r/StrategyRpg • u/[deleted] • Jan 21 '24
Japanese SRPG Disappointed in Tactics Ogre: Reborn
I recently picked up Tactics Ogre: Reborn after being a huge fan of Tactics Strategy genre. I loved playing FF: Tactics, FF: Tactics Advanced, Triangle Strategy. I was looking forward to this game but after playing it for nearly 10 hours I have to say this game is really boring compared to the other titles I just mentioned.
One thing that I really dislike is the Level Cap. It is a terrible mechanic as it does not reward the player for taking the more challenging route in every battle such as killing the entire enemy team instead of just the main target. The level cap also artificially makes the game more difficult with no real strategy added. It's fine to make a game more difficult but there's a difference between a challenge where the player feels like they need to strategize to win, versus a challenge where enemies just feel too Tanky. The latter feels cheap, and is not fun.
I've had much more fun playing the FF Tactics games, and especially the recent Triangle Strategy game which seemed to balanced the mechanics quite well and actually felt like a FUN challenge. The battles in Triangle Strategy were designed in such a way that enemy units would play a particular way depending on the stage and players would have to strategically adapt in order to win.
It felt so rewarding to lose the first attempt to the CPU, but then win the second one after figuring out a decent strategy from the knowledge of the previous match. I did not get the same feeling at all from Tactics Ogre. It felt like the only way they thought of making this game hard was to make enemies have a ton of health. There doesn't even seem to be much tactics involved. The player shouldn't have to feel like they have to play less since the extra EXP they obtained will be capped and not matter anyway.
I will continue playing this game to fully assess... but as of 10 hours so far, I'm sorry to say the game is very lack luster, very straight forward, repetitive, and unfortunately NOT fun.