I'm updating my text only Android app with thousands of watercolor-style images. I almost went with Gemini 3.1 Flash Image because the quality is great and the API is dead simple.
Then I ran the numbers.
At the volume I needed, the API costs would've landed somewhere around $3,000 USD. For a solo dev that's not a line item, that's a funeral.
So I gave Krea 2 a shot instead, rented a cheap GPU online, and just let it rip.
The result: thousands of watercolor images generated, consistent style across the whole set, and my total spend was a rounding error compared to the API route. Same GPU rental is still running batches while I write this.
WHAT DO I SAY!!!! Long live Krea 2.
Here are a few random ones from the batches so far š
Just because you're some dumb zoomer dumb enough that to you nothing but the latest thing exists,Ā
Gets upvoted, I get downvoted. Alright, I'm done here. If what you get here is insults for making a suggestion, then this place can go to hell for all I care.
I see so many people come here with technical issues and it often turns out they're following old guides that tell them to install 1111. Back in the day, I used it and it was a great tool but it hasn't been updated for over six months and it doesn't look like it will be.
A sticky post telling people about this and redirecting them to alternatives like Forge and Comfy would be extremely helpful imho.
Edit: for all of you saying "no, it's not dead", fine, you tell me how to run Flux on it. Listen, I don't hate it but something that can't run a model that was released seven months ago is de facto dead. People new to this place shouldn't be led to use a tool that's not being updated.
They charge you for waiting while pod starting. My current pod: 40 minutes of waiting - still not started. But account money go down.. It is pure scam tactics. It is not only one random pod, tried multiple pods - similar behavior, extremely slow start and Web UI hangs as hell. Now it resembles Google Collab, same horrible experience.
So to begin with, I've been creating AI art since the advent of dall-e 2 (slightly before Stable Diffusion) and I've come upon an interesting set of shifts in how I approach the medium based on my underlying assumptions about what art is about. I might write a longer post later once I've thought through the implications of each level of development, and I don't know if I've enough data to say for sure I've stumbled on a universal pattern for users of the medium, but this is, at least, an analysis of my personal journey as an AI artist.
Once I looked back on the kinds of AI images I felt inclined to generate, I've noticed there were certain breakthroughs in how I thought about AI art and my over-all relationship to art as a whole.
Level 1: Generating whatever you found pretty
This is where most people start, I think, where AI art starts as exactly analogous to making any other art (i.e. drawing, painting, etc) so naturally you just generate whatever you find immediately aesthetically pleasing. At this level, there's an awe for the technical excellence of these algorithms and you find yourself just spamming the prettiest things you can think of. Technical excellence is equated to good art, especially if you haven't developed your artistic sense through other mediums. I'd say the majority of the "button pusher slop makers" are at this level
Level 2: Generating whatever you find interesting
After a while, something interesting happens. Since the algorithm handles all the execution for you, you come to realize you're not having much of a hand in the process. If you strip it down to what you ARE in charge of, you may start thinking, "Well, surely the prompt is in my control, so maybe that's where the artistry is?" And so the term like "prompt engineering" comes into play where since the idea of technical excellence = good art, and since you need to demonstrate some level of technical excellence to be considered a good artist, surely there's skill in crafting a good prompt? There's still tendency to think that good art comes from technical excellence, however, there's a growing awareness that the idea matters too. So you start to venture away from what immediately comes to mind and start coming up with more interesting things. Since you can create ANYTHING, you may as well make good use of that freedom. Here is where you find those who can generate stuff that are actually worth looking at.
Level 3: Pushing the Boundaries
Level 2 is where you start getting more creative, but something is still amiss. Maybe the concepts you generate seem rehashed, or maybe you're starting to get the feeling it isn't really "art" until you push the boundaries of the human imagination. At this point, you might start to realize that the technicalities of the prompt don't matter, nor the technical excellence of the piece, but rather, the ideas and concepts behind them. At this point, the concept behind the prompt is the one thing you realize you ought to be in full control of. And since the idea is the most important part of the process, here's where you start to realize that to do art is to express something of value. Technical excellence is no longer equated to what makes art good, but rather, the ideas that went into it
Level 4: Making Meaning
If you've gotten to level 3, you've come to grips with the medium. It might start dawning on you that most art, no matter conventional or AI, is exceedingly boring due to this obsession with technical excellence. But something is still not quite right. Sure, the ideas may be interesting enough to evoke a response in the perceiver, but it still doesn't answer why you should even be doing art at all. There's a disconnect between the foundation of art philosophers preach about, with it being about "expression" and connecting to a "transcedental" nature and what you're actually doing. Then maybe, just maybe, by chance you happen to be going through some trouble and use the medium to express that, or may feel inspired to create something you actually give a damn about. And once you do, a most peculiar insight may come to you; that the best ideas are the meaningful ones. The ones that actually move you and come from your personal experience rather than coming from some external source. This is because, if you've ever experienced this (I sure did), when you create something of actual meaning and substance rather than just what's "pretty" or what's "interesting" or what's "weird", you actually resonate with your own work and gain not just empty entertainment, but a sense of fulfillment from your own work. And then you start to understand what separates a drawing, an image, a painting, a photograph, whatever it is, from true art. Colloquially some call this "fine art" but I think it's far more accessible than that. It can, but doesn't need to make some grand statement about existence or society, nor does it need to be complicated, it just needs to resonate with your soul.
