r/StarKid • • Apr 08 '25

Cinderella's Castle... (jeff rant)

57 Upvotes

PLEASE google what parasocial means before commenting and stop incorrectly quoting my words

Okay.. for reference, im a BIG starkid fan- I think theyre funny and Jeff's musical writing is amazing.

and, im not parasocial, these are real people and i dont know them ... but

recently ive been watching more of the non-musical events (where the cast interacts with each other) and jeff gives me MAJOR bad vibes.. like he SEEMS very self-centered, and its clear based on how many songs and solo moments he gets ESPECIALLY compared to many other incredible actors and singers - his reaction video with jon makes him seem so salty and arrogant edit due to confusion (this is not a comment on his relationship with jon, just specifying which video)

even just the way the description labels the actresses and actors.. "AND jeff blim" when cinderella is the star?? it should be "and bryce charles" also, starring often goes regarding to first appearance and jeff is first??

my main problem is his "falsetto" singing voice:
he looks great in cinderellas castle, the costuming, sets, and makeup are great!! but the first song on an initial listen sounds SO BAD to me. i think his voice sounds terrible in falsetto. hes musically talented, so the notes arent wrong but ...

it originally took me a while to really appreciate his falsetto and i did like it, but NPMD was SO GOOD and it didnt have his falsetto at all - (its also my personal opinion that if it werent for scheduling issues, he would have played max (im glad he didnt i think will is FANTASTIC and him and jon shine so well))

NPMD ruined any love i had for his voice, because the absence of it (i think) made the songs better (even though theyre his songs and theyre great)- my fav songs from every musical are not sung by him (i am also a picky bitch, i like angela, shes an amazing actress, but i didnt like her songs in Black Friday (she was great in NPMD, my sister and i sing her final song frequently, her tone is beautiful))

i know a lot of people have mixed opinions on him, i like his acting and voices when speaking or singing more in his chest voice, but i just cant stand his falsetto and i dont think i can like his songs until i listen to them 20 times, while much of the cast sounds amazing on an initial listen

my biggest gripe is how frequently his falsetto is used -he dominates the songs and is mixed in cast recordings to be even LOUDER, he just seems so self centered, like just because he writes the songs, he feels the need to be the star in everything

regardless of who writes the music, songs should be more evenly dispersed (and they are, besides for jeff)

i havent even finished cinderella's castle yet, but none of my friends really care for starkid, so id like to hear if any of yall agree with me - NPMD started INCREDIBLY and this one started so badly i didnt want to watch it (but everyone is so funny and bryce's voice is amazing!!)

Im still a huge starkid fan and i love everyone, i just wish jeff's ego wasn't as glaring

edit: wow yall are quick lol (thanks for the correction regarding Will in NPMD)

(sorry about referring to all of his higher singing as falsetto, but it does seem to be mixed, and i prefer how singers sound in their full chest voice)

yes, many of his characters are purposefully "bad people" and i think those characters are funny (and they obviously dont reflect who he is as a person)

i was not trying to "attack" him, especially for his morals: his voice dominates songs. in moments where the cast is supposed to be harmonious, it doesn't come across that way.

i dont think jeff is a bad person and i dont think that the characteristics that i mentioned make him a bad person (i #never said that, but feel free to fight the scarecrow lol)

(and having an opinion on a public figure is not parasocial, if it were, positive views are parasocial, too lol) jeff is a good writer and has acknowledged criticism in the past and he writes great parts for other people, too ("seems" does not mean "is") im not saying that he has some moral failing, just that i recognize patterns and (purposeful or not) his dominance in songs seems self-centered to me, i just wish it happened less

its also fine for him to HAVE an ego regarding good songs that he wrote?? idk why yall hate that word so much (along with "bad vibe" like its a very common phrase) ego just refers to ones own feelings of self-esteem

thank you to the few who actually addressed the point of my post šŸ™

and thanks for the discussion, including yall who disagreed with me (and i’m sorry that my main point was not clear, i use casual language for casual criticism- i’m #pro jeff overall)


r/StarKid • • Sep 12 '24

Any Starkid members who spoke out on the Gaza genocide?

0 Upvotes

Starkid being generally progressive and speaking out during the BLM protests, I expected some of them to speak out once again during the Gaza genocide. I see none, and I really hope none of them are actually zionists, it would be really devastating to learn my favorite artists support a genocide.


r/StarKid • • Aug 16 '24

I asked this AI some StarKid questions

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

(Cropped out, but in the first one i asked it to say the cast for twisted)


r/StarKid • • Jul 20 '24

Nightmare Time How do I watch NTM1 if Robert is in it? NSFW

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone, this is my first time posting here.

