r/SubaruForester • • 4h ago

Just walked away from the car of our dreams

19 Upvotes

The Subaru Forester Hybrid Sport we were waiting for finally arrived at the dealership today. Our sales rep had quoted us a price of $40,677 before taxes and fees. We knew we were shopping at a tough time, and hybrids are in high demand across Southern California.

Then we found out that the management decided to slap a 15% markup on all hybrids effective immediately. Just like that, our $40k vehicle turned into $46k, not including taxes.

So, I decided to walk away. I told them to give me a call when they’re willing to stick to the original price, because this new pricing just doesn’t add up. It seems like a bunch of dealerships in SoCal decided to start this markup today.

Now I’m looking at a RAV4 Hybrid instead. I’ve already reserved an XSE model that’s expected to arrive in the next week or two, and it’s several thousand dollars less than the Forester.

Did I make the right choice here? I’d feel a lot better if the Subaru Forester fans could reassure me. I get that Subaru is in it for the profits, but this whole situation just feels really wrong.


r/SubaruForester • • 2h ago

Help cleaning?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I bought this car used and I love it in every way. However, previous owner somehow got a splash of liquid that somehow got on the inside of the speedometer glass and on the screen. Any ideas on how I can clean it? Am I safe to remove those screws at the top and put out the plastic, clean it, then put it back in? Thank you in advance!


r/SubaruForester • • 5m ago

Ripped the drain bolt assembly out of the oil pan!

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Well, I decided to do an oil change on our new 2026 Forester, first time for it and me. Was just a post-break in period change as recommended by many here, it was at 1100ish miles.

I ended up finding the drain bolt impossible to loosen and then when grabbing a breaker bar started going the wrong way and ended up ripping it out that way. Huge mistake on my part.

I am wondering though if anyone else found the bolt really difficult to loosen from the factory though. Did you have success with a breaker bar provided you didn’t go the wrong way like me?

I was initially hoping the bolt had been badly overtightened and it’d be a warranty fix, but then looked at the wear and realized I’d turned it the wrong way.

We’re going to have to take it in to a local shop we trust since the dealer is 150 miles away. An expensive mistake for sure.

It’s sad seeing the Subie out of commission. I miss her!


r/SubaruForester • • 39m ago

Subaru oil interval - why every 6 months? I'm not close to 6k miles

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/SubaruForester • • 1h ago

Old vs. New - Seeking Forester Touring Recommendations

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Asking here as well! Any recommendations from fellow Forester owners would be greatly appreciated!

Many thanks in advance!


r/SubaruForester • • 2h ago

Tire Advice

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

I know there are about a million threads on this, but I've read several and still can't come to a decision. I'm between two tires, the Pirelli Scorpion Weatheractive, and the Nokian Encompass AW02. I have a 2023 Sport and I live in the upper Midwest. I've researched my way into decision paralysis, so I'm looking for outside input.

Per rankings/data on the Discount Tire website, looks like the Pirellis may have slightly better stopping distance in dry conditions, but worse in wet. They are also rated to be a little quieter, but that's not a concern for me, when we all know the car overall is fairly loud. I'm seeing a nearly $40 difference per tire between the two, and I am unfortunately strapped for cash atm, but know I need better tires for winter. I drive about 20k miles per year with work and other travel, so I need something reliable and safe.

With the strong el niño this year, I'm not sure we're going to see extreme snow, so I'm not concerned about a true winter tire. I also don't have money for an extra set of wheels, or space to store them on my own. I'm aware the best solution is a summer/all-season and a winter set, but I'm working with what I've got.

Does anyone have experience with either tire, or a strong brand preference? Do you have alternate recommendations I'm not considering? (I know Michelin CCs and Bridgestone are top tier, but out of budget for me.)

TIA for any help!


r/SubaruForester • • 2h ago

What is that sound?

1 Upvotes

Not concerned about it, just curious. It always makes this sound whenever you open the driver door after parking, regardless if you sit inside for 10 seconds or an hour prior to opening the door.

The noise after the doors unlock, when the screen lights up.


r/SubaruForester • • 18h ago

For Me - Spare Is Required on a Hybrid!

18 Upvotes

In March, I upgraded from a 2018 Forester to a 2026 Forester Hybrid Premium. I love my new Hybrid so much! The lack of a spare tire didn’t bother me until I had a tire blowout on the interstate at 11pm. It was a miracle that I got to the shoulder safely.
I had to have my car towed to my home.
The next day I had to have it towed to the dealer to have the tire replaced and check for damage.
I have realized that I need to have a spare for my safety. I drive a lot and have had a number of flats over the years. There is junk from construction all over the roads in Florida.
If I have a spare, the tire can be changed and I’m on my way. Then the tire can be fixed later.
Just curious what other Hybrid owners have done.


r/SubaruForester • • 13h ago

Weird whale sound on my Forester 2019 Limited

6 Upvotes

Hi!

