r/Stoicism • • Nov 06 '24 Hehehe

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance I need to withstand the boasting from all my red-voting coworkers tomorrow.

0 Upvotes

I voted blue and I'm heartbroken and disenchanted and just kind of done. I know it is practically going to be a party at my workplace tomorrow and I need to not get fired for speaking my mind.


r/Stoicism • • Nov 06 '24

Stoicism in Practice Handling the Election Results

0 Upvotes

Hello, my friends.

There's probably a lot of us here who are trying to come to grips with the results of the election. As the father of a 4-year old girl, I am having my own struggles with it, as well. Watching the winds change throughout the night I started to fall into a deep despair, resenting my fellow man for their choices that would affect my daughter's future.

I became sick with anger and fear, and felt the need to lash out at the next Trump supporter I saw. In that moment, I thought to myself, "I don't want to feel this way. What is in my control?"

The words of Marcus Aurelius rang through my head. "All these things happen to them by reason of their ignorance of what is good and evil." We can't hold anger towards these people, because they don't even know the difference between right and wrong. And "All is opinion" anyways, perhaps it's my own views that are flawed. What good would come from turning myself into an extremist? Nothing. Any energy I spend on this would be energy that I could spend on my wife and daughter, who need me now more than ever.

There are plenty of other people who are feeling helpless in these uncertain times right now, and they're in danger of turning to anger instead of reason. I implore all of you to focus your energy on finding those people and help guide them towards reason, or else the problem is in danger of becoming much bigger. That's not to say you should invalidate their feelings, however. Help them realize what is in their sphere of control and how to best react to it. But above all, listen to them, because sometimes that's all they need.

"We have two ears and one mouth, so we are meant to listen twice as much as we speak." -Epictetus


r/Stoicism • • Apr 24 '22

Stoic Theory/Study Female/POC Stoics, are there any?

2 Upvotes

Great philosophy is great, regardless of the source—bug I find myself wondering why stoicism often lives in the sphere of the “white male”, even in contemporary examples. I believe it’s a great school of thought and would be curious if anyone has sources that extend beyond the typical eurocentric/androcentric perspectives that are often lauded in stoic philosophy.


r/Stoicism • • May 17 '22

Stoic Meditation Marty Byrde from Netflix show Ozark is a quintessential Stoic

11 Upvotes

If someone saw the show, you know exactly what I'm talking about. I highly suggest you watch it because its really good


r/Stoicism • • Jul 29 '23

Seeking Stoic Advice I have cheated and now I'm heartbroken, in need of stoic guidance

1 Upvotes

I cheated on my ex-girlfriend (Whom I'm still close with) whilst we were in a committed relationship and she found out now she never wants to see me again, breaking my heart. I never told her and hid it because I was too ashamed, insecure and afraid of the consequence. I have lost a person who I deeply cared about and likely also a lot of our coming friends.

I have betrayed my own morals and principles. I don't know what to do now and feel really lost.

Update:

Thanks to everyone who provided me with advice, I appreciate it dearly.

I'm not looking for empathy pity or salvation. I'm well aware of facing the consequences of my actions. Not only have I lost somebody who I deeply care about, I have also hurt her in a way that may effect the rest of her life. That's where the pain truly comes from and it shook me to my core.

I'm here because I'm lost and broken. I am looking for rebuild myself from the ground up and and get on the right part. I just don't know where to start.


r/Stoicism • • Sep 10 '25

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance Trump and his prayers in schools

5 Upvotes

Learning about how trump wants to make kids pray in schools is genuinely making me depressed. My dad is obsessed with trump and every morning when i wake up i have to see his dumb face on the tv and it makes me irrationally angry. Is it possible to be neutral on this? Is that even what I should do? Bc the anger feels pointless when theres nothing i can do to help the situation.


r/Stoicism • • Jan 16 '25

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance How to remain stoic as a man, when it comes to the blatantly obvious double standards in similar situations with women?

0 Upvotes

I'm really struggling with this one. I'm generally pretty care-free nowadays but the one thing that continues to trigger me on a day to day basis is the existence of double standards in todays society in men vs women. I work in a female dominant workplace and am the only male working in a team of a dozen women. I am pretty close knit with these girls so it's nothing too serious, but here are some examples.

