r/StarVStheForcesofEvil
•
u/bananahkim
•
Dec 03 '24
Original Fanwork Heartbeat
Requested by anonymous on tumblr.
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil
•
u/bananahkim
•
Dec 03 '24
Requested by anonymous on tumblr.
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/Technical_Bonus_9696 • Jun 21 '25
Yep, it's time for another rant, man, and honestly, I think this issue was already talked before but it really is gross that there's people (or edgelords, you could say) constantly say destroying magic caused a "genocide", which...yeah, no, that's not how it works, and even if it is, why are people so insanely angry about that? Magical beings were never a focus on the show anyways, it was mostly between Mewmans and Monsters, but people seem to care about it just to knock it down a peg.
Wouldn't "purgatory work better"? It's just a less gross word because genocides don't work like that and freankly them overusing the word and the fact that they try to "villanize" Star caused of this sometimes doesn't help. I mean, tha'ts like saying Luz Noceda at the end of Owl House destroyed magic and by default, that means she also caused a "genocide". See how stupid that sounds?
Sorry for this rant, but I guess it just shows how petty the people who hated teh finale are when they throw such an ugly word like that when I'm pretty sure they're not exactly dead, they're just likely somewhere and it's just stupid. Not to mention, this is FICTIONAL, like...there's genocides happenign IRl and those should be called out and stopped, it's nothing like THIS.
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/Longjumping_Air_7562 • Jul 25 '25
Adam McArthur was such a nice person to talk with! Very talkative, made sure everyone was happy!
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/murrlogic • Sep 14 '19
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/Bluellan • Jul 03 '20
Please stop raiding Disney. It's cringe at this point. It's over and been over for years. The creator has moved on to other projects and declares it finished. Disney has moved on to other shows and projects. They aren't going to take a show out of production and replace it with an old show and only run it for a single season. They would have to hire more staff to make it and there's no money to be made after running it for a single season. They won't bring it back and some of you need to accept that. All these raids are making people look like spoiled children. Some shows only got 2 seasons with no resolution and nobody raiding them for more. Just accept the show is over, enjoyed it happened and move on.
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/EntertainmentFun9218 • Dec 22 '24
IF WE WANT SEASON 5, WE HAVE TO START RECORDING VIDEOS ON TIK TOK AND MAKE THIS SERIES BROADCAST WHEREVER WE CAN, SO THAT THEY SIGN PETITIONS AND DISNEY PAYS ATTENTION TO US
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/Rbrewfob • Jan 06 '20
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/KristopheIsCool2010 • Jul 23 '25
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/[deleted] • Apr 29 '17
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/[deleted] • Mar 18 '17
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/Rbrewfob • Aug 28 '19
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/TheOneWhoSaysMeep • Feb 06 '18
Idk, it seems kind of pointless. At this moment, downvoting is really only used when you don't like someone else's ship or opinion. I think if we got rid of it, we would get to see more variety in posts and comments, and actually be able to have decent conversations.
Plus, in the case of spamming or trolling, shouldn't the mods just handle that themselves?
Don't know if this is a realistic option or not, just throwing it out there. :P
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/jeepdave • Apr 08 '18
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/Consistent_Safety871 • Apr 08 '25

I am really annoyed by how Eclipsa is shown as this character who had her rightful throne stolen away from her because she fell in love with a monster. Or how everybody hates her just because she fell in love with a monster. And while I agree she was misunderstood and that she at least doesn't have any evil intentions, this doesn't excuse her awful performance as queen. Why do I say that? Well, let me explain by looking at her actions with a different perspective. Let's start with her first reign.
1st reign:
In her first reign, Eclipsa marries King Shastacan Spiderbite as per her late mother’s wishes. However, she is not happy in her first marriage. You see, she fell in love with someone else. Who did she fall in love with? Well, a monster named Globgore. But who is Globgore? A mewman-eating, village-destroying monster—also the King of Monsters—whom the Butterfly Kingdom is actively at war with. In all her wisdom, she decides to run off with Globgore. This one act alone is horrific for any mewman living in the kingdom.
