r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 25 '25

Absolutely crap. Couldn't finish it

13 Upvotes

How is Star Trek section 31 which was billed as such a great movie - turned out to be so bad. I'm only a half an hour into it and I had to turn it off. This is definitely not up to Star Trek standards by any means.


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 25 '25

Horrible.

16 Upvotes

I’m not gonna make it through the entire movie unless it gets less bad real quick. From the intro on it’s been a shit show. Bad sets. Bad graphics. The worst dialog. I mean embarrassingly bad for the actors dialog. Not their fault. It really feels like it was written by ai that never had been trained on anything. wtf. How shitty.


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 26 '25

Who are the fans of this movie and what did they enjoy about it?

7 Upvotes

Serious, non-snark question. I'm banned from /StarTrek and most anywhere else on here is going to be anti-NuTrek or just not serious. It has the second worst IMDB score of anything Star Trek production, between "Shades of Gray" and "Worst Contact," and yet there are still some people rating it highly there. Obviously it resonated with some people and Id be interest in understanding that better


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 25 '25 Take My Energy

24 minutes in

14 Upvotes

I’m going to have to stop and go do something else. This is is the point where the different members of section 31 are introduced to Georgiou and the audience, and it’s a ripoff of guardians of the galaxy, which I love, except this isn’t guardians of the galaxy. This is Star Trek.


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jul 08 '24

Agent Georgiou will be great in Star Trek s31

2 Upvotes

Michelle Yeoh formerly a emperor formerly starship captain


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 25 '25

Something feels out of place in time here.

1 Upvotes

So I was initially delighted to see that Rachel Garrett is a character in Section 31. We are definitely led to believe that she is the same Rachel Garrett who was in command of the Enterprise-C in the episode Yesterday’s Enterprise. 

I’m trying to figure out the timeline…but the math is just not mathing for me. 

So Yesterday’s Enterprise was a season 3 episode. The Enterprise-D was commissioned in 2363 so let’s assume season 3 was also 3 years later. That would place the events in Yesterday’s Enterprise at about 2366. Now in the episode the Enterprise-C came forward in time 22 years, which means that Rachel Garrett was from about 2344.

We met Philippa Georgiou in the first season of Star Trek Discovery which is beings in 2255 (89 years prior to when Garrett was lost in command of the Enterprise-C). Georgiou goes forward into the future with the Discovery crew and then is returned back to her time by the Guardian of Forever. Presumably the Guardian returned her back to the late 2250’s as she was the mirror counterpart of Captain Philippa Georgiou who died in 2255. 

So let’s be generous and say the events in Section 31 take place 10 years after the first season of Discovery. That would put us at about 2265. This places us about 79 years before Garrett and the Enterprise-C was lost. 

Additionally, in the movie Rachel Garrett seems to be in her 20’s or early 30’s…let’s say the character is 25 years old.

So 79+25 would suggest that Rachel Garrett was roughly 104 years old at the time of her death in Yesterday’s Enterprise?

Like I said the math is not mathing for me.


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 26 '25

Meme/Joke A Simple 'Section 31' Change That Would Likely Fix Most People's Concerns

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 30 '25

Did it get any better?

12 Upvotes

I only made it to when they went from the office to the ship and everyone was introduced to Philippa. The script and characters were horrible, it was just too painful to watch. I didn't think it could be worse than Discovery, I was wrong. I liked the Philippa character, I had high hopes.

Did it get any better? Is worth diving back in?


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 25 '25

Loved this movie

12 Upvotes

Hoping they have a series or sequel. The characters were interesting. Lots of action. Really loved it!


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 23 '25

Article/Review Star Trek: Section 31 is firing on all cylinders

Thumbnail
theverge.com
15 Upvotes

r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 23 '25

Article/Review STAR TREK: SECTION 31 Is a Dreary, Unfortunate Misfire — Our Spoiler-Free Review

Thumbnail
blog.trekcore.com
10 Upvotes

r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 25 '25

Question S31 better or worse than TNG “shades of grey”?

2 Upvotes

Please, share other comparisons.


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 25 '25

This movie seems like it was written by 60-year-old ad executives to try and get tweens into the Star Trek genre.