I really enjoyed TGWDLM and BF but I was confused about why Robert was not in the next few projects like NPMD and ended up looking up what happened and why he was fired from Starkid. I completely understood why he wasn't in NTM2 because of that as well (I watched Nightmare time 2 first since I was struggling to watch NTM 1 initially because of the format and accessibility issues like subtitles and stuff) but now that I've finished NTM2, I really want to watch NTM1 as well and I'm really into the stories.

My issue is, I'm struggling to get through NTM1 currently because Robert is generally on the screen and his presence makes me deeply uncomfortable knowing everything he's done. I'm trying to have nuance and I'm completely sold on all the recastings that came in later so going back to watching him as Hidgens or Ethan is literally making my skin crawl. It also felt like a massive betrayal knowing what the actor did because I'd enjoyed his portrayal of the characters immensely before having knowledge of this, and now I can't fathom the idea of him existing in the series at all especially because everyone else in Starkid is so wonderful and I generally view their stuff as trigger-free and wholesome.

So my question here is, how do y'all enjoy the previous musicals and content despite him being there and knowing what an awful person he is? How do you separate the characters he's played with the actor himself when you know other people can play them just as well (if not better)? And how do I watch Nightmare time 1 with the same feeling of joy that I was watching NTM2 with?

Sorry if my question sounds silly or like I don't have any critical thinking skills. I prefer to avoid things that might be potentially triggering to me, and while NTM1 isn't triggering on its own, I question how I should be dealing with or perceiving the presence of someone who's done triggering things in the past.


r/StarKid • • Jan 05 '26

TGWDLM Would you watch a TGWDLM reanimated if it looked like this?

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

It would be more polished than this with thinner lines but I wanted to give a taste of what I’m able to do


r/StarKid • • May 17 '25

My conspiracy thought- they’re doing the remount to replace Robert as the definitive Hidgens

0 Upvotes

THIS IS PROBABLY NOT CORRECT. This is just a nagging feeling I keep thinking about


r/StarKid • • Mar 26 '22

Twisted At the musical off Alladin

0 Upvotes

Jafar: Golden Rule My brain staring to sing: Follow the golden rule cause life is a 2 way street

The prins walked by, My brain be like NO ONE REMEMBERS ACHMED


r/StarKid • • Aug 19 '22

A mods view and a nice plea to you all

1 Upvotes

All Toxic robert stans can comment under here but don't tell me to go touch grass or any other unfunny bs you like to write

I do not condone Roberts actions and do not approve of any bullying and being an assh*le to people trying to show why he should not be in npmd. Read the petition pinned to the subs top and watch the tik tok that collected all the evidence. We should be taking care of our queer and younger community! Not throw them apart in this! I will block anyone trying to hurt the people (me included) who made this petition. Be it threats or bullying. Starkid is important to us and if it is too you look at the petition.


r/StarKid • • Apr 06 '26

TGWDLM So um Where is The Proshot?

5 Upvotes

Are they waiting until after London? Lol


r/StarKid • • Mar 31 '26

Hatchetfield Roleplay server (for Hatchetfield)

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

HIIIII! So my friend started this roleplay server, and genuinely it’s REALLY FUN! That being said, we only have 16 people in it, and I (Ruth) need more people to flirt with (no but actually just it’s way more fun with more people, we’re really fun, and VERY inappropriate!) please be above 14, and tbh, the owner doesn’t know I’m advertising this, but yeah. I included some of my favorite out of context screenshots at the end for funsies.


r/StarKid • • Apr 13 '24

Cinderella's Castle anyone else disappointed by the cinderella demos..?

0 Upvotes

i'm not sure if this is just the cycle demos go through, and i understand it'll get better when it's more fleshed out, but the lyrics and music felt so bland and poorly timed it's really making me lose interest in the show. am i being a starkid snob or is anyone else feeling this too? no hate, love what starkid does; this just doesn't feel up to par.


r/StarKid • • Dec 28 '25

Other So this is how the list for the characters as animals is going, how do we feel?

Post image
8 Upvotes

I can answer any questions


r/StarKid • • Oct 24 '23

Opinion of Jeff’s Music?

0 Upvotes

Ok so I’ve been thinking about his music in NPMD and have two major issues with his music.

Now don’t get me wrong, most of his music is great. But there are just some things that bother me.

