I didn't think it was horrible, but I do have a problem when a movie insults my intelligence. The Star Wars genre has always been long on fiction and short on science but this movie totally planet busted the suspension of disbelief. I feel embarrassed that we've all hyped Star Wars to a new generation of children and all of them who see this movie are going to be dumber as a result.
I liked Rey. I could see how a female living in a world without other human males would have to get tough to survive, but how does a person raised in poverty from a very young age (3?) by aliens and living hand to mouth wind up with a haughty British accent?
It's been said (I see) that Rey is "overpowered". I don't mind that she is powerful. That's the force. What bothers me is that it took Luke and Anakin years to turn their power into something useful. I really have no patience for "deus ex machina" or in this case god from thin air. It makes no sense that she could beat Kylo Ren, gun down storm troopers, or use any of the advanced Jedi abilities without any kind of training.
Finn's character is ridiculous and paper thin. Here is a man who is raised from a child in the ranks of storm troopers yet he suddenly grows a conscience during an attack on a village. Fine. But then he decides he wants to desert the First Order. Fine. On the way out he kills his fellow soldiers and is thrilled about it. How can someone abandon his life based on a conflict of conscience and then start killing his former friends without a good deal of hesitation and remorse? Is he a sociopath or something? Who does that and how can anyone consider him to be a hero or ever trust him? To change sides so cavalierly and then kill your former friends means you lack a conscience rather than you possess one.
Phasma--how ridiculous is she? Here is a person who has risen through the ranks to become and officer. She's special and clearly she's stronger and harder than all the rest. Yet, put a blaster up against her head and she will give you the codes to lower the Death Planet's shields and enable the Rebels to kill all her friends and coworkers.
I'm not hard. I'm not tough, but I like to think that if someone put a gun against my head and asked me to ENABLE them to destroy everyone and everything in my country I would have the stones to tell them to go pound sand. This, especially considering that they would probably kill me anyway, which is basically what they did by locking her in a garbage chute just before they blow up the planet. She's not only cowardly but also dumb. I find that very hard to believe and frankly quite insulting to my intelligence. Also, they should have removed her helmet. With her helmet removed it would have been more plausible that she felt vulnerable enough to submit to what the Rebels wanted.
5. You blow up my planets then you are a monster. If I blow up your planet then I'm a freedom fighter. I find it hard to accept that either side made the decision to blow up entire planets and their populations so casually. To watch the First Order soldiers and officers fire their weapon so casually is unbelievable. You can be three things if you do something horrible. 1. Numb. No emotion or affect. 2. Delighted because you are a sick fuck. 3. Horrified and fighting your conscience even while you obey your orders.
What you are not is casual like you are making coffee for the boss.
6. The Death Planet (which is what I call it) is ridiculous. It is the most insulting concoction of engineering that fiction has ever created. Let's set aside the fact that they've basically carved out giant chunks of a planet and create a military base the size of Russia on it for a second. Let's ignore that this facility is over-sized considering the small number of troops it houses (let alone under-defended).
A. If you extinguish a sun then you extinguish the planets in orbit around it.
B. If you launch a particle weapon from one solar system to another you cannot expect that particle beam to split apart, change directions and hit various objects as if it were a homing missile.
C. If you are on a planet and can see the particle beam coming then that means the beam is traveling at sub light speed. If it's traveling as sub light speed then it would take centuries for it to travel from one solar system to the next.
D. If people on the planet could see the beam coming at them then so could the ships in orbit with all their scanners and detection equipment. Yet they all just sat there and didn't try to jump to light speed.
E. You can't extinguish a sun. What we also know is that when a sun runs out of fuel it goes supernova. Even if they were somehow able to siphon off the fuel of this sun then the sun would blow up.
F. The law of constancy of mass has been VIOLATED! (raped even!) As you draw off energy from the sun and store it in a planet that would greatly increase the mass and thus gravity of the planet. If you take enough energy that it extinguishes a sun and somehow put it in a space that is much smaller than the sun (which violates the law of conservation of mass) then it's likely everything on that planet would collapse into a black hole. At the LEAST people are going to find it hard to move around because the gravity goes up.
G. They already fired their planet buster so that means they've already extinguished their sun. Maybe they had 2 suns? But even so, once that second sun is gone then all they've got is a massive base out in the middle of nowhere.
H. If they extinguished their sun then they must have moved the entire planet to another solar system and done so in a relatively short period of time. That takes faster than light travel. FASTER THAN LIGHT TRAVEL OF AN ENTIRE PLANET! Bullshit.
7. How does Finn know how to use a light saber? That doesn't sound like Storm Trooper training to me. Especially not for someone who worked as a janitor.
8. Finn and Poe become fast friends. It's not like the Empire or it's descendants never tried to gain someone's confidence by befriending them so they could later use that relationship to destroy them. How can Poe be so trusting and naive and yet such a cunning and brilliant pilot? He's an idiot and apparently Disney thinks we are too.
9. I don't think there is a supercomputer in the world that can compute the odds of Rey being able to steal the Millennium Falcon, pilot it into space AND get picked up by a freighter piloted by Han Solo who was the original owner before it was stolen several times. It boggles the mind. What's the biggest number you can think of? That number to one.
10. Han Solo is a piece of shit. Here's why. A. He is once again a scumbag smuggler. B. He's lost his crew because the contraband he was carrying apparently ate them. He relates this fact as comic relief. "Yeah, I got all my crew killed because I got them to help me smuggle monsters. Hahaha! Ain't that funny?
11. They launch an entire mission to destroy the Death Planet because a former Storm Trooper said he can sabotage it from the inside, but they don't bother asking him how. The whole meeting takes about 30 seconds and they commit all their resources to the attack based on this flimsy poorly thought out plan.
The first Star Wars spent the entire movie building up to an attack that had in depth (if risky) plans to destroy the Death Star. Yet, they blew this one up with almost no planning.
12. Rebel pilots are ridiculous. Real pilots speak without affect. They are professional, calm, and serious. They behave this way so that when things get crazy they are trained to endure it. Yet these guys are yelling and hooting and when half their forces are destroyed they are still happy go lucky.
Go to a abattoir and see where your hamburger comes from and you will leave with a sense of reverence. You may still eat hamburgers but you will at least be a little more pensive about the process. These guys treat the entire destruction of planets and the deaths of all their friends and colleagues as if it were nothing.
Who does that? When 9/11 happened people were pretty upset and scared. They blew up the Republic in this movie. That's billions of people and not a single person cried or mourned or had a breakdown?
WTF?
Honestly, I find it hard to root for a people so cavalier and devoid of conscience and humanity.
Oh well. At least they gave us lots of shots of Daisy Ridley's ass (13).
Edit: Yes I know my outline is out of order. The website changed the numbering because I wrote a second paragraph. When I go to edit all numbering is correct. Sorry. Talk to Reddit Admins.