r/StarWarsTFA • • Jan 09 '16

Revenge of the Sith was better than The Force Awakens

0 Upvotes

As much as the prequels get bashed, I actually felt Revenge of the Sith was better than The Force Awakens (at least I enjoyed it more). I'm wondering if anyone else felt that way too.


r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 22 '15

Am I the only one. It was shit. (Spoiler)

5 Upvotes

This was total shit.

  1. Not a death star but a death planet the rebels destroy. Rinse and repeat.

  2. Solo's idiot son, Jedi trained by Luke and using the dark side of the force is hard pressed by a defecting storm trooper and beaten by a girl with the force thats totally untrained.

It almost a remake of "A New Hope". Luke gets to be Yoda in the next one I see.


r/StarWarsTFA • • Jan 09 '16

Is Adam Driver Too Ugly To Play Kylo Ren?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/StarWarsTFA • • Apr 29 '16

Everything Wrong With Star Wars: Episode VII - The Force Awakens

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 20 '15

[Spoiler Heavy] Loved the film, but have a few critiques

0 Upvotes

Overall this was a great movie but there were a few things that it's clear Abrams needs to adjust before making the next installments.

  1. I know this isn't really his forte but MUSIC. Music in star wars is extremely important, just about each character/class of character (i.e. droid, sith, light side,even certain planets like Naboo and Tatooine) have DISTINCTIVE theme songs, I can listen to just about every soundtrack and tell you what planet we're on and who the character we're focusing on is. AND THAT'S THE POINT. For this movie, the music was more or less a wishy-washy blend of old themes, and the thematic elements in general follow suit.

  2. He doesn't read his lore, and he doesn't know Sith. I think JJ just thinks "Sith" is a fill-in for the "Bad Guys" but there's more to them than that, they have a long and rich history with a lot of important themes and defining characteristics. First of all, sith have scars, they're supposed to be gnarled, a side-effect of the dark side. Pretty much every sith has a nasty facial scar, horrid teeth, and DISTINCTIVE SITH EYES. Even Jar Jar has them (a strong case for the Jar Jar/sith lord conspiracy theory). Kylo has none of these which mayyy be because he's extremely new and untested but it makes no sense for him to be this used by the dark side without having a whole lot of power, which is another thing. Kylo is weak as frick. To his credit, he did that cool "hold a blaster shot in midair" thing at the beginning of the movie, but then he's severely crippled by Chewie's Bowcaster later. Granted, he was taken off guard but those endowed with the force are supposed to be able to sense blaster shots (which is why they can deflect them). ALSO, CHEWIE'S BLASTER IS SUPPOSED TO BE GREEN. Moreover, there's a pretty well-established lore surrounding Luke, Leia, and Han's children and the new plots make absolutely no reference to them or even try to give them credence, the point of the SW universe is that it can be played off of because things are kept so consistent while being expounded upon so thoroughly.

  3. The dialogue was pretty odd and stilted, it doesn't carry the same feeling as earlier movies did. SW has a fast-paced, witty dialogue, it's not centric on the long facial-shot, intense staring model which is common nowadays, its difference is what set it apart, that needs to be resurrected.

  4. THE FIGHTING. Okay why is there NO JUMPING?! Force jumping is like, extremely important in all of the games and movies, its part of what allows them to get to half the places they can get to (i.e. why they can have battles on skyscrapers and in between lava-seeping platforms on Mustafar), and sets them apart. There's barely any mention to their force powers at all aside making the areas where the force is supposedly active a bit blurrier than usual, but we HAVE THE TECHNOLOGY to see the super cool powers the force gives you, like lightning, there really should've been more lightning. Plus, these guys were just not as good at swordfighting as the others. Take the earlier movies, the actors are well-trained and the fighting styles are well-researched and practiced, drawing on many traditions and sacred arts. Think about the first movie, Darth Maul's actor (besides being just really cool in general) is a professional in martial arts, and his fighting was excellent, the fight scenes were both engaging and beautiful to watch, the saber-fighting in this film was very random, stilted, and not clean at all. Other movies have more dynamic fight scenes as well, they move locations often and are almost never alone until the very last, critical moments. There was also not enough glowering and estimation of one another out of respect and calculation, which made the two of them seem even more like the bumbling rookies they are.

