r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Jun 29 '26

Question/Discussion Unpopular opinion, but I feel like people should ground their Speculative Evolution projects in reality before posting them on here. Does anyone agree with me?

0 Upvotes

I just replied to a user earlier about a criticism they made about an organism evolving wheels, and I agreed with them as I felt like it was a lot more based on making a cool design than actual speculative biology which is why I'm making this post. I feel like the subreddit is losing the plot on what speculative evolution is supposed to be in the first place. Speculative evolution shouldn't be fantasy design with breif explanations​, it should try to be more realistic and give an in detail informed explanation from a biological standpoint on how this creature can evolve. So saying "Well my epic dragon monster evolved specific adaptations to breath fire" doesn't count, it's kinda the bare minimum of an explanation really. I agree everyone starts somewhere. No one's perfect, but it gets to a point where it's so normalized it kind of becomes an issues, therefore degrading what the source material is supposed to be in the first place. I feel like people here really take advantage of the whole "well it doesn't have to be realistic thing" and now we have all these posts that barely coralate with actual biology. Speaking of biology. I think people should really study biology and how evolution works before posting tons of fantasy based stuff with little to no explanation on how said traits of these creatures could possibly exist, and what would even pressure them to gain those features to begin with. Sorry if I sound a bit rambly, but I just wanted to give my opinion on these issues. I just feel like this subreddit is really lenient on just having creature design everywhere instead of real speculative biology. As you can tell I'm pretty big on hard spec evo. I even think projects like Serina, which is loved by most of this community, started becoming really outlandish and fantastical in the end. Like with the "metamorph birds" and how the ending mainly just makes a fanfiction for the sapient species, hardly focusing on other fauna at those periods. But I don't ​think everyone has to make the same projects, nor do I care if people disagree with me. Though I feel like having realism, and not just fantasy with vague descriptions in a subreddit about speculative biology is important, even if this isn't r/hardspecevo


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Jun 23 '26

Alien Life Stop giving your aliens spines!

6 Upvotes

Alright, this has been something that's been bothering me for quite a while and I have to know if I'm invalid for this. I'm not well versed in biology but I've been bored and trying to create my own alien, and I've been trying to look at others for reference, but I keep hitting a wall: bones.

I mean, a skeletal structure of sorts makes sense, but so many of the times, they are so close to Earths it just ends up looking like a dinosaur. I can't be crazy for saying that aliens wouldn't have a rib cage, head, neck, and spine right? I mean especially not in the same order as some Earth animals. Even exoskeletons make more sense, they're simple, but bones are sooo elaborate and specific across all vertebrates! Why would an alien have a neck and a pertruding head? It just seems incredibly Earth-biased.

I don't doubt aliens would have some crossover with human species considering how biodiverse our planet is, but seriously? A full on skeleton and ribcage just like an animal we know? That just seems so Earth exclusive. Even from actual astro/xenobiologists making speculative designs I've noticed this problem on and it's driving me up a wall!

Am I in the wrong for this take or do I have a point???


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Jul 21 '26

Question/Discussion Would dwarf women with beards have low fertility?

5 Upvotes

In some fantasy settings female dwarves have beards just like the men, as someone else said "as any student of Tolkien knows even females of the Khazad have beards that make the most hirsute patriarch of Humankind look almost clean shaven in comparison".

Lets imagine a scifi setting where are imagined as hominids or hominid descendants. Would having beards mean that dwarven women are less fertile in comparison to human women, because hirsutism in women implies high levels of testosterone?


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Jun 03 '24

Question Are there transgender sophonts?

44 Upvotes

Hello! It seems that this month is Pride Month in English-speaking countries. (I'm Japanese, but the custom of Pride Month has not yet spread in Japan.) Incidentally, I'm also cisgender heterosexual, but I was born in June.

Now, this time I've prepared a question that's perfect for Pride Month. That is, can transgender sophonts exist?

By sophonts, I mean "intelligent life forms evolved from non-human (non-primate) animals," such as classic dinosauroids and those that appear in "The Future is Wild," "Serina," and "Hamsters Paradise." This is because we only know that aliens usually have one or two, and at most no more than three, sexualities.

Returning to the topic, homosexuality almost certainly exists in sophonts. This is because there are a great many animal species in which homosexual behavior has been reported.

