r/StarTrekTNG • u/nooniensoong97 • May 08 '26
Treknatural
r/StarTrekTNG • u/NeoNoir90210 • Apr 08 '26
“I, Borg” is usually held up as one of Picard’s best moments. He has a real chance to cripple the Borg by using Hugh as a weapon, and he walks it back. He chooses not to turn an individual into a tool for genocide, even knowing what the Borg have done. It’s consistent with who he is. It’s also a decision made with the Federation still standing behind him. The Borg are a threat, but they are not an immediate, existential problem in that moment.
Now look at Janeway with Species 8472 in “Scorpion.” She does the opposite. She allies with the Borg to survive, fully aware of what they are and what they’ve done. She gives them a weapon to fight 8472 because the alternative is Voyager being wiped out. There’s no speech that solves it, no third option that preserves her ideals. It’s a deal with an enemy to stay alive.
If you flip those situations, I don’t think they land the same way. Put Picard in “Scorpion,” cut off from Starfleet, with his ship on the verge of destruction, and I’m not convinced he makes that alliance. His instinct in “I, Borg” was to pull back from using the Borg’s own nature against them, even when it could have ended the threat. That same instinct in the Delta Quadrant could get his crew killed.
And if you put Janeway in “I, Borg,” it’s hard to see her passing up that opportunity. Not out of cruelty, but because she consistently prioritizes the survival of her crew over holding the moral high ground. She’s shown she’s willing to use what’s in front of her, even if it’s uncomfortable.
A lot of this comes down to how the characters are written and the context they’re placed in. Picard is built to be an idealist inside a system that can absorb that idealism. The Enterprise-D is a flagship, the Federation is stable, and the stories are structured to give him room to find a principled way out. Even when the stakes are high, the world around him is not collapsing. That’s what allows Picard to be Picard.
Janeway doesn’t get that. Voyager strips away the institution and forces her to operate without support, without reinforcement, and without the assumption that things will stabilize. The writing pushes her into corners where there is no clean answer, and she has to act anyway.
That’s why swapping them matters. Picard’s strengths are tied to the Alpha Quadrant and the system behind him. Take that away, and those same instincts start to look like a liability. He works because of his context, not in spite of it.
r/StarTrekTNG • u/Successful-Bed-8255 • May 13 '26
r/StarTrekTNG • u/ThrawnAndOrder • Dec 29 '25
EDIT... people are asking for examples, so here you go:
Season 1 (1987–1988)
The Naked Now
The Last Outpost
Lonely Among Us
The Battle
The Big Goodbye
Angel One
Too Short a Season
When the Bough Breaks
We’ll Always Have Paris
Season 2 (1988–1989)
The Child
Where Silence Has Lease
Loud as a Whisper
The Schizoid Man
The Dauphin
Contagion
The Icarus Factor
Pen Pals
Up the Long Ladder
Shades of Gray
Season 3 (1989–1990)
The Ensigns of Command
Who Watches the Watchers
The Bonding
The Enemy
The Price
The Vengeance Factor
The Hunted
The High Ground
The Offspring
Allegiance
Captain’s Holiday
Hollow Pursuits
Transfigurations
Season 4 (1990–1991)
Legacy
Reunion
Final Mission
The Loss
The Wounded
Night Terrors
Identity Crisis
The Host
The Mind’s Eye
In Theory
Season 5 (1991–1992)
Silicon Avatar
The Game
New Ground
Hero Worship
Conundrum
Power Play
The First Duty
Imaginary Friend
The Next Phase
Time’s Arrow
Season 6 (1992–1993)
Realm of Fear
Rascals
Tapestry
Frame of Mind
Suspicions
Rightful Heir
Second Chances
Descent
Season 7 (1993–1994)
Liaisons
Interface
Gambit
Phantasms
Dark Page
Attached
Inheritance
Homeward
Sub Rosa
Thine Own Self
Eye of the Beholder
Journey’s End
Firstborn
Bloodlines
Preemptive Strike
.............. I just find they lack so much imagination.
r/StarTrekTNG • u/--lily-rose-- • Mar 27 '25
r/StarTrekTNG • u/BruceDSpruce • 17d ago
I’ve had a longstanding question that exists between the canon and my head-canon…
I think there’s a direct relationship between 4 distinct characters (groups) in Star Trek but I’m not sure if there is an in-universe reason or a fan’s head-canon they’re be willing to share.
