r/StarcraftLore • u/MjLovenJolly • Sep 13 '19
Looking back at the different drafts of the lore
Hello there. I know this sub isn't very active, but I couldn't think of anywhere else to put this that wouldn't get obscured by non-lore related topics.
Starcraft lore, like Warcraft lore, has been subject to a tumultuous development full of rewrites, retcons, mistakes and other inconsistencies. I have identified roughly three periods or drafts in the development of starcraft lore: the Starcraft alpha/beta lore, the SC1/BW lore, and the SC2 lore. Each draft is unrecognizable from the rest, as though they take place in different universes that superficially resemble each other. This phenomenon happens in many works of fiction and tvtropes calls it "continuity drift."
My division of the continuity drafts into these three periods is arbitrary, as even within a single draft there may be numerous rewrites and inconsistencies. I refer to these as drafts because, as history shows, Blizzard constantly suffers from continuity drift to the point where a decade from now I fully expect that the SC2 draft will be unrecognizable from the status quo. What follows is my attempt to reconstruct and critique these drafts to satisfy my own curiosity and perhaps enlighten others. This isn't an academic paper with citations, but a very rough draft intended simply to pitch my current thoughts. I apologize if it reads as rambling.
The following will include noticeable and perhaps obnoxious criticism of the story, particularly from SC/BW onward. I understand that the plots of SC and BW are remembered quite fondly, but I do not feel that way. Looking back at it now, the writing feels questionable and that annoys me precisely because I like the premise of Starcraft. I definitely display a bias in favor of the alpha/beta draft, despite it being barebones and lacking an actual plot to compare.
SC alpha/beta draft
The alpha/beta draft is perhaps the most mysterious. We know very little about the development of SC1 besides what we can glean from interviews, the wayback machine's archive of the Starcraft 1 website, the classic battle net strategy compendium, and the SC1 manual. Remnants of this draft survived in some of the subsequent supplemental fiction, and fiction from the subsequent SC/BW draft may still be useful in gleaning insight into the alpha/beta draft.
It changed dramatically in aesthetics between its start and finish. Apparently the oldest idea for Starcraft consisted of pitching "space vampires."
Starcraft was first developed in a version of the WC2 engine, which was planned to take place in space with spaceborne units rather than on planetary surfaces. The three races had very different aesthetics during this period. After E3, Blizzard decided to scrap this and create what would become the final SC1 engine.
The premise of the game appeared to have changed a few times. It always involved a three way war between the terrans, zerg, and protoss, though the exact justification for this changed. Judging by the oldest website archives, Koprulu was always intended to be a border sector where the majority of fighting would take place. Initially it seemed that Blizzard planned a cold war between the sub-galactic civilizations of the protoss and terrans that was interrupted by the sudden invasion of the zerg, but then Koprulu was altered to be isolated from Earth. The SC1 manual further posited that the zerg invaded Koprulu to consume the terrans because they were perceived as providing an edge in a planned galactic war against the protoss. That was the furthest that this iteration of the backstory went as far as I could find. Compared to the plots of the games, this premise is notably more faction-oriented, larger scale, and depersonalized compared to the more cinematic and myopic character focus of the games.
I couldn't get a precise explanation of the scales for the setting during this draft, as it seems the writers were still actively brainstorming up the final release and didn't proofread the manual for consistency. Koprulu is used to refer to both a sector as well as a system. Some passages describe the terrans as all living as a single system consisting of over a dozen planets, while others suggest that terran civilization is spread across multiple star systems. The Protoss Empire is described in some passages as having colonized many hundreds of worlds and interacting with many alien civilizations similar to the Federation in Star Trek, whereas other passages suggest they only live on their homeworld of Aiur. Only the zerg were consistently described as consuming countless worlds across the galaxy in preparation for their invasion of the Protoss Empire.
The terrans seem to have originally been imagined as somewhere between a space western and a cyberpunk dystopia, although these elements seemed to have been severely watered down in the final game aside from remnants like Southern accents, cybernetic implants, and the backstory of Earth involving mutants and cyborgs.
The protoss were originally envisioned as a wholly robotic race before being changed to a biological race, although remnants of this survived in their robotic units (and were revived for the purifier faction in SC2). The protoss were initially conceptualized as serpentine centaurs before being changed to bipedal, although this designed seemed to survive in a doodad for the jungle tileset in StarEdit and may have inspired the design of the xel'naga in SC2.
