

However, today I posted the post was nothing out of the ordinary from what i'v posted also it was extremely similar to a post i'v done before. Well I must of hit a sore spot of a moderator and the turmoil of vile verbal abuse in my "block" report was substantial.

Another redditor saw this and commented on the disgrace of the moderation team were. This comment of support was deleted and I was openly accused by the moderator in question for having a "double account". Apparently they requested further information from Reddit wonder if she will appologise when she finds out it actually was not.

The key points of narcissism are

Verbal abuse Gaslighting False accusations Gaining the support of others to help with the abuse Threats

All of the above tactics were present in the posts from the moderator. I was informed by my therapist to not use these forums as some victims become narcissist and moderating boards for support are a big interest to these types of individuals as they have the chance to gain power and control over vulnerable individuals. I think I'll be listening to my therapist more now.

I decided to look into other posts this mod had made and they were all harsh abrupt threats. Not quite as bad as the one she'd felt the need to send me but they were all basically unsupportive and insensitive.

Anyway on the whole the mods are horrendous but there were some very nice redditors who were in fact victims and i'v made a couple of good friends and now a new one from the girl (my double) who supported me against the mods all of which watched the drama unfold and will not be returning. We have each other to help now without worry of random abuse.

My advice to anyone is never use forums like this when you're feeling especially upset or vulnerable. Seek medical help or therapy first a blow like this to someone in a bad place is not what you need and could make issues worse. I was told by a support worker they shouldn't really be set up if the mods aren't correctly trained however it is difficult for them supporting establishments to moderate the whole internet.


r/SubredditReviews • • Feb 12 '26

Mod Announcement New Top Mod & Reopening

5 Upvotes

Hello to all that read this.

I've found this subreddit after looking for a way to review and share my thoughts about subreddits where I experienced what it means to contact the mod team of said subreddit.

I found r/SubredditReviews, though I was disappointed when I saw that this sub had been abandoned.

I requested to take over as the new top mod through r/redditrequest. That request was approved minutes before I created this post.

A bit about myself: I'm Florian, here on Reddit u/FlorianFlash and I am currently the top mod of r/discordhelp which is the main and largest subreddit I manage. My goal is it to to keep everything fair and to resolve matters with words rather than actions.

Feel free to leave me questions or other stuff down below, I'll try to read and/or answer everything.

Best regards, u/FlorianFlash


r/SubredditReviews • • May 11 '21

SR: r/Reddit_Island

5 Upvotes

Hello everybody, I am u/Kerviearon25 of Reddit and today we're going to review one of the most up-and-coming subreddits: r/Reddit_Island.

But first off, what is r/Reddit_Island**?**

r/Reddit_Island is a movement established on May 1, 2021 because of a meme explaining how Redditors could buy an island if they wanted to.

r/Reddit_Island can also be considered the modern successor to r/redditisland, a similar attempt in 2011 which failed due to inactivity.

Alright, now what are the positive aspects of the subreddit?

First off, it manages to unite Redditors together on one goal: an island/town.

The subreddit shows that Reddit could unite to ultimately reach a goal they want, whether it's crashing the stock market or getting a pedophile enabler admin fired, Reddit can do that.

Emphasis on COULD.

Okay, there's the positives, what about the negatives?

There is negative aspects about Reddit_Island. And that is Reddit itself.

You see, when r/redditisland came into birth, Reddit was different back then. There was a sense of community and that would result in a far more serious project.. if it hadn't been inactive.

Unfortunately, when you come to r/Reddit_Island, you see memes and conflicting ideas, people supporting a town, people supporting an island.

There is no sign of actual planning or suggestions; it's all just memes.

And it's also filled with the usual "Reddit" circlejerk: "tiktok bad. keanu reeves good", etc.

And there's also a problem with organization and centralization; the moderators ("board members") are not really organized and don't really communicate to the public well.

And one of the moderators are as toxic as can be: a former subreddit moderator was described as a toxic no-lifer troll constantly hindering progress and silencing those who think the project will fall.

As of now, they have been resigned/retired/fired from the team and is currently trying to make their own separate movement akin to the goals of Reddit Island... but I don't think I can see any progress other than trying to contact Elon Musk. I will not mention the movement here.

So what's the final conclusion?

r/Reddit_Island has a lot of potential, but it is hindered by the current Reddit community's circlejerks and the lack of organization within the moderators as well.

Will it succeed? No one knows.

