I want to make this post for anyone else thinking of switching to S1 , especially from FL Studio.
I went to a pro studio this past week, the first time. I do my work in FL studio, but audio editing sucks in FL, so I thought well hey S1 is the best of both worlds according to everyone online. i imported my project into studio one, and there was some great things and not so great things. i think im just going back to FL Studio.
Here is what I liked about S1:
- amazing built-in reference manual that shows you how to do everything. keeps it simple.
- ? mark gives you information about anything you want to learn.
- easy to organize things and colourize, easy on the eyes.
- has way better audio editing than FL studio, but this is also a gripe for me
- keeps all files in one place, easy to change this
- an arranger window, this is such a freaking awesome lovely idea IN THEORY.
What I didn't like:
- overall Studio one feels glitchy, and clunky, and crashy. it feels half-baked in some aspects.
- call me crazy, but the snap feature does not seem robust at all. i CONSTANTLY had to reenable snap to get it to work, select the bars/beats and then the quantize feature as well. sometimes i had all settings correct and it still wouldnt work! this drove me so crazy. i wasted so much time enabling/reenabling.
- i dont know if its a glitch, but when horizontally scrolling with mouse, it kept zooming in! ugh, whyyyy
- the midi editor sucks compared to FL Studio. nothing beats FL studio MIDI editing and I've tried reaper, s1, ableton, reaper, all the others are garbage. its not intuitive, its ugly, and feels like crap. but, the fl studio UI is just so amazing and smooth...sigh
- S1 kept crashing, like enough times i was getting really frustrated. i went deep dive in it for 1-2 weeks and it just kept crashing or stalling. i believe this was due to analog lab being a shitty plugin, but FL studio never crashes this much even with multiple analog lab instances.
- it has audio editing yes, but it was not intuitive, again this was probably a learning curve i didnt have time to delve into. when i tried splicing parts together and have them crossfade at 0 points, there was still audible clicks/drops. ive done crossfading in reaper, and its very seamless and easy in reaper. even fl studio has somewhat basic crossfading features that actually work. but i felt i had to 'play' around with s1 a lot more.
- arranger track is awesome right? well yes, but it does not seem robust. sometimes you can drag sections, sometimes you cant...i somehow dragged the start/end markers from the main window into the arranger window and i was unable to move them back to the main window or delete them?!...also, if you have MIDI notes that start a bit before the bar, but you slice it then move it, you get overlapping midi with other sections if they end past their bar. this makes sense but there should be some sort of option to 'force all midi to start of bar' or 'quanitize midi when slicing' type thing. or i guess you could quantize......
- the built in plugs felt garbage. i mean the reverb plugs suck. fl studio has reverb 2 and reverb, and these reverb plugins are just so freaking awesome. the studio one native plugins didnt do much for me, i tried replicating plugin settings from fl studio but it just wouldnt sound as good.
this is in a nutshell for me, ill add more if there are any.