r/Stoneblade • • Sep 06 '19

Tournament Report - Modern Modern League Results Thread

41 Upvotes

Instead of cross-posting the Modern League Results post from r/ModernMagic into this sub every week, I'll post all the Stoneblade lists that show up there in this thread so it is more accessible for everyone. I'll try to update it every week or so.

Please message me if you feel I've missed out any list from that post. Some Stoneforge Mystic lists which we do not consider as Stoneblade have been purposefully excluded from this thread.

For the most part, we consider these decks as Stoneblade variants:

  • UW/Jeskai/Esper Stoneblade

  • Bant Snowblade (without Collected Company)

  • Deadguy Ale

  • BW Poxblade

  • Mardu Stoneblade (without Young Pyromancer)

  • Abzan Stoneblade

...as well as some spicy variations of these decks.

Notable exclusions would be:

  • Decks running Thalia which are probably better classified as "taxes"

  • Collected Company or Aether Vial decks

  • Tribal decks

Number of posted 5-0 finishes per deck (Updated January 14):

  • UW Stoneblade - 32

  • Jeskai Stoneblade - 24

  • Jeskai (and 4c) Saheeliblade - 6

  • Esper Stoneblade - 11

  • Bant Snowblade - 38

  • Deadguy Ale - 8

  • BW Poxblade - 7

  • Mardu Stoneblade - 6

  • Abzan Stoneblade - 11


r/Stoneblade • • Sep 09 '20

Fluff I heard we sharing lists here

Post image
38 Upvotes

r/Stoneblade • • Sep 26 '19

Article/Guide - Modern Firing Up the Forge: A Guide to Brewing Modern Stoneblade

Thumbnail
cardknocklife.com
35 Upvotes

r/Stoneblade • • Sep 04 '20

Fluff Someone else shared theirs, so here is mine :)

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/Stoneblade • • Nov 16 '20

Fluff Stoneforge Mystic animated 2

33 Upvotes

r/Stoneblade • • Aug 02 '20

Deck Tech - Modern Bant Stoneblade or how I learned to play tempo in Modern and win

32 Upvotes

2 Jace, the Mind Sculptor

3 Teferi, Time Raveler

2 Birds of Paradise

4 Ice-Fang Coatl

4 Noble Hierarch

4 Spell Queller

4 Stoneforge Mystic

2 Uro, Titan of Nature's Wrath

2 Censor

3 Force of Negation

4 Path to Exile

1 Batterskull

1 Sword of Feast and Famine

1 Detention Sphere

1 Tireless Tracker

1 Breeding Pool

1 Field of Ruin

1 Flooded Strand

1 Hallowed Fountain

1 Horizon Canopy

4 Misty Rainforest

3 Snow-Covered Forest

3 Snow-Covered Island

1 Snow-Covered Plains

1 Temple Garden

1 Waterlogged Grove

4 Windswept Heath

Kanister and Bobthedog. Who?

I threw in a 4-1 UR Kiki list behind those black lines.

The above list is the approximate Bant Stoneblade list I have taken to 3 5-0s on MTGO in the past week (33 wins and 12 loses). If you don't like the controlling aspect of other UW Stoneblade lists, I believe this is the best shell for Stoneblade moving forward. Be sure to re-read that sentence. This is not a controlling versus, but a tempo version. You have to be down to play this type of magic to succeed. Here is how:

1 Mana Dorks (4 Noble Hierarchs, 2 Birds of Paradise)

Status: Uncuttable

The mana dorks in this type of list serve so many purposes and therefore are worth their sometimes late game worthlessness. As the biggest departure from other UWg or UW Stoneblade lists, these dorks allow you to accelerate into a turn 3 bomb, eat up 1 mana removal to allow your 2 mana creatures to survive longer and generate more card advantage, fix your mana, and lastly carry swords. This last point is the biggest reason why this list is successful. The most common creature carrying a sword for me is a dork. Which means my opponent will have to answer them eventually. This means they have already added the benefits described above to our game plan before they are killed. One of my biggest concerns with the UW lists are the lack of sword carriers but by adding green we add 6 high impact cards that wield swords very well.

Bant Tip #1 Pay attention to early games where you have multiple dorks to push your advantage as much as possible. The amount of sweepers in game #1 are few and far between. And if you do get board wiped, rebuilding with a dork is a low tempo play. You need better use of your mana so risk it. Also a opening nine cards of 2 dorks, 3 lands, and a stoneforge mystic means you can be hitting an opponent with a Sword of Feast and Famine on turn 3.

(Turn one - dork

turn two - SFM, get Sword of Feast and Famine & dork

turn 3 activate SFM, equip sword, swing, untap 3 mana)

2 Drop Creatures (4 Stoneforge Mystic, 4 Ice-Fang Coatl)

Status: Uncuttable

When an opponent "Bolts the Bird" on turn 1, these 2 creatures are the best follow ups in your gameplan. Both draw a card and will eventually cost your opponent more cards as the game goes on. IFC is more straight forward to play; mostly on your opponent's end step, or combat step to ambush a creature, or in your main phase if you need to hit a land drop. On the other hand, SFM is more intricate. When I play SFM I analyze the board state to determine which piece of equipment I search for. My thought processes is, if the SFM dies will I have someone to carry the Sword? If yes, then get the Sword of Feast and Famine. If SFM is my only creature out, Batterkull will be searched. The only time I deviate from this plan is against Burn or UR Prowess, Batterskull is always the answer.