I've also heard an interesting story that "gender identity is determined by hormones secreted from the Hypothalamus." I don't know if this is true or not, but if gender identity is determined at birth by something as physical as a "brain organ," then I thought it might be possible for transgender people to exist in non-human beings as well.

I know this is a difficult question, but what do you think?


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Sep 21 '21

In Media Does this belong here?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Aug 29 '23

Meta Why is AI art banned?

0 Upvotes

I recently did a post about an ecosystem that I was creating, but it got removed due to a single piece of AI art I had used. In the rules it says about bad ethical practices, so are the mods ill informed or is there something else? Thanks in advance


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Sep 28 '24

Artificial/GMO Evolution My take on real life Catgirls made using genetic engineering. Behold, Homo Sapiens Felinus (also known as Catgirls, Cat People, Neko People or Nekomata).

Post image
0 Upvotes

(Pictured here are 2 average members of this hybrid species, both adults)


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Sep 21 '26

Question/Discussion What if humans had evolved from insects instead of primates? What would our species look like?

0 Upvotes

Humans and other modern primates share common ancestors, and our evolutionary lineage arose within the primates.

But what if our lineage had instead evolved from insect ancestors?

What would humans look like? Would we retain insect-like characteristics? How might our bodies, reproduction, and senses work? And, most importantly, how would that evolutionary history have influenced our culture, customs, society, and the way we built our civilization?

If an intelligent species had evolved from an insect lineage but eventually reached a technological level similar to ours, what do you think it would look like today?


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Nov 26 '20

Do you believe in Evolution or God made everything just the way it is? (Photo: Maasai Mara National Reserve,Kenya

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Aug 30 '21

Paleo Reconstruction The modern "Homo sapien"

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Mar 30 '24

[OC] Future Evolution An as of yet unnamed decsended of humans that because of an end of the world senario escaped into caves and evolved from there.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Sep 11 '18

Biology/Ecology If anyone here Has seen King Kong 2005 then you kniw that the ecosystem on thw isalnd i would say is so Realistic and if you don't know what all the animals are on Skull Island then Look up Wikizilla and go to Slull Island 2005 on PC not Phone it won't work on Phone sadly

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/SpeculativeEvolution • • May 03 '22

Discussion Sapience CAN'T arise from carnivorous predators.

0 Upvotes

I've been a little into spec evo for a bit, sort of drawn in by my discovery of All Tomorrows and Serina. I noticed that one of the posthumans, the killer folk had a particular following. I got curious and checked out the lore behind their existence. The idea of a carnivorous species is fascinating, however, when I thought about it, and saw a post on carnivorous sapience, I came to the conclusion that sapience occurring in ANY carnivorous predator species is impossible. And I will give my reasoning why.

Firstly it is not just the fact that humans had to compete with/were preyed upon by other predators, it's the fact that we ourselves had no previous adaptations for predation. No specialized teeth, no specialized claws that would be associated with a carnivorous predator. This fueled the development of tools to help us kill our prey. If a species had such adaptations for predation, in that case, why would such a species even bother with tools? Why waste energy making a spear when you can kill things just as, if not, more effectively by using your own teeth and claws? Second, in addition to competing with other predators, with being preyed upon, you have that pressure to find ways of defending yourself. We had no way of defending ourselves until someone came up with the idea of living in houses and using the tools we used for hunting as a means of defense, which once again, a predatory species would not have needed to develop in the first place since they have their own natural weapons.

Second, there are nutritional requirements for a brain of human-level intellect that would not be met with the diet of something that exclusively eats meat. Meat may be more nutrient dense than other food sources, but it is the kind of nutrient that matters. And there are several key nutrients for the brain, none of which are found in animal-based food sources. For human intelligence we get our key nutrients from vegetables such as kale, spinach, and broccoli, as well as a variety of nuts and berries. Notice that meat is not one of these sources.

Thirdly, I'm going to go through a list of animals on earth that come close to human intelligence and tell you what they eat. Crows, they are omnivores. Parrots, they are omnivores. The great apes, chimps, gorillas, and bonobos, all of them are omnivores. Raccoons are omnivores. Elephants? herbivores, actually. "But what about toothed whales, and cephalopods?" some may ask. Well, I'd like to include them, but the truth is, given how different the ecology of the oceans are to the ecologies of the land, they don't count, since on some level nearly everything eats some kind of meat in the oceans. Notice that not a single one of the animals I have listed here are predatory carnivores. Wouldn't one think of this as kind of telling? Yes, wolves, and some felids may have a degree of intellect, but when you look at things objectively, they are no more intelligent than a one-and-a-half-year-old human and have no pressures to develop that further, whereas the animals I have listed have at least the intellect of a five-year-old human child and do have some pressures to take that further.