  1. Everything (especially for the guys) is so high. This is very seen in ā€œGo, Go Nighthawks!ā€ Every Guy (besides Corey) is singing crazy high notes. Not to mention the multiple C5’s in the title song. I just wonder when he’ll make songs for baritones/basses. To be fair, Angela did get ā€œBlack Fridayā€ which was a nice alto song.

  2. Some of his lyrics are just….. terrible. Most of the time he just curses for no reason. ā€œFuck you clivesdale, go get fucked, you’re fucking losers, and we’ll kill youā€ā€¦. It’s sort of funny but…. Why? And also (one of my favs to laugh about) ā€œCan I shit or will I drown?ā€

What do you think about Jeff’s Music?


r/StarKid • • Feb 10 '24

Black Friday Question about Gary Goldstein character

0 Upvotes

I was hoping there was some additional context for the character I was maybe missing? Bc it came off as antisemitic to me, which kinda sucks :/

pls no hate, I’m already nervous just asking y’all. I’m only describing my own experience while watching Black Friday. I love the Hatchetfield trilogy but this made me feel uneasy (I’m jewish)

Edit/Update: thanks everyone! It’s validating to know I’m not the only one who clocked it, regardless of folks’ opinion of the character. I never suspected any malice from Starkid, tho we all can agree on the difference between intent and impact ;)

Edit/Update 2: following a comment here making reference to an apology/acknowledgement from Nick Lang, this post was helpful (I don’t use Twitter) 620254349505036288/im-glad-that-nick-is-this-supportive-and](https://www.tumblr.com/joeycupcakerichter/620254349505036288/im-glad-that-nick-is-this-supportive-and)


r/StarKid • • Oct 01 '26

Chain Posts Remove a Starkid Song Every Day, Day 149! Last time you guys removed Kick It Up A Notch (Reprise).

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StarKid • • Oct 18 '23

Why has Starkid started time-locking their content?

3 Upvotes

Good professional theater can be really hard to come by. If you don't live in or near a handful of major theater hubs like New York or Chicago you are typically limited to hoping a touring show has a stop near you (with affordable tickets), taking a gamble with your local community theater productions, or watching proshots. Proshots are easily the most accessible for people to enjoy but because of their cost and the fear that a proshot will devalue the live show, even the biggest and most lucrative shows on broadway usually don't get one.

Which is why it's been so awesome that for years Starkid has been paving the way in accessible theater content. Their shows posted online and typically for free are for many people the only theater they have access to and it has obviously created a dedicated fan base that love to financially support the group whenever they can. That is, until the last few years.

Now, I fully understand locking some content behind a paywall. These shows are expensive to make and there's a lot of really talented people involved that need to make a living. However, I don't know why some content is artificially time-locked. Why are there shows and projects I can't paid to watch year-round? It makes even less sense with projects set in the Hatchetfield universe. One of the big selling points of any project set in Hatchetfield is the interconnectivity of it all. Why are their corners of the universe and potentially important pieces of lore locked away from me, potentially forever, unless I make sure I catch a multi-hour livestream while it's airing live or backed a kickstarter from four years ago?

I am aware that things like Working Boys is currently available to rent, but from what I understand it was originally only going to be available to kickstarter backers and I believe I've read that it's only going to be able to rent for a limited time. Meanwhile to my knowledge VHS Christmas Carols has only ever been offered through live and digital tickets with no digital download option.

I just genuinely don't understand these decisions. Why not allow people to support the you year round? Why the artificial scarcity?


EDIT: I want to clarify a few things:

1) I am aware you can currently rent Working Boys on their website. However, as far as I understand that is only available for the next few weeks. After that it will only be available to Kickstarter Backers. This is what I've been told by others in this subreddit.

2) I am fully willing to pay for it. Everyone involved in these project worked really hard and deserves to get paid.

3) Working Boys is not the only example of this, or at least wasn't when I wrote this.

Last year's Jangle Ball Tour had digital tickets that you can no longer rent. After posting this I did a bit of digging and found a comment on a reddit post from last year from Corey where he did say they were working on a polished Digital Version to release this year, but it took a bit of digging to find.

Also, when I wrote this, Tin Can Bros' "How the Grunch Cribbed Christmas" was unavailable to buy or rent anywhere. The same day I posted this they announced they're releasing it on Youtube in November and Digital Download pre-sales begin next week.

