r/SportsWhatIf • • Jun 01 '13

What if soccer leagues were determined entirely by goal differential?

0 Upvotes

r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 26 '13

What if the San Jose Earthquakes never moved to Houston?

0 Upvotes

A team that had two MLS Cups and in their last year in San Jose, a Supporter's Shield for the most points in the regular season. After that year (2005) they moved to Houston where the team went on to win to Championships in a row (2006 & 2007). San Jose not only lost the team but they lost an important player named Landon Donovan.

So what if they didn't move? Would they have become a dynasty MLS? Would Donovan still be wearing blue? Would they be attracting big names? I always wonder...


r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 26 '13

What if the San Francisco 49ers had taken Aaron Rodgers first overall in the 2005 NFL Draft rather than Alex Smith?

2 Upvotes

In the buildup to the draft it was widely assumed Rodgers would be the first overall choice. Smith was mentioned as a darkhorse until mere days before the pick.

No other quarterbacks were taken until 24th overall when Green Bay, never expecting Rodgers would be there, chose him as Favre's heir. With the next pick in the draft, Washington also took a quarterback—Jason Campbell.

The 49ers and Packers look dramatically different. Maybe Washington too as they could end up with Alex Smith at that spot.


r/SportsWhatIf • • Feb 04 '13

What if the Niners had won last night?

1 Upvotes

How much would the power outage be talked about? Would that be the de facto reason in the comeback? Would there be an asterisk on the game?


r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 26 '13

What if the Pittsburgh Penguins had won the Alex Ovechkin lottery?

1 Upvotes

2004 NHL lottery odds of getting first pick:

  1. Pittsburgh (25% actually, due to NHL draft lottery rules at the time, Pittsburgh had a 48.2% chance of having first overall pick)

  2. Chicago (18.8%)

  3. Washington (14.2%)

  4. Carolina (10.7%)

  5. Phoenix (8.1%)

Top 2004 NHL draft picks:

  1. Alexander Ovechkin

  2. Evgeni Malkin

  3. Cam Barker

  4. Andrew Ladd

  5. Blake Wheeler

What if Pittsburgh, the pre-lottery favorites, had won the first overall draft pick? It was widely known that Alex Ovechkin would be the first overall choice. Chicago would have the second pick by rule and likely take Malkin, leaving Washington picking third (they may not have taken Barker, but no other player in the draft has had anything like the impact of the top two). Pittsburgh would also have worse odds of winning the Sidney Crosby lottery, leaving the best odds to winning Crosby to Buffalo, Columbus, and the New York Rangers.


r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 25 '13

What if Torres wasn't shit?

11 Upvotes

r/SportsWhatIf • • Aug 03 '13

Thoughts on the new flair?

2 Upvotes

I'm planning to add more soon such as the NFL or MLS or NHL. I also had another what if planned today that was over 9000 characters long but i pressed backspace and it backed me up a page. :( 9000 characters gone just like that. But anyways, whaddya guys think of the new flair?


r/SportsWhatIf • • Jul 10 '21

What if FIFA granted FAI's request for a 33rd place at the 2010 World Cup?

2 Upvotes

The two-legged playoff between Republic of Ireland and France for a place in the 2010 FIFA World Cup was full of controversy, with the second leg in France being hotly contested. Thierry Henry admitted to Richard Dunne that he had illegally handled the ball in the build-up to William Gallas' match-winning goal, which had been scored in extra time with 17 minutes remaining in the game. Since then, Henry was accused of cheating for similar comparisons to Maradona's "Hand of God" incident, leading calls from FAI and the Irish government for that 1-1 result to be set aside and for the game to be replayed, later for Ireland to be allowed to enter the World Cup as an unprecedented supernumerary 33rd team. FIFA secretary-general Jerome Valcke had ruled it out a day before the meeting, clarifying that Blatter's comments regarding other teams had already shown the request was "impossible" and had "no hope" of being granted. Suppose by a stroke of fate, FIFA granted Ireland's request. How would Ireland fare in the group stages at that time?


r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 26 '14

What if Phillip Rivers had a bad 2013 season? How would the playoffs be different and what wouldve happened with the Chargers?

2 Upvotes

Would Rivers be out of SD? Where would he go?

Would the Steelers/Dolphins/Ravens be the #6 seed in the AFC?


r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 28 '13

What if the proposed trade between the Blue Jays and Giants that would have swapped Alex Rios and Tim Lincecum actually went through?

3 Upvotes

r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 25 '13

What if Preston Stanley doesn't gain an interest in hockey while in Canada.

3 Upvotes

If he doesn't become interested in hockey while serving as the Governor General of Canada, he doesn't create what becomes the Stanley Cup. What does the NHL look like without it?


r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 26 '13

What if football finished at halftime?

