A small town in Michigan just got notified that a data center is being built next to it. No vote. No community input. Just a letter. This is exactly the pattern playing out across rural America right now — towns that are already struggling get chosen specifically because locals don't have the resources or political power to fight back. The data center gets tax breaks, uses millions of gallons of local water, drives up land prices, and brings maybe 30 permanent jobs. The town gets nothing. I've been investigating both the small-town decline epidemic and the data center expansion, and they are the same story. https://youtu.be/J46ux1UJYsU
I think this sub needs more life… More discussions, more ideas, more questions..
Last time I shared my views on the finances cities should be eligible to and a mechanism of letting cities “die”.
This time I want to discuss what private cities could be like. Could they be a better alternative to the democratic/public cities we have today?
First of all, I’d like to say that one of the main problems cities face is unsustainable development. Sure, reforming the way cities are financed could address this problem to some extent, but I’d like to point to the fact that Free Markets have been the best at utilizing the resources at hand.
And what is a city if not a resource of a land? I think, private sector would mostly develop in a walkable city, rather than into a car dependent sprawl. This would generate more income on less land. While public sector does not care about utilization, it is something private sector is hell bent on.
I would also let the private city collect taxes in the same way public cities do.
To further explore the idea, I urge you to ask questions, make suggestions why it would or wouldn’t work. Should we try it? Why not?
If places like Lenexa, Kansas and Overland Park, Kansas are more dense and have less detached single family housing than kcmo and places like Mesa Arizona are more dense than Phoenix along with scottsdale having less detached single family housing percentages than the “city” how could this be? Also most jobs are in the “suburbs” in the USA and these 2 cities have tiny downtowns. http://www.newgeography.com/content/005264-suburbs-continue-dominate-jobs-and-job-growth
I'm thinking about hoovering up all the StrongTowns reddit posts, website/blog content, book PDFs, etc to train a StrongTownsGPT LLM.
The idea is simple, open another lane of information for those with a more interactive learning style. Would Redditors use it? Would outsiders you're trying to communicate with benefit from it? LMK.
(Or maybe more generally it could be an urbanistGPT?)
We learned after COVID that so many jobs can be done virtually if high speed internet is available. Progressive Insurance was like 95% at the height. This has allowed companies to hire anywhere that has a high speed line. Urbanization is great in theory, but packing more people per spare acre increases the value of the land and housing. Cities constantly regulate and constrain business and industrial operations that cause them to move to more business friendly environments (as the South with Megafactories just outside the city causing employees to drive. This removes the high paying low education/low skill opportunities from the city core. McDonald’s is not a career option, yet lack of other opportunities have made it so.
My thought? There are thousands of smaller towns withering away with homes for less than $100k that if they had high speed internet remote employees could prosper in. Maybe lower wages but if they owned their home they can garden etc. we can leverage the vastness of our Nation and reap the rewards of lower cost of living in small towns. Based on that further development can follow Strong Towns philosophy. Large cities are lost causes.
I just watched another one of NJBs videos, this one about the so-called tired excuse of size and distance playing a factor into why we don't have the same public transit here in North America as they do in The Netherlands.
One thing that I saw mentioned that sparked this entire exercise was his mention of the Quebec-Windsor corridor here in Canada as an example of where 50% of Canadians live.
Though this is true, we still are not even remotely a fair analogue to be compared to the Netherlands, because density is the X factor in viable transit.
So to make a fair comparison I did the following exercise: I took the lists of cities with over 100K population and over 1000 persons per KM^2 in The Netherlands and my home province (and formerly NJBs) of Ontario.
This is already giving a huge benefit of the doubt to NJBs side since I'm looking the entire country of the Netherlands and only the most populated region of the most populated province in Canada, but you'll find the numbers STILL heavily favour the argument that these are not even remotely in the same ballpark.
Graphing each of the 100K cities as nodes on a weighted graph, with the minimum distance between any 2 nodes added we see that the entire nation of the Netherlands has an average distance between nodes of 37.5 km and a worst case of 100 km.
Over here in the DENSEST region of Canada, we have a worst case of over 206 km! And an average of nearly 90 km.