Bant Tip #2 When a Batterskull is on the battlefield but without a germ token, you can activate SFM's ability to put an equipment into play, hold priority, and then pay for the Batterskull to return to your hand. I learned that one on this reddit and I figured I would share it again for any newcomers. Your opponent can still destroy the SFM but SFM's ability will still resolve now with the Batterskull in your hand.

3 Drop Disruption (4 Spell Queller, 3 Teferi, Time Raveler, 3 Force of Negation)

Status: Uncuttable

Some of the key "tempo" cards in our deck. To me the theory of tempo is about mana to battlefield ratio. For instance if you spend 3 mana to play a spell and I spend 3 mana for a Spell Queller I have not only negated your battlefield presence with my 3 mana, but have a 2/3 flyer leftover. In the same scenario, but the opponent's spell is only 2 mana, the difference of a threat on the battlefield is still greater than that 1 extra mana. Even some 1 mana spells our opponents play would have created such swings in battlefield presence that the difference in mana usage is negated. Teferi works in very similar ways, but draws a card and it leaves behind an eventual card advantage engine and constant counter war winning/anti combat trick planeswalker. Force of Negation is very similar, but its alternative casting cost is much steeper of a premium than just paying 3 mana. Nevertheless, Force of Negation allows us to tap out on turns to promote our battlefield, knowing we can respond for "free" on our opponent's turn. If you don't count the Force of Negation in your hand, we have 20 other blue cards. I like those odds.

Bant Tip #3 Common play pattern is to play Teferi, attack with an Ice Fang, and then use the -3 ability to bounce the IFC and draw a card. Later on when you have the open mana you can replay the IFC.

Bant Tip #4 Hopefully everyone knows this by now, but spells (even uncounterable ones) that are exiled with Spell Queller cannot be played when their is a Teferi in play.

Bant Tip #5 Spell Queller has alternate text. It is a 2/3 for 3 with Flash and Flying. There are often times when you need to flash in the Queller and get to attacking. You can bounce it later if needed.

4 Mana Card Advantage Bombs (2 Jace, the Mind Sculptor, 2 Uro, Titan of Nature's Wrath, 1 Tireless Tracker)

Status: Uncuttable, Shark Typhoon is undergoing some testing

Technically these are all 4 drops: JTMS cost 4 mana, Tireless Tracker needs a fourth land to come into play to gain a card (and rarely gets played any other way in this deck), and Uro cost UUGG to escape from the graveyard. Lets delve into all three individually. Someone once told me the most powerful JTMS decks are the ones that can use each of his abilities. Although brainstorming is still the most common option, this decks utilizes the tempo (same definition as above) of his -1 bounce ability to great degrees. And the +2 can be crucial in mid to late game situations to create tempo (wow you drew another land, how did that happen?). I will tell you in all of my time playing with JTMS I do not think I have ever ultimated him. But this is not a control deck, we aren't equipped to keep JTMS alive for 1/2 a dozen turns, and if we have that means our creatures have been attacking.

Tireless Tracker is a non-blue (hi Mystical Dispute!) creature (sweet Negates and Forces bro!) that doesn't utilize the graveyard to create card advantage (please side in Rest in Peace because you saw me play a Uro game 1, I will still come out 1 card ahead of you). Another advantage of Tireless Tracker is the amount of removal needed early on for dorks, IFC, Spell Queller and SFM. Tireless Tracker lives for long periods of time when playing this deck which means more cards which means more wins. I have been testing a Shark Typhoon instead of a Tireless Tracker. As you can see by the previous paragraph I have been more impressed with the Tracker.

Uro, Titan of Nature's Wrath is the best recent addition to the list. It gains life, translate dead creatures into new cards, accelerates, and can close games quickly. However, Uro is a negative tempo play (no board presence while investing mana). When given the option to make other 2 or 3 mana plays I will hold Uro because of that negative tempo aspect. However, just like the rules with SFM, there are some matchups, mostly Burn and Prowess, sometimes Dredge, where Uro needs to be played right away because you need to get it back right away.

Bant Tip #6 Do not hold dorks, ICF, or rather useless SFM in hand. Play them out and get them killed. Uro is a hungry boy and the more food in the graveyard the better.

Bant Tip #7 When applicable hold onto extra land(s) in your hand. Multiple reasons why, first it must force at least some of your opponents to consider what is left in your hand. Second, holding a land allows you to draw a card when you draw Tireless Tracker. Third, if you draw JTMS and you brainstorm you will now be up another card.

Possible Flex Spots (2 Censor, 1 Sphere of Detention)

Status: Very Cuttable - add your favorite cards here

These 3 cards have been filling the role of Acrum's Astrolabe in varying degrees of efficiency. Censor is a great card to have to cycle for Uro, pitch for Force of Negation, and its least used mode counter a spell. But wow does Censoring a card make you smile. I tried other cycling spells but this card has just felt correct. Sphere of Detention is there as one of the cheapest catch all answers to problematic permanents and fills in one of this decks worst types of matchups go wide aggro. Against tokens or even just a battlefield with two off threats this card really shines. Lastly, it is blue so it can be pitched.

Sideboard and Matchup Guides

If there is interest, leave a comment below and I will write up my current side board, a guide and describe the keys to some of the most common match ups.

Sorry this took a minute, real life stuff got in the way.