- A few months ago one of the girls who goes to the gym regularly was talking about how she was "too big" to fit in a mini skirt anymore. I jokingly stated it was because she was "too jacked" from her gym routine and flexed at her, which upset her and they proceeded to tell me off for "body shaming" her. She brought this up again today and I pointed out a recent instance where she had "body shamed" me. She had seen a tall bloke walking down the hallway and one of our colleagues made a reference to how he was hot, but probably married because he was so tall. They then both jokingly stated how this is why I was still single, because I was short. I brought this up to the group and they all just laughed and high fived the girl for a good joke and told me to stop over-reacting. They always make similar comments about men who are bald etc. but god forbid I say anything negative about a woman's appearance.

- Sometimes delirious male patients act inappropriately towards the girls making sexual comments, trying to touch them etc. and they all complain about men being pigs and rally around one another in support and solidarity when it happens. The same thing happens to me with female patients, where they will grab or slap my ass, but it's all just a big joke amongst everyone and if I attempt to say that it's just as inappropriate for me as it is for them, they just say "well now you know how it feels to be a woman".

- I'm casually dating and make my intentions clear from the get go and when I don't "feel it" I'll meet with the girl face to face, let her know respectfully and make a clean break. I'm subsequently labeled as a fuckboy and a player amongst the girls. But they will openly talk about how they'll be seeing a guy and suddenly "get the ick" and ghost him, and all support one another by saying "he just wasn't the one, you just weren't feeling it, you don't owe him an explanation because you owe him nothing". I'll point out that this is exactly what I do except I have the courtesy of confronting the person face to face and giving them an explanation, whilst the girls just ghost the guys they're seeing and thir explanation is something along the lines of well "men don't deserve an explanation because they're probably ghosted someone too" etc.

The situations themself don't bother me much at all. It's the principal that I am condemned for doing the same thing that these women are doing, yet when they are doing it, it's celebrated? It's not just reserved to this group either, it happens amongst every "girl group" I have ever been involved with.


r/Stoicism • • Dec 28 '25

Stoic Banter Should women study stoicism just the same as men?

0 Upvotes

I myself can't find reason why any difference should be made between men and women when it comes to studying philosophy. Musonius Rufus, the teacher of Epictetus, talks about this in his lectures 3 and 4 which can be read here.

Musonius seemed ahead of his time, but since then a lot of cultural change has taken place. Women now have more opportunity to study philosophy in many parts of the world. This seems like good progress to me because:

  • Why would women not be able to study philosophy and correct false beliefs equal to men?

  • Why should a woman not try to live the best possible life?

  • Even if you do adhere to more traditional views of gender roles (such as that a woman should primarily tend the home and raise children and a man should primarily provide and protect) how does that affect the two questions above? Would it only be helpful to a man that he develops into a more just, temperate, courageous and wise person?

I do suspect the community here will agree with Musonius but I was curious due to some recent activity, what do you think?


r/Stoicism • • Mar 22 '23

Seeking Stoic Advice What does stoicism say on masturbation? NSFW

2 Upvotes

On one hand, masturbation is healthy, but on the other hand I can see stoicism oppose it. (I'm not talking about hours upon hours of watching porn, I mean masturbation without any sort of outer connection)


r/Stoicism • • Sep 17 '24

Stoic Banter A genuine discussion regarding Mods to please Ban all the hate/useless post regarding Ryan Holiday.

0 Upvotes

DISCLAIMER:

Please read the ENTIRE thing before coming to a conclusion about anything. If mods think this post is in-appropriate, they can and should remove as they wish. I have no intentions of breaking any rules and not break anyone's heart. I'm just trying to discuss a situation.

Also, I'm not a bot or anything like that and am not even Ryan Holdiay myself with new account lmao. I personally don't know him either or not a fangirl, but I admire his work. So, please don't hate on me, as I'm just pointing out what I have been seeing on this sub.

===========

So, over the years I have been seeing many of post regarding Ryan Holiday (more than 2 years now), and every time I see it's pure hatred toward his product or him being not Stoic or a bad seller or something along the lines.