First of all, magic is the most powerful weapon in the mewman arsenal and is vital in its ongoing war with the monsters. And who controls all the magic? Eclipsa. She effectively left thousands of lives at stake and the kingdom unable to defend itself against any foreign threat—especially against a monster army who doesn’t recognise the difference between civilians and armed forces. Is endangering thousands because you are unhappy in a marriage that you can always end a good thing? Not to mention an unprepared king regent causing a bureaucratic mess and social upheaval. I am not saying that mewmans are completely innocent here. They also did horrible atrocities, monsters, were victims of centuries of mewman oppression. But imagine this from a mewman perspective. Your queen just ran off with the person who destroyed your home and killed your family. To mewmans, he is as bad as Hitler.
To be fair, Globgore did change, but Eclipsa is seemingly the only one who knows about it and that doesn’t change what he did. We don’t let serial killers out of prison because they changed.
So what happens to Eclipsa for endangering thousands of lives? She gets crystallised. An arguably light punishment. Can you imagine what would happen if this occurred in real life? She would be publicly executed. I wouldn’t say Eclipsa or Globgore were wronged for what they did. The only person who was wronged was Meteora.
Meteora:
I am going to detour a little and talk about Meteora. Some say she should have been queen, that the throne was stolen from her. It wasn’t. First of all, Meteora is a bastard child, meaning that she was born outside of the royal marriage, making her illegitimate. But in our history, there were cases where a bastard child came to the throne, I hear you say. Consider the circumstances. There was no way that she would ever be queen. Why? Not only because she was illegitimate but also because she is the daughter of Globgore—who, let me remind you, is seen about as bad as Hitler. It would be like the British making Hitler their Prime Minister during WW2. There would be open revolts, foreign kingdoms would go to war, the Butterfly dynasty would collapse. While we, as viewers, know St. Olga’s was an oppressive institution, it was not seen that way at the time. The king likely thought he was making the best political and personal decision available to him — hiding a scandal while giving Meteora a structured life.
I will detour even more because I really want to talk about this.
Friend, let’s talk about government legitimacy. You see, every government needs to get its legitimacy from somewhere. For example, democracies get their legitimacy from the people. A majority of the people voted for their government, so they have the right to levy taxes and enforce laws. So where do monarchies get their legitimacy from? Short answer: God. God gave that family the right to rule, so they can enforce laws and levy taxes. That is why royal blood was so important, because it gave you the right to rule. But Mewni doesn’t have a religion. So what gives its monarchy legitimacy? I would say it is the control over magic. They are the only ones who can use magic, so they can use that power to rule.
Now, to be fair, bloodline still holds symbolic weight — many people in Mewni clearly care about the Butterfly name and its connection to tradition. But at the end of the day, power doesn’t rest in blood, it rests in magic. Whoever holds the wand holds the power, and by extension, the throne. Mewni’s monarchy functions like a dictatorship disguised in royal aesthetics. This hybrid system — where the aesthetics of monarchy mask the mechanics of dictatorship — means that legitimacy comes not from divine right or democratic will, but from raw magical power. Why do I say that? Think about it. Dictatorships aren’t seen as hereditary even though power often goes from one family generation to another. But they also have to keep their population uneducated and repressed because they don’t have the stability of a monarchy. Mewni's monarchy is interesting because the queen has an actual source of power completely under her control but also wouldn’t be seen as hereditary. That is amazing becuse you don´t need to repress your population, as there is no threath to someone taking that power and you have full advantages of absolutist rule. Anybody who has the magic wand can be the king or queen of Mewni. That’s why when King Shastacan gave Festivia the wand — and legally recognised her — she became the rightful queen. She wasn’t of Butterfly blood, but she held the source of magic. That alone made her legitimate. By all logic, Star is still the rightful princess and Moon still the rightful queen.