PART II The Manabase

1 Breeding Pool 1 Hallowed Fountain 1 Temple Garden

1 Flooded Strand 4 Misty Rainforest 4 Windswept Heath

1 Horizon Canopy 1 Waterlogged Grove 1 Field of Ruin

3 Snow-Covered Forest 3 Snow-Covered Island 1 Snow-Covered Plains

The manabase as been relatively unchanged for a few months for me. One of the biggest upgrades was going up to 3 Forest and 3 Islands. All of these basics help versus the R/G Ponza lists, the Path to Exile removal from U/W, and being able to escape Uro. Once you learn the proper sequencing the mana is so smooth. Which leads me to opening lands:

1 lander w/ no dork = mulligan

1 lander w/ dork = can you protect it with force to ensure you make a 2 drop? If you can't how many 2 drops do you have in hand to get rolling if you draw your 2nd land?

2 lander with or without a dork = The best opening sequence is Temple Garden into basic Island. You can cast all the 2 drops in your deck and regardless of your third land you can play all of your 3 drops except naturally casting Force of Negation. You are also half way to casting Uro and even farther along if you started with a turn one dork. Plains is the weakest land in the deck and is more to ensure your access to white as a color given the mana denial strategies. The banning of astrolabe has weakened the ability to have a turn 3 deathtouched Ice-Fang Coatl. But with Temple Garden into Island you have the freedom to fetch whatever you need in the future.

As I mentioned in Part I holding a land in the late game is very beneficial for Tireless Tracker and JTMS. Balance that with your need to fetch and add another card to the graveyard for Uro.

SIDEBOARD: 2 x Timely Reinforcements 2 x Rest in Peace 1 x On Thin Ice 1 x Celestial Purge 1 x Eidolon of Rhetoric 1 x Deputy of Detention 2 x Aether Gust 1 x Veil of Summer 1 x Knight of Autumn 2 x Ashiok, Dream Render 1 x Batterskull

Burn / UR Prowess +2 Timely Reinforcements +1 Batterskull +1 Celestial Purge or On Thin Ice +1 Eidolon of Rhetoric +2 Aether Gust

-1 Sword of Feast and Famine -1 Tireless Tracker -1 Jace, the Mind Sculptor -3 Teferi, Time Raveler -1 Spell Queller

Gameplan: Protect SFM with Force of Negation so that you can land a Batterskull. Hope that they Bolt your dork (which they should) which facilitates both SFM living and Timely Reinforcements. Eidolon slows down the game so you can hardcast Batterskull. These decks can grind decently well through Bedlam Reveler but boarding in Rest in Peace is not the answer. Pathing an early creature of theirs is a necessary evil however chumping is often a better strategy as the extra land really helps them and you need the PTE for their bigger creatures. The more that your opponent sideboards the more likely you are to win.

Jund / BR Control +1 Batterskull +2 Rest in Peace +1 Celestial Purge +1 Veil of Summer

-2 Force of Negation -2 Spell Queller -1 Stoneforege Mystic

Gameplan: Encourage your friends to play these black based attrition strategies because I love our matchup. There are some openings from Jund that can steam roll you so you have to be aware of these and play around them. The two cards I am most scared of are an early Wrenn and Six and well yimed Kolaghan's Command on your equipment. Both of these cards can be greater than 2 for 1s but more importantly they steal so much of your tempo (the ratio of mana spent to battlefield presence).You also have to be slightly aware of Boil in post game matchups, but games are often decided before Boil has an impact. Yes we are bringing Rest In Peace and leaving in Uro. We are going to do this in a few matchups and don't worry. The benefits of Rest In Peace turning Uro into a 3 mana, gain 3 life, explore is perfectly accetable. You blank a ton of Jund's "power" with RIP. So in all of the game 2 and 3s (and game 1 if you have scouted your opponent) consider if you play your turn and your opponent plays a Wrenn and Six. Sometimes this will help you play around it. Sometimes you will be forced into it. There is consideration for leaving the Force of Negations in to counter some of Junds more powerful spells but I haven't found a configuration that allows for that when a simple Inquisition of Kozilek can rip your hand apart.

Tron (not Eldrazi Tron) +2 Ashiok, Dream Render +1 Knight of Autumn +1 Deputy of Detention

-2 Path to Exile -2 Uro, Titan of Nature's Wrath

Gameplan: Stop them from assembling Tron. Given the current sideboard configuration, Bant Stoneblade is weak to Tron going over the top of us. We could have more counters like Disdainful Stroke or Ceremonious Rejection but those are too narrow for me right now. If the meta shifts or if your LGS is full of Tronners we will have to follow suite. If that is the case you can board out more Spell Quellers for these hard counters. Back to our plan, we have to aggressively counter their ways to get their Tron pieces, perhaps land a turn 2 Ashiok, but most importantly start connecting with Sword of Feast and Famine. Tron still only needs one top deck to crush your game so don't sit there and pout when they rip something of the top. That's often how close this matchup can be. We are leaving in 2 PTE for Wurmcoil Engine, Thought-Knot Seer (or other sideboarded creatures), or in the rare case as ypur only out to reseolved Ulamog. This is another matchup where the more your opponent sideboards the more likely you are to win.

Quick Aside: A couple matchups in and we are already boarding some Spell Quellers out. SQ can be the most back breaking card for your opponents to play against but in these matchups, specifically post board you have different game plans/more efficient cards. Don't under estimate the the SQ.