The 4 people (groups) and my general thoughts are:
- Guinan and the El-Aurians. Multi-dimensional beings. They live at least slightly outside space/time, and live for centuries and can detect changes in the space-time continuum. I think there’s bodies we see on screen, are like favorite outfits or video game avatars for extra dimensional being to interact comfortably in a 3D world. I assume they can interact with other extra-dimensional beings like Q due to the history of conflict.
- Wesley Crusher and the Travelers. Beings able to travel and explore space and time with their amazing mental powers. I honestly think Travelers are on the continuum of the Q-continuum, just the less powerful end.
- Picard in the middle. I don’t know the degree or significance but Picard seems the character most directly in the middle of all this.
- Q and the Q Continuum. The all-powerful extra-dimensional beings. Q specifically seems to want to interact with Picard the most, and can warp time and reality.
Is there specific stories that connect theses more or clarifies what if any ways they’re all related or not? Any theories on how extra-dimensional beings work in Star Trek?
r/StarTrekTNG • u/Significant_Train761 • Sep 05 '26
I have created LGBTQIA+ ST fan community r/Gaytrekkiefans it is my first one i done. But in this one we go from Star trek animated series - Picard ( all the franchise ) including the ST movies.
make it so. engage.
r/StarTrekTNG • u/Adam-Many82 • Aug 24 '22
r/StarTrekTNG • u/Shyam_Lama • Dec 02 '25
This is a brief shot (only a second or two) from an episode in which, iirc, Data played a central role. Anyone know which episode this was?
r/StarTrekTNG • u/Shyam_Lama • Nov 15 '25
See title. The episode starts with Troi waking up, not knowing where she is, and looking in a mirror to discover that she looks like a Romulan. She's then informed by an actual Romulan that she's aboard a Romulan spaceship.
Wikipedia and MemAlpha would have it that she was "kidnapped and surgically altered", but no information about this kidnapping is given in the episode -- in fact the Enterprise crew seem unaware or completely uninterested in the fact that Troi has somehow disappeared. Nor is any info about her disappearance given in any earlier episode AFAIK. Or was there? (I haven't watched all TNG episodes.) It also doesn't make sense that when she's finally back aboard Enterprise the "surgical alterations" are gone in the very next scene, apparently having been undone by Crusher in sickbay without leaving the slightest trace.
It seems to me that it's a very large plothole and a very unusual one since Trek normally plugs plotholes with a line of dialogue or two. But maybe I've missed something.
r/StarTrekTNG • u/Legitimate_Lion_3575 • Mar 17 '26
Meaning, it seems like we're all in a hurry to create new shows when what SHOULD be happening is that we allow the shows that are currently under production to have enough episodes to give the characters and the storyline proper time to develop into something truly meaningful.
r/StarTrekTNG • u/outtatime_88MPH • Apr 14 '25
Prepare the main deflector for Sonic BOOOOM.
r/StarTrekTNG • u/Patora1701 • May 13 '26
She saw the Inner Light
r/StarTrekTNG • u/Outside-Treacle-7406 • 17d ago
r/StarTrekTNG • u/happydude7422 • Mar 16 '26
Since Michael dorn was actually on chips this would be cool if the entire cast of tng were on chips
r/StarTrekTNG • u/ThatsHerbieHandcock • Aug 24 '26
Take your pick as to why it would feel awkward watching that episode. I got ick vibes the whole time like Jenna was taking advantage of someone who clearly couldn't possible understand what's needed for a human relationship. I know they want Data to have autonomy, but sheesh, I kept waiting for someone to step in and say "hey,hey, let's pump the brakes for a second here"