This leads me to conclude that the idea of a predatory species that is an obligate carnivore may sound cool on paper, but in reality is extremely unlikely if not, impossible. Maybe you can have a species of relatively intelligent carnivores, but make them as intelligent as a two-year-old at best if you want accuracy. Looking at some documentaries on alien intelligence, I kind of find it absurd that it is speculated that intelligence of any kind would be likely to develop from a predatory animal as I have already outlined that it's impossible.


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Apr 01 '24

AI-generated content The Magnetic-Gastropod (idea AND image by AI)

Post image
51 Upvotes

r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Apr 21 '22

Terraformed World A Trope That Aeolus Started

2 Upvotes

I have recently been annoyed by the increase of posts on this subreddit with low effort titles such as “What would be the absolutte best species for a world like Serina” or “Would it be fine for my bat seed world to have its creator constantly checking”, these posts are just plain low effort; and they are far too repetitive. People should stop making seed worlds, and just so that you better understand it, here I present a brief history of the genre:

1930: “Last and First Men” book by Olaf Stapeldon, is released, this book first proposed the idea of terraformation.

1970: ”Ringworld” book by Larry Niven is published, in this book is presented a seed world located in a ring-shaped megastructure.

2006: “All Tomorrows” book by C.M. Kosemen is published.

2012: “Aeolus”, project by Preradkor is posted on the internet, in this project, humans terraform a desert world and seed it with domestic animals, from which only survives the budgerigar, 11 million years later humans return to Aeolus to investigate the newly evolved lifeforms. This project was a total breakthrough in the history of seed worlds, as it was the first one-species seed world without posthumans.

2015: “Serina”, project by Dylan Bajda is posted on the internet.

2021: Seed worlds become a repetitive and overused trope.

I know it is not wrong to make a seed world, but you should seriously stop making seed worlds, if you make a seed world, be sure it contains some sort of twist to it. Remember that Serina and Aeolus aren’t the only places to take inspiration from; you can of course make more original seed worlds, you can for example get inspiration from Kaimere, Rhynia, Cambrian Mars, among many others; or you could even create a new seed world concept on your own without being directly inspired by pre-existing projects.

Be. More. Creative.


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Oct 30 '21

Future Evolution I got inspired by All Tomorrows and decided to make these creatures. More information about them are on my Deviantart and Tumblr. The art was made by your’s truly.

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Aug 25 '26

Alien Life The Limbic System versus the Frontal Lobes:  How Bipedalism Leads to Fermi’s Paradox

0 Upvotes

 

The transition from ape to hominin began about six million years ago with the ability to walk upright.  This was not an easy accomplishment.  It creates major engineering conflicts and does not happen unless it offers valuable survival benefits.  The quadruped supports its internal organs with a robust abdominal wall.  The biped bears all that load on the pelvic floor, which has several essential openings.  These cause hernias, organ prolapses, and birth problems.  

Also, the quadruped has, obviously, four points of support, while the biped has only two.  Both must be under the body.  This creates an angle between the thigh bone and the leg bone, which causes the supporting tendons to bowstring and pop out of place.  It is called a patella subluxation, and today it requires a trip to the local ER.  However, if it happened while being chased by a saber toothed cat, it would be much more inconvenient. 

There must have been some offset in survival ability to justify such maladaptive consequences of upright gait.  Initially, it was the ability to commit larceny.  Hominins learned to walk long before they made tools.  They were omnivorous primates, and there was a ready supply of dead meat stashed in trees by carnivores.  The great advantage of early bipedalism was the ability to carry heavy stuff long distances. The earliest bipedal hominins made their living by stealing carcasses cached by carnivores. 

Obviously, it was not safe to eat those carcasses on site.  The ability to move them, to carry them miles back to the tribe and away from the owner’s stash site would have been a huge survival advantage.  It was basically free meat for the family.  That was the first driving force for evolution of bipedalism. 