  5. The technology. Some of it is kind of primitive for a galaxy that's far far away. For instance, the device used to patch up Chewie's arm barely does the job, and poor FiN has to lay on a stretcher for a long time, only getting his pulse checked whereas in older movies they were giving people cybernetic arms and dumping them in healing Batha tanks.

There are plenty more things that I could've covered but these are my first impressions. What did y'all think?


r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 18 '15

Why Are People Butt-hurt About the New Star Wars? (SPOILER FREE, NO SPOILERS PLEASE, SHOW RESPECT)

0 Upvotes

First and foremost, I do respect everyone's opinion and am open for a reasonable debate. I also am a huge Star Wars fan, it is a staple in my life and was at least or greater than 90% of my childhood. Before viewing, if you are going to be that guy with a Rancor up your butt and post spoilers you are just ungrateful. It just is not fair and quite upsetting.

Maybe it was my bias for the franchise, but oh my "The Force Awakens" was a GREAT episode. I am willing to say this movie was as good as "The Empire Strikes Back". There are such nitty-picky things that people are dissecting from this film and some of the things are ridiculous and I think if you are a "true" Star Wars fan, you should not be judging this film so damn hard.

REMEMBER; I feel some people don't realize the time gap from the prior addition, there are a lot of questions both before viewing it and after viewing it. Just like a piece of fine art, a great piece of cinema should have the audience thinking. Relating to the fact that this is going to be a part of a trilogy after all, this film was a major success by my definition. I KNOW, we all have different standards of a movie but DAMN. Again, I just feel this movie was a STRONG, STRONG Star Wars film.

So I want to just give my two cents about certain aspects people seem to be clung to. If you are watching this movie I feel there are a couple things to consider BEFORE making some ludicrous statements.

  1. During the Original Trilogy, the ways of the Force were already scattered. It is even possibly more so now. After watching the film, remember all of the dialogue. IT IS IMPORTANT, don't get overwhelmed. It is impossible not to- I cried and laughed through the whole damn movie!

  2. Don't be so high-strung. RELAX AND JUST TAKE IN THE MOVIE, don't think about so damn hard. Treat the movie as you should treat everyone else in public. A- Don't judge characters by look. B- Give everyone a chance to introduce themselves. C- Lastly, if you are going to think about the movie really hard and act like a snotty film critic at least PUT YOURSELF IN THE SHOES OF THE CHARACTERS. If you still feel like bashing it, then you are truly a sorry lump of melancholy friend.

J.J. did a GREAT job. Both him and the always wonderful Lawrence Kashdan wrote a great story. ONE LITTLE THING. These new characters are DEFINITELY going to be worth investing into. This new trilogy is going to be competing hardcore with the original trilogy.

May the Force be with you all. : -)


r/StarWarsTFA • • Jan 10 '16

Kylo Ren Darth Vadar Connection (Theory)

0 Upvotes

So we all have pretty much figured out by now that Kylo-Ren is going to end up being a good guy. If you haven't, here is how it breaks down. In the scene where Kylo-Ren is talking to Vader's melted helmet, he is telling Vader he wants to be like him. At first it gives the impression that he wants to embrace the dark side. Later on in the movie Kylo-Ren has to kill Han but apologizes for it. The reason.....He has to make a sacrifice to get on the side of Supreme Commander Snoke. When he is talking to Vader's, helmet he is actually talking to the Vader that saved Luke and betrayed the Emperor. This all is a hint from JJ that Kylo-Ren will join with Luke to bring down the Empire!


r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 31 '15

IT ALL MAKES SENSE IF YOU READ THIS. SPOILERS

0 Upvotes

Finn was the subject of force mind control (these are not the droids you seek stuff) which changed him from a storm trooper to the resistance side. But who did that. Well Poe Damaron of course who is in fact Darth Plagueis reincarnated/snoke/alter ego. Fun fun fun. Poe has infiltrated the resistance and is in a position of trust in the search for Luke. Historically siths always have an alter ego and infiltrate the good side -remember sideous. PD are DPs initials too. And poe is the "black leader" in the resistance squadron with a call sign "black one". And when he dies he leaves his jacket behind remember? Like Yodas cloak. All the clues you need are in plain view. Ive posted elsewhere here about this.