I was checking all the levels of the liquids since it’s getting colder and noticed this “whale” sound coming from the engine. It starts at sec 16.

Has anyone dealt with this before?

I’m planning on replacing the timing belt soon, since I got the car with 94,000 miles. Any other urgent suggestions?

It’s a 2019 Limited with 100,000 miles


r/SubaruForester • • 3h ago

Does anyone have an idea what’s wrong with the camera?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/SubaruForester • • 22h ago

Body work help

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

Hi, this was a big goof on my part. I hurt my 2016 Forester 😩 is there anyway that I can repair this on my own? How do I even begin???? Please help!


r/SubaruForester • • 11h ago

Passenger side ball joint

3 Upvotes

Does anyone have any advice on how to get the ball joint out without torching it. I only have basic tools.


r/SubaruForester • • 14h ago

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited @101k miles - maintenance tips

5 Upvotes

Hi all,

I am going to look at (and hopefully buy) a 2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited @101k miles. 1 owner, oil changes every 6k miles, dif fluid at 80k, all other routine maintenance, no transmission fluid change. All done by the dealership that sold the car & and is now reselling it as used.

I hope to run this thing until the transmission/engine goes at 200k-250k+ miles.

What should I know before getting myself into the Subaru community on how to fix/extend its life without a major ($1k+) repair?


r/SubaruForester • • 15h ago

HF Jacks & Stands

Post image
4 Upvotes

I am needing to purchase a jack & set of stands for my 2017, and I am overwhelmed with Harbor Freight's 3 ton options. For Daytona, there is:

- low profile super duty

- long reach low profile

- low profile

- standard

then Pittsburgh has a standard and low profile model, that are very competitively priced

I am needing to be able to do suspension work, brakes, and fluid changes. Which of these, and which corresponding jack stands, will actually work for me?

I've heard a lot of conflicting info such as "you need a long reach jack to reach the jack points without driving up on ramps" or "you need 6 ton Daytona jack stands just to provide enough height to get the wheels off the ground".

These are the couple I was looking at for black friday (pictured), but am worried about the Daytona being overkill.


r/SubaruForester • • 1d ago

Has anyone else had these issues w/ their Forester?

31 Upvotes

So I bought my Forester brand new in 2021, and was really excited about it… really wanted to love this car, and most people I know have had only positive experiences with Subaru. But I’ve had several points of failure, a couple serious ones, all under 60k miles. The biggest ones:

• Complete transmission failure at 40k miles requiring replacement of the transmission (it was covered under warranty, but was really disturbing to me that a brand new car required this at 40k miles?)

• Engine coolant valve failed at 54k miles completely bricking the car and leaving it inoperable in the middle of traffic.

Have other’s had these issues? Or did I just get a lemon?

- 2021 Forester Sport, 5 years old, currently at 60k miles, my experience:

Under 1,000 miles:
- Windshield cracked from what I assumed was a minor stone strike. Used my insurance glass benefit to replace it. But I’ve been reading that this appears to be a known weakness of the OEM glass on this generation?

Around 20,000 miles:
- Rear gate LED light failed, replaced under warranty
- Driver side rear passenger door edge guard detached - never replaced. The dealer has never had the part in stock, and I was told it's being discontinued

Around 40,000 miles:
- CVT transmission failure, jerking and stuttering when accelerating from a stop, plus the car abruptly shutting off while driving. Required complete transmission replacement (was under warranty - thank god)
- Note that it seemed the replacement transmission is a remanufactured same-design CVT? Not an updated or redesigned unit? Which doesn’t leave me feeling good about this…

Around 44,000 miles:
- Start/stop system causing the car to shut off completely while stopped at lights, required full battery system replacement including new housing. - Was told there was a hardware software compatibility issue and that I needed a new housing system to hold a larger battery. Told it wasn't covered under warranty and charged $352.49 out of pocket
- Driver side window failure, regulator and motor replaced ($107 extended warranty deductible)

Around 50,000 miles:
- Driver seat sport leather upholstery cracking and ripping. The seat cover replaced by Subaru as a courtesy after I contacted Subaru customer advocacy about the next incident

Around 54,000 miles:
- Engine coolant valve (TCV) failure — car became completely inoperable while driving in traffic, leaving me stranded in the middle of an intersection off a highway off-ramp. Had to get the car towed, etc. Most dangerous incident and what ultimately prompted me to contact Subaru Customer Advocacy. Subaru reimbursed me for the towing, etc
- Supposedly replaced with a redesigned / updated part

Overall… the warranty coverages have prevented financial catastrophe, and Subaru customer advocacy has been somewhat responsive. But I’m just shocked at everything that has gone wrong with a “new” car, after having drove a 2006 Hyundai for 16 years and never had any repairs, just routine maintenance.