U/W and UWr control -2 Path to Exile up to 3 if their sideboard plan doesn't include creatures -1 Stoneforge Mystic -1 Detention Sphere or Birds of Paradise

+1 Batterskull +1 Veil of Summer +2 Rest in Peace +1 Knight of Autumn (consider if they have enchantment removal)

Gameplan: Have fun. This matchup is one of the most fun to play as you can put your opponent on the back foot, especially if you have won game 1. This is by no means an easy match up but you do have the tools. Lets break this down piece by piece. UW is gonna have a bunch of PTEs and Field of Ruins so you need to fetch your shocklands and keep your basics in your deck. Save your Field of Ruin for either their Ruins (when tapped out) or Celestial Colonade. This however brings me to the next point is Shark Typhoon. This card drastically changes the way we approach this match up. UW's ability to be mana efficent and apply pressure at instand speed gives us more to consider. We need to leave some PTEs in to combat this card or other sideboard swerves like Monastery Mentor. Next, you have to decide if you are playing the Teferi battle early game. You want to be playing at instant speed as often as possible so 3 mana Teferi becomes a huge sticking point. If your sideboard has room for more Mystical Disputes this gets much easier. So much like the Jund matchup with Wrenn and Six your early game always needs to be considering what happens if you pass your turn and your opponent plays a Teferi. Spell Queller is your biggest swiss army knife in these matchups. Always consider Spell Quelling your own spell when being countered or responded to which puts your opponent's removal in weird situations that can create tempo for you. (Game 1 you can use PTE in the same way to ramp your own creatures into lands to try amd go over your opponent. Those PTEs would have been dead anyway.) The extra Batterskull is to have more threats as UW usually has a few ways to remove artifacts. If this removal is enchantment based thats what Knight of Autumn is for, while being a decent beater on its own. Lastly, this is another match up where Uro and Rest in Peace exsist in the same configuration. Mystic Sanctuary, Frantic Inventory, Snapcaster Mage, and some other sideboard swerves like Elspeth are drastically impacted. UW, since Mystic Sanctuary, have been more hesitant to play Rest in Peace versus midrange but if you see one in game 2 you have a plan. "Guess I need to board put these Uros!" you comment as your actually board out your Rest in Peaces. Get wrecked kid.

One more note here, be aware of your clock. On MTGO I play out each game to its finish as these decks that just want to turtle and ultimate Teferi should be forced to play more magic. No affront to UW players but I am going to use the parameters of the platform to beat you however I can. In real life you gotta scoop when there's no chance to give you the oppurtunity to win the next game(s).

UW Stoneblade Decks Addendum

The above still apllies to UW decks with stoneforge mystic. Treat these decks like UW control but analysis what aspect of the UW control deck has been cut for the SFM package and adjuat ypur sideboard game accordingly. UW Stoneblade's biggeat issue is sword carriers. There is reason to keep more of your PTEs in as they struggle to play enough creatures. If my opponent does have the SFM package Knight of Autumn is for sure coming in to snipe an equipment. Opposing Shark Typhoons help UW solve this issue but again at what cost to their "control" side of the matchup.

Scapeshift Variants -4 Path to Exile (if they have Uro this is still correct. You can bounce Uro and you are bringing in RIP) -1 Tireless Tracker (any decks that can "go off" means that Tireless Tracker should be boarded out)

+2 Aether Gust +2 Ashiok, Dream Render +2 Reat in Peace (this one is more correct if you see Mystic Sanctuary and Uro)

Gameplan: Tempo, tempo, tempo. Bob and weave with your instant speed plays without having to worry about Teferi, yeah!!!! Prioritze the Sword of Feast and Famine, get a hit in and get ahead. Try and save Aether Gust for Primeval Titan, Spell Queller for Scapeshift and Cryptic Command. There is also consideration for On Thin Ice and Deputy of Detention to combat some of their creatures without ramping them, especially in game 3.

Primeval Titan decks function very similarly to these Scapeahift decks and may even have some of the same cards. However, if you are playing an AmuLIT version there is a different sideboard gameplan. I am specifially putting Valakut + Mountaims as the cards that switch your thinking. If they have those, go with the plan above, if not go with the plan below. (Dryad of the Illysian Grove decks still fall under the "don't" category.

-1 Tireless Tracker -1 Ice Fang Coatl -1 Spell Queller -1 SFM

+2 Aether Gust +1 Deputy of Detention +2 Ashiok, Dream Render +1 Veil of Summer (blue versions with counter magic)

Gameplan: Path their creatures preferably Primeval Titan and loop Detention Sphere and Deputy of Detention to take care of their zombie horde. Your equipment really shines in this matchup.

E-Tron +1 Knight of Autumn +1 Ashiok, Dream Render (could be 2 depending on play/draw)

-1 Stoneforge Mystic -1 Detention Sphere -1 Uro (if they have Relic maindeck, especially if you play some in the first game)

Gameplan: This is a Jund-ish matchup without your opponent's having discard. The entire game revolves around trading resources until you can counter an All is Dust. Spell Queller is fantastic against the majority of their deck as they lack removal. Rant here, the fact that this deck gets to play Dismember pisses me off. Such a color pie mistake. End rant. Quick tron starts into big creatures can be an issue but PTE can help even it out.

RG Ponza -2 JTMS -1 SFM

+2 Aether Gust +1 Knight of Autumn

Gameplan: You have to balance out their acceleration into BBE and other big dragons with their acceleration into Blood Moons, Chandras, and Klothys. You have the proper answers in your deck to both sides of this equation but you may draw the wrong half of your deck. Ice-Fang Coatl pulls a lot of weight here as a cantrip and as some of the only ways to remove a creature that has protection from white. You only need one of each color to operate now that you have boarded out your Jaces. They are also weak against BBE (as WOTC intended). So fetching basics is ok. Uro is more of an afterthought especially with Scavenging Ooze and Klothys. Again, if your opponent sees Uro in game 1, making a comment about it during sideboarding to influence your opponent to board in 4 Relic of Progenitus is a sweet trick.