Sheila the wise


r/StarWarsTFA • • Aug 17 '16

The most appealing outfits Finn Star War leather jacket is now available in our online shop omu at reasonable price. This elegant jacket has worn by the famous celebrity John Boyega as Finn.

Thumbnail
ebay.com
0 Upvotes

r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 24 '15

Why is everyone just excusing Ren and Rey? (SPOILERS)

1 Upvotes

I'm of the camp that thinks Rey shouldn't have been able to beat Ren in a light saber battle in the first episode. I've read a lot of peoples' explanaition of it, but they still don't make sense to me.

A) "Rey is strong with the force." - Well, so is Ren. I think people are forgetting that he is also descended from the great Skywalker bloodline. And even if he isn't as naturally talented as Rey, I'd put him at least above average. He must have been pretty competent to be able to turn against Luke and destroy the entire new generation of Jedi. So let's say he has potential similar to Rey, but not quite, BUT has YEARS of training over her, that still means he should wipe the floor with her.

B) Rey was actually trained by Luke as a child, then had her memory wiped (most plausible explanation in my opinion) - Still, we see in the flashback that she was abandoned as a small child. That gives her a couple of years of training with Luke. Ren has been training since he was a child, and is now an adult. Based on the film, I'd say he's in his early 20's, 18-19 years old at the youngest. That gives him 10+ years of additional training that Rey didn't have. So Ren, with Skywalker blood, trained with Luke, one of the strongest Jedi ever, and then switched to the dark side and gained additional training and powers, only to be brought down by this girl on her first day of using the Force. I can't buy that.

C) Ren was damaged by Chewie's Bowcaster - First of all, why didn't he freeze it in mid air like he did earlier in the movie? So he can't stop Chewie's shot from high above on a platform overlooking the bridge, but when Poe shoots him (from behind) from only a few yards away, he has time to turn around and stop it? Second of all, the gap in power between Ren and Rey should be so vast (because of point made in B) that, even wounded, Ren should have been able to ultimately win. In my mind, the ending makes more sense if when Rey suddenly realizes she should use the force (duh), she begins being able to go toe to toe with Ren, even scoring some solid blows. Ren, realizing that he should take her more seriously, ends the fight. As he is about to finish her off, that horribly convenient earthquake can then seperate them like it did.

Idk, these hero stories only work for me if there's a giant, seemingly impossible obstacle, that the main hero(ine) must fight and train super hard to somehow overcome. Seems like now, in the first episode we already know Rey has the edge. Yeah, Ren's going off to get more training, but so is Rey, and with the famed Luke Skywalker to boot. I feel like they already got this in the bag.


r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 21 '15

How many Star Wars haters does it take to screw in a light bulb?

0 Upvotes

None, because Star Wars haters are with the dark side.


r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 20 '15

[Spoilers] The Celebration of Mediocrity

6 Upvotes

So yeah, SPOILERS!

One thing I noticed reading on the internet is that having critique is being frowned upon lately. "How dare you talk bad about it you hater" or "can't you just like the movie for what it is and enjoy that?", is what you'll hear frequently.

This bothers me because this is basically the same is asking someone to settle for less, when that's not necessary. And this is especially the case with Star Wars. Critique is either waved away by calling someone a hater or, and this worries me, by speculating it away by either saying that it'll be all explained later or by just imagining things. I don't think you're supposed to guess what certain characters motivations or backgrounds are, or why certain events happen the way they do in a movie.

