r/SturgillSimpson • • Mar 02 '26 Annoyed

'Mutiny' is Extremely Good; It's Not Great

0 Upvotes

A bit of an "Emperor Has No Clothes" effect already happening with 'Mutiny' since its YouTube release so lets set the record frankly with ourselves as fans:

The grooves are thick and sick.
The vibes are immaculate and a blast.
The band is on fire, locked in and world class.
The songcraft and lyrics are threadbare and thin.

As I recall, Simpson indicated this record was partially or largely written in-studio and recorded live, and it feels like that --- great energy, relatively rushed-feeling songs (especially compared Simpson's heights and general catalogue).

I'm going to get downvoted into oblivion, I know, but this is the frank reality and I think musicians and songwriters here will agree. Very good album, but short of great — by design, I think. These dudes were just off tour, on fire, just having fun.


r/SturgillSimpson • • Oct 04 '26

Stan fans

0 Upvotes

What happened in the last couple years to the fan base on here? I say this as someone who has been listening since 2015, but the people posting on here is 95% unhinged. That Sturg couldn’t possibly do anything wrong, have any faults, nothing could be done better about the album drops or ticket sales or bullshit he says.

He is an amazing musician. The most recent album is fine. But people on here making their kids after this guy and just glazing every thing he says and does. Someone probably started a church of Stu already. Is it jam band people? Is it Gen Z? Or did he just grab ahold of a bunch of 40 year old dudes with goatees in their moms basement?

It’s just a bummer, because there’s no real discourse anymore. It’s just “the boys showed up last night, greatest concert in human history”.


r/SturgillSimpson • • Jul 25 '24

Is Sturgill the greatest country musician of all time?

0 Upvotes

I know it’s a big title but think about it. His voice is a combination of the greatest country singers of time (Jones & Whitley), his guitar playing is a breed of its own fusing bluegrass,blues, ect., and his songwriting definitely up there with the greats.

It’s hard to compete with artists like Willie, Hank Sr., Merle and a lot of great songwriters who have definitely lived it. but he undeniably sits among the top classes on every category.

If not who would you put above him? Willie? Could Sturgill be the greatest talent out there today?


r/SturgillSimpson • • Aug 21 '23

Who the fuck is sturgill simpson?

0 Upvotes

For some reason my reddit keeps sending me notifications for this sub despite me never looking up sturgill Simpson , or ever listening to his music or consuming any content he’s ever done, WHO is this guy.


r/SturgillSimpson • • Feb 13 '24

Please tell me I’m not the only one daydreaming of a Beyoncé/Sturgill collab

0 Upvotes

EDIT: Damn! I did not think my stoned thought would be this controversial. All I’m going to say is 1 - yes, I’m serious. 2 - if ya’ll want to miss out on good music just because it’s Beyoncé, then that’s your choice, but the stuff she just dropped is awesome, and so is Daddy Lessons from a few years ago.


r/SturgillSimpson • • Oct 06 '26

Metamodern Ticket Static

0 Upvotes

Johnny Blue Skies Non-transferable ticket policies are security theater nobody asked for—well-intentioned anti-scalper tools that are "back woods handcuffs" for true fans. Plenty of shows left to fix it so we can all shake our groove things without pre-show headaches.


r/SturgillSimpson • • Feb 29 '24

Let me know your top 3 Sturgill songs and I’ll let you know if you’re in.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/SturgillSimpson • • Apr 23 '26

So he says that his concert tix can only be resold at Face

0 Upvotes

Why TF are they $450 on axs resale then


r/SturgillSimpson • • Sep 28 '24

Anybody thinking what I’m thinking? @rogan

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/SturgillSimpson • • Jan 08 '25

What does Life ain't fair and God is cruel, but at least she ain't the man mean????

0 Upvotes

Also, and thank God, I couldn't tell her if I had to, who I am, who is she???? I'm so lost. I've been tryna figure this sht out for months 😔😭


r/SturgillSimpson • • Oct 14 '26

It’s time for me to admit that I was slightly disappointed by my JBS live experience

0 Upvotes

I know this might get me downvoted and most here won’t agree, but I wanted to share my experience. Of course this is just my opinion and sorry for the long post.

I’ve been a huge Sturgill/JBS fan since 2016 and have listened to everything he’s put out, including buying his last 3 records on vinyl. When I saw that he was coming to my city I was ecstatic and bought tickets immediately. I did find the tickets were a little pricier than I expected but that’s a separate conversation and I felt that way less when I found out he was playing 3 hour sets.

I had the concert date circled on my calendar for months and couldn’t wait. I was listening religiously leading up the show and made a whole evening of the show.

Then came the show.. now let me say that I actually really enjoyed the show. The band, the lights, and Johnny himself were all amazing, but during the show I learned quickly that they are a jam band. I’ve been to many shows and I think this is the first jam band I’ve ever seen.

What I didn’t love about the jam aspect was that it felt like every song was stretched out and it started to almost feel tedious. I love Sturgill’s beautiful arrangements on his recordings but these felt more stripped down and it started to feel like every song had a super long jam session that to me wasn’t adding much. It made the songs feel less unique. I also think this took my GF out of it a little which didn’t help.

I guess at the end of the day I wouldn’t have minded the songs being fuller and closer to the recordings and only a few jams mixed in vs every single song being a long jam.

