Hi guys, i've been a big star trek fan for all my life. Watched TNG, DS9, Enterprise, Voyager, TOS, and all the movies. I recently watched Picard and SNW for the first times, and finally Discovery fell into my lap as the last major series that I haven't seen.
I just finished season 2 (full disclosure, i have not seen later seasons yet) and I have to say, that finale was probably the worst episode of star trek that I have ever seen. I looked up reviews, other reddit posts, etc. to see what other people had to say about this finale, and I have to say, the criticism is not strong enough. I spent about an hour drafting this post out of pure contempt, but if anyone makes it to the end, i applaud your commitment.
I'm not going to critique acting, directing, cinematography, or visual effects. Disco actually has a lot of strong points with these aspects. I want to focus on what I think went wrong with the story, because I think it speaks to what we want as star trek fans, and because i really have nothing against any of the cast members or the production team (except the writers).
I don't like when writers feel the need to close every tiny plothole to make chronologies work. What ends up happening, which we saw in this episode, was that you spend way too much time focusing on the details that don't actually matter for this specific series. And you are still guaranteed to miss something, which they definitely did miss a lot of things. You end up focusing too much on getting two paintings to line up, instead of actually making sure each painting is meaningful. If you carve a marble sculpture too much, trying to address every imperfection, eventually you're left with nothing. Im not worried about how Discovery ties into the canon. Im more worried about whether or not Discovery is a series good enough to be a part of the canon.
I can't believe they spent so many episodes building up the mysterious figure of the red angel, who possessed technology beyond what the federation could even comprehend, just for that person to end up being a regular ol' person - coincidentally a starfleet officer on board the Discovery and also one of Spock's half siblings - in a time traveling suit, which for some reason is designed only for one person. I was fascinated to actually learn about a species that was way beyond the federation in tech. We've seen something similar before in the form of the Borg, but never in the context of a species that wasn't like belligerently destructive. I was interested to see what a benevolent superspecies would look like, and how humans (who arguably value freedom over safety) would deal with the idea that they were at another species' mercy, albeit one with good intentions. Would we side with the good people, even if they refused to give us a voice? That's a plotline i'd love to explore. They had a lot of potential to do just this with Control, but Control ended up being pretty incompetent, monolithic, and universally destructive, just like the borg. Leeland was also a pretty boring dude who we didn't spend enough time focusing on.
We also spent about 30 minutes with Michael travelling to the different signals, where we just see what already happened again for about 5 seconds, and then SHE DISAPPEARS. I wanted to punch the screen when this happened. How can you possibly go back in time to set current events in motion, and not show us what it was that they actually set in motion?? it's like the writers thought that as long as the red angel did a bar crawl of the signals, that's good enough. No! I'm not watching this show just to watch michael watch stuff! I wanted to get new information about those old sequences that I didn't know the first time I saw them, and I didn't get that. The main feeling i was left with was confusion.
And for the love of god, I can barely watch when they do this stupid thing where starfleet officers are dying by the second, and yet main characters don't mind having unnecessary, 5 minute long sentimental conversations, which are literally, in real time, costing lives. where is the sense of urgency?? It makes all these higher-ups look so incompetent, so out-of-touch with the deaths of their crew members. Think Janeway. Think Picard. Think Sisto. None of them were the type of person to sit around and let people die for the sake of a personal revelation. When you lock yourself into a huge space battle where crew members are fighting just to give you enough time to get something done, it's insulting to sit through long-winded apologies and goodbyes. And then in the end it only works because, like, spock had a hunch? Really?
This was an episode that focused on spectacle, on suspense, and on getting across the finish line. It's antithetical to what star trek is. People can watch star wars, or harry potter, or lord of the rings, if they are looking for a series with cool emotional moments that doesn't stress itself too much on the "how?" aspect (in other words, the science) or the "why?" aspect (the questions that the premise itself raises). Star trek lives in this grey area of conceivability, where the technology we see is believable, even if unachievable in practice. But this season just went completely off into the realm of fantasy, and it abandoned the idea that fans need to be relatively convinced of the tech. Then they made this lame, half-assed attempt to close plotholes, which to me just screams "we didn't feel like putting in the work to make a good episode, but we also don't want to be criticized for writing a bad one." I don't care that holographic communications suddenly stopped. I care that the USS Discovery just miraculously gets erased from the records, and the justification for that is thrown together in about 20 seconds.
I would rather have seen a series where the chronology doesn't perfectly hand off to the next series, but where the story itself is consistent or at least coherent. A good show rewards the audience for paying attention and for picking up on details. In this episode, i felt the more i paid attention, the more i was punished.
I have always loved star trek because it is in many ways an allegory for humanity. It expands us to the size of the entire universe, and we find pieces of ourselves everywhere we go. It's beautiful. But what it is not - is a michael bay, explosion-filled, teary-eyed show where as long as we feel slightly emotional, who cares if it makes sense? It's like all starfleet principles went out the window whenever a main character felt a lil sad. I can't help but feel like the writing in this finale was so unbelievably negligent. Star trek is great because it brings tears to people's eyes when we feel empathy towards something we barely recognize. But here, we're getting closer to the genre of fantasy drama, and further from science fiction. We spent about 5 minutes watching spock and michael say bye to each other, but we spent literally zero seconds unpacking this whole, you know, TIME WORMHOLE thing.
I'm sorry for the length. I'm just so frustrated because it seems like apparently we can only be entertained by laser beams and time travel, and apparently we're too stupid for the writers to feel like they need to make any kind of sense. I hope the next seasons do a better job than the end of this one, because i gotta say i am not terribly encouraged by what i just saw. I don't have anyting against anyone who enjoys this show, i just think that paramount can do a lot better than this.