r/SturgillSimpson
•
u/WallowerForever
•
Mar 02 '26
'Mutiny' is Extremely Good; It's Not Great
A bit of an "Emperor Has No Clothes" effect already happening with 'Mutiny' since its YouTube release so lets set the record frankly with ourselves as fans:
The grooves are thick and sick.
The vibes are immaculate and a blast.
The band is on fire, locked in and world class.
The songcraft and lyrics are threadbare and thin.
As I recall, Simpson indicated this record was partially or largely written in-studio and recorded live, and it feels like that --- great energy, relatively rushed-feeling songs (especially compared Simpson's heights and general catalogue).
I'm going to get downvoted into oblivion, I know, but this is the frank reality and I think musicians and songwriters here will agree. Very good album, but short of great — by design, I think. These dudes were just off tour, on fire, just having fun.