Other primates cannot do this.  The chimpanzee can only carry small items in one hand, while walking on the other three extremities.  The bonobo can carry items while walking on two feet, but only for short distances and with an awkward broad-based gait, like a raccoon and some other mammals.  Most animals carry resources with their mouths, stomachs, or prehensile tails.  Only bipedal hominins can heft the carcass of a half-eaten gazelle onto the shoulder and carry it for miles. 

The next chapter begins with those now idle hands.  It would not have been long before they were used to wield sticks and throw stones.  These are two separate technologies.  Modern apes use sticks as clubs in conflicts among themselves, and even as spears, sharpened on one end, to hunt small animals. Hominins began this practice well back in the Paleolithic Era.  Archeologists have found such weapons that are 400,000 years old. The practice continues among extant Neolithic tribes today. 

The throwing of stones led inevitably to the breaking of stones, beginning the slow progression of lithic technology.  The 2.6 million year old Oldowan tools are little more than broken stones, with sharp edges used for cutting and scraping.  About 1.8 million years ago, the Acheulean tools appeared.  These were hand axes flaked on both sides of one end, showing intentional flaking patterns.  Mousterian tools appeared 400,000 years ago, with complete blades worked on both sides by percussion.  Blade technologies began about 50,000 ago, with long, thin tools that could be hafted to stone and bone handles.  Pressure flaking appeared about 20,000 years ago, allowing refinement of shapes and re-sharpening of edges.  

As these technologies progressed, so did the hunting and larceny skills of Hominins.  This was the driving force for the next change in Hominins, the gradual increase in intelligence.  Hominins were omnivorous apes, eating nuts, berries, insects, small animals, and the occasional large animal that they could steal or kill.  Those food sources were not getting smarter.  Hominins got smarter because they were competing with each other, stealing from each other, and probably eating each other, just as humans today eat monkeys and apes. 

During this six million years, there occurred a succession of Hominins, overlapping in time and range.  The current count of extinct hominids stands at twenty-five species.  Today, only one hominin remains, Homo sapiens, the best of the lot.   H. sapiens persists because they were better at outsmarting and out competing the other hominids.  They were the most larcenous and the most murderous. 

The limbic system is the old brain.  It controls emotions and basic body functions.  It is the part of the brain that gives us greed, hunger, lust, desire, anger, fear, love, hatred, and all those basic feelings that rule our lives.  It evolves very slowly.  By the end of the Paleolithic Era, it had become well adapted for exploitation of our fellow hominids, including other H. sapiens.  When all other hominids were gone, we turned this well-tested and perfected limbic system on each other. 

Meanwhile, the neocortex became smarter.  It evolved rapidly, bringing increased intelligence, tool making, and language.  With development of language H. sapiens acquire a hierarchical knowledge structure.  They could build upon prior knowledge.  The arms race that began with Oldowan tools 2.6 million years ago grew exponentially.  It continues today in contemporary warfare.  Observe the weapon evolution of the past five years in Eastern Europe. 

Only ten thousand years have passed since the end of the Paleolithic Era.  That is not enough time for the limbic system to evolve.  Humans have the same violent aggressive emotions they had then.  As H. sapiens becomes progressively more capable of homicide and larceny, they will continue to prey on each other until they destroy their world and themselves.  The persistence of an ancient limbic system, armed with the exponential increase in destructive weapons, makes this inevitable. 

I suspect this is a common pathway for intelligent species.  They all develop intelligence for the same reason.  They are competing with other similar species.  I do not know of any other adaptive value for technical intelligence.  In the process, they all become proficient at larceny, exploitation, and fratricide. Once they succeed as the dominant species, they continue to prey on one another and exploit their planet, resulting in their own destruction. 

Organized religions have tried to combat these self-destructive tendencies.  They focus on expanding altruism and trust beyond the local family and community.  Religions teach people shared values and sets of behaviors that get their followers to work together toward a common good.  Unfortunately, the limbic systems often intervenes and gets large groups of believers working towards the same old fiercely competitive behaviors. 

There may be some intelligent species in the universe that escape this fate.  I suspect they are few and far between.  Most will follow the track that is carrying H. sapiens to their doom.  Some may succeed in transitioning from a larcenous fratricidal species into interstellar wayfarers.  They may find and observe us.   