Isn't it the job of the movie to give you that information? Things like - what's the situation right now? What is the resistance? How does this all relate to the new republic? What is the new order? Where did they get a planet sized Death Star? Who are the knights of Ren, and where are they? And who the @$%! is Snoke anyway, and why does he look like he was animated the year A New Hope came out? Why does Kylo wear a mask? Why was the falcon just lying around on a planet? What happened between Leia and Han? Why is R2D2 conveniently (to the plot) waiting until after the battle to show the map? Who is Maz Kanata? Why is there a rivalry between Kylo and Hux? Why does Fin just want to run off (with Rey) all the time? What planets did they blow up, and especially why? Why does chewie's gun make people explode all of a sudden? And wtf is going on? You know, basic stuff. And since when do characters in a movie make obvious in-jokes on previous movies like they have seen the movies? They have Star Wars in the theaters in a galaxy far far away too?

Also, the argument that the originals had their flaws too and didn't explain everything either, doesn't stand. Of course they weren't flawless, I won't argue that, but at least they explained the stuff that was necessary. Enough that you didn't scratch your head at the end.

This is for the people who say it was a great movie and all the things they didn't understand just makes them want to see the next movie so bad, because it will all be explained in that one. If you are in a restaurant, and your starter just doesn't taste right, because they put half the ingredients in the main course, are you gonna give that starter a great review because it really made you want to eat the main course even more?

This is like letting the director getting away with a mediocre movie, giving it a great review and then doing the directors job for him by explaining away the problems with speculation (with your wookiepedia knowledge). Am I the only one who thinks this is dangerous? It's basically just giving them a free pass to just crapping out lazily written, rushed products and get away with it.

And don't get me wrong, The Force Awakens had its moments, and it certainly wasn't a horrible movie. But come on, as a stand alone movie, it's really not good. Imagine this wasn't Star Wars, no way it would have the reviews it has right now.

But that's just the point, Star Wars has become untouchable, anything Star Wars is amazing because Star Wars. This type of unaccountability is in 'my opinion' bad, and 'undeniably' good, for people who want to make a lot of money.

Ps. Did anyone else think the sounds were off? Like not Star Wars, and more JJ Abrams Star Trek, maybe it was the theater I saw it in, maybe it's just me.


r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 21 '15

Great homage to the original trilogy with the best bits of modern film making!

0 Upvotes

I just want to say that I really enjoyed it, and that it lived up to the hype for me! A lot of negative people are shouting quite loudly and I just wanted to say that I thought it was really well done. Fantastic job JJ Abrams, he managed to give a great homage to the original trilogy, to those people who say too similar, remember that George Lucas himself said each trilogy was to "mirror the other, like poetry". And I think JJ did that fantastically well. Practical effects mixed with CGI was great (apart from maybe one character who stuck out a bit), the aerial combat scenes were enough to make me want to be a pilot, and the lightsaber fights were realistic, people not really knowing what they were doing but each person having a distinctly different fight style! I loved how the dark side of the force now actually feels more powerful than the light, Kylo Rens rage filled outbursts showing how the dark side corrupts people and is about emotional outbursts, and Reys tranquility showing how her strength comes from NOT letting that happen. Old cast were great, new cast were fantastic in acting and character. I cannot wait to go see it again!


r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 21 '15

Kylo Ren, Han, and Rey explained...things are hardly ever as they seem to be in Star Wars. [MASSIVE SPOILERS]

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/StarWarsTFA • • Apr 05 '16

Question: Will TFA be released in Blue ray 3D?

0 Upvotes

r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 22 '15

(Spoilers) Rey is basically confirmed to be...

2 Upvotes

...a Skywalker.

This was a dialogue between R2 and C3PO.

C3PO: What did you find?

R2D2: indecipherable beeps

C3PO: Don't call me that!

Those indecipherable beeps, based on Threepio's reaction, could be assumed to be 'I found the bastard.'

He found Rey.

The bastard child.

Of Luke Skywalker.


r/StarWarsTFA • • Feb 08 '16

[REVIEW] We got Disney'd.