Now, I don't consider myself as a “professional” in Stoicism or anything like that, but it's ridiculous the amount of hate he gets for selling overpriced books, coins, courses and what not. Isn't that against the philosophy of Stoicism? Unnecessary hatred? I would understand if people were critical regarding the thing he said wrong in videos or wrong citation or misinterpretation, but no they are literally hate post that he is a “fake alpha male guru bro of stoicism” and some people even saying they would kill him (you know what post I'm talking about). I personally have not seen/bought his course or coins, but he was the first person I know who introduce me to Stoicism on YouTube.

All the people preaching that they should read the original Stoicism text fail to understand that a beginner or someone who is new to Stoicism don't know how to read that book. They think it's just another biography or novel that is supposed to be read in linear fashion, but no It's supposed to be read again and again over the course of years.

This is where his books come into play, they are more beginner-friendly and introduce Stoic materials with ease. I'm not saying his books are 100% perfect. I also know that they might come as “self-help books” to some people. But, I don't give a fuck about his political side that some people get triggered with. I think he and others have done more good to society than a fake guru like Andrew Tate, who is fucking up brains of this generation with women hate and misogynistic views.

If you find his books expensive, overpriced, hate coins, hate his course/newsletters, hate capitalism, hate rich people, hate the way he sells the book then it's simple… DON'T FUCKING BUY IT MAN? His entire life is books as he is an author, how do you expect him to earn money for his entire family by selling just books with royalties? It's not enough of course that is why his business model is harsh, but as someone who have seen worse than this I think this is nothing compared to other people. I myself am not rich and sometimes am wary of buying expensive stuff and books, but then I resolve by working hard and earning that money to satisfy my needs (sometimes I even pirate books and games online, honestly).

But guys, tbh, Why hate on someone you merely know as a person, when you can just ignore and move on if you don't like. If you think his videos are wrong, then please correct him by citing what is correct and what is wrong. That is called constructive criticism and that is something I think even as a newbie understands what Stoicism teaches rather than pure hatred for someone like him.

That's it. I will let mods do their job now and let community decide.

RANT END phew.


r/Stoicism • • Apr 27 '19

If you a stoic, why you post photo of books that you bought? What are you, a sheep that show eaten grass instead of growed wool?

0 Upvotes

r/Stoicism • • Jun 24 '25

Stoicism in Practice The best new job in response to AI is not plumber

0 Upvotes

For 40 years I looked for happiness everywhere... youth, good hair, status, health, money, nice house, loved ones, prestigious employer, great career...

Unsurprisingly, all those things betrayed me as I aged and life happened. They were gifts that Fortune randomly throws out and takes away.

Before AI I thought... "at least I'll always have a job/food/shelter/healthcare." I might not have status or good lucks anymore but I'll have security and my career which I enjoy.

But thanks to AI, it has shown me that I cannot depend on anything given by Fortune. I must depend on something that Fortune cannot give and therefore cannot take away... virtue, personal character.

That's not to say there won't be discomfort, humiliation, or living in Hoovervilles in my future.

But the road is now clear to me, that to walk the path of the great sages is the way to go (Tubero, Pius, maybe Cato). Of course I'm not saying to give up or that plumbing is not prudent.

The Buddhists have an interesting idea...

  • They believe in endless reincarnation

  • So Buddha asked his students, what is more, all the tears you've shed in all your lifetimes or all the water in the oceans? The students answer our tears

  • Then he asked what is taller, the bones of all the things you've killed or the Himalayas? The bones!

  • Now I don't believe in reincarnation, but as Marcus points out, seeking favor and fortune has been happening over and over since the age of Vespasian. People doing the exact same things

  • Marcus says: "The age of Vespasian, for example. People doing the exact same things: marrying, raising children, getting sick, dying, waging war, throwing parties, doing business, farming, flattering, boasting, distrusting, plotting, hoping others will die, complaining about their own lives, falling in love, putting away money, seeking high office and power. And that life they led is nowhere to be found."

  • How about instead I try something special for once? Or am I really just going to live my one life in the most boring way. Like a Tiberius or a Nero or some middling person

TLDR; Thank you AI for showing me what really matters in life, that virtue is the sole good and that it's insanity to depend on what Fortune might or might not throw out.