So to have even a comparable transit system we'd need to spend almost 3 times the resources connecting these sparse population centres. It's just not feasible and size is a entirely fair argument here.
I believe strongly that walkable cities is a future we need and can’t avoid, but I sadly believe that because of our political polarization, the only people pushing walkable cities also believe in radical gender ideology, equity and Marxist ideals which I don’t stand by. What should I do?
NOTE- Thank you guys so much for all the feedback.
These dedications come with conditions and restrictions. Some of the easements were for Utility use some of the easements were dedicated for public use like beach, recreation, and vehicle and foot traffic on roadways, including sidewalks or boardwalks. They didn’t allow private structures like cabanas, garages and tiny homes to be built on tax free land that was dedicated for Public Use that is the issue. Now we’ve got some Nimby little fruitcake that wants to disturb private property owners on the historical Indian Trail after hours yet they’re not brave enough to use their name. They like to hide behind anonymous sock, puppet, personas, and wine and cry about someone objecting to their trespassing.. The Indian Trail is not well lit. There’s no street lights if you want to go for a walk it’s safer to stay on a public street. Most people have them connected to their driveway, but some do not some homes are secluded and require trail access at night time the trail becomes essential for private property owners
I had a crazy idea and was wondering what you thought of it. Like how some municipalities have their own fiber optic broadband services, what would you think about a town creating their own rideshare app to compete with Uber/Lyft? It wouldn't need to profit so it could charge lower fees and/or pay the drivers better. Once developed, the app could be licensed out to other municipalities so the wheel doesn't have to be reinvented every time. Obviously public transit would be better, but this could be a middle ground to slow down the rate Silicon Valley venture capitalist parasites extract value from a community.
I am concerned with the growing increase of automous vehicles in my city. Using our roads as testing grounds.
As this subreddit prefers, we need less cars on the road not more.
How can I phrase my concerns to my representatives?
Are there any known suggestions to limit their use?
How can I convince right leaning representatives that like privatization of transport over public transport?
I'm looking for points to say on a call about waymo stealing money from the state and hard workers since money will leave go to companies outside our city and not go to taxes for our roads.
I'm looking for ideas about how to restrict waymo and automous taxis on the road by these companies or ways they can be used to benefit us instead of causing more traffic on broken cities that I can say.
I'm not talking about infastructure here or property taxes . I feel like it's misleading to tell people that poor people are subsiding rich people overall. Downtowns have such a small percentage of a city's jobs. And the nearby areas with the lower income residents usually have many less jobs and economic activity. What about federal services like military defense, or federal-state unemployment, FBI, Cost to run the federal government, Medicaid etc.
Most federal money comes from income tax, payroll tax and corporate tax (which is from jobs)
Suburban residents have on average higher incomes in the US putting them at higher tax brackets meaning they have to pay more and most people live in suburbs
Those few iobs that are in downtowns need suburban workers and they need wealthy suburbanites spending their money there too to create more sales tax revenue even in cities where most sales tax is collected in downtowns like Lafayette. I bet most of those spenders are suburban tourists and wealthy suburbanites not the poorer people living nearby
Coming here as a car enthusiast on the autism spectrum; I hate living in the car-centric USA, because I can’t stand the potential sudden horns and engine revs. I am mostly into prewar cars, and the reason why my generation (Gen Z) doesn’t talk about them is abundantly clear: they’re too slow to take on the freeway! In the case of Brass Era and Veteran Era cars, most can’t even be driven around town because there are more local roads than streets! I love these cars because they are (or seem to be) less likely to make sudden sounds (I doubt any of them would backfire if taken care of properly), and they are so much more beautiful than anything past the Fifties! Because of their low running speeds, they would be very relaxing to drive, but there are hardly any <30 mph surfaces they can take! Parking lots and housing developments don’t have enough straight-line space, and dedicated historic vehicle paths would be a neat idea, but I would rather have them run where they’re meant to run: streets and dirt roads! We need lower-speed streets not just for people and cyclists’ safety, but also the safety for the cars who truly matter.