17 Upvotes

r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 25 '25

I liked Section 31

42 Upvotes

This got removed from r/startrek for a reason I’m unclear of. To put it out there, I’ve seen every single Trek property, own most of the DVDs, and a few of the books. Different ain’t bad. It’s VERY different than any other Trek. Feels like a video game at points. My only gripes are that I felt they rushed you through the new character intros (they only had 95 minutes so I’ll give them a break) and I wished they pushed it to an R rating so we could have seen more brutality from the Emperor. I’d watch more Section 31 if they made them. But apparently I’m in a minority 🖖


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jul 27 '24

Trailer "Star Trek: Section 31" Teaser Trailer

Thumbnail
youtube.com
17 Upvotes

r/StarTrekS31 • • Aug 08 '24

Article/Review The ‘Star Trek: Section 31’ Movie Sees A “Misfit” Crew Balancing Special Ops Mission And Starfleet Morality

Thumbnail
trekmovie.com
5 Upvotes

r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 24 '25

I’d love a prequel series.

2 Upvotes

If we can afford to have Yeoh on the show AND we killed two and replaced one crew member who sounded really fun to see bouncing off of in the opening scenes of the movie.

I’d love Star Trek does Agents of SHIELD.


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 24 '25

This movie convinced me never to take online Star Trek discourse seriously.

50 Upvotes

I just finished the movie and I really enjoyed the action flick. I actually wouldn’t mind if this was a mini series, or a sequel on S31 missions every episode would be a lot of fun… or a short trek on Philipa’s younger years. I like that they made a Star Trek show that actually has little to do with Starfleet because the Star Trek universe actually has plenty of story opportunities outside starfleet and the federation.

I went online and searched for “Section 31 review” and literally every video or article I come across has some version of the title “worst Star Trek movie”… few of them actually discuss the movie. You can tell content creators are just jumping on the hate bandwagon. It’s not nearly as dramatic as so many of these people make it. I hope the rage watching green light’s more movies/shows.


r/StarTrekS31 • • Mar 16 '21

Theory My conspiracy theory for what section 31 show really is.

6 Upvotes

I think the whole section 31 series is a red harring. I feel we are getting a Temporal Wars show.

Discovery has talked about temporal wars and time traveling significantly.

This series would easily allow for fan favorites to pop back in and give the show more story lines. Hell we could actually see William Shatner or Denise Crosby. Time travel allows this.

So just my thought.


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 26 '25

Out of phase…

7 Upvotes

Why didn’t the case… and the people go through the floor while out of phase?


r/StarTrekS31 • • Feb 02 '25

Question Pilot episode or movie?

10 Upvotes

This movie literally felt more like a pilot episode! Do we know when the actual show will air? Also, IMDB users gave it a 3.8/10 thus far…ouch!!


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 24 '25

Oh dear......

36 Upvotes

I'm a big fan of Discovery (yes, not a popular view) and I loved Emperor Georgiou. I so wanted to love this film.

Unfortunately it's dreary, formulaic and looks like they spent less on it than a single episode of Discovery (and I'm guessing that's NOT the case).

I think Section 31 might have made a good case of the week series, but this is just pointless.

Sorry for the negativity, but as I'm home alone with my dogs this was the only place to vent. The dogs are now happily watching reruns of Babylon 5!


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 27 '25

Alok should have been klingon

5 Upvotes

Yeah, the show was a mess.

But this guy should have been a smooth-headed tos klingon, rather than a 20th century Eugenics Wars refugee.


r/StarTrekS31 • • Jan 25 '25

It had all the ingredients for a good movie except a script

18 Upvotes

Loved the vibe and aesthetic they were going for, but the script/dialogue was just not it.

It kinda seemed like it was supposed to be a tv show and halfway through production they folded and crammed it into 90min.

My main questions were

  1. Why did she leave her empire to become somewhat of a pacifist in a parallel universe?

  2. Why did they kill off the coolest character of the gang (Melle) and then the other characters barely acknowledge it in the next scene? Yes they talk about her but there’s almost zero emotional stakes for their friend that just got vaporized

Idk and then JLC popping up made me think of Borderlands from this last year lol. But I will say that S31 is LIGHTYEARS better than that movie!