I love Starkids and Tin Can Bros and want to support their content. A major reason I wrote this is because I was worried I wouldn't be able to. Since then I've found other projects of there's that I didn't realize had been re-released or posted on their site to purchase, like "VHS Christmas Carol" and "The Solve It Squad: Back in the Biz". Some of this is on me (I didn't realize VHS Christmas Carol actually got a YouTube release) but I also think some of their stuff could be a bit clearer on how to support them. For example, some of their shows are available to purchase on their store page, but Working Boys is for sale in the tickets section on their main site as part of the Halloween livestream.


r/StarKid • • Apr 12 '25

Nerdy Prudes Must Die I think Richie would own a cumjar. I am not apologizing for this one NSFW

Post image
0 Upvotes

(That's a lie I'm sorry who gave me free will?)


r/StarKid • • Oct 25 '23

Will I get banned

1 Upvotes

Will I get banned if I make a teir list of songs that include r0b£r+?


r/StarKid • • Jul 08 '24

AMA PAUL PERKINS (23)

0 Upvotes

Hello I am Paul Perkins, formerly Paul Matthews, I am happily married to Emma Matthews and work at CCRP which I love and definitely have no grudges against.. AMA? I don't know how this works


r/StarKid • • Jun 20 '26

Two Point Studios's New Animation Has A Suspiciously Similar Delivery Of A Joke From NPMD...

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

Obligatory disclaimer: I'm not saying they stole the joke from Starkid (even if they did that's fine imo lol, no one owns jokes) but it's pretty funny how similar the delivery is to Curt's in NPMD.


r/StarKid • • Oct 25 '23

What's going on with Hidgens's original actor?

0 Upvotes

hey so I noticed a lot of people aren't saying...well the name of Henry Hidgens's original actor (I'm not saying his name since idk what he did and I don't want people to yell at me) and...I'm just confused I know this would probably fit more on r/OutOfTheLoop but well it's also Starkid related hence why I'm posting it here...if I could have some context that would be appreciated...sorry if I'm being a bother btw


r/StarKid • • Dec 23 '23

My personal ranking of Starkid Shows (controversial opinion)

5 Upvotes

So to first say yes I know this is controversail opinion wise but my last place I just didn't like them. I just could never get into them and the fact that they kept making more made it worse imo, despite staring incredibly talented people.

Anyways here is my ranking.

  1. Starship/Twisted (couldn't pick)

  2. A VHS Christmas Carol/VHSCCS

  3. Holy Musical B@man!

  4. AVPM

  5. AVPS

  6. Ani: A Parody

  7. Firebringer

  8. Trail to Oregon!

  9. AVPSY

  10. Me and My Dick

  11. All Hatchetfield Musicals/Shows

I'd like to see what everyone else's rankings are. I've seen a few online and you can see who is usually the newer Starkid fans because most of them, even though they took the time to watch them all, would rank all the Hatchetfields at the top which I just can't comprehend. But that is just me.


r/StarKid • • Oct 14 '23

Hatchetfield Can we please stop doing TGWDLM fanservice? [Minor BF and NPMD Spoilers] Spoiler

5 Upvotes

Edit: I should preface this by saying I think I enjoyed Nerdy Prudes Must Die more than I enjoyed TGWDLM. Which is saying a lot, because I've seen TGWDLM what must be 30 times. The first act is hilarious and I really love how they allow the story to grow naturally into itself. It's captivating, and it just keeps ramping up and up and up and up until around when Ruth dies.

When Black Friday came out, it really bothered me how many gags they ripped from TGWDLM. It really robbed the show of its own identity for me and made me roll my eyes every time. I came to see the new characters! If I wanted to watch TGWDLM, I'd watch TGWDLM!

NPMD was a lot better about this for the most part, and most of its references were subtle enough to not bother me, but there's still a scene where we get our usual Paul and Emma banter that doesn't really do anything for the story other than give you a reason to go "Look! There they are! The characters I like from the show I like!" The scene could've worked just fine if it was just Emma alone working the coffee shop instead of trying to shoehorn in a Paul cameo. All it really did was halt the plot for a few minutes.

I still really loved NPMD overall. Despite its flaws, I think it's highs were even higher than even TGWDLM. Which is why it just drives me crazy how much they keep flaunting the connection to TGWDLM around like they aren't confident enough in the show's own cast to captivate the audience on its own. I love the new characters! I came to see them!

Anyway, that's really all, I'm curious if anyone else is annoyed by the callbacks.


r/StarKid • • Apr 24 '25

Ranking StarKid Musicals as I watch them for the first time, Part 2: TGWDLM and Cinderella's Castle

11 Upvotes

As a new StarKid fan, I'm working my way through all their musicals and sharing my thoughts on Reddit so I can pretend my opinion is important. šŸ˜„ Part 1 was here for anyone curious.