Aggro/Combo Creature decks (Merfolk, Humans, and Goblins) -3 Force of Negations -1 JTMS

+1 Deputy of Detention +1 On Thin Ice +1 Veil of Summer (situational) or Aether Gust or Batterskull +1 Knight of Autumn

Gameplan: If you ever see an Aether Vial in game 1, Force of Negation it. Your Force is likely dead and the tempo your opponent will gain is often lights out. In games 2 and 3 you have better tools to fight your opponents gameplan. Also these aggro decks have some weird sideboarding plana where they think they can side out the Aether Vials and out grind you. Knight of Autumn is serviceable if they keep Aether Vials in. These are matchups where the more your opponent boards the better off you are. Veil can be a great card versus Goblins or Humans or Merfolk if they cast a removal creature or spell. Aether Gust versus the Goblins is very nice.

If you have gotten this far here is another piece of awesome advice. In all of these guides I have left Censor in because to me its a cantrip with the upside of countering something. If you are worried about cutting another piece feel free to cut Censor instead. It reduces your ability to see more cards but can ease you into going all in on the game plans listed above.

**** If I have missed a match up that you experience a bunch or want me to go into a specific match up even more in depth, by all means leave a comment below.****

EDIT: Added Mana base and Sideboard Guide


r/Stoneblade • • Sep 09 '19

Modern Here's the Jeskai Stoneblade list that Won Team Modern GP Indy

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/Stoneblade • • Sep 30 '19

General - Modern UW Control or UW Stoneblade in Modern? John "Do0mSwitch" Star gives us his insights!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
28 Upvotes

r/Stoneblade • • Sep 06 '20

Tournament Report - Modern My First Week as a Stoneblade Player (Results, what's working and what's not)

27 Upvotes

What's poppin? My name is Elijah. I am a long time Magic player, and I have been playing Modern since it's creation. Jeskai Control with Thundermaw Hellkites and Cryptic Command was my first deck. Man, how the times have changed. Since then I've borrowed and played pretty much every deck known to be powerful in the format (and mostly played Gifts Store when I didn't know what to play). This week, I decided that I was going to become a better man. I drunkenly ordered most of foil UW Stoneblade and found this subreddit. I'm here to breathe some life back into it.

This week was the first time I had cast Stoneforge Mystic in Modern, though I played her when Deathblade was big in Legacy, and a lot in Standard. I always thought of playing Modern as "linear gameplan only or I lose" and boy am I glad I drank a 6 pack of Blue Moon last Friday because getting into this deck was a great decision. Onto the deck!

Creatures x7

3 Snapcaster Mage

4 Stoneforge Mystic]

Instants and Sorceries x19

2 Spell Snare

4 Opt

4 Path to Exile

2 Mana Leak

2 Archmage's Charm

3 Shark Typhoon

2 Cryptic Command

Planeswalkers x5

2 Jace, the Mind Sculptor

2 Teferi, Time Raveler

1 Teferi, Hero of Dominaria

Artifacts x3

1 Sword of Feast and Famine

1 Batterskull

1 Sword of Fire and Ice

Lands x24

4 Flooded Strand

3 Misty Rainforest

3 Hallowed Fountain

1 Celestial Colonnade

2 Mystic Sanctuary

4 Field of Ruin

5 Island

2 Plains

2 Force of Negation

Sideboard x15

2 Timely Reinforcements

2 Aether Gust

2 Celestial Purge

1 Condemn

2 Disdainful Stroke

2 Ceremonious Rejection

1 Detention Sphere

2 Supreme Verdict

1 Vendilion Clique

Cards arrived on Wednesday 30 minutes before the tournament so my GF and I had to race up there while she sleeved my deck and her Bogles deck (fuck bogles me and my homies hate bogles).

Wednesday Tournament

Round One: 2-0'd GB Midrange

Round Two: 0-2'd Bant Uroza

Round Three: 2-1'd Bogles (my gf)

Round Four: 2-0'd Grixis Death Shadow

Overall 3-1

At this point, I was pretty happy with the deck. I did not know how to beat the Uroza match up at all, but fair match ups felt amazing. Equipping Sharks with Swords is a wet dream.

Thursday we drove down 30 minutes to another shop I had never played at. Only 6 of us there, but we played three rounds

Thursday Tournament

Round One: 2-1'd Humans

Round Two: 2-0'd Jund

Round Three: 2-1'd Bogles (my gf again, I'm gonna be honest this match up his horse shit)

Overall 6-1

Hell yeah, brother. I am cleaning up on tournaments right now. I was feeling very confident about the deck and was having a lot of fun! This build felt okay, but I noticed a lot of hands I was not drawing enough lands, but I told myself I wasn't gonna change anything for the first week to get some details.

Friday's Tournament. Notes about this tournament, this one is probably one of the harder tournaments. The match ups I don't feel like I was favored in much, but again, I'm new so I'm probably wrong.

Friday Night Modern

Round One Bye 1-0

Round Two: 2-0'd Mono Red Prowess

Round Three: 2-1'd Bogles (Yee fucking haw)

Round Four: 2-1'd Humans

Overall 9-1

Today (Saturday) I decided to go ahead and purchase the deck on MTGO and play in the Challenge since I had so much success. I figured the people I would play on MTGO would be MUCH better than the average player around me. I didn't expect much at all, and though I didn't do well, I did better than I anticipated.