The zerg underwent many changes in aesthetic design, such as bio-mechanical a la Giger or structures composed of giant rib cages, but their general concept as a horde of space locusts appears to have remained consistent. The old website suggested they were genetically engineered by another race, but the manual downplayed this by explaining they were uplifted by the xel'naga but their subsequent evolution was of their own accord. In contrast to the games, their hive mind was depicted as an actual group mind rather than a master/slave relationship. According to the website, zerg behavior became smarter as their numbers increased. Passages in the manual describe the Overmind as being literally composed of the minds of the zerg networked by telepathy, and only one passage ever suggests that the Overmind was a physical entity in contradiction of the others.
Speaking of the xel'naga, they were only a footnote in the lore at this period from what I could find. They only served to explain the origins, relationship, and motivations of the protoss and zerg in a typical usage of the scifi precursors trope. The website briefly mentioned them as race who predated the protoss, and the manual confirms that they were exterminated by the zerg.
While the alpha/beta draft lacked an actual plot, in my estimation the plot it setup seemed very different from how the SC/BW draft ultimately played out.
The alpha/beta draft setup the invasion of terran space by the zerg with further intervention by the protoss. While the zerg ultimately intended to invade the protoss in a galactic war, the setup suggested that for the foreseeable future the plot would be limited to koprulu and explore how the terrans respond to the two alien invasions, how the protoss deal with a philosophical schism regarding whether or not to callously exterminate the terrans while dealing with the zerg, and how the zerg would respond to the protoss becoming prematurely involved.
While the website and manual teased that Aiur would be a battlefield in the conflict, this didn't seem like it would happen in the foreseeable future. The scales involved suggested that the koprulu first contact war would last for many years, and that an invasion of Aiur would be concurrent with a galactic war waged by the zerg against the protoss. Obviously these conflicts are far too large to explore satisfactorily in a single RTS game, especially not with the technical limitations of the late 90s.
You would be right, but that didn't stop Blizzard.
In conclusion, the alpha/beta draft is an interesting hint at what Starcraft could have been had its setup been followed upon, but now it is irrelevant to and unrecognizable from the current status quo.
SC/BW draft
Many others might not distinguish between the alpha/beta draft and the SC/BW draft, but I do. The Starcraft game and its expansion Brood War diverged in subtle but dramatic ways from the lore as established in the alpha/beta draft. Additionally, development of the games' story appears to have been quite tumultuous and rushed. The cinematics were created separately from the script, which in some cases had to be rewritten to fit the cinematics into the story although I couldn't find any explanation of how much was rewritten. The missions themselves were designed to fit studio mandates intended to showcase aspects of the engine, such as tilesets and versus battles. This caused the resulting plot to meander and interrupt the tonal flow of the narrative, so we're already off to a rough start.
While the first contact war and protoss/zerg galactic war teased by the alpha/beta draft sounded like it would last for years or decades or more, the first game breezed through all of it in just thirty relatively short missions across three campaigns. Numerous plot hooks from the alpha/beta draft were either dramatically simplified or dropped entirely as a result.
Perhaps the most obvious divergence is the scale. The alpha/beta draft teased a gritty quasi-realistic interstellar war that could last many years with numerous characters involved. The SC1 game depicted a conflict that involved about a dozen characters in a more cinematic or Hollywood-esque fashion. While both had a dark tone, I did not really give the impression from the game that the conflict was particularly large or realistic.
Because it compresses many years worth of interstellar war into what the official timeline claims is no more than a few months in total, the plot of SC1 feels unbelievably plot-driven. Events happen not because logistics make them plausible, and characters behave not because of motivations and opportunities to act, but because the plot demands it. Key plot developments feel very clumsy or plot contrivances due to the rushed and meandering nature of the plot.
For example, during Episode 1 the Sons of Korhal rescue the Magistrate and Raynor from their predicaments and then promote them to lieutenants serving directly under Mengsk himself. While it makes sense for the SoK to behave heroically because they are rebels fighting heroically against a corrupt government, it doesn't make sense for Magistrate and Raynor to be immediately promoted except to keep them relevant to the plot when they otherwise would vanish from it. This plot point would make sense if they had years to climb the ranks, but it makes no sense if the events take place over the month or so according to the canon timeline.