2nd reign:
Eclipsa’s second reign really shows her incompetency. After Star does the biggest mistake of her life and gives the throne “back” to Eclipsa (who also abdicated by running off with a monster, so has no legitimate claim), HER FIRST ACT 5 SECONDS AFTER BECOMING QUEEN IS ALREADY A DISASTER. What did she do? She moved the capital to the monster temple. But why is this so bad, you ask? Well, let’s compare the two capitals.
The old capital has: centuries of infrastructural development, well-established trade routes, fertile land, enough room for expansion, a good central location between the kingdoms, and is surrounded by water—making it easily defendable. The land around it is mostly without trees, making a surprise attack impossible.
And the new? Well, it is a marsh or a swamp—it is not really clearly defined—but neither is suitable for growing corn. The agricultural production would plummet. The region is not even close to being able to support such a large population. While I couldn’t find any concrete information on its exact location, from the show it can be deduced that it is quite isolated from the rest of the kingdoms. That would make trade or international diplomacy quite hard. It is also quite enclosed by mountains and the Forest of Certain Death, making expansion quite hard and it has no source of clean water. From what I can tell, the water next to it is either an ocean or a swamp (I could be wrong it is not really shown so take this witha a grain of salt). And from what we’ve seen, magic can’t just make food instantly—it has to be grown.
Anyway, but that is recoverable. I mean, with magic and constant focus, the new capital could be built to its needs (despite the massive bureaucratic and logistical problems of the relocation of so many people).
So what does Eclipsa do? Completely ignores the kingdom and leaves an inexperienced and irresponsible 15-year-old (I think she was 15 at the time) to basically rule on her behalf while she cries about her frozen husband. Nothing. No economic or social reforms. No help to the people whose lives were destroyed by HER DAUGHTER. No help to the monsters who were still being discriminated against. Just nothing. But she does ATTACK a member of the Magic High Commission.
Now, they were turned into just blatant racists by the end of the show, HOWEVER they were still, at the time, a respected organisation by the other kingdoms. Her attack only solidified the other nations' fears of her and continued to alienate her on the international stage. I would just like to say that Rhombulus was justified to deny Eclipsa’s wish. As we established before, Globgore is still seen as a village-destroying, mewman-eating monster. In his eyes, Eclipsa was asking him to unfreeze a WAR CRIMINAL. It also shows how irrational and hot-tempered Eclipsa is—immediately resorting to violence when she did not get her way. Afterward, she completely ignored a ROYAL VISIT from the only kingdom willing to even speak to her and left an unprepared Star to conduct the tour, who majorly fumbled it.
Another awful act was confiscating the houses of mewmans and "returning" them to the monsters. This, in my opinion, was the worst decree done by Eclipsa—not only was she expropriating homes mewman families used to live in for generations, but she left many of them literally homeless and basically to their fate. And you wonder why so many mewmans grew to absolutely despise their "Queen" who had only done them harm so far. Eclipsa repeatedly forgets that she is the “queen” of MONSTERS AND MEWMANS and repeatedly blatantly favours the monsters—completely alienating the majority of the population.
Also, it is completely unfair to punish someone for the mistakes of their predecessors generations ago. I would also like to mention a different side. One more tied to economics, because even if the morality behind the decision is completely justified (which it is not), the economic impact would have been terrible. Massive land reforms do not work for a reason. Because what Eclipsa did is take land from highly productive, skilful, smart farmers and gave it to the unproductive, unskilful monsters lacking proper tools or knowledge. It has happened in Africa and every time the agricultural production was completely destroyed.
But it wasn’t just farmers. It was everyone: textiles, ironworkers, pottery, woodworkers, animal farmers, glassmakers… everyone. And as I have said, we see from the old Monster Town that the monsters have nowhere near the knowledge or the skills to replace that. The iron tools couldn’t be replaced, the clothing would be reversed to its most basic form, the bricks wouldn’t be produced… It would be an economic collapse, ironically hurting the ones that it is trying to help—the monsters. In reality, we would see poverty and mass starvation. Just look from the eyes of the avrage citizen. In last few month your queen seems to hate you is activly trying to free the most horrific monster you ever knew abaout took away your home, destroyed your standard of living, and coused mass food insecurities. No wonder there was a coup.
