r/StarTrekProdigy • • Feb 18 '25

Character Discussion Dal should have been Janeway's son

0 Upvotes

In the infamous VOY episode Threshold, Tom Paris mutated into a lizard alien and kidnaps Captain Janeway, making her mutate into a lizard herself. Tom breeds with Janeway, making alien lizard babies. The Voyager crew finds them and cures them, but they left the babies on the planet though in the Delta Quadrant.

This would have been an awesome backstory for Dal, being one of the lizard babies that the Voyager crew left behind.

Dal would have been found by his Ferengi foster mother on the planet, and the rest is history.


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Jul 06 '24

Question Anyone else think this should be the end?

0 Upvotes

Just kinda curious if anyone else thinks Prodigy shouldn't continue any further?

I would like a movie just to finally give us Dal's backstory. But, I just saw a 40 episode series, and I loved 39 episodes (I didn't think it made sense for the characters to fight their holograms in "Imposter Syndrome").

It's like I've just watched the Beatles finish Abbey Road. Yeah, I'm sure they could put out some more decent work, but this is the high point! Quit now and you're legends!


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Dec 08 '22

Makes no sense

0 Upvotes

Why can't they just land on some habitable planet and send a message to Starfleet about the virus from somewhere outside Protostar?


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Jul 04 '24

Fan Art Let's do this! First up: the fan favorite!

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/StarTrekProdigy • • Nov 09 '21

Can we talk about how ridiculous that “Brig” is?

1 Upvotes

The Protostar is a small ship by Federation standards. The bridge nearly takes up a tenth of the main body if not more. In the same episode we see that the crew has a bunk barracks style room, and the shuttle bay is so small that to use it you need to replicate a shuttle, so barely large enough for one shuttle. Everything we see about the ship is to emphasize how small it is, and what comprises had to be made from Star Trek norms to accommodate that small size.

So why is the brig the same size as the engine room? Makes you wonder what the purpose of the ship is when arguably anyone in the brig has more living space than a normal crew member.


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Feb 11 '23

Pronunciation of 'Prodigy' in the series

5 Upvotes

So dumb question: whenever anyone says 'prodigy' in the show they say 'praw-gin-ee' instead of 'prawd-ehh-gee'.

I've never heard it this way-- proper British of some sort???


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Jul 05 '26

General Discussion More friction = better than DISCO

17 Upvotes

Why is this the best star trek show with the most star trek like structure right now?

Seriously, why is a kid's show better than the other offerings?

Honestly, even the concept of the protostar drive as propulsion is better thoughts out than the spore drive. I just love that the protostar drive has a cooling off / charging period, it makes for so much better storytelling than the lazy frictionless disco travel.


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Jan 14 '22

Question Does anyone hear the first few notes of the Imperial March melody played out in the beginning of the opening credits?

1 Upvotes

r/StarTrekProdigy • • Jul 09 '24

Meme/Joke All Humans are SIMS

2 Upvotes

I can’t get over the fact that all humans in this show look like SIMS. It’s funny because I think of the game when I was a teen and then see these Trek characters act in similar ways to the game at times.


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Jul 10 '24

General Discussion A lot of Season 2's episodes were "we need to do X, but first something came up"...

0 Upvotes

While watching the second season of the show I noticed a weird pattern - a lot of the episodes started off by wanting to do one task, but then getting interrupted for the whole episode:

  • Ep6 - we need to hijack the Infinity, but first let's chase our holograms

  • Ep7 - we need to take the Infinity through the Borg conduit, but first let's race!

  • Ep8 - we need to get to our destination, but first lets get Zero a new body

  • Ep 9&10 - Wesley wants to put us where we need to go, but first we need to escape the Loom

  • Ep 11 - we need to get the Protostar back home, but first we need to get some antimatter

  • Ep 12 - we need to get the Protostar back home, but first we need some deuterium

  • Ep13 - we need to get the Protostar back home, but first we need exotic matter, but first we need to deal with Tribbles

  • Ep14 - we need to meet with Janeway, but first alternative timeline shenanigans!