-- u/Kerviearon25


r/SubredditReviews • • Nov 30 '19

[long-ish Review] r/EntitledParents

5 Upvotes

What I Rate The Subreddit:

Out of 5 stars, I give it a 0.5. Below is why. (It May sound like a rant! But it’s not, so don’t be rude about that please).

To Start:

This subreddit, it tells great stories. Sure some may be real and some may be utter chaos and fake.

Moderators:

They have nice moderators and not so nice ones — as to be expected. But, the not so nice ones are like — well can be entitled — over the top rude. Also, they side with one person and with one story. The non-victim’s story.

Ex: I was just commenting on this old post because it had a cliffhanger and the person said that if we wanted to know the rest then to comment below and they will message you privately. (I did not expect a reply from the OP due to the post being months or years old). Then, this guy replies to my comment and goes off about how I can’t comment that. Also, there was some foul language involved, and some slashing and shamming. Also, more than just that. So, I reported the guy and told him that I reported him for xx (I listed the reasons) and I told him to please leave me alone. I also added a “have a nice day, evening, or night!”. Then, he said he reported me for false (yes, he said false) things such as I was the one calling him all the names and shaming him — when I wasn’t. So, I was like, in my mind, “ok, I’ll just notify the moderators my side of the story and hope they don’t take the false side.” So I did that. They completely shut me down, banned me from commenting and posting. I gave it 2 months, to let them cool off and think it through more.

Sidebar~ You can say that I’m ranting, that I’m just a mad xxx, but I’m not. I’m cool with it now, since it’s legit been more than 6 months. Maybe a year and 2 months?. I’m not going to have any of the “you are just ranting and are mad” stuff, so please do not comment it. Thanks!

I messaged them, a nice lady said she’d look into it. Never did, never got back to me. So, I am still banned and I got no clue when they will unban me.

Also, she said to just continue getting my karma and account up — age and karma. Then she’ll see. So, I have been doing that.

As you can see, from clicking on my profile and seeing, that I have indeed been getting it up.


That’s all. And that’s the reason why I give it a 0.5.


r/SubredditReviews • • Jun 23 '14

/r/getdisciplined: hey, you, stop that and do something! [big (90k+)]

5 Upvotes

/r/getdisciplined

Top post: I just don't care about myself.


Submissions:

You see a lot of the same stuff on the subreddit but with different answers. Everyone there is trying to change or to try to be helpful into changing someone.

  1. "If you submit content here, it will be read. There is a small group of people who try and stay pretty active and responsive. Be ready for a little dose of honesty if you're looking for someone to help you figure out getting disciplined." -Tyryneasaure

  2. "In the same manner that dumb questions receive dumb answers, serious questions receive serious answers. Subscribers who want to impeove their own life through pursuing discipline, often strive towards that seriously." -PeaceH

As you can tell by not only going to the subreddit and looking at the posts, but to actually check out the comments, you can tell that the submissions are usually people looking for help and getting help. A lot of the posts are about the same, with people just generally getting out of laziness.

9/10


Community:

Without the community, the subreddit falls.

  1. "I would like to see more community interaction, possibly team challenges or community goals." -EdmondDantes_

  2. "It seems the topics fall in the same categories and don't really provide insight. It takes more than a to do list and calorie counter sometimes." -rnmarks

  3. "If i could compare it to a workforce, i'd say there are a lot of engineers here, but instead of a lot of quiet, hard working people trying to figure out schematics, mechanics and configurations, we are all just trying to figure out how to live our lives in an optimal and individual method." -Tyryneasaure

The community, while looking to be great, actually seems pretty one-sided and thus kind of bland and seeming to be all-knowing by the second quote.

7/10


Moderation:

The mods play a huge role in the sanity and control of the subreddit. Sadly, the moderation bit is always usually left out and very bare in comparison to community and submissions.

  1. "Under 'Other Subreddits' I would suggest a methods category with subs such as /r/TrackmyPomodoros and /r/theXeffect which are pretty specific." -YWEYAWYWAYAS

It's hard to find what the users think about the moderation. In almost every subreddit, the other categories are commented on more often than the moderation category. We are sure that the mods usually do and help against trolls, but with no real data or proof it's hard to tell. It gets our complimentary, NEI mark.

7/10


Overall:

7/10

While the submissions got a good start in the review, the others had to fall and couldn't keep up and support its high mark.

