r/StarcraftFeedback • • Jul 16 '10

I can do video replay analysis for lower level (Bronze-Gold) players, if anyone is interested.

12 Upvotes

A few of you might recognize me from my commentaries, but I'm also looking to provide feedback via Day9 style video analysis (except it'll be all in game; I won't show my ugly mug at all). I'm only doing this for the lower leagues because I'm a decent Platinum player (although Diamond in 2v2), and I don't really feel comfortable giving advice to players better than me, no matter how well I know the theory.

So, if you're a Bronze, Silver, or Gold player interested in getting some feedback, you can either PM me directly, post in this thread, or request for a video analysis when you post your own thread.

If you do want me to take a look at one of your games, please make sure to state the following things:

  • Which player you are

  • What rank you are

  • What you think you did well

  • What you think you need to work on

For a poor sample of my work, I've uploaded Diggles vs Mulsori so far.

tl;dr I'll do Day9 style commentaries for Bronze-Gold players. This is my YT channel created for this subreddit. Please allow ~2 days for the video to go up on YouTube.

Edit: Got rid of the part about me whining about my wisdom teeth, added something that'll help me organize.


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Aug 11 '10

TvT - Diamond, me vs Tasteless

Thumbnail starcraft2reps.com
11 Upvotes

r/StarcraftFeedback • • Nov 27 '11

Diamond zerg offering free coaching!

10 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I've been playing/streaming starcraft 2 for white some time now and feel like offering the community something back. If you're a platinum or lower level player in need of some help and tips, I want to try and help. My main race is zerg, but for any leagues gold or lower I can coach. Platinum players I will help as well, but my off races are kind of rusty in higher level play. If you have any questions or want to schedule a session, feel free to contact me through Reddit or email me at [email protected]. you can also check me out at twitch.tv/erik33045.

I hope to hear from you guys, and GLHF!


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Dec 08 '11

I'm in this season of the AHGL. I'm Gold and in big trouble.

9 Upvotes

I joined Season 2 of the AHGL with my company and I'm trying to greatly improve. I am winning only 50% of my games in the Gold division. I am not getting any better. If anyone has time, can you take a peak at a replay or two of mine and tell me what I can do better? Any advice would be great.

https://rapidshare.com/files/1512827447/Multiplayer.rar (all 20 replays from my start. I know 20 matches isn't much, but I play as much as I can)

EDIT: I apologize for not selecting specific replays. I feel overall I'll do the same things each match. I appreciate the replies. I'll take this info to heart.


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Oct 23 '11

Masters Random willing to give help

9 Upvotes

Hey all,

If you need any help with your games feel free to send me some replays and I will look them over and give you some feedback on what I feel you could have done better and what you did good.

If you have any questions about builds feel free to PM me as well.

Thanks guys.


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Jul 14 '10

TvP - Gold - Won - MMT vs Lot Rush from Proxy Gates

Thumbnail starcraft2reps.com
9 Upvotes

r/StarcraftFeedback • • Nov 06 '12

[Bronze P] 10 Games, 1 win.

8 Upvotes

From newest to oldest, all ladder unless stated otherwise:

Notice that while in one of those games I "win" (the PvZ in Ohana), I think the other player either had a DC or was just giving me points.

So... I'm trying, I practice, I watched dApollo's tutorials, I watch my replays, I watch the streamers, I watch the Day[9] Dailies, I tried to learn a few Build Orders, but I have no idea what to do and what I'm doing wrong. Please take a look at some of my replays, if someone can help me, I really want to improve...


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Jul 03 '11

Bronze Zerg looking for help!

8 Upvotes

I'm generally really bad, and I'm just looking for some tips to pull me ahead in Bronze.

Here's my last game: ZvT, I lost. http://sc2rep.com/replays/%28Z%29Noobiticus_vs_%28T%29Dueg__sc2rep_com_20110704/10744


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Sep 02 '10

YABOT 1.2 was released a few days ago. If you don't know what it is yet you're missing out!