  • Ep15 - we need to get Protostar back home, but first we are being attacked

  • Ep20 - we need to send the Protostar back in time, but first we need to deal with the Loom

Like sure, some of them worked pretty fine since they aligned the big quest with the small problem of the episode, like fixing up the Protostar. While others would've worked better if the series didn't have a ticking clock and a big story to get to...


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Jul 22 '22

Prodigy is a Star Trek/LOTR crossover?

4 Upvotes

Just discovered Prodigy after finishing Strange New Worlds- it is charming & clever! I It was a delight to find LOTR baked into the plot. The first thing you notice is “Hey, the Diviner looks a lot like Gollum in the Peter Jackson movie.” Then you get to the scene where the kids hide from Drednok, a recreation of Frodo & friends avoiding the Nazgûl. The mine planet = Isengard, and of course there’s our final impression of the Diviner as the crew flies away. Wow.

Also Murf is a cutie. 🥰

Looking forward to more episodes!


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Jul 31 '24

Question One really major error from end of season 1

2 Upvotes

So I though Janeway made them Warrant Officers.

Warrant Officers have no place at the academy. They are actual officers, without commission, but with that level of authority. They should technically be sort of non-commissioned Ensigns without the need to go to the academy.

It's a rank. She gave them rank, and it should have bypassed the academy altogether.

They basically should have been going to whatever basic training the enlisted personnel go through, and then assigned to a ship as officers based on the Admirals say-so.


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Jul 21 '24

Character Discussion No gwyn and dal kiss season 2???

2 Upvotes

When i see every episode of the new season, i cant see or find the kiss, i mean, the creadores really forget that part or what???


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Nov 05 '22

Dauntless

1 Upvotes

It’s exceptionally weird to me and hard to believe Starfleet would build a close copy of a fake ship built by an alien to trick/kill the crew of voyager. Down to the details and colour scheme of the bridge layout.

Makes zero sense. Like sure make a ship that uses slipstream tech but this is just wrong and weird.


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Jul 21 '26

Message from the Mods Join us in r/StrangeNewWorlds for episode discussions of season four!

1 Upvotes

r/StrangeNewWorlds ...

... your home for discussion on the series as it begins season four on Thursday, July 23!

"In the upcoming fourth season, the crew of the U.S.S. Enterprise — led by Captain Christopher Pike — embarks on a series of thrilling and emotional adventures across the stars. As they journey to strange new worlds, they will battle inner demons and external threats, encounter colorful new characters, reunite with familiar faces and confront terrifying aliens. Through it all, they strive to embrace a bright, hopeful future."


If you like it here, join us in our network's other subs:

r/ClassicTrek (for discussion of TOS, TAS, TNG, DS9, VOY, ENT and the films)

r/trekacademy

r/StarTrekDiscovery

r/LowerDecks

r/StarTrekPicard


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Jul 08 '24

Character Discussion My thoughts on Season 2...

8 Upvotes

Before I get to the bad part of this review, I’ll say this first. I loved season two, it was Star Trek to its fullest. It reminds me how it used to be, the storytelling and the emotions to each story. I loved the characters, the new and the old. Thanks to them being aliens, using the they/them pronouns in the story was the right way to use them. 

However, the ending of the story, that’s where things went off to the wrong side of things. Making it so that Dal, who was becoming a strong male lead, became second best and let Gwyn become the strong lead, if you get what I’m getting at, making her the captain instead of Dal. (Sorry, I’m bad with words so they come out in ways that might not be right but is the best that I can do.) Don’t get me wrong, I love a decent strong female lead, but this shouldn’t be how season two should have ended for Dal.

I'm sorry, but with all the character development we saw with Dal, only to see him step aside to become Gwyn’s Number 1 instead of Captain. Saying that he made a mistake, that the captain chair was never his but Gwyn. I'm sorry, but to me that just leaves a bad taste in my mouth. 

Don’t get me wrong, whilst I might not like it, I can understand him taking the backseat to learn what he needs. 