Relevant subreddits: /r/GetMotivated, /r/Fitness, /r/NoFap

Full thread


r/SubredditReviews • • May 12 '21

Please Review my Subreddit!

4 Upvotes

r/SubredditReviews • • Mar 05 '17

R/uncensorednews is just a censored news stream from Breitbart to promote their racist, pro-Trump agenda

4 Upvotes

I got banned from r/uncensorednews for leaving a comment that only said "via Breitbart is all I need to know" which seemed like a pretty harsh response. Then today I see another article that seemed outrageous, and guess where it was from...Breitbart.

I'm pretty sure r/uncensorednews is just a new sub for r/the_donald to promote their "all cucks are fags; all hail emperor Trump", ignored propaganda.


r/SubredditReviews • • Dec 05 '16

PSA: Anyone can post now, new sidebar, new rules

4 Upvotes

Hi guys

I know this place has been dead for around a year now but I think it is a phenomenal idea that can be put to good use. You'll notice the sidebar has been updated with what we're about now.

The tl;dr to the changes are

  • Anyone can post now

  • Users can submit their subs for review

  • Users can submite their reviews for any sub

Basically, mods can post their subs here and then we as a community can review them, and tell them how they can improve. We still have the old system too, however, so feel free to submit your review for any sub you want.

I'm still expecting serious discussion and well thought out comments and submissions. Low effort and non-constructive pieces will be removed with no warning, so put some time into your reviews.

Hope everyone's having a nice December, and happy reviewing.


r/SubredditReviews • • Dec 05 '21

r/CarsandbikesIndia is corrupt.

3 Upvotes

r/carsandbikesIndia has a very corrupt mod team. I was just posting and the moderators ban me and tell me to get some help. Here are some links to help you.

Invalid bans be like

the only doctor here is your mum?

Cheers, u/Stroov. You've just lost your subreddit.


r/SubredditReviews • • May 28 '20

r/DannyBoyle is a subreddit dedicated to the director of Trainspotting, The Beach, 28 Days Later, Slumdog Millionaire, 127 Hours, Steve Jobs and Yesterday fame.

3 Upvotes

Brand new. New to modding and creating subs. Huge movie need. Tell me what to do better


r/SubredditReviews • • Dec 07 '19

A subreddit with a more modern approach to presenting finance topics. A millennial subreddit you could say. I hope to make Finance more exciting.

3 Upvotes

r/SubredditReviews • • Nov 11 '18

Politics: It's not just for breakfast.

3 Upvotes

The Politics subreddit is very useful for finding news. That is one reason why it is as popular as it is. The views today are generally from the left but that has not always been true. In general the moderation is not biased. It tries to be fair but it appears to be taxed and strained.

As a News and Commentary Index

Plusses: This is a primary reason that the sub is absolutely spectacular, especially in comparison to any news service or news search service on the Internet. If some one goes to news.google.com or yahoo news (but to a lesser degree the AP Wire), what they see are the headlines that are chosen by a machine learning algorithm that spots popular headlines. The range of subjects will be quite narrow, often only involving a few people or incidents. If there is a crime in city X this will be all over the regular news index.

Compare that with /r/politics where from 200 to 1500 people are searching for articles. That's 10 to 20 times more variety than what can be found by searching an ML driven news service.

Plus while the sub tends toward progressive or liberal there are conservatives who consistently post from conservative sources. Hint: I watch the "New" Queue most of the time which gives the widest variety. The "Hot" queue will be liberal. The "Controversial" queue will be conservative.

Minus's: Only white listed sources are allowed. That means "small" news organizations are left out and news services that the moderators are sparring with are left out. For how long? Who knows. No one.

Commentary

/r/politics are filled with good commentators and commenting can be fun. However, it is easy to be personally attacked. Remember that sarcasm can not be guaranteed to be understood - so when feeling like being sarcastic be sure to use /s. The sub has extensive rules to protect people from attack.

But there is of course no protection from down-voting. And one of the drawbacks for conservatives, currently, is they will be down-voted due to the sheer number of progressives. If someone doesn't have enough karma Reddit will slow down their Internet speed to 8 minutes per message. A drag for sure.

Moderation

Some peoples experience is that moderators are biased toward the dominant users who at this point are on the left. I don't agree. I've been penalized along with "the right." If anything there is a "built in" bias against users who have been there the longest and I don't think the moderators realize this. What I do think is that the moderators are probably overworked. They could clarify and improve the rules and make them easier for people to understand and follow.