Has anyone else been pushed by AI towards more Stoicism?


r/Stoicism • • Nov 06 '24

Seeking Personal Stoic Guidance I'm going to need Stoicism after election

0 Upvotes

Well Hell. I just can't listen to the verbal diarea of this manchild. I can't listen to the pundents, broadcasters, or even comedians talk about this manchild. Another four years of this buffoon.

I was sick of him in the 80's. I knew what kind of man he was then. I'm going to need help.

I am so thankful that I went through Therapy last year. That I discovered Stoicism last year. I was able to clear out my head of nonsense garbage and focus on what's important. I think I'm really going to have to double down on my focus, my direction, anchor myself in my beliefs and moral compass.

I don't want to retreat into myself. That's not the way. I just can't let outside distraction derail my progress I've already made. I just can't rest on my laurels. I can't let other sideline my objectives.

This next four years is going to be a test. A test of patience, a test of will, a test not only of myself but others around me. Oh boy.

Must keep Perspective. Be present and centered in every moment. This is going to be a change. But change is good if you focus on the outcome, it's going through it that's bumpy and jarring.

Fucking Hell


r/Stoicism • • Dec 03 '23

Seeking Stoic Advice Struggling with sexual desire and buying sex NSFW

0 Upvotes

Although sex is a normal thing, as a single virgin 28M am struggling with it. Ideal solution would be to have a stable relationship with someone, and i can do it if i pursue. But i come from a conservative background where my parents won't accept it. I have been seeing a few woman online chat/call upon their recommendation, but i live in abroad (in a more liberal society), so the communication gap with the other people matters a lot. I have been away from my family over 5 years. I do need physical affection and love and hug in this single life (friends are not enough). I don't see myself getting married soon, and i have been seriously considering buying instead of wasting my 20s youth time just like that. Can’t deny that this sex drive may have affected my work. Ethically i am against porn and trafficking. But i am not sure what would be of me if i buy sex. In the end, i don't think i will find any open-minded woman who will accept my "past sex-buying" experience.

I think male sex drive is uniquely high. We can disregard it focusing on productive works, but that never vanishes the urge. The urge is like a pitfall, you will fall to it naturally if you roam near it, if the atmosphere provokes yourself. Then how do i confront this hidden energy? Whether i accept myself or obtain strategies to be blind to the sex drive- that's what i wonder.


r/Stoicism • • Feb 14 '25

Stoicism in Practice Were the Stoics Hypocrites?

0 Upvotes

Stoicism places extreme value on virtue, kindness, justice. All of the stoics adhere to these tenets.

Do these values jibe with the widespread practice of slavery?

I understand people will argue "slavery was just part of the culture." "It was a different time." "They were integral to the economy". "Marcus Aurelius was kind to his slaves."

My argument is that Stoicism and it's core values are timeless. What's good is always good. To me, in no circumstance, is slavery acceptable.

Was there some cognitive dissonance with leaders like MA? I understand that things like wealth and stoicism are not mutually exclusive, and I can accept that (although I may not like it). However, to me slavery and Stoicism absolutely are mutually exclusive.

Obviously MA extolled the values above, but he also had to know that slavery ,even as a concept, was wrong. He had no problem (apparently) of doing the right thing always, even against counsel. But why didn't he, as emperor, do something about slavery? You can't have your cake and eat it too.

What thoughts do you guys have on this, and how do you reconcile it?


r/Stoicism • • Oct 02 '23

New to Stoicism i'm starting to believe that stoicism doesn't really work.

3 Upvotes

i'm not here to hate on people that say it works for them but i'm reading currently the daily stoic and it says that you should know what's in your control and what's not in your and you should accept the things that are out of your control.

but here me out things sounds great on paper but today when shit hit the fan i couldn't say oh this is out of my control and i should accept it and move on. it didn't work like this for me, i thought about it i even slept without eating, i couldn't put what i read to practice.

and secondly if i have emotions about something outside of my control should i not process them should i just say it's out of my control and that's it?.


r/Stoicism • • Dec 11 '23

Seeking Stoic Advice What would the stoics have thought about eating animals in modern day?

6 Upvotes

After reading meditations, it's clear that Marcus Aurelius was focused on living within his own nature as a human being, and valued the humans ability to reason above everything.