0 Upvotes

The Force Awakens is a complete disaster of a film for the die hard Star Wars fan, but probably great for the casual fan that doesn't really care all that much. Here's why:

  1. Leia is not a Jedi. Really? Does it make sense that a force-sensitive person would walk away from the power to be a Jedi? Especially when she saw 1st hand how dark Jedis can almost take over the galaxy. Does it make sense that she'd let her brother teach all the Jedi alone? No. I fully understand that we don't want to see a CGI Carrie Fisher jumping around with a lightsaber, but story-wise, it makes no sense. A good writer could've found a way around her being a Jedi, but also not currently being in fighting form. Leia cracking Death Star jokes doesn't help either.
    Han: "I'm trying to be helpful." Leia: "When did THAT ever help? And don't say the Death Star!" Leia just flippantly brings up the station that blew up her home world. Sure, that makes sense. Great writing JJ.

  2. Kylo Ren made the hero of the galaxy, Luke Skywalker, run away and hide? Seriously? I'm sorry, Kylo doesn't seem that much of a bad ass to me. Finn (Jar Jar 2.0) held his own against him for far too long. He then loses straight up to a person who never once held an ignited lightsaber in her life. I Don't care if he was wounded with a bowcaster, the person responsible for making Luke hide like a coward for an entire film should have easily overcome that.

  3. Finn is Jar Jar Binks. Disney's marketing of this film has Finn holding Luke's lightsaber on every poster and advertisement he's on. A bit misleading seeing as the guy gets his ass kicked every time he turns the thing on. Teasing Finn was a red herring, to surprise us all with the 1st female Jedi. I'm glad to have a female Jedi lead, just not glad they didn't proudly declare it by putting the lightsaber in Rey's hands in all the marketing from the start. It made poor Finn look like a chump and it didn't have to. It looks like they were purposely misleading to trick people into the theater because they thought we'd be too sexist to pay to see a female lead. I truly don't get why this doesn't anger more people. Anyway, Finn being the only stormtrooper to decide he's not going to fight just didn't seem plausible. Him telling the table of Rey, Han, and Maz that he was scared and wanted to run away was especially cringe inducing. Then him losing to the stormtrooper in a 1 on 1 duel is just the last straw for me. I know Finn himself was a stormtrooper, but he is one of the hero leads and none of them can lose a lightsaber duel to an un-named, face-less, throw away character. They simply can't. Not without that person looking like a giant moron anyway. You wonder why Finn's action figure is selling for $7 less than everyone else's right now? It's not because of his race, it's because he was portrayed like an idiot.

  4. Rey is god. I don't like it when the hero (female, male, or gender-less) is vastly overpowered without trying. Rey is more powerful than Luke was in Empire Strikes Back. With ZERO training. She can fly as well as Han and Lando with no experience flying the Falcon, and she can even translate every language like C3P0. I love that we have a female lead. I hate that she is a Mary Sue.

  5. Han Solo's death held no emotion for me. I went into this film with no spoilers, but I saw Han Solo's death coming from an hour away. Then when the actual scene is setup, it's insanely obvious what's about to happen. They may as well have had a neon sign in the background that read: "Han solo dies in this scene! Don't go for popcorn!" This is the kind of thing that pulls me out of movies. Then the actual death happened and I was like, "meh". The problem with me seeing the death coming from more then an hour away is I'll imagine the impending death scene. And it was cooler in my head.

  6. Chewie and Leia walk past each other after Han dies. This is a film breaking error on the part of JJ (Jar Jar) Abrams. It makes absolutely no sense that old friends and comrades would simply walk right past each other after the death of someone so important to both of them. They walked past each other without SO MUCH AS A GLANCE BETWEEN THEM. If they aren't ready to talk or if Leia wants to talk to Rey, fine, but you have to show something. A simple nod. Anything. I don't require anything that would take longer than 3 seconds of screen time, but to show nothing is a bush league mistake. These two characters are broken until it's explained why they behaved as if they'd never met before. I guess, Han who? As it stands, this is the worst single moment I've ever seen in a Star Wars film. It's not even close. Greedo shooting 1st is a very distant 2nd.

I get the need to want to love this. I get why it's hard to say it's a bad movie when those classic Star Wars films are in your blood. But this is a JJ Abrams film. And it's a very bad one. As a die hard Star Wars fan it causes me near physical pain to admit that. In a sense this film is 100% exactly like the first person shooter game Star Wars: Battlefront. It's a very thin experience for casuals, but it's painted like Star Wars, so people think they love it.


r/StarWarsTFA • • Jan 06 '16

Image of Rey on Ahch-to training with Luke. NSFW

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 25 '15

Theory! Rey is a Dark Lord/user! (Spoilers of course!)