0 Upvotes

Inspired by this set of stats: http://www.soccerstats.com/timing.asp?league=england

So, the league would look like it says, and what it says is drastically different from the full time results.

 	 	                     P	W	D	L	Pts

 	 	1	Manchester Utd	 23	 13	 7	 3	46

 	 	2	Chelsea	         23	 12	 9	 2	45

 	 	3	Manchester City	 23	 10	 10	 3	40

 	 	4	Sunderland   	 23	 9	 7	 7	34

 	 	5	Everton	         23	 7	 12	 4	33

 	 	6	Aston Villa	     23	 7	 10	 6	31

 	 	7	Fulham	         23	 8	 7	 8	31

 	 	8	Tottenham	     23	 6	 12	 5	30

 	 	9	West Bromwich	 23	 7	 9	 7	30

 	 	10	Liverpool	     23	 8	 5	 10	29

 	 	11	Newcastle Utd	 23	 7	 8	 8	29

 	 	12	Arsenal	         23	 5	 13	 5	28

 	 	13	West Ham Utd	 23	 7	 6	 10	27

 	 	14	Stoke City	     23	 5	 12	 6	27

 	 	15	Reading	         23	 6	 8	 9	26

 	 	16	Swansea City	 23	 4	 13	 6	25

 	 	17	Norwich City	 23	 5	 8	 10	23

 	 	18	Southampton	     23	 5	 8	 10	23

 	 	19	Wigan Athletic	 23	 3	 11	 9	20

 	 	20	QP Rangers   	 23	 2	 13	 8	19

What I'm interested in is what the difference in narratives would be. Who would be the massively on form strikers? Will we see in Sunderland in the Champion's League? Is Norwich suffering second season blues, while their ex boss leads Villa to Europe?

Anyway, be interested if you could dig up some interesting tales of the first half!


r/SportsWhatIf • • Feb 03 '13

What If Luc Bourdon didn't crash his motorcycle?

0 Upvotes

How could his career have panned out?


r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 27 '13

You're greatest What If Teams of all time?

4 Upvotes

NBA

The 1998-99 What If Raptors had at one point, Tracy McGrady, Vince Carter and future defensive player of the year, Marcus Camby as the core of their team. T-Mac left after the 99-00 season and for a period of 3-4 years in the early 2000's was probably the best guard in the NBA. Camby was traded before the 98-99 season to the Knicks for Charles Oakley who was already 67 years old at that point and on his last legs.

The other great What If Team of all time for me was the late 80's-early 90's Celtics with Reggie Lewis, Larry Bird and Len Bias at the helm of their team. We can't really be sure if that team ever would have come together though because there'd be no reason for the Celtics to draft Reggie Lewis had Len Bias survived.

Edit: In before anyone points out the terrible grammatical error in the title.


r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 25 '13

What if the Carolina Panthers won Super Bowl XXXVIII?

4 Upvotes

Would Jake Delhomme go on to win multiple SBs? Would the cajun filet biscuit combo become the greatest meal of all time?


r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 28 '18

What if the Panthers and Jaguars both made it to the Superbowl in 1996?

0 Upvotes

r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 28 '13

What if Ultimate Frisbee was introduced at the 2012 Olympic Games?

4 Upvotes

r/SportsWhatIf • • Feb 01 '13

What if the MLB had decided not to allow the Mets in their ranks?

4 Upvotes

In november 1958, William Shea had an Idea. The Continental League.

It never played a single game, but what If?

The proposed league fell appart when It was announced that the Mets would be one of the two new National League teams, along with the Houston Colt .45's.

So What if instead the second team had been awarded to, say Dallas?


r/SportsWhatIf • • Apr 13 '19

What if the Tigers had defeated the Twins in the 1987 ALCS championship series?

0 Upvotes

r/SportsWhatIf • • Feb 01 '19

What if the 49ers were able to complete their comeback against the Redskins in the 1983 NFC Championship game?

0 Upvotes

r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 07 '19

What if the Bills had beaten the Bengals in the 1988 AFC Championship game?

0 Upvotes

r/SportsWhatIf • • Aug 23 '19

What if the Expos had beaten the Dodgers in the 1981 NLCS?

0 Upvotes

r/SportsWhatIf • • May 28 '21

In the year 2023, Sacromento California, Tacoma Washington, Boulder Colorado, and Milwaukee Wisconsin get NFL teams.

0 Upvotes

How would the NFL be changed by this?


r/SportsWhatIf • • Jul 10 '19

What if the Eagles beat the Rams in the 2001 NFC Championship Game?

0 Upvotes

r/SportsWhatIf • • Jan 04 '20

Challenge: Have the St Louis Rams become a dynesty that wins five or six Superbowls, starting in 1999.

0 Upvotes