TL;DR: I didn’t realize JBS was a jam band and that personally took away from my experience a little bit. That said, the show was still fantastic and it was such a treat to finally hear so many of my favourite songs live.


r/SturgillSimpson • • Jun 09 '24

I know we all want to see him live but who is with me boycotting ticketmaster/livenation?

6 Upvotes

And honestly I don't think AXS is any better when it comes to fees and "dynamic pricing"

That being said, as excited as I am about the new music and tour I really am not interested in spending so much money on tickets.

I know that art in all of its forms doesn't make much money especially here in the digital age, but wiping out your fans bank accounts in collaboration with a company that has ruined many a small venue and monopolized the rest isn't the answer.

Boycott these venues and companies if you truly care about live music being accessible to all, as it should be.

Buy merch and physical media (vinyl and CD) direct from the artist if you want to support them.


r/SturgillSimpson • • Nov 24 '24

Thoughts on the Crowd

1 Upvotes

This was my first time seeing him headline, is his crowd always wooked out and full of drunk cowboy kids? Everyone was so fucked up in the pit and I saw numerous people drop.

I had a kid that was out on his feet barely able to stand and kept falling into my girlfriend and then got pissy with me when I told him to focus more on standing and not worrying about filming. I was also surprised to see the nitrous mafia when I walked out. The music was amazing but the crowd reminded me of a Billy Strings show, which is not a positive thing in my eyes.


r/SturgillSimpson • • Mar 06 '26

Harry Styles

0 Upvotes

Harry Styles new album fucks. So much disco and dancing going down in this house!


r/SturgillSimpson • • Dec 04 '25

Obligatory Wrapped Post

Post image
0 Upvotes

Don’t miss out on Rattlesnake Milk now ya hear?


r/SturgillSimpson • • Sep 09 '26

Dear Johnny, when are you gonna play Weatherman by Hank Williams Jr?

0 Upvotes

I need some (Johnny) blue skies and sunshine


r/SturgillSimpson • • Jun 05 '26

Not able to sell tickets?

Post image
5 Upvotes

I need to put my tickets up for sale because of some other obligation that came up. I figured I would sell them in the marketplace for what I bought them, like I've done before... but they've disabled selling tickets. I should be able to sell them for what I paid. Does anyone know what's going on?


r/SturgillSimpson • • Mar 21 '26

Just finished my first listen

10 Upvotes

Waited to get my hands on the vinyl and play it through some speakers… they better tour this thing hard.

I want jams, I want Marshall’s, I want disco balls, I want wardrobe, I want a Grammy (not like that shit matters, but they deserve it).

Saw JBS last tour and thought they didn’t drive it hard enough. They were a fledgling emerging sound. It’s different now. VERY different. Lets fuk!!


r/SturgillSimpson • • 26d ago

I know Sturgill has said they're not big fans of sit ins but looking for Dave Schools showing up in NOLA

0 Upvotes

And hmmmmm, what oh what do we want to hear? Maybe some JJ Cale? 🤔


r/SturgillSimpson • • Feb 17 '25

What are concerts even like anymore?

0 Upvotes

I haven’t been to a large show since 2018 when I caught Sturgill at Hinterland in Iowa. Prior to that, I lived in Austin TX for a decade and would go to a show at least once a week, anywhere from a hundred people to a couple thousand people at any gig. Covid really wrecked my idea of crowd comfort and I feel people are wired differently in social settings like that now. Myself included. My anxiety has gotten worse as I’m 40 now and the idea of going to a big show solo gives a great pause. But outside of a few listening room type experiences, I’m not of the “big show” personality nor energy to navigate crowds.

I’m signed up for the presale for the Independence MO show in May. The venue is next door to my “safe space” (Costco!!!) so that area is familiar. It is still a two hour trip each way from home and I’ll sufferer the blinding headlights in i35 to make it happen. Cause I need this. Also might need a cheap hot dog and a 40lb bag of dog food by then.

All this to ask…. What’s everyone’s vibe at these shows? Are ya getting down with people that listen to Stu in all kinds of weather? Or people that’ll go to a show just to be going out? Or a mix? Is this gonna be one to wear my walking shoes and hope for the best or pony up for a seat instead and hope the people around me are chill? Any guidance or experiences are much appreciated.


r/SturgillSimpson • • May 02 '26

Playing the glazed donut

0 Upvotes

Just curious for anyone else who got a glazed donut. Are you spinning it or saving it? You had to have opened it right? So might as well play it. That’s my opinion, curious on what others who were lucky enough to get one are doing.


r/SturgillSimpson • • Dec 03 '25

This is 5 years in a row

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/SturgillSimpson • • 21d ago

Party foul on the buzzkill in Lexington that killed the blow up couple someone brought to toss about.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/SturgillSimpson • • Sep 16 '24

Question: How Long Will We Do This 'Johnny Blue Skies' Charade?

16 Upvotes

Before you downvote —  I think "Johnny Blue Skies" is awesome, aesthetically and philosophically, but fans seem more committed to it than Simpson is: The new tour is billed as "Sturgill Simpson's Why Not? Tour," his official website is still SturgillSimpson.com, Passage Du Desir is listed under Sturgill's name on streaming and he's still billed as Sturgill Simpson at major festivals, etc.

I don't know anyone who calls him Jonny Blue Skies — he's still effectively Sturgill Simpson, to the world and even officially in many channels. Do you think this will fade away after one album, or continue as a half-step branding effort?

Go see him live either way — the music has never been better.