1 Upvotes

Everything we know about SW says that to be on the light side, is hard work. It takes a long time, and training is hard. Even though Luke's training was short, Yoda warned him, don't take the easy way, THAT is the way to the dark side. Incomplete training, using anger/hate/fear is the way to the dark side. Now lets look at Rey. What do we know about her? She was abandoned. She lives in fear, she's anxious for someone to return. She is extremely aggressive in all of her actions. Even when she finally awakens in the final fight, she is calm for one second then gnashes her teeth and goes wild! Her easy mastery of the force can only be attributed to the dark side. She is afraid (she tries to run just like Fin). She has lots of redeeming qualities of course, but her main ones highlight her as a Dark user of the force. Her new 'father figure' is killed right away. We don't need to explain anything about how she can beat Kylo, she is drawn to the Dark side whereas he chooses it. The draw is what makes a dark user powerful, very quickly.


r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 23 '15

Saw it yesterday. Here's my take on it. (Spoilers)

2 Upvotes

I didn't think it was horrible, but I do have a problem when a movie insults my intelligence. The Star Wars genre has always been long on fiction and short on science but this movie totally planet busted the suspension of disbelief. I feel embarrassed that we've all hyped Star Wars to a new generation of children and all of them who see this movie are going to be dumber as a result.

  1. I liked Rey. I could see how a female living in a world without other human males would have to get tough to survive, but how does a person raised in poverty from a very young age (3?) by aliens and living hand to mouth wind up with a haughty British accent?

  2. It's been said (I see) that Rey is "overpowered". I don't mind that she is powerful. That's the force. What bothers me is that it took Luke and Anakin years to turn their power into something useful. I really have no patience for "deus ex machina" or in this case god from thin air. It makes no sense that she could beat Kylo Ren, gun down storm troopers, or use any of the advanced Jedi abilities without any kind of training.

  3. Finn's character is ridiculous and paper thin. Here is a man who is raised from a child in the ranks of storm troopers yet he suddenly grows a conscience during an attack on a village. Fine. But then he decides he wants to desert the First Order. Fine. On the way out he kills his fellow soldiers and is thrilled about it. How can someone abandon his life based on a conflict of conscience and then start killing his former friends without a good deal of hesitation and remorse? Is he a sociopath or something? Who does that and how can anyone consider him to be a hero or ever trust him? To change sides so cavalierly and then kill your former friends means you lack a conscience rather than you possess one.

  4. Phasma--how ridiculous is she? Here is a person who has risen through the ranks to become and officer. She's special and clearly she's stronger and harder than all the rest. Yet, put a blaster up against her head and she will give you the codes to lower the Death Planet's shields and enable the Rebels to kill all her friends and coworkers.

I'm not hard. I'm not tough, but I like to think that if someone put a gun against my head and asked me to ENABLE them to destroy everyone and everything in my country I would have the stones to tell them to go pound sand. This, especially considering that they would probably kill me anyway, which is basically what they did by locking her in a garbage chute just before they blow up the planet. She's not only cowardly but also dumb. I find that very hard to believe and frankly quite insulting to my intelligence. Also, they should have removed her helmet. With her helmet removed it would have been more plausible that she felt vulnerable enough to submit to what the Rebels wanted.

5. You blow up my planets then you are a monster. If I blow up your planet then I'm a freedom fighter. I find it hard to accept that either side made the decision to blow up entire planets and their populations so casually. To watch the First Order soldiers and officers fire their weapon so casually is unbelievable. You can be three things if you do something horrible. 1. Numb. No emotion or affect. 2. Delighted because you are a sick fuck. 3. Horrified and fighting your conscience even while you obey your orders.

What you are not is casual like you are making coffee for the boss.

6. The Death Planet (which is what I call it) is ridiculous. It is the most insulting concoction of engineering that fiction has ever created. Let's set aside the fact that they've basically carved out giant chunks of a planet and create a military base the size of Russia on it for a second. Let's ignore that this facility is over-sized considering the small number of troops it houses (let alone under-defended).