On one hand, eating meat is human nature, we are clearly omnivores and have eaten meat as a species for as long as we've been around. However in modern day, eating meat isn't a requirement to live a healthy life, and the mass production of meat is widely thought to be inefficient and cruel, so using reason and the information we have available, eating meat wouldn't be the virtuous choice.

I've just been thinking about this lately, and thought there was a bit of a clash between our nature and our ability to reason in this area. There's probably more stuff like this as the modern world is so different to what was going on back when Marcus was knocking about.


r/Stoicism • • May 12 '22

Stoic Theory/Study Would Socrates and Epictetus have considered podcasters like Joe Rogan to be modern Sophists?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/Stoicism • • Sep 08 '24 Heart of Silver

Stoic Banter How Stoicism Became The World’s Greatest Scam

Thumbnail
youtu.be
22 Upvotes

New video just posted by the YouTube channel Aperture. Really interesting discussion about how the “stoicism” of today has become more “broicism.” Would love to hear everyone’s thoughts!


r/Stoicism • • Jun 27 '24

Stoic Banter What is the stoic POV on socialism?

1 Upvotes

Serious question, what is the stoic perceptive on socialism?


r/Stoicism • • Aug 12 '21

Seeking Stoic Advice Who here is vegan or has considered it?

105 Upvotes

Since the stoics talk about pursuing virtue, we cannot argue that the consumption of a sentient being is right.


r/Stoicism • • Aug 30 '18

John McCain's Stoic Christian Philosophy

9 Upvotes

"In captivity, McCain urged his fellow prisoners not to pray for their release or their own personal success.

That stayed with him. "I pray to do the right thing so I won't look back in regret or embarrassment or even shame that I betrayed my principles and my faith," he told me in 2008."

Source: "How McCain's faith sustained him"

Rest In Peace, Sir


r/Stoicism • • Aug 12 '21

New to Stoicism UPDATE: Stoics are too passive

2 Upvotes

After reading the responses on the last post, I remain resolute in my conclusion that modern practitioners of stoicism are too passive. Passiveness / pacifism are not good and virtuous in and of themselves. In the comments people were saying I had a misunderstanding of Stoicism and how it is not pacifism per se, I agree and explain this distinction below, and that I have not read the stoics. I disagree, I have read Aurelius, Seneca, and Epictetus (the latter of which is my favorite).

Don't behave cowardly and be passive and put up with it because it is cowardice masquerading as virtue. Defend your honor. There was a time when men of the past understood this idea and even dueled and put their life on the line in order to defend their honor. I am NOT saying that we go back to dueling or escalate to violence, only using that example to indicate that once upon a time men were courageous and masculine and would be willing to fight to defend their honor. To those who are going to misconstrue everything I have said, here are my basic claims so you dont put words in my mouth:

  1. Stoicism is fantastic for dealing with life events out of your control eg getting let go from your work, getting broken up with, dealing with an infirmity etc.

  2. Stoicism is not fantastic for social life events in your control that require action. In practice, stoicism is very close to pacifism by modern practitioners of stoicism. This is because stoicism in some sense emasculates you because you wont have the proper masculine aggression that is needed in situations like defending your honor when you're getting bullied, teased, ridiculed, having your gf getting harassed by men, youre out with your mom and someone touches her etc, your inaction would be the result of your calm rational stoic principles that would be absolutely useless here. When your kid is getting bullied, what do you tell them? Son be stoic and let the bullies take your money, hit you, deride you and be effectively labeled the biggest wimp in the school because as long as you have virtuous thoughts that all that matters little man.

I am aware that stoicism is not pacifism. Dont misrepresent me. I understand Aurelius was an emperor of rome who led battles against germanic tribes. Only that in practice, modern adherents of stoicism would not encourage aggression or standing up for yourself and your honor/ your gf / your mother etc in the false name of virtue and letting things be and not allowing aggression get to you bc we're stoics and we should not let emotions get to us and we should be rational. However it is clear that this approach does not work in these social situations and not taking action is extremely cowardly.

3) I am not saying go guns blazing with violence or 10/10 aggression, only that you have the tools of aggression, potential for violence, a willingness for confrontration etc and use them judiciously in amounts that fit the situation should you be presented with a circumstance like above.

