(Warning: Long read.)
The Skyrim card price rise: Was there manipulation behind it?
MAYBE. I feel that the rise and fall of the Skyrim card we have seen may have been the result of market manipulation by a group or individual. I have been searching to try and track down any group that might be orchestrating this, but I can't see anyone has posted publicly about it anywhere. Some people I've spoken to have suspected 4chan but couldn't find anything posted online, unless it was being set up in IRC or somewhere. Honestly it could have been a single guy with a few hundred bucks to throw around though.
I think Skyrim foil prices were probably manipulated and the increase in regular skyrim card prices were simply a reaction from the market thinking that they had additional value. More on how it could have been done in a bit.
Why am I sharing this?
I am interested in the idea that a small group could be capable of manipulating market prices, sort of a Steam Market cartel if you will, but I cannot work out a viable scenario where it will work, Steam's fees are just too steep.
Rest assured, if I thought any of this information would actually net me a sizable profit, I would just be using it for myself and not sharing. I am only discussing because I don't think there is room for me to make a profit as an individual. It's a zero-sum game, someone will always win and someone will always have to take the loss (actually negative since Steam takes a chunk each time too,) because demand to buy the cards for actual use just isn't strong enough and I would say trading at the moment seems to be 70% among other traders and speculators. I mostly just enjoy talking about the market and speculating on what will happen.
I am sure some people will downvote what I am about to say for being unethical. People may say those who game the market for profit are jerks, but I would argue everyone in /r/steamtradingcards and /r/steamgameswap is trying to trade something that will give an increased benefit for them... whether that is a game they consider of a higher value, or pure wallet funds. Trading for profit has been ingrained into the Steam psyche by things like TF2 and Dota item trading. So if you think market traders are any worse than item or game traders, I say people have already been doing this kind of thing with earbuds for years.
Is manipulating the Steam Community Market against the ToS?
As far as I can tell, manipulating the market by sheer economic power (ie. Driving prices by buying or selling large quantities) is not against the ToS. Valve still continues to profit on each transaction, unless prices get driven so high and items become so monopolized that no one is buying.
In contrast I feel that using scripts/bots to automatically buy is against the ToS and you are at risk of getting banned if you do it, I would not recommend even using a script to check the agreement checkbox for you automatically.
Theories on price manipulation, and why price manipulation won't work:
Driving prices up
Say my friends and I decide we are going to set a desired market value of $5 for the SS Reus foil, we will start buying up all cards at current price of $1.90 up to $4.40 ($5 minus Steam fee is about $4.40.)
But what the hell do we do about all the cards listed between $4.40 and $5? Even if we buy half the cards available on the market and all agree not to sell below a set price and slowly offload as an organized group, we still have no control over anyone who decides to sell in that price range, because we will take a loss on anything bought in that range. We have to keep buying up cards at lowball prices to maintain the high price. That range is huge and Valve likely put it in place for this reason.
Raising prices is the easy part, I could do that myself for one day, or indefinitely with a good-sized group. Selling is the hard part, people undercutting you as you try to unload a sizable inventory.
Also there is a big difference between temporarily boosting the prices of a single card, which can be done for a few hundred dollars, or creating a fundamental change in the market. If you want to create a permanent shift in the market and reset the base price, you must manipulate the entire SS getaway foil set (10 cards) simultaneously, not just a single card, to set a new bottom for the entire SS foil market. This is the hard part because I estimate it would take over $5,000 to ensure success.
It's wide-scale psychological manipulation of individual market users. You don't have to do 100% of the work, once you get momentum going (either up or down) the market will continue to drift temporarily thanks to newbie traders following the pattern. The more quickly and dramatic you shift prices, the more exaggerated the effect on the general trading population will be. For example, if someone manipulated the Skyrim cards they probably aimed for a $5 sell point but hype and market confusion took it up to $6 temporarily, a panic correction to $4, now it's still kind of rubber-banding up and down toward an equilibrium point (which is still artificial -- Skyrim is not worth that premium. This is a residual effect from manipulation or some really weird groupthink.) Note that this shift also carried over to regular skyrim cards which in my opinion have no reason to be valued higher than the other 9.
Driving prices down:
Theoretically you can drive prices down, to crash prices to rock bottom and give yourself an opportunity to scoop some up for yourself. This solves two problems: It avoids the 15% fee spread dilemma, and you also don't need as much capital to drop the market as compared to raising it.