A. If you extinguish a sun then you extinguish the planets in orbit around it.

B. If you launch a particle weapon from one solar system to another you cannot expect that particle beam to split apart, change directions and hit various objects as if it were a homing missile.

C. If you are on a planet and can see the particle beam coming then that means the beam is traveling at sub light speed. If it's traveling as sub light speed then it would take centuries for it to travel from one solar system to the next.

D. If people on the planet could see the beam coming at them then so could the ships in orbit with all their scanners and detection equipment. Yet they all just sat there and didn't try to jump to light speed.

E. You can't extinguish a sun. What we also know is that when a sun runs out of fuel it goes supernova. Even if they were somehow able to siphon off the fuel of this sun then the sun would blow up.

F. The law of constancy of mass has been VIOLATED! (raped even!) As you draw off energy from the sun and store it in a planet that would greatly increase the mass and thus gravity of the planet. If you take enough energy that it extinguishes a sun and somehow put it in a space that is much smaller than the sun (which violates the law of conservation of mass) then it's likely everything on that planet would collapse into a black hole. At the LEAST people are going to find it hard to move around because the gravity goes up.

G. They already fired their planet buster so that means they've already extinguished their sun. Maybe they had 2 suns? But even so, once that second sun is gone then all they've got is a massive base out in the middle of nowhere.

H. If they extinguished their sun then they must have moved the entire planet to another solar system and done so in a relatively short period of time. That takes faster than light travel. FASTER THAN LIGHT TRAVEL OF AN ENTIRE PLANET! Bullshit.

7. How does Finn know how to use a light saber? That doesn't sound like Storm Trooper training to me. Especially not for someone who worked as a janitor.

8. Finn and Poe become fast friends. It's not like the Empire or it's descendants never tried to gain someone's confidence by befriending them so they could later use that relationship to destroy them. How can Poe be so trusting and naive and yet such a cunning and brilliant pilot? He's an idiot and apparently Disney thinks we are too.

9. I don't think there is a supercomputer in the world that can compute the odds of Rey being able to steal the Millennium Falcon, pilot it into space AND get picked up by a freighter piloted by Han Solo who was the original owner before it was stolen several times. It boggles the mind. What's the biggest number you can think of? That number to one.

10. Han Solo is a piece of shit. Here's why. A. He is once again a scumbag smuggler. B. He's lost his crew because the contraband he was carrying apparently ate them. He relates this fact as comic relief. "Yeah, I got all my crew killed because I got them to help me smuggle monsters. Hahaha! Ain't that funny?

11. They launch an entire mission to destroy the Death Planet because a former Storm Trooper said he can sabotage it from the inside, but they don't bother asking him how. The whole meeting takes about 30 seconds and they commit all their resources to the attack based on this flimsy poorly thought out plan.

The first Star Wars spent the entire movie building up to an attack that had in depth (if risky) plans to destroy the Death Star. Yet, they blew this one up with almost no planning.

12. Rebel pilots are ridiculous. Real pilots speak without affect. They are professional, calm, and serious. They behave this way so that when things get crazy they are trained to endure it. Yet these guys are yelling and hooting and when half their forces are destroyed they are still happy go lucky.

Go to a abattoir and see where your hamburger comes from and you will leave with a sense of reverence. You may still eat hamburgers but you will at least be a little more pensive about the process. These guys treat the entire destruction of planets and the deaths of all their friends and colleagues as if it were nothing.

Who does that? When 9/11 happened people were pretty upset and scared. They blew up the Republic in this movie. That's billions of people and not a single person cried or mourned or had a breakdown?

WTF?

Honestly, I find it hard to root for a people so cavalier and devoid of conscience and humanity.

Oh well. At least they gave us lots of shots of Daisy Ridley's ass (13).