9/5 Modern Challenge on MTGO

Round One: 2-0'd Mono Green Tron

Round Two: 2-0'd RW Prison

Round Three: 0-2'd Bogles (I hate Bogles Players)

Round Four: 1-2'd Bant Uro

Round Five: 2-0'd Bogles (haha I hate bogles players)

Round Six: 2-0'd Dredge (mulled to 4 both games :/)

Round Seven: 2-1'd Slivers

Round Eight: 0-2'd Izzet Blitz

Overall Record for the Week: 14-4 (71% win rate)

After this week of playing, here are my thoughts and notes. I'd love to discuss with you all. :)

  • I always felt like I was on the back foot. Never did I feel ahead in my games until either a Batterskull did damage, or a Feast of Famine trigger happened.

  • Shark Typhoon is good, but the deck feels so clunky. I think I need to be more aggressive with cycling to draw, rather than making Sharks.

  • Archmage's Charm was either the best card in the deck, or felt horrible. I probably didn't board it out enough.

  • Jace feels week, but needed. Teferi feels a bit stronger in most situations with having more loyalty and plus-ing him doesn't feel as bad in most situations as fate sealing.

  • Stoneforge Mystic is MUCH better than I thought it would be. It was a rampant growth, didn't get killed too often by bolt, and even blocks pretty decently.

  • Spell Snare is nuts, keep playing it.

  • I had lots of mana problems. Not drawing enough. I dunno if that's just me, or if that's how the deck genuinely feel.

Hopefully next week I can do another update if this is helpful to anyone. I'd love to discuss the deck in detail, teach me how to be a better Stoneblade player!!


r/Stoneblade • • Sep 22 '19

Tournament Report - Modern Face2Face 3k Winning Decklist!

27 Upvotes

Hey after winning GP Indianapolis I made some changes to my list and took it to the 3k in my city this past saturday. Was 6-0-1 after swiss and won the tournament! Attached is the deck list. I made a sideboard guide in the comments.

https://www.mtggoldfish.com/deck/2276605#paper


r/Stoneblade • • Feb 26 '21

Fluff Old border True Name

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/Stoneblade • • Jun 22 '21

General - Modern This sub is slow but innovation isn’t

23 Upvotes

Morning, stoneblade aficionados. Over the last few weeks there have been major changes to the modern metagame, and tons of new tools for the toolbox that is stoneforge mystic. There are more viable versions of stoneblade today than there was a week ago, a year ago, or back when squadron hawk was a magic card. I’d love to hear about what you have been testing, and how it’s gone.

I plan on making a short tournament report later this evening as I test out the counter - ragavan style Jeskai list. From gold fishing, play testing, and listening to too many streams at work, the Jeskai list is my current favorite blade variant. It showcases how busted [[Ragavan, Nimble Pilferer]] can be and capitalizes best on the extra mana they provide to land Jace earlier, counter spells, and keep mana open while playing the Mystic. Anecdotally, not once but twice over the weekend I stole and played my opponents [[Teferi, Time Raveler]] on turn two.

However, it’s clear that Esper lists utilizing [[Esper Sentinel]] are very good, and [[Ephemerate]] plans can be backed up well by a stoneblade package. Has anyone here messed with Esper or b/w lists yet? I’ve even seen Mardu and Abzan lists pop up in my local meta, likely due to the efficient removal accessed by these colors.

I don’t know about you but right now feels like a good time to have the stoneblade pieces, and a good time to test jamming them into your favorite color pairing. And that’s not even mentioning how busted [[Kaldra compleat]] is for our package. Like, am I cutting main deck swords now? Maybe. Anyway, that’s just me trying to drum up some conversation on this sub. May you never draw batterskull in your opener, and good luck brewing.


r/Stoneblade • • Oct 08 '19

Article/Guide - Modern I wrote a short "article" on when to search up which equipment in UW Stoneblade, hope some of you find it interesting

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
22 Upvotes

r/Stoneblade • • Oct 06 '19

General - Modern Jeskai Stoneblade decklist Comparison and Breakdown

22 Upvotes

A couple of days ago I made this post comparing and analyzing all 5-0 UW Stoneblade decklists from the weekly MTGO League dumps. Now it's time for Jeskai to get the same treatment. Here's the spreadsheet I made for it (it's on a different page on the same excel document).

As I mentioned on the other post:

Initially I wanted to include sideboards on this but it proved harder than I expected as there is way too much variance between them. I will keep updating this spreadsheet as more lists get published.

This is what I believe the "average decklist" would look like for Jeskai:

Creatures (12-17):

4 Snapcaster Mage

4 Stoneforge Mystic

4 Spell Queller

Planeswalkers (3-5):

3 Teferi, Time Raveler

2 Jace, the Mind Sculptor

Spells (15-19):

4 Opt

2 Path to Exile

4 Lightning Bolt

4 Lightning Helix

2 Spell Snare

2 Spell Pierce

Artifacts (2):

1 Sword of Feast and Famine

1 Batterskull

Lands (23):

2 Celestial Colonnade

4 Flooded Strand

4 Scalding Tarn

2 Hallowed Fountain

1 Steam Vents

2 Sacred Foundry

2 Spirebluff Canal

2 Inspiring Vantage

2 Island

1 Plains

1 Mountain

This time around, however, I'm not as confident on it as I was about the UW Stoneblade "average list". This version of the deck has more variance than UW and therefore it's harder to make this sort of thing, but I'll get into more of that on my observations below.

Starting with the creatures, as usual, 4 Snap, 4 SFM and 4 Spell Queller is pretty much the true creature-core of the deck. Occasionally we see 2 copies of Geist being played which are usually accompanied by 3 Giver of Runes. Other creatures like Clique and Resto are also occasionally played albeit much less frequently. Given this, we usually see decks either running 12-13 creatures or 16-17. For my "average list" I decided to go with the first option, but either one would be fine.