Thumbnail
sc2mapster.com
8 Upvotes

r/StarcraftFeedback • • Aug 16 '10

Im the toss player. Please give advice so I can get the hell out of bronze

Thumbnail starcraft2reps.com
8 Upvotes

r/StarcraftFeedback • • Jul 15 '10

ZvX - Diamond - 3 games - LF feedback

8 Upvotes

http://starcraft2reps.com/index.php?a=details&id=682

http://starcraft2reps.com/index.php?a=details&id=683

http://starcraft2reps.com/index.php?a=details&id=684

3 games, 684 is probably the one I want feedback on most, I won the games on Metalopolis but lost the other two, I really find my macro with zerg is lacking, if you look at my hotkeys I think this is my biggest weakness so criticism there would be good. Any other general mistakes and missteps you notice would be good too. The Metalopolis game is a prime example of just not being able to macro hard enough to keep my minerals down. Halp.

On the LT game I think I just powered too hard, 1-2 more spinecrawlers and more units and I think I am in great position that game, thoughts?

Thx friends!

PS If anyone wants to practice specific matchups on any map feel free to msg me I'm a random player so don't mind working on anything, just seems I am losing with zerg the most.

PPS feel free to LOL at my OL dying in the steppes game, I know I did -.-;


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Nov 09 '11

Masters Terran -- Free Replay Analysis

7 Upvotes

Hi all,

Thought this might be fun and helpful to some. I am a masters T player on NA. I've been playing since the beta and I've been in masters league since it was added to the game. My name is murDOC.581 on NA, so feel free to add me if you'd like.

I play fairly "non-traditionally" and usually spend most of my time trying to find ways to exploit the current meta game rather than simply looking for the best ways to execute it.

I am a big believer in the "work on your mechanics first" philosophy, so I think I will keep my analysis/criticisms to diamond/plat players for now. If you are in Gold or lower, I don't even have to watch your replays to know what is wrong with your game; you need to make more workers, find ways to spend your money, learn to control your army, etc.

If you are interested, please send replays to [email protected]


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Aug 19 '10

I have no midgame, and if I dont win in the first 10-15 minutes I have never won. any strategies/ tips? Here is a replay (I'm Protoss)

Thumbnail starcraft2reps.com
7 Upvotes

r/StarcraftFeedback • • Aug 17 '10

This is one of my sloppiest games, but one of my most fun. I lost, and need criticism.

7 Upvotes

I'm the Protoss player and while the Zerg kept me off balance most of the game, I felt it was pretty close until near the middle of the game. Then I just lost it for some reason, despite the superior army. Was it simply micro?

http://starcraft2reps.com/index.php?a=details&id=1281


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Aug 16 '10

PvZ, Low Diamond, [Lost Temple]

Thumbnail starcraft2reps.com
7 Upvotes

r/StarcraftFeedback • • Aug 09 '10

TvP - me (unranked but Silver in beta) against a Diamond. Mostly got destroyed. What went wrong?

Thumbnail starcraft2reps.com
7 Upvotes

r/StarcraftFeedback • • Mar 17 '12

High gold TvZ on Entombed Valley. I know my main mistakes (non-existant splits, not making ghosts for EMP, etc.), but my question is: How do I manage expansions better? I feel like whenever I get past 3 base I have no idea how to defend expands / position my army.

Thumbnail
starcraft2reps.com
6 Upvotes

r/StarcraftFeedback • • Feb 14 '12

[PvZ] FFE vs banes and mass muta

6 Upvotes

Hey, could I get some opinions on what I did wrong in this game? I scouted the baneling nest early and was scared of an all in, but it never came and I was overrun by mass muta. I see some mistakes that I made, my probe production could have been a bit better, but I feel I did fairly well (52 workers produced @ 12 mins, + original 6), and my third was late (13:40), however I didn't feel safe to get it earlier cause mutas. What do you guys think?

http://drop.sc/112266

Thanks in advance!

Edit: Sorry forgot to mention this is Gold level.