Now, I understand that it is a children’s show whose viewers probably don’t understand basic economics. But my problem is that the issue that the show is trying to present is incredibly complex. It includes many things—among them economics—and I would argue that by not representing all the sides fairly, it is actively doing more harm than good.
Final thoughts:
Eclipsa is a good person. She tries to do good, but meaning good and doing good are two very different things. By being so completely incompetent, irrational, and sometimes just straight-up stupid, she does far, far more harm than good. Her inability to separate her feelings from her public responsibilities makes her incredibly unreliable. She herself caused the instability that allowed someone like Mina to rise to power. Monster and mewman civilisations can be integrated, but Eclipsa’s constant favouritism and alienation of the rest of the population was not the way to do it. She should have never been queen, and her incompetence endangered the lives of the entire kingdom. If Mina hadn’t led a coup, someone else would have.
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/General_Dictator • Apr 28 '19
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/Ordinary_Chemical596 • Jul 01 '26
Sorry, this was not meant to be so long. This was originally like 7 sentences. 💀
One of the biggest themes of this show in the latter two seasons is prejudice, y’know, don’t solely judge people based on looks as we are all “human” or have feelings. It’s an honest sentiment, but the way this show goes about communicating that sentiment is fucked. Let me explain.
In the last 2 seasons of the show, Star discovers that monsters can be just as normal as humans and monsters then turn into some marginalized class. The thing is, monsters have been morally gray or downright vicious since the very start of the show. Literally, at the beginning, these monsters had unique advantages in combat over any human/mewman, and they had evil intentions of stealing the wand for selfish reasons. Toffee was a bad person at the end of the day as he was a general who amassed a monster army and killed Queen Moon’s mother and other mewmans. The goal was for him to destroy magic so that monsters would have a tactical advantage to take over by force. Star’s magic was truly the main thing that was protecting these mewmans. This show is called Star VS the Forces of Evil, and Queen Moon gave it to her to protect her from “the forces of evil,” aka monsters who were threatening her. It’s important that mewmans marginalized monsters in the first place… but they are fucking monsters! Of course they should be scared. If bears became human-like, I wouldn’t be any less afraid of them. If anything, I would probably be more scared as they might want revenge for any time we killed them. As I said, these monsters have tactical advantages in hand-to-hand combat, but the magic is something that they don’t have. So, by the end of the show, magic is destroyed. Now, that creates a huge problem for all sorts of reasons. Not only did Star kill a bunch of magic-based creatures that we spend episodes getting to know, that’s a whole separate problem. The one problem I want to focus on is how mewmans have a huge disadvantage in case Toffee sympathizers come out and disrupt things. It is silly to assume the best in all of these monsters that have feelings of hostility towards mewmans after centuries of oppression. Now that they have the upper hand, they can easily take over. Magic created a better power balance, as seen with how Moon disrupted Toffee’s army.
Of course, Mewny has formed alliances with many kingdoms, such as the Underworld and the Pony Head Kingdom, so one could assume that if monsters do act up, the alliance could protect them. But there are a few things wrong with that. The first is that past events such with Meterora prove that alliances can only go so far. Secondly, the more damning of which, now that Mewny has no power or magic as a nation, why would they be alliances with these other nations anymore. There is no advantage with partnering with Mewny now that they have 0 power. If anything, this decision to kill members of the magical high commission and destroy magic would make them less favorable overall.
Then, there was the whole Meteora problem. She was sympathetic, sure, but her powers as a hybrid Mewman and monster completely overwhelmed everyone from all sorts of powers backgrounds, making her one of the most powerful characters in the show. Meteroa’s overwhelming power shows a reason why these two species should not mix because the power dynamics are completely out of balance. Yes, her destruction was caused by trauma, but that doesn’t justify her actions at the end of the day. Toffee and Meteora are sympathetic, but are evil at the end of the day. Ludo gets redeemed because he was punished each time he committed an evil act against Star, but also never committed a truly heinous crime.
