r/SportsCardTracker • • Aug 31 '26

Neutral [Neutral] u/jcnardonejr

4 Upvotes

Seller kind of kept stringing me along on shipping the card. Never in a rush for a 60$ card, but when I had asked he mentioned to get it out next day, it took an additional three before I followed up asking for the tracking.

I think from payment to USPS scan it was a whole week. I get it things happen.

Today it finally arrived and the bubble mailer was taped up kind of unprofessionally, probably in a rush to get it out. The label was printed on paper and taped down. Not everyone has access to a thermal printer, but the exterior already gave me a bad feeling.

I opened up the packaging and found the card was wrapped with bubblewrap, between two pieces of cardboard that were not secured together. When I pulled out packaging the card came out easily as if it weren’t secured at all. If you look at the tape on the cardboard no where does it secure the two pieces.

Overall unimpressed. Card arrived safely.

tldr: Ebay authentication level packaging, nice guy. Would NOT deal with again.

https://imgur.com/a/D5VAnoP


r/SportsCardTracker • • Feb 10 '24

Positive [Positive] u/localcardshop

0 Upvotes

Guy has been getting a ton of heat on here so wanted to share my experience: some people have mentioned red flags which I understand, only offered venmo but was cool with venmo goods and services. He was fun to talk to, had a crazy collection that he sent a ton of pics of, we agreed on a good price, and he shipped out a couple days later. Cards arrived in great condition and he threw in some extras. Won’t lie, I was sketched out because of the negative comments, so I followed up each day. He stayed in constant communication with me and gave me updates the whole time. I don’t blame people for having their reservations, but I had a great experience with him. Would buy from him again.


r/SportsCardTracker • • Apr 13 '26

Negative [negative]u/BengalHawk

0 Upvotes

Made a trade with him last week and agreed to ship 4/6. I shipped on Monday 4/6 and gave him tracking Tuesday morning. We live close by so he received Tuesday afternoon. He messaged me on Wednesday saying he “knocked his water bottle over” and damaged the cards he was supposed to send me. He shipped me back my cards and my shipping costs after I asked. He said he’d include extras for the inconvenience. I told him I’d like to see pictures of the damaged cards and that I didn’t believe his story. I did receive my cards back, but the extras were 2 cards worth maybe a dollar each. I asked again for pictures of the damaged cards to no response. I last asked on Thursday morning and haven’t heard anything in the several days since.

Long story short, user agreed to trade, changes his mind about the trade after he already received his end of the deal, cooked up a fake story about damaging the cards he was supposed to send, won’t provide proof of the damage, and has now gone radio silent. I did get my cards back, but the whole experience was annoying.


r/SportsCardTracker • • Aug 22 '26

Negative (negative) u/bullpenbreaksco

0 Upvotes

Posted the link to their eBay auction on r/sportscards . Then tried to negotiate and take dms to sell there which was already a red flag. Felt I was safer going thru eBay. Then the seller cancelled when they didn't get the price they wanted.


r/SportsCardTracker • • Mar 31 '24

Negative [negative]u/wutong01

0 Upvotes

Ordered G&S from him, he said he shipped, he even had a receipt that made it look like he shipped but they never showed up. He said he’d refund me Friday and didn’t, so I had to pi my PP. I got refunded but sucks whether it was lost by USPS or he didn’t ship, idk. Would probably leave neutral feedback if allowed, due to the receipt, but not an option and not positive.


r/SportsCardTracker • • Jul 05 '24

Positive {positive} u/hey_just_call_me_red

0 Upvotes

Sold two cards to this user that totaled close to 200$. Smooth, seamless transaction. Would definitely do deals with him again.


r/SportsCardTracker • • Dec 15 '23

Positive (Positive) u/theMantleMartyr

4 Upvotes

Won a giveaway and he promptly shipped. Got some really cool cards, including a couple that will stay in my PC.