How would you do this? You would start listing and removing cards rapidly, to influence others who are selling their own cards. Most people will take the lowest price on the market, subtract a few cents from it, and that's their sell price. You want to be constantly posting new trades at progressively lower prices, so people make their own items listed below your price, but removing yours before anyone has a chance to buy them from you. It's risky, because someone might manage to buy it before you can cancel the trade. You need to work out a tradeoff between lowering the market quickly, and doing it safely so you don't lose your cards to bots or scripts that can purchase them instantly.
Driving prices down also could create a "market memory" – the price may not rise as high as it was previously again.
Valve can easily remove this possibility by creating a minimum time between listing and cancelling a trade, or making a maximum number of listings per minute.
How the market gets influenced:
Intentional price driving: People who have a vested interest make posts and blogs discussing how great an opportunity to make money trading cards are. They post saying it's great and can only go up when it's in their interest to raise prices (when they want to sell), and they instill panic and discourage trading to lower prices (when they want to buy.) Along with propaganda, this also includes flipping trades and the techniques discussed above. The market is very easy to manipulate this way... when I was holding foil cards and wanted them to go up, even when I started to have doubts I didn't post for fear of it having a negative outcome on the market. Even a couple hundred people on Reddit getting your negative idea into their head is bad for prices.
Unintentional price driving: Any time someone talks about trading with another trader, they are affecting the psyche of the overall market. These people don't have a vested interest, they might just post about how selling all their cards allowed them to purchase free games during the summer sale, or telling people that trading cards are a terrible idea when they don't know much about them. This also includes people's actions as they are being led by the invisible hand of the market... maybe they get so spooked by a price drop that they hop on the bandwagon and sell immediately too.
In the case of the Skyrim price rise, the lines start to blur between unintentional and intentional. Soon the whole market is aware that SOMETHING is driving prices up and will try to rationalize this however possible. The main way I saw this done, was people suggesting that the kinds of people who play Skyrim are the kinds of people who like to hoard things, and may just keep the cards in their inventory as a collectible for the art. I don't think this is true on any significant scale.
Everything you read about trading cards, even this post, is influencing your behavior to an extent. It can vary from extremely slight (you consider a point and decide you agree/disagree with it, but it doesn't change anything about how you act), or you can read something that sends you into a panic/frenzy to buy or sell immediately, when it convinces you that prices will rise or fall.
I feel prices for items on the market have an innate desire to slide downward in price, and only move upward when some news or information affects them. The higher the ratio of people selling : people buying, the faster this will happen.
Potential for manipulation
Let's look at Tomb Raider Foil – Out of 723 available cards to buy right now, only 300 of them are under $5.00 in value, you can ignore over half of the listings if that's as high as you want to raise prices. You can buy half the listings (and 100% of the reasonable ones) for $1,000. I would say this is a high potential for manipulation.
Compare to regular Tomb Raider card.... you would need to buy over 5000 cards at a cost of $1,250 just to raise the price by 10 cents. So we could say that SS foils are about 30 times more effecient to manipulate than regular SS cards.
What about regular (non-SS cards)? Let's look at the Bit Trip Runner cards, which are currently the cheapest to craft badges with. A Radbot card from that set is currently $0.13. To buy every single card available currently, it will cost you less than $100. That means for $600, you can form a temporary monopoly on the entire Bit.Trip set. Of course, you need to worry about the unlimited nature of these cards and that people can still farm them. By comparison, for $600 you could only buy up every copy of a single Super Meat Boy card under $5 value.
Is anyone going to really spend $1,000 to corner the market on a particular card set? It seems quite rare and unlikely, really it doesn't seem worth it since you can't even cash out Steam wallet funds, but with the advent of Level 100+ Steam accounts where people are estimated to have put in about 5k to achieve that level, it's not unthinkable.
My personal position in all of this (full disclosure)
I cashed out all my foils yesterday for $2+ each except I sold Skyrim for $5.10 on Tuesday.
If you are still holding foils today, I feel you are approaching the point of unprofitability and have no choice but to stay for the long run or cash out for a few pennies of profit. During the sale I was very pro-foils and expecting all of them to be at $5 for the next month but now I am seeing that even $2 each is too much for most people to be willing to pay. I will be keeping a watchful eye but I don't think you could convince me to buy back in.
I am holding about 4 sets of non-foil getaway cards, that is my long-term speculative play. My foil profit has already covered any potential losses there.
Way too many speculation built into the price right now, those people aren't going to hold forever and need to dump at some point. You are also dealing with a combination of people using scripts, and theoretically people in Chinese jails or Russia who are willing to sit flipping for 12 hours a day for pennies. If you expect to sell a full foil set for $100 in a month, save yourself the trouble and cash out now.
TL;DR: I feel trading card market manipulation can occur in large groups, but it will likely take the form of a pyramid scheme where the people at the bottom end up getting burned and taking the losses.