I got several suggestions to watch TGWDLM next and of course Cinderella's Castle just came out, so I had to watch that as well.

Cinderella's Castle

A really good musical. I saw a lot of mixed reception on this sub, so I went in with low expectations. Maybe that helped because CC blew my those low expectations out of the water! I really liked Cursed Crazy. There was some top notch choreography going on there. "I Look Good In This" was really good too. As someone who really likes villain songs, this one was top tier. I've bought their soundtrack on Shopify and I'll listen to it a bit more to see if any more earworms develop.

The secondary characters were all awesome. Sir Hops-A-Lot and Crumb were charming and cute, and deserved a song. I thought the Prince was a funny comic relief character, and was a great way to take the Prince. Oh, and Rancilda's dream of living under a bridge and throwing out riddles was a great gag.

Going back to the Prince for a second, a common way to take on the problematic "prince saves the girl" storyline is to invert it so the girl actually saves the Prince. Or to turn the Prince into a villain the girl has to defeat. Making him a douchey buffon that's not really a villain but just kind of a bad person you don't have any sympathy for is honestly really smart.

The set was beautiful. Top notch production values, just ::chef's kiss:: good.

But while I liked almost all the secondary characters, Cinderella herself is my only real problem. Her treatment of Thadeus really made me dislike her for a bit there. If she'd maybe reeled that in or apologized to him when she realized he wasn't like the Prince, it could have worked better. But man, that was just mean. It also felt kind of out of character, so I just sort of pushed it out of my head.

I also wouldn't have minded if she'd have planned that the slipper magic would bring her back to life. Like, maybe somehow she arranged that final scene where she returns victorious. As it was, it felt very deus-ex-machina. But honestly, not a huge complaint. Bryce Charles's singing was so good, it's easy to overlook those flaws.

The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals

I knew going in it's a fan-favorite so I was ready to really enjoy this one.

It started out strong. La Dee Da Da Day is a straight up banger, one of the best songs in any StarKid musical. The coffee shop song was awesome too, and watching Lauren Lopez's face as she did the dance number was hilarious. But, I kind of rolled my eyes at Professor Hidgens. He's both a biology professor and a disaster prepper. That seemed just a little too convenient. They lampshaded it a bit with the whole "You predicted this would happen?" question, but then... neither of those traits really mattered? Anyone could have guessed the alien's gimmick so he didn't need to be a professor. And he immediately betrayed his other big personality trait letting the monsters in. It really didn't make any sense to me (although Working Boys is the third best song).

And, OK, I know this is my hangup, and they couldn't have predicted the way the world would be in 2025 when I'm watching this musical, but having the army guy say "America is Great Again" after he was assimilated is an obvious Trump reference.

I do not care for Trump. I don't know StarKid's political leanings, but I really liked the message behind Twisted, of being kind to others and using government to help the people, not enrich yourself. Trump is diametrically opposed to that message. TGWDLM isn't very political at all, so I felt some whiplash when they basically linked the badguys to MAGA in the musical. I just didn't feel like thinking about Trump while trying to enjoy some media. But that could have still been fine... if the badguy's hadn't won

I wouldn't have liked the downer ending anyway, granted. I was expecting Paul's hatred of musicals to pay off making him able to resist them, or maybe it would look like they got to him, and he'd do a musical number, but then it would be revealed he still hates musicals and fought them off and he was just pretending to be assimilated. I didn't expect him to lose, and it to feel like MAGA won. I feel like I already see that happening all the time in the real world, I don't need to be reminded of it in a musical.

It has some great songs. The concept is clever and I recognize how someone else could like it. But it's just not for me.

OK, so with all that said, here's my new rankings:

A Tier

  1. Twisted - A Masterpiece

  2. VHSCC - Also a masterpiece! Really only in #2 because it's so short, and because Twisted contains a more original plot. (I haven't seen the longer one yet!)

B Tier

  1. Firebringer - It's got problems, but has one of my favorite songs and the spoken portions have some great running bits. This one is really hanging around in my head rent-free and may have to get moved to A-tier.

  2. Cinderella's Castle - A few minor problems preventing it from going to A tier, but overall an amazing production. More than any other StarKid musical, I wish I'd seen it live.

  3. Trail to Oregon - Hilarious, but no earworms.

D Tier

  1. The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals - I get how other people would love this musical, but it wasn't for me.

EDIT: Yeah, that's right, TGWDLM is at the bottom! Bring on the downvotes! I can't go lower than zero! 🤣