Rules

In general the rules are well-spelled out. Especially the civility rules. The rules about civility come with examples of things to avoid. However this is not true of all rules. For instance the rule on "baiting" was not really ever a rule. It was originally advice to avoid BEING Baited. Well now its a rule. And its only 11 words long. There are no examples of what baiting is in the rule and its enforcement could be more practical and consistent. Another rule to be aware of: the "don't flood the queue" rule. This originally had to do with Reddit performance. But over time it has taken on a meaning that we should allow others to post. People love to post news. And if someone posts too much of it, others don't get a chance. Flooding the queue can be a serious offense.

Enforcement

Breaking rules in /r/politics is not like getting a speeding ticket. While the penalties may get worse over time "the points never come off your license." Yes. This is archaic. And it is unfair to long term users. So if you are likely to break a rule once every two years by 8 years someone might get completely bounced - (I don't know for sure. I will find out more).

Recommendations

I strongly encourage people who want to be informed to look at and use /r/politics to find a wide variety of national political news though if they are looking for conservative news there won't be as much. Depending on where someone is from, the sub is probably less good for finding local news.

Be very careful in making comments. Moderation though possibly strained is heavy and can be punitive. Be careful to read all the rules before commenting. Note that on the new format all the rules are hard to find (The rule on "baiting" does not even appear) and it is necessary to go to the old format to see the rules.

-- Gonz.


r/SubredditReviews • • Apr 11 '17

r/relationships has problems with older men dating younger women.

3 Upvotes

This sub seemed pretty generalized, allowing people to make posts on anything from problems talking with S.O.s to sexual issues. I'd raised a personal hygiene issue to find advice on it, and was subsequently told that I couldn't post it because it was 'meta complaint'. The only problem is I have no idea what that means, and the only thing I can think of is that the post was removed because it detailed an older man dating a younger woman.

A few people gave advice but it immediately brought out lots of trolly types who suggested "perhaps you should date an actual adult".

The only problem is I was/am. It was like getting hate mail immediately for who I was dating. I'd reported those posts, and although they were removed, my original post was as well, and the only reason was 'meta complaint'. I asked them to explain why they considered it a meta complaint, and got silence. Silence usually indicates a bogus claim.

tl;dr, they don't like seeing people ask for relationship advice between older men and younger women.


r/SubredditReviews • • Feb 13 '26

💩 r/discordapp

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Let's start with some general information: I love to help people with Discord. I know a lot of bots, settings and other stuff. I help people with it as long as I can remember being on Discord.

When I joined Reddit I quickly found r/discordapp and other subreddits about Discord like r/discordbots and others. I helped people there the best I can.

One time, I suddenly get the message that I got banned from the subreddit. The modmail doesn't provide any information about why I got banned so I send a modmail to the mods myself asking why I got banned.

They close the modmail without answering me.

I try it again, nicer than before. They close it again.

Then I find out they have a Discord server. With a bit of hope I join the server and send them a message via the ModMail bot. See that conversation below. You can clearly see they never answered me and banned me from that server shortly after.

They have never told me why I got banned nor does anyone want to answer any question I am asking.

Later I requested to took over r/discordhelp and am now managing that one with the intent to be a better moderator than the ones at r/discordapp.


r/SubredditReviews • • Sep 04 '22

Plan to review every subreddit

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I think that this is a good place to post this, I'm planning to review every subreddit, starting with the popular ones. First up, r/funny: https://youtu.be/Wn-Ya0Jwp7g.

Thanks!

Po


r/SubredditReviews • • Aug 01 '22

Find lost online friends

2 Upvotes

r/SubredditReviews • • Nov 05 '20

please review the sub r/artoilpainting

2 Upvotes

r/SubredditReviews • • Jul 22 '20

What do you guys think of my sub for hanging out and making friends, /r/TheGreatOnesReborn ?

2 Upvotes

/r/TheGreatOnesReborn is an 18+ sub for people to make friends and get to know each other. We talk about and post almost anything, though lately it's mostly just music or weird videos we find on YouTube.

The sub is just basically a place to hang out with buddies when you have nothing better to do. I've been promoting today and could use some of your thoughts to make things better and hopefully do better the next time I promote.

Thanks!


r/SubredditReviews • • May 11 '20

Please give your hoñnnNNnÑest opinñion of /r/SurrealEntropy

2 Upvotes

Looking to make improvements/see what's working. Thanks!