There may be "levels of development" beyond these ones I listed. And maybe you disagree with me that this is a universal experience. I'm also not saying once you're at a certain "level" you only do that category of images, just that it might become your "primary" activity.
All I can do, in the end, is be authentic about my own experience and hope that it resonates with yours.
LTX is literally the worst company in open weights models! They use ton of blatant bots to manipulate comments. And even after 2 months after the model release they still appear. It's very dirty, very disrespectful to the community
They also manipulate upvotes/downvotes. On my comment that I'm tired of LTX there were +6 votes. But after they appear, the post magically went down to -4 votes. That's crazy. The dirtiest company that exists
They are actual bots, if you open their profile, they are glazing different kind of products all around all the time
We are getting a LOT of these posts lately and they feel very low-effort. Yes some people probably want to legitimately learn but these posts don't feel like that. It's almost always not even something that someone was actually attempting to do but was just missing a part of the process. It's more a "can you do my homework" low effort type of post.
TLDR: Artists arenāt so much against AI. Itās that artists *can't* commercialise the output. At least, not ethically.
I use AI every day in making art. AI upscaling, content-aware fill, Neural Filters etc. A couple years ago I started an AI project with Artbreeder that has sold over a thousand prints.
I see this sub constantly misrepresent, denigrate and downvote artists. I suspect most artists have left as things have become toxic.
I work in the film industry, everyone I know has played around with AI art generators. Midjourney, StableDiffusion, DALL-E. You name it. We canāt use them commercially because, unlike previous databases, like FFHQ used in creating StyleGAN2 (Artbreeder is the interface I use for StyleGAN2), the images were sourced in a non-permissive way.
Nobody was mad at Artbreeder. NVIDIA did things right.
Artists are not much scared of AI. When I broke my wrist a few months ago, I was probably in the top 1% users in diffusion-based generators. I stopped using MJ, SD, D-E when I saw what was in the datasets. I couldn't commercialise my output and wasted about a month of my time and $400 in generations.
All artists I know have tested and found derivative / over-fit outputs. This is the scary part if any. We have no way of knowing what was sourced for the output. Because artists generally respect one another: we listen when other artists say āI donāt want to be in the databaseā. Equivocation on this sub and elsewhere around the AI just ālooking atā the art like someone walking through an art gallery is not a good answer. Weāve tested it enough to see over-fitting examples.
I donāt think any artist is going to be mad that someone is privately using open-sourced versions of SD to cook up images based on their imaginations āespecially if āby Artist Nameā isnāt in the input.
A professional artist is someone who makes money off what they do. Professional artists canāt make money with things like MJ, SD, and D-E... yet they see those generators dragging their heels on opt-out requests and making money in the process. That is annoying to say the least.
Iāve been seeing anti-AI comments on posts lately. I just realized there are actually no rules here against anti-AI comments or posts, which feels contradictory since this community is specifically about OPEN-SOURCE AI art and creation.
People are coming onto posts here just to comment that "AI isn't art" or even calling it an "addiction." I've attached a screenshot as an example, and it just shows how many comments like this Iāve been seeing under our posts.
(Disclaimer: Please do not harass or hate the person in the screenshot, even if you find out who they are. This is about the broader issue, not a specific person.)
Edit: There are legitimate concerns regarding closed-source AI and its impact on our environment, but open-source AI gives a positive outlook for its creativity in its use.
Edit 2: I think people are misunderstanding the point. The goal isn't to shut down AI debates or hate towards those who are against it; it's just about respecting the designated topic of this subreddit. Just like posting AI art in r/antiai wouldn't make sense, this simply isn't the right subreddit for that discussion.
Today I did a lot of studying (you know, it's Christmas haha). First, if you are reading this in your bedroom I want you to look around at everything that surround you. Looks familiar - your computer, its LEDs lighting, your funko pops etc. BRANDED STUFF you are proud to display. A LOT of it. I counted over 200 objects in my room alone. And i'm not rich. I generated 10 pictures (using a cloud instance to run the best models), upscaled with 3rd party tools, recolored and relit, and showed the results to friends to see what they thought. They know nothing about AI so it's helpful as an objective reference.