I can name other examples like the entirety of Alpha Squadron defecting along with Duke, the zerg following the psi-emitter and crushing terran worlds with little resistance being way too convenient to Mengsk, Mengsk suddenly turning evil when his backstory firmly established he was the victim of the Confederacy, the zerg conveniently leaving terran space after the fall of Tarsonis rather than continuing to attack the terrans, etc. But that's beside my overall point, though I will happily explain my thoughts to anyone who asks.
At this point, I have to criticize the linear structure of the three campaigns relative to one another. Episode 2 and Episode 3 feel disjointed from Episode 1 due to their excessive focus on the protoss and zerg. The terran cameos don't feel like they genuinely belong to the story, but more like hamfisted attempts to make them feel like part of the same story. I feel this attempt to tie the three campaigns into a single linear narrative did more harm than good to their writing. I feel that if the campaigns had been independent that the writers could have dedicated more time to exploring the characterization and motivation of the zerg and protoss characters, who I feel suffered immensely from being forcibly tied into the story of the terran characters.
The zerg and protoss specific plot hooks from the manual were downplayed or discarded as a result. Where the manual made a big deal about humanity being the "determinant" in the zerg's planned galactic war with the protoss, in the final game the same amount of importance is placed on QoB but imo her story feels underwhelming and disjointed when analyzed critically. The manual teased that the protoss expedition to Koprulu would experience a schism between two sides regarding whether or not to genocide the terrans, but this is never explored because Episode 1 neatly closes the first contact war with the terrans so we never get to see how the protoss characters acted during this time. Episode 3 places its moral focus on the schism between the khalai and dark templar, with the humans relegated to a very minor role at most.
The dark templar being uniquely able to kill the otherwise immortal zerg leaders feels like a very lazy plot contrivance that was only added because the writer had previously written themself into a corner by making the zerg invincible otherwise. The manual explained that the zerg couldn't survive a galactic war against the protoss at the time of the koprulu conflict, so the game's plot points come out of left field. Furthermore, this is used to justify the presence of the dark templar and the resolution of their schism with the khalai, but it still feels very forced to me since the manual took great pains to make the Conclave's fear look justified whereas the game depicts them as acting very foolishly. As I said before, this is all probably the result of the writer compressing decades worth of war into a few months.
The ending of SC1 leaves very few loose ends, few opportunities for sequels, and felt to me like it wasted a lot of its premise. The Confederacy was barely explored before being replaced by the Dominion, but their worlds were devastated so that further conflict wasn't feasible. The Overmind was killed off, but since it was essentially synonymous with the zerg this essentially destroyed the culture of the zerg before we had much time to explore it. The protoss were devastated and wouldn't be able to survive another conflict.
But of course that didn't stop Blizzard from releasing a sequel the very next year.
Brood War's old website teased a premise for the game that doesn't match the final product. The website mentioned that the zerg leaders, in the absence of the overmind, would fight a brood war and QoB wasn't mentioned as a candidate here. Instead of the UED, the Dominion would face a conspiracy from within. The protoss were concerned with rebuilding. This clearly reflects an earlier draft of the story.
In the game, the overarching plot is that Earth has sent a fleet to conquer Koprulu and deal with the threat posed by the aliens. The brood war itself is between QoB and the other zerg who are somehow united despite the lack of overmind (who is somehow resurrected, trivializing its death in SC1), and seems to take over the plot to the exclusion of the other subplots. The protoss do not rebuild at all, but flee their homeworld because the Conclave was killed and the zerg are still wreaking havoc even without the overmind.
Compared to SC1, the plot of BW feels even more rushed to the point of seeming lazy and disrespectful. Characters constantly make decisions that seem blatantly idiotic to drive the plot forward, such as any time that anyone trusts QoB or Duran despite having no reason to. Plot devices like the new overmind and the temple on Shakuras appear out of nowhere with little explanation to drive the plot forward.
BW introduces a notable retcon in the form of Duran. In SC1 the Overmind stated that it intended to assimilate the protoss. In BW, Duran explains he is creating protoss/zerg hybrids as part of an evil plot that he was plotting centuries in advance. In other words, Duran has essentially the same motivation as the Overmind yet we are expected to believe these are two completely different things. Zeratul, who previously learned that the Overmind intended to assimilate the protoss, does not make any connection despite the obvious similarities. It feels like the writer either forgot what they wrote before or changed their minds about the plot trajectory and hoped nobody would notice the discrepancy. While this is a fairly small discrepancy between SC1 and BW because SC1 only vaguely alluded to the zerg's backstory, Duran's revelations do not fit with the alpha/beta draft's explanation of the zerg backstory at all.