Edit: Yes I know my outline is out of order. The website changed the numbering because I wrote a second paragraph. When I go to edit all numbering is correct. Sorry. Talk to Reddit Admins.


r/StarWarsTFA • • Feb 03 '16

Overrated

0 Upvotes

Am I the only one who thinks this movie is SUPER overrated? The pacing was abysmal, the story was a rehash of the original trilogy, the characters were one dimensional and the entirety of the plot depended on a massive series of coincidences. I mean, the original episodes depended on some coincidences, but Force Awakens is literally nothing but a series of unfortunate events (lol). I know it's an action movie and they're trying to do some fan service here, but it's like they're treating the average fan like a three year old - that the fan will only absorb certain things, and making the jump from cheese to pepperoni (In this case the introduction of some original plotpoints) is just too large. Some examples of odd pacing or plain awful plot development: Rey's sudden grasp of complicated force principles. (able to somehow out of nowhere block interrogation and do Jedi mind tricks) Starkiller Base - At least make a different superweapon Luke Skywalker - Literally a MacGuffin for everyone to chase after for the rest of the movie. Sure, it's a definite improvement on episodes 1-3, but it's not a good movie, and the fact that it's hailed as such by critics and fans alike annoys me. But that might be my inner cynic. Thoughts?


r/StarWarsTFA • • Jan 04 '16

Kylo Ren....Good character bad actor

0 Upvotes

Every one has there own opinion about Kylo, but i don't think that Adam Driver was particularly a good choice for that part, but in some scenes I will admit he was good but in general i really think Kylo could have been better if played by someone else. Someone like Alan Rickman who played Severus Snape would be good but a younger person of course.


r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 21 '15

*All the Spoilers* This movie was just a nostalgia trip.

7 Upvotes

Anytime someone familiar got on screen, the music played a familiar tone while the camera zoomed in.

The entire plot could be almost exactly traced to episode 4. -Space;Droid escape;Desert planet;Lone no-body desert person;escapes the empire/order with Han Solo;meets rebels/resistance; discover super weapon; take down super weapon by blowing up small/large hole;learns ways of the force along the way;end.

Nothing about the universe is explained. Luke is apparently an asshole who despite turning Vader to the lightside can't turn a punkass kid who is HIS SISTERS AND BESTFRIENDS SON back to the light so he just gives up and shuns the galaxy.

This was so bad it makes Phantom Menace look like a work of art. And it pains me to say this because I got hyped up from the trailers. Now I'm just depressed.

If you enjoyed this don't keep reading, because I'll just shit on your fun.

So the first order abducts children to make stormtroopers. The fuck is this? Aren't the imperials a race of people? Is the First Order just some kind of Cult? And what happened to the Empire? Bloody hell, what happened to the Rebel fleet, are they just x-wings now?

I feel incredibly let down by this film. It didn't just fail to deliver something new, it failed the years of character development fans came to interpret. How is anyone suppose to believe Luke, the last Jedi, either couldn't or refused to defeat Kylo Ren to avoid this whole situation and lead everyone on a goose chase?

How does a group a fraction of the size of the Empire manage to build a plant-gun when the empire had trouble building a death star? "Oh look, this movie is so different because the death star is a fucking planet now!" The whole scene where Leia and the Ackbar are talking about how to destroy it could have been reduced to 10 seconds if they just said "What's the plan, deathstar it? Yup, deathstar." as in, aim for the relative small hole and shoot.

I can't believe all the expanded universe lore got traded for this POS.

Fuck you Disney. Fuck you for shitting on my childhood and turning it into a nostalgic marketing money-grab.


r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 20 '15

jj abrams afraid of being the sequels guy? [minor spoiler?]

1 Upvotes

so i saw this article after just seeing the movie:

http://home.bt.com/news/uk-news/star-wars-director-jj-abrams-feared-being-the-guy-who-does-sequels-11364029664834

so if you don't want to be known as the sequels guy, STOP RECYCLING PREVIOUS MOVIE PLOTS... SO, just like in his second star trek movie where he recycled the wrath of khan storyline, he just did the same thing with episode seven. good job making episode four and episode six again... wtf?


r/StarWarsTFA • • Dec 24 '15

I love the movie, but another perspective NSFW

Thumbnail
deathandtaxesmag.com
0 Upvotes