The bottom line: stoicism is not a one size fits all bandage for all your problems. When stoicism is helpful: for things out of your control like a break up, an illness, kid got into a car accident, staying calm and composed in these situations is extremely good and honorable.

When stoicism is bad: when guys are touching / flirting with your girlfriend and youre standing there idly and meekly because your stoic beliefs have hindered your aggression. Your kid is being bullied, youre out with your mom and someone touches her etc. I am not saying you beat them to a pulp, use rational judgment when deciding how much force, aggression, and potential violence is needed to end the situation without being a coward, yet avoid the other extreme of being a volatile angry mad man who wants to fight anyone who looks at you funny.

What are your thoughts? I love stoicism. Please engage in good faith discussion, I am willing to learn from everyone's point of view. Thanks.


r/Stoicism • • Jun 17 '23

Seeking Stoic Advice I hate the fact that some people have won in life by being rich doing what they love. e.g streamers, YTubers, Artists, Athletes etc and the rest of us are just NPCs. here in this world mostly for the purpose of making the rich and famous more rich and famous.

1 Upvotes

Ok that last sentence was taking it too far and not really the topic of this post but i sometimes i feel like that.

They are exceptions tho, Doctors, and scientists to me are the only normal professions where i actually regard them higher than any Elite and have no envy and jealousy towards them even tho some of them are rich. Why ? mostly because their job is fulfilling and purposeful their success and money is well deserved, that's why I dont envy them. A society without scientists and doctors would be a terrible sight to see.

But when it comes to the aforementioned vocations, to me a streamer that sits in front of his computer and film themselves and gets $60M to upto $100M deals its just downright depressing to me. And i hate that instead of being happy for them like most people im just a hater simply because it wasn't me gettig that money. Clearly they have won in life and i didn't.

What's interesting is that if i was rich i wouldn't be doing much different from what im doing now which is just staying in my house taking care of my brothers kids while he work. However if i were rich i would be able to do what i desired the most in life(right after my familys health) and that is setting up my mom, dad and brother for life. Have them have an easier life by living off my money yet here i am living off my brothers money. Bc im a 29 yo dude with severe mental illness that destroyed my life in my teens. I have severe social anxiety and mild hypochondria.

But besides SA i have a lot of regrets in my life. I had the opportunity to date two of the hottest girls in school ( 3 if i count one that had one of the best glow up ive ever seen, but by that time i was either out of high school or knees deep in SA, cant remember).but anyway, i was always a timid dude with girls i liked even wayyy before i developed SA.(i was an extrovert)

i another regret was not taking education/school/English as a second language seriously(it lead me to having very poor communication skills in terms of vocabulary, quick wits, intelligent talks etc. i basically sound like a 8 year old even in my own mother language; Spanish. For reference I have been living in the states since i was 10 and i can barely have short conversation without sounding like i just started learning English a few months ago.( Ive been trying to read more books-- last two i read was The Stand and Perfume: the story of a murderer--to improve that but that don't really help me speak, besides all my vocab goes out the window when im in the spot. SA deff has an impact on that.) And btw im 100 sure i have no learning disability or low iq. if there's one thing i remember about my dad in my childhood was him being proud of me for my cleverness/savyness when I was really young.

Let me throw this out there too, I started balding pretty young at around 16yo. that did a number on my insecurities too but what started my SA was my insecurities about my feet( they are or at least were back then a bit big but most fat, I got very insecure about my feet and to make long story short that developed into SA.

Anyways i dont want to make this longer than it has to. This is mostly me trying to do something to feel a little better at the moment ( the terminology espcapes me). It's 3am and its been 2 hours since i got to our new place which took 5 hours to get here. Me and my sister in laws brother did the whole moving(brother was working at his new job in the hospital) we got up at 4am and got here at 1230am. All i could think was man i wish i was rich so my life would be easier even tho i know i have it way better than a shit ton of ppl especially those kids dying of painful cancer as we speak. I never reach out like this but today broke me.

How can i be happy with myself and stop worrying about other ppl making it in life while i live in misery?

If this is not the right sub please guide me to one i could post this to.

This post took me an hour to write.