I asked Subaru Customer Advocacy if they have any type of “goodwill or loyalty program” if I were to consider giving Subaru another chance, but they do not and said they could offer a coupon towards the purchase of a brand new car. And after my experience, I’m just not feeling confident in the reliability of Subaru - after all this I’m leaning towards looking for a 5th gen 4Runner.


r/SubaruForester • • 14h ago

Forester Premium Headrest Problem?

3 Upvotes

Hi,

I’m almost getting my forester premium ‘26 by coming week but I had issue with the headrest while test driving. It was so hard and forward than the Altima I owned before. I’m not sure if that’s normal or does it cause problem in the long run?

I like to hike and travel a lot so I will be driving a lot of long drives. At least like 8-9 hours/day type once in a month. So I’m not sure if I should commit to this or are there any better options?

Salesman there said I could flip 180 but I’m sure that’s not safe. Also I’m 5 ft and for me this flip was pretty comfy but I don’t want to do it if it’s going to cause serious problems.

I’d like to get some recommendations/ experiences. Thank you!!


r/SubaruForester • • 20h ago

Best air mattress for Subaru Forester (2025)

5 Upvotes

Hey all!

Just got my first Subaru this year (2025 Forester) and will be finally venturing into car camping. I’ve car camped in the outback before but first time with the Forester.

Any air mattress suggestions? 2 person mattress. Been doing some research but figured I’d ask the pros.

Thanks all!


r/SubaruForester • • 23h ago

2016 Subaru Forester single thump when turning wheel

3 Upvotes

r/SubaruForester • • 21h ago

Question regarding 2023 and up brake pedal.

2 Upvotes

I had a 2020 Forester sport, car was totaled and I replaced it with a new to me 2023 wilderness. I’ve read that the vacuum style brake booster has been replaced by an electronic system. Does this newer system cause the brake pedal to have more tension than the older vacuum style system? I feel like I have to push the pedal harder than I did in my 2020 to engage the brakes.

Thanks to anyone that can provide some information regarding this.


r/SubaruForester • • 18h ago

While changing spark plugs, found some oil on the threads

0 Upvotes

2015 Forester 2.5 140K miles. Found some oil on the threads on two of the spark plugs I took out but doesn't look like it's getting to the tips. No oil in the coil boots that I could see. Nothing looks fouled, just worn plugs. I assume that the valve cover gasket and spark plug tube gaskets need to be replaced to fix this issue.

I was just wondering could the oil getting on the threads be related to the cam carrier seals? Wasn't sure if that was a possibility.


r/SubaruForester • • 1d ago

First Forester, 7th Subaru

Thumbnail
gallery
99 Upvotes

Hello from Toronto, Canada! Just picked up my 7th Subaru, but this is my first Forester. Came from a Crosstrek Wilderness, The dealership offered me a deal too good to refuse for the trade in (since the Crosstrek Wilderness isn't sold in Canada anymore). Loving the vehicle so far. Thought I'd say hi!


r/SubaruForester • • 17h ago

My 2015 Subaru Forester's engine does not turn on

0 Upvotes

I am currently parked in a subway station, the Subaru's engine does not turn on anymore. What do I do?


r/SubaruForester • • 22h ago

Leaking transmission case?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

2016 forester. Is my transmission case leaking right? Picture was taken on the driver side. Was checking my cv axle and saw this.


r/SubaruForester • • 1d ago

2005 Forester Seat Cushion

1 Upvotes

Hopefully this helps someone as I couldn't find much info about this issue online surprisingly. Both of the front seats have these 2 rigid, rectangular things in the butt of the seat, which are really uncomfortable to sit on. I suspect it's the heating element. I tried to shift them around and bury them into the padding but it didn't do much and I was afraid of causing damage.

Thankfully, I have found a cheap and great solution - an ikea chair pad 'JUSTINA'. It is the perfect thickness. I tried a thicker ikea cushion but it was too mushy and uncomfortable lol. Stoked!