Regarding the planeswalker suite, almost every list ran 3 T3feri. Its interaction with Queller makes it an auto-include in this deck. It also aligns perfectly with what Jeskai wants to be doing. After disappearing for some weeks, it seems like Jace is back. The last four 5-0 lists all ran 2 copies of it (alongside 3 T3feri). Although this isn't always the rule, we usually see Jace being played in the lists that only run 12-13 creatures.

As for the spells, almost every list ran the full set of bolts (which makes sense since it is one of the main reasons to be on these colours) as well as 2-4 Lightning Helix. Between Bolt, Path and Helix, Jeskai runs a lot of spot removal, with the average amount of it being about 10 spells. Spell Pierce also seems to be a lot more popular in Jeskai than it is in UW Stoneblade. Finally, Jeskai doesn't lean that heavily into maindeck countermagic, altough some lists do play Mana Leak, Cryptic and/or Force.

Moving on to the blades, although the Sword of Feast and Famine plus Batterskull combination is still by far the most common, some lists have opted for Sword of Fire and Ice over Feast of Famine which is something we did not observe on UW Stoneblade. Double batterskull was also never seen, although triple blades still occasionally shows up.

Finally onto the lands. This is one of the areas I had the most trouble breaking down. 23 Lands seems to be the general rule for Jeskai (as oposed to 24 lands which is what UW plays). The most common setup consists of:

  • 2 Colonnades

  • 8 fetches (usually 4 Strands and 4 Tarns)

  • 4-5 shocks (usually with more copies of Hallowed Fountain than the other two)

  • 3-6 fast lands (this varied a bit more)

  • 4 basics (usually 2 islands, 1 plains, 1 mountain)

Well, and that is all this time. Vote here to let me know which Stoneblade variant decklist comparison and breakdown you'd like to see next. I'm thinking of doing Abzan next (since I haven't touched on the BWx variants yet) unless I get a lot of requests for something else.

Thanks for reading, I hope this was useful in some way :)

Updated October 6, 2019


r/Stoneblade • • Dec 13 '19

General - Modern Bant Snowblade decklist Comparison and Breakdown

21 Upvotes

A couple of months ago (before Eldraine), I made two posts comparing all 5-0 Stoneblade lists for Jeskai and UW Stoneblade respectively (you can find them by clicking those links). I didn't do one for Bant at the time because it was nowhere near as popular as its other two counterparts. Well, that's no longer the case. With Oko's arrival to the format, Bant has risen to become Modern's best and most popular Stoneblade variant.

So, here it is, at last, the long awaited spreadsheet for Bant that some of you requested. This time I also made a sideboard comparison, which is something the other two posts were missing. I'll only be analyzing decks that 5-0'd since the release of Eldraine, since the decks prior to that looked quite different.

Let's get started. Here is what the "average decklist" looks like for Bant:

Creatures (16):

4 Noble Hierarch

4 Stoneforge Mystic

4 Ice-Fang Coatl

4 Spell Queller

Starting with the creatures, it's worth mentioning that almost every deck ran at the very least these 4 creatures and usually went with a full playset of each. Some decks opted to run a few additional creatures, but none of them were very popular or showed up in more than two or three separate lists.

Planeswalkers (7):

3 Oko, Thief of Crowns

2 Teferi, Time Raveler

2 Jace, the Mind Sculptor

The planeswalker suite is also pretty straightforward. Almost every deck ran 3 Oko, 2 or 3 T3feri and 1 or 2 Jace. The majority of them went with a 3:2:2 layout. Playing the third T3feri was quite common in the first couple of weeks but more recent lists opted to go with only 2.

Spells (9):

4 Path to Exile

2 Mana Leak

3 Force of Negation

There's no reason not to run a full playset of Path and 3 Force of Negation in a deck like this, as those are pretty much the best removal and countermagic spells available for a deck like this. Mana Leak comes close in popularity, with almost every deck playing a pair of copies, but it took a little longer for it to catch on, as older lists weren't running it. Spell Pierce is also a decent option, though it wasn't that popular.

Artifacts (6):

4 Arcum's Astrolab

1 Sword of Feast and Famine

1 Batterskull

Moving on to the artifacts, aside from the mandatory Batterskull and Sword of Feast and Famine, which most if not all blue-based Stoneblade decks should be running, Bant also has access to Arcum's Astrolab since it is running so many snow basics. Most lists chose to run the full playset since it's great for mana fixing, replaces itself and acts as extra Elk fodder for Oko later on in the game. It is pretty much never a dead card no matter what stage of the game you're at. A couple of lists also played Sword of Fire and Ice as their third maindeck sword but none replaced Sword of Feast and Famine with it.

Lands (22):

3 Prismatic Vista

3 Misty Rainforest

1 Flooded Strand

3 Windswept Heath

1 Breeding Pool

1 Hallowed Fountain

1 Temple Garden

1 Horizon Canopy

2 Field of Ruin

2 Snow-Covered Island

2 Snow-Covered Plains

2 Snow-Covered Forest

Most decks ran 9 or 10 fetchlands (usually 3 or 4 of which were Prismatic Vista), one of each bant shockland, one or two Horizon lands and 5 or 6 snow-covered basics, making 21 or 22 lands in total. Field of Ruin has gained more popularity recently, with most lists running a couple copies now. Other utility lands (like Moorland Haunt or Gavony Township) and fastlands were also played in some decks but their inclusion was quite rare.