Beyond Duran not fitting into the story, his addition suggests that the franchise would add a fourth race for hybrids or xel'naga or an original race as the new antagonist. I feel that from an aesthetic and RTS perspective that this is a bad fit for Starcraft, which was already plenty sufficient with only the three races of terran, zerg and protoss. A 4th race that mixes elements of protoss and zerg doesn't feel like it would be distinct enough to justify including. (Blizzard ultimately scrapped plans for a 4th race anyway.)
I didn't mention it before, but there's also a consistent trend across the games to demote the zerg. In the alpha/beta draft, the zerg were presented as the ultimate villains of the franchise. They started the first contact war and intended to consume the terrans, protoss, and potentially the universe! In the SC/BW draft they became essentially slaves to QoB (who behaved more human than zerg) and Duran, while the hybrids (or returning xel'naga?) became the overarching villains. I feel like this was unnecessary and destroyed what made the zerg unique and interesting in the first place.
There are only a few of the issues I noticed in the story of SC/BW, and there are plenty others I either haven't brought up or didn't notice/remember.
In conclusion, the SC/BW is a 90s video game story with great presentation that coincides with amazing gameplay, but from a literary perspective the plotting is severely hampered by its questionable writing.
SC2 draft
I won't criticize the SC2 draft's writing very much because many others have already done so at length. What I will note is that the SC2 draft's continuity drift is merely an extension of what started in the SC/BW draft and that it is relatively more consistent with the SC/BW draft than either are with the alpha/beta draft.
SC2 was created roughly a decade after SC/BW, in a very different market, with much more advanced computers, a much larger budget, a different writing team, and its expansions were released years apart. As Blizzard games in general are prone to continuity drift, the longer time between installments means for SC2 it is relatively worse than that suffered between SC and BW.
I believe this draft continues into the present, as no material has yet come out with dramatically alters the context of this draft. However, as I said before, I fully expect that after some years I will be able to identify a fourth draft of the lore if the continuity drift continues as expected.
The SC2 draft continued the SC/BW draft's steady changes to the zerg, ultimately rendering them unrecognizable. In the alpha/beta draft and in the SC/BW draft prior to QoB's introduction, the zerg were presented as a "devouring swarm" archetype. They engaged in the genocide of other species as a matter of course, without any concept of diplomacy. By the end of SC2, they have lost this aspect and now more closely resemble the formics from Ender's Game. Not only are they capable of diplomacy, the narrative treats them as unambiguous heroes.
I haven't mentioned the terran and protoss governments as much as the zerg's, but I feel they suffered a similar mistreatment. The SC/BW draft introduced major governments only to kill and/or replace them. SC/BW introduced the Confederacy, Overmind, Conclave, and UED, then killed them off in favor of new governments. In SC2, these new governments were Dominion, Daelaam, and Overqueen. While the specifics changed over the course of the story, with Valerian replacing Mengsk and Zagara replacing QoB, the institutions themselves were not utterly destroyed like those initially introduced in SC/BW.
I feel this difference is important to note because it means that Blizzard considers this the status quo and is resistant to changing it. I suspect that, had the first Starcraft game been released today rather than two decades ago, Blizzard would have considered the Confederacy, Overmind and Conclave the status quo and been resistant to casually discarding them as happened in reality.
This status quo also ties into why I distinguish the SC2 draft from the SC/BW draft. The SC2 draft continues from the events of SC/BW without completely changing their context, as SC/BW does compared to the alpha/beta draft (e.g. replacing the determinant with just QoB). This status quo is so ingrained that, during the promotion of the Kerrigan skin for Overwatch, Kerrigan was mistakenly described as a Dominion ghost. While this could be brushed off as a mistake, I would not be surprised if Blizzard actually did go so far as to retcon the Confederacy out of existence, along with most of the events of the SC/BW draft.
While in terms of events the SC2 draft does technically continue directly from the SC/BW draft, so much of the events of the SC/BW draft are irrelevant to the status quo of the SC2 draft. I think this may be loosely comparable to how, say, World of Warcraft completely changes the events of WC1 and WC2 and retains only a vague idea of them. Without something like a StarCraft Chroncle to explain it, it is impossible to predict with any certainly what Blizzard's current conception of the StarCraft lore is supposed to be.
In conclusion, SC2 is a pretty amazing modern game with great gameplay and cool skins and what not, but the story is not going to win any awards.