Futuristic / cyberpunk stuff (90% of what we see in civitai) is cheating. The human brain accepts the toaster is round and the helmet has 30 antennae's because they can tell it's 'fantasy' - it's like watching a movie so you leave your suspension of disbelief at the door.
This brings us to 'today's age' scene. In scenes taking place indoors, it's a huge problem -100% failure rate with my friends. Not because the human looked fake mind you, but people know a fridge is usually branded X, a tv has a little logo on the frame, and in startup offices, 'the coffee machine' is actually a nespresso dispenser. That kind of thing. They KNOW this without thinking it.
Clothing. Did you notice that all the AI stuff regardless of model has ZERO crease? Everyone owns an iron in the world of AI XD. Go and open instagram - bar the 'models', every day pictures will show flaws in the texture, the harsh light will bring these crease in view - this true even for pro shots -i analyzed hundreds of images and they all have creases. Ai stuff doesn't. I even did some img2img trials to remove just the creases - it works -everytime.
Object that are fit for function. This sub is filled with girls wearing jackets with 3 zippers, shoes that look like converse and have Jordans designs or Nike logos, or shirts that buttons completely misaligned - that shirt would never close, never mind be sold. The objects don't exist on our plane of existence. We KNOW brands*.* We are fed advertising 24/7. We know what a bmw series 3 looks like, even if we didn't even know it was called a series 3, because they are ubiquitous.
Camera angles. I dare you to make a picture where the main character is standing up, full body, and bringing their foot forward towards the camera. Even with control net i couldn't. They do it sited, but never standing up. Because i have this feeling they weren't trained on portrait mostly. ANd for the adversing people here, forget about designer shoes, they all look like lego blocks. Again, her I imagine the models were trained on human portraits, not instagram or TikTok stills that have these very aggressive, low angled camera phones where people show 'the drip' as they call it.
So i started to think how do i fix this? Two solutions
We cheat, and place the subject outdoors. No objects, no way to even reference where it was taken, bang, human brain tricked. BUt films happen anywhere. Tiktoks is 90% bedroom stuff. The REAL content is NOT "surrealist".
Create LORAs for a) poses (which solves the camera angle) and b) objects (go take some photos of your Nespresso machine lol, i did)
I promised you a conspiracy. Well, i started researching if anyone was doing mass LORA chaining on hundreds of objects to create realistic , arbitrary and deterministic photos to generate realistic videos for filmakers.
Guess who is doing that? Runway. They are working with brands to create LORAs of their models - think of is a marketplace of branded items. So how is that a conspiracy? Well, imagine you want to take part in an "AI film competition" and you want to do something set in today's time - like ANY indy film.
You won't settle for that bizarro coffee machine or substandard 'generic' laptop. You see where this is headed? Because you don't have the time, the energy or the cash to make the loras of EVERY object, like you would in blender by buying assets, you're going to use the ones runway give you for free. Congratulations, now everyone with headphones use 'beats by dre' or whatever marketing campain of the day.
Sorry this was long - but it's helping me make better content, and I went and rented some mass GPU time to train my LORAs on real objects. I'll need a lot of GPU power, so wish me luck, because I think the last thing we want is cookie cutter AI movies that make our hobby look bad.
Thanks for reading, would love to know your thoughts. And of course, Merry Christmas to all of you!
I visit this subreddit often but I barely notice any difference between the pictures generated by Flux and older SD models. To be honest, I can't even tell whether a picture was generated by Flux / SDXL / SD1.5 unless the poster specifies it.
It it makes any difference I am not badmouthing Flux. I am just trying to understand Flux since I don't own it. I would appreciate it if someone can explain why Flux is better than older SD models in about 100 words and/or a few pictures in comparison. Cheers.
model creators: please think of us. occasionally at least. the world had IRL ārealismā in the form of oh, idk, every photograph taken before the last couple yearsā¦? if you could summon the will-power to exclude Pony/Illustrious/Noob (whateverthehell tween gooners are into these days) OUT of your āphotographicā models that would be amazeballs. xo
I've seen this misinformation repeated a lot across several threads so I want to make a post to address this as a professional web developer and someone who worked at a webhost:
The important part is that R2 has no egress costs.
A Civitai employee also said that they just hit 100TB of storage. Luckily R2 offers a calculator for hosting costs: https://r2-calculator.cloudflare.com/
Which means they're only paying a bit under 1500$ for hosting and bandwidth.
Which also means what they paid a developer to create the clubs would have been enough to pay for many months of model hosting.