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Feb 03 '12

Year of SC2 - Replays For Review

6 Upvotes

As I continue my year of Starcraft 2, I have hit a rather large wall. I was in platinum for a time, but was demoted back to Gold last season, and there I have been stuck. A commenter on my blog suggested a post of replays to here and I also put them up on my blog.

I decided to do a duo of replays from each race, one loss and win vs P and T, and two losses vs Z. I feel like this will help point out my problems better, perhaps. Reviewing them myself, I see problem areas already. In the Entombed Valley ZvZ loss, I made too many drones towards the end. If those were roaches or lings, I perhaps would have fared better. In the ZvP loss, I had way too few drones until a minute or two before my opponent attacked. The shorter ZvZ is a classic case of my crappy micro, I believe. It was also included because a redditor (Rexel) was my opponent and was adamant that I upload it to Reddit.

I have been using 14g 14p to open for every match-up. It was suggested to me by a masters player who helped a few times and I have had success with it. I think that sticking to so much ling/bling/muta, though, is a detriment rather than a good plan. I thought it would help me focus on my play issues, but don’t know if it’s working.

ZvZ – Loss

ZvZ- Loss

ZvT- Win

ZvT- Loss

ZvP- Win

ZvP- Loss


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Dec 01 '11

I would love to have some high level players analyse my replay! zvt (replay inside)

6 Upvotes

cross post from /r/starcraft2_class

Recently I feel like my greatest weakness is zvt late to midgame. However, I don't think my main problem is literally the matchup, but maybe more some general habits and general stuff that I do wrong. I wish you guys could point out things I'm doing wrong and maybe give me a couple of hints.

In this replay I'm not quite sure what I did wrong. I feel like my opening / composition was pretty much spot on.

here's a list of things I think might have cost me the game:

  • Lack of sparse agression (drops)!

  • I should have put those spine at my expands instead of in the middle.

  • Losing my 2 middle-expands too many times by not controlling the middle of the map.!

  • Retreating to deal with drops and losing the control of the middle

  • Not burying lings/spitting creep at all possible expands!

What do you think? is anything making you cringe watching me play?

replay here, high diamond zerg(me) vs mid-master terran.


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Nov 07 '11

TvP, I don't want to be that guy in bronze with 1500 wins :(

6 Upvotes

I've played this game a fair amount, and pretty much every single time I have a lengthy game against protoss I get obliterated. Any help would be appreciated.


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Nov 05 '11

Bronze Zerg (best of 3) ZvP

6 Upvotes

Hey guys! This is my first time looking for feedback on my gameplay. Any criticism is welcome, don't worry I won't get offended.

eXoTom has a stream and I was his only viewer so we played a best of 3. We didn't know each other before the games. We are both bronze players.

also let me know if I formatted this post wrong.


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Nov 02 '11

Masters Terran taking in replays

6 Upvotes

Hey guys!

I thought I'd lend my assistance and look over any replays you want to send me. I'm a Masters Terran on the NA server.

You can contact me in several ways

SC2: jdsarge.987 E-mail: [email protected]

Or submit your replay as a comment here! I'm willing to help/coach any race! My zerg and protoss aren't as good as my terran, but I'd say they are about diamond level. Don't expect crazy pro level coaching, but I'll help anyone out who needs it.

Thanks guys!

Proof that I'm masters: http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/profile/430244/1/jdsarge/


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Jun 13 '11

Bronze Toss. I don't get how I lost this.

6 Upvotes

http://replayfu.com/r/mVgXxd

I had more of everything than he did. He barely even expanded and I get fucked in the ass. I was originally just going to wall off with cannons and pull some mass void ray bullshit but I decided against it.

EDIT: I am furb in this battle. Bronze scrub extraordinaire.


r/StarcraftFeedback • • Jun 03 '11

Completely lost in ZvZ

6 Upvotes

Guys, i really need help in ZvZ. Im in diamond league and have great win/loss ration against P and T. vs another Z im lucky if i win 1 game every 10, no joke. Ive tried looking on liquidpedia for builds but to no avail.

Please can someone guide me in the right direction, ZvZ is then bane(ling) of my existence!