Sideboard:

1 Engineered Explosives

2 Veil of Summer

1 Celestial Purge

1 Disdainful Stroke

2 Rest in Peace

2 Damping Sphere

2 Timely Reinforcements

2 Mystical Dispute

1 Ashiok, Dream Render

1 Supreme Verdict

Finally, the sideboard was probably the most inconsistent part of the deck as you'd expect. This is part of the reason I didn't include it on my previous two posts. I won't go into much detail here since it largely depends on the meta you're facing, but I found these 15 cards to show up the most frequently.

That's all for now. I hope you found my deck comparison and data analysis helpful in any way. I might make an updated version in the future (and update my other two posts as well) if the format sees a major shake-up or Bant stops being the top Stoneblade variant for some reason.


r/Stoneblade • • Oct 03 '19

General - Modern UW Stoneblade decklist Comparison and Reflection

21 Upvotes

I made a spreadsheet comparing all the UW Stoneblade lists that were posted on the weekly Modern League dumps since the SFM unban. You can find a compilation of all the 5-0 Stoneblade decks that WotC shared on the Modern League Results post I made on r/Stoneblade.

Initially I wanted to include sideboards on this but it proved harder than I expected as there is way too much variance between them.

I will keep updating this spreadsheet as more lists get published. I'm planing on doing something similar for Jeskai Stoneblade next (if people are interested) and perhaps for the other Stoneblade variants as well, further down the road.

So without further ado, based on the data I collected, here's what I believe the average UW Stoneblade list looks like:

Creatures (9-10):

4 Snapcaster Mage

4 Stoneforge Mystic

0-2 Spell Queller

0-2 Vendillion Clique

Planeswalkers (5):

2-3 Teferi, Time Raveler

2-3 Jace, the Mind Sculptor

Spells (18-20):

4 Opt

4 Path to Exile

2-3 Spell Snare

2 Mana Leak

3 Force of Negation

2-3 Cryptic Command

0-1 Supreme Verdict

Artifacts (2):

1 Sword of Feast and Famine

1 Batterskull

Lands (24):

2 Celestial Colonnade

4 Flooded Strand

2 Hallowed Fountain

2 Glacial Fortress

4 Field of Ruin

2 Secondary Fetchland (either Ux fetches, Prismatic Vista, or a split between the two)

6 Island

2 Plains

On the spreadsheet, the cards marked green are what I consider to be part of the core of the deck, or at least, what most people were running. Cards marked yellow are slight deviations from the rule (for example, playing 2 or 4 Force when most people play 3). Cards marked red are outliers.

Regarding the creature suite, most lists ran 1-2 other creatures besides the Snapcaster + SFM core. A couple weeks ago playing 1-2 Clique was more common but recently people have shifted more towards playing Spell Queller instead.

Running 5 Walkers was the most common option with T3feri and Jace being by far the most picked. Lists usually played 2 T3feri and 3 Jace or 2 Jace and 3 T3feri.

The deck also runs a pretty large spell suite to fuel Snap and protect the SFM plan. The biggest variance here usually boils down to whether the deck runs maindeck Verdict (usually a single copy) or not. Some decks also played other alternative removal spells on that flex slot like Oust and Dismember. Dismember in particular was pretty popular for a while until it fell out of favor.

Regarding the blades, almost every deck played at least one batterskull which was usually paired with Sword of Feast and Famine. Some decks opted to play 2 Batterskull and nothing else. Some added Sword of Fire and Ice as the 3rd blade, but none played it over Sword of Feast and Famine.

The mana base was probably what remained the most constant across all decks, with almost all of them running 24 lands and following the standard land layout we are used to seeing in traditional UW Control. They usually only differed on which fetches they had besides the 4 Flooded Strands.

Link to r/ModernMagic thread.

Updated October 1, 2019


r/Stoneblade • • May 28 '21

General Info I'll be trying this out in BW stoneblade

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/Stoneblade • • Oct 02 '19

Article/Guide - Modern Esper Stoneblade Primer

20 Upvotes

It's not mine but I found this Primer for Esper Stoneblade already using some Eldraine cards and thought more people would find it useful.


r/Stoneblade • • Jan 30 '22

Spoiler Discussion [Neo]Lion Sash

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/Stoneblade • • Mar 29 '23

Spoiler Discussion Sword of Once and Future

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/Stoneblade • • Jun 23 '21

Counter-Ragavan/Jeskai MonkeyBlade Tournament Report

Thumbnail self.modernmagic
18 Upvotes

r/Stoneblade • • Feb 15 '21

B&R announcement should be good for us in both Modern and Legacy

Thumbnail
magic.wizards.com
18 Upvotes

r/Stoneblade • • Jul 13 '20

General - Modern Death of Arcum rise of stoneblade

18 Upvotes

With the death of Astrolabe in modern I'm ready to jump ship from bant snow back to my roots of uw stoneblade. I am planning to start with a list like this one.

https://mtgdecks.net/Modern/uw-stoneforge-decklist-by-lirek154-986827

Has anyone played with any core21 cards in a core like this yet? I've heard the new AK is pretty good but I wouldn't know where to start with cuts. Where are you all planning on starting? Are you playing any 5feri? I love me some bolt, any spicy jeskai blade lists?


r/Stoneblade • • Sep 30 '19

Tournament Report - Modern Bant Stoneblade Tournament Report and Deck Tech SCG IQ Finals

18 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I recently went 7-1-1 with Bant Stoneblade at a recent Modern SCG IQ. I wrote a little deck tech and tournament report here if you are interested:

http://themagiccenter.com/articles/strategy/bant-stoneblade-deck-tech-and-tournament-report/