r/StanleyKubrick • u/TakeOffYourMask • Sep 30 '23
Eyes Wide Shut For the last time, Kubrick was NOT sending secret messages about rich and powerful people in Eyes Wide Shut, and I can prove it
EWS was based on a novella called "Dream Novel" written (and set in) Vienna in the early 1900s. It was a favorite of Kubrick's from his young adult years, back when he wasn't plugged in to high society at all.
EWS essentially follows the whole plot of "Dream Novel" except in a few key details that don't matter for this post. Apart from the character of Ziegler and the early part of the movie involving Ziegler's Christmas party there isn't much in EWS that isn't already in "Dream Novel".
The secret society, the masked ball, the fuckin' and suckin', the dead patient with the horny daughter, the costume shop owner pimping out his daughter, the hooker he nearly sleeps with, the scene in the morgue, etc. EWS's biggest changes, other than the character of Ziegler, are all the stuff associated with modernizing the story.
Urban legends have since arisen that Kubrick made the movie to expose the evil secret pedophile cabal that rules the world. There are specific claims that he:
Made the movie to expose human and/or child trafficking
Included even worse material that would threaten the global sex cabal even worse that was cut from the film.
Was killed to maintain his silence or in retribution
He made the movie to say something about actual rich and powerful people that he knew.
These claims are ridiculous because:
EWS isn't really about "trafficking" at all. Not one person in the movie is actually being "trafficked" for sure. It is hinted both in the movie and in the book that the costume shop daughter is present at the masked ball, but that's the closest thing we get to actual trafficking. There are plenty of elite prostitutes working for the rich and powerful secret society in the movie, and presumably these women were procured somehow, but that's not really the classical meaning of "human trafficking". And there is no pedophilia in the movie or in the original book. The costume shop owner's daughter is a teenager, not a prepubescent kid. That doesn't make it right, it just makes it categorically distinct from pedophilia (which is clinically defined as a sexual attraction to prepubescent kids). All this to say that you can't impose a 21st century moral panic onto a 20th century book and movie.
There is absolutely no evidence of this. You can disregard anything that Vivian Kubrick has said. She's mentally unwell, estranged from her family, and has joined Scientology. This is a great tragedy for her family, so do not exploit her illness and delusions for salacious purposes. Regarding cut scenes, all movies have cut scenes. I'm aware of a scene involving Cruise and Kidman in a rowboat with Madison Eginton that was cut. The masked ball went through many revisions as Kubrick often develops scenes during filming. IIRC Kidman mentioned that she did some stronger shots than what you see in the final movie (presumably from the fantasy scene with that navy guy or from her orgy dream for which concept art was created but never used). But nothing to do with footage more damaging to the IRL cabal that Kubrick allegedly had in mind.
He was 70. It's true both his parents lived until they were about 82, but the guy died in bed next to his wife after an epically long and probably very stressful shoot. He didn't drink a poisoned cocktail in Monaco or get garrotted by ninja. There is absolutely no evidence that his death wasn't exactly what it seemed.
Again, to be as clear as I can, everything (consequential for this post) that happens in EWS also happened in the novella written over a hundred years ago, and that Kubrick had been a fan of since long before he was rubbing shoulders with rich and powerful people. Kubrick was a street kid from the Bronx. If he had a beef, he'd say so. Not leave hidden messages for basement dwellers.