For the third season, I for one, would like to see maybe a time skip or two where Dal learns what he needs to become a captain. That way if they don’t want to do a season four, we at least see Dal become a captain. 

I have heard that people say that Gwyn should be in command, or always has been. Maybe that is true, maybe it wasn’t, but you all forget one important thing, Gwyn was born to be in command. Her father knew that he might not make it and as such, he brought her up to be one leader, to finish off what he couldn’t. 

However, Dal wasn't. 

Dal had to learn on the job how to become a leader, making mistakes along the way like any leader who suddenly becomes one without warning. He becomes a real captain by trial by fire, instead of the standard way that people become captains. To take that away from him does him wrong. Yes he still has a lot to learn, and to a point stepping back to learn what he needs was the right move for him, but that doesn't mean he can't or shouldn't be a captain. I didn’t like it that the creators of this good show made him look like he isn’t right to be a captain.

I want him to be a captain. For the creators to change what he wants isn’t right in my books. I don’t know about the rest of you, but this is just wrong. Yes dreams change, but to do this, hell no… not after everything that he has been through to get to this point. It feels a bit Woke… making it that men should step aside for women to be the leader.

Before you downvote me for saying this, I really did enjoy the season, it's just that I didn’t like how they ended it. I just hope they have some good for Dal to make it up to what they did to him. And not put him in another role.


r/StarTrekProdigy • • May 11 '23

Just watched the first episode, it feels more like a Star Wars story to me.

0 Upvotes

r/StarTrekProdigy • • Aug 10 '24

Question Can someone do an AI job on the main characters to see what they would look like in real life?

0 Upvotes

We see Janeway, The Doctor and Chakotay as animated characters so I'm curious to see what the others would look like if they had been in a live action TV series.


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Nov 18 '22

My theory on Gwyn's origins

0 Upvotes

I believe that Asencia is actually past Gwyn. Remember that Gwyn, like her supposed father, is from the future. Look at the eyes on both Asencia and Gwyn, they look eerily similar, look at their hairstyles as well, similar, and also look at how close Asencia and the Diviner are getting while the Diviner is recuperating in sickbay on the Dauntless.

I'm theorizing is that Diviner somehow either kidnaps Asencia and subjects her to some heavy modifications, e.g. like how the Klingon Voq underwent extensive surgery to pose as the human Ash Tyler in DSC, or something happens that makes Asencia turn into Gwyn, maybe she gets injured and the Diviner saves her life by assimilating her? This would explain why Gwyn knows so much about Starfleet and the Federation as seen in the earlier episodes.


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Oct 17 '23

Why is the ship flying around giant effigies of the crew and Janeway in the opening credits?

0 Upvotes

It doesn't make sense to me.


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Nov 17 '21

I wanted to like this as a kids show or for nostalgia but does anyone else hate the “captain” I know he will probably have some lessons coming up but man I hate his character Atleast right now.

20 Upvotes

r/StarTrekProdigy • • Dec 05 '25

Question Sort of prodigy related

0 Upvotes

As necale hasn’t come out and said it yet but Ryan volk-weiss has been posting on his twitter interviews he’s done with Allen ruck the borg queen Alice Kraig Walter koening and also Peter weller who appeared in Star Trek into darkness and it appears a 2nd season of the center seat is coming which would be on the 60th anniversary of the original show and the 2nd season would focus on tng movies the kelvin movies and possibly the streaming shows so they could have interviews with people like Kate mulgrew the actor who played tachoi as well as Robert Picardo and Aldo more of the cast of prodigy and you can catch the center seat on you tube if you’re a trek fan it is a must watch


r/StarTrekProdigy • • Nov 05 '21

Two

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/StarTrekProdigy • • Sep 24 '22

When did we find out that Gwyn is non-binary?

Thumbnail
pride.com
4 Upvotes

r/StarTrekProdigy • • Nov 05 '22

Chakotay

1 Upvotes

Is it just me or does the Chakotay animation make him look way younger than he was in Voyager?