They will immediately recognize us for what we are, and where we are in our evolution.  They will not welcome us to join them out in interstellar space.  We are not nice civilized creatures.  We would not make good neighbors.  They will likely observe and contain us, without contact, waiting to see whether we survive this critical stage in evolution.  

So, the explanation for the Fermi Paradox is that all intelligent species are highly competitive, fratricidal, larcenous, murderous creatures.  That was their drive to become intelligent.  The great majority of them kill themselves off before expanding into interstellar space.  Those that overcome these shortcomings avoid any contact with those that have not.  

If we hope to eventually expand into interstellar space and contact sentient aliens, we will first have to get our limbic systems under control and learn to behave like responsible adult interstellar citizens.  Unfortunately, that is not likely to happen.


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Jun 24 '22

Discussion Are plants the superior creation of complex evolution?

1 Upvotes

Plants are undoubtedly intelligent, and in terms of being able to understand their environment, they are far better able to, all without organs. Plants can sense and react to soil microorganisms, light sensitivity, water quality, and many other obvious ones like temperature and weather. My point being, plants are very complex and aware of their environment in a different yet similar way to animals with some plants being even more aware of their surroundings than some animals. They literally get their energy from the sun, and have a much more efficient method of utilizing more of that energy, while many animals are left to hunt of forage. Plants also make up 99.7% of Earth’s biomass, with all other life making up only 0.3%. They clearly dominate us as the more abundant form of life. If plants came before fungi and animals, and filled far more specific and unique niches than animals have, would that leave animals just to fill the niches that were left? And (just for fun) if aliens were to visit earth, would they acknowledge the plants as the rulers of this world instead of us?


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Feb 14 '25

Redesign (media: skibidi toilet series) realistic skibidi toilet

Post image
40 Upvotes

r/SpeculativeEvolution • • May 16 '15

Discussion language is a barrier. we'll evolve into wordless telepathy.

0 Upvotes

and I want this evolutionary step to happen in my lifetime?.


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Dec 06 '21

Alien Life All the continents of Maacuria (Alien Worlds 2.0)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Feb 07 '25

Future Evolution The cameramens from skibidi toilet as a (somewhat ) plausible lifeforms

5 Upvotes

Cameramens or more fittingly named "hermit folks" are a descendant of humans that lives in the dumpster world that was once home of their ancestors.

Although their body are normal,their heads are anything but , since , at birth, they have an extremely underdevelloped skull wich have a. almost gelatinous consistence. For their 8 first month, they will scavenge in the rubbish of humanity, searching for things with cavities(usually tv , camera heads or speaker heads)to put their "heads" in. After that the head will grow into the shape of said object.

The hermit folks lives in a eusocial, termite like hierarchy, in the colony there are -the human sized worker that collect food for the colony and breed with the queen -the "titans" , quadrupedal bear like warriors that defend the colony -the Queen who is 78 ft long, 9 ft wide and 20 tons heavy, whose sole purpose is to gave birth to more hermit folks .

Workers that don't breed with the Queen will change genders like clownfish and become females. When the queen dies, said female worker will cannibalize to queen to become the new queen


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Sep 23 '26

Question/Discussion Should creationists participate in speculative evolution?

0 Upvotes

I am a Christian, with some interests in creationism. However, I have been into spec evo for a while, with Kaimere mainly being a major influence to it, but I was like 13 or 14 at that time, so I wasn't accustomed to the rules and how they worked. And later, I discovered Godzilla: Savage Planet made by Wyatt Andrews Workshop. And me being a kaiju nerd too, I became interested in kaiju spec evo.

And as I'm typing this, I have my own spec evo series of Godzilla and non Godzilla fauna coping within the modern day, after the Noahic Flood.

The purpose of my spec evo series is to break the Christian media stereotype and prove that Christians CAN make peak content, even if it's not related to their religion and/or even contradicts it.​

But I'm not sure if it's a good idea and I need some feedback.

And don't worry, I don't believe feathered dinos are just birds and that dinosaurs, in general, inspired dragons legends around the world.


r/SpeculativeEvolution • • Apr 14 '22

Question/Help Requested I’m going to design an alien world what environment should the planet be ?

0 Upvotes
144 votes, Apr 17 '22
24 Desert
21 Tundra
12 Temperate
28 Tropical
12 Taiga
47 Cloud world