Okay, so bottomline: the show has created this incredibly complex issue. It’s so complex, that I failed to acknowledge all the facets at play here. Like, the whole thing with Mina & Salaria along with Mewdependance day is one thing, but then you have the Lobster Claws episode demonstrating how monsters can pretty much be instinctively evil. In any case, the problem lies in how the way in which they answered this issue leaves a lot of holes in the plot, leaving the ending to be non-conclusive and deeply unsatisfying. The show just decides to this different angle in the second half and it just messes with the pre-established ideas set up in the first two seasons. It makes me frustrated as I feel as if the first two seasons are disconnected from the second half, making the show inconsistent with itself. It doesn’t properly set up the ideas it introduces in the second half.
Here is the thesis: Destroying magic in the finale creates inequality in a separate way against Mewmans undermining the whole equality message that the show is aiming for, as monsters have proven to have viscous, self-serving tendencies against others.
It’s a huge shame that it ended up very messy because there are so many things that this show does right! The dynamic between Star and Marco being platonic is genuinely fun and they play off of each other very well. The cast of fun characters from both Echocreek and Mewny are amazing and memorable. The animation way super fun in the early episodes. The plot becoming more in-depth as we explore characters and history is genuinely interesting and compelling, but they fumbled the bad at the end creating this ending that feels deeply flawed.
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/Red_Pineapple012 • Nov 19 '25
I don't hate this show, honestly kinda love it. But we can all agree this series had a bad ending
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/[deleted] • Jul 21 '15
I'm starting to love this show. If it hasn't been made already, I can see the biggest criticism of the show, besides the lack of depth in both the plot and characters which for now gets a pass because it's a brand new show and needs time to develop, is the lack of lgbt representation and its push of heteronormative relationships.
However, I think they might have alluded to some already. I know this is me reading way too much into things, but I think based on what we've seen so far, Jackie Lynn Thomas is a lesbian. Here me out. So when we get our introduction to her in matchmakers, she only acknowledges star. In cheer up star, we see that her skateboard has a heart on it, I know that means nothing but in last night's episode, she rides said skateboard with Janna. They're both on the same skateboard and Janna is pretty much grasping Jackie Lynn's chest.
Anyways I am reading way too much into things but I think it would be cool if that happened. plus it makes starco more of a possibility. I ship starco and last night had plenty of that but let me know what you all think. I really think this show has the potential to be on par with Steven Universe, not only in terms of story/character depth but also being progressive as well.
-someone who has too much time on their hands
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/merdem12 • Apr 19 '19
Like I mean the relationship was too rushed and they didn't get developed enough, most (not all though) of the "romantic" moments were moments that were in times of danger. Having said that I'm not saying their friendship is a lie they've gone through moments where their friendship was falling apart but they always managed to pull themselves together. Aside from the Blood Moon Ball (although that too was kinda of a moment where Marco had to come because he had to save Star from Tom not because he just felt like dancing with her) they've never had a true romantic moment that didn't involve danger or someone making the situation romantic. (the booth buddies episode is an example of a forced romantic moment from an outside source)
I can understand why the creator personally doesn't ship Starco because it's not a well structured ship. Since there is tons of shows where the characters don't end up with their main love interest such as Regular Show, Adventure Time, and Gravity Falls ( shows that really demonstrate the difficulty of what real love is all about) the whole concept of falling in love with the main girl and being a couple isn't as popular anyone. It's possible Starco might happen since the fans really want it to but on the surface Star and Marco have a relationship that's built on friendship since they trust each other and respect each other not out of love.
Besides this is SVTFOE there's always something shocking that's going to happen.
Maybe it will happen but I think it won't.
Not hating on the folks who ship Starco though y'all have your opinions and I have mine
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/jona_grey • May 16 '19
r/StarVStheForcesofEvil • u/sinistermack • Mar 07 '17
Remember Naysaya??
Remember what was writte about it??
"It reveals itself when the afflicted attempts to woo their true love exposing the victim's deepest darkest secrets for all to hear and to judge"
Pretty much confirmed that Jackie is Marco's true love.
Check mate, Starcos