First off, allow me to preface this by saying I've been playing fighting game's competitively for 10 years or so, and I've played (and enjoyed) almost every single one to come out at at least a competent level. Fighting game's are my hobby, and I love the genre to death; all I want is to fight strong opponents and to see the FGC prosper. I'd also like to thank everyone in advance who takes the time to read all of this (I know it's an ass load of text), and to encourage discussion too.
Now, I'll be the first to admit that this game deserves some of the hate that it gets. The single player content is abysmal, and capcom's marketing tactics tend to range from greedy to idiotic (if this game were originally released as a beta then I doubt we'd be hearing almost anyone complain). But I feel like throughout the life of this game no one's taken the time to examine and point out the things the game does really well. Now, in the end a lot of this is subjective; everyone plays fighting games looking to scratch some kind of itch, but exactly what itch can vary from person to person. Some fighting games excel at certain areas and are lacking in others, and I think it's important to realize no fighting game is going to be able to accommodate everyone's taste and still maintain good design and balance, it just isn't feasible. I can completely accept that SF5 might not be your cup of tea, and there's plenty of other excellent fighting game's out there that can scratch itches SF5 can't reach.
First thing I'd like to cover is the claim that player individuality has a hard time shining outside of character choice (eg: Daigo's Ryu plays the same as Tokido's Ryu for example). I think this is a relatively valid statement, but I unlike everyone I seem to hear, I think this is an actually good quality, or rather it exists for good reason. Unlike previous installments of Street Fighter, the characters in SF5 were designed very deliberately and with a specific archetype/playstyle in mind. Every character's toolkit was well thought out, and every move they have tends to serve a function. As a result, the optimal style of play for a character is way more obvious, and players are expected to mold themselves to the characters as opposed to vice-versa. Lets compare SF5 Bison, for example, to his SF4 counterpart. Personally, I think SF5 Bison fits the whole "Dictator" motif miles better than SF4's. The slow walk speed is very reminiscent of a cocky villian slowly moving forward to their target's inevitable demise. Up close, he's very oppressive and hits super hard, just like a psycho power'd dictator should. SF4's Bison on the other hand, has a moveset that's basically copy pasted from SF2/SFA, with no attempt to mold him into a more personified character. As a result, you'll find that a large chunk of his moveset is basically never used in competitive play, and his whole game plan devolves into pressuring with scissor-kick and abusing his footsie normals. Similar arguments can be made for a lot of the cast (lookin at Vega real hard here).
The next thing I'd like to discuss is everyone's constant bitching about 50/50's. Now I'm personally not sure why this is even a thing, because out of all the fighting game's I've played in my life, SF5 is towards the bottom in terms of 50/50's. Like, did you guys every play SF4? Ibuki and Akuma could literally vortex you to death off a single knockdown anywhere on the screen (to say nothing of unblockable setups), and I'm not even gonna get into how utterly absurd the 50/50's are in Marvel. The closes thing we have to that in SF5 is throw loops in the corner, and personally I like the idea that if you manage to corner you opponent you are rewarded with some pretty threatening oki.
I also see a lot of people complain about the lack of combo variety. While this is a legitimate complaint, I think it's important to point out that cool combos and sick tech has never been something street fighter has excelled at. Sure SF4 was better in this regard thanks to FADC mechanics, but outside of stylish stun combos players still used this mechanic strictly to optimize damage and positioning, making the whole "creativity" aspect kind of pointless. Additionally, I think the Focus Attack mechanic ended up doing more harm than good in the long run since it fucked with the footsie game super hard (it was a low risk/high reward option that some characters could deal with and others couldn't). If crazy combos and confirms are what you're after, Guilty Gear and Marvel have plenty of the that, and I think it's great to show those games some love too.
Next is what I think is the game's biggest asset compared to other fighting games, namely its relative simplicity and accessibility. Fighting games are difficult by nature because you're fighting another person who (ideally) has practiced it and knows the ins and outs of the game. This to me is the most pure and enjoyable part of fighting games, which is why it baffles me that people want to increase the execution barrier (I personally find execution to be the least interesting part of fighting games; might as well go play guitar hero). All that would do is require you to spend more time in training mode, and make actual interactions between the players way less consistent. I think we can all agree that the easier it is for a player to get exactly what they want to come out in a match the better. And the ease of use will make it so that we have more players who are able to perform at a high level, and in the end isn't getting good and fighting strong opponents the most enjoyable aspect of fighting games? That's the thing this game allows you to do better than any other, since getting to a high level takes less time compared to others (still takes a fucking lot of time combined with having good mind set mind you; it's not like you can hammer training mode and online for a few days and end up beating Daigo).
This is way less important (and a little subjective) so I'll make this one short, but I'd just like to say real quick that I find this game to be visually amazing, save for a few weirdly modeled faces. The sound design is also top notch.
I'll finish by saying that, yeah the game isn't perfect. While it's relatively balanced for a fighting game, there is still much that could be done to improve it (Balrog and Ibuki could use a nerf or two, and several characters could stand to get buffed a little more). Personally I think V-Reversals should be buffed, as right now they're not worth using for a good chunk of the cast, and maybe damage should be lowered a little so that you don't lose off single mistake. But I see people suggesting drastic changes to an already pretty solid fighting game, changes that I'm 99% sure would only break the game. In the end, I just wish people would appreciate the game for what it is instead of trying to turn it into their "ideal" fighting game.
Again, thanks for reading and feel free to discuss.