Mantle is a good dude who recently caught some flack for his curtness. But I’ve always found him to be direct, engaging and knowledgeable. He’s definitely a good egg on the sub, regardless if you like his methods haha.


r/SportsCardTracker • • Mar 31 '24

Positive [positive] u/grundizzle

3 Upvotes

End of the day it’s on me to take it on the chin as the seller. Using this as a lesson moving forward. My guy didn’t do anything wrong as the buyer and it’s understandable that he was unsatisfied with what happened. Keep the cards when they come, it’s on me🫱🏾‍🫲🏻♥️


r/SportsCardTracker • • Sep 19 '25

Positive [Positive] u/StelioKontos69420

0 Upvotes

Great purchase from u/StelioKontos69420! He had bulk base and low-end inserts/SPs from a bunch of sets I was working on, and we worked out a very fair deal a big lot of cards. Everything was packaged beautifully and arrived quickly, and in great shape. Terrific to deal with, and I'd definitely look to buy from him again. Thanks!


r/SportsCardTracker • • Oct 04 '26

Positive [Positive] u/JJ_McCarthy_Stan

0 Upvotes

Bought three cards off of the seller--great communication, fair negotiation and the cards arrived quickly and as described... Thanks a ton!!


r/SportsCardTracker • • Jul 05 '24

Positive [Positive] u/hey_just_call_me_red

0 Upvotes

Perfect transaction every time.


r/SportsCardTracker • • Jul 05 '24

Positive [positive] u/hey_just_call_me_red

0 Upvotes

Sold a lot of Ernie Banks SGC graded cards to this user. Prom payment and all around great transaction!


r/SportsCardTracker • • Jul 05 '24

Positive [positive] u/hey_just_call_me_red

0 Upvotes

had a good transaction. deal was smooth and easy. enjoyed working with him. would do again


r/SportsCardTracker • • Aug 14 '23

Positive [Positive] u/themantlemartyr

0 Upvotes

Easy to work with and even gave me a shout out!


r/SportsCardTracker • • May 21 '23

Positive (Positive) u/enoch33rd

1 Upvotes

Cards were delayed to to no fault of his. Nicely packaged, would buy/trade again


r/SportsCardTracker • • Feb 12 '24

Positive (Positive) u/sitcomonthespot

1 Upvotes

Agreed to terms. I paid, he safely packaged and sent. I received timely in as expected condition.

Flawless transaction. Recommended user: u/sitcomonthespot


r/SportsCardTracker • • Nov 18 '20

Positive [Positive] u/StevenJeon

1 Upvotes

Packaged the cards very well and everything came in great condition. Would definitely recommend trading with Steven.


r/SportsCardTracker • • Apr 29 '26

Negative [Negative] u/III-Low-4658

0 Upvotes

Huge Scammer!! Please be aware of this user.. Never Shipped items. Still see him posting..


r/SportsCardTracker • • Sep 18 '25

Negative [Negative] u/STIHL_MLBTheShowFan

15 Upvotes

Basically sold him a braves 1/10 , he paid 5$ shipping for priority , explained the situation and told him I could afford the 11$ ( thats what it was costing when I went to usps ) , ended up shipping it in an envelope ( really secured ) , he makes a negative post about me saying I never shipped him his cards and basically me stealing his 5$ for shipping , I refunded him that 5$ , and he said that he sees his card in the mail , I reached out so many times after so he could fix the negative review ( like he said he would ) and it’s been 2-3 weeks and now I’m blocked by him. He got his card and he never took down my bad review.

Will never ever do business with him and I recommend no one does too.


r/SportsCardTracker • • Jul 28 '26

Positive [positive]u/monetarylapse

2 Upvotes

I can’t say enough about this guy. He is the best seller on Reddit. If you haven’t gotten anything from him yet…..you should. Will keep doing business.


r/SportsCardTracker • • 19d ago

Positive [Positive] u/Ornery-Reindeer-5295

1 Upvotes

Bought an oversize card from u/Ornery-Reindeer-5295 who did a great job of safely packing and shipping it to me. Super happy with the deal! Thanks!!


r/SportsCardTracker • • Jun 15 '23

Positive [Positive] u/theMantleMartyr

1 Upvotes

Sent me some non baseball cards at shipping cost. Opened them with my nephews and they loved them! Thanks again!


r/SportsCardTracker • • Feb 26 '24

Positive [Positive] u/theMantleMartyr

1 Upvotes

Amazing deal with him. Could not have been a better transaction. A++++


r/SportsCardTracker • • Jul 05 '24

Positive [positive] u/hey_just_call_me_red

1 Upvotes

Sold a vintage lot to this user - great communication and prompt payment!